SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Download to read offline
Research Trends on Southeast Asian Sea Nomads


                               By Cynthia Chou
Research Trends on Southeast Asian Sea Nomads
By Cynthia Chou

[Dr. Cynthia Chou is associate professor in the Department of Asian Studies, Institute of
Cross-cultural and Regional Studies–Language, Religion and Society, University of
Copenhagen. She also serves as head of the Southeast Asian Studies Programme.]


                             Sea Nomads in Southeast Asia

Southeast Asia, a region encompassing an expanse of coasts and islands rich in varied
maritime resources, is known widely for its long-established maritime traditions. What is
regrettably less known is the phenomenon of sea nomadism. The history and culture of
the mobile boat-dwelling people, often known as sea nomads, dates back many centuries.
Today, they continue to traverse the waters of the archipelago and to challenge the
classical idea of citizenship that is defined within bounded territories and guaranteed by a
sovereign state. Their continued widespread distribution throughout the area bears
testament to a very different indigenous perception and mapping of the region.

Debates have broiled over the most appropriate term of reference for the boat-dwelling
mariners, variously known as “sea folk,” “sea gypsies,” “sea people,” “boat people,” “sea
roaming groups,” “maritime mobile groups,” and “sea hunters and gatherers.” These
terms have all proved lacking in scientific and ethnographic merit. In comparison, the
term “sea nomads” has steadfastly remained the term of preference by the general public,
researchers, and officials. This is not to say that the term “nomad” has not been disputed.
Opponents of this appellation maintain that it is etymologically derived from the Greek
expression nomás which means “moving around and living on pasturage.” Hence, the
argument goes, the word is irrelevant for maritime communities. Proponents of the term
nonetheless argue that contemporary anthropological usage has broadened its meaning to
include all groups of people who practice spatial mobility to enhance their well being and
survival.

Communities of sea nomads are widely regarded by other inhabitants of the area as the
orang asli of the region. This term has been translated variously as “indigenous peoples”
(Chou 1997) or as “true,” “genuine,” and “real” inhabitants (Sather 1997:17, 20).
Whichever translation one is inclined toward, the heart of the matter is that the space
which others have named “Southeast Asia,” comprising a number of bordered nation-
states, is, in contrast, a space of deep emotional and personal meaning for the sea nomads.
From the latter’s perspective, it is a space charted by the extent of their sea-faring skills
and postulated as a network of places connected by inter-related kinship ties to form what


                                                                                            1
they call tempat/tanah saya (my place or my territory). Based upon these premises, sea
nomads claim ownership of and sovereignty over this entire space, despite the
interference posed by current political borders.

The existence of early and extensive trade and seafaring networks in the region (Sather
1995) reflects the almost unhampered movement of sea nomads historically. In the past,
they were vigorously involved in symbiotic relations with the early Malay states of the
western Malay region and later with a succession of sultanates in coastal Borneo, the
southern Philippines, and eastern Indonesia (Sather 1997:329-33). In the process, they
generated great wealth by providing maritime commodities to facilitate trade, formed a
naval force to secure and protect sea lanes that were absolutely vital to the development
of maritime Southeast Asia, and served as “integrating information-carriers” connecting
subsidiary chiefs with a developing peasantry. These roles were central to the larger-scale
integration of an increasingly centralized politics that shaped and developed maritime
Southeast Asia (Benjamin 1986:16). Paradoxically, as states emerged, the sea nomads
became progressively peripheralized and impoverished. It has reached the point that they
are now defined as being on the margins of “otherness” for the culturally and politically
dominant populations of the region.

My purpose in this essay is to relate briefly the study of sea nomads to current
discussions concerning flexible citizenships, borders, and borderlands. My discussion is
based on a selection of works representative of past and present writings, including
several recent, unpublished manuscripts—all of which contribute to a more refined,
deeper, and coherent understanding of the sea nomads. Regrettably, there is still a dearth
of ethnographic studies.

Numerous widely scattered communities of sea nomads can be found all over Southeast
Asia. They consist of at least three major ethnolinguistic groups, each with their own
histories, culture, and speech patterns. They are: (a) the Moken and related Moklen of the
Mergui Archipelago of Burma, with extensions southward into the islands of southwest
Thailand (Court 1971; Hogan 1972; Ivanoff 1985); (b) the Orang Suku Laut, literally the
“Tribe of Sea People,” comprising diverse congeries of variously named groups
inhabiting the Riau-Lingga Archipelago, Batam, and the coastal waters of eastern
Sumatra and southern Johor and, until recently, Singapore (Logan 1847; Carey 1970;
Andaya 1975; Sandbukt 1982:17; Mariam Mohd. Ali 1984; Wee 1985; Chou 2003); and
(c) the Bajau Laut, the largest and most widely dispersed of these groups living in the
Sulu Archipelago of the Philippines, eastern Borneo, Sulawesi, and the islands of eastern
Indonesia (Sather 1997:2).




                                                                                             2
The sea-faring activities of the sea nomads today create an endemic sense of anxiety and
social instability in state officials. Their mobility and sense of multi-local belonging-ness
greatly strains all interpretations and conceptualizations of citizenship within bounded
territories. Until the middle of the last century, the sea nomads lived entirely afloat as
boat-dwelling fishing communities. Since then, rapid change has occurred as political
borders and boundaries have been drawn and re-drawn with the birth of new nations and
the question of citizenship.

Unexpectedly, the recent catastrophic tsunami that shook the world brought international
media attention to the sea nomads of Southeast Asia (see, for example, “The Wisdom of
the Sea,” Bangkok Post, 17 January 2005:1, 8). Unfortunately, it has also given officials
an opportunity to pressure sea nomads to become sedentary. State developmental
programs have caused an increasing number of families—willingly or unwillingly—to
erect pile-houses over the shallow bays that had previously served as spots for boat
anchorage.

                           Revisiting Past and Present Works

A mish-mash of Chinese and Arab accounts are about the only sources of material
available for our understanding of the sea nomads before 1500. By putting together the
important work of Chau Ju-kua as complied by Hirth and Rockhill (1911) with Ferrand’s
(1913) invaluable collection of Arab and Persian documentation of this region, we see
how the sea-faring lifestyle and activities of the sea nomads were hastily interpreted and
the people themselves presented as “pirates and cruel; sailors dread them” (Chau Ju-kua
1911:11).

Gaps in information on the sea nomads speckle the time chart from the sixteenth to the
eighteenth centuries. Piecing together European records of exploration, travel
commentaries, and passing comments sketchily fills the lacunae. Samples include the
following.

•   Portuguese references to the Celates or Orang Selat, sea nomads seen in the Strait of
    Malacca and the Riouw-Lingga Archipelago in the sixteenth to eighteenth century
    (Barros 1777; Pires 1944). There is also a scattered Dutch and English literature from
    this period on the sighting of sea nomads in the same area.
•   Spanish sources from the sixteenth to the nineteenth centuries focussing on the Sulu
    Seas. In particular, the Historia de las islas de Mindanao, Joló y sus adyacentes
    (1667) is a detailed and comprehensive description of the Spanish frontier by
    Francisco Combés, a clergyman with a deep interest in customs and languages.




                                                                                            3
•   Portuguese reports compiled by the missionary François Valentijn (1724-1726) on the
    eastern Bajaus at the end of the seventeenth century.
•   English reports, especially the description by English captain and explorer Thomas
    Forrest (1780; 1792) of the Bajau at the close of the eighteenth century.

The character of these writings was highly descriptive and oftentimes exaggerated. Very
much based upon personal “enquiries and conjectures” (Forrest 1780: preface), these
narratives were not necessarily based on scientific methods. From the European
perspective, the sea nomads were a novel ethnographic phenomenon. Often their habitats
remained unknown to the Europeans, who were only able to write about what they
occasionally and fleetingly observed from a distance during exploratory voyages.
Information about the sea nomads was also contingent on political changes in the
archipelago. When the Dutch displaced the Portuguese in Malacca at the dawn of the
seventeenth century, Portuguese writers shifted their focus. This is why Valentijn makes
little mention of Malacca and Sumatra in his Oud en Nieuw Oost-Indiën and, compared to
earlier Portuguese writings, hardly mentions the Celates.

From the early nineteenth to the early twentieth century, the study of sea nomads was
done mostly by colonial administrators. Contributions such as Findlayson and Raffles
(1826 in Gibson-Hill 1973:122) described the sea nomads as a “lower class of Malays.”
In 1906, a two-volume compendium of Malayan ethnography by English ethnologist
W.W. Skeat and C.O. Blagden was made available. It drew up a classification based on
putative physical anthropological distinctions among what the authors regarded as the
primitive tribes of Malaya. They incorrectly classified the Orang Suku Laut as primitive
forest nomads of the interior of Batam Island and, even more confoundingly, described
the “Orang Laut, Sambimba” as possessing no boats and fearing water. This
misinformation resulted in a distorted understanding of the boat nomad culture and
misled later writers on Malaya such as Heine-Geldern (1923), who relied on this book as
a guide to the little known sea nomads of the region.

Skeat and Blagden (1906) also wrote within a political frame of mind that almost
completely ignored the ethnographic continuum running from the mainland of Johor
through the Riouw (Riau) Islands to the east coast of Sumatra. This led them and others
to miss out on a better-informed ethnographic understanding of cultures and histories that
did not correlate with recently constructed political borders. Much of the narrative
unearthed from these early writings about the sea nomads is configured in encounters
between mobile populations in fixed localities. Observing from a distance, the writers of
this period did little to map out and understand the movements and migrations of mobile
populations. Seen in this light, their understanding of sea nomads stood in a troubled
relationship with territorial boundedness.


                                                                                         4
A long period of silence followed the colonial administrative reports. It was almost fifty
years later, in 1954, that the sea nomads were thoroughly analysed in a doctoral
dissertation by David Sopher. Initially published in 1965 as Sea Nomads: A Study Based
on the Literature of the Maritime Boat People of Southeast Asia and reprinted in 1977
with a postscript under a slightly revised title, The Sea Nomads: A Study of the Maritime
Boat People of Southeast Asia, the work has since become a classic. Based on secondary
material of published research and observations by other writers, Sopher’s study is
concerned with the cultural patterning and geography of the sea nomads. For the first
time, we have a comprehensive study based on geographical methods of the mobile boat-
dwelling people “over a very extensive area…stretching more than 2,000 miles.” Sopher
looked beyond the confines of political borders and boundaries to present an overview of
the cultural geography, migratory movements, and environmental relationships of the sea
nomads.

More systematic as well as more scientifically sound work, especially by historians and
social scientists, on the society and culture of sea nomads also appeared around the time
of Sopher’s publication. Examples of other influential works were Hans Kähler’s 1960
linguistic study, Ethnographische und linguistiche Studien über die Orang Darat, Orang
Akit, Orang Laut und Orang Utan im Riau-Archipel und auf den Inseln an der Ostküste
von Sumatra, and Nicholas Tarling’s 1963 historical study, Piracy and Politics in the
Malay World. Although scientifically better informed studies were now materializing, the
topic of boat-dwelling mariners continued to be understudied and published works
remained sporadic.

Historical studies based on sound archival research and ethnographies derived from
fieldwork and close contact with the sea nomads only began to surface in the 1970s and
thereafter. A selection of exciting books and monographs with their abbreviated titles in
chronological order follows: The People of Sulu by H. Arlo Nimmo (1972), The Kingdom
of Johor by Leonard Y. Andaya (1975), The Prince of Pirates by Carl A. Trocki (1979),
Duano Littoral Fishing by Øyvind Sandbukt (1982), A History of Malaysia by Barbara
Watson Andaya and Leonard Andaya (1982), Ideology, Identity and Change by Carol
Warren (1983), Celebrations with the Sun by Bruno Bottignolo (1995), The Bajau Laut
by Clifford Sather (1997), The Moken by Jacques Ivanoff (1997), The Sulu Zone by
James Warren (1998), Fließende Grezen. Konstruktion, Oszillation und Wandel
ethnischer Identität der Orang Suku Laut im Riau-Archipel by Lioba Lenhart (2002), and
Indonesian Sea Nomads by Cynthia Chou (2003).

Journal articles have also proliferated. Examples include Carey (1970), Chou (1995, 1997,
2004), Chou and Wee (2002), Lapian (1979), Lapian and Nagatsu (1996), Lenhart (1997,


                                                                                         5
2002), Nimmo (1970, 1986, 1990), Pelras (1972), Sandbukt (1984), Sather (1995, 1998,
1999), and Zacot (1978). The following are examples of unpublished manuscripts that are
not always easily accessible, but which provide important and up-to-date information:
Normala Manap (1983), Mariam Mohd. Ali (1984), Morrison (1994), Nagatsu (1995),
and Farwig (2002).

The above listing of books, articles, and unpublished manuscripts is but a suggestive and
not a definitive list. There are scholars whose works are of the highest quality who could
not be mentioned here. An invaluable project to compile a comprehensive bibliography
of works on the sea nomads was undertaken by the Center for Southeast Asian Studies,
Kyoto University, in the early 1990s; their findings were published in the first two issues
of the Sama Bajau Studies Newsletter (1995, 1996).

This body of work of the last forty years is of great value. Much of what has been
documented pertains to issues concerning the socialization of time, space, and identity. A
substantial amount of literature has also focussed on processes of change, modernization,
and development. This interest is due very much to the quickening and broadening
processes of economic, social, political, and technological development that have had an
impact on intercultural contact everywhere in the post-war decades. Sound research
techniques and fieldwork participation have produced more accurate and refined
ethnographic detail that integrates viewpoints and experiences both within and between
core, semi-marginal, and marginal societies.

For the first time, too, we see fundamental theoretical revisions about the prehistory and
indigenous cultural history of the region. New approaches in linguistics and anthropology,
including functionalism and structural-functionalism, Marxist and neo-Marxist
perspectives, and interpretive and postmodernist approaches, have been tried, worked on,
and debated. This has opened an understanding of the social organization and cultural
premises that structure the sea nomads’ daily life and led to new insights into identity,
social hierarchy, and stigmatization at the local, transnational, and supranational scale of
sea nomad mobility.

Two recent works can serve to illustrate some trends. The first is James Warren’s 1998
monograph, The Sulu Zone: The World Capitalist Economy and the Historical
Imagination. This text focuses on the relationship between social groups like the Sama
Laut, Iranun, Balangini Samal, and Taosug and their physical environment. It develops a
“critical understanding and discussion of historiographical methods and models in
problematizing of economic and cultural ‘border zones’ in a changing global-local
context” (9). This exciting piece of work involves “framing and re-presenting the
ethnohistory of the Sulu zone in its own terms… rather than merely as a corollary of the


                                                                                          6
history of Western [imperialist] expansion” in the region (13). Inspired by the
historiographical formulations and debates of the neo-Marxist dependency theorists,
particularly Andre Gunder Frank (1978) and Paul Baran (1957), by the World System
approach of Immanuel Wallerstein (1974), and by the theories and concepts of Latin
American economists and Annales historians, Warren demonstrates the evolution of areas
and the concept of “periphery” as “a series of intersections, encounters or ‘historical
accidents usually due to contact with foreign formations’ (Meillassoux 1972:101)”
(Warren 1998: 14-15). Second, my own forthcoming essay (2005) looks at political and
social tensions between fixed national boundaries with inflexible state requirements of
citizenship, on the one hand, and the flexible requirements of the Orang Suku Laut of
Riau, Indonesia, on the other. This essay reflects attempts in recent research to capture
and place the dynamics of sea nomads, well known for their mobility, within the wider
social science of borders, citizenship, and nation states.

                                   Closing Thoughts

Although great strides have been made in the study of sea nomads in Southeast Asia,
much more research is required. This exercise of revisiting older writings and reviewing
recent works has adumbrated potential directions that could lead to new ranges of
knowledge in the field. In addition, much of the older ethnographic record—which
narrowly looks at the organisation of sea nomads’ travel routes, their techniques for
spatial production of locality, and the often humdrum preoccupations of small scale
communities—can be reread from other points of view. These issues and ethnographic
details can be reconceived as dynamic and exciting interstices of transnational mobility
and cultural belongingness. In them we can see how the ideas of community, citizenship,
and legal rights are reconfigured, reinterpreted, and reconceptualized in the encounter
between mobile populations and nation states.

References

Andaya, Leonard Y. 1975. The Kingdom of Johor, 1641-1728. Kuala Lumpur: Oxford
  University Press.
Andaya, Barbara Watson, and Leonard Andaya. 1982. A History of Malaysia. London:
  Macmillan Press.
Baran, Paul. 1957. “The ‘Classical’ in Southeast Asia: The Present in the Past.” Journal
  of Southeast Asian Studies 26, no. 1: 75-91.
Barros, João de. 1777. Da Asia. Dos Feitos que os Portuguezes fizeram no descubrimento
  e conquista dos mares e terras do Oriente. Decade segunda, parte II. Lisbon.
Benjamin, Geoffrey. 1986. “Achievements and Gaps in Orang Asli Research.”
  Akademika 35(July): 7-46.


                                                                                       7
Bottignolo, Bruno. 1995. Celebrations with the Sun: An Overview of Religious
  Phenomena among the Badjaos. Manila: Ateneo de Manila University Press.
Carey, Iskandar. 1970. “Some Notes on the Sea Nomads of Johor.” Federation Museum
  Journal 15: 181-184.
Chau Ju-kua: His Work on the Chinese and Arab Trade in the Twelfth and Thirteenth
  Centuries, entitled Chu-fan-chï. Translated from the Chinese and annotated by
  Friedrich Hirth and W.W. Rockhill. Petersburg: Printing Office of the Imperial
  Academy of Sciences, 1911.
Chou, Cynthia. 1995. “Orang Laut Women in Riau: An Exploration of Difference and the
  Emblems of Status and Prestige.” In “Gender and the Sexes in the Indonesian
  Archipelago,” ed. Laura Summers and William D. Wilder, Indonesian Circle 67
  (November): 175-98.
——. 1997. “Contesting the Tenure of Territoriality: The Orang Suku Laut.” In “Riau in
  Transition,” eds. Cynthia Chou and Will Derks, Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land-en
  Vilkenkunde 153: 605-29.
——. 2003. Indonesian Sea Nomads: Money, Magic, and Fear of the Orang Suku Laut.
  Leiden, London and New York: International Institute for Asian Studies and
  RoutledgeCurzon.
——. 2004. “The Orang Suku Laut: Owners of or Strangers in the Riau Archipelago of
  Indonesia?” In Customary Strangers: New Perspectives on Peripatetic Peoples in the
  Middle East, Africa, and Asia, ed. Joseph C. Berland and Aparna Rao, pp. 309-328.
  Westport, CT and London: Prager.
——. 2005. “Borders and Multiple Realities: The Orang Suku Laut of Riau, Indonesia.”
  In Centring the Margin: Agency and Narrative in Southeast Asian Borderlands, ed.
  Alexander Horstmann and Reed L. Wadley. Oxford: Berghahn Books.
Chou, Cynthia and Vivienne Wee. 2002. “Tribality and Globalization: The Orang Suku
  Laut and the ‘Growth Triangle’ in a Contested Environment.” In Tribal Communities
  in the Malay World: Historical, Cultural and Social Perpectives, ed. Geoffrey
  Benjamin and Cynthia Chou, pp. 318-363. Leiden and Singapore: International
  Instittue for Asian Studies and Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.
Combes, Francisco. 1897 [1667]. Historia de las islas de Mindanao, Joló y sus
  adyacentes. Madrid: Retana W.E. and P. Pastells.
Court, Christopher. 1971. “A Fleeting Encounter with the Moken (the Sea Gypsies) in
  Southern Thailand: Some Linguistic and General Notes.” Journal of the Siam Society
  59: 83-95.
Farwig, Victoria. 2002. “A Comparison of the Environmental Awareness and Perceptions
  of the Communities of Ambuea and Sampela. The Wakatobi Marine National Park,
  Sulawesi, Indonesia.” BSc (Honours) dissertation, The University of Portsmouth,
  United Kingdom.




                                                                                   8
Ferrand, Gabriel. 1913. Relations de Voyages et textes géographiques arabes, persans et
  turks relatifs à l’Extrême-Orient du VIIIe siècles. Paris: Ernst Leroux. 2 volumes.
Findlayson, G., and Thomas Stamford Raffles. 1826. A Mission to Siam and Hue.
  London. Quoted from C.A. Gibson-Hill. 1973. “The Orang Laut of Singapore River
  and the Sampan Panjang.” Journal of the Malayan/Malaysian Branch of the Royal
  Asiatic Society 25/1: 161-75. Reprinted in 150th Anniversary of the Founding of
  Singapore. Journal of the Malayan/Malaysian Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society, pp.
  121-34.
Forrest, Thomas. 1780. A Voyage to New Guinea, and the Moluccas from Balambangan,
  2nd ed. London: G. Scott.
——. 1792. A Voyage from Calcutta to the Mergui Archipelago, Lying on the East Side
  of the Bay of Bengal. London: G. Scott.
Frank, Andre Gunder. 1978. World Accumulation, 1492-1789. London: MacMillan Press.
Heine-Geldern, Robert. 1923. “Südost Asien.” In Illustrierte Völkerkunde, Bd. II, ed.
  Georg Buschan, pp. 689-968. Stuttgart: Schrecker und Schröder.
Hogan, David. 1972. “Men of the Sea: Coastal Tribes of South Thailand’s West Coast.”
  Journal of the Siam Society 60: 205-35.
Ivanoff, Jacques. 1985. “L’épopée de Gaman: Conséquences des rapports entre
  Moken/Malais et Moken/Birmans.” ASEMI 16: 173-94.
——. 1997. Moken: Sea Gypsies of the Andaman Sea Post-war Chronicles. Bangkok:
  White Lotus.
Kähler, Hans. 1960. Ethnographische und Linguistiche Studien über die Orang Darat,
  Orang Akit, Orang Laut und Orang Utan im Riau-Archipel und auf den Inseln an du
  Ostküste von Sumatra. Berlin: Verlag von Dietrich Reimar.
Lapian, Adrain B. 1979. “Le Rôle des Orang Laut dans l’histoire de Riau.” Archipel 18:
  215-222.
Lapian, Adrain B., and Kazufumi Nagatsu. 1996. “Research on Bajau Communities:
  Maritime People in Southeast Asia.” Asian Research Trends: A Humanities and Social
  Science Review 6: 45-70.
Lenhart, Lioba. 1997. “Orang Suku Laut Ethnicity and Acculturation.” In “Riau in
  Transition,” ed. Cynthia Chou and Will Derks, Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land-en
  Vilkenkunde 153: 577-604.
——. 2002. “Orang Suku Laut Identity: The Construction of Ethnic Realities.” In Tribal
  Communities in the Malay World: Historical, Cultural and Social Perpectives, ed.
  Geoffrey Benjamin and Cynthia Chou, pp. 293-317. Leiden and Singapore:
  International Instittue for Asian Studies and Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.
Logan, J.R. 1847. “The Ethnology of the Johor Archipelago.” Journal of the Indian
  Archipelago and Eastern Asia 1: 336-40.




                                                                                     9
Mariam Mohd. Ali. 1984. “Orang Baru and Orang Lama: Ways of Being Malay in
  Singapore’s North Coast.” B.Soc.Sc. (Hons.) dissertation. National University of
  Singapore, Singapore.
Meillassoux, Claude. 1972. “From Reproduction to Production.” Economy and Society 1:
  93-105.
Morrison, Jean. 1994. “The Bajau: Gender Relations and Social Change among a Bajau
  Fishing Community in Sabah, East Malaysia.” Ph.D. thesis, University of Hull, United
  Kingdom.
Nagatsu, Kazifumi. 1995. “Sama no Gyorou Katsudou no Jittai to Kankyokan:
  Minzokukankyouron-teki Shiten kara.” Master’s thesis, Kyoto University, Japan.
Nimmo, H. Arlo. 1970. “Bajau Sex and Reproduction.” Ethnology 9, no. 3: 251-262.
——. 1972. The Sea People of Sulu: A Study of Social Change in the Philippines. San
  Francisco: Chandler Publishing.
——. 1986. “Recent Population Movements in the Sulu Archipelago: Implications to
  Sama Culture History.” Archipel 32: 25-38.
——. 1990. “The Boats of the Tawi-Tawi Bajau, Sulu Archipelago, Philippines.” Asian
  Perspectives, 29, no. 1: 51-88.
Normala Manap. 1983. “Pulau Seking: Social History and an Ethnography.” B.Soc.Sc.
  (Hons.) dissertation. National University of Singapore, Singapore.
Pelras, Christian. 1972. “Notes sur Quelques Populations Aquatiques de l’Archipel
  Nusantarien.” Archipel 3: 133-168.
Pires, Tomé. 1944. Suma Oriental: An Account of the East from the Red Sea to Japan,
  written in Melaka 1512-1515. 2 volumes. Translated by A. Cortesão. London: Hakluyt
  Society.
Sama Bajau Studies Newsletter 1 (1995). Kyoto: Center for Southeast Asian Studies.
——. 2 (1996). Kyoto: Center for Southeast Asian Studies.
Sandbukt, Øyvind. 1982. “Duano Littoral Fishing: Adaptive Strategies within a Money
  Economy.” Ph.D. thesis, University of Cambridge, United Kingdom.
——. 1984. “The Sea Nomads of Southeast Asia: New Perspectives on Ancient
  Traditions.” Annual Newsletter of the Scandinavian Institute of Asian Studies 17: 3-13.
Sather, Clifford A. 1995. “Sea Nomads and Rainforest Hunter-gatherers: Foraging
  Adaptations in the Indo-Malaysian Archipelago.” In The Austronesians: Historical and
  Comparative Perspectives, ed. Peter Bellwood, James J. Fox, and Darrell Tryon, pp.
  229-68. Canberra: Department of Anthropology, Research School of Pacific and Asian
  Studies Publication, Australian National University.
——. 1997. The Bajau Laut: Adaptation, History, and Fate in a Maritime Fishing
  Society of South-eastern Sabah. Kuala Lumpur: Oxford University Press.
——. 1998. “Sea Nomads, Ethnicity, and Otherness: The Orang Suku Laut and Malay
  Identity in the Straits of Melaka.” Suomen Antropologi 2, no. 23 (October): 20-36.




                                                                                      10
——. 1999. The Orang Laut. Academy of Social Sciences (AKASS) Heritage Paper
  Series, Occasional Paper No. 5. Penang: Academy of Social Sciences.
Skeat, Walter William, and Charles Otto Blagden. 1906. Pagan Races of the Malay
  Peninsula. 2 volumes. London: Macmillan & Co. Ltd.
Sopher, David. 1977. The Sea Nomads: A Study of the Maritime Boat People of Southeast
  Asia. Singapore: National Museum Publication. First edition, 1965.
Tarling, Nicholas. 1963. Piracy and Politics in the Malay World: A Study of British
  Imperialism in Nineteenth-century South-east Asia. Melbourne: F.W. Cheshire.
Trocki, Carl. 1979. Prince of Pirates: The Temenggongs and the Development of Johor
  and Singapore 1784-1885. Singapore: Singapore University Press.
Valentijn, François. 1724-1726. Oud en Nieuw Oost-Indiën, Vervattende een
  Naaukeurige en Uitvoerige Verhandelinge van Nederlands Mogenthevd in die
  Gewesten …in vyf deelen. Doordrecht-Amsterdam.
Wallerstein, Immanuel. 1974. The Modern World-System: Capitalist Agriculture and The
  Origins of the European World Economy in the Sixteenth Century. New York:
  Academic Press.
Warren, Carol. 1983. Ideology, Identity, and Change: The Experience of the Bajau Laut
  of East Malaysia 1969-1975. Southeast Asian Monograph Series No. 14. Townsville,
  Queensland: James Cook University of North Queensland.
Warren, James. 1998. The Sulu Zone: The World Capitalist Economy and the Historical
  Imagination. Amsterdam: VU University Press.
Wee, Vivienne. 1985. “Melayu: Hierarchies of Being in Riau.” Ph.D. thesis, Australian
  National University, Australia.
Zacot, Francois. 1978. “The Voice of the Bajo People.” In Proceedings: Second
  International Conference on Austronesian Linguistics, Vol. 1: Western Austronesian,
  Pacific Linguistics, Series C, no. 61, ed. S.A. Wurm and L. Carrington, pp. 665-78.
  Canberra: The Australian National University Research School of Pacific Studies.




                                                                                  11

More Related Content

What's hot

What's hot (11)

African culture
African cultureAfrican culture
African culture
 
I
II
I
 
2 1 africa and the bantu
2 1 africa and the bantu2 1 africa and the bantu
2 1 africa and the bantu
 
Geography Of Mesopotamia
Geography Of MesopotamiaGeography Of Mesopotamia
Geography Of Mesopotamia
 
Southern culturaleurope
Southern culturaleuropeSouthern culturaleurope
Southern culturaleurope
 
Early migrations bantu, indo europeans, austronesians
Early  migrations  bantu, indo europeans, austronesiansEarly  migrations  bantu, indo europeans, austronesians
Early migrations bantu, indo europeans, austronesians
 
Africa
AfricaAfrica
Africa
 
1.5 events in w africa
1.5 events in w africa1.5 events in w africa
1.5 events in w africa
 
Phoenicians powerpoint
Phoenicians powerpointPhoenicians powerpoint
Phoenicians powerpoint
 
Leila Egypt
Leila EgyptLeila Egypt
Leila Egypt
 
2010 intro to africa
 2010 intro to africa 2010 intro to africa
2010 intro to africa
 

Viewers also liked

Sulu @ Symfony User Group Munich
Sulu @ Symfony User Group MunichSulu @ Symfony User Group Munich
Sulu @ Symfony User Group MunichSulu
 
State formation in early maritime southeast asia
State formation in early maritime southeast asiaState formation in early maritime southeast asia
State formation in early maritime southeast asiaJewel Mercader
 
Acciaioli et al asaa 2014 paper v5 jc_Regionalism
Acciaioli et al asaa 2014 paper v5 jc_RegionalismAcciaioli et al asaa 2014 paper v5 jc_Regionalism
Acciaioli et al asaa 2014 paper v5 jc_RegionalismMuki Trenggono Wicaksono
 
Relationship with the sea
Relationship with the seaRelationship with the sea
Relationship with the seaJewel Mercader
 
Activities List, Sharing
Activities List, SharingActivities List, Sharing
Activities List, SharingHardy Alexander
 
Introduction to-programming
Introduction to-programmingIntroduction to-programming
Introduction to-programming_Inghz
 
แบบฝึกชุดที่ 4.1
แบบฝึกชุดที่ 4.1แบบฝึกชุดที่ 4.1
แบบฝึกชุดที่ 4.1nongdata nonthakote
 
Impacting student success 2013
Impacting student success 2013Impacting student success 2013
Impacting student success 2013Nancy Nelson
 
פרויקט אלכסנדר זייד בן צבי 2 כניסות
פרויקט אלכסנדר זייד בן צבי 2 כניסותפרויקט אלכסנדר זייד בן צבי 2 כניסות
פרויקט אלכסנדר זייד בן צבי 2 כניסותGilad Bdolach ???? ?????
 
Paper on Incan Gustatory Perception
Paper on Incan Gustatory PerceptionPaper on Incan Gustatory Perception
Paper on Incan Gustatory PerceptionJewel Mercader
 
The sulu zone revisited
The sulu zone revisitedThe sulu zone revisited
The sulu zone revisitedJewel Mercader
 
Maximizing learning for all learners
Maximizing learning for all learnersMaximizing learning for all learners
Maximizing learning for all learnersNancy Nelson
 
La Enseñanza. Teorías y practicas de la enseñanza.
La Enseñanza. Teorías y practicas de la enseñanza.La Enseñanza. Teorías y practicas de la enseñanza.
La Enseñanza. Teorías y practicas de la enseñanza.Jimena Jimena
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Us history
Us historyUs history
Us history
 
Sulu @ Symfony User Group Munich
Sulu @ Symfony User Group MunichSulu @ Symfony User Group Munich
Sulu @ Symfony User Group Munich
 
State formation in early maritime southeast asia
State formation in early maritime southeast asiaState formation in early maritime southeast asia
State formation in early maritime southeast asia
 
Acciaioli et al asaa 2014 paper v5 jc_Regionalism
Acciaioli et al asaa 2014 paper v5 jc_RegionalismAcciaioli et al asaa 2014 paper v5 jc_Regionalism
Acciaioli et al asaa 2014 paper v5 jc_Regionalism
 
Relationship with the sea
Relationship with the seaRelationship with the sea
Relationship with the sea
 
Literature Search
Literature SearchLiterature Search
Literature Search
 
Activities List, Sharing
Activities List, SharingActivities List, Sharing
Activities List, Sharing
 
Introduction to-programming
Introduction to-programmingIntroduction to-programming
Introduction to-programming
 
แบบฝึกชุดที่ 4.1
แบบฝึกชุดที่ 4.1แบบฝึกชุดที่ 4.1
แบบฝึกชุดที่ 4.1
 
Impacting student success 2013
Impacting student success 2013Impacting student success 2013
Impacting student success 2013
 
Sis musc-ident
Sis musc-identSis musc-ident
Sis musc-ident
 
פרויקט אלכסנדר זייד בן צבי 2 כניסות
פרויקט אלכסנדר זייד בן צבי 2 כניסותפרויקט אלכסנדר זייד בן צבי 2 כניסות
פרויקט אלכסנדר זייד בן צבי 2 כניסות
 
ชุดที่ 2
ชุดที่ 2ชุดที่ 2
ชุดที่ 2
 
H. Negm cv
H. Negm cvH. Negm cv
H. Negm cv
 
Paper on Incan Gustatory Perception
Paper on Incan Gustatory PerceptionPaper on Incan Gustatory Perception
Paper on Incan Gustatory Perception
 
Hearts, then Charts
Hearts, then ChartsHearts, then Charts
Hearts, then Charts
 
The sulu zone revisited
The sulu zone revisitedThe sulu zone revisited
The sulu zone revisited
 
Maximizing learning for all learners
Maximizing learning for all learnersMaximizing learning for all learners
Maximizing learning for all learners
 
La Enseñanza. Teorías y practicas de la enseñanza.
La Enseñanza. Teorías y practicas de la enseñanza.La Enseñanza. Teorías y practicas de la enseñanza.
La Enseñanza. Teorías y practicas de la enseñanza.
 
PGESCo C.V
PGESCo  C.VPGESCo  C.V
PGESCo C.V
 

Similar to Sea nomads in southeast asia

Treaty Rights Ignored Neocolonialism and the Makah Whale Hunt .docx
Treaty Rights Ignored Neocolonialism and the Makah Whale Hunt .docxTreaty Rights Ignored Neocolonialism and the Makah Whale Hunt .docx
Treaty Rights Ignored Neocolonialism and the Makah Whale Hunt .docxjuliennehar
 
Sama at sea and in land in indonesia
Sama at sea and in land in indonesiaSama at sea and in land in indonesia
Sama at sea and in land in indonesiaJewel Mercader
 
Defining and Studying the Modern African DiasporaAuthor.docx
Defining and Studying the Modern African DiasporaAuthor.docxDefining and Studying the Modern African DiasporaAuthor.docx
Defining and Studying the Modern African DiasporaAuthor.docxAASTHA76
 
Colonization
ColonizationColonization
Colonizationtonysafyc
 
A Complex of Seas Passages between Pacific Histories.pdf
A Complex of Seas  Passages between Pacific Histories.pdfA Complex of Seas  Passages between Pacific Histories.pdf
A Complex of Seas Passages between Pacific Histories.pdfAnna Landers
 
Ancient Greece Physical Geography Essay
Ancient Greece Physical Geography EssayAncient Greece Physical Geography Essay
Ancient Greece Physical Geography EssaySamantha Ross
 
The Destruction Of Ancient Mesopotamia
The Destruction Of Ancient MesopotamiaThe Destruction Of Ancient Mesopotamia
The Destruction Of Ancient MesopotamiaJessica Briggs
 
Ethno archaeology and early austronesian fishing strategies in near-shore env...
Ethno archaeology and early austronesian fishing strategies in near-shore env...Ethno archaeology and early austronesian fishing strategies in near-shore env...
Ethno archaeology and early austronesian fishing strategies in near-shore env...Jewel Mercader
 
The A Religious History.docx
The A Religious History.docxThe A Religious History.docx
The A Religious History.docx4934bk
 
Worlds ApartAbdulrahman AlbasariDr. Dana M. ReemesHistory .docx
Worlds ApartAbdulrahman AlbasariDr. Dana M. ReemesHistory .docxWorlds ApartAbdulrahman AlbasariDr. Dana M. ReemesHistory .docx
Worlds ApartAbdulrahman AlbasariDr. Dana M. ReemesHistory .docxambersalomon88660
 
Early China Research Paper
Early China Research PaperEarly China Research Paper
Early China Research PaperJamie Boyd
 
The Beginnings Of The Persian Empire
The Beginnings Of The Persian EmpireThe Beginnings Of The Persian Empire
The Beginnings Of The Persian EmpireCandace Daigle
 
Development And Application Of Geographic Information System
Development And Application Of Geographic Information SystemDevelopment And Application Of Geographic Information System
Development And Application Of Geographic Information SystemCecilia Lucero
 
Indigenous voyaging polynesian navigation1 overview§ portuguese
Indigenous voyaging polynesian navigation1 overview§ portuguese Indigenous voyaging polynesian navigation1 overview§ portuguese
Indigenous voyaging polynesian navigation1 overview§ portuguese ssuserd93c47
 
[Whitmore] brush and ship the southern chinese diaspora and
[Whitmore] brush and ship the southern chinese diaspora and[Whitmore] brush and ship the southern chinese diaspora and
[Whitmore] brush and ship the southern chinese diaspora andĐức Anh
 
Research Paper On Minerve
Research Paper On MinerveResearch Paper On Minerve
Research Paper On MinerveRebecca Buono
 

Similar to Sea nomads in southeast asia (20)

Treaty Rights Ignored Neocolonialism and the Makah Whale Hunt .docx
Treaty Rights Ignored Neocolonialism and the Makah Whale Hunt .docxTreaty Rights Ignored Neocolonialism and the Makah Whale Hunt .docx
Treaty Rights Ignored Neocolonialism and the Makah Whale Hunt .docx
 
Sama at sea and in land in indonesia
Sama at sea and in land in indonesiaSama at sea and in land in indonesia
Sama at sea and in land in indonesia
 
Defining and Studying the Modern African DiasporaAuthor.docx
Defining and Studying the Modern African DiasporaAuthor.docxDefining and Studying the Modern African DiasporaAuthor.docx
Defining and Studying the Modern African DiasporaAuthor.docx
 
Colonization
ColonizationColonization
Colonization
 
Vilar et al 2014 AJPA
Vilar et al 2014 AJPAVilar et al 2014 AJPA
Vilar et al 2014 AJPA
 
A Complex of Seas Passages between Pacific Histories.pdf
A Complex of Seas  Passages between Pacific Histories.pdfA Complex of Seas  Passages between Pacific Histories.pdf
A Complex of Seas Passages between Pacific Histories.pdf
 
Ancient Greece Physical Geography Essay
Ancient Greece Physical Geography EssayAncient Greece Physical Geography Essay
Ancient Greece Physical Geography Essay
 
The Destruction Of Ancient Mesopotamia
The Destruction Of Ancient MesopotamiaThe Destruction Of Ancient Mesopotamia
The Destruction Of Ancient Mesopotamia
 
The Maya and the World, An Update
The Maya and the World, An UpdateThe Maya and the World, An Update
The Maya and the World, An Update
 
Ethno archaeology and early austronesian fishing strategies in near-shore env...
Ethno archaeology and early austronesian fishing strategies in near-shore env...Ethno archaeology and early austronesian fishing strategies in near-shore env...
Ethno archaeology and early austronesian fishing strategies in near-shore env...
 
The A Religious History.docx
The A Religious History.docxThe A Religious History.docx
The A Religious History.docx
 
Worlds ApartAbdulrahman AlbasariDr. Dana M. ReemesHistory .docx
Worlds ApartAbdulrahman AlbasariDr. Dana M. ReemesHistory .docxWorlds ApartAbdulrahman AlbasariDr. Dana M. ReemesHistory .docx
Worlds ApartAbdulrahman AlbasariDr. Dana M. ReemesHistory .docx
 
Early China Research Paper
Early China Research PaperEarly China Research Paper
Early China Research Paper
 
Party In Oceania
Party In OceaniaParty In Oceania
Party In Oceania
 
The Beginnings Of The Persian Empire
The Beginnings Of The Persian EmpireThe Beginnings Of The Persian Empire
The Beginnings Of The Persian Empire
 
The Indonesian Ancestors Part 2
The Indonesian Ancestors Part 2The Indonesian Ancestors Part 2
The Indonesian Ancestors Part 2
 
Development And Application Of Geographic Information System
Development And Application Of Geographic Information SystemDevelopment And Application Of Geographic Information System
Development And Application Of Geographic Information System
 
Indigenous voyaging polynesian navigation1 overview§ portuguese
Indigenous voyaging polynesian navigation1 overview§ portuguese Indigenous voyaging polynesian navigation1 overview§ portuguese
Indigenous voyaging polynesian navigation1 overview§ portuguese
 
[Whitmore] brush and ship the southern chinese diaspora and
[Whitmore] brush and ship the southern chinese diaspora and[Whitmore] brush and ship the southern chinese diaspora and
[Whitmore] brush and ship the southern chinese diaspora and
 
Research Paper On Minerve
Research Paper On MinerveResearch Paper On Minerve
Research Paper On Minerve
 

More from Jewel Mercader

Philippine creational mythology, structural anthropology 1
Philippine creational mythology, structural anthropology 1Philippine creational mythology, structural anthropology 1
Philippine creational mythology, structural anthropology 1Jewel Mercader
 
Ethnographic Review on Sama Dilaut's Epic Silungan Baltapa
Ethnographic Review on Sama Dilaut's Epic Silungan BaltapaEthnographic Review on Sama Dilaut's Epic Silungan Baltapa
Ethnographic Review on Sama Dilaut's Epic Silungan BaltapaJewel Mercader
 
Philippine negritos by rahmann
Philippine negritos by rahmannPhilippine negritos by rahmann
Philippine negritos by rahmannJewel Mercader
 
Hunter gatherers and their neighbors from prehistory to the present by headla...
Hunter gatherers and their neighbors from prehistory to the present by headla...Hunter gatherers and their neighbors from prehistory to the present by headla...
Hunter gatherers and their neighbors from prehistory to the present by headla...Jewel Mercader
 
Illegal immigrants in sabah
Illegal immigrants in sabahIllegal immigrants in sabah
Illegal immigrants in sabahJewel Mercader
 
Conflicts resolution and leadership in the dynamics of ethnic identity
Conflicts resolution and leadership in the dynamics of ethnic identityConflicts resolution and leadership in the dynamics of ethnic identity
Conflicts resolution and leadership in the dynamics of ethnic identityJewel Mercader
 
Bajau social structure
Bajau social structureBajau social structure
Bajau social structureJewel Mercader
 
Sama bajau settlements and southern voyages
Sama bajau settlements and southern voyagesSama bajau settlements and southern voyages
Sama bajau settlements and southern voyagesJewel Mercader
 
The far eastern origin of the dravidians
The far eastern origin of the dravidiansThe far eastern origin of the dravidians
The far eastern origin of the dravidiansJewel Mercader
 
Kings and queens of england
Kings and queens of englandKings and queens of england
Kings and queens of englandJewel Mercader
 
Echo in national museum seminar report
Echo in national museum seminar reportEcho in national museum seminar report
Echo in national museum seminar reportJewel Mercader
 
Start 2012 seminar in ust
Start 2012 seminar in ustStart 2012 seminar in ust
Start 2012 seminar in ustJewel Mercader
 
Negrito Race: The Ultimate Link of Filipinos to the World
Negrito Race: The Ultimate Link of Filipinos to the WorldNegrito Race: The Ultimate Link of Filipinos to the World
Negrito Race: The Ultimate Link of Filipinos to the WorldJewel Mercader
 
A bibliography of the agta negritos of eastern luzon, philippines
A bibliography of the agta negritos of eastern luzon, philippinesA bibliography of the agta negritos of eastern luzon, philippines
A bibliography of the agta negritos of eastern luzon, philippinesJewel Mercader
 
Types of negritos in the philippine islands by bean
Types of negritos in the philippine islands by beanTypes of negritos in the philippine islands by bean
Types of negritos in the philippine islands by beanJewel Mercader
 

More from Jewel Mercader (20)

Philippine creational mythology, structural anthropology 1
Philippine creational mythology, structural anthropology 1Philippine creational mythology, structural anthropology 1
Philippine creational mythology, structural anthropology 1
 
Report on sabah claim
Report on sabah claimReport on sabah claim
Report on sabah claim
 
Ethnographic Review on Sama Dilaut's Epic Silungan Baltapa
Ethnographic Review on Sama Dilaut's Epic Silungan BaltapaEthnographic Review on Sama Dilaut's Epic Silungan Baltapa
Ethnographic Review on Sama Dilaut's Epic Silungan Baltapa
 
Philippine negritos by rahmann
Philippine negritos by rahmannPhilippine negritos by rahmann
Philippine negritos by rahmann
 
Hunter gatherers and their neighbors from prehistory to the present by headla...
Hunter gatherers and their neighbors from prehistory to the present by headla...Hunter gatherers and their neighbors from prehistory to the present by headla...
Hunter gatherers and their neighbors from prehistory to the present by headla...
 
Illegal immigrants in sabah
Illegal immigrants in sabahIllegal immigrants in sabah
Illegal immigrants in sabah
 
Conflicts resolution and leadership in the dynamics of ethnic identity
Conflicts resolution and leadership in the dynamics of ethnic identityConflicts resolution and leadership in the dynamics of ethnic identity
Conflicts resolution and leadership in the dynamics of ethnic identity
 
Bajau social structure
Bajau social structureBajau social structure
Bajau social structure
 
Maritime slavery
Maritime slaveryMaritime slavery
Maritime slavery
 
Sama bajau settlements and southern voyages
Sama bajau settlements and southern voyagesSama bajau settlements and southern voyages
Sama bajau settlements and southern voyages
 
The far eastern origin of the dravidians
The far eastern origin of the dravidiansThe far eastern origin of the dravidians
The far eastern origin of the dravidians
 
Dravidian language
Dravidian languageDravidian language
Dravidian language
 
New zealand history
New zealand historyNew zealand history
New zealand history
 
Kings and queens of england
Kings and queens of englandKings and queens of england
Kings and queens of england
 
European history
European historyEuropean history
European history
 
Echo in national museum seminar report
Echo in national museum seminar reportEcho in national museum seminar report
Echo in national museum seminar report
 
Start 2012 seminar in ust
Start 2012 seminar in ustStart 2012 seminar in ust
Start 2012 seminar in ust
 
Negrito Race: The Ultimate Link of Filipinos to the World
Negrito Race: The Ultimate Link of Filipinos to the WorldNegrito Race: The Ultimate Link of Filipinos to the World
Negrito Race: The Ultimate Link of Filipinos to the World
 
A bibliography of the agta negritos of eastern luzon, philippines
A bibliography of the agta negritos of eastern luzon, philippinesA bibliography of the agta negritos of eastern luzon, philippines
A bibliography of the agta negritos of eastern luzon, philippines
 
Types of negritos in the philippine islands by bean
Types of negritos in the philippine islands by beanTypes of negritos in the philippine islands by bean
Types of negritos in the philippine islands by bean
 

Sea nomads in southeast asia

  • 1. Research Trends on Southeast Asian Sea Nomads By Cynthia Chou
  • 2. Research Trends on Southeast Asian Sea Nomads By Cynthia Chou [Dr. Cynthia Chou is associate professor in the Department of Asian Studies, Institute of Cross-cultural and Regional Studies–Language, Religion and Society, University of Copenhagen. She also serves as head of the Southeast Asian Studies Programme.] Sea Nomads in Southeast Asia Southeast Asia, a region encompassing an expanse of coasts and islands rich in varied maritime resources, is known widely for its long-established maritime traditions. What is regrettably less known is the phenomenon of sea nomadism. The history and culture of the mobile boat-dwelling people, often known as sea nomads, dates back many centuries. Today, they continue to traverse the waters of the archipelago and to challenge the classical idea of citizenship that is defined within bounded territories and guaranteed by a sovereign state. Their continued widespread distribution throughout the area bears testament to a very different indigenous perception and mapping of the region. Debates have broiled over the most appropriate term of reference for the boat-dwelling mariners, variously known as “sea folk,” “sea gypsies,” “sea people,” “boat people,” “sea roaming groups,” “maritime mobile groups,” and “sea hunters and gatherers.” These terms have all proved lacking in scientific and ethnographic merit. In comparison, the term “sea nomads” has steadfastly remained the term of preference by the general public, researchers, and officials. This is not to say that the term “nomad” has not been disputed. Opponents of this appellation maintain that it is etymologically derived from the Greek expression nomás which means “moving around and living on pasturage.” Hence, the argument goes, the word is irrelevant for maritime communities. Proponents of the term nonetheless argue that contemporary anthropological usage has broadened its meaning to include all groups of people who practice spatial mobility to enhance their well being and survival. Communities of sea nomads are widely regarded by other inhabitants of the area as the orang asli of the region. This term has been translated variously as “indigenous peoples” (Chou 1997) or as “true,” “genuine,” and “real” inhabitants (Sather 1997:17, 20). Whichever translation one is inclined toward, the heart of the matter is that the space which others have named “Southeast Asia,” comprising a number of bordered nation- states, is, in contrast, a space of deep emotional and personal meaning for the sea nomads. From the latter’s perspective, it is a space charted by the extent of their sea-faring skills and postulated as a network of places connected by inter-related kinship ties to form what 1
  • 3. they call tempat/tanah saya (my place or my territory). Based upon these premises, sea nomads claim ownership of and sovereignty over this entire space, despite the interference posed by current political borders. The existence of early and extensive trade and seafaring networks in the region (Sather 1995) reflects the almost unhampered movement of sea nomads historically. In the past, they were vigorously involved in symbiotic relations with the early Malay states of the western Malay region and later with a succession of sultanates in coastal Borneo, the southern Philippines, and eastern Indonesia (Sather 1997:329-33). In the process, they generated great wealth by providing maritime commodities to facilitate trade, formed a naval force to secure and protect sea lanes that were absolutely vital to the development of maritime Southeast Asia, and served as “integrating information-carriers” connecting subsidiary chiefs with a developing peasantry. These roles were central to the larger-scale integration of an increasingly centralized politics that shaped and developed maritime Southeast Asia (Benjamin 1986:16). Paradoxically, as states emerged, the sea nomads became progressively peripheralized and impoverished. It has reached the point that they are now defined as being on the margins of “otherness” for the culturally and politically dominant populations of the region. My purpose in this essay is to relate briefly the study of sea nomads to current discussions concerning flexible citizenships, borders, and borderlands. My discussion is based on a selection of works representative of past and present writings, including several recent, unpublished manuscripts—all of which contribute to a more refined, deeper, and coherent understanding of the sea nomads. Regrettably, there is still a dearth of ethnographic studies. Numerous widely scattered communities of sea nomads can be found all over Southeast Asia. They consist of at least three major ethnolinguistic groups, each with their own histories, culture, and speech patterns. They are: (a) the Moken and related Moklen of the Mergui Archipelago of Burma, with extensions southward into the islands of southwest Thailand (Court 1971; Hogan 1972; Ivanoff 1985); (b) the Orang Suku Laut, literally the “Tribe of Sea People,” comprising diverse congeries of variously named groups inhabiting the Riau-Lingga Archipelago, Batam, and the coastal waters of eastern Sumatra and southern Johor and, until recently, Singapore (Logan 1847; Carey 1970; Andaya 1975; Sandbukt 1982:17; Mariam Mohd. Ali 1984; Wee 1985; Chou 2003); and (c) the Bajau Laut, the largest and most widely dispersed of these groups living in the Sulu Archipelago of the Philippines, eastern Borneo, Sulawesi, and the islands of eastern Indonesia (Sather 1997:2). 2
  • 4. The sea-faring activities of the sea nomads today create an endemic sense of anxiety and social instability in state officials. Their mobility and sense of multi-local belonging-ness greatly strains all interpretations and conceptualizations of citizenship within bounded territories. Until the middle of the last century, the sea nomads lived entirely afloat as boat-dwelling fishing communities. Since then, rapid change has occurred as political borders and boundaries have been drawn and re-drawn with the birth of new nations and the question of citizenship. Unexpectedly, the recent catastrophic tsunami that shook the world brought international media attention to the sea nomads of Southeast Asia (see, for example, “The Wisdom of the Sea,” Bangkok Post, 17 January 2005:1, 8). Unfortunately, it has also given officials an opportunity to pressure sea nomads to become sedentary. State developmental programs have caused an increasing number of families—willingly or unwillingly—to erect pile-houses over the shallow bays that had previously served as spots for boat anchorage. Revisiting Past and Present Works A mish-mash of Chinese and Arab accounts are about the only sources of material available for our understanding of the sea nomads before 1500. By putting together the important work of Chau Ju-kua as complied by Hirth and Rockhill (1911) with Ferrand’s (1913) invaluable collection of Arab and Persian documentation of this region, we see how the sea-faring lifestyle and activities of the sea nomads were hastily interpreted and the people themselves presented as “pirates and cruel; sailors dread them” (Chau Ju-kua 1911:11). Gaps in information on the sea nomads speckle the time chart from the sixteenth to the eighteenth centuries. Piecing together European records of exploration, travel commentaries, and passing comments sketchily fills the lacunae. Samples include the following. • Portuguese references to the Celates or Orang Selat, sea nomads seen in the Strait of Malacca and the Riouw-Lingga Archipelago in the sixteenth to eighteenth century (Barros 1777; Pires 1944). There is also a scattered Dutch and English literature from this period on the sighting of sea nomads in the same area. • Spanish sources from the sixteenth to the nineteenth centuries focussing on the Sulu Seas. In particular, the Historia de las islas de Mindanao, Joló y sus adyacentes (1667) is a detailed and comprehensive description of the Spanish frontier by Francisco Combés, a clergyman with a deep interest in customs and languages. 3
  • 5. Portuguese reports compiled by the missionary François Valentijn (1724-1726) on the eastern Bajaus at the end of the seventeenth century. • English reports, especially the description by English captain and explorer Thomas Forrest (1780; 1792) of the Bajau at the close of the eighteenth century. The character of these writings was highly descriptive and oftentimes exaggerated. Very much based upon personal “enquiries and conjectures” (Forrest 1780: preface), these narratives were not necessarily based on scientific methods. From the European perspective, the sea nomads were a novel ethnographic phenomenon. Often their habitats remained unknown to the Europeans, who were only able to write about what they occasionally and fleetingly observed from a distance during exploratory voyages. Information about the sea nomads was also contingent on political changes in the archipelago. When the Dutch displaced the Portuguese in Malacca at the dawn of the seventeenth century, Portuguese writers shifted their focus. This is why Valentijn makes little mention of Malacca and Sumatra in his Oud en Nieuw Oost-Indiën and, compared to earlier Portuguese writings, hardly mentions the Celates. From the early nineteenth to the early twentieth century, the study of sea nomads was done mostly by colonial administrators. Contributions such as Findlayson and Raffles (1826 in Gibson-Hill 1973:122) described the sea nomads as a “lower class of Malays.” In 1906, a two-volume compendium of Malayan ethnography by English ethnologist W.W. Skeat and C.O. Blagden was made available. It drew up a classification based on putative physical anthropological distinctions among what the authors regarded as the primitive tribes of Malaya. They incorrectly classified the Orang Suku Laut as primitive forest nomads of the interior of Batam Island and, even more confoundingly, described the “Orang Laut, Sambimba” as possessing no boats and fearing water. This misinformation resulted in a distorted understanding of the boat nomad culture and misled later writers on Malaya such as Heine-Geldern (1923), who relied on this book as a guide to the little known sea nomads of the region. Skeat and Blagden (1906) also wrote within a political frame of mind that almost completely ignored the ethnographic continuum running from the mainland of Johor through the Riouw (Riau) Islands to the east coast of Sumatra. This led them and others to miss out on a better-informed ethnographic understanding of cultures and histories that did not correlate with recently constructed political borders. Much of the narrative unearthed from these early writings about the sea nomads is configured in encounters between mobile populations in fixed localities. Observing from a distance, the writers of this period did little to map out and understand the movements and migrations of mobile populations. Seen in this light, their understanding of sea nomads stood in a troubled relationship with territorial boundedness. 4
  • 6. A long period of silence followed the colonial administrative reports. It was almost fifty years later, in 1954, that the sea nomads were thoroughly analysed in a doctoral dissertation by David Sopher. Initially published in 1965 as Sea Nomads: A Study Based on the Literature of the Maritime Boat People of Southeast Asia and reprinted in 1977 with a postscript under a slightly revised title, The Sea Nomads: A Study of the Maritime Boat People of Southeast Asia, the work has since become a classic. Based on secondary material of published research and observations by other writers, Sopher’s study is concerned with the cultural patterning and geography of the sea nomads. For the first time, we have a comprehensive study based on geographical methods of the mobile boat- dwelling people “over a very extensive area…stretching more than 2,000 miles.” Sopher looked beyond the confines of political borders and boundaries to present an overview of the cultural geography, migratory movements, and environmental relationships of the sea nomads. More systematic as well as more scientifically sound work, especially by historians and social scientists, on the society and culture of sea nomads also appeared around the time of Sopher’s publication. Examples of other influential works were Hans Kähler’s 1960 linguistic study, Ethnographische und linguistiche Studien über die Orang Darat, Orang Akit, Orang Laut und Orang Utan im Riau-Archipel und auf den Inseln an der Ostküste von Sumatra, and Nicholas Tarling’s 1963 historical study, Piracy and Politics in the Malay World. Although scientifically better informed studies were now materializing, the topic of boat-dwelling mariners continued to be understudied and published works remained sporadic. Historical studies based on sound archival research and ethnographies derived from fieldwork and close contact with the sea nomads only began to surface in the 1970s and thereafter. A selection of exciting books and monographs with their abbreviated titles in chronological order follows: The People of Sulu by H. Arlo Nimmo (1972), The Kingdom of Johor by Leonard Y. Andaya (1975), The Prince of Pirates by Carl A. Trocki (1979), Duano Littoral Fishing by Øyvind Sandbukt (1982), A History of Malaysia by Barbara Watson Andaya and Leonard Andaya (1982), Ideology, Identity and Change by Carol Warren (1983), Celebrations with the Sun by Bruno Bottignolo (1995), The Bajau Laut by Clifford Sather (1997), The Moken by Jacques Ivanoff (1997), The Sulu Zone by James Warren (1998), Fließende Grezen. Konstruktion, Oszillation und Wandel ethnischer Identität der Orang Suku Laut im Riau-Archipel by Lioba Lenhart (2002), and Indonesian Sea Nomads by Cynthia Chou (2003). Journal articles have also proliferated. Examples include Carey (1970), Chou (1995, 1997, 2004), Chou and Wee (2002), Lapian (1979), Lapian and Nagatsu (1996), Lenhart (1997, 5
  • 7. 2002), Nimmo (1970, 1986, 1990), Pelras (1972), Sandbukt (1984), Sather (1995, 1998, 1999), and Zacot (1978). The following are examples of unpublished manuscripts that are not always easily accessible, but which provide important and up-to-date information: Normala Manap (1983), Mariam Mohd. Ali (1984), Morrison (1994), Nagatsu (1995), and Farwig (2002). The above listing of books, articles, and unpublished manuscripts is but a suggestive and not a definitive list. There are scholars whose works are of the highest quality who could not be mentioned here. An invaluable project to compile a comprehensive bibliography of works on the sea nomads was undertaken by the Center for Southeast Asian Studies, Kyoto University, in the early 1990s; their findings were published in the first two issues of the Sama Bajau Studies Newsletter (1995, 1996). This body of work of the last forty years is of great value. Much of what has been documented pertains to issues concerning the socialization of time, space, and identity. A substantial amount of literature has also focussed on processes of change, modernization, and development. This interest is due very much to the quickening and broadening processes of economic, social, political, and technological development that have had an impact on intercultural contact everywhere in the post-war decades. Sound research techniques and fieldwork participation have produced more accurate and refined ethnographic detail that integrates viewpoints and experiences both within and between core, semi-marginal, and marginal societies. For the first time, too, we see fundamental theoretical revisions about the prehistory and indigenous cultural history of the region. New approaches in linguistics and anthropology, including functionalism and structural-functionalism, Marxist and neo-Marxist perspectives, and interpretive and postmodernist approaches, have been tried, worked on, and debated. This has opened an understanding of the social organization and cultural premises that structure the sea nomads’ daily life and led to new insights into identity, social hierarchy, and stigmatization at the local, transnational, and supranational scale of sea nomad mobility. Two recent works can serve to illustrate some trends. The first is James Warren’s 1998 monograph, The Sulu Zone: The World Capitalist Economy and the Historical Imagination. This text focuses on the relationship between social groups like the Sama Laut, Iranun, Balangini Samal, and Taosug and their physical environment. It develops a “critical understanding and discussion of historiographical methods and models in problematizing of economic and cultural ‘border zones’ in a changing global-local context” (9). This exciting piece of work involves “framing and re-presenting the ethnohistory of the Sulu zone in its own terms… rather than merely as a corollary of the 6
  • 8. history of Western [imperialist] expansion” in the region (13). Inspired by the historiographical formulations and debates of the neo-Marxist dependency theorists, particularly Andre Gunder Frank (1978) and Paul Baran (1957), by the World System approach of Immanuel Wallerstein (1974), and by the theories and concepts of Latin American economists and Annales historians, Warren demonstrates the evolution of areas and the concept of “periphery” as “a series of intersections, encounters or ‘historical accidents usually due to contact with foreign formations’ (Meillassoux 1972:101)” (Warren 1998: 14-15). Second, my own forthcoming essay (2005) looks at political and social tensions between fixed national boundaries with inflexible state requirements of citizenship, on the one hand, and the flexible requirements of the Orang Suku Laut of Riau, Indonesia, on the other. This essay reflects attempts in recent research to capture and place the dynamics of sea nomads, well known for their mobility, within the wider social science of borders, citizenship, and nation states. Closing Thoughts Although great strides have been made in the study of sea nomads in Southeast Asia, much more research is required. This exercise of revisiting older writings and reviewing recent works has adumbrated potential directions that could lead to new ranges of knowledge in the field. In addition, much of the older ethnographic record—which narrowly looks at the organisation of sea nomads’ travel routes, their techniques for spatial production of locality, and the often humdrum preoccupations of small scale communities—can be reread from other points of view. These issues and ethnographic details can be reconceived as dynamic and exciting interstices of transnational mobility and cultural belongingness. In them we can see how the ideas of community, citizenship, and legal rights are reconfigured, reinterpreted, and reconceptualized in the encounter between mobile populations and nation states. References Andaya, Leonard Y. 1975. The Kingdom of Johor, 1641-1728. Kuala Lumpur: Oxford University Press. Andaya, Barbara Watson, and Leonard Andaya. 1982. A History of Malaysia. London: Macmillan Press. Baran, Paul. 1957. “The ‘Classical’ in Southeast Asia: The Present in the Past.” Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 26, no. 1: 75-91. Barros, João de. 1777. Da Asia. Dos Feitos que os Portuguezes fizeram no descubrimento e conquista dos mares e terras do Oriente. Decade segunda, parte II. Lisbon. Benjamin, Geoffrey. 1986. “Achievements and Gaps in Orang Asli Research.” Akademika 35(July): 7-46. 7
  • 9. Bottignolo, Bruno. 1995. Celebrations with the Sun: An Overview of Religious Phenomena among the Badjaos. Manila: Ateneo de Manila University Press. Carey, Iskandar. 1970. “Some Notes on the Sea Nomads of Johor.” Federation Museum Journal 15: 181-184. Chau Ju-kua: His Work on the Chinese and Arab Trade in the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centuries, entitled Chu-fan-chï. Translated from the Chinese and annotated by Friedrich Hirth and W.W. Rockhill. Petersburg: Printing Office of the Imperial Academy of Sciences, 1911. Chou, Cynthia. 1995. “Orang Laut Women in Riau: An Exploration of Difference and the Emblems of Status and Prestige.” In “Gender and the Sexes in the Indonesian Archipelago,” ed. Laura Summers and William D. Wilder, Indonesian Circle 67 (November): 175-98. ——. 1997. “Contesting the Tenure of Territoriality: The Orang Suku Laut.” In “Riau in Transition,” eds. Cynthia Chou and Will Derks, Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land-en Vilkenkunde 153: 605-29. ——. 2003. Indonesian Sea Nomads: Money, Magic, and Fear of the Orang Suku Laut. Leiden, London and New York: International Institute for Asian Studies and RoutledgeCurzon. ——. 2004. “The Orang Suku Laut: Owners of or Strangers in the Riau Archipelago of Indonesia?” In Customary Strangers: New Perspectives on Peripatetic Peoples in the Middle East, Africa, and Asia, ed. Joseph C. Berland and Aparna Rao, pp. 309-328. Westport, CT and London: Prager. ——. 2005. “Borders and Multiple Realities: The Orang Suku Laut of Riau, Indonesia.” In Centring the Margin: Agency and Narrative in Southeast Asian Borderlands, ed. Alexander Horstmann and Reed L. Wadley. Oxford: Berghahn Books. Chou, Cynthia and Vivienne Wee. 2002. “Tribality and Globalization: The Orang Suku Laut and the ‘Growth Triangle’ in a Contested Environment.” In Tribal Communities in the Malay World: Historical, Cultural and Social Perpectives, ed. Geoffrey Benjamin and Cynthia Chou, pp. 318-363. Leiden and Singapore: International Instittue for Asian Studies and Institute of Southeast Asian Studies. Combes, Francisco. 1897 [1667]. Historia de las islas de Mindanao, Joló y sus adyacentes. Madrid: Retana W.E. and P. Pastells. Court, Christopher. 1971. “A Fleeting Encounter with the Moken (the Sea Gypsies) in Southern Thailand: Some Linguistic and General Notes.” Journal of the Siam Society 59: 83-95. Farwig, Victoria. 2002. “A Comparison of the Environmental Awareness and Perceptions of the Communities of Ambuea and Sampela. The Wakatobi Marine National Park, Sulawesi, Indonesia.” BSc (Honours) dissertation, The University of Portsmouth, United Kingdom. 8
  • 10. Ferrand, Gabriel. 1913. Relations de Voyages et textes géographiques arabes, persans et turks relatifs à l’Extrême-Orient du VIIIe siècles. Paris: Ernst Leroux. 2 volumes. Findlayson, G., and Thomas Stamford Raffles. 1826. A Mission to Siam and Hue. London. Quoted from C.A. Gibson-Hill. 1973. “The Orang Laut of Singapore River and the Sampan Panjang.” Journal of the Malayan/Malaysian Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society 25/1: 161-75. Reprinted in 150th Anniversary of the Founding of Singapore. Journal of the Malayan/Malaysian Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society, pp. 121-34. Forrest, Thomas. 1780. A Voyage to New Guinea, and the Moluccas from Balambangan, 2nd ed. London: G. Scott. ——. 1792. A Voyage from Calcutta to the Mergui Archipelago, Lying on the East Side of the Bay of Bengal. London: G. Scott. Frank, Andre Gunder. 1978. World Accumulation, 1492-1789. London: MacMillan Press. Heine-Geldern, Robert. 1923. “Südost Asien.” In Illustrierte Völkerkunde, Bd. II, ed. Georg Buschan, pp. 689-968. Stuttgart: Schrecker und Schröder. Hogan, David. 1972. “Men of the Sea: Coastal Tribes of South Thailand’s West Coast.” Journal of the Siam Society 60: 205-35. Ivanoff, Jacques. 1985. “L’épopée de Gaman: Conséquences des rapports entre Moken/Malais et Moken/Birmans.” ASEMI 16: 173-94. ——. 1997. Moken: Sea Gypsies of the Andaman Sea Post-war Chronicles. Bangkok: White Lotus. Kähler, Hans. 1960. Ethnographische und Linguistiche Studien über die Orang Darat, Orang Akit, Orang Laut und Orang Utan im Riau-Archipel und auf den Inseln an du Ostküste von Sumatra. Berlin: Verlag von Dietrich Reimar. Lapian, Adrain B. 1979. “Le Rôle des Orang Laut dans l’histoire de Riau.” Archipel 18: 215-222. Lapian, Adrain B., and Kazufumi Nagatsu. 1996. “Research on Bajau Communities: Maritime People in Southeast Asia.” Asian Research Trends: A Humanities and Social Science Review 6: 45-70. Lenhart, Lioba. 1997. “Orang Suku Laut Ethnicity and Acculturation.” In “Riau in Transition,” ed. Cynthia Chou and Will Derks, Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land-en Vilkenkunde 153: 577-604. ——. 2002. “Orang Suku Laut Identity: The Construction of Ethnic Realities.” In Tribal Communities in the Malay World: Historical, Cultural and Social Perpectives, ed. Geoffrey Benjamin and Cynthia Chou, pp. 293-317. Leiden and Singapore: International Instittue for Asian Studies and Institute of Southeast Asian Studies. Logan, J.R. 1847. “The Ethnology of the Johor Archipelago.” Journal of the Indian Archipelago and Eastern Asia 1: 336-40. 9
  • 11. Mariam Mohd. Ali. 1984. “Orang Baru and Orang Lama: Ways of Being Malay in Singapore’s North Coast.” B.Soc.Sc. (Hons.) dissertation. National University of Singapore, Singapore. Meillassoux, Claude. 1972. “From Reproduction to Production.” Economy and Society 1: 93-105. Morrison, Jean. 1994. “The Bajau: Gender Relations and Social Change among a Bajau Fishing Community in Sabah, East Malaysia.” Ph.D. thesis, University of Hull, United Kingdom. Nagatsu, Kazifumi. 1995. “Sama no Gyorou Katsudou no Jittai to Kankyokan: Minzokukankyouron-teki Shiten kara.” Master’s thesis, Kyoto University, Japan. Nimmo, H. Arlo. 1970. “Bajau Sex and Reproduction.” Ethnology 9, no. 3: 251-262. ——. 1972. The Sea People of Sulu: A Study of Social Change in the Philippines. San Francisco: Chandler Publishing. ——. 1986. “Recent Population Movements in the Sulu Archipelago: Implications to Sama Culture History.” Archipel 32: 25-38. ——. 1990. “The Boats of the Tawi-Tawi Bajau, Sulu Archipelago, Philippines.” Asian Perspectives, 29, no. 1: 51-88. Normala Manap. 1983. “Pulau Seking: Social History and an Ethnography.” B.Soc.Sc. (Hons.) dissertation. National University of Singapore, Singapore. Pelras, Christian. 1972. “Notes sur Quelques Populations Aquatiques de l’Archipel Nusantarien.” Archipel 3: 133-168. Pires, Tomé. 1944. Suma Oriental: An Account of the East from the Red Sea to Japan, written in Melaka 1512-1515. 2 volumes. Translated by A. Cortesão. London: Hakluyt Society. Sama Bajau Studies Newsletter 1 (1995). Kyoto: Center for Southeast Asian Studies. ——. 2 (1996). Kyoto: Center for Southeast Asian Studies. Sandbukt, Øyvind. 1982. “Duano Littoral Fishing: Adaptive Strategies within a Money Economy.” Ph.D. thesis, University of Cambridge, United Kingdom. ——. 1984. “The Sea Nomads of Southeast Asia: New Perspectives on Ancient Traditions.” Annual Newsletter of the Scandinavian Institute of Asian Studies 17: 3-13. Sather, Clifford A. 1995. “Sea Nomads and Rainforest Hunter-gatherers: Foraging Adaptations in the Indo-Malaysian Archipelago.” In The Austronesians: Historical and Comparative Perspectives, ed. Peter Bellwood, James J. Fox, and Darrell Tryon, pp. 229-68. Canberra: Department of Anthropology, Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies Publication, Australian National University. ——. 1997. The Bajau Laut: Adaptation, History, and Fate in a Maritime Fishing Society of South-eastern Sabah. Kuala Lumpur: Oxford University Press. ——. 1998. “Sea Nomads, Ethnicity, and Otherness: The Orang Suku Laut and Malay Identity in the Straits of Melaka.” Suomen Antropologi 2, no. 23 (October): 20-36. 10
  • 12. ——. 1999. The Orang Laut. Academy of Social Sciences (AKASS) Heritage Paper Series, Occasional Paper No. 5. Penang: Academy of Social Sciences. Skeat, Walter William, and Charles Otto Blagden. 1906. Pagan Races of the Malay Peninsula. 2 volumes. London: Macmillan & Co. Ltd. Sopher, David. 1977. The Sea Nomads: A Study of the Maritime Boat People of Southeast Asia. Singapore: National Museum Publication. First edition, 1965. Tarling, Nicholas. 1963. Piracy and Politics in the Malay World: A Study of British Imperialism in Nineteenth-century South-east Asia. Melbourne: F.W. Cheshire. Trocki, Carl. 1979. Prince of Pirates: The Temenggongs and the Development of Johor and Singapore 1784-1885. Singapore: Singapore University Press. Valentijn, François. 1724-1726. Oud en Nieuw Oost-Indiën, Vervattende een Naaukeurige en Uitvoerige Verhandelinge van Nederlands Mogenthevd in die Gewesten …in vyf deelen. Doordrecht-Amsterdam. Wallerstein, Immanuel. 1974. The Modern World-System: Capitalist Agriculture and The Origins of the European World Economy in the Sixteenth Century. New York: Academic Press. Warren, Carol. 1983. Ideology, Identity, and Change: The Experience of the Bajau Laut of East Malaysia 1969-1975. Southeast Asian Monograph Series No. 14. Townsville, Queensland: James Cook University of North Queensland. Warren, James. 1998. The Sulu Zone: The World Capitalist Economy and the Historical Imagination. Amsterdam: VU University Press. Wee, Vivienne. 1985. “Melayu: Hierarchies of Being in Riau.” Ph.D. thesis, Australian National University, Australia. Zacot, Francois. 1978. “The Voice of the Bajo People.” In Proceedings: Second International Conference on Austronesian Linguistics, Vol. 1: Western Austronesian, Pacific Linguistics, Series C, no. 61, ed. S.A. Wurm and L. Carrington, pp. 665-78. Canberra: The Australian National University Research School of Pacific Studies. 11