Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Difficult user testing participants v2 pdf


Published on

UX Camp Brighton 2019 slides

Published in: Technology
  • Be the first to comment

Difficult user testing participants v2 pdf

  1. 1. @laura_yarrow Difficult research participants …and (non-sinister) ways of dealing with them
  2. 2. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 2 ★ Research in labs/in office ★ In-house or agency ★ Recruiting participants ★ Organising the day ★ Managing a client and observers This covers:
  3. 3. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 3 Sometimes, no matter what you do, tricky participants just happen.
  4. 4. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 4 Disclaimer: Most user testing participants are reacting to an unnatural situation
  5. 5. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 5 The many types of participant to deal with…
  6. 6. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 6 The Chatterbox ★ Spend all the session off topic ★ Tell you their life story - use the session as a social event ★ Lengthy discussions about the task ★ Don’t take it seriously Tips: ✓ Put a large clock on the desk ✓ Time-boxed script ✓ Don’t be afraid to interrupt ✓ Use closed questions at the end to get to the point MR CHATTERBOX
  7. 7. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 7 2. The Mute ★ Nervous, detached, despondent, or naturally quiet ★ Recent trauma or bad situation ★ Won’t talk through what they’re doing, afraid we’re testing them ✓ Be kind ✓ Be ready with open ended questions ✓ Have an introduction at the start that states they’re not being tested MR QUIET Tips:
  8. 8. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 8 3. The Pleasers ★ Wants to tell you what you want to hear ★ Won’t criticise anything, even if they struggle ★ If asked to rate anything, will give 10/10 ★ Will rush through everything like a race ✓ Screen for their sentiment towards brands/clients ✓ Emphasise your neutrality ✓ Play devils advocate - say you have to bring back a balanced set of feedback MR PERFECT Tips:
  9. 9. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 9 4. The Nosey Ones ★ Grill you about the client or organisation ★ Find it hard to focus on the tasks and research ★ May start using their phone/your tech to look up details! ✓ Again, reiterate your independence ✓ Let them know you can tell them at the end ✓ Don’t name anyone ✓ Test a range of products/sites/apps to maintain neutrality MR NOSEY Tips:
  10. 10. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 10 5. The Cheaters ★ Lied on the screener! ★ Trying to make a profession out of being a research participant ★ Will skew your research findings ★ Say they use the tech or devices required but can’t in the session ✓ Compare previous answers to screeners ✓ Keep a blacklist - take note of names that respond regularly ✓ Always recruit a backup LITTLE MISS NAUGHTY Tips:
  11. 11. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 11 6. The Undercover Agent ★ Refuses to be recorded or observed ★ Highly suspicious, very wary of recording devices ★ May have had a past bad experience ✓ Ask them in the screener if they are happy to be recorded in the session ✓ Give them a copy of the consent form ✓ Let them know exactly what you do with the recordings ✓ In the worst case, fall back to audio recording, or good note-taking! MR WORRY Tips:
  12. 12. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 12 7. The Free Spirit ✓ Time-box your script and tasks ✓ State “I want to spend 5 minutes talking about…” ✓ Keep a clock on the desk and keep referring to it ✓ Send instructions before hand about thinking out loud so they can practice LITTLE MISS SCATTERBRAIN ★ Regularly goes off course, distracted ★ Opening new tabs in browsers, not sticking to tasks ★ Incoherently narrates, can’t think out loud ★ Will show you photos on their phone of their cat/grandkids/plant ★ Possibly eating a MacDonalds lunch throughout Tips:
  13. 13. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 13 8. The Reluctant Participant ★ Treat it like an interview ★ Won’t touch the tech or engage ★ Think it’s a quiz and try and guess the answers to tasks without doing them ✓ Set expectations if you want them to use some devices ✓ “Can you show me how you would do this?” ✓ “Without telling me…” ✓ Gesture at the devices you want them to use… LITTLE MISS STUBBORN Tips:
  14. 14. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 14 9. The Confused ★ Not sure why they’re here / never done this before ★ Doesn’t normally use the tech you’re expecting them to use ★ Thinks they can bring their friend/child/dog… MR MUDDLE Tips: ✓ Send a guide before hand ✓ Brief them in at the start (what/why), and have they done this before? ✓ Only one question at a time ✓ Screen for devices they’re familiar with / technical ability
  15. 15. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 15 10. The Inappropriate Person ★ Wants to talk about you more than the tasks ★ Makes inappropriate comments ★ Poor hygiene etc ★ Inadvertently in-appropriate ✓ Don’t go alone, take a colleague who’s always watching ✓ End the test if you feel uncomfortable ✓ You can position them where you want! LITTLE MISS SCARY Tips:
  16. 16. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 16 11. The No Show ★ Doesn’t let you know ★ Doesn’t answer the phone ★ May turn up really late and try and slot themselves in ★ Will suggest a date in 4 weeks when they have a slot free… ✓ Blacklist ✓ Capture their phone number and text the night before ✓ Have a backup participant, or “floater” ✓ Allow breaks between each session where you could squeeze them in MR NOBODY Tips:
  17. 17. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 17 Summary ✓ Send out information before ✓ Have a time-boxed script to follow ✓ Text the night before ✓ Have a backup participant ✓ Screen properly (device, sentiment, job…) ✓ Brief the participant at the start ✓ Hide the tech ✓ Tell them what you do with recordings ✓ Allow for 5 minutes of settling in at the start ✓ Take a colleague MR CLEVER
  18. 18. @laura_yarrowDifficult user testing participants 18 Thanks, any questions? Email: Twitter: @laura_yarrow All images courtesy of