SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 15
Is Flint Unique?
The case of Hoosick Falls, NY
Kyle Monahan | 3-14-2016
Water Diplomacy Colloquium
Hoosick Falls, NY
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
Background
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
• Biggest employer is a plastics plant
• Less than 4,000 residents
• Water supply contaminated with
perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA)
Why PFOA?
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
• Industry of course!
• PFOA used in production of plastics,
firefighting foams and Teflon© type
coatings
• Occurs throughout NY
(Sinclair et al, 2006)
C8HF15O2
Why PFOA?
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
• You may know a similar chemical:
Hoosick Falls, NY - Background
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
• Toxicity is “unclear”
• Bio-accumulates & bio-concentrates
• Piscivorous birds especially at risk (EPA,
2006)
• May cause: developmental, reproductive
and other systematic effects (ATSDR, 2009).
Why Hoosick?
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
• Toxicity is “unclear”
• Bio-accumulates & bio-concentrates
• Piscivorous birds especially at risk (EPA,
2006)
• May cause: developmental, reproductive
and other systematic effects (ATSDR, 2009).
Why Hoosick?
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
• Toxicity is “unclear”
• Bio-accumulates & bio-concentrates
• Piscivorous birds especially at risk (EPA,
2006)
• May cause: developmental, reproductive
and other systematic effects (ATSDR, 2009).
Current Solutions?
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
• Temporary fix: activated carbon, bottled
water, flushing systems
It’s not just Flint
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
Current Solutions?
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
It’s not just Flint
But lead isn’t PFOA!
Many other chemical
spills around US
It’s not just Flint
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
• How do we deal with the high level of
contamination already present?
• What about toxicity
• We have toxicity information on <2% of
chemicals in use (Acosta, 2012).
It’s not just Flint
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
• How do we deal with the high level of
contamination already present?
• What about toxicity
• We have toxicity information on <2% of
chemicals in use (Acosta, 2012).
It’s not just Flint
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
Questions:
Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
• How do we deal with the high level of
contamination already present in the US?
• We have toxicity information on <2% of
chemicals in use (Acosta, 2012). What do we do
about less well-documented chemicals?

More Related Content

Similar to Monahan_Water_Diplomacy_Talk

Pre production plastics and stormwater-h2 o-gtg
Pre production plastics and stormwater-h2 o-gtgPre production plastics and stormwater-h2 o-gtg
Pre production plastics and stormwater-h2 o-gtgGreg Gearheart
 
Total Maximum Daily Load - Hawaii Status Report
Total Maximum Daily Load - Hawaii Status ReportTotal Maximum Daily Load - Hawaii Status Report
Total Maximum Daily Load - Hawaii Status Reportcorrin
 
Environmental Health Presentation
Environmental Health PresentationEnvironmental Health Presentation
Environmental Health PresentationKaitlin Zwingert
 
Environmental toxicity Dr prerok regmi 15th May 2018
Environmental toxicity Dr prerok regmi 15th May 2018Environmental toxicity Dr prerok regmi 15th May 2018
Environmental toxicity Dr prerok regmi 15th May 2018Dr. Prerok regmi
 
Lab #11 – EcotoxicologyPrelab DiscussionT.docx
Lab #11 – EcotoxicologyPrelab DiscussionT.docxLab #11 – EcotoxicologyPrelab DiscussionT.docx
Lab #11 – EcotoxicologyPrelab DiscussionT.docxcroysierkathey
 
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resources
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental ResourcesMonahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resources
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resourcesgabriellebastien
 
Superfund Home Environmental Case Study
Superfund Home Environmental Case StudySuperfund Home Environmental Case Study
Superfund Home Environmental Case StudyLana Sorrels
 
Session 2: How Unconventional Natural Gas Extraction Effects Children
Session 2: How Unconventional Natural Gas Extraction Effects ChildrenSession 2: How Unconventional Natural Gas Extraction Effects Children
Session 2: How Unconventional Natural Gas Extraction Effects ChildrenCenter for Environmental Health
 
Palm bay Utilities Annual Drinking Water Report - 2011
Palm bay Utilities Annual Drinking Water Report - 2011Palm bay Utilities Annual Drinking Water Report - 2011
Palm bay Utilities Annual Drinking Water Report - 2011Jason Yarborough
 
Fluoridation in saskatoon
Fluoridation in saskatoonFluoridation in saskatoon
Fluoridation in saskatoonsaskohc
 
Lecture 1 1 ss-3
Lecture 1 1 ss-3Lecture 1 1 ss-3
Lecture 1 1 ss-3mobb2x
 
Tracy Stamos Revised Thesis 3_15_2006
Tracy Stamos Revised Thesis 3_15_2006Tracy Stamos Revised Thesis 3_15_2006
Tracy Stamos Revised Thesis 3_15_2006Tracy Stamos
 

Similar to Monahan_Water_Diplomacy_Talk (20)

Pre production plastics and stormwater-h2 o-gtg
Pre production plastics and stormwater-h2 o-gtgPre production plastics and stormwater-h2 o-gtg
Pre production plastics and stormwater-h2 o-gtg
 
Total Maximum Daily Load - Hawaii Status Report
Total Maximum Daily Load - Hawaii Status ReportTotal Maximum Daily Load - Hawaii Status Report
Total Maximum Daily Load - Hawaii Status Report
 
Environmental Health Presentation
Environmental Health PresentationEnvironmental Health Presentation
Environmental Health Presentation
 
Environmental toxicity Dr prerok regmi 15th May 2018
Environmental toxicity Dr prerok regmi 15th May 2018Environmental toxicity Dr prerok regmi 15th May 2018
Environmental toxicity Dr prerok regmi 15th May 2018
 
Lab #11 – EcotoxicologyPrelab DiscussionT.docx
Lab #11 – EcotoxicologyPrelab DiscussionT.docxLab #11 – EcotoxicologyPrelab DiscussionT.docx
Lab #11 – EcotoxicologyPrelab DiscussionT.docx
 
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resources
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental ResourcesMonahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resources
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resources
 
Safe Water World (210)
Safe Water World (210)Safe Water World (210)
Safe Water World (210)
 
Safewater
SafewaterSafewater
Safewater
 
Grand Lake HABs
Grand Lake HABsGrand Lake HABs
Grand Lake HABs
 
Essay On Water Pollution
Essay On Water PollutionEssay On Water Pollution
Essay On Water Pollution
 
SDWF School Programs
SDWF School ProgramsSDWF School Programs
SDWF School Programs
 
Superfund Home Environmental Case Study
Superfund Home Environmental Case StudySuperfund Home Environmental Case Study
Superfund Home Environmental Case Study
 
Session 2: How Unconventional Natural Gas Extraction Effects Children
Session 2: How Unconventional Natural Gas Extraction Effects ChildrenSession 2: How Unconventional Natural Gas Extraction Effects Children
Session 2: How Unconventional Natural Gas Extraction Effects Children
 
Palm bay Utilities Annual Drinking Water Report - 2011
Palm bay Utilities Annual Drinking Water Report - 2011Palm bay Utilities Annual Drinking Water Report - 2011
Palm bay Utilities Annual Drinking Water Report - 2011
 
20060126.ppt
20060126.ppt20060126.ppt
20060126.ppt
 
MIcroplatic .pptx
MIcroplatic .pptxMIcroplatic .pptx
MIcroplatic .pptx
 
Fluoridation in saskatoon
Fluoridation in saskatoonFluoridation in saskatoon
Fluoridation in saskatoon
 
Lecture 1 1 ss-3
Lecture 1 1 ss-3Lecture 1 1 ss-3
Lecture 1 1 ss-3
 
Pollution
PollutionPollution
Pollution
 
Tracy Stamos Revised Thesis 3_15_2006
Tracy Stamos Revised Thesis 3_15_2006Tracy Stamos Revised Thesis 3_15_2006
Tracy Stamos Revised Thesis 3_15_2006
 

Monahan_Water_Diplomacy_Talk

  • 1. Is Flint Unique? The case of Hoosick Falls, NY Kyle Monahan | 3-14-2016 Water Diplomacy Colloquium
  • 2. Hoosick Falls, NY Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
  • 3. Background Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium • Biggest employer is a plastics plant • Less than 4,000 residents • Water supply contaminated with perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA)
  • 4. Why PFOA? Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium • Industry of course! • PFOA used in production of plastics, firefighting foams and Teflon© type coatings • Occurs throughout NY (Sinclair et al, 2006) C8HF15O2
  • 5. Why PFOA? Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium • You may know a similar chemical:
  • 6. Hoosick Falls, NY - Background Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium • Toxicity is “unclear” • Bio-accumulates & bio-concentrates • Piscivorous birds especially at risk (EPA, 2006) • May cause: developmental, reproductive and other systematic effects (ATSDR, 2009).
  • 7. Why Hoosick? Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium • Toxicity is “unclear” • Bio-accumulates & bio-concentrates • Piscivorous birds especially at risk (EPA, 2006) • May cause: developmental, reproductive and other systematic effects (ATSDR, 2009).
  • 8. Why Hoosick? Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium • Toxicity is “unclear” • Bio-accumulates & bio-concentrates • Piscivorous birds especially at risk (EPA, 2006) • May cause: developmental, reproductive and other systematic effects (ATSDR, 2009).
  • 9. Current Solutions? Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium • Temporary fix: activated carbon, bottled water, flushing systems
  • 10. It’s not just Flint Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
  • 11. Current Solutions? Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium It’s not just Flint But lead isn’t PFOA! Many other chemical spills around US
  • 12. It’s not just Flint Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium • How do we deal with the high level of contamination already present? • What about toxicity • We have toxicity information on <2% of chemicals in use (Acosta, 2012).
  • 13. It’s not just Flint Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium • How do we deal with the high level of contamination already present? • What about toxicity • We have toxicity information on <2% of chemicals in use (Acosta, 2012).
  • 14. It’s not just Flint Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium
  • 15. Questions: Tufts University | Water Diplomacy Colloquium • How do we deal with the high level of contamination already present in the US? • We have toxicity information on <2% of chemicals in use (Acosta, 2012). What do we do about less well-documented chemicals?

Editor's Notes

  1. View of downtown Hoosick Falls, NY
  2. Sinclair, Ewan, et al. "Occurrence of perfluoroalkyl surfactants in water, fish, and birds from New York State." Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 50.3 (2006): 398-410. Florentin, Arnaud, et al. "Impacts of two perfluorinated compounds (PFOS and PFOA) on human hepatoma cells: cytotoxicity but no genotoxicity?."International journal of hygiene and environmental health 214.6 (2011): 493-499.
  3. Sinclair, Ewan, et al. "Occurrence of perfluoroalkyl surfactants in water, fish, and birds from New York State." Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 50.3 (2006): 398-410. Florentin, Arnaud, et al. "Impacts of two perfluorinated compounds (PFOS and PFOA) on human hepatoma cells: cytotoxicity but no genotoxicity?."International journal of hygiene and environmental health 214.6 (2011): 493-499.
  4. Sources: https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2014-04/documents/factsheet_contaminant_pfos_pfoa_march2014.pdf https://www.epa.gov/aboutepa/hoosick-falls-water-contamination
  5. More information: http://www.timesunion.com/local/article/Governor-meets-with-Hoosick-Falls-officials-over-6788137.php http://www.villageofhoosickfalls.com/Water/default.html http://www.cnn.com/2016/01/30/us/new-york-hoosick-falls-water/ http://www.dec.ny.gov/press/105069.html https://www.epa.gov/aboutepa/hoosick-falls-water-contamination
  6. More information: http://www.timesunion.com/local/article/Governor-meets-with-Hoosick-Falls-officials-over-6788137.php http://www.villageofhoosickfalls.com/Water/default.html http://www.cnn.com/2016/01/30/us/new-york-hoosick-falls-water/ http://www.dec.ny.gov/press/105069.html https://www.epa.gov/aboutepa/hoosick-falls-water-contamination