SlideShare a Scribd company logo
CL+B FEST 2019
16 March 2019
Dr. Niels Vandezande
VIRTUAL CURRENCIES, A VIABLE
TRANSFER OF VALUE?
CRYPTOCURRENCIES
2
• 2008: Bitcoin white paper Satoshi Nakamoto
• First blockchain use case
• 2009: genesis block
• 2010: First physical transaction
• 2 pizza’s @ BTC 10.000
• 2011: parity with USD
• 2013: first hype -> BTC 1 > USD 1.000
• 2014-2016: relative stability around USD 500
• 2017: second hype -> BTC 1 = USD 20.000
• 2018-2019: going down (BTC 1 around USD 4.000)
3
BITCOIN
4
BITCOIN AND CRYPTOCURRENCIES
• Other cryptocurrencies:
• Often imitations of bitcoin, but could also serve other purposes: Ethereum
• -> issue of network economics
• Bitcoin forks: seceding from the bitcoin blockchain
• Bitcoin Cash
• Bitcoin Gold
• Bitcoin Private
• Scalability issues
• Bitcoin can only process limited amount of transactions (4/s versus 25k/s Visa)
• consequence: confirmation delays and high transaction costs
PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE
5
• No payment apps
• App Store only launched in 2008
• Slow processing time
• Often several working days
• High transaction fees
• Due to many parties involved in a typical transaction
• Network costs
• Particularly expensive before wider adoption of broadband
• Financial crisis
• Trust in financial system undermined
6
PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: SITUATION AT 2008
7
PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: ACTORS
8
PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: ACTORS
By Dyah N.K. Makhijani (2006) “An Introduction of Payment
Systems”, https://www.bi.go.id/en/sistem-
pembayaran/edukasi/Documents/1fe856cd22d04b9abfd4
4ab050545fefAnIntroductiononPaymentSystem.pdf.
9
PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: ACTORS
10
PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: COSTS
Accourt (2016) “Bank charges on international payments An analysis of the UK SME market”, report for MoneyMovers.
• Swift payments
• Cheap payments
• No reliance on intermediaries
• Anonymity
• Good for underbanked
• No seizure or theft
• No taxes
• No chargebacks
11
PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: PROMISES OF BITCOIN
• Swift payments
• Bottleneck due to scaling problem
• Cheap payments
• High transaction fees due to scaling problem
• No reliance on intermediaries
• Plethora of intermediaries mimicking traditional intermediaries
• Anonymity
• Not that hard to identify person behind the transaction
12
PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: PROMISES OF BITCOIN
• Good for underbanked
• No reliance on banks, but also alternatives
• No seizure or theft
• Keys can be seized or stolen
• No taxes
• False, can be subjected to VAT and capital gains tax
• No chargebacks
• But non-revocation can also be a bad thing
13
PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: PROMISES OF BITCOIN
• Benefits: who mines a block receives
new units of bitcoin (12,5 anno 2018)
• Costs:
• Equipment: specialized ASIC-miners
required
• Electricity: every transaction uses about
as much electricity as a median
household per month
• Data: bitcoin blockchain > 170GB
14
BITCOIN: COSTS AND BENEFITS
By Marco Krohn (Own work) [CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0)], via
Wikimedia Commons
15
BITCOIN: TRANSACTION COSTS
16
BITCOIN: INTERMEDIARIES
UNDERBANKED
17
M-Pesa
• Mobile phone money transfer
• Available in Kenya, Tanzania, Afghanistan, South Africa, India,
Romania (and Albania)
• Allows users to deposit, withdraw, transfer money and pay for goods
and services
• Using account on mobile phone, operated by telecom provider
18
ALTERNATIVES FOR UNDERBANKED
19
ALTERNATIVES FOR UNDERBANKED
20
ALTERNATIVES FOR UNDERBANKED
MONEY: THEORIES AND ORIGINS
21
• Assets used to conclude payments?
• But: there is also money that doesn’t serve as means of payment
• And means of payment that aren’t money
• UCC: a medium of exchange currently authorized or adopted by a
domestic or foreign government
• In part refers to legal tender
• Black’s Law Dictionary: generally accepted medium of exchange – often
with the status of legal tender – that represents purchasing power, or
assets that can be easily converted into cash
• First part: legal tender
• Second part: but also not legal tender (see M1 and M2)
MONEY: DEFINITION
22
• State theory: State determines means of payment, unit of account and
denominations -> Not just legal tender, but what is accepted by State
• Societal theory: what has confidence of the people
and is used in commerce
• Functions: medium of exchange, unit of account,
store of value
23
MONEY: ECONOMIC THEORIES
• Popular opinion: bartering theory
• Money was created to solve the issues of bartering
• However:
• no perfect bartering society ever existed
• Money as unit of account came before physical circulation
• First money: money as credit
• Oldest law codes noted debts in weights of silver (even before 2000 B.C.)
• However, that silver did not circulate, it only serves as common unit of account to settle debts
• See also Yap stones: stone served as money, but did not have to circulate
• => centralized or even decentralized ledgers!
• Next step: money as physical unit
• First coins found in Lydia (700 B.C.)
24
MONEY: ORIGINS
By Bartek.cieslak (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0
(https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)], via Wikimedia
Commons
E-MONEY AND PAYMENT SERVICES
25
E-MONEY: SECOND DIRECTIVE (2009/110/EC)
• E-money
• Definition refined (see next slide)
• E-money institutions
• Lighter regime (no longer credit institutions, but still no deposit-taking)
• Operational requirements: EUR 350k initial capital, own funds rules
• Prudential rules: see PSD
• Broader activities (limited credit-granting relating to payment services)
• Safeguarding requirements
• Waivers and redeemability maintained
• Review: should have coincided with review PSD
26
E-MONEY: SCOPE
• Electronically, including magnetically, stored value
• Technology neutral
• Funds must be available to bearer
• Represented by a claim on the issuer
• Question of ownership
• Reimbursement -> redeemability
• Issued on receipt of funds
• Protection against over-issuing (though EMD1 failed here)
• Creation of new units must correspond to funds received hereto (prepaid)
• Accepted by institutions other than their issuer
• Distinction from single- or limited-purpose instruments
• See limited network scope exemption
27
PAYMENT SERVICES: SECOND DIRECTIVE
(2015/2366)
• Scope: addition of third parties, tightening of scope exemptions
• Authorization and operational requirements largely the same
• Tighter rules regarding execution of transactions (e.g. focus on strong user
authentication, limitation of payer’s liability for unauthorized transactions to EUR 50)
• Quid EMD2?
• Applicable since January 2018
28
PAYMENT SERVICES: SCOPE
• Provision of payment services as main business
• Funds: could include VC, though not universally accepted
• Focus on payment accounts
• Services:
• Cash withdrawal and placement
• Transactions funded by payment account or credit line
• Issuing payment instruments
• Money remittance (cash-based, without account)
• Payment initiation and account information services
29
PAYMENT SERVICES: SCOPE EXEMPTIONS
• Cash transactions, document-based transactions, cash transport, etc.
• Technical service providers
• Added value exemption
• Those not acting as mere intermediary are exempted
• PSD2: more clearly limited to electronic communications services and for limited value
• Limited networks exemption
• Services within limited network or limited range of goods/services exempted
• PSD2: limited network around issuer, limited range of goods/services, services limited to one MS
for social or tax purposes
• Money exchange exemption
• Only covers cash-to-cash operations
30
VIRTUAL CURRENCIES: E-MONEY?
• Closed scheme virtual currencies
• No exchange between VC and legal tender -> no e-money
• Unidirectional scheme virtual currencies
• Could theoretically fulfill all criteria
• However: differentiation needed in practice
• Bidirectional scheme virtual currencies
• Also here: possible in theory, need for differentiation in practice
• E.g. cryptocurrencies: issuing (in the sense of creation) controlled by algorithm, not by receipt of
funds
• E.g. Second Life Linden dollar: can only be used in Second Life
31
VIRTUAL CURRENCIES: PAYMENT SERVICES?
• Closed scheme and unidirectional scheme virtual currencies
• Not included under scope (and would benefit from scope exemption anyway)
• Bidirectional scheme virtual currencies
• Scope exemption could apply to services with limited acceptance
• Differences between MS: FR and LU in favor of inclusion; BE, DE and UK not
• However: also here case-by-case approach needed
• Consequence: if EMD2 and PSD2 cannot be applied -> resort to regular
contract law
32
VIRTUAL CURRENCIES: LICENSED SERVICE
PROVIDERS?
• Several cases in BE, LU and UK of virtual currency service providers being
licensed
• Need to distinguish between what the license is for and what not
• Positive development
• Could help foster trust
• Can be competitive advantage
• Could lead to transitory measures
• Negative development
• Divergence between MS does not facilitate harmonization of this framework -> passporting?
• False perception of trustworthiness of other service providers
• Burden for market entrants
33
CONCLUSIONS
34
CRYPTOCURRENCIES: APPLICABILITY CURRENT
LAW
• Can we apply some of the current frameworks in EU financial law?
• E-money and payment services: principally not applicable
• Can we make these frameworks applicable?
• E-money and payment services: e-money is in need of overhaul, list of payment services can be
extended
• No legal tender: can be accepted at own risk, but not mandatory
• User: bears the risk of loss, theft, value fluctuations, etc.
• Service provider:
• No payment service of e-money: so no license required
• but: could be coupled to offering payment services (e.g. Circle)
• ->need to investigate whether other services offered are bound to license
duty
36
CRYPTOCURRENCIES IN PRACTICE
• What if also a payment service is offered?
• Apply for license at competent regulator
• Prudential requirements
• Capital requirements (between 20k and 120k, depending on service)
• Documentation and accounting
• Processing of personal data (limited and with explicit consent)
• AML rules also applicable!
37
CRYPTOCURRENCIES IN PRACTICE
• Main opportunities?
• Global remittance: migrants send over USD 600 billion home per year
• Blockchain technology: so much more than cryptocurrencies
• Trading and interbanking: could be used in trade finance
• For merchants: first-mover advantage? But also risks!
• But: we need to fix some things
• Today, bitcoin is not a viable means of payment
• Technical, governance and legal issues to be tackled
38
CRYPTOCURRENCIES IN PRACTICE
ANY QUESTIONS?
Dr. Niels Vandezande
Legal Consultant @ Timelex
Research Fellow @ KU Leuven CiTiP
niels.vandezande@timelex.eu
www.timelex.eu
be.linkedin.com/in/nvandezande
twitter.com/nielsvandezande
39

More Related Content

More from Brussels Legal Hackers

20190221 Data subject rights in practice
20190221 Data subject rights in practice20190221 Data subject rights in practice
20190221 Data subject rights in practice
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20180619 Controller-to-Processor agreements
20180619 Controller-to-Processor agreements20180619 Controller-to-Processor agreements
20180619 Controller-to-Processor agreements
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20180607 - Tech Summit presentation
20180607 - Tech Summit presentation20180607 - Tech Summit presentation
20180607 - Tech Summit presentation
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20180317 CLBfest 2018 - Trase
20180317 CLBfest 2018 - Trase20180317 CLBfest 2018 - Trase
20180317 CLBfest 2018 - Trase
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20171108 IAPP Congress - Privacy by Design presentation
20171108 IAPP Congress - Privacy by Design presentation20171108 IAPP Congress - Privacy by Design presentation
20171108 IAPP Congress - Privacy by Design presentation
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20171106 - Privacy Design Lab - LINDDUN
20171106 - Privacy Design Lab - LINDDUN20171106 - Privacy Design Lab - LINDDUN
20171106 - Privacy Design Lab - LINDDUN
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20170601 - Digital festival presentation
20170601 - Digital festival presentation20170601 - Digital festival presentation
20170601 - Digital festival presentation
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20170801 GDPR Q&A intro
20170801 GDPR Q&A intro20170801 GDPR Q&A intro
20170801 GDPR Q&A intro
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (2)
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (2)20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (2)
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (2)
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20170620 MEETUP smart contracts proof of concept for prescriptions
20170620 MEETUP smart contracts proof of concept for prescriptions20170620 MEETUP smart contracts proof of concept for prescriptions
20170620 MEETUP smart contracts proof of concept for prescriptions
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (1)
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (1)20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (1)
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (1)
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20170418 MEETUP on Creative Commons
20170418 MEETUP on Creative Commons20170418 MEETUP on Creative Commons
20170418 MEETUP on Creative Commons
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20170122 MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
20170122 MEETUP on autonomous vehicles20170122 MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
20170122 MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20170122 intro MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
20170122 intro MEETUP on autonomous vehicles20170122 intro MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
20170122 intro MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
Brussels Legal Hackers
 
20161127 KICK-OFF Legal Hacking Brussels
20161127 KICK-OFF Legal Hacking Brussels20161127 KICK-OFF Legal Hacking Brussels
20161127 KICK-OFF Legal Hacking Brussels
Brussels Legal Hackers
 

More from Brussels Legal Hackers (15)

20190221 Data subject rights in practice
20190221 Data subject rights in practice20190221 Data subject rights in practice
20190221 Data subject rights in practice
 
20180619 Controller-to-Processor agreements
20180619 Controller-to-Processor agreements20180619 Controller-to-Processor agreements
20180619 Controller-to-Processor agreements
 
20180607 - Tech Summit presentation
20180607 - Tech Summit presentation20180607 - Tech Summit presentation
20180607 - Tech Summit presentation
 
20180317 CLBfest 2018 - Trase
20180317 CLBfest 2018 - Trase20180317 CLBfest 2018 - Trase
20180317 CLBfest 2018 - Trase
 
20171108 IAPP Congress - Privacy by Design presentation
20171108 IAPP Congress - Privacy by Design presentation20171108 IAPP Congress - Privacy by Design presentation
20171108 IAPP Congress - Privacy by Design presentation
 
20171106 - Privacy Design Lab - LINDDUN
20171106 - Privacy Design Lab - LINDDUN20171106 - Privacy Design Lab - LINDDUN
20171106 - Privacy Design Lab - LINDDUN
 
20170601 - Digital festival presentation
20170601 - Digital festival presentation20170601 - Digital festival presentation
20170601 - Digital festival presentation
 
20170801 GDPR Q&A intro
20170801 GDPR Q&A intro20170801 GDPR Q&A intro
20170801 GDPR Q&A intro
 
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (2)
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (2)20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (2)
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (2)
 
20170620 MEETUP smart contracts proof of concept for prescriptions
20170620 MEETUP smart contracts proof of concept for prescriptions20170620 MEETUP smart contracts proof of concept for prescriptions
20170620 MEETUP smart contracts proof of concept for prescriptions
 
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (1)
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (1)20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (1)
20170620 MEETUP intro to blockchain and smart contracts (1)
 
20170418 MEETUP on Creative Commons
20170418 MEETUP on Creative Commons20170418 MEETUP on Creative Commons
20170418 MEETUP on Creative Commons
 
20170122 MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
20170122 MEETUP on autonomous vehicles20170122 MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
20170122 MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
 
20170122 intro MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
20170122 intro MEETUP on autonomous vehicles20170122 intro MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
20170122 intro MEETUP on autonomous vehicles
 
20161127 KICK-OFF Legal Hacking Brussels
20161127 KICK-OFF Legal Hacking Brussels20161127 KICK-OFF Legal Hacking Brussels
20161127 KICK-OFF Legal Hacking Brussels
 

Recently uploaded

78 Microsoft-Publisher - Sirin Sultana Bora.pptx
78 Microsoft-Publisher - Sirin Sultana Bora.pptx78 Microsoft-Publisher - Sirin Sultana Bora.pptx
78 Microsoft-Publisher - Sirin Sultana Bora.pptx
Kalna College
 
Data Structure using C by Dr. K Adisesha .ppsx
Data Structure using C by Dr. K Adisesha .ppsxData Structure using C by Dr. K Adisesha .ppsx
Data Structure using C by Dr. K Adisesha .ppsx
Prof. Dr. K. Adisesha
 
A Free 200-Page eBook ~ Brain and Mind Exercise.pptx
A Free 200-Page eBook ~ Brain and Mind Exercise.pptxA Free 200-Page eBook ~ Brain and Mind Exercise.pptx
A Free 200-Page eBook ~ Brain and Mind Exercise.pptx
OH TEIK BIN
 
RESULTS OF THE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE.pptx
RESULTS OF THE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE.pptxRESULTS OF THE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE.pptx
RESULTS OF THE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE.pptx
zuzanka
 
How to Setup Default Value for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Setup Default Value for a Field in Odoo 17How to Setup Default Value for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Setup Default Value for a Field in Odoo 17
Celine George
 
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) CurriculumPhilippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
MJDuyan
 
HYPERTENSION - SLIDE SHARE PRESENTATION.
HYPERTENSION - SLIDE SHARE PRESENTATION.HYPERTENSION - SLIDE SHARE PRESENTATION.
HYPERTENSION - SLIDE SHARE PRESENTATION.
deepaannamalai16
 
Haunted Houses by H W Longfellow for class 10
Haunted Houses by H W Longfellow for class 10Haunted Houses by H W Longfellow for class 10
Haunted Houses by H W Longfellow for class 10
nitinpv4ai
 
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skillsspot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
haiqairshad
 
Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...
Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...
Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...
TechSoup
 
Bonku-Babus-Friend by Sathyajith Ray (9)
Bonku-Babus-Friend by Sathyajith Ray  (9)Bonku-Babus-Friend by Sathyajith Ray  (9)
Bonku-Babus-Friend by Sathyajith Ray (9)
nitinpv4ai
 
Andreas Schleicher presents PISA 2022 Volume III - Creative Thinking - 18 Jun...
Andreas Schleicher presents PISA 2022 Volume III - Creative Thinking - 18 Jun...Andreas Schleicher presents PISA 2022 Volume III - Creative Thinking - 18 Jun...
Andreas Schleicher presents PISA 2022 Volume III - Creative Thinking - 18 Jun...
EduSkills OECD
 
Level 3 NCEA - NZ: A Nation In the Making 1872 - 1900 SML.ppt
Level 3 NCEA - NZ: A  Nation In the Making 1872 - 1900 SML.pptLevel 3 NCEA - NZ: A  Nation In the Making 1872 - 1900 SML.ppt
Level 3 NCEA - NZ: A Nation In the Making 1872 - 1900 SML.ppt
Henry Hollis
 
Observational Learning
Observational Learning Observational Learning
Observational Learning
sanamushtaq922
 
BIOLOGY NATIONAL EXAMINATION COUNCIL (NECO) 2024 PRACTICAL MANUAL.pptx
BIOLOGY NATIONAL EXAMINATION COUNCIL (NECO) 2024 PRACTICAL MANUAL.pptxBIOLOGY NATIONAL EXAMINATION COUNCIL (NECO) 2024 PRACTICAL MANUAL.pptx
BIOLOGY NATIONAL EXAMINATION COUNCIL (NECO) 2024 PRACTICAL MANUAL.pptx
RidwanHassanYusuf
 
How to Manage Reception Report in Odoo 17
How to Manage Reception Report in Odoo 17How to Manage Reception Report in Odoo 17
How to Manage Reception Report in Odoo 17
Celine George
 
BPSC-105 important questions for june term end exam
BPSC-105 important questions for june term end examBPSC-105 important questions for june term end exam
BPSC-105 important questions for june term end exam
sonukumargpnirsadhan
 
KHUSWANT SINGH.pptx ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KHUSHWANT SINGH
KHUSWANT SINGH.pptx ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KHUSHWANT SINGHKHUSWANT SINGH.pptx ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KHUSHWANT SINGH
KHUSWANT SINGH.pptx ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KHUSHWANT SINGH
shreyassri1208
 
Bossa N’ Roll Records by Ismael Vazquez.
Bossa N’ Roll Records by Ismael Vazquez.Bossa N’ Roll Records by Ismael Vazquez.
Bossa N’ Roll Records by Ismael Vazquez.
IsmaelVazquez38
 
Gender and Mental Health - Counselling and Family Therapy Applications and In...
Gender and Mental Health - Counselling and Family Therapy Applications and In...Gender and Mental Health - Counselling and Family Therapy Applications and In...
Gender and Mental Health - Counselling and Family Therapy Applications and In...
PsychoTech Services
 

Recently uploaded (20)

78 Microsoft-Publisher - Sirin Sultana Bora.pptx
78 Microsoft-Publisher - Sirin Sultana Bora.pptx78 Microsoft-Publisher - Sirin Sultana Bora.pptx
78 Microsoft-Publisher - Sirin Sultana Bora.pptx
 
Data Structure using C by Dr. K Adisesha .ppsx
Data Structure using C by Dr. K Adisesha .ppsxData Structure using C by Dr. K Adisesha .ppsx
Data Structure using C by Dr. K Adisesha .ppsx
 
A Free 200-Page eBook ~ Brain and Mind Exercise.pptx
A Free 200-Page eBook ~ Brain and Mind Exercise.pptxA Free 200-Page eBook ~ Brain and Mind Exercise.pptx
A Free 200-Page eBook ~ Brain and Mind Exercise.pptx
 
RESULTS OF THE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE.pptx
RESULTS OF THE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE.pptxRESULTS OF THE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE.pptx
RESULTS OF THE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE.pptx
 
How to Setup Default Value for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Setup Default Value for a Field in Odoo 17How to Setup Default Value for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Setup Default Value for a Field in Odoo 17
 
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) CurriculumPhilippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
 
HYPERTENSION - SLIDE SHARE PRESENTATION.
HYPERTENSION - SLIDE SHARE PRESENTATION.HYPERTENSION - SLIDE SHARE PRESENTATION.
HYPERTENSION - SLIDE SHARE PRESENTATION.
 
Haunted Houses by H W Longfellow for class 10
Haunted Houses by H W Longfellow for class 10Haunted Houses by H W Longfellow for class 10
Haunted Houses by H W Longfellow for class 10
 
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skillsspot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
 
Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...
Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...
Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...
 
Bonku-Babus-Friend by Sathyajith Ray (9)
Bonku-Babus-Friend by Sathyajith Ray  (9)Bonku-Babus-Friend by Sathyajith Ray  (9)
Bonku-Babus-Friend by Sathyajith Ray (9)
 
Andreas Schleicher presents PISA 2022 Volume III - Creative Thinking - 18 Jun...
Andreas Schleicher presents PISA 2022 Volume III - Creative Thinking - 18 Jun...Andreas Schleicher presents PISA 2022 Volume III - Creative Thinking - 18 Jun...
Andreas Schleicher presents PISA 2022 Volume III - Creative Thinking - 18 Jun...
 
Level 3 NCEA - NZ: A Nation In the Making 1872 - 1900 SML.ppt
Level 3 NCEA - NZ: A  Nation In the Making 1872 - 1900 SML.pptLevel 3 NCEA - NZ: A  Nation In the Making 1872 - 1900 SML.ppt
Level 3 NCEA - NZ: A Nation In the Making 1872 - 1900 SML.ppt
 
Observational Learning
Observational Learning Observational Learning
Observational Learning
 
BIOLOGY NATIONAL EXAMINATION COUNCIL (NECO) 2024 PRACTICAL MANUAL.pptx
BIOLOGY NATIONAL EXAMINATION COUNCIL (NECO) 2024 PRACTICAL MANUAL.pptxBIOLOGY NATIONAL EXAMINATION COUNCIL (NECO) 2024 PRACTICAL MANUAL.pptx
BIOLOGY NATIONAL EXAMINATION COUNCIL (NECO) 2024 PRACTICAL MANUAL.pptx
 
How to Manage Reception Report in Odoo 17
How to Manage Reception Report in Odoo 17How to Manage Reception Report in Odoo 17
How to Manage Reception Report in Odoo 17
 
BPSC-105 important questions for june term end exam
BPSC-105 important questions for june term end examBPSC-105 important questions for june term end exam
BPSC-105 important questions for june term end exam
 
KHUSWANT SINGH.pptx ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KHUSHWANT SINGH
KHUSWANT SINGH.pptx ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KHUSHWANT SINGHKHUSWANT SINGH.pptx ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KHUSHWANT SINGH
KHUSWANT SINGH.pptx ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KHUSHWANT SINGH
 
Bossa N’ Roll Records by Ismael Vazquez.
Bossa N’ Roll Records by Ismael Vazquez.Bossa N’ Roll Records by Ismael Vazquez.
Bossa N’ Roll Records by Ismael Vazquez.
 
Gender and Mental Health - Counselling and Family Therapy Applications and In...
Gender and Mental Health - Counselling and Family Therapy Applications and In...Gender and Mental Health - Counselling and Family Therapy Applications and In...
Gender and Mental Health - Counselling and Family Therapy Applications and In...
 

20190316 - CLBFest - Virtual Currencies - Niels Vandezande

  • 1. CL+B FEST 2019 16 March 2019 Dr. Niels Vandezande VIRTUAL CURRENCIES, A VIABLE TRANSFER OF VALUE?
  • 3. • 2008: Bitcoin white paper Satoshi Nakamoto • First blockchain use case • 2009: genesis block • 2010: First physical transaction • 2 pizza’s @ BTC 10.000 • 2011: parity with USD • 2013: first hype -> BTC 1 > USD 1.000 • 2014-2016: relative stability around USD 500 • 2017: second hype -> BTC 1 = USD 20.000 • 2018-2019: going down (BTC 1 around USD 4.000) 3 BITCOIN
  • 4. 4 BITCOIN AND CRYPTOCURRENCIES • Other cryptocurrencies: • Often imitations of bitcoin, but could also serve other purposes: Ethereum • -> issue of network economics • Bitcoin forks: seceding from the bitcoin blockchain • Bitcoin Cash • Bitcoin Gold • Bitcoin Private • Scalability issues • Bitcoin can only process limited amount of transactions (4/s versus 25k/s Visa) • consequence: confirmation delays and high transaction costs
  • 6. • No payment apps • App Store only launched in 2008 • Slow processing time • Often several working days • High transaction fees • Due to many parties involved in a typical transaction • Network costs • Particularly expensive before wider adoption of broadband • Financial crisis • Trust in financial system undermined 6 PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: SITUATION AT 2008
  • 8. 8 PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: ACTORS By Dyah N.K. Makhijani (2006) “An Introduction of Payment Systems”, https://www.bi.go.id/en/sistem- pembayaran/edukasi/Documents/1fe856cd22d04b9abfd4 4ab050545fefAnIntroductiononPaymentSystem.pdf.
  • 10. 10 PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: COSTS Accourt (2016) “Bank charges on international payments An analysis of the UK SME market”, report for MoneyMovers.
  • 11. • Swift payments • Cheap payments • No reliance on intermediaries • Anonymity • Good for underbanked • No seizure or theft • No taxes • No chargebacks 11 PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: PROMISES OF BITCOIN
  • 12. • Swift payments • Bottleneck due to scaling problem • Cheap payments • High transaction fees due to scaling problem • No reliance on intermediaries • Plethora of intermediaries mimicking traditional intermediaries • Anonymity • Not that hard to identify person behind the transaction 12 PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: PROMISES OF BITCOIN
  • 13. • Good for underbanked • No reliance on banks, but also alternatives • No seizure or theft • Keys can be seized or stolen • No taxes • False, can be subjected to VAT and capital gains tax • No chargebacks • But non-revocation can also be a bad thing 13 PAYMENTS LANDSCAPE: PROMISES OF BITCOIN
  • 14. • Benefits: who mines a block receives new units of bitcoin (12,5 anno 2018) • Costs: • Equipment: specialized ASIC-miners required • Electricity: every transaction uses about as much electricity as a median household per month • Data: bitcoin blockchain > 170GB 14 BITCOIN: COSTS AND BENEFITS By Marco Krohn (Own work) [CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0)], via Wikimedia Commons
  • 18. M-Pesa • Mobile phone money transfer • Available in Kenya, Tanzania, Afghanistan, South Africa, India, Romania (and Albania) • Allows users to deposit, withdraw, transfer money and pay for goods and services • Using account on mobile phone, operated by telecom provider 18 ALTERNATIVES FOR UNDERBANKED
  • 21. MONEY: THEORIES AND ORIGINS 21
  • 22. • Assets used to conclude payments? • But: there is also money that doesn’t serve as means of payment • And means of payment that aren’t money • UCC: a medium of exchange currently authorized or adopted by a domestic or foreign government • In part refers to legal tender • Black’s Law Dictionary: generally accepted medium of exchange – often with the status of legal tender – that represents purchasing power, or assets that can be easily converted into cash • First part: legal tender • Second part: but also not legal tender (see M1 and M2) MONEY: DEFINITION 22
  • 23. • State theory: State determines means of payment, unit of account and denominations -> Not just legal tender, but what is accepted by State • Societal theory: what has confidence of the people and is used in commerce • Functions: medium of exchange, unit of account, store of value 23 MONEY: ECONOMIC THEORIES
  • 24. • Popular opinion: bartering theory • Money was created to solve the issues of bartering • However: • no perfect bartering society ever existed • Money as unit of account came before physical circulation • First money: money as credit • Oldest law codes noted debts in weights of silver (even before 2000 B.C.) • However, that silver did not circulate, it only serves as common unit of account to settle debts • See also Yap stones: stone served as money, but did not have to circulate • => centralized or even decentralized ledgers! • Next step: money as physical unit • First coins found in Lydia (700 B.C.) 24 MONEY: ORIGINS By Bartek.cieslak (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons
  • 25. E-MONEY AND PAYMENT SERVICES 25
  • 26. E-MONEY: SECOND DIRECTIVE (2009/110/EC) • E-money • Definition refined (see next slide) • E-money institutions • Lighter regime (no longer credit institutions, but still no deposit-taking) • Operational requirements: EUR 350k initial capital, own funds rules • Prudential rules: see PSD • Broader activities (limited credit-granting relating to payment services) • Safeguarding requirements • Waivers and redeemability maintained • Review: should have coincided with review PSD 26
  • 27. E-MONEY: SCOPE • Electronically, including magnetically, stored value • Technology neutral • Funds must be available to bearer • Represented by a claim on the issuer • Question of ownership • Reimbursement -> redeemability • Issued on receipt of funds • Protection against over-issuing (though EMD1 failed here) • Creation of new units must correspond to funds received hereto (prepaid) • Accepted by institutions other than their issuer • Distinction from single- or limited-purpose instruments • See limited network scope exemption 27
  • 28. PAYMENT SERVICES: SECOND DIRECTIVE (2015/2366) • Scope: addition of third parties, tightening of scope exemptions • Authorization and operational requirements largely the same • Tighter rules regarding execution of transactions (e.g. focus on strong user authentication, limitation of payer’s liability for unauthorized transactions to EUR 50) • Quid EMD2? • Applicable since January 2018 28
  • 29. PAYMENT SERVICES: SCOPE • Provision of payment services as main business • Funds: could include VC, though not universally accepted • Focus on payment accounts • Services: • Cash withdrawal and placement • Transactions funded by payment account or credit line • Issuing payment instruments • Money remittance (cash-based, without account) • Payment initiation and account information services 29
  • 30. PAYMENT SERVICES: SCOPE EXEMPTIONS • Cash transactions, document-based transactions, cash transport, etc. • Technical service providers • Added value exemption • Those not acting as mere intermediary are exempted • PSD2: more clearly limited to electronic communications services and for limited value • Limited networks exemption • Services within limited network or limited range of goods/services exempted • PSD2: limited network around issuer, limited range of goods/services, services limited to one MS for social or tax purposes • Money exchange exemption • Only covers cash-to-cash operations 30
  • 31. VIRTUAL CURRENCIES: E-MONEY? • Closed scheme virtual currencies • No exchange between VC and legal tender -> no e-money • Unidirectional scheme virtual currencies • Could theoretically fulfill all criteria • However: differentiation needed in practice • Bidirectional scheme virtual currencies • Also here: possible in theory, need for differentiation in practice • E.g. cryptocurrencies: issuing (in the sense of creation) controlled by algorithm, not by receipt of funds • E.g. Second Life Linden dollar: can only be used in Second Life 31
  • 32. VIRTUAL CURRENCIES: PAYMENT SERVICES? • Closed scheme and unidirectional scheme virtual currencies • Not included under scope (and would benefit from scope exemption anyway) • Bidirectional scheme virtual currencies • Scope exemption could apply to services with limited acceptance • Differences between MS: FR and LU in favor of inclusion; BE, DE and UK not • However: also here case-by-case approach needed • Consequence: if EMD2 and PSD2 cannot be applied -> resort to regular contract law 32
  • 33. VIRTUAL CURRENCIES: LICENSED SERVICE PROVIDERS? • Several cases in BE, LU and UK of virtual currency service providers being licensed • Need to distinguish between what the license is for and what not • Positive development • Could help foster trust • Can be competitive advantage • Could lead to transitory measures • Negative development • Divergence between MS does not facilitate harmonization of this framework -> passporting? • False perception of trustworthiness of other service providers • Burden for market entrants 33
  • 35. CRYPTOCURRENCIES: APPLICABILITY CURRENT LAW • Can we apply some of the current frameworks in EU financial law? • E-money and payment services: principally not applicable • Can we make these frameworks applicable? • E-money and payment services: e-money is in need of overhaul, list of payment services can be extended
  • 36. • No legal tender: can be accepted at own risk, but not mandatory • User: bears the risk of loss, theft, value fluctuations, etc. • Service provider: • No payment service of e-money: so no license required • but: could be coupled to offering payment services (e.g. Circle) • ->need to investigate whether other services offered are bound to license duty 36 CRYPTOCURRENCIES IN PRACTICE
  • 37. • What if also a payment service is offered? • Apply for license at competent regulator • Prudential requirements • Capital requirements (between 20k and 120k, depending on service) • Documentation and accounting • Processing of personal data (limited and with explicit consent) • AML rules also applicable! 37 CRYPTOCURRENCIES IN PRACTICE
  • 38. • Main opportunities? • Global remittance: migrants send over USD 600 billion home per year • Blockchain technology: so much more than cryptocurrencies • Trading and interbanking: could be used in trade finance • For merchants: first-mover advantage? But also risks! • But: we need to fix some things • Today, bitcoin is not a viable means of payment • Technical, governance and legal issues to be tackled 38 CRYPTOCURRENCIES IN PRACTICE
  • 39. ANY QUESTIONS? Dr. Niels Vandezande Legal Consultant @ Timelex Research Fellow @ KU Leuven CiTiP niels.vandezande@timelex.eu www.timelex.eu be.linkedin.com/in/nvandezande twitter.com/nielsvandezande 39