Advertisement
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?
CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?

Check these out next

Enterprise Application Integration Technologies
Enterprise Application Integration Technologies
Peter R. Egli
Integration patterns and practices for cloud and mobile computing
Integration patterns and practices for cloud and mobile computing
SHAKIL AKHTAR
7 eai-patterns
7 eai-patterns
Claudia Rosu
Enterprise Integration Patterns Revisited (again) for the Era of Big Data, In...
Enterprise Integration Patterns Revisited (again) for the Era of Big Data, In...
Kai Wähner
Need Of Enterprise Integration
Need Of Enterprise Integration
kumar gaurav
Enterprise Integration Patterns Revisited (EIP, Apache Camel, Talend ESB)
Enterprise Integration Patterns Revisited (EIP, Apache Camel, Talend ESB)
Kai Wähner
MuCon 2015 - Microservices in Integration Architecture
MuCon 2015 - Microservices in Integration Architecture
Kim Clark
Systems Integration in the Cloud Era with Apache Camel @ ApacheCon Europe 2012
Systems Integration in the Cloud Era with Apache Camel @ ApacheCon Europe 2012
Kai Wähner
1 of 80

CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?

May. 15, 2012••
Download to read offline
Technology
Business

Spoilt for Choice - Which Integration Framework to use on the Java (JVM) Platform? Apache Camel, Spring Integration, Mule ESB? Or when to use an Enterprise Service Bus (ESB) instead?

Kai Wähner
Technology Evangelist at Confluent
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Recommended

Spoilt for Choice: How to Choose the Right Enterprise Service Bus (ESB)?Spoilt for Choice: How to Choose the Right Enterprise Service Bus (ESB)?
Spoilt for Choice: How to Choose the Right Enterprise Service Bus (ESB)?Kai Wähner52.2K views•58 slides
Scandev / SDC2013 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use – A...Scandev / SDC2013 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use – A...
Scandev / SDC2013 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use – A...Kai Wähner4.4K views•79 slides
CamelOne 2012 - BPM beyond Web ServicesCamelOne 2012 - BPM beyond Web Services
CamelOne 2012 - BPM beyond Web ServicesKai Wähner6.4K views•55 slides
Choosing The Right ESBChoosing The Right ESB
Choosing The Right ESBMohammed Fazuluddin7.4K views•26 slides
ESB vs API managementESB vs API management
ESB vs API managementAdroitLogic8.8K views•31 slides
Systems Integration in the Cloud Era - API vs. Integration Framework vs. Ente...Systems Integration in the Cloud Era - API vs. Integration Framework vs. Ente...
Systems Integration in the Cloud Era - API vs. Integration Framework vs. Ente...Kai Wähner11.2K views•80 slides

More Related Content

Slideshows for you(20)

Enterprise Application Integration TechnologiesEnterprise Application Integration Technologies
Enterprise Application Integration Technologies
Peter R. Egli•21.1K views
Integration patterns and practices for cloud and mobile computingIntegration patterns and practices for cloud and mobile computing
Integration patterns and practices for cloud and mobile computing
SHAKIL AKHTAR•3.6K views
7 eai-patterns7 eai-patterns
7 eai-patterns
Claudia Rosu•17K views
Enterprise Integration Patterns Revisited (again) for the Era of Big Data, In...Enterprise Integration Patterns Revisited (again) for the Era of Big Data, In...
Enterprise Integration Patterns Revisited (again) for the Era of Big Data, In...
Kai Wähner•8.1K views
Need Of Enterprise IntegrationNeed Of Enterprise Integration
Need Of Enterprise Integration
kumar gaurav•549 views
Enterprise Integration Patterns Revisited (EIP, Apache Camel, Talend ESB)Enterprise Integration Patterns Revisited (EIP, Apache Camel, Talend ESB)
Enterprise Integration Patterns Revisited (EIP, Apache Camel, Talend ESB)
Kai Wähner•17.1K views
MuCon 2015 - Microservices in Integration ArchitectureMuCon 2015 - Microservices in Integration Architecture
MuCon 2015 - Microservices in Integration Architecture
Kim Clark•5.8K views
Systems Integration in the Cloud Era with Apache Camel @ ApacheCon Europe 2012Systems Integration in the Cloud Era with Apache Camel @ ApacheCon Europe 2012
Systems Integration in the Cloud Era with Apache Camel @ ApacheCon Europe 2012
Kai Wähner•11.1K views
Modern Enterprise integration StrategiesModern Enterprise integration Strategies
Modern Enterprise integration Strategies
Jesus Rodriguez•10.7K views
TS 4839 - Enterprise Integration Patterns in PracticeTS 4839 - Enterprise Integration Patterns in Practice
TS 4839 - Enterprise Integration Patterns in Practice
aegloff•3.7K views
Differentiating between web APIs, SOA, & integration …and why it mattersDifferentiating between web APIs, SOA, & integration …and why it matters
Differentiating between web APIs, SOA, & integration …and why it matters
Kim Clark•3.8K views
Future of Integration | MuleSoftFuture of Integration | MuleSoft
Future of Integration | MuleSoft
MuleSoft•7.7K views
WSO2Con EU 2015: Keynote - System of Systems - Building a Connected BusinessWSO2Con EU 2015: Keynote - System of Systems - Building a Connected Business
WSO2Con EU 2015: Keynote - System of Systems - Building a Connected Business
WSO2•1.4K views
Where can you use serverless?  How does it relate to APIs, integration and mi...Where can you use serverless?  How does it relate to APIs, integration and mi...
Where can you use serverless?  How does it relate to APIs, integration and mi...
Kim Clark•836 views
Building enterprise depth APIs with the IBM hybrid integration portfolioBuilding enterprise depth APIs with the IBM hybrid integration portfolio
Building enterprise depth APIs with the IBM hybrid integration portfolio
Kim Clark•797 views
Microservices = Death of the Enterprise Service Bus (ESB)?Microservices = Death of the Enterprise Service Bus (ESB)?
Microservices = Death of the Enterprise Service Bus (ESB)?
Kai Wähner•35.4K views
Microservices with MuleMicroservices with Mule
Microservices with Mule
Coforge (Erstwhile WHISHWORKS)•474 views
Application Networks: Microservices and APIs at NetflixApplication Networks: Microservices and APIs at Netflix
Application Networks: Microservices and APIs at Netflix
MuleSoft•15.5K views
What’s behind a high quality web API? Ensure your APIs are more than just a ...What’s behind a high quality web API? Ensure your APIs are more than just a ...
What’s behind a high quality web API? Ensure your APIs are more than just a ...
Kim Clark•2.2K views
Placement of BPM runtime components in an SOA environmentPlacement of BPM runtime components in an SOA environment
Placement of BPM runtime components in an SOA environment
Kim Clark•1.6K views

Similar to CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?(20)

Next Generation – Systems Integration in the Cloud Era with Apache Camel - Ja...Next Generation – Systems Integration in the Cloud Era with Apache Camel - Ja...
Next Generation – Systems Integration in the Cloud Era with Apache Camel - Ja...
Kai Wähner•4.7K views
Showdown: Integration Framework (Spring Integration, Apache Camel) vs. Enterp...Showdown: Integration Framework (Spring Integration, Apache Camel) vs. Enterp...
Showdown: Integration Framework (Spring Integration, Apache Camel) vs. Enterp...
Kai Wähner•34.2K views
Systems Integration in the NoSQL Era with Apache Camel (Neo4j, CouchDB, AWS S...Systems Integration in the NoSQL Era with Apache Camel (Neo4j, CouchDB, AWS S...
Systems Integration in the NoSQL Era with Apache Camel (Neo4j, CouchDB, AWS S...
Kai Wähner•4.9K views
Tips and tricks for optimizing windows virtual desktops final - Jeff StokesTips and tricks for optimizing windows virtual desktops final - Jeff Stokes
Tips and tricks for optimizing windows virtual desktops final - Jeff Stokes
Jeff Stokes•51 views
Cloud Done Right - PaaS is the Remedy to VM HangoverCloud Done Right - PaaS is the Remedy to VM Hangover
Cloud Done Right - PaaS is the Remedy to VM Hangover
Mohamad Afshar•801 views
Window azure v 1.1Window azure v 1.1
Window azure v 1.1
Tester 0101•375 views
Google app engine - OverviewGoogle app engine - Overview
Google app engine - Overview
Nathan Quach•2.3K views
Het Microsoft Integratie Platform – Welk model past u het beste? (Steef Jan W...Het Microsoft Integratie Platform – Welk model past u het beste? (Steef Jan W...
Het Microsoft Integratie Platform – Welk model past u het beste? (Steef Jan W...
Codit•281 views
Microservice ArchitectureMicroservice Architecture
Microservice Architecture
Dhaval Shah•430 views
Middleware 2002Middleware 2002
Middleware 2002
eaiti•629 views
S18S18
S18
TH Schee•597 views
Oracle iAS Forms to WebLogic Suite for AlescoOracle iAS Forms to WebLogic Suite for Alesco
Oracle iAS Forms to WebLogic Suite for Alesco
Fumiko Yamashita•3.5K views
Convince your boss to go Serverless at AWS User Group Tirupathi and Serverles...Convince your boss to go Serverless at AWS User Group Tirupathi and Serverles...
Convince your boss to go Serverless at AWS User Group Tirupathi and Serverles...
Vadym Kazulkin•239 views
Automating and Accelerating Application Deployments to IBM WebSphere without ...Automating and Accelerating Application Deployments to IBM WebSphere without ...
Automating and Accelerating Application Deployments to IBM WebSphere without ...
XebiaLabs•2.1K views
The Road To Event-Driven ArchitectureThe Road To Event-Driven Architecture
The Road To Event-Driven Architecture
SheenBrisals•53 views
Everware cbdi opposites attract 04-12-11Everware cbdi opposites attract 04-12-11
Everware cbdi opposites attract 04-12-11
davemayo•760 views
apidays LIVE Paris 2021 - APIs - How did we get here and where are we going n...apidays LIVE Paris 2021 - APIs - How did we get here and where are we going n...
apidays LIVE Paris 2021 - APIs - How did we get here and where are we going n...
apidays•121 views
Enterprise Architecture FrameworksEnterprise Architecture Frameworks
Enterprise Architecture Frameworks
Stephen Lahanas•58.8K views
Automated Release Pipelines with Azure DevOpsAutomated Release Pipelines with Azure DevOps
Automated Release Pipelines with Azure DevOps
ProjectCon•313 views
AWS_DevOpsAWS_DevOps
AWS_DevOps
David Chapman•475 views
Advertisement

More from Kai Wähner(20)

Apache Kafka as Data Hub for Crypto, NFT, Metaverse (Beyond the Buzz!)Apache Kafka as Data Hub for Crypto, NFT, Metaverse (Beyond the Buzz!)
Apache Kafka as Data Hub for Crypto, NFT, Metaverse (Beyond the Buzz!)
Kai Wähner•155 views
When NOT to use Apache Kafka?When NOT to use Apache Kafka?
When NOT to use Apache Kafka?
Kai Wähner•1.3K views
Kafka for Live Commerce to Transform the Retail and Shopping MetaverseKafka for Live Commerce to Transform the Retail and Shopping Metaverse
Kafka for Live Commerce to Transform the Retail and Shopping Metaverse
Kai Wähner•127 views
The Heart of the Data Mesh Beats in Real-Time with Apache KafkaThe Heart of the Data Mesh Beats in Real-Time with Apache Kafka
The Heart of the Data Mesh Beats in Real-Time with Apache Kafka
Kai Wähner•1.9K views
Apache Kafka vs. Cloud-native iPaaS Integration Platform MiddlewareApache Kafka vs. Cloud-native iPaaS Integration Platform Middleware
Apache Kafka vs. Cloud-native iPaaS Integration Platform Middleware
Kai Wähner•478 views
Data Warehouse vs. Data Lake vs. Data Streaming – Friends, Enemies, Frenemies?Data Warehouse vs. Data Lake vs. Data Streaming – Friends, Enemies, Frenemies?
Data Warehouse vs. Data Lake vs. Data Streaming – Friends, Enemies, Frenemies?
Kai Wähner•331 views
Serverless Kafka and Spark in a Multi-Cloud Lakehouse ArchitectureServerless Kafka and Spark in a Multi-Cloud Lakehouse Architecture
Serverless Kafka and Spark in a Multi-Cloud Lakehouse Architecture
Kai Wähner•1.8K views
Data Streaming with Apache Kafka in the Defence and Cybersecurity IndustryData Streaming with Apache Kafka in the Defence and Cybersecurity Industry
Data Streaming with Apache Kafka in the Defence and Cybersecurity Industry
Kai Wähner•714 views
Apache Kafka in the Healthcare IndustryApache Kafka in the Healthcare Industry
Apache Kafka in the Healthcare Industry
Kai Wähner•147 views
Apache Kafka in the Healthcare IndustryApache Kafka in the Healthcare Industry
Apache Kafka in the Healthcare Industry
Kai Wähner•2K views
Apache Kafka for Real-time Supply Chain in the Food and Retail IndustryApache Kafka for Real-time Supply Chain in the Food and Retail Industry
Apache Kafka for Real-time Supply Chain in the Food and Retail Industry
Kai Wähner•189 views
Kafka for Real-Time Replication between Edge and Hybrid CloudKafka for Real-Time Replication between Edge and Hybrid Cloud
Kafka for Real-Time Replication between Edge and Hybrid Cloud
Kai Wähner•1.4K views
Apache Kafka Landscape for Automotive and ManufacturingApache Kafka Landscape for Automotive and Manufacturing
Apache Kafka Landscape for Automotive and Manufacturing
Kai Wähner•165 views
Kappa vs Lambda Architectures and Technology ComparisonKappa vs Lambda Architectures and Technology Comparison
Kappa vs Lambda Architectures and Technology Comparison
Kai Wähner•1K views
The Top 5 Apache Kafka Use Cases and Architectures in 2022The Top 5 Apache Kafka Use Cases and Architectures in 2022
The Top 5 Apache Kafka Use Cases and Architectures in 2022
Kai Wähner•8.2K views
Event Streaming CTO Roundtable for Cloud-native Kafka ArchitecturesEvent Streaming CTO Roundtable for Cloud-native Kafka Architectures
Event Streaming CTO Roundtable for Cloud-native Kafka Architectures
Kai Wähner•324 views
Apache Kafka in the Public Sector (Government, National Security, Citizen Ser...Apache Kafka in the Public Sector (Government, National Security, Citizen Ser...
Apache Kafka in the Public Sector (Government, National Security, Citizen Ser...
Kai Wähner•338 views
Telco 4.0 - Payment and FinServ Integration for Data in Motion with 5G and Ap...Telco 4.0 - Payment and FinServ Integration for Data in Motion with 5G and Ap...
Telco 4.0 - Payment and FinServ Integration for Data in Motion with 5G and Ap...
Kai Wähner•408 views
Apache Kafka in the Transportation and LogisticsApache Kafka in the Transportation and Logistics
Apache Kafka in the Transportation and Logistics
Kai Wähner•797 views
Apache Kafka for Cybersecurity and SIEM / SOAR ModernizationApache Kafka for Cybersecurity and SIEM / SOAR Modernization
Apache Kafka for Cybersecurity and SIEM / SOAR Modernization
Kai Wähner•812 views

Recently uploaded(20)

Enterprise Conferencing Solutions PPT.pptxEnterprise Conferencing Solutions PPT.pptx
Enterprise Conferencing Solutions PPT.pptx
Suma Soft Pvt. Ltd.•0 views
Unlock the power of MLOps.pdfUnlock the power of MLOps.pdf
Unlock the power of MLOps.pdf
StephenAmell4•0 views
Future Managers with New Technology.pptxFuture Managers with New Technology.pptx
Future Managers with New Technology.pptx
Simhadri Bhavana•0 views
Python para equipos de ciberseguridad(pycones)Python para equipos de ciberseguridad(pycones)
Python para equipos de ciberseguridad(pycones)
Jose Manuel Ortega Candel•0 views
Developing Using Meta Pool in AuroraDeveloping Using Meta Pool in Aurora
Developing Using Meta Pool in Aurora
Neven6•0 views
trackingSpoofedIp.pptxtrackingSpoofedIp.pptx
trackingSpoofedIp.pptx
BincySam2•0 views
Python Operators.pptxPython Operators.pptx
Python Operators.pptx
M Vishnuvardhan Reddy•0 views
Python Strings.pptxPython Strings.pptx
Python Strings.pptx
M Vishnuvardhan Reddy•0 views
Valere Project Portfolio June 2023Valere Project Portfolio June 2023
Valere Project Portfolio June 2023
Alexander Turgeon•0 views
Accelerating Flow with Team Topologies & Friends @ Wroclaw Kanban, Lean & Cof...Accelerating Flow with Team Topologies & Friends @ Wroclaw Kanban, Lean & Cof...
Accelerating Flow with Team Topologies & Friends @ Wroclaw Kanban, Lean & Cof...
Manuel Pais•0 views
W-2-Ch-2-Intro to Power plants.pptW-2-Ch-2-Intro to Power plants.ppt
W-2-Ch-2-Intro to Power plants.ppt
vishnoo7•0 views
Tips and tricks for data science projects with Python Tips and tricks for data science projects with Python
Tips and tricks for data science projects with Python
Jose Manuel Ortega Candel•0 views
Implementing cert-manager in K8sImplementing cert-manager in K8s
Implementing cert-manager in K8s
Jose Manuel Ortega Candel•0 views
GIGALIGHT-Optical Transceiver SiPh MZ Quad Operating Point LockingGIGALIGHT-Optical Transceiver SiPh MZ Quad Operating Point Locking
GIGALIGHT-Optical Transceiver SiPh MZ Quad Operating Point Locking
Gigalight•0 views
Lists_tuples.pptxLists_tuples.pptx
Lists_tuples.pptx
M Vishnuvardhan Reddy•0 views
Cloud Forensics ToolsCloud Forensics Tools
Cloud Forensics Tools
Christopher Doman•0 views
COMPUTATIONAL ANALYSIS OF CIS-REGULATORY ELEMENTS AND ASSOCIATED TRANSCRIPTIO...COMPUTATIONAL ANALYSIS OF CIS-REGULATORY ELEMENTS AND ASSOCIATED TRANSCRIPTIO...
COMPUTATIONAL ANALYSIS OF CIS-REGULATORY ELEMENTS AND ASSOCIATED TRANSCRIPTIO...
VartikaRai17•0 views
Supply Chain AttacksSupply Chain Attacks
Supply Chain Attacks
Lionel Faleiro•0 views
AES.pptAES.ppt
AES.ppt
BincySam2•2 views
HTML_Images.pptHTML_Images.ppt
HTML_Images.ppt
jaspreetkaur908049•2 views
Advertisement

CamelOne 2012 - Spoilt for Choice: Which Integration Framework to use?

  1. Spoilt for Choice – Which Integration Framework to choose? Integration vs. Mule ESB vs. www.mwea.de Kai Wähner
  2. Kai Wähner Main Tasks Evaluation of Technologies and Products Requirements Engineering Enterprise Architecture Management Business Process Management Architecture and Development of Applications Planning and Introduction of SOA Integration of Legacy Applications Cloud Computing Consulting Contact Developing Email: kai.waehner@mwea.de Speaking Blog: www.kai-waehner.de/blog Coaching Twitter: @KaiWaehner Writing Social Networks: Xing, LinkedIn www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 2
  3. What is the Key Message? www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 3
  4. Key Messages Do not reinvent the „integration wheel“! www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 4
  5. Key Messages Do not reinvent the „integration wheel“! There are some good alternatives for Integration! www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 5
  6. Key Messages Do not reinvent the „integration wheel“! There are some good alternatives for Integration! Often an ESB is the wrong Choice! www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 6
  7. Agenda 1)  Systems Integration 2)  Integration Frameworks 3)  Spring Integration 4)  Mule ESB 5)  Apache Camel 6)  And the Winner is ... www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 7
  8. Agenda 1)  Systems Integration 2)  Integration Frameworks 3)  Spring Integration 4)  Mule ESB 5)  Apache Camel 6)  And the Winner is ... www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 8
  9. What is the Problem? Growth •  Applications •  Interfaces •  Technologies •  Products www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 9
  10. Heterogeneity www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 10
  11. Spaghetti Solutions Everybody communicates to everybody www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 11
  12. Solution: Systems Integration All Roads lead to Rome ... www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 12
  13. Alternatives for Systems Integration Enterprise Service Bus Integration (ESB) No Tool Framework Complexity of Integration Low High www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 13
  14. Alternatives for Systems Integration Enterprise Service Bus Integration (ESB) No Tool Framework Complexity of Integration Low High Spring Integration vs. Mule ESB vs. Apache Camel www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 14
  15. Agenda 1)  Systems Integration 2)  Integration Frameworks 3)  Spring Integration 4)  Mule ESB 5)  Apache Camel 6)  And the Winner is ... www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 15
  16. Wishes •  Standardized Modeling •  Efficient Realization •  Automatic Testing www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 16
  17. Enterprise Integration Patterns (EIP) www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 17
  18. Enterprise Integration Patterns (EIP) www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 18
  19. Enterprise Integration Patterns (EIP) www.mwea.de 19
  20. Relation between EIPs and Integrations Frameworks Integration vs. Mule ESB vs. implement www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 20
  21. Comparison Criteria •  Open source •  Basic concepts / architecture •  Testability •  Commercial support •  Error handling •  Monitoring •  Enterprise readiness •  Developer-centric vs. designer-centric •  Expandability •  Deployment •  Popularity •  Tool support •  Connectivity •  Domain specific language (DSL) www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 21
  22. Similarities www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 22
  23. Connectivity Integration of different Technologies www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 23
  24. Domain Specific Languages (DSL) „A domain-specific language (DSL) is a programming language or specification language dedicated to a particular problem domain, a particular problem representation technique, and / or a particular solution technique.“ Wikipedia www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 24
  25. Architecture http://java.dzone.com/articles/apache-camel-integration (Exemplarily: Apache Camel => Concepts are all the same, only different names) www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 25
  26. Deployment Standalone Application Server Web Container Spring Container OSGi Cloud www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 26
  27. Enterprise-Ready •  Maturity •  Transactions •  Concurrency •  Error handling •  Monitoring •  Testability www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 27
  28. Licensing Integration vs. Mule ESB vs. Apache License Common Public Apache License Atttribution License (CPAL) www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 28
  29. Commercial Support Integration vs. Mule ESB vs. www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 29
  30. Tool Support Integration Graph for Spring Integration Mule Studio for Mule ESB Fuse IDE for Apache Camel Talend Studio for Apache Camel www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 30
  31. Upcoming Procedure • Concepts of each Framework • Code Example • Live Demo www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 31
  32. Comparison Criteria •  Open source •  Basic concepts / architecture •  Testability •  Commercial support •  Error handling •  Monitoring •  Enterprise readiness •  Developer-centric vs. designer-centric •  Expandability •  Deployment Focus •  Popularity •  Tool support •  Connectivity •  Domain specific language (DSL) www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 32
  33. Agenda 1)  Systems Integration 2)  Integration Frameworks 3)  Spring Integration 4)  Mule ESB 5)  Apache Camel 6)  And the Winner is ... www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 33
  34. Connectivity AMQP Feed File FTP(S) GemFire HTTP TCP How to create own custom adapter? UDP JDBC JMS Mail MongoDB Redis RMI SFTP Stream Twitter Web Service XML XMPP www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 34
  35. DSLs XML (Not production-ready yet) www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 35
  36. Code Example www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 36
  37. Code Example http://blog.springsource.org/2012/03/05/introducing-spring-integration-scala-dsl/ www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 37
  38. Live Demo Spring Integration in Action www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 38
  39. Integration Graph www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 39
  40. Integration Graph Pro •  Visual Designer for Spring Integration flows •  Vice versa Editing (code generation vs. coding by hand) •  Open Source (part of Spring IDE at github) •  Simple Eclipse plugin – „Just Spring Integration“ •  Export of flow diagrams Contra •  Non-intuitive usability •  Unclear diagrams •  Immature (e.g. missing documentation, problems with code examples) www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 40
  41. Agenda 1)  Systems Integration 2)  Integration Frameworks 3)  Spring Integration 4)  Mule ESB 5)  Apache Camel 6)  And the Winner is ... www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 41
  42. Mule ESB www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 42
  43. Standalone / Web Application Deployment http://www.mulesoft.org/documentation/display/MULE3USER/Embedding+Mule+in+a+Java+Application+or+Webapp www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 43
  44. Connectivity AS400 Data Queue Amazon S3 Abdera Authorize.net Amazon SQS Atom Apple Push JCR jBPM Base64 encoded Bit.ly JDBC CICS CTG Byte arrays CMIS Jersey CXF CSV Jetty Email Encrypted JMS FTP LDAP Hibernate CyberSource Multicast HTTP/S Facebook POP3/S Legs4Mule GZIP Flickr Quartz IMAP/S Hex Strings HBase Restlet HTML/ XHTML Magento RMI Java Objects SAP Servlet SFTP SMTP/S SOAP JSON STDIO EDI TCP COBOL Copybook UDP XML VM XMPP Many more Connectors + WebSphere MQ WSDL easy to create own Connectors www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 44
  45. Connectivity Several Proprietary Connectors available, for instance: www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 45
  46. OSGi Support? „OSGi adds another complexity to building applications. [...] OSGi is a great specification for middleware vendors, but a terrible specification for the end user.“ Ross Mason, MuleSoft, November 2010 www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 46
  47. DSLs XML www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 47
  48. Code Example www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 48
  49. Live Demo Mule in Action www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 49
  50. Mule Studio www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 50
  51. Mule Studio Pro •  Visual Designer for Mule Flows •  Visual „Live Monitoring“ •  Vice versa Editing (Code generation vs. coding by hand) •  Simple Eclipse plugin – „Just Mule“ •  Intuitive GUI Contra •  Proprietary •  Subscription required for many enterprise features (such as monitoring) www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 51
  52. Agenda 1)  Systems Integration 2)  Integration Frameworks 3)  Spring Integration 4)  Mule ESB 5)  Apache Camel 6)  And the Winner is ... www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 52
  53. DSLs XML www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 53
  54. Connectivity LDAP XSLT TCP SQL SMTP JMS Netty Jetty RMI FTP Lucene JDBC EJB Twitter Bean-Validation MQ IRC JMX Quartz CXF RSS AMQP jclouds Atom AWS Akka HTTP File Many more Components + MongoDB easy to create own Components www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 54
  55. Code Example www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 55
  56. Code Example www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 56
  57. Live Demo Apache Camel in Action www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 57
  58. Tool Support Fuse IDE vs. Talend Open Studio for ESB www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 58
  59. Fuse IDE www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 59
  60. Fuse IDE Pro •  Visual Designer for Camel routes •  Visual „Live Monitoring“ (for debugging, browsing, tracing) •  Vice versa Editing (code generation vs. coding by-hand) •  Just a simple Eclipse-Plugin – „Just Camel“ •  Intuitive GUI •  Export of route diagrams •  JUnit Test Wizard (generates scaffolding for tests) Contra •  Proprietary •  Subscription required •  Only XML DSL (this is not really a contra, because only Camel offers other DSLs) www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 60
  61. Talend Open Studio for ESB www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 61
  62. Talend Open Studio for ESB Pro •  Visual Designer for Camel routes •  Visual „Live Monitoring“ •  Open Source (at github) •  Community Edition (not all features) •  Zero Coding Contra •  Zero Coding •  Only Java DSL (plus a lot of boilerplate code) •  No vice versa code editing (only code generation) •  No intuitive user interface => no simple Eclipse plugin => based on Eclipse, but it is more an own product (1GB) => full ESB only www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 62
  63. Agenda 1)  Systems Integration 2)  Integration Frameworks 3)  Spring Integration 4)  Mule ESB 5)  Apache Camel 6)  And the Winner is ... www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 63
  64. And the Winner is ... Integration Mule ESB www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 64
  65. When to use? Integration Mule ESB www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 65
  66. When to use? •  Spring Project •  „Typical“ JVM Technologies •  No additional Framework Integration Mule ESB www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 66
  67. When to use? Integration •  One of the available proprietary Connectors is required Mule ESB www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 67
  68. When to use? Integration Mule ESB •  In all other Cases www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 68
  69. Alternatives for Systems Integration Enterprise Service Bus Integration (ESB) No Tool Framework Complexity of Integration Low High www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 69
  70. Alternatives for Systems Integration Enterprise Service Bus Integration (ESB) No Tool Framework Complexity of Integration Low High Integration Connectivity Routing Transformation www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 70
  71. Alternatives for Systems Integration Enterprise Service Bus Integration (ESB) No Tool Framework Complexity of Integration Low High Spring Integration Integration vs. Connectivity Mule ESB Routing vs. Transformation Apache Camel www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 71
  72. Alternatives for Systems Integration Enterprise Service Bus Integration (ESB) No Tool Framework Complexity of Integration Low High www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 72
  73. Alternatives for Systems Integration Enterprise Service Bus Integration (ESB) No Tool Framework Complexity of Integration Low High Middleware Product Integration Integration Connectivity Business Process Management Routing Business Activity Monitoring Transformation Registry / Repository Rules Engine www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 73
  74. Alternatives for Systems Integration Enterprise Service Bus Integration (ESB) No Tool Framework Complexity of Integration Low High Middleware Product Integration Integration Connectivity Business Process Management Routing Business Activity Monitoring Transformation Registry / Repository Rules Engine www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 74
  75. Alternatives for Systems Integration Enterprise Service Bus Integration (ESB) No Tool Framework Complexity of Integration Low High Apache ServiceMix, Mule ESB, WSO2 ESB Middleware Product vs. Integration IBM Message Broker, Business Process Management IBM ESB, Oracle ESB, Business Activity Monitoring webMethods ESB Registry / Repository Rules Engine www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 75
  76. Did you get the Key Messages? www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 76
  77. Key Messages Do not reinvent the „integration wheel“! There are some good alternatives for Integration! Often an ESB is the wrong Choice! www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 77
  78. Did you get the Key Messages? www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 78
  79. Become a Part of the Open Source Community www.mwea.de Kai Wähner 15.05.2012 Seite 79
  80. Thank you for your Attention. Any Questions? Integration or Mule ESB or = Smart EAI Kai Wähner MaibornWolff et al: www.mwea.de Email: kai.waehner@mwea.de Twitter: @KaiWaehner Blog: www.kai-waehner.de/blog www.mwea.de Kai Wähner
Advertisement