Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Commercial Solar Economics

2,579 views

Published on

Commercial Solar presentation focusing on the finance of loans and PPAs

Published in: Economy & Finance
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Commercial Solar Economics

  1. 1. Andy Black “Commercial Solar Economics & Solar Financial Analyst (408) 428 0808x1 Introduction to Financing with Leases & andy@ongrid.net PPAs”Solar Living Institute: April 20, 2008, Los Angeles, CA, 9am-5pm Contact: Solar Living Institute: www.solarliving.org, 707 744 2017 to register 8:30 Check-in 9:10 Introductions Commercial Tax & Incentive Issues Break, Q & A, Networking TOU & Demand Rate Choices & Case Studies ~12:00 Lunch, Q & A, Networking (~30 minutes if possible) Choosing Rebates vs. PBIs Commercial Financing In General Break, Q & A Financing with Leases Financing with PPAs ~4:30 Formal Conclusion, Break, Q & A Interactive Examples (for those who wish to stay) Using the OnGrid Tool We must be out by 5:00 (add’l questions outside)Diligence: Heights by great men reached and kept were not obtained by sudden flight, but they, while their companions slept, were toiling upward in the night. - Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
  2. 2. Andy Black “Commercial Solar Economics & Solar Financial Analyst (408) 428 0808x1 Introduction to Financing with Leases & andy@ongrid.net PPAs”Solar Living Institute: April 20, 2008, Los Angeles, CA, 9am-5pm Contact: Solar Living Institute: www.solarliving.org, 707 744 2017 to registerAbstract:This rigorous workshop is designed to help commercial systems integrators (dealers, installers, andsalespeople) understand and make the financial case for commercial PV systems including specificsfor the local/nearby utilities (depending on location), then understand how to finance them withPPAs and Leases.“Economics of Solar: Making The Financial Case for Residential Solar” or equivalent is a requiredprerequisite.This class includes: Economics of commercial & municipal systems, including the additional incentives (tax credits, RECs, PBIs, depreciation), and utility tariff options (including TOU and demand charge rate choices) PPAs: Understanding the basics, subtleties, complexities, risks, and opportunities Leases: Understanding the major types, how and when they are used A short list of financing, legal, tax, and accounting providers who specialize in solarAll students will receive a copy of the demo version of the OnGrid Tool (licensing agreement will berequired).Biography:Andy Black is a Solar Financial Analyst and the owner of OnGrid Solar. OnGrid Solar providesfinancial analysis and sales education & software to solar installers to help them make a strong salescase for solar electricity to their customers. Andy has more than a dozen years of design, consulting,teaching, sales, and research experience in solar. He specializes in demonstrating the financial paybackof solar electricity systems. He is a former NABCEP certified solar installer.Andy Black is a recent member of the Board of Directors of the American Solar Energy Society andserved as Chapters Representative. He is also a member of the Advisory Board of the NorthernCalifornia Solar Energy Association.Andy’s formal education includes a Bachelor’s in Electrical Engineering from Penn State University, aMaster’s in Electrical Engineering from University of Southern California, and a Marketing Certificateat the University of California. His training in solar electricity includes Solar Energy International’sintensive photovoltaic coursework and more than a dozen specialty courses in solar electric and relatedfields. He presents regularly on the financial analysis of solar electricity to audiences nationwide.Andy is also the groundskeeper and servant for a cat at his home in San Jose, CA.Contact Info: Andy Black, CEO OnGrid Solar 4175 Renaissance Dr #4, San Jose, CA 95134 (408) 428 0808x1 andy@ongrid.net www.ongrid.net
  3. 3. COMMERCIAL SOLAR Introductions & Thanks ECONOMICS & FINANCING !  Solar Power International 09 Andy Black !  Solar Electric Power Association Solar Financial Analyst "  Julia Hamm & Emily Brown, & Stuart Raper & Sales Software Creator !  Andy Black, OnGrid Solar "  Solar Financial Analyst & OnGrid Tool Creator Solar Power International 2009 !  You for coming! © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 2 Quick Survey - Quick Survey - Who’s Here? !  Existing integrators / dealer / installers Your Goals for Today? "  Managers & Owners !  Learn about economics for general knowledge !  Salesperson for integrator / dealer / installer !  Want to use economics for selling / grow !  New or hopeful integrators / dealers / installers !  New or hopeful salespeople business !  Government / Utilities !  Want to learn about / have the OnGrid Tool !  Customers / consumers / end users !  Want to increase your knowledge to develop !  Manufacturers your own tool !  Others? !  Who’s taken the Residential/Basic Payback Class?© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 3 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 4 Quick Survey - Instructor Background Area(s) of Interest? !  Came to learn specifically about: !  M.S. Electrical Engineering "  Commercial Financial Analysis: IRR, Tax, etc !  SEI graduate & NABCEP Certified PV Installer "  Commercial Lease Financing !  13 Years involved with Solar "  Commercial PPA Financing !  9 Years studying, writing, & presenting about # Use PPAs in selling Solar Financial Issues # Create new PPA offering to market !  5 Years as Solar Salesperson !  Other interests? !  Now a Solar Financial Analyst & !  Networking list? Creator of the “OnGrid Tool” solar sales software© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 5 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 6
  4. 4. Handout Resource List Decorum !  Resources available at www.ongrid.net !  Questions: Please focus on Solar Economics & Payback " Articles & papers on solar “Payback” !  No Side Conversations Please " Upcoming classes & events "  Hard for others to hear # Sales & Marketing !  Cell phones to fun mode # Slides from past classes !  Site Logistics & Breaks "  Free demos of the OnGrid Tool "  Facilities "  Lunch & 2 breaks: Networking© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 7 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 8 Agenda Installed System Costs - Size !  Commercial Solar Financial Analysis !  Typical range $7-$11/ CEC AC watt thru 10/2008 "  Commercial Incentive, Tax, & Tariff Issues !  Commercial, Gov’t & Non-Profit: $7-$9/Watt CEC AC "  Four Financial Analysis Methods & Examples "  $5.50-$7.50/Watt STC DC (1 W DC =~ .83 W AC) !  Choosing Rebates vs. PBIs "  $5.50/W STC is typical for 500kW+ !  Financing with Leasing & PPAs !  Some economies of scale !  Interactive Examples using the OnGrid Tool !  Price Trends 2003-2008 Questions preferred at points marked: "  Germany & Spain Questions? "  Please focus on Economics Questions? !  Price Declines Since 11/2008 and Predictions !  Down $1 by 5/2009; Down $1.50-$2 by 12/2009© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 9 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 10 PBI: Performance CSI EPBB Rebate Based Incentive !  Systems under 50kW (30kW in 2010+) !  Systems over 50kW (30kW in 2010+) !  EPBB: Expected Performance Based Buydown "  Optional for systems <50kW "  Adjusted for Expected Performance: !  Paid for all kWh produced for first 5 years # Tilt, Orientation, Shading, Location, Module "  Actual performance Temperature (due to lack of air flow) # EPBB Calculator: www.csi-epbb.com Questions?© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 11 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 12
  5. 5. CSI Trigger Tracker Step Statewide MW in Step EPBB Payments (per Watt) Residential Commercial Government / PBI Payments (per kWh) Residential Commercial Government / Tax Benefit Overview Non-Profit Non-Profit 1 50 n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a 2 70 $2.50 $2.50 $3.25 $0.39 $0.39 $0.50 3 4 5 100 130 160 $2.20 $1.90 $1.55 $2.20 $1.90 $1.55 $2.95 $2.65 $2.30 $0.34 $0.26 $0.22 $0.34 $0.26 $0.22 $0.46 $0.37 $0.32 !  Federal Investment Tax Credit (ITC)/Grant !  Federal & State Accelerated Depreciation 6 190 $1.10 $1.10 $1.85 $0.15 $0.15 $0.26 7 215 $0.65 $0.65 $1.40 $0.09 $0.09 $0.19 8 250 $0.35 $0.35 $1.10 $0.05 $0.05 $0.15 9 285 $0.25 $0.25 $0.90 $0.03 $0.03 $0.12 !  Only apply to taxable entities (not schools, 10 350 $0.20 $0.20 $0.70 $0.03 $0.03 $0.10 non-profits, gov’t, etc) Disclaimer: I’m not a CPA or lawyer, and am not providing tax advice. Seek qualified professional help Trigger Tracker website: http://www.csi-trigger.com As of 10/19/09 Program Data & Statistics: http://csi.powerclerk.com© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 13 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 14 Federal Investment Federal ITC “Grant” Tax Credit - Commercial - Commercial 2009-2010 !  30% Investment Tax Credit - Extended 10/2008 "  Must be “placed in service” in 2006-2016 !  30% ITC becomes (or optionally can be?) a Grant "  10% if installed after 2016 !  Same general features and intended functionality as “There is no feast which does not come to an end.” the ITC, but better: - Chinese proverb ! "  Paid < 60 days of “placed in service” or application !  IRS Form 3468 (Sect 48 of Internal Revenue Code) "  Usable even if no tax appetite (effectively a !  Unused credit can be carried forward 20 years refundable ITC or Federal Rebate) !  Commercial !  Commercial systems only "  Including home businesses > 20% sqf - with caution !  “Placed in service” in 2009-2010 only, or !  Limited by AMT in 2008, No AMT limit 2009-2016 "  Construction Initiated 2009-10, completed by 2017 !  Vests at 20% per year (over 5 years) !  Treasury web application now Commercial Solar Economics & Financing available© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 15 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. - 16 Federal ITC “Grant” Limitations “Placed In Service” !  Commercial systems only SEIA “Guide to Federal Tax Incentives for Solar Energy” "  Limited to IRC Sec 48 and some Sec 45 Available at: www.seia.org! !  Pass-thru entities (partnerships, LLCs, S-corps) !  Equipment delivered and construction / installation can use grant, as long as none of the recipients is completed! non-taxable (and therefore disqualified) "  Minor tasks like painting need not be finished ! "  I.e. One disqualifies all, regardless of small % !  Taxpayer has taken legal title and control ! !  Allows transfer of ownership !  Pre-operational tests demonstrate the equipment !  Recapture of Grant or ITC on permanent functions as intended ! cessation of production !  Taxpayer has licenses, permits, and PTO (permission !  May be state taxable in certain cases to operate)!© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 17 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 18
  6. 6. “Placed In Service” Depreciation - Federal !  Depreciation = tax deduction spread over time POSTT:! !  MACRS 5-Year Accelerated Depreciation (1/2 yr conv.) !  Permits & Permission to Operate signed off! MACRS: Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System "  !  Operation Commenced! IRS Form 4562 "  !  Equivalent of tax deducting system’s ‘basis’ over 5.5 years !  Synchronization with the Grid! Net Value = Basis * Tax Rate !  Testing Complete! Net Value = (System ITC basis - 1/2 ITC) * Tax Rate Net Value = System ITC basis * 85% * Tax Rate !  Turnover to the Customer! !  Regular Schedule: 20%, 32%, 19.2%, 11.52%, 11.52%, 5.76% !  2008-09 Schedule: 60%, 16%, 9.6%, 5.76%, 5.76%, 2.88% "  2008-09 Gets 50% “Bonus Acceleration of Depreciation” !  Commercial (including home businesses >50% by sqf) !  Up to 20 year carry-forward© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 19 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 20 Depreciation - CA State Financial Hazards & Gotchas !  Corporate: 12 Year Straight Line method !  Federal Tax on Rebate !  Non-Corporate: MACRS 5-Year !  1099 tax forms have been issued to "  (Sole-Proprietors, LLP, etc) recipients !  Section 136 applies only to residential !  State Depr Basis is Top Line Cost minus Rebate & State Tax Credit !  Commercial (including home businesses) Questions?© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 21 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 22 Rebate Tax Interactions Tax Credit & Depr. Example !  If the rebate is non-taxable, the federal ITC Non-Taxed Rebate $150K System Cost is on amount after rebate -$50K Rebate $100K Net Cost After Rebate !  If rebate is taxable, then federal ITC is on -$30K Tax Credit Value (30% of $100K) amount before rebate -$35K Depr Value (85% of $100K * 41%) =$35K Net Cost !  Rebates are not state taxable in CA 41% = combined net federal & state tax rate (35% Federal, 8.84% CA State)© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 23 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 24
  7. 7. Tax Credit & Depr. Example Tax Credit & Depr. Example Taxed Rebate Non-Taxed Rebate Taxed Rebate $150K System Cost $150K System Cost $150K System Cost -$50K Rebate -$50K Rebate -$50K Rebate +17.5K Rebate Tax ($50K * 35% Fed Tax) +17.5K Rebate Tax $100K Net Cost After Rebate -$45K Tax Credit Value (30% of $150K) -$30K Tax Credit Value -$45K Tax Credit Value -$52K Depr Value (85% of $150K * 41%) -$35K Depr Value (85K * 41%) -$52K Depr Value (127.5K * 41%) =$20.5K Net Cost =$35K Net Cost =$20.5K Net Cost If commercial, want rebate taxable (no choice) Then tax credit and depreciation are on amount before rebate "  Worth more to pay tax on rebate, then get 30% credit and " © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. depreciation on rebate © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 25 Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 26 Section 179 Not Available Small Business Carry-Back of NOL !  Can’t use Section 179 Deduction (in lieu !  In 2009(+?), small businesses can carry of depreciation) and also get ITC or back Net Operating Losses up to 5 years Treasury Grant "  $15 Million Gross Receipts limitation "  Normally only 2 year carry-back !  2009 Economic Stimulus© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 27 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 28 Tax Benefits System Variables in More Depth !  ITC & MACRS reduce customer cost, but not !  Demand Charges up-front !  RECs !  Not available to all customers - affected by !  Time-of-Use (TOU) Choices & Issues AMT (before 2009 only) !  Commercial Tax Issues "  Ask about customers “tax appetite” "  More in Lease & PPA section !  Customers beware of optimistic sales claims© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 29 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 30
  8. 8. CPUC Loading Order Least GHG, Least Total Cost Electric Rate Structures Overview (including new power plants) 1a. Customer Awareness via Energy Audits and Analysis 1 - Energy Efficiency & Conservation 1b. Efficiency Rebates !  Options for Solar - Net Metering Eg: programmable thermostats and lighting controls, CFLs, etc. 2a. TOU & Super-Peak Rates !  3 Customer Classes (Res, Com, Ag) 2b. Demand Charges 2 - Demand Response & Load Control 2c. Utility Control Systems with large critical !  2 Types of Rate (Flat, TOU) Greater customers System 2d. Advanced Metering 2e. “Flex Your Power” Ads "  TOU: Time of Use 3 - Renewables Reliability 2f. PV 3. California Solar Initiative (PV), !  Demand Charges for Commercial & other RE programs Overall 4 - Clean Cost Fossil Effectiveness© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 31 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 32 Time of Use with Common Electric Rate Schedules Annual Net Metering Net Metering on an annual basis Common Commercial Rate !  Utility Common Ag Rates Schedules Combined with !  Time Of Use metering CA - PG&E A1, A6, A10, E19, E20 AG1, AG4, AG5 CA - SCE GS-1, GS-2, TOU-GS-3, TOU-8 PA-1, PA-2 !  Sell at high rate, Buy at low rate CA - SDG&E A, AL-TOU, A6-TOU, DG-R PA !  2:1 or 3:1 in customer favor !  Can reduce system size 0-30% NJ - JCPL GLP "  Reduction depends on % on-peak usage & rate schedule NJ – PSEG GP #  Commercial is usually small reduction #  Shading and orientation AZ - APS E-32 Questions?© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 33 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 34 Time Of Use Commercial Rates (PG&E) Commercial PG&E A6 & A10 Demand Commercial "A6" & "A10" Time-of-Use Pricing Periods Rate Size Flat Rate TOU Rate Charge Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday A1 <20kW 13-19¢ Flat None Midnight - 6am Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak 40¢ Peak 6am - 8:30am Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak A6 Any* None 8:30am - Noon Off-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Off-Peak 11¢ Off-Peak Noon - 6pm Off-Peak Peak Peak Peak Peak Peak Off-Peak A10 <500kW 10-13¢ Flat High 6pm - 9:30pm Off-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Off-Peak 15¢ Peak 9:30pm - Midnight Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak A10 TOU <500kW High 9-11¢ Off-Peak 14¢ Peak !  Use and/or Sell On-Peak @ up to 40¢/kWh on A6 E19**/E20 >500kW High 7-8¢ Off-Peak !  More usage on peak, less benefit from TOU *If not required to be on another rate schedule **Required schedule if measured demand is >500kW Questions?© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 35 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 36
  9. 9. SCE Commercial Commercial Rates (SCE) Time Of Use SCE Commercial Time-of-Use Pricing Periods Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday 11pm - 5am Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak 5am - 8am Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak Off-Peak 8am - Noon Off-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Off-Peak Noon - 6pm Off-Peak Peak Peak Peak Peak Peak Off-Peak 6pm - 11pm Off-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Part-Peak Off-Peak !  Use and/or Sell On-Peak @ 24-32¢/kWh on Option R "  Part-Peak @ 14-19¢/kWh !  More usage on peak, less benefit from TOU Questions?© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 37 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 38 Electric Rate Structures Overview Demand Charges !  Usually applies only to Large users Commercial and Agricultural !  Options for Solar - Net Metering "  !  On a per kW basis (load, not usage) !  3 Customer Classes (Res, Com, Ag) "  Size of the wire, power plant for peak usage !  2 Types of Rate (Flat, TOU) "  TOU: Time of Use !  Demand Charges for Commercial !  Based on highest 15-30 minute peak load average any time during the last 1-12 billing months Questions?© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 39 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 40 Demand Profile vs. Reducing Demand Charges Solar Production !  Difficult for solar to offset demand TYPICAL "  Clouds, spikes in usage not during solar hours, BUILDING DEMAND inverters tripping offline DEMAND & !  Add control systems ~$30K+ IDEAL PRODUCTION SOLAR !  Some rates have no/low demand charges PRODUCTION "  And sometimes high peak (sell) rates 7am 12noon 5pm "  Benefits depend on Size: Usage ratio and demand & HOUR usage patterns with respect to rate schedule hours© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 41 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 42
  10. 10. Reducing Demand Charges RECs, Green Tags, TRCs !  RECs = Renewable Energy Credits !  TRC = Tradable Renewable Certificates !  Green Tags = RECs = TRCs = S-RECs !  What are these? "  The green value part of a solar kWh "  The Legal Rights to Green-ness Electricity (kWh) Generating Plant (kWh) Green Tags (kWh) Questions?© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 43 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 44 REC Value CA REC Value !  RECs have value to other consumers !  REC sale value can be added to other value generated by the system to calculate payback, etc. " Those who can’t get solar directly "  Not included in any examples here " Utilities who need it to get into "  Likely 1¢ to 5¢/kWh in California - same as Wind compliance with emissions "  Must give up “Green Attributes” & claims requirements. !  Challenges in aggregating from small systems !  The best performing systems produce the most !  Value ranges from 1¢ to 68¢/kWh RECs "  Depends on location, type & term !  Double counting in sales Questions? "  Depends on state mandate for S-RECs !  Green-e Certified RECs: www.green-e.org© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 45 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 46 NJ REC Value Commercial Cost / Value Overview - System Cost !  REC sale value can be added to other value + Rebate / PBI generated by the system to calculate payback, etc. - Tax on Rebate / PBI "  15 year producible life + 30% Fed Tax Credit "  Assumption in examples at 48¢ for 1 year, 30¢ for + ~41% Depreciation * 85% 12 more years, and 10¢ for the final 2 years + Savings & Inflation !  Challenges in aggregating from small systems - Lost Electric Bill Tax Deduction "  Estimated/calculated RECs used - Maintenance & Inflation - Inverter Replacement Cost !  The best performing systems produce the most + REC Value, Green Marketing, Morale RECs ------------------------------------------ Questions? = Net Cost Questions?© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 47 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 48
  11. 11. Financial Analysis Agenda Methods & Tests Overview !  Commercial Solar Financial Analysis !  Simple Payback: In reasonable time "  Commercial Incentive, Tax, & Tariff Issues !  Total Lifecycle Cash Flow "  Four Financial Analysis Methods & Examples "  Gives back lots more than cost over time !  Choosing Rebates vs. PBIs !  Rate of Return analysis: 6-15+% returns !  Financing with Leasing & PPAs !  Cash Flow when financing: Cash Positive !  Interactive Examples using the OnGrid Tool !  Increase in Appraisal Valuation "  Appraises for more than it cost© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 49 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 50 General Commercial Utility Specific Variables & Assumptions Commercial & !  35% federal tax bracket, corresponding state tax bracket Muni/Non-Profit Assumptions !  Facing south, 14° pitch, simple composition shingle roof by Staring/Ending Rate AC kWh ~2008 Cost per Schedule full service provider, no complications Utility Insolation Production per rated kW per year rated Watt Peak%/ PP% Incentives Demand !  Slightly conservative real system performance, no shade A1 / A6 CA - PG&E San Francisco 1540 / CEC kW $1.10/W Rebate 47%/35% !  Final Net Cost = total installed system costs - Rebate (if any) - GS2B / GS2A 10kW: $8.50 CEC CA - SCE Los Angeles 1590 / CEC kW 48%/43% $1.55/W Rebate 2009 Fed 30% ITC + $800 Permit + $0 Utility Fee 25kW: $8.25 CEC 50kW: $8.00 CEC 2x Min Demand AL-TOU / DG-R !  System maintenance cost is 0.25% of gross system cost per CA - SDG&E San Diego 1700 / CEC kW 39%/51% $1.55/W Rebate 2x Min Demand year, adjusted for inflation SRECs: 48¢/1yr, NJ - JCPL Newark 1100 / STC kW 50kW: $6.50 STC GP 30¢/12yrs, 10¢/12yrs !  5.0% electric inflation (2.2% in CO) $1/W Rebate !  Module degradation: 0.5% per year !  Inverter replacement costing $700/kW occurs in year 15 !  Solar only - no Energy Efficiency included© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 51 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 52 General Gov’t/Non-Profit Variables & Assumptions !  Facing south, 14° pitch, simple composition shingle roof by full service provider, no complications !  Slightly conservative real system performance, no shade Final Net Cost = total installed system costs - Rebate (if Watt’$ the Payback? !  any) + $800 Permit + $0 Utility Fee !  System maintenance cost is 0.25% of gross system cost per year, adjusted for inflation !  5.0% electric inflation (except CO is 2.2%) !  Module degradation: 0.5% per year !  Inverter replacement costing $700/kW occurs in year 15 !  Solar only - no Energy Efficiency included© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 53 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 54
  12. 12. General Commercial Variables & Assumptions !  35% federal tax bracket, corresponding state tax bracket !  Facing south, 14° pitch, simple composition shingle roof by full service provider, no complications !  Slightly conservative real system performance, no shade !  Final Net Cost = total installed system costs - Rebate (if any) - 2009 Fed 30% ITC + $800 Permit + $0 Utility Fee !  System maintenance cost is 0.25% of gross system cost per year, adjusted for inflation !  5.0% electric inflation (2.2% in CO) !  Module degradation: 0.5% per year !  Inverter replacement costing $700/kW occurs in year 15 !  Solar only - no Energy Efficiency included© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 51 Utility Specific Commercial & Muni/Non-Profit Assumptions Staring/Ending Rate AC kWh ~2008 Cost per Schedule Utility Insolation Production per Incentives rated Watt Peak%/ PP% rated kW per year Demand A1 / A6 CA - PG&E San Francisco 1540 / CEC kW $1.10/W Rebate 47%/35% GS2B / GS2A 10kW: $8.50 CEC CA - SCE Los Angeles 1590 / CEC kW 48%/43% $1.55/W Rebate 25kW: $8.25 CEC 2x Min Demand 50kW: $8.00 CEC AL-TOU / DG-R CA - SDG&E San Diego 1700 / CEC kW 39%/51% $1.55/W Rebate 2x Min Demand SRECs: 48¢/1yr, NJ - JCPL Newark 1100 / STC kW 50kW: $6.50 STC GP 30¢/12yrs, 10¢/12yrs $1/W Rebate© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 52
  13. 13. Commercial Total Total Lifecycle Payback Lifecycle Payback kWh PV System Final Net Cost w/ Cumulative Savings Lifecycle Years Pre-Solar Utility Usage per Size & Tax Benefits & Over First 25 Years Payback To Bill Month Rating Rebate (including inflation) Ratio Payback PG&E $346 2000 10 kW CEC $23K $68K 2.9x 11 PG&E $853 5000 25 kW CEC $56K $172K 3.1x 10.6 PG&E $1,696 10000 50 kW CEC $107K $344K 3.2x 10.3 SCE $333 2000 10 kW CEC $20K $27K 1.3x 21.1 SCE $695 5000 25 kW CEC $48K $75K 1.5x 19.1 SCE $1,297 10000 50 kW CEC $92K $156K 1.7x 18.2 Total Savings SDG&E $371 2000 10 kW CEC $20K $55K 2.7x 11.6 SDG&E $840 5000 25 kW CEC $48K $137K 2.8x 11.2 Initial Cost SDG&E $1,621 10000 50 kW CEC $92K $274K 3.0x 10.9 NJ - JCPL $692 10000 50 kW STC $91K $116K 1.3x 8.1 NC - Progress $800 10000 50 kW STC $47K $88K 1.9x 17.9 CT - UI $2,309 10000 50 kW PTC $133K $310K 2.3x 13.1 AZ - APS $906 10000 50 kW STC $60K $127K 2.1x 16.4 !  Total Savings (whole area) is much larger than Initial Cost HI - HECO $2,144 10000 50 kW STC $47K $368K 7.9x 5.1 CO - Xcel $805 10000 50 kW STC $109K $57K 0.5x 40.2© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 55 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 56 Gov’t/Non-Profit Total Lifecycle Payback Total Lifecycle Payback PV System Final Net Cost w/ Cumulative Savings Lifecycle Gov’t/Non-Profit vs. Commercial Pre-Solar kWh Usage Utility Size & Tax Benefits & Over First 25 Years Payback Bill per Month Rating Rebate (including inflation) Ratio PG&E $346 2000 10 kW CEC $68K $122K 1.8x PG&E $853 5000 25 kW CEC $162K $306K 1.9x PG&E $1,696 10000 50 kW CEC $311K $613K 2.0x !  Differerences between Gov’t/Non-Profit SCE $333 2000 10 kW CEC $63K $48K 0.8x SCE $695 5000 25 kW CEC $150K $134K 0.9x & Commercial? - Taxes! SCE $1,297 10000 50 kW CEC $285K $278K 1.0x SDG&E $371 2000 10 kW CEC $63K $97K 1.6x !  Tax deduction for electricity SDG&E $840 5000 25 kW CEC $150K $244K 1.6x SDG&E $1,621 10000 50 kW CEC $285K $488K 1.7x !  Commercial tax deduction lowers the NJ - JCPL NC - Progress $692 $800 10000 10000 50 kW STC 50 kW STC $301K $351K $318K $150K 1.1x 0.4x value of a kWh saved by solar CT - UI $2,309 10000 50 kW PTC $336K $539K 1.6x !  Commercial gets tax credit & depreciation AZ - APS $906 10000 50 kW STC $276K $218K 0.8x HI - HECO $2,144 10000 50 kW STC $351K $628K 1.8x CO - Xcel $805 10000 50 kW STC $351K $95K 0.3x Questions?© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 57 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 58 IRR Timeline Year X Year: Year 0 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 … … (12-15-20) System -System Cost Cost +Incentives Rebate PBI 1 PBI 2 PBI 3 … PBI X … +Bill Savings Savings 1 Savings 2 Savings 3 … Savings X … Maint. X -Maintenance Maint. 1 Maint. 2 Maint. 3 … … Watt’$ the Rate %f Return? Inverter +Fed Tax Credit Fed ITC +State Tax Credit State ITC -Fed Cost of Fed Cost State Tax Credit State ITC +Fed Depr. Fed Depr Fed Depr Fed Depr … +State Depr. State Depr State Depr State Depr … - Fed Cost of Fed Cost of Fed Cost of … State Depr State Depr State Depr =Net Net 0 Net 1 Net 2 Net 3 … Net X … !  IRR is function of Net0 : Net25 line !  Inverter replacement: $700/kW in yr 12-20 !  PBI, Savings, Maintenance adjust for inflation and/or module degradation© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 59 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 60
  14. 14. Commercial Total Lifecycle Payback kWh PV System Final Net Cost w/ Cumulative Savings Lifecycle Years Pre-Solar Utility Usage per Size & Tax Benefits & Over First 25 Years Payback To Bill Month Rating Rebate (including inflation) Ratio Payback PG&E $346 2000 10 kW CEC $23K $68K 2.9x 11 PG&E $853 5000 25 kW CEC $56K $172K 3.1x 10.6 PG&E $1,696 10000 50 kW CEC $107K $344K 3.2x 10.3 SCE $333 2000 10 kW CEC $20K $27K 1.3x 21.1 SCE $695 5000 25 kW CEC $48K $75K 1.5x 19.1 SCE $1,297 10000 50 kW CEC $92K $156K 1.7x 18.2 SDG&E $371 2000 10 kW CEC $20K $55K 2.7x 11.6 SDG&E $840 5000 25 kW CEC $48K $137K 2.8x 11.2 SDG&E $1,621 10000 50 kW CEC $92K $274K 3.0x 10.9 NJ - JCPL $692 10000 50 kW STC $91K $116K 1.3x 8.1 NC - Progress $800 10000 50 kW STC $47K $88K 1.9x 17.9 CT - UI $2,309 10000 50 kW PTC $133K $310K 2.3x 13.1 AZ - APS $906 10000 50 kW STC $60K $127K 2.1x 16.4 HI - HECO $2,144 10000 50 kW STC $47K $368K 7.9x 5.1 CO - Xcel $805 10000 50 kW STC $109K $57K 0.5x 40.2© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 56 Gov’t/Non-Profit Total Lifecycle Payback PV System Final Net Cost w/ Cumulative Savings Lifecycle Pre-Solar kWh Usage Utility Size & Tax Benefits & Over First 25 Years Payback Bill per Month Rating Rebate (including inflation) Ratio PG&E $346 2000 10 kW CEC $68K $122K 1.8x PG&E $853 5000 25 kW CEC $162K $306K 1.9x PG&E $1,696 10000 50 kW CEC $311K $613K 2.0x SCE $333 2000 10 kW CEC $63K $48K 0.8x SCE $695 5000 25 kW CEC $150K $134K 0.9x SCE $1,297 10000 50 kW CEC $285K $278K 1.0x SDG&E $371 2000 10 kW CEC $63K $97K 1.6x SDG&E $840 5000 25 kW CEC $150K $244K 1.6x SDG&E $1,621 10000 50 kW CEC $285K $488K 1.7x NJ - JCPL $692 10000 50 kW STC $301K $318K 1.1x NC - Progress $800 10000 50 kW STC $351K $150K 0.4x CT - UI $2,309 10000 50 kW PTC $336K $539K 1.6x AZ - APS $906 10000 50 kW STC $276K $218K 0.8x HI - HECO $2,144 10000 50 kW STC $351K $628K 1.8x CO - Xcel $805 10000 50 kW STC $351K $95K 0.3x© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 57
  15. 15. Commercial Analysis Commercially Attractive? !  Ideal commercial customers can see after- !  IRR must exceed a hurdle rate tax IRRs in the 3% to 8% range "  > “Risk Free Rate” + ~1-2% = Risk Free Rate + Sum of Risks (more later) "  Comparable to other business investments #  Source: Photon International, Aug 2007, p114 "  Plus has green marketing and morale !  Current “Risk Free” interest rates: benefits "  LIBOR = 1.25% As of October 2009 "  10yr = 3.5%, 30yr = 4.4% As of 10/29/2009 "  Depends heavily on system cost !  ! Commercially Attractive >= 6-7%? !  Must properly factor all benefits and costs !  PPA & Lease investors were getting 6-8% "  More on this later, due to recent financial market© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 61 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 62 Complete Commercial Analysis Commercial Rates of Return PV System After-Tax Pre-Solar kWh Usage System Gross Final Net Cost w/ Tax Utility Size & Annual Bill per Month Cost Benefits & Rebate !  Proper commercial analysis is after-tax PG&E $346 2000 Rating 10 kW CEC $85K $23K Return 7.4% !  A. Extra incentives: PG&E $853 5000 25 kW CEC $206K $56K 7.8% PG&E $1,696 10000 50 kW CEC $399K $107K 8.2% "  Federal Tax Credit & Depreciation SCE $333 2000 10 kW CEC $85K $20K 1.8% !  B. Loss of electric expense tax deduction SCE SCE $695 $1,297 5000 10000 25 kW CEC 50 kW CEC $206K $399K $48K $92K 2.8% 3.4% !  A & B approximately offset each other SDG&E $371 2000 10 kW CEC $85K $20K 6.6% SDG&E $840 5000 25 kW CEC $206K $48K 7.0% "  Net results are comparable to residential, but SDG&E $1,621 10000 50 kW CEC $399K $92K 7.4% are “after tax” values, so sometimes appear NJ - JCPL $692 10000 50 kW STC $350K $91K 6.9% NC - Progress $800 10000 50 kW STC $350K $47K 3.5% smaller. CT - UI $2,309 10000 50 kW PTC $375K $133K 5.9% AZ - APS $906 10000 50 kW STC $350K $60K 4.6% HI - HECO $2,144 10000 50 kW STC $350K $47K 14.4% Questions? CO - Xcel $805 10000 50 kW STC $350K $109K -3.7%© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 63 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 64 Gov’t/Non-Profit Analysis Gov’t/Non-Profit Rates of Return PV System Pre-Tax Pre-Solar kWh Usage System Gross Final Net Cost w/ Tax Utility Size & Annual Bill per Month Cost Benefits & Rebate !  Ideal government & non-profit customers PG&E $346 2000 Rating 10 kW CEC $85K $68K Return 4.2% can see non-tax IRRs in 1% to 5% PG&E $853 5000 25 kW CEC $206K $162K 4.6% PG&E $1,696 10000 50 kW CEC $399K $311K 5.0% "  Comparable to funding costs (muni bonds) SCE $333 2000 10 kW CEC $85K $63K -1.7% SCE $695 5000 25 kW CEC $206K $150K -0.7% "  Long term thinking, modest returns OK SCE $1,297 10000 50 kW CEC $399K $285K -0.2% SDG&E $371 2000 10 kW CEC $85K $63K 3.1% "  Has green societal and moral benefits SDG&E $840 5000 25 kW CEC $206K $150K 3.5% SDG&E $1,621 10000 50 kW CEC $399K $285K 3.8% !  Simpler analysis of benefits and costs NJ - JCPL $692 10000 50 kW STC $350K $301K 0.5% NC - Progress $800 10000 50 kW STC $350K $351K #NUM! CT - UI $2,309 10000 50 kW PTC $375K $336K 3.3% AZ - APS $906 10000 50 kW STC $350K $276K -1.5% HI - HECO $2,144 10000 50 kW STC $350K $351K 4.2% CO - Xcel $805 10000 50 kW STC $350K $351K #NUM!© 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 65 © 2009 OnGrid Solar, All rights reserved. Commercial Solar Economics & Financing - 66

×