Place, Housing & Opportunity: Fair Housing for Supporting Thriving Families and Communities

Kristen Cuhran
Kristen CuhranAssociate Director at Fair Housing Center of Southeast & Mid Michigan
Place, Housing & Opportunity: Fair Housing for
Supporting Thriving Families and Communities
KEYNOTE ADDRESS - 2015 FAIR HOUSING BREAKFAST
FAIR HOUSING CENTER OF SOUTHEASTERNMICHIGAN
ANN ARBOR, MI – MARCH 25TH
2015
JASON REECE
DIRECTOR OF RESEARCH, THE KIRWAN INSTITUTE FOR THE STUDY OF RACE & ETHNICITY
LECTURER, CITY & REGIONAL PLANNING PROGRAM, KNOWLTON SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE
THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY
Why Fair Housing Matters
SUPPORTING THRIVING FAMILIES & COMMUNITIES
Housing matters, place matters….
The Significance of Housing to
Child Development
 Housing stressed families
spent 30% less on food, 50%
less on clothing, and 70%
less on health care (Joint
Center for Housing Studies)
 Children are particularly
vulnerable to housing
instability, impacting health
and educational outcomes
(stress, toxin/environmental
exposure, classroom/school
instability)
 Housing instability can
potentially undermine child
development initiatives and
interventions
Place/Community Matters.
(Places of Toxic Stress)
“Point to a group of toddlers in a low-income neighborhood, and — especially if they’re boys
— they’re much more likely to end up dropping out of school, struggling in dead-end jobs and
having trouble with the law.
Something is profoundly wrong when we can point to 2-year-olds in this country and make a
plausible bet about their long-term outcomes — not based on their brains and capabilities,
but on their ZIP codes.”
- Nick Kristof, “For Obama’s Second Term, Mr. President Start Here”. New York Times. January 23, 2012
The Role of Chronic Stress & ACE’s
(Adverse Childhood Experiences)
Toxic Stress:
Areas of Youth
Gun Violence
YOUTH VICTIMS OF
GUN VIOLENCE IN
COLUMBUS, 2012 (BY
RACE)
Thriving Neighborhoods = Thriving Children
Struggling neighborhoods = Struggling Children
Opportunity structures are vital to combating
the impact of poverty,creating strong
neighborhoods and an environment in which
children can become successful adults.
Neighborhood conditions and childhood development are intricately intertwined
Scope of the Challenge
SUPPORTING THRIVING FAMILIES & COMMUNITIES
Continued Challenges:
Disinvestment & Unhealthy Neighborhoods
Continued Challenges: Exclusion
Washtenaw Co. FHEA Data
Overall Opportunity (quintiles)
Very High [71.3 - 93.4]
High [62.7 - 71.3]
Moderate [54.2 - 62.6]
Low [45.1 - 54.1]
Very Low [16.3 - 45.0]
HUD’s FHEA
Opportunity Index:
Relative to Washtenaw
County, Michigan Block
Groups
The Geography of Opportunity
School Quality & Assisted
Housing in SE Michigan
Continued Challenges:
Dimensions of Affordability
Who isn’t served by the housing market?
Population at125% of the poverty in the U.S.
Nearly 1 in 3
children
1 out of 3 African
Americans,
Latinos and
Native Americans
1 in 3 disabled
1 in 4
immigrants
Place, Housing & Opportunity: Fair Housing for Supporting Thriving Families and Communities
Continued Challenges:
The Ghost of History
Baltimore: Passes First Racial Zoning Ordinance
in 1910/1911
(Used Public Health Language as Justification)
 "Blacks should be
quarantinedin isolated
slums in order to reduce the
incidents of civil
disturbance, to prevent the
spread of communicable
disease into the nearby
White neighborhoods, and
to protect property values
among the White majority."
 Baltimore Mayor Bary Mahool,
1910
Opportunity
SUPPORTING THRIVING FAMILIES & COMMUNITIES
A New Family Portrait – Population Change by Race.
Source: Figure from the PolicyLink Equity Atlas
Recognition of the
Challenge and the Stakes
Quote from “Housing Affordability and Economic Equity –
Analysis,Washtenaw County, MI” Office of Community and
Economic DevelopmentWashtenaw County
Investing in Places & Assuring Housing
Choice in Areas of Opportunity
Where Do We Go
From Here?
 Raising awareness of the critical
need for fair housing to support an
economically vibrant community
 Identifying more resources to
support fair housing
 Building community will to work
together (leveraging resources and
supportivepartnerships) to support
fair housing
 Supporting a policy framework
which assures access to opportunity
for all
Innovation: Housing as a Health
Intervention
 Public health stakeholders are looking toward housing as a critical “social
determinant” linked to health problems
 We can anticipate more projects involving health practitioners and stakeholders to
support housing as a health intervention
Housing rehabilitation as part of the Nationwide Childrens Hospital
Healthy Neighborhoods, Healthy Families Program
1 of 23

Recommended

Intro to Marginalized Communities for Medical Students by
Intro to Marginalized Communities for Medical StudentsIntro to Marginalized Communities for Medical Students
Intro to Marginalized Communities for Medical Studentsnatalielovesey
1.2K views36 slides
Gender issues in agricultural services by
Gender issues in agricultural servicesGender issues in agricultural services
Gender issues in agricultural servicesGarimaGupta229
3.1K views15 slides
Marginalized populations group presentation by
Marginalized populations group  presentationMarginalized populations group  presentation
Marginalized populations group presentationmroe589
934 views12 slides
Poverty: The Growing Wealth Divide by
Poverty: The Growing Wealth DividePoverty: The Growing Wealth Divide
Poverty: The Growing Wealth DivideJoshua Goh
649 views6 slides
Building Stronger Communities for Better Health: Moving from Science to Polic... by
Building Stronger Communities for Better Health: Moving from Science to Polic...Building Stronger Communities for Better Health: Moving from Science to Polic...
Building Stronger Communities for Better Health: Moving from Science to Polic...VDH, Office of Minority Health and Public Health Policy
422 views20 slides

More Related Content

What's hot

Effectiveness of Poverty Alleviation Projects at the Upazila Level in Bangladesh by
Effectiveness of Poverty Alleviation Projects at the Upazila Level in BangladeshEffectiveness of Poverty Alleviation Projects at the Upazila Level in Bangladesh
Effectiveness of Poverty Alleviation Projects at the Upazila Level in BangladeshAhsan Aziz Sarkar
151 views32 slides
Women, Poverty & Welfare by
Women, Poverty & WelfareWomen, Poverty & Welfare
Women, Poverty & WelfareCharles Franklin
1.3K views16 slides
Zero Hunger Partnership: From Service to Systemic Change by
Zero Hunger Partnership: From Service to Systemic ChangeZero Hunger Partnership: From Service to Systemic Change
Zero Hunger Partnership: From Service to Systemic ChangeBonner Foundation
325 views18 slides
World Population And Poverty by
World Population And PovertyWorld Population And Poverty
World Population And PovertyRegimantas Urbanas
1.8K views9 slides
Women and the sustainable management of environment by
Women and the sustainable management of environmentWomen and the sustainable management of environment
Women and the sustainable management of environmentTasadduq Hussain
262 views4 slides
Poverty Workshop 2009 by
Poverty Workshop 2009Poverty Workshop 2009
Poverty Workshop 2009sadierynmiller
649 views21 slides

What's hot(20)

Effectiveness of Poverty Alleviation Projects at the Upazila Level in Bangladesh by Ahsan Aziz Sarkar
Effectiveness of Poverty Alleviation Projects at the Upazila Level in BangladeshEffectiveness of Poverty Alleviation Projects at the Upazila Level in Bangladesh
Effectiveness of Poverty Alleviation Projects at the Upazila Level in Bangladesh
Ahsan Aziz Sarkar151 views
Zero Hunger Partnership: From Service to Systemic Change by Bonner Foundation
Zero Hunger Partnership: From Service to Systemic ChangeZero Hunger Partnership: From Service to Systemic Change
Zero Hunger Partnership: From Service to Systemic Change
Bonner Foundation325 views
Women and the sustainable management of environment by Tasadduq Hussain
Women and the sustainable management of environmentWomen and the sustainable management of environment
Women and the sustainable management of environment
Tasadduq Hussain262 views
Gobezie UN-WOMEN Gobezie-RP-2-EGM-RW-Sep2011 by Getaneh Gobezie
Gobezie UN-WOMEN Gobezie-RP-2-EGM-RW-Sep2011Gobezie UN-WOMEN Gobezie-RP-2-EGM-RW-Sep2011
Gobezie UN-WOMEN Gobezie-RP-2-EGM-RW-Sep2011
Getaneh Gobezie430 views
Disasters and the cycle of poverty by Kayes Shimul
Disasters and the cycle of povertyDisasters and the cycle of poverty
Disasters and the cycle of poverty
Kayes Shimul624 views
Feminisation of poverty by Josna Antony
Feminisation of povertyFeminisation of poverty
Feminisation of poverty
Josna Antony7.6K views
Women’s empowerment in agriculture: Lessons from qualitative research by IFPRI Gender
Women’s empowerment in agriculture: Lessons from qualitative researchWomen’s empowerment in agriculture: Lessons from qualitative research
Women’s empowerment in agriculture: Lessons from qualitative research
IFPRI Gender238 views
Course 1 B.ED PLURALISTIC SOCIETY marginalization by Namrata Saxena
Course 1 B.ED PLURALISTIC SOCIETY  marginalizationCourse 1 B.ED PLURALISTIC SOCIETY  marginalization
Course 1 B.ED PLURALISTIC SOCIETY marginalization
Namrata Saxena3.9K views
Causes and Effects of Poverty by Lyndon Leow
Causes and Effects of PovertyCauses and Effects of Poverty
Causes and Effects of Poverty
Lyndon Leow88.9K views
Poverty and Underdevelopment by ed gbargaye
Poverty and UnderdevelopmentPoverty and Underdevelopment
Poverty and Underdevelopment
ed gbargaye2.8K views
Classroom, curriculum, and marginalization mishra by Dr Mahendra K Mishra
Classroom, curriculum, and marginalization mishraClassroom, curriculum, and marginalization mishra
Classroom, curriculum, and marginalization mishra

Similar to Place, Housing & Opportunity: Fair Housing for Supporting Thriving Families and Communities

Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun... by
Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...
Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...angela_silveira
426 views45 slides
Expanding Opportunity for All: Responding to the Situatedness of Marginalized... by
Expanding Opportunity for All: Responding to the Situatedness of Marginalized...Expanding Opportunity for All: Responding to the Situatedness of Marginalized...
Expanding Opportunity for All: Responding to the Situatedness of Marginalized...Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race and Ethnicity
878 views79 slides
Shoulder to Shoulder General Orientation by
Shoulder to Shoulder General OrientationShoulder to Shoulder General Orientation
Shoulder to Shoulder General Orientationshouldertoshoulder
387 views62 slides
Mapping Communities of Opportunity in Massachusetts by
Mapping Communities of Opportunity in Massachusetts Mapping Communities of Opportunity in Massachusetts
Mapping Communities of Opportunity in Massachusetts Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race and Ethnicity
932 views49 slides
Edu 211 contemporary issues l.1 es by
Edu 211 contemporary issues l.1  esEdu 211 contemporary issues l.1  es
Edu 211 contemporary issues l.1 esiregnieruofa
766 views60 slides
Planning for the Commonwealth’s Economic Rebound by
Planning for the Commonwealth’s Economic Rebound Planning for the Commonwealth’s Economic Rebound
Planning for the Commonwealth’s Economic Rebound Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race and Ethnicity
370 views44 slides

Similar to Place, Housing & Opportunity: Fair Housing for Supporting Thriving Families and Communities(20)

Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun... by angela_silveira
Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...
Learning and Development: Preventing Generational Poverty | Economic opportun...
angela_silveira426 views
Edu 211 contemporary issues l.1 es by iregnieruofa
Edu 211 contemporary issues l.1  esEdu 211 contemporary issues l.1  es
Edu 211 contemporary issues l.1 es
iregnieruofa766 views
Socioeconomic Stratification 2021-22.pdf by ThomasHorton27
Socioeconomic Stratification 2021-22.pdfSocioeconomic Stratification 2021-22.pdf
Socioeconomic Stratification 2021-22.pdf
ThomasHorton279 views
OIEA_futures_inst_demo_poverty_education_gap_8.18.15_vers7.0 by Daniel James OHanlon
OIEA_futures_inst_demo_poverty_education_gap_8.18.15_vers7.0OIEA_futures_inst_demo_poverty_education_gap_8.18.15_vers7.0
OIEA_futures_inst_demo_poverty_education_gap_8.18.15_vers7.0
CONTEMPOBARY INDIA AND EDUCATION - UNIT 5 - (B.Ed. 1 YEAR -1 SEMESTER) by Dhanalakshmi733993
CONTEMPOBARY INDIA AND EDUCATION - UNIT 5 - (B.Ed. 1 YEAR -1 SEMESTER)CONTEMPOBARY INDIA AND EDUCATION - UNIT 5 - (B.Ed. 1 YEAR -1 SEMESTER)
CONTEMPOBARY INDIA AND EDUCATION - UNIT 5 - (B.Ed. 1 YEAR -1 SEMESTER)
A place-conscious approach can strengthen integrated strategies in poor neigh... by Jonathan Dunnemann
A place-conscious approach can strengthen integrated strategies in poor neigh...A place-conscious approach can strengthen integrated strategies in poor neigh...
A place-conscious approach can strengthen integrated strategies in poor neigh...
Jonathan Dunnemann3.4K views
Best_Community_and_Organization_Report by Jerry Best
Best_Community_and_Organization_ReportBest_Community_and_Organization_Report
Best_Community_and_Organization_Report
Jerry Best244 views
Ppt race and ethnic variations revised by Anna Montes
Ppt race and ethnic variations revisedPpt race and ethnic variations revised
Ppt race and ethnic variations revised
Anna Montes1.5K views
Cause And Effect Essay On Poverty by Missy Willis
Cause And Effect Essay On PovertyCause And Effect Essay On Poverty
Cause And Effect Essay On Poverty
Missy Willis23 views
Malcolm Potts Crisis in the Sahel: Where Population and Climate Change Are Co... by LIDC
Malcolm Potts Crisis in the Sahel: Where Population and Climate Change Are Co...Malcolm Potts Crisis in the Sahel: Where Population and Climate Change Are Co...
Malcolm Potts Crisis in the Sahel: Where Population and Climate Change Are Co...
LIDC1.4K views
Aetna Presentation Social Determinants of Latino Health by Danny Santibanez
Aetna Presentation Social Determinants of Latino HealthAetna Presentation Social Determinants of Latino Health
Aetna Presentation Social Determinants of Latino Health
Danny Santibanez1.3K views

Recently uploaded

Contributi L. 3/2019 by
Contributi L. 3/2019Contributi L. 3/2019
Contributi L. 3/2019Partito democratico
60 views256 slides
IEA EnergyEfficiency Report 2023 by
IEA EnergyEfficiency Report 2023IEA EnergyEfficiency Report 2023
IEA EnergyEfficiency Report 2023Energy for One World
11 views126 slides
CCVS AGM - Volunteer Cambs .pdf by
CCVS AGM - Volunteer Cambs .pdfCCVS AGM - Volunteer Cambs .pdf
CCVS AGM - Volunteer Cambs .pdfCambridge Council for Voluntary Service
5 views14 slides
Monitoring and Evaluation Plan (Theory of change, results framework, Logframe... by
Monitoring and Evaluation Plan (Theory of change, results framework, Logframe...Monitoring and Evaluation Plan (Theory of change, results framework, Logframe...
Monitoring and Evaluation Plan (Theory of change, results framework, Logframe...Scoffy Wangang
5 views58 slides
East godavari_art63.pdf by
East godavari_art63.pdfEast godavari_art63.pdf
East godavari_art63.pdfnarsireddynannuri1
6 views2 slides
COP 28 GHANA DELEGATES.docx by
COP 28 GHANA DELEGATES.docxCOP 28 GHANA DELEGATES.docx
COP 28 GHANA DELEGATES.docxKweku Zurek
6.6K views23 slides

Recently uploaded(20)

Monitoring and Evaluation Plan (Theory of change, results framework, Logframe... by Scoffy Wangang
Monitoring and Evaluation Plan (Theory of change, results framework, Logframe...Monitoring and Evaluation Plan (Theory of change, results framework, Logframe...
Monitoring and Evaluation Plan (Theory of change, results framework, Logframe...
Scoffy Wangang5 views
COP 28 GHANA DELEGATES.docx by Kweku Zurek
COP 28 GHANA DELEGATES.docxCOP 28 GHANA DELEGATES.docx
COP 28 GHANA DELEGATES.docx
Kweku Zurek6.6K views
MMF Newsletter Februar 2022.pdf by mmpcofficial
MMF Newsletter Februar 2022.pdfMMF Newsletter Februar 2022.pdf
MMF Newsletter Februar 2022.pdf
mmpcofficial7 views
COP28: Example of Formation of Negotiated Texts: Global StockTake by Energy for One World
COP28: Example of  Formation of Negotiated Texts: Global StockTakeCOP28: Example of  Formation of Negotiated Texts: Global StockTake
COP28: Example of Formation of Negotiated Texts: Global StockTake
Food for Elderly homeless by SERUDS INDIA
Food for Elderly homelessFood for Elderly homeless
Food for Elderly homeless
SERUDS INDIA10 views
Case study of Gokarna Multi-village scheme, Kumta, Karnataka_IIM-B_2023.pdf by India Water Portal
Case study of Gokarna Multi-village scheme, Kumta, Karnataka_IIM-B_2023.pdfCase study of Gokarna Multi-village scheme, Kumta, Karnataka_IIM-B_2023.pdf
Case study of Gokarna Multi-village scheme, Kumta, Karnataka_IIM-B_2023.pdf
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level - A... by OECD CFE
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level  - A...Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level  - A...
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level - A...
OECD CFE7 views
WCAG 2.2 - An Overview of the New Accessibility Guidelines.pptx by AbilityNet
WCAG 2.2 - An Overview of the New Accessibility Guidelines.pptxWCAG 2.2 - An Overview of the New Accessibility Guidelines.pptx
WCAG 2.2 - An Overview of the New Accessibility Guidelines.pptx
AbilityNet72 views
Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS... by India Water Portal
Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS...Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS...
Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS...
Cover Letter for Canada VISITOR visa.pdf by Ariful Saimon
Cover Letter for Canada VISITOR visa.pdfCover Letter for Canada VISITOR visa.pdf
Cover Letter for Canada VISITOR visa.pdf
Ariful Saimon8 views
Managing drinking water infrastructure in West Bengal Gram Panchayats_Sujata ... by India Water Portal
Managing drinking water infrastructure in West Bengal Gram Panchayats_Sujata ...Managing drinking water infrastructure in West Bengal Gram Panchayats_Sujata ...
Managing drinking water infrastructure in West Bengal Gram Panchayats_Sujata ...
The National Security Framework of Spain by Miguel A. Amutio
The National Security Framework of SpainThe National Security Framework of Spain
The National Security Framework of Spain
Miguel A. Amutio33 views

Place, Housing & Opportunity: Fair Housing for Supporting Thriving Families and Communities

  • 1. Place, Housing & Opportunity: Fair Housing for Supporting Thriving Families and Communities KEYNOTE ADDRESS - 2015 FAIR HOUSING BREAKFAST FAIR HOUSING CENTER OF SOUTHEASTERNMICHIGAN ANN ARBOR, MI – MARCH 25TH 2015 JASON REECE DIRECTOR OF RESEARCH, THE KIRWAN INSTITUTE FOR THE STUDY OF RACE & ETHNICITY LECTURER, CITY & REGIONAL PLANNING PROGRAM, KNOWLTON SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY
  • 2. Why Fair Housing Matters SUPPORTING THRIVING FAMILIES & COMMUNITIES
  • 4. The Significance of Housing to Child Development  Housing stressed families spent 30% less on food, 50% less on clothing, and 70% less on health care (Joint Center for Housing Studies)  Children are particularly vulnerable to housing instability, impacting health and educational outcomes (stress, toxin/environmental exposure, classroom/school instability)  Housing instability can potentially undermine child development initiatives and interventions
  • 5. Place/Community Matters. (Places of Toxic Stress) “Point to a group of toddlers in a low-income neighborhood, and — especially if they’re boys — they’re much more likely to end up dropping out of school, struggling in dead-end jobs and having trouble with the law. Something is profoundly wrong when we can point to 2-year-olds in this country and make a plausible bet about their long-term outcomes — not based on their brains and capabilities, but on their ZIP codes.” - Nick Kristof, “For Obama’s Second Term, Mr. President Start Here”. New York Times. January 23, 2012
  • 6. The Role of Chronic Stress & ACE’s (Adverse Childhood Experiences)
  • 7. Toxic Stress: Areas of Youth Gun Violence YOUTH VICTIMS OF GUN VIOLENCE IN COLUMBUS, 2012 (BY RACE)
  • 8. Thriving Neighborhoods = Thriving Children Struggling neighborhoods = Struggling Children Opportunity structures are vital to combating the impact of poverty,creating strong neighborhoods and an environment in which children can become successful adults. Neighborhood conditions and childhood development are intricately intertwined
  • 9. Scope of the Challenge SUPPORTING THRIVING FAMILIES & COMMUNITIES
  • 10. Continued Challenges: Disinvestment & Unhealthy Neighborhoods
  • 12. Washtenaw Co. FHEA Data Overall Opportunity (quintiles) Very High [71.3 - 93.4] High [62.7 - 71.3] Moderate [54.2 - 62.6] Low [45.1 - 54.1] Very Low [16.3 - 45.0] HUD’s FHEA Opportunity Index: Relative to Washtenaw County, Michigan Block Groups The Geography of Opportunity
  • 13. School Quality & Assisted Housing in SE Michigan
  • 14. Continued Challenges: Dimensions of Affordability Who isn’t served by the housing market? Population at125% of the poverty in the U.S. Nearly 1 in 3 children 1 out of 3 African Americans, Latinos and Native Americans 1 in 3 disabled 1 in 4 immigrants
  • 17. Baltimore: Passes First Racial Zoning Ordinance in 1910/1911 (Used Public Health Language as Justification)  "Blacks should be quarantinedin isolated slums in order to reduce the incidents of civil disturbance, to prevent the spread of communicable disease into the nearby White neighborhoods, and to protect property values among the White majority."  Baltimore Mayor Bary Mahool, 1910
  • 19. A New Family Portrait – Population Change by Race. Source: Figure from the PolicyLink Equity Atlas
  • 20. Recognition of the Challenge and the Stakes Quote from “Housing Affordability and Economic Equity – Analysis,Washtenaw County, MI” Office of Community and Economic DevelopmentWashtenaw County
  • 21. Investing in Places & Assuring Housing Choice in Areas of Opportunity
  • 22. Where Do We Go From Here?  Raising awareness of the critical need for fair housing to support an economically vibrant community  Identifying more resources to support fair housing  Building community will to work together (leveraging resources and supportivepartnerships) to support fair housing  Supporting a policy framework which assures access to opportunity for all
  • 23. Innovation: Housing as a Health Intervention  Public health stakeholders are looking toward housing as a critical “social determinant” linked to health problems  We can anticipate more projects involving health practitioners and stakeholders to support housing as a health intervention Housing rehabilitation as part of the Nationwide Childrens Hospital Healthy Neighborhoods, Healthy Families Program