Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

4th OpenAIRE Workshop, Nils Dietrich

667 views

Published on

4th OpenAIRE Workshop - Legal and Sustainability Issues for Open Access Infrastructures
Nov. Vilnius
Legal prototype of e-infrastructure – legal evaluation of selected usage scenarios - Nils Dietrich, Faculty of law, Goettingen University

Published in: Technology, Education
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

4th OpenAIRE Workshop, Nils Dietrich

  1. 1. N l s D et ri c h, LL. M i i . Uni vers i t ät Göt t i ngen Cont ac t : n. di et ri c h@ ura. uni - goet t i ngen. de j Cas e St udi es Spec i f i c Us age Sc enari os T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1
  2. 2. “Legal P rot ot ype” of e- i nf ras t ruc t ure •Wt hi n i t hi s part us e of of dat a t he s t udy t he c ons t rai nt s on t he s t em i ng m f rom IP ri ght s are el aborat ed on i n det ai l . •The anal ys i s i s bas ed on s el ec t ed s c enari os f or t he us age of res earc h dat a. T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 •The 2
  3. 3. End us er s c enari o A P ct ure i a res earcher w ho i s a part i ci pant i n an EC proj ect and report s i n O penA R I Epl us an O pen A cces s publ i cat i on res ul t i ng f rom t hi s EC proj ect . The publ i cat i on ref ers t o al ready avai l abl e pri m ary dat a t hat has a D aCi t e- D I . at O The res earcher can ei t her ent er t hi s D I or O brow e dat as et s w t h D aCi t e- D I s t o generat e s i at O t he l i nk bet w een t he publ i cat i on and t he dat a. T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 3
  4. 4. W c h t ypes of us age are hi rel evant ? •Thi s s c enari o i s an exam e of t he l i nki ng of a pl publ i c at i on t o pri m ary dat a. • The s c i ent i s t i s abl e t o generat e a l i nk bet w een t he publ i c at i on and t he dat a. • The s c i ent i s t i s abl e t o ac c es s dat as et s . • OpenAIR has t o res ol ve t he D us i ng t he D aCi t e E OI at dat abas e. T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 4
  5. 5. Is t here i nf ri ngem ent of IP ri ght s •The t ype of res earc h dat a t hat i s deal t w t h here i s i pri m ary dat a. •Suc h pri m ary dat a w l l norm l y not be prot ec t ed by i al c opyri ght . •B t he ut dat abas e t hat c ont ai ns t he pri m ary dat a i s T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 5
  6. 6. Is t here i nf ri ngem ent of IP ri ght s •The us e of a s ubs t ant i al part of a(-) abas e dat • The us e by t he s i ngl e res earc her (+) • The us e by t he OpenAIR i nf ras t ruc t ure i t s el f E •Ext rac t i o n and re- ut i l i s at i on • Ac c es s i ng • Li nki ng T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 6
  7. 7. Is t here i nf ri ngem ent of IP ri ght s •Ac c es s i ng • B t he us er y • B t he OpenAIR i nf ras t ruc t ure y E •Li nki ng • It depends on t he nat i onal j uri s di c t i on, w her het l i nki ng i s a rel evant ac t . T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 7
  8. 8. Cons equenc es •It i s s t i l l not c l ear w het her us ers are al l ow ed t o generat e l i nks t o dat a t hat i s al ready avai l abl e on t he i nt ernet . •OpenAIR Ep l us w oul d i nf ri nge t he s ui generi s dat abas e prot ec t i on ri ght i f i t proc es s es t he dat a of t he D OI w t hout t he perm s s i on of t he ri ght hol der of i i t he D aCi t e dat abas e. at T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 8
  9. 9. Thi rd- part y provi der s c enari o D I n t he N herl ands al l uni vers i t i es and t he R et oyal N herl ands A et cadem y of A s and Sci ences us e t he res earch i nf orm i on s ys t em cal l ed rt at , M S. I n t he open acces s part i nf orm i on on res earch proj ect s , ETI at i ncl udi ng t hei r out put , m be f ound. P s i bl e t ypes of out put ay os i ncl ude dat as et s , art i cl es , conf erence papers and pres ent at i ons . The N R S s ys t em w ch i s us ed as an aggregat or f or A CI , hi O penA R I Epl us , harves t s m adat a f rom M S, publ i cat i on et ETI repos i t ori es and dat as et repos i t ori es . W hen m adat a of t hes e et di f f erent s ources s hares a com on m adat a el em , f or i ns t ance m et ent t he EU proj ect code, N R S i s abl e t o s how t he rel at i ons hi ps A CI bet teen p n earch p r h 2 1 T elg lwd o O e A R pu . cproj t 0 3 , h e a su y f res I E ls o y ig ect s organi s at i ons , res earchers and 9
  10. 10. W c h t ypes of us age are hi rel evant ? •M adat a et i s harves t ed f rom M ETIS and ot her repos i t ori es . •Af t er harves t i ng, t he m adat a i s s t ored i n et OpenAIR Epl us . •NAR CIS i s abl e t o s how w c h doc um s s hare a m adat a hi ent et el em , e. g. w c h dat a bel ongs t o a s pec i f i c ent hi T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1 0
  11. 11. Is t here i nf ri ngem ent of IP ri ght s •The ac t i ons of harves t i ng m adat a c arri ed out by et N CIS i n t hi s s c enari o c oul d es pec i al l y AR i nf ri nge t he s ui generi s dat abas e prot ec t i on ri ght of t he di f f erent repos i t ori es . •If s om e of t he m adat a i s prot ec t ed by c opyri ght , t he et harves t i ng c oul d al s o i nf ri nge c opyri ght . T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1 1
  12. 12. Is t here i nf ri ngem ent of IP ri ght s •At f i rs t N CIS ac c es s es t he open ac c es s part of t he AR repos i t ori es . •One c oul d t hi nk about t he appl i c at i on of t he s c i ent i f i c res earc h exc ept i on. •NAR CIS s how rel at i ons hi ps bet w s een t he dat a. T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1 2
  13. 13. Cons equenc es •Wt hout i an agreem ent w t h t he repos i t ori es on t he i c opyi ng of t hei r dat a, OpenAIR i s not al l ow E ed t o harves t t hei r dat a and c opy i t i nt o t he OpenAIR i nf ras t ruc t ure. E •As i t i s one of t he goal s of t he proj ec t t o enabl e t he m ual harves t i ng of res ourc es bet w ut een OpenAIR E and ext ernal s ourc es , i t i s very i m port ant t o T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1 3
  14. 14. Thank you f or your at t ent i on! T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1 4

×