Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

9.13.11 CHSOCM Tweetchat Transcript

835 views

Published on

Transcript from 9/13/11 church social media chat on Twitter. Focus on social policies.

Published in: Business, Technology
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

9.13.11 CHSOCM Tweetchat Transcript

  1. 1. Tuesday, September 13, 2011Note Data and transcript from HashTracking.com. #CHSOCM HashTracking.com Report466 tweets generated 1,774,965 impressions, reaching an audience of 83,629 followers within the past24 hours| Generated Tue Sep 13 2011 22:16:13 GMT-0400 (Eastern Daylight Time)Top 10 by number of impressions Top 10 by number of tweets 1. paulsteinbrueck: 1,156,703 1. meredithgould: 55 2. drothamel: 220,266 2. asacredrebel: 42 3. meredithgould: 208,670 3. chsocm: 37 4. denise205: 28,056 4. sm4faith: 34 5. youravgpastor: 25,494 5. paulsteinbrueck: 31 6. rampracer: 24,717 6. mgoins: 31 7. mgoins: 15,252 7. drothamel: 27 8. chsocm: 12,210 8. denise205: 24 9. tsudo: 10,851 9. klamach: 18 10. rev_david: 7,290 10. revweb: 16 1
  2. 2. Chsocm:Good evening everyone & welcome to our weekly church & social media (#chsocm) chat, especially thosejoining for the first time.If youre new, try using the Tweetchat platform, which automagically adds the hashtag.asacredrebel:Welcome!Chsocm:If this is your first tweetchat ever, please do not get discouraged by the pace!A transcript will be available in 2 forms by tomorrow morning here: http://bit.ly/pTDoAbRevWeb:@bfelice Glad youre here. Hope you find it helpful, fun and a community builder for you.Chsocm:We’ll get started in a minute with self-introductions, but as ever, we start with prayer. Or maybe well justuse @edkay77s "Yay!"rampracer:RT @ A transcript will be available in 2 forms by tomorrow morning here: http://bit.ly/pTDoAbChsocm:Let us pray:Almighty & merciful God, we rejoice in your abiding presence everywhere & your mercy at all times.We give thanks for this & every opportunity to share experience & inquiry anchored in faith.edkay77:Amen!bfelice:@revweb @mgoins @sm4faith ty tyChsocm:We ask your Holy Spirit to inspire tonight’s conversation & guide us as we move forward in love & service.Amen.RevWeb:Amen!drothamel:Amen. 2
  3. 3. Chsocm:Next up: self-introductions. In addition to your church affiliation, please let everyone how you currently usesocial mediayouravgpastor:Amen!theologybird:Hello! Episcopalian, Twitter, FB, some other dabbling...cephasmedia:Laura Toepfer, Episcopal priest and social media consultant.klamach:amen! Chris Lawrence, St Peters Salem, blogger/tweeter/fb-ERChsocm:moderating this chat @meredithgould, sociologist, author, keen on using social media to build community,also active in #hcsmRevWeb:#Episcopal priest in Baltimore using SM for #evangelism, networking, community building & weddingplans. #3xCharmChsocm:We will assume tweets during this chat yours & do not represent your church or organizationmgoins:Meredith Goins, librarian, volunteer at New Providence Presbyterian in Maryville, TNbfelice:episcopalian. wearer of many hats including communications cap.klamach:and Episcopalian (Anglo-catholic)Chsocm:Kindly remember that we’re here to share with & support one another. Please use DM or email to pitchproducts/servicesmgoins:Use sm for collection development (ie books to buy, links to use!) and to share news and updates.mgoins:@meredithgould Right back attcha Mere!mnplatypus:Im Angela, communication secretary in a large ELCA congregation in west metro Minneapolis, Minnesota 3
  4. 4. Denise205:I work in Catholic publishing on Web content. Live near Chicago.rev_david:David. #ELCA pastor breathing smoke in Texas. Lurking while in a meeting in the synod office.klamach:Perfect! RT @ We will assume tweets during this chat yours & do not represent your church ororganizationmgoins:@rev_david Glad you can join us!@meredithgould:@rev_david Read your blog post about the heat in TX & the pic of the ground was parching #ELCAdrothamel:@rev_david Good use of meeting time. ;-)Chsocm:Great to see regulars and some new folks!paulsteinbrueck:@drothamel @rev_david LOL!Chsocm:Tonight we’re chatting about social media policies. Some issues & examples available on our blog:http://tinyurl.com/3v5u2r9youravgpastor:Why wouldnt the ELCA want to have their views represented by Joe Smith???mgoins:Oops, child up. Back in a few.asacredrebel:Jerry ELCA pastor just getting out of Bible study...Denise205:I didnt do my pre-reading, but will jump in as makes sense. I hope you do too!Denise205:@asacredrebel Welcome!Chsocm:T1 Whats your current experience with developing & establishing a social media policy for yourchurch/faith-based organization?rev_david:@youravgpastor I have a hard enough time just speaking for myself :-) 4
  5. 5. @meredithgould:RT T1 Whats your current experience with developing & establishing a social media policy for yrchurch/faith-based organization?Denise205:@sm4faith Well, it was available for those who wanted to read it ahead of time. Beauty is its referenced forlater reading too!@meredithgould:@sm4faith Not to worry, you dont need to have read up on this in advance!sm4faith:t1 varied - policy at one church - find good people and trust their judgementdrothamel:T1: As of right now, my church doesnt have an official SM policy. Im using the @mnplatypus strategy fornow.edkay77:T1 I havent had experience doing one, but would be looking to develop something as a model for otherchurchesasacredrebel:T1 - it is like beating my head against a brick wall as social media is not neededklamach:@csalafia you should follow the chat and contribute!youravgpastor:I have nothing as of yet. #shame #guilt@meredithgould:@sm4faith Yipes! Every post? Who reviewed and approved? How long did THAT take??theologybird:MT @edkay77: T1 I havent had experience doing one, but would be looking to develop something //me toopaulsteinbrueck:T1: I dont believe a social media policy is needed 4 my church or company. :)sm4faith:@youravgpastor No shame - its another way of talking - you have a talking policy?mgoins:T1: No policy yet - introducing church admin to sm on Friday (yikes!)theologybird:RT @asacredrebel: T1 - it is like beating my head against a brick wall as social media is not needed //andor evil 5
  6. 6. asacredrebel:@meredithgould @sm4faith Sounds like a full time position....drothamel:T1 also begs the question, "do you have a evangelism policy or a marketing policy, or stewardshippolicy?"sm4faith:@meredithgould @sm4faith The every post situation is new - will loosen as they grow accustomed@meredithgould:@sm4faith Or exhausted!@meredithgould:RT @drothamel: T1 also begs the question, "do you have a evangelism policy or a marketing policy, orstewardship policy?"paulsteinbrueck:RT @ T1 Whats ur current experience with developing & establishing a social media policy for yourchurch/faith-based org?drothamel:T1: Having a "policy" is FAR less important than having a plan/strategy.paulsteinbrueck:RT @drothamel: T1 also begs the question, "do you have a evangelism policy or a marketing policy, orstewardship policy?"sm4faith:MT @drothamel: T1: Having a "policy" is FAR less important than having a plan/strategy.youravgpastor:RT @drothamel: T1: Having a "policy" is FAR less important than having a plan/strategy.Chsocm:T1a: What’s your greatest concern about such policies?mgoins:@drothamel Policy leads to plan?sm4faith:@mgoins Say more, because I dont see where youre coming from yet.drothamel:@mgoins I think those things are more appropriately classified as plan/strategy, rather than policy.rev_david:T1ish - A SocMed strategy should be less about "policing" and more about empowering 6
  7. 7. Denise205:@mgoins Good luck!paulsteinbrueck:RT @rev_david: T1ish - A SocMed strategy should be less about "policing" and more about empowering //Yes!sm4faith:t1a depends on what kind of church organisation and purpose of using SMmgoins:@paulsteinbrueck Policy allows committees to implement plan. Policy is first step!asacredrebel:T1ish - A SocMed strategy should be less about "policing" and more about empowering @rev_david//AMENmgoins:@Denise205 Thank you. You have all made this possible, while allowing me to grow too!mirgray:@sm4faith We dont have a speaking policy but some training in healthy evangelism isnt a bad thing.drothamel:RT @rev_david: T1ish - A SocMed strategy should be less about "policing" and more about empoweringrampracer:RT @rev_david: T1ish - A SocMed strategy should be less about "policing" and more about empoweringyouravgpastor:RT @drothamel: RT @rev_david: T1ish - A SocMed strategy should be less about "policing" and more aboutempoweringDenise205:@mgoins Be sure to let us know how Friday goes!mgoins:@paulsteinbrueck Actually, both.asacredrebel:T1 - Policy could get in the way of ministry that needs to be done. Did Jesus have a policy for the way thedisciples acted?sm4faith:if use of sm represents key officials in the church, policy more important - a different role 7
  8. 8. bfelice:In MO, interesting back and forth over SM (facebook) policy for teachers between legislature and courts.http://is.gd/pVEHulmnplatypus:I guess what I mean is not worry that someone will come in and spam everyone (on church acct) and undomy hard workmirgray:Does "guidelines" work better than "policy"?T @ Generally speaking, "policies" are used to restrict, ratherthan enable...edwardjensen:Looking forward to following the feed tonight. Good questions and exchange being had.sm4faith:Also where you have a team of say 11 people using one sm handle, guidelines can give confidence thatyoure doing it rightdrothamel:@asacredrebel I think Jesus policies were pretty good: Love God. Love your neighbor. Those work for SM,too. :-)asacredrebel:@sm4faith would not this be handled differently by the people. I do not tweet everything I want to becauseof the role I fillmgoins:@sm4faith Agree completely. Helps define tone.sm4faith:working with public policy in schools, there are thou shalt and thou shalt not policies 1/2asacredrebel:@drothamel AMEN that is true, but were those policies or a way of life?rev_david:The risk we run is micro-managing / over-managing, which is the best way to kill any ministrysm4faith:"shalt not" policies can enable more - if not on list its ok - your call! 2/2@meredithgould:RT @rev_david: The risk we run is micro-managing / over-managing, which is the best way to kill anyministrymirgray:Is it Sojourners that explains their guidelines with biblical text and plain language explanation? 8
  9. 9. mnplatypus:SM is a moving target - subject to change / innovationtheologybird:@rev_david The other edge of the risk is neglect and equally dangerous.drothamel:@asacredrebel those are a way of life, no doubt. But managers need policies to justify existence, so Imwilling to concede those.edkay77:MT @asacredrebel T1 - Policy could get in the way // Could also save an org/ch from a gaffe from ppl whomean well but dont do wellChsocm:T1b Whats your best hope for these policies or guidelines?asacredrebel:@drothamel I can agree with that.sm4faith:a lot of our church social media ventures are about as autonymous as a cell group - do they have policies?tsudo: If a team is given adequate education & vision then policies arent often needed. As @rev_david said trustthe whopaulsteinbrueck:@asacredrebel Theres a huge diff b/w what ppl do thru a churchs official sm profiles & their own personalprofiles.mirgray:Does multiple voices on one account work or better to have main account rt so people know whose talking?asacredrebel:@edkay77 absolutely! It is a double edged sword. One that should be handled delicately, but not playedwith!RevWeb:T1b That guidelines will help protect & model good SM use for young people.edkay77:RT @sm4faith where you have a team of say 11 people using one sm handle, guidelines can give confidencethat youre doing it rightsm4faith:@mirgray Depends on ministry concerned.asacredrebel:T1b - that they do not hinder, but empower. They do not get in the way, but support 9
  10. 10. @meredithgould:@mirgray If its an orgs account, the voice should be unified even if one person is repping the orgpaulsteinbrueck:T1b: my best hope for sm policies is that they go away. :Pklamach:RT @meredithgould: @mirgray If its an orgs account, the voice should be unified even if one person isrepping the org@meredithgould:RT @paulsteinbrueck: T1b: my best hope for sm policies is that they go away. :P LOLOLdrothamel:RT @asacredrebel: T1b - that they do not hinder, but empower. They do not get in the way, but support.rampracer:RT @ T1b Whats your best hope for these policies or guidelines?sm4faith:RT @paulsteinbrueck: T1b: my best hope for sm policies is that they go away. :P < LOL! Love it :)tsudo:T1b To create mindfulness & process that doesnt rely on a single persontheologybird:RT @tsudo: T1b To create mindfulness & process that doesnt rely on a single person@meredithgould:I advocate a social anarchist theory of orgs: keep structure when it works, ditch it when it stops working.Policies, too.asacredrebel:RT @tsudo: T1b To create mindfulness & process that doesnt rely on a single person //relying on oneperson could be a problemsm4faith:I dont actually like unified voices, I like a generous variety of viewpoints. Too much unity suggests cult.asacredrebel:@meredithgould Absolutely. That is the way to go and be and do!mirgray:T1b To show diversity & help seekers feel they could belong. To avoid burnout by empowering. To showwe love w/o being clones.RevWeb:RT @sm4faith: I dont actually like unified voices, I like a generous variety of viewpoints. Too much unitysuggests cult. 10
  11. 11. youravgpastor:At this point Im in such a redevelopment process that policies seem counterproductive.asacredrebel:@Denise205 which may not seem to be unified voices, in a blog setting.paulsteinbrueck:Just to clarify, an official sm strategy is hugely important. A policy for personal sm use not so much.sm4faith:MT @mirgray: T1b To show diversity & help seekers feel they could belong. ... To show we love w/o beingclones. < agreemgoins:Policies can be required by churchs polity. Such is life. Not a bad thing, just a part of the process.mirgray:+ 1 RT @Denise205 Good point: remember that social media includes blogs as well as FB, Twitter,YouTubeChsocm:Does the social media platform matter relative to "unified voices"?Denise205:@asacredrebel and I find no problem with thatrampracer:RT @ Does the social media platform matter relative to "unified voices"?ZemaIsAGal:RT @DMAUB: "@drothamel: about to hop on the chat while listening to that new @DMAUB album.#winning"youravgpastor:Hey quick aside folks, anyone satisfied w/ a twitter app on iPad that works well w/ these chats???drothamel:When I think "unified voice" I think more in terms of style than content.RchrdBott:Pastoral call... missed the first half. Hi, all!asacredrebel:@RchrdBott welcome!Denise205:@RchrdBott Hello!@meredithgould:For organizational/diocesan Twitter accts I like to see initials used to indicate who is tweeting. 11
  12. 12. asacredrebel:yes. No. Maybe!smshepherds:Each SM platform requires its own nuance. Its clunky to cotag on FB. Easy to cite different authors onblogs.Denise205:RT @paulsteinbrueck: Yes, unity in purpose is important. Unity in personality is not..klamach:No. I reject diversity for every context. I reject diversity of opinion if it runs against a churchs missionstatement.mgoins:@meredithgould Agreed! This is common across the mktg spectrum.rev_david:Spirit works best among people empowered & trusted to use their gifts.bfelice:@meredithgould really depends on the message...some msgs from judicatories are from the org not thepersondrothamel:@meredithgould Ive used organizational accts. where we did that. such as," /dr or ^dr."rampracer:@youravgpastor really like Hootsuite appsm4faith:RT @rev_david: Spirit works best among people empowered & trusted to use their gifts.scottagunn:@meredithgould Why do you like initials? Shouldnt "corp" voice prevail over individual?paulsteinbrueck:@asacredrebel Im not sure I follow. Can you clarify?@meredithgould:@scottagunn Depends on how acct is being used. Initials could show an active, vibrant staff.RchrdBott:@meredithgould I agree. Initials help us understand that our voice is made up of many voices - and realpeople.smshepherds: 12
  13. 13. Great point re: SM in ministry. RT @paulsteinbrueck: Yes, unity in purpose is important. Unity inpersonality is not..RockingReverend:RT @rev_david: Spirit works best among people empowered & trusted to use their gifts.asacredrebel:@paulsteinbrueck if a group of bloggers write about the same topic but disagree are they not unified by theblog they share?drothamel:@meredithgould initials also enable us to appropriately assign the spelling/grammatical errors. :-DRevWeb:@scottagunn @meredithgould I notice AP and NYT use initials when posting on corp acct. Different thothan diocese w/a msg.mgoins:@RchrdBott @meredithgould Having edu staff, youth staff, pastoral care staff all on same feed can beawesome!@meredithgould:@drothamel Indeed! Grammar Police: To Serve and Correct!!mirgray:Like bible studies I prefer to hear many viewpoints if tone remains respectful. So only some topics / issuesneed policy.smshepherds:If pastoral staff and chuch communicators are allowed to disagree IRL, why not online?@meredithgould:@smshepherds They/we are allowed to disagree IRL?asacredrebel:@klamach how would you deal with someone saying that?Chsocm:T2 How might the church & faith-based organizations benefit from establishing social media policies?mgoins:@drothamel @meredithgould The way Im typing tonight, I need your red pen!Denise205:@meredithgould @drothamel Do the grammar police really approve puns?scottagunn:@RevWeb @meredithgould Ok. Tricky to get indiv/corp balance rightpaulsteinbrueck: 13
  14. 14. RT @ T2 How might the church & faith-based organizations benefit from establishing social media policies?mgoins:@meredithgould Measurement, purpose/mission, audience.@meredithgould:@scottagunn Very tricky, which is why it might have to be different for different platformssm4faith:we give people ministry roles because we trust them and sometimes they stuff up - in real life and online -no differencedrothamel:@Denise205 @meredithgould puns are like donuts for the grammar police!RevWeb:T2 Guidelines give multiple posters framework. No flying blind. Helps those reading/ing comments.asacredrebel:T2 Clarity of MissionDenise205:@drothamel @meredithgould Ill have to keep that one in mind! :)paulsteinbrueck:If by smn policy, were talking a/b official sm strategy, it provides unity, clarity of purpose.drothamel:T2: Guidelines can provide organization/structure for orgs. who have many voices to manage.sm4faith:t2 may help people new to the medium to get a feel for how they could best contributeasacredrebel:T2 are these policies things that are written? or is it an understanding with a gate keeper?smshepherds:If a church wouldnt neglect a policy on doctrine or background checks for nursery workers, they shouldntneglect a social policy.theologybird:RT @sm4faith: t2 may help people new to the medium to get a feel for how they could best contributeRevWeb:T2 Just a thought. Do policies stifle the Spirit?klamach:@asacredrebel :-) I am learning!mnplatypus: 14
  15. 15. Must get home, will catch up via transcript in the AMmgoins:T2: Who, what, when, where, why and how you engage (WWWWH)asacredrebel:@smshepherds were suppose to do background checks on nursery workers!!! ;)skenow:Just joining the chat - thanks for saving me a seat, !@meredithgould:@skenow And its in the front pew...youre the only one sitting there!mgoins:@RevWeb Only if theyre so detailed that there is no room for discussion or revision.@meredithgould:its...I meant its not itspaulsteinbrueck:@skenow Welcome Steve!skenow:@meredithgould Yes! The front is the best!@meredithgould:@EmilySO Welcome!Denise205:@RevWeb The Spirit can work through anything...policies or notmgoins:@meredithgould @skenow Im a 3rd pew from front kinda gal (keeps me out of trouble) You an sit with me;-)Chsocm:Topic 3...lets squeeze another in during our final 10 minutes...asacredrebel:@RevWeb the Spirit works in spite of us and will work in spite of a policy...Chsocm:T3 Rather than re-invent the wheel, any industries/sectors from which churches might adopt/adapt socialmedia guidelines?@meredithgould: 15
  16. 16. @Denise205 LOLmirgray:Bad policies, probably yes. RT @ T2 Just a thought. Do policies stifle the Spirit?@meredithgould:Big shock: I was always a back row wiseacre type.skenow:RT @ Rather than re-invent the wheel, any industries/sectors from which churches might adopt/adaptsocial media guidelines?mgoins:T3: non-profit sm has some great stuff out there. And believe it or not, fundraisers have some amazing smpolicies as well.@meredithgould:RT @ T3 Rather than re-invent the wheel, any industries/sectors from which churches might adopt/adaptguidelines?@meredithgould:@paulsteinbrueck Official policiesasacredrebel:@mgoins do you have any examples you can share?sm4faith:I think sm are very fluid, our understanding of how they can be missional is fluid, and policy must thereforealso be fluidEmilySO:Agreed - Id like to see some too. RT @asacredrebel: @mgoins do you have any examples you can share?bfelice:edu npo SM policies worth a look seeskenow:@EmilySO I would say Best Buy is an anomaly - most corporates policies fall into the "Thou shalt not"categorymgoins:@asacredrebel You just read my mind: http://bit.ly/benJoeasacredrebel:@sm4faith like the waters of baptism?!EmilySO:@skenow Very true. I was very fortunate to spend some time on the BBY team - so I am "spoiled"mirgray: 16
  17. 17. +1 RT @ T3: non-profit sm has some great stuff out there. And believe it or not, fundraisers have someamazing sm policies as well.sm4faith:If a church adopts a business sm policy, how can that work? Our goals are very different@meredithgould:@sm4faith Not if the organization/biz is mission-based (e.g., hospital)bfelice:maybe of interest: secular http://bit.ly/paee8P church/judicatory: http://bit.ly/rhiMoNsm4faith:@meredithgould depends on the hospital!@meredithgould:@sm4faith True!paulsteinbrueck:I would think wed want to look to orgs that have a lot of volunteers & engage them in social media.@meredithgould:RT @paulsteinbrueck: I would think wed want to look to orgs that have a lot of volunteers & engage themin social media.asacredrebel:@sm4faith also depends on the congregation! Some of them are run like a businessmirgray:I would disagree. Good ones focus "shalls". MT @skenow @EmilySO Most corporates policies fall into the"Thou shalt not" categorynaaho:sorry I had to miss this week. Looking forward to transcript!sm4faith:Ok looking at one someone just shared, policy must not be illegal!skenow:Heres a database of social media policies http://ow.ly/6tGlJmgoins:Another example of sm policies can be seen at: http://socialmediagovernance.com/policies.phpmgoins:@asacredrebel Ah the joy of being a librarian... meeting info needs!mattkinsi:Im the social media coordinator for @uuca - weve got one too. Ill work on making it public.mgoins: 17
  18. 18. @skenow Excellent link! You and I are on the same wavelength my friend.theologybird:RT @skenow: Heres a database of social media policies http://ow.ly/6tGlJChsocm:T3a Any guideline that might cross (so to speak) all denominations?mirgray:@sm4faith Initial goal is same - engage more people. What happens after is different.bfelice:love all the links!asacredrebel:RT @ T3a Any guideline that might cross (so to speak) all denominations?skenow:@mgoins ;-)paulsteinbrueck:T3: Always be thinking... what would Jesus tweet?Chsocm:Yet another great chat. Would you believe were coming up on the hour in a few minutes?sm4faith:One of the links suggested a personal and a church facebook account - that is against FBs Terms.csalafia:RT @paulsteinbrueck: T3: Always be thinking... what would Jesus tweet?paulsteinbrueck:@meredithgould Yes and "Get thee behind me Satan!"mattkinsi:T3 - Dont tweet/etc. anything you wouldnt want a first time visitor to see/hear when they walk throughthe door.drothamel:T3: Love God. Love your neighbor. Do those, and youll be just fine.asacredrebel:@paulsteinbrueck and I always thought that was What Would Judas Tweet...Denise205: 18
  19. 19. RT @drothamel: T3: Love God. Love your neighbor. Do those, and youll be just fine.RevWeb:Amen to that! RT @drothamel: T3: Love God. Love your neighbor. Do those, and youll be just fine.mgoins:@meredithgould WWGT - Im totally using that...Chsocm:Love God. Love your neighbor...and with that, well conclude with this prayer from Complineskenow:@mirgray @EmilySO That is true, my point is most corporate social media policies are not goodDenise205:Thanks for moderating another fast-moving chat!Chscom:Keep watch, dear Lord, with those who work or watch or weep this night & give your angels charge overthose who sleep. 19

×