28 i chronicle


Published on

Eurozone Debt Crisis

  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

28 i chronicle

  1. 1. September 2011, Volume: 28 ISSUE VOLUME Investeurs Chronicles News …… In Focus Cover Story ....... News on Industry and It takes 32 Rs. to cross Eurozone in Intensive care Emerging Markets poverty line! Open Forum……. Stats Watch ....... Outlook Policy Rate Hike Falling connection-GSM Onshore Yuan subscriber
  2. 2. Call Rates as on 23 rd September 2011  6.50% - 8.35% Figure FactsForexForward Rates against INR as on 23rdSeptember, 2011 Spot Rate 1 mth 3 mth 6 mthUS 49.63 49.88 50.3 50.56Euro 66.8 67.12 67.68 68.06Sterling 76.52 76.88 77.49 77.84 16501.Yen 65.11 65.47 66.08 66.53 74Swiss 54.43 54.75 55.32 55.79Franc 4946.8 4867.7Source: Hindu BusinessLine 16162 5Libor RatesLibor % 1 mth 3 mth 6 mth 12 mthUS 0.23 0.36 0.54 0.84 Sensex NiftyEuro 1.29 1.48 1.69 2.03Sterling 0.68 0.93 1.21 1.69Yen 0.14 0.19 0.33 0.55Swiss Franc 0.003 0.010 0.057 0.29 64681Forward Cover 28134 1 mth 3 mth 6 mthUS 6.13% 5.47% 3.80%Euro 5.83% 5.34% 3.82%Sterling 5.72% 5.14% 3.50%Yen 6.73% 6.04% 4.42% 27271 58801Swiss Franc 7.15% 6.63% 5.07%as on 23rd September, 2011 Source: Hindu BusinessLine Gold (10 gm) Silver (1 KG)CommoditiesAluminum (1 kg) 108.65Copper (1 Kg) 397.40 50.01Zinc (1 kg) 96.75 110.9Steel L(1000kg) 31800As on 23 rd September 2011 104.0 8 45.35 Crude Oil (per barrel) Dollar th rd Data from 12 September to 23 September
  3. 3. StatsWatch YEAR Outlook -Coal Falling Connections- GSM subscribers Onshore Yuan For more than a decade, economists and officials in other countries have charged that the Chinese government has kept the value of its currency artificially low to make the countrys exports more affordable. China’s currency started appreciating in July 2005, remained stagnant from July 2008 till May 2010 and started appreciating again in June 2010. Spot Yuan (USD/ CNY) was at 6.3832 on 16 Sept, 2011. Though it was below its all time high of 6.3705 on Aug 30, it has risen 3.24% so far this year and 6.94% since its de- pegging in June 2010. Currently, inflation is the biggest threat faced by Chinese administration. Hence, China continues to focus on curbing inflation and to reduce the economy’s reliance on exports and Yuan appreciation is one of the tools to achieve that. China’s economic outlook isGloss rosier compared with developed countries, that helps stimulate demand for the currency. The Yuan is expected to strengthen and rise 4% to around 6.115 by the end of “Dumping” this year as the government uses it to reduce the nation’s inflationary pressure and helpThe practice of selling goods outside of the usual distribution channels, often its overheating economy,a foreign market, for a lower than normal price.
  4. 4. Cover Story Run up to our cover story “The crisis Continues-European Union” published 0n 6th June 2011 Eurozone in Intensive CareAlmost every day, warnings come thick and fast that the euro currency club cannot Further, the first view ignores the successful use of fiscal tightening to escape debtsurvive the ongoing Greek crisis. A wide range of policy makers and analysts are crises in, for example, Brazil and Turkey in the early 2000s as well as the oft-citedconvinced the eurozone will be torn apart by the wrangling over how much cash to examples of simultaneous austerity and expansion of Canada and Sweden in theloan the Greeks and how much of the countrys debt to write off. The government at 1990s. But they had the benefits of a rapidly recovering global economy to exportthe heart of concerns, Greece, risks being unable to pay wages and pensions, if the into as also had the ability to depreciate their currencies. Greece has neither. Itfunds (8 billion euros) are not released in next two weeks. Panicked officials are racing cannot escape its predicament using fiscal policy. It needs a debt restructuring.to plug a gaping hole in the budget and accelerate reforms to evade such a possibility. The second myth involves a willful or ignorant confusion of short-run stimulus andA hastily announced property tax which should raise about €2 billion, to keep the long-run solvency. The irony is that, assuming growth in their economies willbudget deficit below 9% of GDP this year, is a shot at pleasing international lenders. materialize despite short-run fiscal tightening; the US, the UK and Germany areA €13 bn bond-buying spree in the mid of September, by the European Central Bank jeopardizing the attempts of others to do the same. What those three countries(ECB) has compounded the controversy. The purchase of Italian and Spanish think will reassure the markets about solvency will in fact scare them aboutgovernment debt led to the resignation of Jürgen Stark, the ECBs hardline chief growth.economist, who argued that Rome and Madrid should be prevented from accessing Meanwhile, the source of much of this tension – the eurozone’s painfully slow andECB funds before instituting further austerity measures. disunited approach to resolving the Greek crisis – continues.The problem is that although a beefed-up EFSF (European Financial Stability Fund) The fine print of the fusswill be able to cope with the smaller peripherals, it is unable to support the For the uninitiated, the obvious solution to the problem may be Greece exitingrefinancing needs of an economy as big as Italy. At an auction of Italian five-year bonds eurozone. After all, it is the proverbial Achilles’ heel here. However, it is easieron September 13th its borrowing costs jumped to 5.6%, up from 4.9% at a similar thought of than done. Adopting the euro was designed to be irrevocable, andauction in July. Another problem is that the pressure on European banks is increasing. European Union treaties dont contain provisions that would permit a country toAgain, the real last resort is the ECB, which could relieve the pressures on the system leave. Amending the treaties could take years and requires unanimousby being prepared to buy without limit the bonds of solvent euro-zone countries. But agreement—including that of any country threatened with expulsion. That meansthe ECB is itself divided by disagreement. Greece cant be pushed out against its will. But fellow members could make life soFiscal policy in a debt crisis attracts two divergent views: one, austerity never works; difficult for Greece that is has no choice. After all, Greece depends almost entirelytwo, you don’t get out of debt by taking on more debt. Neither is necessarily true. But on loans from the euro zone and International Monetary Fund while the Europeanthe problem right now is that the first holds in Greece, where policy is based on Central Bank is providing badly needed liquidity to Greeces enfeebled banks.ignoring it, and the second fails to hold in Germany, the US and UK, where policy is Those faucets could be shut off.based on accepting it!
  5. 5. But such an action would be hugely costly. It would leave Greece with little or noability and incentive to service its euro denominated bonds. Remember, banksacross Europe hold Greek bonds and they would suffer giant losses. Duringsubprime crisis, toxic debt was hidden in ‘derivatives,’ and kept off balance-sheet.Now instead of sub-prime property loans, the banks across America and Europeare hiding toxic Greek debt in their assets: Thus even small exposures – US bankshold only $1.5bn (€1.1bn) in Greek debt, and British banks are on the hook for$3.4bn (€2.5bn) – could be masking considerably larger off-balance sheet risks.Besides the American and British exposure, the direct impact list include: Japanesebanks holding $432m (€316m) in Greek debt, Turkey $30.4bn (€22bn), Poland$8bn (€5.8bn), Croatia, Hungary and the Czech Republic combined are exposed tosome $460m (€336m) – and on through Bulgaria, Serbia, and Romania.A Banking CrisisNo wonder then that the sovereign debt crisis has transformed into a ‘BankingSector Crisis’.Greek default can lead to a severe liquidity crunch and flight to safety of depositsfrom not only Greek and euro area banks, but from a number of closely inter- Commotion Continuesconnected banking systems, especially those with close trading and investment Even if the banks exposure to Greece was minimized and their positionlinks to the European Economic Community. This is bound to induce contagion consolidated, there still are a couple of reasons that will keep the threat of aacross the entire euro area and spill over to euro area banks’ cross-links to Eastern broader collapse alive.and Central Europe and beyond. The first is that market pressures will move on to the next most likely "candidate"Already, credit-default-swap spreads for European banks, a measure of how costly to follow the path of Greece; Ireland and Portugal who have also received bailouts.it is to buy insurance against their default, are at record highs. The rates that banks There will most probably be speculation regarding the future of Spain and Italy.charge each other for loans in the interbank market are rising, too. Banks are The second issue is that if Greece eventually defaults, it will most probably re-finding it hard to issue longer-term debt, too. The market for unsecured bonds has adopt its national currency, the drachma, which implies that inflation will sharplybeen closed for weeks, leaving banks with no option but to sell covered bonds at rise leading to hyperinflation. This means that Greece will have absolutely nousurious interest rates that will challenge their profitability. capacity to trade with its European partners under free market conditions, since she will have to impose protectionist measures in an attempt to safeguard whatever is left of her economy.
  6. 6. The protectionist measures, together with the massive depreciation of the Greekcurrency, will have two effects: (a) Greek exports will become very cheap andtherefore will be preferred over the equivalent products of Greeces competitors,who are also part of the Euro (b) Greece will act like a black hole that will absorball the money that is thrown her way without giving anything away (since she willmostly export and not import). This will understandably destabilize trade, whichagain will have negative implications for the rest as it will as well lead to a viciouscycle.At any rate the catastrophic implications of a Greek exit or default are such thatwill force European leaders to devise any sort of action that will prevent them.EurobondWith the European Union (EU) on the brink, the world is hoping that the political note that its debt is far higher, so the ripple effects could be more serious.leadership in eurozone agrees to plans for a common euro zone sovereign bond Total Greek public debt is about 370 billion euros, or $500 billion. By comparison,that could avert Europe’s “Lehman moment”, and the prospect of fresh financial Argentinas debt was $82 billion when it defaulted in 2001; when Russia defaulted, incontagion. Although such a bond cannot address the deeper structural issues that 1998, its debt was $79 billion.the euro zone faces, of slow growth and political asymmetries, this joint debt issue At its heart, the eurozones problems remain rooted in the banking sector. A decisionwill go some way towards easing the impending credit crunch by lowering the cost by the French and German parliaments to underwrite their biggest at-risk banksof borrowing for debt-ridden countries and, as important, sending signals to the would take the problem off the table for now. But policymakers remain in denial andinvestor community that Europe’s strong economies are – finally – ready to take prevarication among politicians dumps the problem back in the ECBs lap. Insome responsibility for the smaller and weaker states. A euro-bond issue will also particular, work on transforming Europes main financial rescue vehicle, the proposedgive Europe the breather it needs to redefine the contours of the monetary union. 440 billion euro European Financial Stability Facility, would have to be fast tracked soOne sticking point about the euro bond is that it is likely to come with stricter and that it would be in a position to buy European bonds and, crucially, provide emergencymore intrusive financial oversight, at which member countries may baulk. loans to countries that need to inject money into capital starved banks.Conclusion Rising government credit risks, including recent Italy’s downgrade, shaky assetWhile other countries have defaulted on their sovereign debt in recent times markets, weakening growth: the makers of the horror movie of 2008 are clearlywithout causing systemic contagion, analysts weighing the numbers on Greece contemplating a sequel – “Lehman Brothers II: This Time its Sovereign”.
  7. 7. Everonn to sell 12% stake to Dubai-based GEMS Contracts for 7,300 km roads to be awarded by Education for Rs 138 crore March-end: Joshi Embattled Chennai-based Company Everonn Education, The government today said contracts for laying over whose founder is in jail, will sell a 12% stake for Rs 138 7,300 km roads will be awarded by the end of current12th rate hike by RBI; loans to cost more crore to Dubai-based GEMS Education via a preferential financial year."...Before the year ends, we will awardConcerned over high inflation, the Reserve Bank on 16th allotment of shares. Each share will cost GEMS 528, an concessions for over 7,300 km (roads). This will harnessSeptember 2011 raised key interest rates by 25 basis over 40% premium to Tuesdays (20th September 2011) private investment of over Rs 50,000 crore," Road,points, its 12th such hike since March, 2010, making auto, closing price. GEMS belongs to the Varkey Group, founded Transport & Highways Minister C P Joshi said at thehome and other loans more expensive. Following the by Padmashri Award recipient and Dubai-based NRI Conference on Public Private Partnership (PPP) inincrease, the short-term lending (repo) rate stands at 8.25 entrepreneur Sunny Varkey. National Highways: Challenges & Opportunities. He saidper cent and the short-term borrowing rate (reverse that out of Indias highways network of 71,000 km, uprepo) is 7.25 per cent. The RBI, while announcing its mid- Desktops wont die so soon gradation projects for about 16,000 km have beenterm review of the monetary policy, kept all other rates In the April-June quarter, desktop PCs accounted for 61 completed, while about 15,000 km are in differentand ratios unchanged per cent of the total market size of 2.5 million PC units stages of implementation of being awarded. sold (the installed base is estimated at around 53 millionConsumer Price Index up 1.18% in Aug; food and units), according to Gartner. In 2011, while the growth ofclothing dearer desktops is expected to rise 10 per cent to 6.74 millionExpensive food and clothing pushed up the Consumer units, the share of desktops as a percentage of total PCPrice Index (CPI) by 1.18 per cent in August vis-a-vis the shipments is expected to fall marginally to 60 per cent. Inprevious month, but experts said too much should not be 2012, desktops are estimated to grow by 11.9 per centread into the numbers, as the data on retail prices is yet to (7.54 million units).stabilise. The CPI based on retail prices stood at 111.7points in August, compared to 110.4 points in July, as per 12th rate hike by RBI; loans to cost moredata released by the government. The main increase was Concerned over high inflation, the Reserve Bank on 16thseen in the prices of vegetables, with the index rising by September 2011 raised key interest rates by 25 basis4.61 per cent month-on-month to 113.4 points, while the points, its 12th such hike since March, 2010, making auto,indices for milk and milk products and fruits went up by home and other loans more expensive. Following theover 1 per cent each. increase, the short-term lending (repo) rate stands at 8.25 per cent and the short-term borrowing rate (reverse repo) is 7.25 per cent.
  8. 8. Emerging Markets Indonesia: Coal production may reach 370 million discount-deals operator, acquired Ensogo, a Thai tons this year company operating the same business, while Rakuten, aSouth Africa: No surprise as rates held steady Given current production trends, Indonesian coal output Japanese e- commerce company, bought Tarad.com, aThe Reserve Bank has left the repo rate unchanged at may reach 370 million tons by the end of this year, if Thai online market. The two global players came to5.5%, as widely forecast. Although economic data out rainfall is not too excessive during the final three months, Thailand as they are looking to expand to the fast-this week sent mixed signals about the state of the the Indonesian Coal Mining Association (APBI) growing, less-crowded Asian market.South African economy, the dovish stance of the announced. The association said that from January tomonetary policy committee (MPC) after its three-day August, the country’s coal production had already Egypt asks U.S. business for help, urges investmentmeeting was no surprise. Money markets factored in reached 235 million tons. Earlier estimates had targeted Badly in need of cash flow, Egypt appealed to the U.S.a small chance of a repo rate cut late this year or this year’s coal production to between 340 million and business community to help the country rebuild followingearly next year, but the steep rand depreciation may 360 million tons. In 2011, Bob predicted that around 65 street protests that pushed its president out in February.limit further monetary loosening. million tons of coal would be sold to the domestic market The Egyptian government has forecast growth of through the domestic market obligation (DMO) somewhere between 3 to 3.5 percent in the current fiscalIndonesia: Rupiah drops to lowest rate this regulation, which requires coal producers to sell a part of year ending June and has narrowed its budget deficit toyear their production to local buyers.In 2012, he estimated 8.6 percent of gross domestic productThe rupiah dropped to 9,367 per US dollar at that 75 million tons of coal would be allocated for theopening time on 22nd September morning, its lowest country’s coal users. Singapore jobless rate up slightly in Q2position since May last year. Commonwealth Bank Singapores final unemployment rate increased slightly incurrency analyst Mika Martumpal said the rupiah Thailand: Thai tech companies draw global the second quarter, but is lower than the preliminarydepreciation had followed the falling stock and interest figure of 2.2 per cent reported in July. According to thecommodity markets. He said many investors had let Competition in the local online business is heating up Ministry of Manpower (MOM), the overall unemploymentgo of stocks and bonds and shifted to dollars, further with some global companies exploring opportunities to rate increased from a seasonally adjusted 1.9 per cent inpressuring the rupiah.“The market [situation] has buy or form partnerships with Thai online firms to March 2011 to 2.1 per cent in June 2011 with the slowerbeen triggered by the Greek default risk and the provide services here. Baidu, a Chinese search engine unemployment growth. Services continued to generatedecision of the [US] Federal Reserve, announced last operator, is in talks to invest in some Thai websites with the bulk of the employment gains, adding 20,200 workersnight,” Mika said. strong customer bases such as Mthai and Kapook, said an in the second quarter. Construction expanded by 3,600, industry source. Earlier, Living Social, a US online higher while manufacturing rose by 800, up from the flat gains (100) in the previous quarter.
  9. 9. Open Forum InFocus It takes 32 Rs. to cross poverty line! POLICY RATE HIKE: The other side of DiscussionIf a person is spending more than Rs.32 a day in urban India, is he poor? No. All I Said Was Don’t Ignore Turkey Rate Cuts & Fall in Inflation: BasuAtleast the Planning Commission thinks so! According to a reply submitted by the In the run up to the monetary policy review on September 16,Planning Commission to the Supreme Court, anyone spending more than Rs 965 chief economic advisor Kaushik Basu said he did not favour an interest rate increase. Theper month in urban India and Rs 781 in rural India will be deemed to be not poor. RBI lifted the key policy rate 25 basis points.This effectively means that those spending in excess of Rs 32 a day in urban areas Contrary to what you were advising, the RBI has raised rates. Does this show aor Rs 26 a day in villages would no longer be eligible to draw benefits of central conflict among the decision-makers?and state government welfare schemes for those living below the poverty line. Not at all. Let me first clarify that what I advised RBI was to “consider” not raising theNot surprisingly, it has created outrage among activists who feel it’s a ploy to interest rate. Turkey, despite high inflation, began lowering interest rates from theartificially depress the number of poor in India. However, commission maintains middle of last year. Critics were fully braced for further inflation. What happened wasthat these were provisional figures based on the Tendulkar committee report interesting. Turkey’s growth rate rose—as expected; Turkey now stands with China atupdated for current prices by taking account of the Consumer Price Index for the top of the league among G20 nations. The surprise was in the inflation. Far fromIndustrial and Agricultural workers. rising it came down from over 10% in April 2010 to around 6%. I am fully aware thatPractically applying this idea of Planning Commission would yield following nations have their own idiosyncracies; but we must not dismiss other nations’picture according to prices in the national capital: experiences out of hand. I used the Turkish experience—and some of Brazil—and also some economic theory to argue that it is no longer obvious that India should continue to raise interest rates. I urged the RBI to think out of the box and then act. It is my job as an economic adviser to float new ideas and not simply parrot the majority opinion. And I am glad that India’s policy cycle is robust enough that we can openly discuss different ideas. It is RBI’s job to take a final call. I like to believe that it did consider my views and then took the decision. The Reserve Bank is a thinking organization and I have great respect for those at its helm. But that does not mean that we will all reach the same conclusion. Total coincidence of opinions is not a sign of good government but of a bad totalitarian state.
  10. 10. The Turkish Central Bank lowered interest rates not to control inflation but to counter capital inflows?You are right about that. But the reason for which Turkey did this is of no interest to me. Turkey’s action has thrown up evidence that is of interest. Fleming did not discoverpenicillin because he was looking for it; it was a by-product of other activity. It is entirely possible that after studying this serendipitous experiment we will conclude that it isunlikely to be repeated in India. I am fine with that. But we must have the openness to examine it.Do you believe, as some have argued, that to control inflation India has to keep its growth down to below 8%?No I don’t. The kind of research which leads to such a belief entails statistically extending a nation’s past experience to create a potential growth path. For a dynamic nation ona take-off path, such as India, such projections are deeply misleading. There are many economies in early stages that have grown consistently beyond what would have beenconsidered their capacity growth by this calculation. From 1966 to the end of the 70s, South Korea grew at astonishing rates, often above 10% per annum. This was also aperiod when it had high inflation. In fact, barring one year, it had double-digit inflation for this entire 14-year stretch. It is important to see that neither of these two trends gotin the way of the other. It would have been a mistake if Korea had cut its growth back during this vital period in the belief that it was performing above capacity.Are inflation and slowdown signs of the government running out of ideas and the Indian miracle coming to an end?The inflation situation and the slowdown in growth are indeed a matter of concern, but let us not get things out of proportion. A growth rate of 7.7%—the figure Indiaachieved in the first quarter of 2011-12—is disappointing compared to what we have achieved in recent times. But by any international comparison it is remarkableperformance. The fact that it disappoints us shows more than anything else how our yardstick has changed. We are demanding of India, which is a good sign. As for inflation,9.8% is unacceptably high and we have to work to bring it down. But once again we have to recognize that there are nations—industrialized and emerging-—that have hadinflation many times more than that. Further, India’s nominal income is growing by roughly 18% per annum. So even if inflation takes away 10 of those percentage points,people have more real goods and services to consume each year by a hefty 8%. This is no mean achievement.Should we accept high inflation and press full throttle on growth?We should not accept it and we press full throttle. Let me explain. I have argued elsewhere that it is natural to get an additional 2 percentage points of inflation during anation’s rapid growth phase. If in addition we treat up to 2 or 3 inflation as standard as many central banks do, even then we are talking of an inflation of less than 5%. I am infavor of using such a target. I don’t think that just because we are in a high growth phase we have to inflate faster. At times, in rapidly growing economies such as ours orKorea’s in the seventies, there is so much change that inflation goes up as happened in Korea and is happening here. But there is no “has to” about this. We simply need to findthe new policy rules, for a new and changing economy.
  11. 11. About Investeurs Consulting P. Limited Investeurs Consulting Pvt. Ltd. is a business and financial advisory company, successfully serving businesses since 1994; we offer advisory and consultancy services for successful fund syndication. We have serviced diverse businesses by arranging finance of over $1600 million. We are strategic advisors to our clients during the ideation phase, implementation guides through start-up phase, and trusted advisors overall. All businesses go through a similar life cycle.Once an idea is conceived and a business is established, a company requires capital to fund ongoing growth and expansion. The Capital Structure has to be optimally structured during each phase of business cycle. Investeurs perceives the requirement and accordingly arranges funds to help companies smoothly achieve milestones in the process. Investeurs Competency Kit  Alignment of services with client’s business  Round the year Financial assistance  Facilitator between Banks and Clients  Hassel free & on time service  Industry & Market updatesTeamChronicleBhavna Goal bhavna@investeurs.com NidhiGogia- nidhi@investeurs.comAkanksha Srivastva akanksha@investeurs.com Harpreet Kaur harpreet@investeurs.comDisclaimer: Investeurs Chronicles is prepared by Research & Analysis Team of Investeurs Consulting Private Limited to provide the recipient with relevant information pertaining to the world economy. Theinformation contained in the document is based on the releases made by various newspaper & publications; hence, we are not responsible for any inaccuracies in the information provided.  Investeurs Consulting P. Limited   S-16, U.G.F, Green Park Ext. New Delhi-110016, www.investeurs.com