1. 3rd Scottish Linked Data Interest Group workshop
Linking Data…
what about Know-How?
Paolo Pareti
PhD student at Edinburgh University
10 September 2014

2. Linked Data

3. Linked Data from Web Resources

4. Can the same be done for Know-How?
?

5. What?

6. What is Know-How in this Context?

7. What is Know-How in this Context?

8. What is Know-How in this Context?

9. What is Know-How in this Context?
Focus on Human Know-How:
● instructions created by humans for humans
● tasks where humans are (so far) the main agents

10. Some Important Properties
of Human Know-How
Human Know-how can be:
● vague (different interpretations)
● erroneous
● missing (common sense is often assumed)
● distributed (related knowledge in different repositories)
● diverse (multiple approaches, possibly contradicting)
● evolving (knowledge changes, new knowledge is created)

11. Some Important Properties
of Human Know-How
Human Know-how can be:
● vague (different interpretations)
● erroneous
● missing (common sense is often assumed)
● distributed (related knowledge in different repositories)
● diverse (multiple approaches, possibly contradicting)
● evolving (knowledge changes, new knowledge is created)

12. Why?

13. Why Human Know-How as Linked Data?
machine
understandable
integration with
other knowledge
reusable
open data
better search
and discovery
common sense
task reasoning
activity
recognition
automation
software/robotic
immediate
benefits
future
benefits
data
knowledge

14. Why Human Know-How as Linked Data?
machine
understandable
integration with
other knowledge
reusable
open data
better search
and discovery
common sense
task reasoning
activity
recognition
automation
software/robotic
immediate
benefits
future
benefits
data
knowledge

15. How?

16. How can Know-How be Represented?
How to notify a client that the
requested order has been dispatched?

17. How can it be represented?
Procedure to notify a client that the
order has been dispatched:
1. Make a copy of the dispatch
receipt
2. Send the receipt to the client
3. Send a confirmation email to the
client's email address

18. How can it be represented?
Procedure to notify a client that the
order has been dispatched:
1. Make a copy of the dispatch
receipt
2. Send the receipt to the client
3. Send a confirmation email to the
client's email address
Linked Data
P0

19. How can it be represented?
Procedure to notify a client that the
order has been dispatched:
1. Make a copy of the dispatch
receipt
2. Send the receipt to the client
3. Send a confirmation email to the
client's email address
Linked Data
P0
P1 P2 P3

20. How can it be represented?
Procedure to notify a client that the
order has been dispatched:
1. Make a copy of the dispatch
receipt
2. Send the receipt to the client
3. Send a confirmation email to the
client's email address
Linked Data
P0
P1 P2 P3
?

21. How can it be represented?
Procedure to notify a client that the order
has been dispatched:
1. Make a copy of the dispatch receipt
2. Send the receipt to the client
3. Send a confirmation email to the
client's email address
Linked Data
P0
P1 P2 P3 How to send a receipt to the client:
1. Put the receipt in an A6 envelope
2. Write the client's delivery address
3. Send using a 1rst Class signed
stamp
S0
S1 S2 S3
?

22. How can it be represented?
Procedure to notify a client that the order
has been dispatched:
1. Make a copy of the dispatch receipt
2. Send the receipt to the client
3. Send a confirmation email to the
client's email address
Linked Data
P0
P1 P2 P3 How to send a receipt to the client:
1. Put the receipt in an A6 envelope
2. Write the client's delivery address
3. Send using a 1rst Class signed
stamp
S0
S1 S2 S3

23. Simple RDF vocabulary
Linked Data
P0
P1 P2 P3
S0
S1 S2 S3
:P0 :has_step :P1 .
:P0 :has_step :P2 .
:P0 :has_step :P3 .
:P2 :has_method :S0 .
:S0 :has_step :S1 .
:S0 :has_step :S2 .
:S0 :has_step :S3 .

24. How can it be represented?
Procedure to notify a client that the order
has been dispatched:
1. Make a copy of the dispatch receipt
2. Send the receipt to the client
3. Send a confirmation email to the
client's email address
How to send a receipt to the client:
1. Put the receipt in an A6 envelope
2. Write the client's delivery address
3. Send using a 1rst Class signed
stamp
How to notify a client that the
order has been dispatched:
1. Make a copy of the dispatch
receipt
2. Send the receipt to the client
3. Send a confirmation email to
the client's email address

25. How can it be represented?
Procedure to notify a client that the order
has been dispatched:
1. Make a copy of the dispatch receipt
2. Send the receipt to the client
3. Send a confirmation email to the
client's email address
How to send a receipt to the client:
1. Put the receipt in an A6 envelope
2. Write the client's delivery address
3. Send using a 1rst Class signed
stamp
How to notify a client that the
order has been dispatched:
1. Make a copy of the dispatch
receipt
2. Send the receipt to the client
a. Put the receipt in an A6
envelope
b. Write the client's
delivery address
c. Send using a 1rst
Class signed stamp
3. Send a confirmation email to
the client's email address

26. Really?

27. Experiments and Results
Is it possible to extract the Linked data representation of
procedures and then link it with other related knowledge?
1. Knowledge Extraction
2. Knowledge Integration

28. Knowledge Extraction
Automatic knowledge extraction from semi-structured
websites
Results (from crawling the WikiHow and Snapguide websites):
● 211,696 extracted procedures
● 2,609,236 extracted entities

29. Knowledge Integration
Two kinds of integration of know-how:
● with existing Linked Data
● with other know-how

30. Integration with existing Linked Data
Extracted
Know-How
Dataset
How to make a pancake
requires
2 eggs
http://de.dbpedia.org/page/Egg
is a

31. Integration with other Know-How
Extracted
Know-How
Dataset
How to make a pancake
has step
break the eggs
has method
How to break an egg

32. Integration Process… in a nutshell
Extracted
Know-How
Dataset
Links
NLP
Machine
Learning

33. Know-How Integration:
Results
Community Integration* Automatic Integration
Number of links 106,056 221,351
Precision 70.7% 87.3%
Coverage 27.5% 50.4%
Type of links HTML links RDF links
*Links manually generated by the WikiHow community

34. Know-How as Linked Data?
● It is possible to represent know-how as Linked Data
● Linked Data can be useful in the human know-how domain
for a large number of applications
● Experimental evidence has been provided in the use-case
of links generation

35. References:
Pareti Paolo, Ewan Klein, and Adam Barker. "A semantic web of know-how:
linked data for community-centric tasks." Proceedings of the companion
publication of the 23rd international conference on World wide web companion.
International World Wide Web Conferences Steering Committee, 2014.
Pareti Paolo, Ryutaro Ichise, Benoit Testu, Ewan Klein, and Adam Barker
“Integrating Know-How into the Linked Data Cloud” Knowledge Engineering and
Knowledge Management (EKAW 2014), 24 - 28 November 2014, Linköping,
Sweden (forthcoming)