SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 47
Getting the goods
Jennifer LaFleur
Reveal | The Center for Investigative Reporting
First, know what laws govern
the records
you are seeking
p.s. Hang in there - cat video later
Two sets of laws
State open-records laws (which
includes public universities)
Federal Freedom of Information Act
(which can relate be helpful in cases
where universities participate in
federal grant programs)
What do state laws
cover?
State, city and county
governments
Police departments
Sheriff’s departments
State and municipal courts
School districts
Charter schools
Quasi-governmental agencies
State laws typically don’t
cover
Answers to questions
Information that an agency has to
create
State records laws
Many are similar to FOIA – but differ as what
organizations are covered, exemptions and
procedures.
They are called different things and you cite them
differently
Some states have an administrative appeal
process.
TX – Required to go to AG
MO – Rep must ask for ruling
CA – Nope
What does FOIA cover?
U.S. federal agency records
Paper, electronic, tape
recordings, data
Sometimes (but not always)
government contractor’s
records
Does not cover
Congress
The Courts
Answers to questions
The nine exemptions to FOIA
1. National Security
2. Internal agency personnel rules
3. Information exempt by other laws
4. Trade secrets
5. Internal agency memoranda
6. Personal privacy
7. Law enforcement investigations
8. Federally regulated banks
9. Oil and gas wells
HIPAA
Health Insurance Portability
and Accountability Act
Designed to protect patient
information and covers
entities that electronically
transfer patient information.
A check list to help negotiate for data and
records, of all kinds
(in a perfect world):
Assume the records are public. They belong
to the taxpayers/tuition payers
The basics steps for
requesting records
File a request – that starts the time
clock and creates a paper trail.
Find out who it should go to and
what you should ask for
Letter should describe what you’re
asking for
Request an itemized cost estimate
Provide all possible contact
information
Note that you’re willing to negotiate
Turning No into Yes
Know the law
Do your homework
Be persistent
Appeal
Who else has the same records?
Check retention schedules
Ask for record layout for
electronic records
Carry a flash drive
Massachusetts
municipal
records
retention
Dos and Don’ts
Know what you’re asking for
Follow, follow, follow
Pick it up
Know the law
Be willing to negotiate
Write about it
Dos and Don’ts
Know what you’re asking for
Follow, follow, follow
Be willing to negotiate
Pick it up
Know the law
Write about it
Be ready for excuses
FERPA
Our computer
system can’t
do that.
We can give
you only
printed pages
We don’t have
the authority
to do that
Our database is on a
mainframe and it’s
very complicated,
Missy
We don’t have the
authority to do
that
That will cost
$25,000.
That uses proprietary
software.
We don’t keep that on
computer
That information is
protected by law
Okay, we do,
but it’s a lot
of files
Where to get more information
Student Press Law Center: www.splc.org
IRE: www.ire.org
State attornies general – for state records
Reporters Committee: www.rcfp.org
National Freedom of Information Coalition:
www.nfoic.org
SPLC
RCFP
Jennifer LaFleur
Reveal | The Center for Investigative Reporting
jlafleur@cironline.org
www.revealnews.org
@j_la28

More Related Content

What's hot

Lone Star Chapter 3
Lone Star Chapter 3Lone Star Chapter 3
Lone Star Chapter 3dhohnhol
 
Chapter 3 - The U.S. Supreme Court: The Final Word
Chapter 3 - The U.S. Supreme Court: The Final WordChapter 3 - The U.S. Supreme Court: The Final Word
Chapter 3 - The U.S. Supreme Court: The Final Wordlisajurs
 
Chapter 3
Chapter 3Chapter 3
Chapter 3gbrand
 
11/08/19 UIE Letter To MSTOA...Executive Ruler
11/08/19 UIE Letter To MSTOA...Executive Ruler11/08/19 UIE Letter To MSTOA...Executive Ruler
11/08/19 UIE Letter To MSTOA...Executive RulerVogelDenise
 
Nursing home law_v4
Nursing home law_v4Nursing home law_v4
Nursing home law_v4Neal Axton
 
20 New Trends and Developments in Computer and Internet Law
20 New Trends and Developments in Computer and Internet Law20 New Trends and Developments in Computer and Internet Law
20 New Trends and Developments in Computer and Internet LawKlemchuk LLP
 
Fed cts what they do
Fed cts what they doFed cts what they do
Fed cts what they dosevans-idaho
 
Saying no to the government
Saying no to the governmentSaying no to the government
Saying no to the governmentguest70f067f
 
The Judicial Branch
The Judicial BranchThe Judicial Branch
The Judicial BranchDan Hess
 

What's hot (19)

Lone Star Chapter 3
Lone Star Chapter 3Lone Star Chapter 3
Lone Star Chapter 3
 
Chapter 3 - The U.S. Supreme Court: The Final Word
Chapter 3 - The U.S. Supreme Court: The Final WordChapter 3 - The U.S. Supreme Court: The Final Word
Chapter 3 - The U.S. Supreme Court: The Final Word
 
The Courts
The CourtsThe Courts
The Courts
 
Judicial Branch
Judicial BranchJudicial Branch
Judicial Branch
 
The Courts
The CourtsThe Courts
The Courts
 
Chapter 3
Chapter 3Chapter 3
Chapter 3
 
11/08/19 UIE Letter To MSTOA...Executive Ruler
11/08/19 UIE Letter To MSTOA...Executive Ruler11/08/19 UIE Letter To MSTOA...Executive Ruler
11/08/19 UIE Letter To MSTOA...Executive Ruler
 
Uga Social Media Privacy June2011
Uga Social Media Privacy June2011Uga Social Media Privacy June2011
Uga Social Media Privacy June2011
 
Nursing home law_v4
Nursing home law_v4Nursing home law_v4
Nursing home law_v4
 
20 New Trends and Developments in Computer and Internet Law
20 New Trends and Developments in Computer and Internet Law20 New Trends and Developments in Computer and Internet Law
20 New Trends and Developments in Computer and Internet Law
 
Fed cts what they do
Fed cts what they doFed cts what they do
Fed cts what they do
 
Cyberlaw
CyberlawCyberlaw
Cyberlaw
 
Chapter 14
Chapter 14Chapter 14
Chapter 14
 
Saying no to the government
Saying no to the governmentSaying no to the government
Saying no to the government
 
Judicial Branch
Judicial BranchJudicial Branch
Judicial Branch
 
The Judicial Branch
The Judicial BranchThe Judicial Branch
The Judicial Branch
 
The Courts Take 2
The Courts Take 2The Courts Take 2
The Courts Take 2
 
Reboot11 Elvira Berlingieri
Reboot11 Elvira BerlingieriReboot11 Elvira Berlingieri
Reboot11 Elvira Berlingieri
 
CV for Michael Anderson
CV for Michael AndersonCV for Michael Anderson
CV for Michael Anderson
 

Viewers also liked

Data journalism without data
Data journalism without dataData journalism without data
Data journalism without dataJennifer LaFleur
 
Diagnosing dirty data_ire2013
Diagnosing dirty data_ire2013Diagnosing dirty data_ire2013
Diagnosing dirty data_ire2013Jennifer LaFleur
 
Number Off
Number OffNumber Off
Number OffLouka5
 
Cat techie aka vaidehi sachin nbc newsmakers broadcasting real hidden story
Cat techie aka vaidehi sachin nbc newsmakers broadcasting real hidden storyCat techie aka vaidehi sachin nbc newsmakers broadcasting real hidden story
Cat techie aka vaidehi sachin nbc newsmakers broadcasting real hidden storyVAidehi Sachin
 
Nr14: Ten tips for data journalists
Nr14: Ten tips for data journalistsNr14: Ten tips for data journalists
Nr14: Ten tips for data journalistsJennifer LaFleur
 
VVOJ Intro to data journalism
VVOJ Intro to data journalismVVOJ Intro to data journalism
VVOJ Intro to data journalismJennifer LaFleur
 
Crunching the numbers NR14
Crunching the numbers NR14Crunching the numbers NR14
Crunching the numbers NR14Jennifer LaFleur
 
Data journalism at Techraking 6
Data journalism at Techraking 6Data journalism at Techraking 6
Data journalism at Techraking 6Jennifer LaFleur
 
Mind the Gap NICAR14 (holes in data)
Mind the Gap NICAR14 (holes in data)Mind the Gap NICAR14 (holes in data)
Mind the Gap NICAR14 (holes in data)Jennifer LaFleur
 
The CASTLE Principles - mini description
The CASTLE Principles - mini descriptionThe CASTLE Principles - mini description
The CASTLE Principles - mini descriptionLance Secretan
 
The CASTLE Principles - Presentation
The CASTLE Principles - PresentationThe CASTLE Principles - Presentation
The CASTLE Principles - PresentationLance Secretan
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Data journalism without data
Data journalism without dataData journalism without data
Data journalism without data
 
Diagnosing dirty data_ire2013
Diagnosing dirty data_ire2013Diagnosing dirty data_ire2013
Diagnosing dirty data_ire2013
 
Number Off
Number OffNumber Off
Number Off
 
Cat techie aka vaidehi sachin nbc newsmakers broadcasting real hidden story
Cat techie aka vaidehi sachin nbc newsmakers broadcasting real hidden storyCat techie aka vaidehi sachin nbc newsmakers broadcasting real hidden story
Cat techie aka vaidehi sachin nbc newsmakers broadcasting real hidden story
 
Nr14: Ten tips for data journalists
Nr14: Ten tips for data journalistsNr14: Ten tips for data journalists
Nr14: Ten tips for data journalists
 
VVOJ Intro to data journalism
VVOJ Intro to data journalismVVOJ Intro to data journalism
VVOJ Intro to data journalism
 
ACP Digging Deeper
ACP Digging DeeperACP Digging Deeper
ACP Digging Deeper
 
Getting it the rightest
Getting it the rightestGetting it the rightest
Getting it the rightest
 
Crunching the numbers NR14
Crunching the numbers NR14Crunching the numbers NR14
Crunching the numbers NR14
 
Data journalism at Techraking 6
Data journalism at Techraking 6Data journalism at Techraking 6
Data journalism at Techraking 6
 
Mind the Gap NICAR14 (holes in data)
Mind the Gap NICAR14 (holes in data)Mind the Gap NICAR14 (holes in data)
Mind the Gap NICAR14 (holes in data)
 
The CASTLE Principles - mini description
The CASTLE Principles - mini descriptionThe CASTLE Principles - mini description
The CASTLE Principles - mini description
 
The CASTLE Principles - Presentation
The CASTLE Principles - PresentationThe CASTLE Principles - Presentation
The CASTLE Principles - Presentation
 
Transparency ire13
Transparency ire13Transparency ire13
Transparency ire13
 
Ona 2012
Ona 2012Ona 2012
Ona 2012
 
Cats stats
Cats statsCats stats
Cats stats
 

Similar to ACP Getting the Goods

I’m attaching some info on the agency I work for. I work remot.docx
I’m attaching some info on the agency I work for. I work remot.docxI’m attaching some info on the agency I work for. I work remot.docx
I’m attaching some info on the agency I work for. I work remot.docxdonnajames55
 
2008 12 08 2008 Privacy
2008 12 08 2008 Privacy2008 12 08 2008 Privacy
2008 12 08 2008 PrivacyLance Hoffman
 
Transparency: how do I do it?
Transparency: how do I do it?Transparency: how do I do it?
Transparency: how do I do it?EmilyDShaw
 
9414 Unit 3 Government resources 3
9414 Unit 3 Government resources 39414 Unit 3 Government resources 3
9414 Unit 3 Government resources 3davismd4mu
 
Legal Research & Fed. Legal Resources
Legal Research & Fed. Legal ResourcesLegal Research & Fed. Legal Resources
Legal Research & Fed. Legal ResourcesBrian Huffman
 
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAIN
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAINCOMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAIN
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAINamiable_indian
 
Mwlug Compliance And E Discovery Policies
Mwlug   Compliance And E Discovery PoliciesMwlug   Compliance And E Discovery Policies
Mwlug Compliance And E Discovery PoliciesLotusDR
 
Cost effectiveknfall2011 2
Cost effectiveknfall2011 2Cost effectiveknfall2011 2
Cost effectiveknfall2011 2Sue Altmeyer
 
Free and Low-Cost Legal Research
Free and Low-Cost Legal ResearchFree and Low-Cost Legal Research
Free and Low-Cost Legal Researchdukelawreference
 
Legal rights eq
Legal rights eqLegal rights eq
Legal rights eqtp3115
 
Uniform Electronic Legal Material Act Update
Uniform Electronic Legal Material Act UpdateUniform Electronic Legal Material Act Update
Uniform Electronic Legal Material Act UpdateMary Jenkins
 
Locating Legal Information On The Web
Locating Legal  Information On The WebLocating Legal  Information On The Web
Locating Legal Information On The Weblegal4
 
Locating Legal Information On The Web
Locating Legal Information On The WebLocating Legal Information On The Web
Locating Legal Information On The Weblegalcounsel
 
Pick one of the following crimes and do research on it.1.         .docx
Pick one of the following crimes and do research on it.1.         .docxPick one of the following crimes and do research on it.1.         .docx
Pick one of the following crimes and do research on it.1.         .docxrowthechang
 

Similar to ACP Getting the Goods (20)

I’m attaching some info on the agency I work for. I work remot.docx
I’m attaching some info on the agency I work for. I work remot.docxI’m attaching some info on the agency I work for. I work remot.docx
I’m attaching some info on the agency I work for. I work remot.docx
 
2008 12 08 2008 Privacy
2008 12 08 2008 Privacy2008 12 08 2008 Privacy
2008 12 08 2008 Privacy
 
legal system.ppt
legal system.pptlegal system.ppt
legal system.ppt
 
Transparency: how do I do it?
Transparency: how do I do it?Transparency: how do I do it?
Transparency: how do I do it?
 
9414 Unit 3 Government resources 3
9414 Unit 3 Government resources 39414 Unit 3 Government resources 3
9414 Unit 3 Government resources 3
 
trial1
trial1trial1
trial1
 
trial2
trial2trial2
trial2
 
Legal Research & Fed. Legal Resources
Legal Research & Fed. Legal ResourcesLegal Research & Fed. Legal Resources
Legal Research & Fed. Legal Resources
 
Basic Legal Research for the Non-Law Librarian
Basic Legal Research for the Non-Law Librarian Basic Legal Research for the Non-Law Librarian
Basic Legal Research for the Non-Law Librarian
 
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAIN
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAINCOMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAIN
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAIN
 
Mwlug Compliance And E Discovery Policies
Mwlug   Compliance And E Discovery PoliciesMwlug   Compliance And E Discovery Policies
Mwlug Compliance And E Discovery Policies
 
Cost effectiveknfall2011 2
Cost effectiveknfall2011 2Cost effectiveknfall2011 2
Cost effectiveknfall2011 2
 
Free and Low-Cost Legal Research
Free and Low-Cost Legal ResearchFree and Low-Cost Legal Research
Free and Low-Cost Legal Research
 
Basic Legal Research For Any Librarian
Basic Legal Research For Any LibrarianBasic Legal Research For Any Librarian
Basic Legal Research For Any Librarian
 
Be A Wonk
Be A WonkBe A Wonk
Be A Wonk
 
Legal rights eq
Legal rights eqLegal rights eq
Legal rights eq
 
Uniform Electronic Legal Material Act Update
Uniform Electronic Legal Material Act UpdateUniform Electronic Legal Material Act Update
Uniform Electronic Legal Material Act Update
 
Locating Legal Information On The Web
Locating Legal  Information On The WebLocating Legal  Information On The Web
Locating Legal Information On The Web
 
Locating Legal Information On The Web
Locating Legal Information On The WebLocating Legal Information On The Web
Locating Legal Information On The Web
 
Pick one of the following crimes and do research on it.1.         .docx
Pick one of the following crimes and do research on it.1.         .docxPick one of the following crimes and do research on it.1.         .docx
Pick one of the following crimes and do research on it.1.         .docx
 

ACP Getting the Goods

  • 1. Getting the goods Jennifer LaFleur Reveal | The Center for Investigative Reporting
  • 2. First, know what laws govern the records you are seeking p.s. Hang in there - cat video later
  • 3. Two sets of laws State open-records laws (which includes public universities) Federal Freedom of Information Act (which can relate be helpful in cases where universities participate in federal grant programs)
  • 4. What do state laws cover? State, city and county governments Police departments Sheriff’s departments State and municipal courts School districts Charter schools Quasi-governmental agencies
  • 5. State laws typically don’t cover Answers to questions Information that an agency has to create
  • 6. State records laws Many are similar to FOIA – but differ as what organizations are covered, exemptions and procedures. They are called different things and you cite them differently Some states have an administrative appeal process. TX – Required to go to AG MO – Rep must ask for ruling CA – Nope
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10. What does FOIA cover? U.S. federal agency records Paper, electronic, tape recordings, data Sometimes (but not always) government contractor’s records Does not cover Congress The Courts Answers to questions
  • 11.
  • 12. The nine exemptions to FOIA 1. National Security 2. Internal agency personnel rules 3. Information exempt by other laws 4. Trade secrets 5. Internal agency memoranda 6. Personal privacy 7. Law enforcement investigations 8. Federally regulated banks 9. Oil and gas wells
  • 13.
  • 14. HIPAA Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act Designed to protect patient information and covers entities that electronically transfer patient information.
  • 15.
  • 16. A check list to help negotiate for data and records, of all kinds (in a perfect world):
  • 17. Assume the records are public. They belong to the taxpayers/tuition payers
  • 18. The basics steps for requesting records File a request – that starts the time clock and creates a paper trail. Find out who it should go to and what you should ask for Letter should describe what you’re asking for Request an itemized cost estimate Provide all possible contact information Note that you’re willing to negotiate
  • 19. Turning No into Yes Know the law Do your homework Be persistent Appeal Who else has the same records? Check retention schedules Ask for record layout for electronic records Carry a flash drive
  • 21. Dos and Don’ts Know what you’re asking for Follow, follow, follow Pick it up Know the law Be willing to negotiate Write about it
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25. Dos and Don’ts Know what you’re asking for Follow, follow, follow Be willing to negotiate Pick it up Know the law Write about it Be ready for excuses
  • 26. FERPA
  • 28. We can give you only printed pages
  • 29.
  • 30. We don’t have the authority to do that
  • 31.
  • 32. Our database is on a mainframe and it’s very complicated, Missy We don’t have the authority to do that
  • 33. That will cost $25,000. That uses proprietary software.
  • 34. We don’t keep that on computer That information is protected by law
  • 35. Okay, we do, but it’s a lot of files
  • 36.
  • 37.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41. Where to get more information Student Press Law Center: www.splc.org IRE: www.ire.org State attornies general – for state records Reporters Committee: www.rcfp.org National Freedom of Information Coalition: www.nfoic.org
  • 42.
  • 43. SPLC
  • 44. RCFP
  • 45.
  • 46.
  • 47. Jennifer LaFleur Reveal | The Center for Investigative Reporting jlafleur@cironline.org www.revealnews.org @j_la28