Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Messner2011

ISOJ 2011

  • Login to see the comments

  • Be the first to like this

Messner2011

  1. 1. Shoveling tweets: An analysis of theShoveling tweets: An analysis of the microblogging engagement ofmicroblogging engagement of traditional news organizationstraditional news organizations Marcus Messner Maureen Linke Asriel Eford School of Mass Communications  Virginia Commonwealth University International Symposium on Online Journalism  April 1, 2011
  2. 2. RationaleRationale Online social networks and social bookmarking allow traditional news media to increase Web traffic Promote news content (hyperlinks) Breaking news coverage Building and engaging community Goal of study was to explore the adoption rate of Twitter by traditional news media in the U.S.
  3. 3. Rise of TwitterRise of Twitter 5-year anniversary: 200 million users 7th most popular website in U.S. 11% of Internet users every day International impact in news events Citizen journalists vs. traditional journalists Traditional news media buzz Social bookmarking
  4. 4. Research QuestionsResearch Questions RQ1: Adoption of social bookmarking for Twitter? RQ2: Difference in adoption of social bookmarking for Twitter and other social networking sites? RQ3: Difference among traditional news media in use of social bookmarking? RQ4: Traditional news media use of Twitter? RQ5: Difference among traditional news media in use of Twitter?
  5. 5. MethodologyMethodology Two-study approach Social bookmarking Twitter use Social bookmarking Sample: Top 99 newspapers and top 100 TV stations in the United States March 25-26, 2009 & August 1-2, 2010 Analysis of lead story by bookmarking tools Analysis of Twitter accounts and followers
  6. 6. MethodologyMethodology Twitter use Analysis of newspapers and TV stations with Twitter accounts: 180 in 2009, 198 in 2010 April 4-5, 2009 & August 1-2, 2010 Analysis of tweets - Number of tweets (2009: 1568; 2010: 1112) - News value - Hyperlinks (internal/external)
  7. 7. Results: BookmarkingResults: Bookmarking RQ1: Adoption of social bookmarking for Twitter? 2009: 36.7% (n=73) 2010: 91.7% (n=182)
  8. 8. Results: BookmarkingResults: Bookmarking RQ2: Difference in adoption of social bookmarking for Twitter and other social networking sites? 2009/2010: 100% (n=199) E-Mail 2009: 96.5% (n=192) Social bookmarking 2010: 98.5% (n=196) Social bookmarking 2009: Ø 16 tools 2010: Ø 110 tools
  9. 9. Results: BookmarkingResults: Bookmarking RQ2: Difference in adoption of social bookmarking for Twitter and other social networking sites? Facebook MySpace Twitter 2009 83.9% (n=167) 38.2% (n=76) 36.7% (n=73) 2010 97.5% (n=194) 59.8% (n=119) 91.5% (n=182)
  10. 10. Results: BookmarkingResults: Bookmarking RQ3: Difference among traditional news media in use of social bookmarking? Television: More tools in 2010 2009 Facebook MySpace Twitter Newspaper 86.9% (n=86) 41.4 % (n=41) 44.4% (n=44) Television 81.0% (n=81) 35.0% (n=35) 29.0% (n=29) Total 83.9% (n=167) 38.2% (n=76) 36.7% (n=73) 2010 Facebook MySpace Twitter Newspaper 94.9% (n=94) 52.5% (n=52) 88.9% (n=88) Television 100% (n=100) 67.0% (n=67) 94.0% (n=94) Total 97.5% (n=194) 59.8% (n=119) 91.5% (n=182)
  11. 11. Results: Twitter UseResults: Twitter Use RQ4: Traditional news media use of Twitter? 2009: 90.5% (n=180) have accounts 2010: 99.5% (n=198) have accounts 2009: Ø 8.7 daily tweets (max: 110) 2010: Ø 5.6 daily tweets (max: 96) 2009: 34.4% (n=62) did not tweet 2010: 26.3% (n=52) did not tweet
  12. 12. Results: Twitter UseResults: Twitter Use RQ4: Traditional news media use of Twitter? 2009: 94.3% (n=1478) tweets news related, 5.7% (n=90) personal 2010: 96.5% (n=1073) tweets news related, 3.5% (n=39) personal
  13. 13. Results: Twitter UseResults: Twitter Use RQ4: Traditional news media use of Twitter? 2009: 93% (n=1458) of tweets had hyperlinks 2010: 95.5% (n=1062) of tweets had hyperlinks 2009: 98.5% (n=1438) internal links 2010: 99.3% (n=1055) internal links 13
  14. 14. Results: Twitter UseResults: Twitter Use RQ5: Difference among traditional news media in use of Twitter? Similar trends for adoption of Twitter: Very similar trends for news value of tweets, hyperlinks 2010: Television increased number of tweets 2009 2010 Newspapers 90.9% (n=90) 100% (n=99) Television 90.0% (n=90) 99.0% (n=99) Total 90.5% (n=180) 99.5% (n=198)
  15. 15. DiscussionDiscussion Twitter is fully adopted by traditional news media, but not used to its full potential Mainly used as a promotional tool with extensive internal linking Most tweets are still shovelware Little online community building and engagement Disconnect between Twitter adoption and social bookmarking availability
  16. 16. What to do?What to do? More attention needs to be paid to community building Twitter needs to be engaged as an online social network, not just another publication platform Regular engagement, even with shovelware Future research: Long-term study and Twitter use of reporters
  17. 17. QuestionsQuestions Marcus Messner Maureen Linke Asriel Eford School of Mass Communications  Virginia Commonwealth University International Symposium on Online Journalism  April 1, 2011

×