Beam blank casting is a mature process born in 1968 [1]. Around 60 casters has been installed since. In this paper a thorough review of the literature on defects in beam blanks is carried out. The focus is on the formation mechanism and the solutions proposed to decrease their occurrence. Surface defects included are longitudinal cracks and transverse cracks. Internal defects are blowholes and solidification cracks. The review includes the techniques used to investigate the defects: metallographical characterizations, CFD, thermodynamical and thermomechanical modelling, etc. The measures taken have to do with changes in casting system (i.e. SEN design), mold design, secondary cooling modifications and regulation, strand support.
A review of defects in beam blank casting and the measures proposed for their elimination
1. A Review of Defects in Beam Blank
Casting and the Measures Proposed for
their Elimination
Jorge Madias (1), Cristian Genzano (1), Marco Oropeza (2), Carlos Moss (2)
(2) Gerdau Corsa, Ciudad Sahagun, Mexico
(1) metallon, San Nicolas, Argentina
3. Introduction
metallon
Consulting & training company based in San Nicolas,
Argentina
Technical assistance
Short courses
Met lab services
Library services
Gerdau Corsa Sahagun
Start-up 2015
Consteel EAF, LF, billet/bloom/beam blank caster, universal
mill
1.000.000 tpy crude steel capacity
700.000 tpy rolled products capacity
4. Introduction
Beam blank casting
Mature process, born in 1968
≈60 casters installed worldwide
Focus of the paper
Defects formation mechanism
Solutions proposed to decrease their occurrence
Changes in casting system (i.e. SEN design)
Mold design
Secondary cooling modifications and regulation
Strand support
Techniques used to investigate the defects
Metallographic characterizations
CFD, thermodynamical and thermomechanical modelling
Plant tests
5. Introduction
Three casting modes
Open casting (metering nozzles)
Semi submerged casting
(metering nozzles and funnels)
Semi submerged casting
(two or one SEN)
6. Introduction
Three casting modes: advantages and drawbacks
Casting type Advantages Drawbacks
Open casting Low cost: No need for SEN and
casting powder
High productivity: possibility of
automatic metering nozzle change
Splashing: cold drops
Reoxidation: macroinclusions, trapped
scum
Oil lubrication: Pin holes; risk of cracks
due to higher heat transfer
Al-killed steel not feasible
Semi submerged
casting
Less splashing
Less reoxidation
Less pin-holes
More control of heat transfer
Higher cost (funnel and casting powder)
Submerged
casting
No splashing: no cold drops
No reoxidation: no macroinclusions
Casting of Al-killed steels
Higher control of heat transfer (less
risk of cracking)
Higher cost (Stopper rod/ slide gate,
SEN and casting powder)
Lower productivity (limited by SEN life)
9. Introduction
Plate molds
More alternatives to manage water cooling
Slots, holes with spacer, full hole, distance between
holes, distance to hot face
More rigidity of the assembly
Stability of transverse geometry of cooling
channels
Easy achievement of different taper modes
Higher cost
10. Surface defects
Pin holes
Usual for casting with metering nozzle with oil
lubrication
May be deleterious for the final product if
Concentrated in a particular zone (“nest”)
Deep enough as to not disappear in the reheating
furnace
Visible if in the first rolling steps the materials has free
spreading (it is not contained) somewhere
Almost scale-free in the beam blank, but then in the
reheating furnace the become filled with scale
11. Surface defects
Pin holes
Moisture in oil
Moisture pick-up in oil circuit)
Too high oil rate
Inhomogeneous transverse distribution
Too thick oil slot gap (more than 0.5 mm)
Partial obstruction of oil slot gap by splashing
Sudden variations in steel mold level
Use of pulsing bomb
Lack of deoxidation
Electromagnetic stirring helps in pinhole elimination
12. Surface defects
Bleeding
As in billets, this defect occurs when small strand
breakout takes place, healing immediately, without
metal loss
Annular stress may promote bleeding
670 mm wide beam blank
Bleeding in the inner surface of the wing
14. Surface defects
Trapped scum
Typical of open casting
Due to thorough
reoxidation of the liquid
steel in contact with air
and oxidizing slag
Usually a liquid
manganese silicate, but if
a solid precipitates,
viscosity increases and
entrapment may occur
If silicon content is too
high (due to a low Mn/Si
ratio), silica precipitation
occurs,
If aluminum wire injection
in the mold is practiced,
alumina precipitation may
occur if it is excessive or
it is not in the right point
15. Surface defects
Casting powder entrapment
Similar to scum entrapment
Higher viscosity may occur in this case through
Alumina pick-up
Reduction reactions between elements in the steel
and oxides in the casting powder
Example, dissolved titanium reacting with silica in the slag
Enhanced through turbulence
Excessive electromagnetic stirring
Short SEN / funnel submersion
16. Surface defects
Network cracks
Related with high copper content in the steel
High copper scrap charge
Where gap between strand and mold becomes
large, grain size increases and if copper content is
high, network cracking may occur
Rolled H Beam, Dragon Steel Corporation
17. Surface defects
Longitudinal facial cracks
Fairly common for beam blanks
Formed in the mold
Similar to longitudinal cracks in slabs and blooms
In rolled product, its metallographic features are
Internal oxidation (as polished, no etching)
Decarburization (etching with Nital 2%)
Oxygen penetration (hot etching with alkaline sodic chromate)
Influencing factors
Chemistry of the liquid steel
Properties of the casting powder
Deviations of caster radius caused by mold oscillation
Primary cooling: Water flow rate and temperature
Secondary cooling: Water flow rate
1050 mm wide beam blank
Longitudinal crack between web and fillet
18. Surface defects
Longitudinal facial
cracks
Steel chemistry
Sulphur content
Carbon content
Peritectic
transformation needs
to be avoided
POSCO scarfed
beam blanks
corresponding to
2,000 heats
0.12 – 0.13%
carbon the more
sensible range
Stahlwerke Thüringen
C 0.08% max
19. Surface defects
Longitudinal facial cracks
Casting powder
Stahlwerke Thüringen
Low viscosity mold flux
for small beam blanks at
low speed<1 m/min)
“Soft” cooling at
meniscus level was
obtained
Lower capacity for
infiltration and lubrication
compensated by low
viscosity
JFE Steel Mitsushima
Different set of casting
conditions
Low viscosity gave place
to longitudinal cracks
(among other reasons)
20. Surface defects
Longitudinal facial cracks
Casting powder
In cold zones of the meniscus (i.e., close to the
SEN), casting powder may reach the limit of its
performance and give place to surface cracks
Entrapment of non-molten
mold flux; distorted oscillation
marks, small depression
Longitudinal facial crack in the
web, due to thermal shock by
direct contact with the mold
1050 mm wide beam blank
21. Surface defects
Longitudinal facial cracks
Casting speed
Posco experience
As the casting speed increases
Solidifying shell is thinner
Heat flow increases
Strain is larger
Result: More cracks
23. Surface defects
Longitudinal facial cracks
Secondary cooling
Extensive use of mathematical modeling
Jin Yi Iron & Steel: optimization of secondary cooling
to avoid these cracks
ANSYS for the thermo mechanical model
MATLAB for parameter optimization
Maanshan Steel: thorough modeling of secondary
cooling with the same purpose, taking into account
all the mechanisms involved in heat transfer
24. Surface defects
Longitudinal facial cracks
Summary of plant experiences
Company/Plant Year Corrective actions
JFE Steel Mizushima 1975 Decrease sulphur; increase mold flux viscosity; improve mold alignment
JFE Steel Mizushima 1981 Decrease sulphur; adequate mold flux; minimize mold misalignment; adequate
primary cooling; soft secondary cooling in first segments; better distribution of
sprays in transverse section
Stahlwerke Thüringen 1998 High basicity low viscosity casting powder
JFE Steel Fukuyama 1996 Decrease sulphur; decrease secondary cooling flow rate
Stahlwerke Thüringen 1997 C<0.08% (Mn 0.60 to ensure mechanical properties)
Posco 2002 Avoid 0.12-0.13% C; lower casting speed
Stahlwerke Thüringen 2002 Avoid 0.12% C
Jinyi Iron & Steel 2013 Lower water flow rate in all secondary cooling segments
Maanshan Steel 2014 More secondary water to fillet; less to wing ends and web center. -10% segment
1; -7% segment 2
25. Surface defects
Longitudinal facial cracks
Corrective actions
Metallurgy
Low sulphur
Avoid peritectic transformation
Mold flux
High basicity
Even heat transfer
Mold design
To avoid longitudinal cracks in the shoulder
Secondary cooling
Less water, mostly for the first segments
Better transverse distribution
26. Internal defects
Blowholes
Depending on the root
cause, they may be
concentrated in the first
heat of the sequence or
in some given heat, or
all along the sequence
Start: close to the beam
blank surface, when
there is enough gas
segregation to the
interdendritic spaces
End: when somewhere
below the meniscus, the
ferrostatic pressure is
higher than the gas
pressure
27. Internal defects
Blowholes
Excess of gases dissolved in the steel (oxygen,
nitrogen, hydrogen), enough to produce a bubble
Compromise between clogging and blowholes
28. Internal defects
Blowholes
Typical industrial cases
High oxygen
Lack of deoxidation (coordination, slag carry over)
High oxygen and nitrogen
First heat of the sequence
High hydrogen
Moisture in new lining of ladle or tundish
High nitrogen
Ladle with long treatment, when nitrogen is used for stirring
29. Internal defects
Blowholes
Dragon Steel Corp. case
Casting with metering nozzle
80 kg Al addition during tapping
40 kg CaFe to get O<10 ppm
Oxygen injection in tundish if temperature too low
Thorough study of LMF and caster variables
High moisture in tundish repair refractory material
30. Internal defects
Web central cracks
Equivalent to centerline
segregation in slabs
Not enough support length
Insufficient secondary
cooling
Bulging, and in severe
cases, an internal opening
in the web
Rolled H beam
Central segregation
Crack formation
Some countermeasures
Use of roll checker
Equipment for segment
alignment
31. Internal defects
Inner crack in wing end
May promote strand breakout
Resemble off-corner cracks in billets and slabs
32. Internal defects
Inner crack in wing end
JFE Steel Kurashiki case
Strand breakout in some heats
Improvement plan
Solution: optimization of mold taper in wing ends
Study Objective
Observation of breakout boxes Research solidification in mold; find cause
Solidification macrostructure Mechanism of formation of inner cracks in wing end
Sulphur addition test Measurement of shell thickness in normal operation
Mold temperature Estimation of heat flow in several parts of the mold
33. Internal defects
Web central cracks
JFE Steel Mitzushima
Caster 12.5 m radius,
funnel casting
400 x 460 x 120 mm
287 x 560 x 120 mm
Influence of sulphur
content and casting
speed
Solutions
Intensive spray cooling
on the web portion
Strict maintenance of
roll gap
34. Conclusions
Beam blank casting is an established process with a
50 years history
It is not free of surface and inner defects
Some of them share features with billet defects; other
has more to do with slab defects
The complex shape induce specific solidification
defects
The occurrence of defects requires carrying out
improvement plans to make them minimal
Defect characterization is important
Simulations may help to elucidate the formation
mechanism and to suggest corrective measures
35. Jorge Madias (1), Cristian Genzano (1), Marco Oropeza (2), Carlos Moss (2)
(1) metallon, San Nicolas, Argentina
(2) Gerdau Corsa, Ciudad Sahagun, Mexico