1. BODIES &
BUILDINGS
NYU ITP LECTURE COURSE FALL 2014
NOVEMBER 11, 2015
JEN VAN DER MEER @JENVANDERMEER WWW.JENVANDERMEER.COM
2. This course has really just been a
survey of my favorite heroes that
changed paradigms:
November 30, 2014
2
SECRET
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
Donella Meadows
Rachel Carson
Jane Jacobs
3. ASSIGNMENT
What part of the system of how we make and maintain our
buildings, interests you the most?
What are the anomalies and failures that irk you?
What possibilities do you see?
November 30, 2014
3
4. READING
Pick any one of the “Facsicles” from ArtFarm on architecture
theory:
http://www.archfarm.org/en/
November 30, 2014
4
6. PLACES TO INTERVENE IN A SYSTEM:
12. Constants, parameters, numbers (subsidies, taxes, standards)
11. The sizes of buffers and other stabilizing stocks, relative to their flows
10. The structure of material stocks and flows (transport networks, population age structures)
9. Length of delays, relative to the rate of system change
8. The strength of negative feedback loops, relative to the impacts they are trying to correct against
7. The gain around driving positive feedback loops
6. The structure of information flows (who does and does not have access to what kinds of
information)
5. The rules of the system (such as incentives, punishments, constraints)
4. The power to add, change, evolve, or self-organize system structure
3. The goals of the system
2. The mindset or paradigm out of which the system – its goals, power structure, rules, its culture-arises
1. The power to transcend paradigms
6
November 30, 2014
7. 1. The power to transcend paradigms
Keep oneself unattached in the arena of
paradigms.
-D. Meadows.
7
November 30, 2014
8. No paradigm is “true”
Every one, including the one that sweetly shapes
your worldview, is a tremendously limited
understanding of an immense and amazing universe
that is far beyond human comprehension. It is to
“get” at a gut level the paradigm that there are
paradigms, and to see that that itself is a paradigm,
and to regard that whole realization as devastatingly
funny.
8
November 30, 2014
9. The basis for radical empowerment
If no paradigm is right, you can choose whatever one
will help you to achieve your purpose, you can listen
to the universe and do his, her, its will, which is
probably a lot better informed than your will.
9
November 30, 2014
11. November 30, 2014
11
THE TOO SMART CITY?
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
12. November 30, 2014
12
THE TOO SMART CITY?
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
Critics see a massive shift in urban
priorities conducted largely out of the
public eye. Many of them compare the
networks being built today to the way cities
were redesigned for car travel in the first
half of the 20th century: As dirt roads were
paved, then widened, then run through
neighborhoods, and raised into
overpasses, they remapped cities
completely, for better and worse.
13. November 30, 2014
13
MASDAR CITY, NEAR ABU DHABI
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2010/09/26/arts/design/26ma
sdar-graphic.html?ref=design&_r=0
16. November 30, 2014
16
AGAINST THE SMART CITY
By building their cities up from nothing, on
sites as close to the bare Cartesian plane
as can practically be achieved, developers
forge from the earth a liminal setting that
the philosopher Gilles Deleuze
characterized as “any-space”whatever”
-Adam Greenfield
17. November 30, 2014
17
THE TOO SMART CITY?
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
Critics see a massive shift in urban
priorities conducted largely out of the
public eye. Many of them compare the
networks being built today to the way cities
were redesigned for car travel in the first
half of the 20th century: As dirt roads were
paved, then widened, then run through
neighborhoods, and raised into
overpasses, they remapped cities
completely, for better and worse.
18. November 30, 2014
18
SMART CITY LAYER CAKE
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
Critics see a massive shift in urban
priorities conducted largely out of the
public eye. Many of them compare the
networks being built today to the way cities
were redesigned for car travel in the first
half of the 20th century: As dirt roads were
paved, then widened, then run through
neighborhoods, and raised into
overpasses, they remapped cities
completely, for better and worse.
19. November 30, 2014
19
SMART CITY AS A CHIP
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
Critics see a massive shift in urban
priorities conducted largely out of the
public eye. Many of them compare the
networks being built today to the way cities
were redesigned for car travel in the first
half of the 20th century: As dirt roads were
paved, then widened, then run through
neighborhoods, and raised into
overpasses, they remapped cities
completely, for better and worse.
20. November 30, 2014
20
SMART CITY WHEEL OF
INFRASTRUCTURE
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
Critics see a massive shift in urban
priorities conducted largely out of the
public eye. Many of them compare the
networks being built today to the way cities
were redesigned for car travel in the first
half of the 20th century: As dirt roads were
paved, then widened, then run through
neighborhoods, and raised into
overpasses, they remapped cities
completely, for better and worse.
25. GENERATIVE DESIGN
Generative design is not about designing a building,
it’s about designing the system that designs a
building.
Using modeling and to see what works.
25
November 30, 2014
26. “VIRTUAL BUILDING”
a concept in which all design, construction,
environmental performance, and operational problems
are visualised, solved, and optimised using integrated
computer simulation.
-The Arup Journal 2/2008
26
November 30, 2014
28. “VIRTUAL BUILDING”
The virtual building is intended to support stakeholders throughout the
project’s lifetime in the following areas:
Exploration: a constantly evolving tool for exploring new directions in design
and construction
Communication: enabling project teams to quickly and accurately
communicate design forms, functions, and behaviours to other team
members and the broader collection of stakeholders
Integration: providing an environment where design and facility team
members can share and co-ordinate project information quickly and
efficiently
Optimization: facilitating analysis tools that are capable of optimising
performance, sustainability, and costs to meet both short-term and long-term
goals.
28
November 30, 2014
30. HOW COULD GENERATIVE
ARCHITECTURE MAKE CITIES ACTUALLY
SMART?
Exploration:
Communication:
Integration:
Optimization:
What else?
30
November 30, 2014
32. November 30, 2014
32
MORE MARC LESS JANE?
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
Critics see a massive shift in urban
priorities conducted largely out of the
public eye. Many of them compare the
networks being built today to the way cities
were redesigned for car travel in the first
half of the 20th century: As dirt roads were
paved, then widened, then run through
neighborhoods, and raised into
overpasses, they remapped cities
completely, for better and worse.
33. November 30, 2014
33
MORE CORBUSIER LESS JANE?
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
Critics see a massive shift in urban
priorities conducted largely out of the
public eye. Many of them compare the
networks being built today to the way cities
were redesigned for car travel in the first
half of the 20th century: As dirt roads were
paved, then widened, then run through
neighborhoods, and raised into
overpasses, they remapped cities
completely, for better and worse.
35. Writing about the city remained her
passion. She often went up to the rooftop
of her apartment building and watched the
garbage trucks as they made their way
through the city streets, picking the
sidewalks clean. She would think, "What a
complicated great place this is, and all
these pieces of it that make it work." The
more she investigated and explored
neighborhoods, infrastructure, and
business districts for her stories, the more
she began to see the city as a living,
breathing thing -- complex, wondrous, and
self-perpetuating.
November 30, 2014
35
JANE LIVED HERE
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
36. November 30, 2014
36
JANE FOUGHT MOSES
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
37. November 30, 2014
37
JANE FOUGHT MOSES
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
38. November 30, 2014
38
MOSES WAS CLEANING UP THE
SLUMS
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
39. November 30, 2014
39
MOSES WAS PLANNING ON
CLEANING UP THIS SLUM
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
40. During the 1950s and 1960s, her own home neighborhood of
Greenwich Village was being transformed by developers, the
expansion of New York University (NYU), and by the urban
renewal plans of Robert Moses. Moses – who had already
forced through the Cross Bronx Expressway and other
roadways against neighborhood opposition – envisioned an
expressway (The Lower Manhattan Expressway, or "Lomex")
directly through Washington Square Park.[citation needed]
His plan, funded as "slum clearance" by Title I of the Housing
Act of 1949, also called for multiple blocks to be razed and
replaced with upscale high-rises. The plan forced 132
families out of their homes and displaced 1000 small
businesses – the result was Washington Square Village.
November 30, 2014
40
JANE FOUGHT MOSES
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
41. November 30, 2014
41
JANE FOUGHT MOSES
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
42. SCHOLAR’S VIEW: SMART CITY
“Smart City is referred as the safe, secure environmentally green, and efficient urban
center of the future with advanced infrastructures such as sensors, electronics and
networks to stimulate sustainable economic growth & a high quality of life” (Hall, 2000)
“A city to be smart when investments in human and social capital and traditional
(transport) and modern (ICT) communication infrastructure fuel sustainable economic
growth and a high quality of life, with a wise management of natural resources, through
participatory governance” (Caragliu, 2009)
“A city well performing in a forward-looking way in economy, people, governance,
mobility, environment & living, built on the smart combination of endowments and
activities of self-decisive independent and aware citizens” (Giffinger & Gudrum, 2010)
- Sourced from
- http://iis-db.stanford.edu/evnts/7239/Jung_Hoon_Lee_final.pdf
November 30, 2014
42
43. CITY’S VIEW
“Smart City as a high-tech intensive and advanced city that connects people,
information and city elements using new technologies in order to create sustainable
greener city, competitive and innovative commerce and an increase life quality with a
straightforward administration and maintenance system of city” (Barcelona City Hall,
2011)
“Amsterdam Smart City uses innovative technology and the willingness to change
behavior related to energy consumption in order to tackle climate goals. Amsterdam
Smart City is an universal approach for design and development of a sustainable,
economically viable program that will reduce the city’s carbon footprint” (Amsterdam
Smart City, 2009)
November 30, 2014
43
44. November 30, 2014
44
THE NIGHTMARE ON CONNECTED
HOME STREET
As I plod through the kitchen, my floor
lights up, exposing rows of flashing LEDS,
and a snippet from an old Queen song
starts to play. “Congratulations!” purrs my
house in an Elvis Presley voice. “You’ve
just hit your step goal for the day!” Years
ago I reset the step goal to 20 because I
was tired of my house nagging me all day.
Every time my couch vibrated or my TV
told me to get up and walk around, I found
myself resenting my home a little bit more.
45. ARUP: SMART CITY = MANAGE
WHAT YOU TUNE
November 30, 2014
45
A smart city is one in which the seams and
structures of the various urban systems are
made clear, simple, responsive and even
malleable via contemporary technology
and design.
Key to this is the idea of measurement; of
infrastructure, buildings and activities
reporting their state and behaviour to
systems that learn and adapt in response
46. November 30, 2014
46
ARUP: SMART CITY = MANAGE
WHAT YOU TUNE
Citizens are not only engaged and
informed in the relationship between their
activities, their neighborhoods, and the
wider urban ecosystems, but are actively
encouraged to see the city itself as
something they can collectively tune, such
that it is efficient, interactive, engaging,
adaptive, and flexible, as opposed to the
inflexible, monofunctional and monolithic
structures of many 20th century cities.
47. ASSIGNMENT
Will your city be smart? Take your core idea that you’ve been
developing and situate it in a city. How will you shape the
future of cities around you?
Escape?
Ignore? Let it happen around you?
Or will you shape the decisions?
November 30, 2014
47