Integration of Family PlanningServices into an STD Clinic Setting National Chlamydia Coalition Meeting          February 2...
Presenter Disclosures• Presenter: Judith C. Shlay, MD• No relationships to disclose
Why Integrate Family Planning             with STD Care• Unintended pregnancy has significant individual  and public healt...
Our Program• Offers FP services at least once a year to  eligible males/females presenting for STD  services• Refers to pr...
Services for Women• STD screening, testing, and treatment• Family Planning:  – Preconception counseling  – Pregnancy testi...
Services for Women• Contraception offered at the DMHC:   –   Oral contraceptives   –   Transdermal patch   –   Vaginal rin...
Services for Men• STD screening, testing, and treatment• Family Planning:  – Involve men in pregnancy planning and prevent...
Objectives• Measure change in enrollment into FP services  after implementation of an integrated STD/family  planning reco...
Methods• Quasi-experimental comparison of enrollment and  patient/provider satisfaction before (2008) and after  (2010) im...
Streamlining Clinic Processes                                  Registration                                     Triage    ...
Electronic Medical Record
Electronic Medical Record
Results of Integration of ServicesPre-Integration of Services     Post-Integration of Services          (2008)            ...
Effectiveness of Contraceptive        Method Provided to Client• Receipt of method at conclusion of the clinic visit  (ass...
Dual Contraceptive Use• Dual use assessed 2010 only:   – Effective dual use included LARC/hormonal     method plus condom ...
Incident Pregnancy                                   2008*                       2010*                                   N...
Incident STDs                              2008                                            2010                           ...
Time and Cost Study• Additional time and cost of integrating FP  services into STD visit: 4.01 minutes and $3.57• Other ad...
Time and Cost Study• Total additional cost:   – $29.25 (with LARC)   – $15.63 (without LARC)
Staff Thoughts about            Integrated Services• All expressed greater job satisfaction providing  integrated care• Al...
Patient Satisfaction with             Integrated Services• Survey before and after integrated FP record in EMR   – 101 pat...
Limitations• Likely an underestimation of pregnancies and  STDs since some patients never return to the clinic• Program co...
Conclusions• STD clinics serve high-risk men and women,  many of whom use these clinics because they  lack access to repro...
Conclusions• Integrated program appears to reduce  pregnancy rates and not increase STD rates• Offering these integrated s...
QuestionsAdditional information:Judith Shlay, MD, MSPH    jshlay@dhha.org      303-602-3714
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Integration of Family Planning Services into an STD Clinic Setting

405 views

Published on

Presented by Judy Shlay, MD, MSPH, Associate Director, Denver Public Health, at the 2013 National Chlamydia Coalition meeting

0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
405
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
5
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
4
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide
  • Supply costs could be reduced if either paid for by the clients or reimbursed through the client’s insurance ($29.25 to $15.63, 47% reduction)
  • Integration of Family Planning Services into an STD Clinic Setting

    1. 1. Integration of Family PlanningServices into an STD Clinic Setting National Chlamydia Coalition Meeting February 21, 2013J. Shlay, D. McEwen, D. Bell, M. Maravi, D. Rinehart, H. Fang, S. Devine, T. Mickiewicz, S. Dreisbach
    2. 2. Presenter Disclosures• Presenter: Judith C. Shlay, MD• No relationships to disclose
    3. 3. Why Integrate Family Planning with STD Care• Unintended pregnancy has significant individual and public health consequences• Similar behaviors lead to both STDs and unintended pregnancy• Patients seeking STD services may not have another source for FP services
    4. 4. Our Program• Offers FP services at least once a year to eligible males/females presenting for STD services• Refers to primary care for ongoing contraceptive/ reproductive care needs• Offers continuity services for teens and high-risk women who require additional support to avoid unintended pregnancy and STD/HIV
    5. 5. Services for Women• STD screening, testing, and treatment• Family Planning: – Preconception counseling – Pregnancy testing – Initial contraception (3-months) and/or emergency contraception
    6. 6. Services for Women• Contraception offered at the DMHC: – Oral contraceptives – Transdermal patch – Vaginal ring – DMPA – IUDs and progestin-only implant – Condoms – Emergency contraception• Referrals for sterilizations
    7. 7. Services for Men• STD screening, testing, and treatment• Family Planning: – Involve men in pregnancy planning and prevention – Provide accurate information on available methods, benefits of spacing children, safe pregnancy/delivery – Preconception counseling – Contraception: offer condoms, female-directed methods discussed• Emergency contraception• Referrals for vasectomies
    8. 8. Objectives• Measure change in enrollment into FP services after implementation of an integrated STD/family planning record with electronic eligibility reminder• Compare client and staff satisfaction before and after implementation• Calculate the additional staff time and clinic costs required to offer FP services to STD clients• Explore incident pregnancy and STD rates before and after implementation
    9. 9. Methods• Quasi-experimental comparison of enrollment and patient/provider satisfaction before (2008) and after (2010) implementation• Incident pregnancy and STD 12-months after initial visit before and after were explored• Time and cost were calculated to perform integrated FP/STD services• Quantitative and qualitative analyses were performed
    10. 10. Streamlining Clinic Processes Registration Triage  Identify symptoms  Interest in FP ServicesNew Pt Visit STD Follow-up Express Visit FP Visit Only Sexual history  STD follow-up  Sexual history  FP only STD testing  Physical exam prn  STD screening  NP, RN Physical exam  FP, if applicable  FP, if applicable FP, if applicable  NP, RN, LPN  LPN, RN, NP NP, RN
    11. 11. Electronic Medical Record
    12. 12. Electronic Medical Record
    13. 13. Results of Integration of ServicesPre-Integration of Services Post-Integration of Services (2008) (2010)• 9,656 clients were eligible • 10,021clients were for FP services eligible for FP services• Males 5,842 and females • Males 5,852 and females 3,853 (40% female) 4,169 (42% female)• Among those eligible: • Among those eligible: 51.6% received FP 95.3% received FP services: services: – Males 53.3% – Males 94.7% – Females 49.1% – Females 96.2%
    14. 14. Effectiveness of Contraceptive Method Provided to Client• Receipt of method at conclusion of the clinic visit (assessed for only 2010): – highly effective method: 24.4% to 29.9%, p<0.01 – moderate effective method: 14.8% to 28.6%, p<0.01 – moderate-low effective method: 33.4% to 26.3%, p<0.01 – low effective method: 5.8%% to 2.7%, p<0.01 – abstinence: 6.5% to 7.7%, p=0.01
    15. 15. Dual Contraceptive Use• Dual use assessed 2010 only: – Effective dual use included LARC/hormonal method plus condom – Less effective dual use included any other method plus condom• Effective dual method use: 25.2%• Less effective dual method use: 4.6%• No dual use: 70.2%
    16. 16. Incident Pregnancy 2008* 2010* N (%) N (%)Enrolled 86/1116 (7.7) 199/1519 (13.1)Not-enrolled 80/411 (19.5) 7/27 (25.9)P-value <0.01 0.05 *Denominator reflects number with follow-up information
    17. 17. Incident STDs 2008 2010 N (%) N (%) Enrolled Not-enrolled P-value* Enrolled Non-enrolled P-value*Female: CT 112/657 67/469 (14.3) 0.21 179/1370 (13.1) 3/36 (8.3) 0.61† (17.0) GC 29/657 (4.4) 14/468 (3.0) 0.22 32/1375 (2.3) 1/36 (2.8) 0.57†Male: CT 97/559 (17.4) 64/376 (17.0) 0.89 138/1042 (13.2) 4/36 (11.1) 1.00† GC 33/559 (5.9) 23377 (6.1) 0.90 51/1049 (4.9) 1/36 (2.8) 1.00† * Chi-square p-value † Fisher exact test two sided p-value
    18. 18. Time and Cost Study• Additional time and cost of integrating FP services into STD visit: 4.01 minutes and $3.57• Other additional costs: – Lab: $5.36 – Overhead: $5.66 – Supplies without providing LARC methods: $1.04 – Supplies including providing LARC methods: $14.66
    19. 19. Time and Cost Study• Total additional cost: – $29.25 (with LARC) – $15.63 (without LARC)
    20. 20. Staff Thoughts about Integrated Services• All expressed greater job satisfaction providing integrated care• All believe integrated FP-STD EMR facilitated more seamless care and enrollment of more eligible patients
    21. 21. Patient Satisfaction with Integrated Services• Survey before and after integrated FP record in EMR – 101 patients in 2009 who received integrated services – 168 patients in 2010 who received integrated services• 99.5% and 99% very satisfied/satisfied (p=0.76) before and after integrated EMR• 86.0% and 79.6% reported the services met their family planning needs (p=0.26)
    22. 22. Limitations• Likely an underestimation of pregnancies and STDs since some patients never return to the clinic• Program conducted in a clinical setting; unable to control for all potential confounders• Formal cost-benefit analysis not performed
    23. 23. Conclusions• STD clinics serve high-risk men and women, many of whom use these clinics because they lack access to reproductive health care services• Integration of services is feasible, well accepted by staff/patients and provides two valuable services to at-risk populations in a single visit – Focuses on overlapping health care issues and behavior• An electronic reminder of eligibility in the EHR facilitates enrollment in FP services among STD clinic patients
    24. 24. Conclusions• Integrated program appears to reduce pregnancy rates and not increase STD rates• Offering these integrated services in an STD setting requires minimal additional time and cost – With first dollar coverage for contraceptive services (Affordable Care Act) and STD clinics developing processes to bill for services, the ability to cover these additional costs should be realized
    25. 25. QuestionsAdditional information:Judith Shlay, MD, MSPH jshlay@dhha.org 303-602-3714

    ×