Reading, writing, and
research in the digital age
Kathryn Zickuhr
Research Associate

November 4, 2013
edUi 2013
@kzickuhr | @pewinternet | @pewresearch
About the Pew Research Center
• Non-partisan “fact tank” in Washington, DC,
made up of seven projects
• Does not promote specific technologies or make
policy recommendations
More: pewresearch.org
@pewresearch
@pewinternet

November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

2
The Internet: A brief history

November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

3
Internet use over time
% of adults ages 18+ who go online, 1995-present

85%

(2013)

90%
80%
70%

50%

60%

(2000)

50%
40%
30%
20%
10%

14%

(1995)

0%

November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

4
72% of online adults (and 80% of
online teens) use social network sites
100%

80%

80

87
68

60%

49

40%

29

20%

0%

12-17
November 4, 2013

18-29

30-49
www.pewinternet.org

50-64

65+
5
The rise of mobile
Cell phones:

• 91% of adults (78% of teens)
Smartphones:
• 56% of adults (37% of teens)

Tablets:
• 34% of adults (23% of teens)

November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

6
Mobile is the needle; social is the thread
How information is woven into our lives
Mobile technology…

Social network sites…

Always with us

Surround us with information through
our many connections

Makes information accessible
anytime and anywhere

Connect us to strong & weak ties

Puts information & connections at
our fingertips

Provide instant feedback, meaning, and
context

Magnifies the demand for timely
information (on-demand)
Makes information locationsensitive
November 4, 2013

Allow us to shape and create
information ourselves and amplify
others’ messages

www.pewinternet.org

7
How Americans find and
share news and information
in the digital age

November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

8
Digital grows as a source for news
% of respondents who got news “yesterday” from each platform
80%
70%
60%

TV
Radio
Newspaper
Online
Any Digital News

50%
40%

30%
20%

50% say
internet is a
main source
for news

10%
0%

1991
November 4, 2013

1994

1997

2000

2003

2006

State of the News Media 2013

2009

2012

stateofthemedia.org

9
News and information
50% of American adults cite the internet as a main
source for national and international news
• 71% of adults under 30 say the internet is a
main news source (vs 55% who cite television)
23% of adults get news on at least two mobile devices
• Info-snacking and just-in-time information
Social media, while an increasing part of the digital news
experience, is not often a main source of news (though it’s
more of a source if you’re mobile)

November 4, 2013

pewinternet.org / journalism.org

10
News and information

More: stateofthemedia.org

November 4, 2013

pewinternet.org / journalism.org

11
“Does anyone still read books?”
Book reading by age group
Among readers, the % in each age group who read a book in print or an e-book
in the past year (2012)

Print

E-books

100%

94%

91%

80%

91%

90%

85%

60%

40%

41%

28%

20%

31%
23%

20%

0%

16-17
November 4, 2013

18-29

30-49
libraries.pewinternet.org

50-64

65+
13
Which is better for these purposes, a
printed book or an e-book?
Among those 16+ who read both a print book & an e-book in the past year (2011)

Print

E-books

100%
80%

83%

81%
73%

69%

60%

53%
40%

43% 45%
35%

20%

25%

19%

9%

0%

Reading with Sharing with
a child
others

November 4, 2013

Reading in
bed

Having a
wide
selection

libraries.pewinternet.org

Reading
while
traveling

13%

Get books
quickly

14
E-books beyond e-readers
Among people who read e-books, the % in each age group who read their e-books on
the following devices (2011)

16-29

30+

60%

55%

50%

40%

46%
41%

38%

30%

25%

20%

26%

23%

16%

10%

0%

Cell phone
November 4, 2013

Desktop or laptop

E-reader

libraries.pewinternet.org

Tablet
15
What do these changes mean
for educational and cultural
institutions?

November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

16
How Americans use libraries

56% of Americans 16+ used a library in the past year
• 53% visited in person
• 25% used website
Books, browsing, librarians are still central, both in how
people use libraries and in their conception of libraries
…but technology is also a common use and a high priority

More: libraries.pewinternet.org
November 4, 2013

libraries.pewinternet.org

17
Public priorities for libraries
Very important

Somewhat important

Librarians to help find info

80

16

Borrowing books

80

15

Free access to computers/internet

77

18

Quiet study spaces

76

19

Programs & classes for children, teens

74

21

Research resources like databases

73

20

67

Job/career resources

63

Free events/activities

30

49

Free public meeting spaces
0
November 4, 2013

22

20

libraries.pewinternet.org

36
40

60

80

100
18
Should libraries…
Should definitely do

Should maybe do

Should definitely not do

85

Coordinate more with schools

11 2

82

Free literacy programs
Separate spaces for different services

61

Have more comfortable spaces

14 3
27

59

28

53

Offer more e-books

36

20

Move stacks out of public locations

0

14

34

41

Make MOST services automated

12

39

42

Move MOST library services online

5

38

43

Help users digitize own materials

9

30

47

More interactive learning experiences

9

39
20

40

19
20

36
60

80

100
How likely would you be to use…
Very likely

Somewhat likely

"Ask a librarian" online service

Not too likely or not at all likely

37

36

26

Library app

35

Tech try-out program

35

Cell GPS app

34

28

36

Library kiosks in community

33

30

35

Personalized accounts

35

34

29

Classes on borrowing e-books

28

28

29

35

34

29

41

Pre-loaded e-readers

26

32

39

Digital media lab

26

32

40

Classes on e-readers

23
0

28
20

40

48
60

80

100
Among the 25% of Americans who used a
library website in the past year:
•

82% searched the library catalog for a book, DVD, CD

•

72% got basic library info (hours, location, etc.)

•

62% reserved a book, DVD, CD (and 51% renewed)

•

51% used an online database.

•

48% looked for info about library programs & events.

•

30% read book reviews / got book recommendations.

•

30% checked whether they owed fines / paid fines online.

•

27% signed up for library programs & events.

•

22% borrowed or downloaded an e-book.

•

6% reserved a meeting room.

November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

21
Research and writing in the digital age

The good, bad, and Google

“The internet makes doing research easier—easier to
do well and easier to do poorly.”
• Difficulties switching between informal and formal tone
• . . . but also more opportunities for students to write, particularly for
an audience

• More information can be very useful (but also overwhelming)
• Requires more sophisticated research skills from students to refine
and sift through search results
• Who can/should teach digital research skills? And how?

November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

22
So how do students conduct
research in the age of Google
and Wikipedia?

November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

23
The sources students are “very likely” to use in a
typical research assignment*:
• Google / search engine (94%)
• Wikipedia (75%)
• YouTube / social media (52%)
• Their peers (42%)
• Spark Notes, Cliff Notes (41%)
• News sites of major news organizations (25%)
• Print or electronic textbooks (18%)
• Online databases such as EBSCO, JSTOR (17%)
• A research librarian at school or public library (16%)
• Printed books other than textbooks (12%)
• Student-oriented search engines like Sweet Search (10%)
* According to middle and high school AP & NWP teachers
Now what?

Fewer traditional touchpoints
• E-books and online services
• Search engines for “short answer” questions (LMGTFY)
• Awareness of services

November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

25
Opportunity
exists between
keyboard and chair
November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

26
Now what?

Fewer traditional touchpoints
• E-books and online services
• Search engines for “short answer” questions (LMGTFY)
• Awareness of services

Convenience and connection
• Social media, email, apps, websites
• Personalized services, recommendations
• “Digital literacy” beyond the classroom
November 4, 2013

www.pewinternet.org

27
Thank you!
Kathryn Zickuhr

Pew Research Center

Research Associate

pewresearch.org
pewresearch.org/internet

kzickuhr@pewresearch.org

November 4, 2013
edUi 2013
@kzickuhr | @pewinternet | @pewresearch

Reading, writing, and research in the digital age

  • 1.
    Reading, writing, and researchin the digital age Kathryn Zickuhr Research Associate November 4, 2013 edUi 2013 @kzickuhr | @pewinternet | @pewresearch
  • 2.
    About the PewResearch Center • Non-partisan “fact tank” in Washington, DC, made up of seven projects • Does not promote specific technologies or make policy recommendations More: pewresearch.org @pewresearch @pewinternet November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 2
  • 3.
    The Internet: Abrief history November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 3
  • 4.
    Internet use overtime % of adults ages 18+ who go online, 1995-present 85% (2013) 90% 80% 70% 50% 60% (2000) 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 14% (1995) 0% November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 4
  • 5.
    72% of onlineadults (and 80% of online teens) use social network sites 100% 80% 80 87 68 60% 49 40% 29 20% 0% 12-17 November 4, 2013 18-29 30-49 www.pewinternet.org 50-64 65+ 5
  • 6.
    The rise ofmobile Cell phones: • 91% of adults (78% of teens) Smartphones: • 56% of adults (37% of teens) Tablets: • 34% of adults (23% of teens) November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 6
  • 7.
    Mobile is theneedle; social is the thread How information is woven into our lives Mobile technology… Social network sites… Always with us Surround us with information through our many connections Makes information accessible anytime and anywhere Connect us to strong & weak ties Puts information & connections at our fingertips Provide instant feedback, meaning, and context Magnifies the demand for timely information (on-demand) Makes information locationsensitive November 4, 2013 Allow us to shape and create information ourselves and amplify others’ messages www.pewinternet.org 7
  • 8.
    How Americans findand share news and information in the digital age November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 8
  • 9.
    Digital grows asa source for news % of respondents who got news “yesterday” from each platform 80% 70% 60% TV Radio Newspaper Online Any Digital News 50% 40% 30% 20% 50% say internet is a main source for news 10% 0% 1991 November 4, 2013 1994 1997 2000 2003 2006 State of the News Media 2013 2009 2012 stateofthemedia.org 9
  • 10.
    News and information 50%of American adults cite the internet as a main source for national and international news • 71% of adults under 30 say the internet is a main news source (vs 55% who cite television) 23% of adults get news on at least two mobile devices • Info-snacking and just-in-time information Social media, while an increasing part of the digital news experience, is not often a main source of news (though it’s more of a source if you’re mobile) November 4, 2013 pewinternet.org / journalism.org 10
  • 11.
    News and information More:stateofthemedia.org November 4, 2013 pewinternet.org / journalism.org 11
  • 12.
    “Does anyone stillread books?”
  • 13.
    Book reading byage group Among readers, the % in each age group who read a book in print or an e-book in the past year (2012) Print E-books 100% 94% 91% 80% 91% 90% 85% 60% 40% 41% 28% 20% 31% 23% 20% 0% 16-17 November 4, 2013 18-29 30-49 libraries.pewinternet.org 50-64 65+ 13
  • 14.
    Which is betterfor these purposes, a printed book or an e-book? Among those 16+ who read both a print book & an e-book in the past year (2011) Print E-books 100% 80% 83% 81% 73% 69% 60% 53% 40% 43% 45% 35% 20% 25% 19% 9% 0% Reading with Sharing with a child others November 4, 2013 Reading in bed Having a wide selection libraries.pewinternet.org Reading while traveling 13% Get books quickly 14
  • 15.
    E-books beyond e-readers Amongpeople who read e-books, the % in each age group who read their e-books on the following devices (2011) 16-29 30+ 60% 55% 50% 40% 46% 41% 38% 30% 25% 20% 26% 23% 16% 10% 0% Cell phone November 4, 2013 Desktop or laptop E-reader libraries.pewinternet.org Tablet 15
  • 16.
    What do thesechanges mean for educational and cultural institutions? November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 16
  • 17.
    How Americans uselibraries 56% of Americans 16+ used a library in the past year • 53% visited in person • 25% used website Books, browsing, librarians are still central, both in how people use libraries and in their conception of libraries …but technology is also a common use and a high priority More: libraries.pewinternet.org November 4, 2013 libraries.pewinternet.org 17
  • 18.
    Public priorities forlibraries Very important Somewhat important Librarians to help find info 80 16 Borrowing books 80 15 Free access to computers/internet 77 18 Quiet study spaces 76 19 Programs & classes for children, teens 74 21 Research resources like databases 73 20 67 Job/career resources 63 Free events/activities 30 49 Free public meeting spaces 0 November 4, 2013 22 20 libraries.pewinternet.org 36 40 60 80 100 18
  • 19.
    Should libraries… Should definitelydo Should maybe do Should definitely not do 85 Coordinate more with schools 11 2 82 Free literacy programs Separate spaces for different services 61 Have more comfortable spaces 14 3 27 59 28 53 Offer more e-books 36 20 Move stacks out of public locations 0 14 34 41 Make MOST services automated 12 39 42 Move MOST library services online 5 38 43 Help users digitize own materials 9 30 47 More interactive learning experiences 9 39 20 40 19 20 36 60 80 100
  • 20.
    How likely wouldyou be to use… Very likely Somewhat likely "Ask a librarian" online service Not too likely or not at all likely 37 36 26 Library app 35 Tech try-out program 35 Cell GPS app 34 28 36 Library kiosks in community 33 30 35 Personalized accounts 35 34 29 Classes on borrowing e-books 28 28 29 35 34 29 41 Pre-loaded e-readers 26 32 39 Digital media lab 26 32 40 Classes on e-readers 23 0 28 20 40 48 60 80 100
  • 21.
    Among the 25%of Americans who used a library website in the past year: • 82% searched the library catalog for a book, DVD, CD • 72% got basic library info (hours, location, etc.) • 62% reserved a book, DVD, CD (and 51% renewed) • 51% used an online database. • 48% looked for info about library programs & events. • 30% read book reviews / got book recommendations. • 30% checked whether they owed fines / paid fines online. • 27% signed up for library programs & events. • 22% borrowed or downloaded an e-book. • 6% reserved a meeting room. November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 21
  • 22.
    Research and writingin the digital age The good, bad, and Google “The internet makes doing research easier—easier to do well and easier to do poorly.” • Difficulties switching between informal and formal tone • . . . but also more opportunities for students to write, particularly for an audience • More information can be very useful (but also overwhelming) • Requires more sophisticated research skills from students to refine and sift through search results • Who can/should teach digital research skills? And how? November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 22
  • 23.
    So how dostudents conduct research in the age of Google and Wikipedia? November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 23
  • 24.
    The sources studentsare “very likely” to use in a typical research assignment*: • Google / search engine (94%) • Wikipedia (75%) • YouTube / social media (52%) • Their peers (42%) • Spark Notes, Cliff Notes (41%) • News sites of major news organizations (25%) • Print or electronic textbooks (18%) • Online databases such as EBSCO, JSTOR (17%) • A research librarian at school or public library (16%) • Printed books other than textbooks (12%) • Student-oriented search engines like Sweet Search (10%) * According to middle and high school AP & NWP teachers
  • 25.
    Now what? Fewer traditionaltouchpoints • E-books and online services • Search engines for “short answer” questions (LMGTFY) • Awareness of services November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 25
  • 26.
    Opportunity exists between keyboard andchair November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 26
  • 27.
    Now what? Fewer traditionaltouchpoints • E-books and online services • Search engines for “short answer” questions (LMGTFY) • Awareness of services Convenience and connection • Social media, email, apps, websites • Personalized services, recommendations • “Digital literacy” beyond the classroom November 4, 2013 www.pewinternet.org 27
  • 28.
    Thank you! Kathryn Zickuhr PewResearch Center Research Associate pewresearch.org pewresearch.org/internet kzickuhr@pewresearch.org November 4, 2013 edUi 2013 @kzickuhr | @pewinternet | @pewresearch