2. Three ideas to take away
Community newspaper organizations
will become extinct
Community host organizations
will be the new species
Community hosting works
3. Change radically or become extinct
Media use changing
Consumers want to do more than browse our offerings
They want to share their events, ideas and solutions.
They want multiple sources, not only ours
They want to filter on their terms, not ours
Businesses want to do more than display their slogans
They understand the limited value of banners and buttons
They understand they have to compete with service in virtual
space the same as they do in real space
They want to establish authority, be sought and found when
needs arise
4. Change radically or become extinct
Barriers to entry lowering
New efficiencies
Web browser rather than web press
Sophisticated tools from open source and open architecture
Networking to learn quickly
New services
New players, uninhibited by legacy, rapidly distinguish themselves as
exciting choice
Instantaneous news, uninhibited by print circulation
Pro-Am integration, uninhibited by legacy brand integrity
New revenue
Don’t need legacy large-advertiser relationships
New quality
Technology, rather than staff reduction, reduces costs leaving quality
high
5. Community Host: the new species
Suppliers
Suppliers ofof
Controlled Content
Controlled Content
Hosts
Hosts ofof
Aggregated
content
Aggregated
content
Tomorrow
Pros, Ams
Non Profits, For Profits
Today
Pros
Share theirShare their
events, Ideas, solutionevents, Ideas, solution
6. Community Host: the new species
Gathering
Gathering
Audiences
Audiences
Gathering
Gathering
Seekers
Seekers
Tomorrow
Answers
Solutions
Today
Entertainment
Access multiple sources,Access multiple sources,
not just oursnot just ours
7. Community Host: the new species
Producing
Producing
Performances
Performances
Organizing
Organizing
Trade Shows
Trade Shows
Tomorrow
Learn from pros
Share with peers
Shop with exhibitors
Today
Entertained by pros
Filter on their terms,Filter on their terms,
not oursnot ours
8. Community Host: the new species
Stakeholders
Their Site
Advertising through serving
Providing answers to questions
Unfiltered access
Their Content
The CommunityThe Community
Hosting BusinessHosting Business
9. Community Host: the new species
Community News Company
Community Host Company
13. ““These are the guys who saved myThese are the guys who saved my
business. I tripled my luncheonbusiness. I tripled my luncheon
servings after three weeks ofservings after three weeks of
bizOffers”bizOffers”
Bricks owner Kate Miller shouting across the restaurant asBricks owner Kate Miller shouting across the restaurant as
VillageSoup COO Ron Belyea walked through her doorVillageSoup COO Ron Belyea walked through her door
Making money online
17. Community hosting market
Legacy weekly newspaper markets
30,000 to 40,000 population centers
Urban neighborhoods
Suburban villages
Exurban towns
120,000 population service centers
Three to five high school districts
Yellow page directory
9,000 to 12,000 business listings
18. Community hosting features
Instantaneous, exclusively local news in weekly
print markets
Revenue from non-print participants
Docs, lawyers, trades
Individual real estate and auto sales staff
Small retail, dining, arts, entertainment
Unfettered, unfiltered voice to all
Making social networking and map mashups
relevant
19. Community hosting works
From event producer to trade show producer
Online ad revenue exceeding $450,000 in 2007 (in a market
of 80,000 residents)
5% of 6,000 local businesses currently participating;
excellent growth opportunities ahead
75% of users, 10+ visits per month
33% of users, 200+ visits per month
One Boston suburban daily: 7% more than 10 times, 0% more
than 200 times
Achieving more than 20% of revenue from online when
industry only achieving 3% to 5%.
20. Community hosting works
VillageSoup is a disruptor
Currently first in circulation in one of our markets
One legacy down 38% from 2004
The other legacy down 71% from 2004
Currently second in circulation in our other market
One legacy down 34% from 2004
The other legacy down 34% from 2004
Award winning web site
Locally 54% of those surveyed visit theSoup at least once daily, only
5% visit legacy competitor’s news sites daily
Typically over 10,000 unique visitors daily in market with 80,000
residents
Spikes whenever weather threatens, sirens blare, municipal debate,
family tragedy or celebration
21. Likely disruptors
Anyone not constrained by
Brand protection
Legacy practices
An aversion to putting feet on the ground
Regional Dailies
Traditional shopper, TMC
Local ISP
Entrepreneurs
22. Become your own disruptor
VillageSoupVillageSoup
CommonCommon
Exclusive license to
VillageSoup Branding
Share technology and
infrastructure
Share best practices and
new opportunities
23. Three ideas to take away
Community newspaper organizations
will become extinct
Community host organizations
will be the new species
Community hosting works
24. VillageSoup Common
We invite you to learn more
www.villagesoup.com
richard@villagesoup.com
207 594 5351
Editor's Notes
Eleven year experiment, creating places where neighbors grow together, learning the news and information that effects the community, sharing the events and ideas that unite the community and shopping the goods and services that sustain the community
It is time for radical change, not incremental change. Yahoo consortiums aren't going to cut it.
As we think about how best to change, it is critical to focus on why in the 1950's the Internet was created.
DARPA scientists were looking for a way to work around the vast bureaucracy of the DOD. They needed a way to seek answers and share ideas scientist to scientist. So, in our case, we set out to create a place that community members could seek answers and share ideas member to member, unfettered by the bureaucracy of our company.
Legacy monopolies are vulnerable. Reporter generated news and information remains essential to the life of the community. But lower barriers, new tools, new cultures makes it dramatically easier for new players to do it.
Create a place for all - Pros remain central but must be comfortable next to ams and interacting with ams, including advertisers
Remember DARPA, many to many, unfettered, unfiltered
Think about what you do when going to a trade show… you learn, share, seek
You are creating a place for these activities in your community. You are hosting the community, going beyond running the show
Three key components: Their content, their site, serving not getting attention
Assumes and consumes the news & information business – a new role in the community
Many different players
Many different roles
From dozens of markets with millions of customers, to millions of markets with dozens of customers.
$19.95 per week for bizMembership
No-fee auction participation, sales price credited to account
Free classifieds with upgrades
Journalist images for sale, commission
Community box office
$25 per year for each real estate data base slot
Bricks pays $19.95 per week, $1,000 per year for freedom to post offers like this, unfettered, unfiltered as frequently as they desire
Feet over the threshold, not clicks on a button
bizMembership includes enhanced listing totally controlled by owner
Our reporters take their own photos and get a percentage on each sale.
Exclusively local listings available on our Main Street location.
Managed by broker. Unfettered unfiltered
There are 10,000 such markets in this country.
Brooklyn, pop 3 million, 99 weeklies
Businesses serve 3 to 4 weekly markets
Like Google, ebay, Craig’s List, many small players paying small amounts.
Businesses competing with service rather than slogans
Network with friends, org members, staff members
Creating loyalty – the new metric
How many of your sites have 33% of users coming more than 7 times a day?
The regional dailies are the ones hurting the most and thus the ones most likely to come into weekly markets. But they better be prepared to be in the hosting business.
With the help of an $885,000 Knight News Challenge Grant, we are engaging in a series of beta tests of a new platform and a new membership organization called VillageSoup Common.
Already have Hamptons, Indianapolis suburbs, Alberta Province Canada, Alabama Coast signed up.
Empowering weeklies to survive and enhance community life.
From News to Hosts
Creating places for neighbors to grow together:
Learning…
Sharing…
Shopping…
If you wish to become your own disruptor of your own business
or you wish to be a disruptor of someone else's business
please contact us.