SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
A GIS Analysis of Los Angeles County Food Resources by Type
and their Relationship to Obesity and Poverty
Lauren Minnick
HSC4933.318: Intro to GIS for Public Health, Spring 2013
INTRODUCTION
Obesity has been on the rise in the United States and has come to the forefront of the discussion of Public Health policy. According to
the CDC’s 2009-2010 obesity data 35.7% of adults in the U.S. were obese (BMI > 30). Obesity contributes to many of our nations health
problems, including diabetes, cardiovascular disease, hypertension, and some cancers, making it an important health concern (Ogden,
2012). One focus of current public health initiatives is the concept of ‘food deserts,’ areas where there exists a lack of healthy food
options (USDA, 2010). However, it is also important to consider the prevalence and availability of unhealthy and inexpensive food
options and the impact this may have on obesity. An additional factor for consideration is socioeconomic status. According to an obesity
report issued by the LA County Health Department, among individuals with incomes below the federal poverty level the obesity rate
was 30.2%, compared to 19.9% among individuals at 200% or above the federal poverty level (County of Los Angeles Public Health,
2012).
JUSTIFICATION
Considering the importance that has been placed on the concept of ‘food deserts’ in current efforts to fight obesity and the emphasis that
this concept places the lack of healthy options. It is also worth considering the prevalence of unhealthy food options and the impact that
this has on obesity. Mapping the prevalence of fast food restaurants is valuable, as these options are both unhealthy and inexpensive and
relate to the known correlation between poverty and obesity.
OBJECTIVE
1.Analyze the spatial relationship between the prevalence of obesity by health district and concentrations of unhealthy food options.
2.Analyze the spatial relationship between the prevalence of obesity by health district and healthy food options.
3.Analyze the spatial relationship between poverty data by census tract, obesity and food resources.
Map 1 Map 2
Map 1. A chloropleth map of the percent of the adult
population in Los Angeles County that are obese, organized by
health district boundaries. Areas of special interest are the
Antellope Valley Health District in the North East with 36.1%
adult obesity and the Inglewood (45.3% obesity), Compton
(32.8% obesity), San Antonio (32% obesity), and East LA
(37.3% obesity) Health Districts in the South Central part of
the county.
Note: Obesity status is based on Body Mass Index (BMI)
calculated from self-reported weight and height. A BMI ≥ 30 is
considered obese (Ogden, 2012).
Map 2. A chloropleth map of the percentage of the population
living below the poverty level by census tract overlaid with
health district boundaries. The darkest purple areas are the
parts of the county with the highest percentage living in
poverty. The health districts with the highest average poverty
rates are Southeast (39.3%), South (32.1%), Southwest
(28.2%), Central (27.7%), Compton (23.2%).
Note: The areas in white have no census data available.
METHODOLOGY
• A GIS analysis was performed to identify the locations of healthy and unhealthy food sources
• GPS data was compiled for the locations of the top 5 grossing fast food restaurants in the United States (McDonalds,
Burger King, Wendy’s, Taco Bell, and Pizza Hut) (McConnell, 2012). These separate layers were merged to create a
single fast food layer.
• Other studies mapping food deserts analyze the accessibility of fresh groceries, so for my analysis GPS data was
compiled for farmer’s markets and 4 common grocery stores in LA County (Farmer’s Markets, Von’s, Ralph’s Grocery
Market, Albertson’s and Walmart Supercenter) (Burns, 2007). These layers were merged to form a single grocery food
source layer.
•A point density analysis was performed for both the fast food locations and grocery locations, in order to assess areas with a high
concentration of locations for each category.
•Obesity data was obtained from the 2011 Los Angeles County Health Survey and prepared in an excel file and joined to health district
polygons.
•Census data regarding poverty levels was obtained from the US Census Bureau and joined to the census tract shapefile.
Note: Santa Catalina Island and San Clemente Island, both part of the Harbor Health District in LA County, have been omitted from this analysis .
Map 4
Map 6Map 5
Map 3
Map 3. GPS point locations where fresh groceries can be
purchased within Los Angeles County.
Actual counts of grocery locations in in Health Districts with
the highest point density concentrations:
• West Health District- 69
•Hollywood-Wilshire Health District- 34
•Central Health District- 21
•Pasadena Health District- 13
•Torrance Health District-39
•Southwest Health District-17
CONCLUSION
•In comparing the map layouts of obesity and poverty there is an apparent correlation between poverty and obesity.
•The Central Health District is a notable outlier, with high levels of poverty (27.7%) and a lower level of obesity (19.1%). Central Health District also contains a
high density of locations to purchase fresh groceries in comparison to other high poverty areas. Indicating that a higher number of locations to purchase fresh
groceries could have a positive impact in decreasing obesity.
•In examining the point density map of locations for purchasing fresh groceries there is a notable low density in the south central part of the county where there
is a high level of obesity and high level of poverty.
•The fast food point density shows a high density of fast food restaurants in several districts that have high levels of poverty and several with high levels of
obesity.
•The maps of locations to purchase fresh groceries contain locations for several major grocery store chains and for farmers markets in LA County. It is not a
complete list and I was unable to obtain data for smaller chains with many locations in the Los Angeles area. A future analysis containing a more complete map
of grocery locations may show a greater density in areas with high poverty and high obesity.
•The scale of obesity data is useful for health districts to know their status in comparison to other districts in the county and is also valuable for the county to
allocate resources. Further research might examine obesity data at a more focused scale, such as neighborhood or census tract, in order to more accurately
identify factors that may contribute to obesity.
Map 4. GPS point locations of fast food restaurants within
Los Angeles County.
Actual counts of fast food locations in Health Districts with
the highest point density concentrations:
•Central Health District- 37
•Southwest Health District- 39
•Southeast Health District- 7
•South- 10
•San Antonio- 41
•Inglewood- 43
Map 5. Point Density Analysis of locations with the highest
concentration of locations where fresh groceries can be
purchased. The West, Hollywood-Wilshire, Central,
Pasadena, Torrance, and Southwest Health Districts contain
the areas with the highest concentrations of fresh grocery
locations. Areas of note that contain a low density are the
Southeast, East LA, San Antonio, South, Compton, and North
East Health Districts.
Map 6. Point Density Analysis of locations with the highest
concentration of fast food restaurants. The Central, Southeast,
Southwest, South, Inglewood, and San Antonio Health
Districts contain the areas with the highest concentrations of
locations where fresh groceries can be purchased.
REFERENCES
Burns, C. Inglis, A. (2007, December). Measuring food access in Melbourne: Access to healthy and fast foods by car, bus, and foot in an urban municipality in Melbourne. Health & Place, 13(4), 877-885. http://www.sciencedirect.com.ezproxy.lib.usf.edu/science/article/pii/S1353829207000263?
McConnell, A. Bhasin, K. (2012, July 12). Ranked: the most popular fast food restaurants in America. Retrieved from http://www.businessinsider.com/the-most-popular-fast-food-restaurants-in-america-2012-7?op=1#ixzz2RRC1Z4VA
Ogden, C. Carroll, M. Kit, B. and Flegal, K. (2012, January). NCHS data brief, 82. Prevalence of obesity in the United States, 2009-2010. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db82.pdf
LA County GIS Data Portal. (2012). Health Districts [Data file]. Available from http://egis3.lacounty.gov/dataportal/2012/03/01/health-districts-hd-2012/
LA County Health Survey. (2011). Obesity/overweight [Data file]. Available from http://publichealth.lacounty.gov/ha/LACHSDataTopics2011.htm
Los Angeles County Public Health. (2012, September). Trends in obesity: adult obesity continues to rise. LA Health. Retrieved from http://publichealth.lacounty.gov/ha/reports/LAHealthBrief_2011/Obesity/Obesity_2012_sFinal.pdf
US Census Bureau. (2011). Poverty status in the past 12 months [Data file] Available from http://factfinder2.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/guided_search.xhtml
US Census Bureau. (2011). California census tracts [Data file]. Available from http://www.census.gov/cgi-bin/geo/shapefiles2011/layers.cgi
USDA. (2010, May). Health food financing initiative. Retrieved from http://www.ams.usda.gov/AMSv1.0/getfile?dDocName=STELPRDC5085689

More Related Content

What's hot

Preventing Childhood Obesity: The Need To Create Healthy Places
Preventing Childhood Obesity: The Need To Create Healthy PlacesPreventing Childhood Obesity: The Need To Create Healthy Places
Preventing Childhood Obesity: The Need To Create Healthy PlacesKlausGroenholm
 
From-Paycheck-to-Pantry-Oxfam-FeedingAmerica
From-Paycheck-to-Pantry-Oxfam-FeedingAmericaFrom-Paycheck-to-Pantry-Oxfam-FeedingAmerica
From-Paycheck-to-Pantry-Oxfam-FeedingAmericaAndrew Yarrow
 
Koch Food Security Field Assessment Report (Final Draft)
Koch  Food Security Field Assessment Report (Final Draft)Koch  Food Security Field Assessment Report (Final Draft)
Koch Food Security Field Assessment Report (Final Draft)George Bete
 
7 coast and jungle malnutrition
7   coast and jungle malnutrition7   coast and jungle malnutrition
7 coast and jungle malnutritionJuan R Farro
 
V_Young Global Public Health Assignment 3
V_Young Global Public Health Assignment 3V_Young Global Public Health Assignment 3
V_Young Global Public Health Assignment 3Vanessa Pike (Young)
 
Food insecurity and copping strategies
Food insecurity and copping strategiesFood insecurity and copping strategies
Food insecurity and copping strategiesAlexander Decker
 
HaleySlone--Hunger--ECA-2
HaleySlone--Hunger--ECA-2HaleySlone--Hunger--ECA-2
HaleySlone--Hunger--ECA-2Haley Slone
 
Hunger and Food Insecurity
Hunger and Food InsecurityHunger and Food Insecurity
Hunger and Food InsecurityMaryPotorti1
 
Analysis of the significance of fishing on food security status of
Analysis of the significance of fishing on food security status ofAnalysis of the significance of fishing on food security status of
Analysis of the significance of fishing on food security status ofAlexander Decker
 
Assessing nutritional status
Assessing nutritional statusAssessing nutritional status
Assessing nutritional statusMurali Krishnan L
 
Determinants of children's nutritional status among primary
Determinants of children's nutritional status among primaryDeterminants of children's nutritional status among primary
Determinants of children's nutritional status among primaryAlexander Decker
 

What's hot (16)

Preventing Childhood Obesity: The Need To Create Healthy Places
Preventing Childhood Obesity: The Need To Create Healthy PlacesPreventing Childhood Obesity: The Need To Create Healthy Places
Preventing Childhood Obesity: The Need To Create Healthy Places
 
From-Paycheck-to-Pantry-Oxfam-FeedingAmerica
From-Paycheck-to-Pantry-Oxfam-FeedingAmericaFrom-Paycheck-to-Pantry-Oxfam-FeedingAmerica
From-Paycheck-to-Pantry-Oxfam-FeedingAmerica
 
Koch Food Security Field Assessment Report (Final Draft)
Koch  Food Security Field Assessment Report (Final Draft)Koch  Food Security Field Assessment Report (Final Draft)
Koch Food Security Field Assessment Report (Final Draft)
 
7 coast and jungle malnutrition
7   coast and jungle malnutrition7   coast and jungle malnutrition
7 coast and jungle malnutrition
 
POL 466 Capstone
POL 466 CapstonePOL 466 Capstone
POL 466 Capstone
 
V_Young Global Public Health Assignment 3
V_Young Global Public Health Assignment 3V_Young Global Public Health Assignment 3
V_Young Global Public Health Assignment 3
 
Food insecurity and copping strategies
Food insecurity and copping strategiesFood insecurity and copping strategies
Food insecurity and copping strategies
 
HaleySlone--Hunger--ECA-2
HaleySlone--Hunger--ECA-2HaleySlone--Hunger--ECA-2
HaleySlone--Hunger--ECA-2
 
Hunger and Food Insecurity
Hunger and Food InsecurityHunger and Food Insecurity
Hunger and Food Insecurity
 
Urban rural disparity
Urban rural disparityUrban rural disparity
Urban rural disparity
 
Analysis of the significance of fishing on food security status of
Analysis of the significance of fishing on food security status ofAnalysis of the significance of fishing on food security status of
Analysis of the significance of fishing on food security status of
 
Olivier Ecker • Leveraging Social Protection Policies and Programs for Promot...
Olivier Ecker • Leveraging Social Protection Policies and Programs for Promot...Olivier Ecker • Leveraging Social Protection Policies and Programs for Promot...
Olivier Ecker • Leveraging Social Protection Policies and Programs for Promot...
 
20200310 araba aerc
20200310 araba aerc20200310 araba aerc
20200310 araba aerc
 
Coping Strategies Index
Coping Strategies IndexCoping Strategies Index
Coping Strategies Index
 
Assessing nutritional status
Assessing nutritional statusAssessing nutritional status
Assessing nutritional status
 
Determinants of children's nutritional status among primary
Determinants of children's nutritional status among primaryDeterminants of children's nutritional status among primary
Determinants of children's nutritional status among primary
 

Similar to Minnick finalposter

Addressing Built Environmental Justice
Addressing Built Environmental JusticeAddressing Built Environmental Justice
Addressing Built Environmental JusticeMary Black
 
Healthy Food Accessibility and Obesity: Case Study of Pennsylvania, USA
Healthy Food Accessibility and Obesity: Case Study of Pennsylvania, USAHealthy Food Accessibility and Obesity: Case Study of Pennsylvania, USA
Healthy Food Accessibility and Obesity: Case Study of Pennsylvania, USArsmahabir
 
Finding The Hidden Wells Within Food Deserts
Finding The Hidden Wells Within Food DesertsFinding The Hidden Wells Within Food Deserts
Finding The Hidden Wells Within Food DesertsMark A. Caldwell
 
Childhood Obesity Powerpoint
Childhood Obesity PowerpointChildhood Obesity Powerpoint
Childhood Obesity Powerpointyvonne ritchie
 
nutritionprofiles_california_101916
nutritionprofiles_california_101916nutritionprofiles_california_101916
nutritionprofiles_california_101916David Thomsen
 
Community Garden Health Impact Assessment - Knox County Health Department
Community Garden Health Impact Assessment - Knox County Health DepartmentCommunity Garden Health Impact Assessment - Knox County Health Department
Community Garden Health Impact Assessment - Knox County Health DepartmentGeoAnitia
 
This assignment is an in-depth, literature-grounded analysis of a .docx
This assignment is an in-depth, literature-grounded analysis of a .docxThis assignment is an in-depth, literature-grounded analysis of a .docx
This assignment is an in-depth, literature-grounded analysis of a .docxchristalgrieg
 
An Overview Of The State Of Native American Health Challenges And Opportunities
An Overview Of The State Of Native American Health  Challenges And OpportunitiesAn Overview Of The State Of Native American Health  Challenges And Opportunities
An Overview Of The State Of Native American Health Challenges And OpportunitiesMary Calkins
 
CaseSMDEPHealthProjectstephanie
CaseSMDEPHealthProjectstephanieCaseSMDEPHealthProjectstephanie
CaseSMDEPHealthProjectstephanieGianina Hernandez
 
Thesis Project - Prodega Volume One: Through the Lens of the Individual
Thesis Project - Prodega Volume One: Through the Lens of the IndividualThesis Project - Prodega Volume One: Through the Lens of the Individual
Thesis Project - Prodega Volume One: Through the Lens of the IndividualChisun Rees
 
Blueprint_Final
Blueprint_FinalBlueprint_Final
Blueprint_FinalDavid Lee
 
3Why Are Some More Vulnerable Than OthersLearning .docx
3Why Are Some More Vulnerable  Than OthersLearning .docx3Why Are Some More Vulnerable  Than OthersLearning .docx
3Why Are Some More Vulnerable Than OthersLearning .docxtamicawaysmith
 
FINALHealthy Habits 101
FINALHealthy Habits 101FINALHealthy Habits 101
FINALHealthy Habits 101Erica Houston
 
Measuring Socio-spatial inequities to retail food access in Hawaii
Measuring Socio-spatial inequities to retail food access in HawaiiMeasuring Socio-spatial inequities to retail food access in Hawaii
Measuring Socio-spatial inequities to retail food access in HawaiiElise Dela Cruz-Talbert
 
Access To Affordable And Nutritious Food Measuring And Understanding Food De...
Access To Affordable And Nutritious Food  Measuring And Understanding Food De...Access To Affordable And Nutritious Food  Measuring And Understanding Food De...
Access To Affordable And Nutritious Food Measuring And Understanding Food De...Amy Cernava
 
Food Ordering App and Mediterranean Harvest For Life Addresses Health, Dispar...
Food Ordering App and Mediterranean Harvest For Life Addresses Health, Dispar...Food Ordering App and Mediterranean Harvest For Life Addresses Health, Dispar...
Food Ordering App and Mediterranean Harvest For Life Addresses Health, Dispar...Tim Maurer
 

Similar to Minnick finalposter (20)

Addressing Built Environmental Justice
Addressing Built Environmental JusticeAddressing Built Environmental Justice
Addressing Built Environmental Justice
 
Secondary Research
Secondary ResearchSecondary Research
Secondary Research
 
FAJBMRCIWoboielu.docx
FAJBMRCIWoboielu.docxFAJBMRCIWoboielu.docx
FAJBMRCIWoboielu.docx
 
Healthy Food Accessibility and Obesity: Case Study of Pennsylvania, USA
Healthy Food Accessibility and Obesity: Case Study of Pennsylvania, USAHealthy Food Accessibility and Obesity: Case Study of Pennsylvania, USA
Healthy Food Accessibility and Obesity: Case Study of Pennsylvania, USA
 
Finding The Hidden Wells Within Food Deserts
Finding The Hidden Wells Within Food DesertsFinding The Hidden Wells Within Food Deserts
Finding The Hidden Wells Within Food Deserts
 
Childhood Obesity Powerpoint
Childhood Obesity PowerpointChildhood Obesity Powerpoint
Childhood Obesity Powerpoint
 
nutritionprofiles_california_101916
nutritionprofiles_california_101916nutritionprofiles_california_101916
nutritionprofiles_california_101916
 
Community Garden Health Impact Assessment - Knox County Health Department
Community Garden Health Impact Assessment - Knox County Health DepartmentCommunity Garden Health Impact Assessment - Knox County Health Department
Community Garden Health Impact Assessment - Knox County Health Department
 
This assignment is an in-depth, literature-grounded analysis of a .docx
This assignment is an in-depth, literature-grounded analysis of a .docxThis assignment is an in-depth, literature-grounded analysis of a .docx
This assignment is an in-depth, literature-grounded analysis of a .docx
 
An Overview Of The State Of Native American Health Challenges And Opportunities
An Overview Of The State Of Native American Health  Challenges And OpportunitiesAn Overview Of The State Of Native American Health  Challenges And Opportunities
An Overview Of The State Of Native American Health Challenges And Opportunities
 
Obesity Epidemic (Research Paper)
Obesity Epidemic (Research Paper) Obesity Epidemic (Research Paper)
Obesity Epidemic (Research Paper)
 
CaseSMDEPHealthProjectstephanie
CaseSMDEPHealthProjectstephanieCaseSMDEPHealthProjectstephanie
CaseSMDEPHealthProjectstephanie
 
Thesis Project - Prodega Volume One: Through the Lens of the Individual
Thesis Project - Prodega Volume One: Through the Lens of the IndividualThesis Project - Prodega Volume One: Through the Lens of the Individual
Thesis Project - Prodega Volume One: Through the Lens of the Individual
 
Blueprint_Final
Blueprint_FinalBlueprint_Final
Blueprint_Final
 
3Why Are Some More Vulnerable Than OthersLearning .docx
3Why Are Some More Vulnerable  Than OthersLearning .docx3Why Are Some More Vulnerable  Than OthersLearning .docx
3Why Are Some More Vulnerable Than OthersLearning .docx
 
FINALHealthy Habits 101
FINALHealthy Habits 101FINALHealthy Habits 101
FINALHealthy Habits 101
 
Measuring Socio-spatial inequities to retail food access in Hawaii
Measuring Socio-spatial inequities to retail food access in HawaiiMeasuring Socio-spatial inequities to retail food access in Hawaii
Measuring Socio-spatial inequities to retail food access in Hawaii
 
Access To Affordable And Nutritious Food Measuring And Understanding Food De...
Access To Affordable And Nutritious Food  Measuring And Understanding Food De...Access To Affordable And Nutritious Food  Measuring And Understanding Food De...
Access To Affordable And Nutritious Food Measuring And Understanding Food De...
 
Food Ordering App and Mediterranean Harvest For Life Addresses Health, Dispar...
Food Ordering App and Mediterranean Harvest For Life Addresses Health, Dispar...Food Ordering App and Mediterranean Harvest For Life Addresses Health, Dispar...
Food Ordering App and Mediterranean Harvest For Life Addresses Health, Dispar...
 
Hametz-ShenkFINALCapstone2016
Hametz-ShenkFINALCapstone2016Hametz-ShenkFINALCapstone2016
Hametz-ShenkFINALCapstone2016
 

More from Lauren Minnick

Minnick ch10 presentation
Minnick ch10 presentationMinnick ch10 presentation
Minnick ch10 presentationLauren Minnick
 
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_3
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_3Minnick ch7 assignment_7_3
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_3Lauren Minnick
 
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_2
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_2Minnick ch7 assignment_7_2
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_2Lauren Minnick
 
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_1
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_1Minnick ch7 assignment_7_1
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_1Lauren Minnick
 
Minnick ch6 assign_6_2
Minnick ch6 assign_6_2Minnick ch6 assign_6_2
Minnick ch6 assign_6_2Lauren Minnick
 
Minnick ch6 assign_6_1
Minnick ch6 assign_6_1Minnick ch6 assign_6_1
Minnick ch6 assign_6_1Lauren Minnick
 
Minnick ch5 assign_5_2
Minnick ch5 assign_5_2Minnick ch5 assign_5_2
Minnick ch5 assign_5_2Lauren Minnick
 
Assignment2 2 laurenminnick
Assignment2 2 laurenminnickAssignment2 2 laurenminnick
Assignment2 2 laurenminnickLauren Minnick
 
Assignment1 2 elizabethminnick (1)
Assignment1 2 elizabethminnick (1)Assignment1 2 elizabethminnick (1)
Assignment1 2 elizabethminnick (1)Lauren Minnick
 
Assignment1 1 elizabethminnick
Assignment1 1 elizabethminnickAssignment1 1 elizabethminnick
Assignment1 1 elizabethminnickLauren Minnick
 

More from Lauren Minnick (13)

Minnick ch10 presentation
Minnick ch10 presentationMinnick ch10 presentation
Minnick ch10 presentation
 
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_3
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_3Minnick ch7 assignment_7_3
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_3
 
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_2
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_2Minnick ch7 assignment_7_2
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_2
 
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_1
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_1Minnick ch7 assignment_7_1
Minnick ch7 assignment_7_1
 
Minnick ch6 assign_6_2
Minnick ch6 assign_6_2Minnick ch6 assign_6_2
Minnick ch6 assign_6_2
 
Minnick ch6 assign_6_1
Minnick ch6 assign_6_1Minnick ch6 assign_6_1
Minnick ch6 assign_6_1
 
Minnick ch5 assign_5_2
Minnick ch5 assign_5_2Minnick ch5 assign_5_2
Minnick ch5 assign_5_2
 
Minnic ch5 assign_5_1
Minnic ch5 assign_5_1Minnic ch5 assign_5_1
Minnic ch5 assign_5_1
 
Assignment3 3 minnick
Assignment3 3 minnickAssignment3 3 minnick
Assignment3 3 minnick
 
Assignment3 1 minnick
Assignment3 1 minnickAssignment3 1 minnick
Assignment3 1 minnick
 
Assignment2 2 laurenminnick
Assignment2 2 laurenminnickAssignment2 2 laurenminnick
Assignment2 2 laurenminnick
 
Assignment1 2 elizabethminnick (1)
Assignment1 2 elizabethminnick (1)Assignment1 2 elizabethminnick (1)
Assignment1 2 elizabethminnick (1)
 
Assignment1 1 elizabethminnick
Assignment1 1 elizabethminnickAssignment1 1 elizabethminnick
Assignment1 1 elizabethminnick
 

Minnick finalposter

  • 1. A GIS Analysis of Los Angeles County Food Resources by Type and their Relationship to Obesity and Poverty Lauren Minnick HSC4933.318: Intro to GIS for Public Health, Spring 2013 INTRODUCTION Obesity has been on the rise in the United States and has come to the forefront of the discussion of Public Health policy. According to the CDC’s 2009-2010 obesity data 35.7% of adults in the U.S. were obese (BMI > 30). Obesity contributes to many of our nations health problems, including diabetes, cardiovascular disease, hypertension, and some cancers, making it an important health concern (Ogden, 2012). One focus of current public health initiatives is the concept of ‘food deserts,’ areas where there exists a lack of healthy food options (USDA, 2010). However, it is also important to consider the prevalence and availability of unhealthy and inexpensive food options and the impact this may have on obesity. An additional factor for consideration is socioeconomic status. According to an obesity report issued by the LA County Health Department, among individuals with incomes below the federal poverty level the obesity rate was 30.2%, compared to 19.9% among individuals at 200% or above the federal poverty level (County of Los Angeles Public Health, 2012). JUSTIFICATION Considering the importance that has been placed on the concept of ‘food deserts’ in current efforts to fight obesity and the emphasis that this concept places the lack of healthy options. It is also worth considering the prevalence of unhealthy food options and the impact that this has on obesity. Mapping the prevalence of fast food restaurants is valuable, as these options are both unhealthy and inexpensive and relate to the known correlation between poverty and obesity. OBJECTIVE 1.Analyze the spatial relationship between the prevalence of obesity by health district and concentrations of unhealthy food options. 2.Analyze the spatial relationship between the prevalence of obesity by health district and healthy food options. 3.Analyze the spatial relationship between poverty data by census tract, obesity and food resources. Map 1 Map 2 Map 1. A chloropleth map of the percent of the adult population in Los Angeles County that are obese, organized by health district boundaries. Areas of special interest are the Antellope Valley Health District in the North East with 36.1% adult obesity and the Inglewood (45.3% obesity), Compton (32.8% obesity), San Antonio (32% obesity), and East LA (37.3% obesity) Health Districts in the South Central part of the county. Note: Obesity status is based on Body Mass Index (BMI) calculated from self-reported weight and height. A BMI ≥ 30 is considered obese (Ogden, 2012). Map 2. A chloropleth map of the percentage of the population living below the poverty level by census tract overlaid with health district boundaries. The darkest purple areas are the parts of the county with the highest percentage living in poverty. The health districts with the highest average poverty rates are Southeast (39.3%), South (32.1%), Southwest (28.2%), Central (27.7%), Compton (23.2%). Note: The areas in white have no census data available. METHODOLOGY • A GIS analysis was performed to identify the locations of healthy and unhealthy food sources • GPS data was compiled for the locations of the top 5 grossing fast food restaurants in the United States (McDonalds, Burger King, Wendy’s, Taco Bell, and Pizza Hut) (McConnell, 2012). These separate layers were merged to create a single fast food layer. • Other studies mapping food deserts analyze the accessibility of fresh groceries, so for my analysis GPS data was compiled for farmer’s markets and 4 common grocery stores in LA County (Farmer’s Markets, Von’s, Ralph’s Grocery Market, Albertson’s and Walmart Supercenter) (Burns, 2007). These layers were merged to form a single grocery food source layer. •A point density analysis was performed for both the fast food locations and grocery locations, in order to assess areas with a high concentration of locations for each category. •Obesity data was obtained from the 2011 Los Angeles County Health Survey and prepared in an excel file and joined to health district polygons. •Census data regarding poverty levels was obtained from the US Census Bureau and joined to the census tract shapefile. Note: Santa Catalina Island and San Clemente Island, both part of the Harbor Health District in LA County, have been omitted from this analysis . Map 4 Map 6Map 5 Map 3 Map 3. GPS point locations where fresh groceries can be purchased within Los Angeles County. Actual counts of grocery locations in in Health Districts with the highest point density concentrations: • West Health District- 69 •Hollywood-Wilshire Health District- 34 •Central Health District- 21 •Pasadena Health District- 13 •Torrance Health District-39 •Southwest Health District-17 CONCLUSION •In comparing the map layouts of obesity and poverty there is an apparent correlation between poverty and obesity. •The Central Health District is a notable outlier, with high levels of poverty (27.7%) and a lower level of obesity (19.1%). Central Health District also contains a high density of locations to purchase fresh groceries in comparison to other high poverty areas. Indicating that a higher number of locations to purchase fresh groceries could have a positive impact in decreasing obesity. •In examining the point density map of locations for purchasing fresh groceries there is a notable low density in the south central part of the county where there is a high level of obesity and high level of poverty. •The fast food point density shows a high density of fast food restaurants in several districts that have high levels of poverty and several with high levels of obesity. •The maps of locations to purchase fresh groceries contain locations for several major grocery store chains and for farmers markets in LA County. It is not a complete list and I was unable to obtain data for smaller chains with many locations in the Los Angeles area. A future analysis containing a more complete map of grocery locations may show a greater density in areas with high poverty and high obesity. •The scale of obesity data is useful for health districts to know their status in comparison to other districts in the county and is also valuable for the county to allocate resources. Further research might examine obesity data at a more focused scale, such as neighborhood or census tract, in order to more accurately identify factors that may contribute to obesity. Map 4. GPS point locations of fast food restaurants within Los Angeles County. Actual counts of fast food locations in Health Districts with the highest point density concentrations: •Central Health District- 37 •Southwest Health District- 39 •Southeast Health District- 7 •South- 10 •San Antonio- 41 •Inglewood- 43 Map 5. Point Density Analysis of locations with the highest concentration of locations where fresh groceries can be purchased. The West, Hollywood-Wilshire, Central, Pasadena, Torrance, and Southwest Health Districts contain the areas with the highest concentrations of fresh grocery locations. Areas of note that contain a low density are the Southeast, East LA, San Antonio, South, Compton, and North East Health Districts. Map 6. Point Density Analysis of locations with the highest concentration of fast food restaurants. The Central, Southeast, Southwest, South, Inglewood, and San Antonio Health Districts contain the areas with the highest concentrations of locations where fresh groceries can be purchased. REFERENCES Burns, C. Inglis, A. (2007, December). Measuring food access in Melbourne: Access to healthy and fast foods by car, bus, and foot in an urban municipality in Melbourne. Health & Place, 13(4), 877-885. http://www.sciencedirect.com.ezproxy.lib.usf.edu/science/article/pii/S1353829207000263? McConnell, A. Bhasin, K. (2012, July 12). Ranked: the most popular fast food restaurants in America. Retrieved from http://www.businessinsider.com/the-most-popular-fast-food-restaurants-in-america-2012-7?op=1#ixzz2RRC1Z4VA Ogden, C. Carroll, M. Kit, B. and Flegal, K. (2012, January). NCHS data brief, 82. Prevalence of obesity in the United States, 2009-2010. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db82.pdf LA County GIS Data Portal. (2012). Health Districts [Data file]. Available from http://egis3.lacounty.gov/dataportal/2012/03/01/health-districts-hd-2012/ LA County Health Survey. (2011). Obesity/overweight [Data file]. Available from http://publichealth.lacounty.gov/ha/LACHSDataTopics2011.htm Los Angeles County Public Health. (2012, September). Trends in obesity: adult obesity continues to rise. LA Health. Retrieved from http://publichealth.lacounty.gov/ha/reports/LAHealthBrief_2011/Obesity/Obesity_2012_sFinal.pdf US Census Bureau. (2011). Poverty status in the past 12 months [Data file] Available from http://factfinder2.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/guided_search.xhtml US Census Bureau. (2011). California census tracts [Data file]. Available from http://www.census.gov/cgi-bin/geo/shapefiles2011/layers.cgi USDA. (2010, May). Health food financing initiative. Retrieved from http://www.ams.usda.gov/AMSv1.0/getfile?dDocName=STELPRDC5085689