Presentation by Steve Carkner, Head of Innovation at Revision Military as part of the Business of IoT Workshop at IoT613 on Thursday, September 29, 2016.
This presentation is targeted towards budding
entrepreneurs that have a product idea – but aren’t
sure where to get the key ingredient to success –
MONEY!
Introduction
This presentation is targeted towards budding
entrepreneurs that have a product idea – but aren’t
sure where to get the key ingredient to success –
$ MONEY! $
Introduction
“other people’s money”
This presentation is targeted towards budding
entrepreneurs that have a product idea – but aren’t
sure where to get the key ingredient to success –
$$ MONEY! $$
Introduction
“other people’s money”
People who expect to make more money…
This presentation is targeted towards budding
entrepreneurs that have a product idea – but aren’t
sure where to get the key ingredient to success –
$$$ MONEY! $$$
Introduction
“other people’s money”
People who expect to make more money…
People who have legal Rights to question
many of the moves you make…
What are you really trying to do?
How much funding do you really need?
How much runway do you personally have?
Investors expect you to have significant “skin in the game”
I have had investors say that they expect nothing less than my
own personal bankruptcy if the business fails.
Can someone else do parts of your business better?
What does success look like?
What are you willing to give up?
Ask Yourself:
You do not have to be the next big thing (contrary to
almost everything you will see and hear about funding a
startup company).
You DO need to recognize what your business is likely
to become
Recognize what your own goals are
Then seek funding (if it’s even needed) that matches!
Who Funds Businesses?
Friends and Family (Love Money)
The easiest to get – at least your first time
Patient money
Great for “walking harvest” business opportunities
Generally small amounts
Love Money can have difficult emotional ties.
Just because you are dealing with family doesn’t mean you
shouldn’t document the deal and outline risk factors involved.
Who Funds Businesses?
Micro-Funding
If you fit any special demographic there may be some easy funds
available to you
Youth under 30, summer business, women focused, community
focused, specific job focused… many others
Often loan based, sometimes with zero interest and occasionally
with no payback required at all if business of product fails
Government or Charity based
Generally small amounts (although some government programs
extend to hundreds-of-thousands)
Although not typically used for high-tech, these programs don’t
explicitly limit the use of funds or type of business.
Who Funds Businesses?
What is an Incubator?
Business incubators are organizations geared toward
speeding up the growth and success of startup and early
stage companies. They’re often a good path to capital, but
rarely put their own hard capital into play directly.
- “Funding” is often in-kind in the form of free rent,
consulting, internet, etc.
If you have watched this show
then you know what an example
of a small incubator can look like:
Who Funds Businesses?
(Underlying the comedy are some very real take-aways on funding a startup)
Crowd Funding
For this audience… If you haven’t heard of crowd
funding, please hang your head in shame and leave now
What you may not realize are some of the pitfalls and
best-uses for crowd funding.
Who Funds Businesses?
Crowd Funding - Pitfalls
From my completely unscientific analysis of crowd-
funding that targets product development:
Funding amount is typically drastically low or non-
existent (product sale only)
Nothing set-aside for major expenses like IP protection,
certification, safety approvals, etc. (especially critical
for IOT devices!)
Development timelines are unrealistic and unsupported
Who Funds Businesses?
Crowd Funding - Advantages
Great way to gauge market interest and acceptance
for a specific demographic
if you are ready to follow through
Excellent for small funding needs
Excellent for products that only require small volumes
to justify development
Wonderful for existing small businesses (and under-
utilized in this area)
Who Funds Businesses?
Angel Investment
Can come alone or as a group
Often focused on areas that are familiar and
comfortable – in Ottawa it is easier to get
“communications” funding than “medical” for
example.
Often focused or more interested in local growth
Can require multiple pitches
Organized groups often require a mentor/sponsor
Sometimes have consultant-hooks in the deal
Who Funds Businesses?
LONE Angel Investment
Lone angels can be risky, especially if they have not done
many deals.
- Inflated expectations
- Emotional
- High maintenance
- Each may require their own special deal which leads to a messy
corporate structure and can hurt future investment
Lone angels can be a benefit
- Willing to roll up their own sleeves and help
- Easier to appeal to their moral compass or personal interests
Who Funds Businesses?
GROUP Angel Investment
Groups vary but will often have well defined structure.
- Requirements to pitch
- Set investment requirements
- Well established legal framework
- Not everyone has to buy-in
There are some huge angel networks such as Keiretsu which are broken up
into chapters and can draw finances worldwide from over 1000 members
allowing raises in the ten-of-millions: http://www.keiretsuforum.com/
And there are small angel groups such as Ottawa’s Purple Angels, Capital Angel
Network.
The National Angel Capital Organization (which I am an original founder)
provides a wealth of information and list of angel investment groups across
Canada: http://www.nacocanada.com/
Who Funds Businesses?
What is a Professional Angel?
A Professional Angel is someone or a group that has done
enough deals or is structured in such a way that they
closely resemble a Venture Capital company
May only lack the official “corporate” designation as a
financier
May actually drive a harder deal than a VC
May be a non-financial corporation (yes, corporations can
act as angel investors especially if there are global, tax or
other hidden drivers to their behaviour… this is good!)
Who Funds Businesses?
Venture (Vulture) Capitalists – VCs.
Although mainstream media likes to demonize VCs as greedy, they remain an excellent
source of funding provided their interests align with yours.
Deliver what you say you can deliver
Deliver when you say you can deliver
Expect short pay-back horizons – if you truly believe that you are going to profitable in 12-18
months this is a great fit
Show major returns, 10-20x is not an unreasonable expectation
Expect difficult financing terms – if you accept them and become dilluted or sqeezed out…
then why did you accept the terms?
The operational and legal costs of operating VCs along with an expectation to return capital
to their investors means deals have to be fairly large to make it worth it for all parties
involved
VCs are themselves funded. You may not realize that while you are making a pitch to a
VC, most VCs also have to make pitches to private investors in order to source their
fund’s capital.
YOUR pitch eventually becomes part of THEIR pitch
Who Funds Businesses?
Banks
Banks really DO fund businesses!
If you can show purchase orders, personal financial success or good
backers then you may be able to get access to conventional (debt)
funding
Programs exist, especially targeted government funds, where the
government will guarantee the loan on your behalf
International sales can be guaranteed through Canada Commercial Corp
(www.ccc.ca)
Consider the ADVANTAGES
No ownership dillution
Low maintenance
No “voting rights”
No “shareholder rights”
Can easily scale up as orders increase
Who Funds Businesses?
Other lesser known sources of funds – dig for them
IRAP/SRED/GRANT
Often big R small D focused
Sometimes repayable, royalty or combination
BCIP (Build in Canada Innovation Program)
A buy and try program that is almost like funding
SADI or similar targeted funds
SADI in particular provides funding for defense and aerospace
related development in the form of long-term loans
Federal, provincial or municipal - Matching Programs
Provide funds on a matching basis with private investment
dollars (1:2 or less is typical)
Who Funds Businesses?
A Summary of Who
Walking
Harvest
Single
product or
Hobby
Slow
growth solid
business
High growth
with
acquisition
exit
High growth
with IPO
exit
Love Money * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Micro
Funding * * * * * * * * *
Incubator * * * * * * *
Crowd
Funding * * * Future? Future? Future?
Angels * * * * * * * * *
Pro-Angels * * * * * * *
VCs * * * * * *
Banks * * * * * * * * * *
A few key ingredients we will cover are:
Your Pitch
Your Plan
Your Model
Your Value
This is really the minimum set of information you need to be
successfully financed from ANY source. Only the level of detail
will change depending on the source you target.
How do I get Financed?
There are LOTS of internet resources on how to create and deliver a
successful pitch:
A pitch can be the 30-second “elevator pitch”
A pitch can be an hour long investor presentation
Having an effective elevator pitch is very important as it provides
the hook you will use over and over again.
The elevator pitch isn’t just for investment, you can also use it to find
new customers, to introduce your business and even to convince
suppliers to partner with you.
Be prepared to vary your pitch to your audience. A financier will have
a different interest than a tech-guru.
First impressions are very important – Any presentation, no matter how
long, can start with the elevator pitch to build excitement right from the
start and leave your audience wanting to learn more.
The Pitch
Creating your 30-Second Pitch
Tell A Story – removes the feel of a hard-sell
Don’t use jargon – Unless you are SURE of your audience
What Problem are you going to solve – NOT your solution
Why are you so damn special?
Invite conversation – This is how 30 seconds turns into 20
minutes
The Pitch
“A lot of soldiers are coming home early with bad backs, worn out knees and a host of medical
problems because they are so overloaded in the field. The U.S. Military knows they are overloaded and
are always looking for solutions. We have a battery technology that removes about 20 pounds from
what the soldier needs to carry. I started working with this technology almost 20 years ago for
smartphones (we called it a 2-way pager or Blackberry back then). Now I am bringing that technology
to soldier power systems.”
<pause – you don’t need to say more>
If I am talking to a military person, I would modify the pitch to make it more personal: “I really respect
how much soldiers carry into the field, I don’t know how they can lug so much around… did you know
that almost 40 pounds of that weight is batteries? We have a technology…”
There are so many opportunities for the person to now ask questions: “you were with Blackberry?”
“what’s the technology?” “how much do those medical costs add up for the government?”
NOW I am no longer “pitching”, instead I am answering questions and the potential investor feels
engaged and in control. Done well they will be the ones who eventually ask “are you looking for
funding?”
Why yes… as a matter of fact we are…
The Pitch
An Exercise
At each table: Create a quick 30-second pitch!
Business: Pick your own idea, or use one of these.
A flashlight product
Media streaming service
Bacteria that can digest spilled oil
10:25 Pick your founder
10:25-10:30 Create your pitch
10:30-10:35 Give your pitch
The Pitch
At some point you will also need a full pitch presentation.
This would be a condensed version of your business plan.
Going into building a business plan and full investor pitch presentation is
beyond the scope of today’s session – but happy to give some real-world
pointers:
Who should pitch?
The founder isn’t always the right person!
Picking someone else shows team depth and willingness to delegate
Passion is important
The LONG Pitch
Avoid At All Costs (how many of these did we hear?):
10 – We have the cheapest…
The LONG Pitch
Avoid At All Costs (how many of these did we hear?):
10 – We have the cheapest…
9 – Everyone will want this…
The LONG Pitch
Avoid At All Costs (how many of these did we hear?):
10 – We have the cheapest…
9 – Everyone will want this…
8 – We have no competitors…
The LONG Pitch
Avoid At All Costs (how many of these did we hear?):
10 – We have the cheapest…
9 – Everyone will want this…
8 – We have no competitors…
7 – Like an iPod (or like Apple or any other wildly successful product)*…
The LONG Pitch
*– it’s OK to humbly state that “we like the user interface on the iPod and would implement a similar interface on our product”
Avoid At All Costs (how many of these did we hear?):
10 – We have the cheapest…
9 – Everyone will want this…
8 – We have no competitors…
7 – Like an iPod (or like Apple or any other wildly successful product)*…
6 – Better than Facebook (or any other wildly successful website)…
The LONG Pitch
*– it’s OK to humbly state that “we like the user interface on the iPod and would implement a similar interface on our product”
Avoid At All Costs (how many of these did we hear?):
10 – We have the cheapest…
9 – Everyone will want this…
8 – We have no competitors…
7 – Like an iPod (or like Apple or any other wildly successful product)*…
6 – Better than Facebook (or any other wildly successful website)…
5 – The product will practically sell itself…
The LONG Pitch
*– it’s OK to humbly state that “we like the user interface on the iPod and would implement a similar interface on our product”
Avoid At All Costs (how many of these did we hear?):
10 – We have the cheapest…
9 – Everyone will want this…
8 – We have no competitors…
7 – Like an iPod (or like Apple or any other wildly successful product)*…
6 – Better than Facebook (or any other wildly successful website)…
5 – The product will practically sell itself…
4 – Everyone needs this…
The LONG Pitch
*– it’s OK to humbly state that “we like the user interface on the iPod and would implement a similar interface on our product”
Avoid At All Costs (how many of these did we hear?):
10 – We have the cheapest…
9 – Everyone will want this…
8 – We have no competitors…
7 – Like an iPod (or like Apple or any other wildly successful product)*…
6 – Better than Facebook (or any other wildly successful website)…
5 – The product will practically sell itself…
4 – Everyone needs this…
3 – We hope… (hope is not a strategy)
The LONG Pitch
*– it’s OK to humbly state that “we like the user interface on the iPod and would implement a similar interface on our product”
Avoid At All Costs (how many of these did we hear?):
10 – We have the cheapest…
9 – Everyone will want this…
8 – We have no competitors…
7 – Like an iPod (or like Apple or any other wildly successful product)*…
6 – Better than Facebook (or any other wildly successful website)…
5 – The product will practically sell itself…
4 – Everyone needs this…
3 – We hope… (hope is not a strategy)
2 – We will worry about monetization later…
The LONG Pitch
*– it’s OK to humbly state that “we like the user interface on the iPod and would implement a similar interface on our product”
Avoid At All Costs (how many of these did we hear?):
10 – We have the cheapest…
9 – Everyone will want this…
8 – We have no competitors…
7 – Like an iPod (or like Apple or any other wildly successful product)*…
6 – Better than Facebook (or any other wildly successful website)…
5 – The product will practically sell itself…
4 – Everyone needs this…
3 – We hope… (hope is not a strategy)
2 – We will worry about monetization later…
1 – We only need 1% market share…
The LONG Pitch
*– it’s OK to humbly state that “we like the user interface on the iPod and would implement a similar interface on our product”
Getting from YES to $$$ in the bank can be a challenge.
Structuring the deal itself will vary drastically depending on
who is investing and what type of investment is involved.
Smaller deals can be dealt with using simpler terms if you
choose the right method.
Be prepared by considering a few of the biggest next-step
questions
OMG – Someone Said YES!
(and you want “someone else’s money”)
Deals can be structured around a single form of compensation,
or a combination of compensation (often called “kickers”)
Straight Debt
Probably the simplest possible deal – An exchange of funds
for a promise of repayment with interest.
Secured, often using the founders own assets (be prepared).
Best for “Walking-Harvest” companies
Kickers:
Escallating interest
Royalties / profit sharing
Warrants for buying shares
Deal Types
Convertible Debt
One of my personal favourites, especially for small startups.
Reduces the need for a valuation
An exchange of funds for a promise of equity in the company
at a rate that matches a follow-on investor.
Eg. Invest $50K in a seed-round. When company does “A”
round for $1M, shares issue as if I invested at that round.
Kickers:
Conversion usually at a discount to follow-on
Interest or pay-out after a fixed time if no series “A”
Royalties / profit sharing occasionally (rare)
Warrants for buying additional shares
Deal Types
Equity
An exchange of funds for part of the company.
Requires setting a value on the company (breaks many deals)
Usually includes seat on the board and carries significant
shareholder rights obligations
Kickers:
Down-round protection
Warrants for buying additional shares
Early liquidation clause (founders beware!)
Performance clauses (delivery, revenue, etc.)
Dividends (for walking-harvest companies, rare)
Deal Types
Less Common Types – at least for startups
Bonds (very similar to debt, usually with a lump payout)
Earn-Out (used more in take-overs)
Deal Types
The best I have seen:
Energetic, passionate, excited
Willing to take advice
Courteous
Already well connected
Prepared (competition, market, and who is your audience are top three)
The Bad that I have seen:
Unsure of market
Out of money / out of time
Desperate
Greedy
The Ugly:
Arrogant
Argues with a room full of people
Won’t take advice
Good, Bad and Ugly
Harlan Sanders of KFC is often held up as a model for tenacity in the face of investors
for being turned down over 1,000 times while seeking funding for KFC.
They Said No!
Harlan Sanders of KFC is often held up as a model for tenacity in the face of investors
for being turned down over 1,000 times while seeking funding for KFC.
I think he was a bit of an idiot… who eventually either got lucky, or just found a
dumb enough investor to join in his business.
They Said No!
Harlan Sanders of KFC is often held up as a model for tenacity in the face of investors
for being turned down over 1,000 times while seeking funding for KFC.
I think he was a bit of an idiot… who eventually either got lucky, or just found a
dumb enough investor to join in his business. Sharpen your plan and pitch!!!
Investors are human beings – and you may not believe it, but they actually
LIKE to say yes and HATE saying No.
You will rarely get an outright “No”, it is softened with terms like “come
back”, “we will keep it in mind”, etc.
So Ask them to educate you – ask for a debrief and offer to bring muffins:
Where did I lose you?
What would help me engage with other investors?
What else? What else? What else? (keep asking this until you really
understand what went wrong)
They Said No!
Your are lucky!
Finding groups, resources and advice has never been easier!
MARS Entrepreneurship 101
Great resources on a variety of topics related to starting and running a business.
Free registration
Financing Unit:
https://entrepreneurs-toolkit.schoolkeep.com/catalog/5xgabtoz/introduction-to-
investment-readiness
Include specialized startup guidance for different industries from Digital Gaming to
Cleantech.
Almost 600 videos from Product Development Planning to Body Language.
Resources
Your are lucky!
Finding groups, resources and advice has never been easier!
MARS Entrepreneurship 101
Great resources on a variety of topics related to starting and running a business.
Free registration
Financing Unit:
https://entrepreneurs-toolkit.schoolkeep.com/catalog/5xgabtoz/introduction-to-
investment-readiness
Includes specialized start-up guidance for different industries from Digital Gaming
to Cleantech.
Almost 600 videos from Product Development Planning to Body Language.
Resources