SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 10
New GASB Updates and Rating Agency Comments
Presented By
Henrich Y. Edimo
History
 On June 25,2012, GASB took Steps to improve the reporting of pension
liabilities by states and local governments and pension plans by using
statements No. 67 (Financial Reporting for Pension Plan) and No. 68
(Accounting and Financial Reporting for Pensions).
 These improvements among others, include the requirement for net
pension liability to be reported on the Balance Sheet
 Prior to the implementation of GASB’s Statement No. 68, some
estimates put government net pension liability at approximately $1
trillion. Estimates of this unfunded liability after Statement No. 68
exceed $3 trillion.
Types of Retirement Systems
 Single Employer: Employer has its own separate account with specific
details regarding its pension assets and liabilities in the annual
financials.
 Agent Multi-employer: Same as single employer system (e.g. Virginia
Employees Retirement System).
 Cost Sharing: Employers don’t have their own separate account and
they have no specific details regarding their pension assets and
liabilities in the annual financials. Only system –wide assets and
liability are shown.
Disclosures
 GASB Statement No. 67
 It mandates a statement of fiduciary net position (amount held in trust
for paying retirement benefits) and a statement of changes in fiduciary
net position.
 It enhances note disclosure s and the RSI (Required Supplementary
Information) for both defined benefit and defined contribution plans.
 It requires the presentation of new information about annual money-
weighted ROR in the footnotes and in 10-years RSI Schedule.
 Defines contribution plan remain unchanged.
Disclosures Continued
 GASB Statement No. 68
 It requires governments providing defined benefit plans to report the
net pension liability in their statement of net assets (Difference
between the present value of pension liability and the fair value of
pension assets, set aside in a trust).
 It mandates pension expenses to be recognized currently. These
expenses/cost structure include: annual service cost and interest on
pension liability, effect on the net pension liability on changes in
benefit terms, effect on difference actuarial assumptions and actual
experience.
 For governments participating in cost-sharing plans, Statement No. 68
requires reporting liabilities and expenses equal to their proportionate
share of their collective net pension liabilities and expenses for the
plan.
Potential Challenges and Issues/
Balance Sheet Effect
 Considerable additional work for actuaries - drives cost.
 May be delays completing work due to understanding and/or
implementing new rules.
 Staff and auditors for cost sharing plans may have a more difficult
learning curve than those with single employer systems.
 Investment return between now and implementation could have a big
effect on the balance sheet.
 Often large surprises for cost sharing employers who usually did not
show employer-specific unfunded liabilities.
 Broad range of effects when measured as a percent of assets or net
assets.
 Late CAFR will be more common than usual during implementation.
 Rating agencies will have a lot of detail to track, much to learn.
Moody’s Thoughts
 Moody’s comments on four areas:
 Multiple-employer cost-sharing plan liabilities would be allocated to
specific government employers based on proportionate share of total
plan contribution.
 Actuarial accrued liabilities would be adjusted based on a high –grade
corporate bond index discount rate .
 Asset smoothing would be replaced with the market value as of the
actuarial reporting date.
 Annual pension contributions would be adjusted to reflect the
foregoing changes as well a common amortization period.
General Effect of Moody’s Proposed Discount Rate
 This implies:
 Another discount rate , in addition to what is used for GASB reporting
 Another alternative estimates of liabilities and unfunded liabilities.
 Another set of #s to explain to investors. City council, tax payers and
media.
 If implemented as proposed, Moody’s would use the same discount rate
for all retirement systems regardless of
 Asset Allocation
 Cost of Investment or administration
 Funded ratio
 Whether open to new hires or not
Conclusion
 Despite varying reports on the exact amount of unfunded liability, the
fact remains that public pension plans undoubtedly have assets
substantially below the present value of the future promises. Full
disclosure of the funding status is critical. While mere recognition of
these net pension liability does not solve the problem, full disclosure is
necessary to allow informed decisions by users and for policy makers to
fully vet solution.
QUESTIONS
 Why Change GASB 25 & 27 Standards ?
 What level of education and training is being provided by GASB and
rating agencies to help stakeholders understand these statements?
 Are rating agencies regulated today? If Yes, by whom and how
independent are those ratings?
 What criteria should we use to determine the discount rate?
 What impact will the entry age methodology have on the fund?
 The implementation of these standards will require considerable
additional work for actuaries, attorneys, auditors and accountants.
Who will foot the bill?
 What is motivating the rating agencies to act swiftly with respect to the
changes implemented by GASB?
 What will be the learning curve towards understanding and
implementing the new standards?

More Related Content

What's hot

Lessons from the Front Lines of GASB 75 Reporting
Lessons from the Front Lines of GASB 75 ReportingLessons from the Front Lines of GASB 75 Reporting
Lessons from the Front Lines of GASB 75 ReportingJim van Iwaarden
 
B2B Webinar January 2011
B2B Webinar January 2011B2B Webinar January 2011
B2B Webinar January 2011dlinehan2
 
Harcourt Brown & Carey NGA State Clean Energy Financing Presentation
Harcourt Brown & Carey NGA State Clean Energy Financing PresentationHarcourt Brown & Carey NGA State Clean Energy Financing Presentation
Harcourt Brown & Carey NGA State Clean Energy Financing PresentationHarcourtBrownEF
 
ASC 606, Revenue From Contracts with Customers Health Care: What to Expect
ASC 606, Revenue From Contracts with Customers Health Care:  What to ExpectASC 606, Revenue From Contracts with Customers Health Care:  What to Expect
ASC 606, Revenue From Contracts with Customers Health Care: What to ExpectCitrin Cooperman
 
GASB 75 Implementation Issues
GASB 75 Implementation IssuesGASB 75 Implementation Issues
GASB 75 Implementation IssuesJim van Iwaarden
 
Top Common Code Section 403(b) Problems and Solutions
Top Common Code Section 403(b) Problems and SolutionsTop Common Code Section 403(b) Problems and Solutions
Top Common Code Section 403(b) Problems and SolutionsMultnomah Group, Inc.
 
DC Plans in a Post-PPA Environment
DC Plans in a Post-PPA EnvironmentDC Plans in a Post-PPA Environment
DC Plans in a Post-PPA EnvironmentRita Holder
 
Advanced Markets Insight: Life Insurance Basics—Life Insurance Pricing and Po...
Advanced Markets Insight: Life Insurance Basics—Life Insurance Pricing and Po...Advanced Markets Insight: Life Insurance Basics—Life Insurance Pricing and Po...
Advanced Markets Insight: Life Insurance Basics—Life Insurance Pricing and Po...M Financial Group
 
TAC Dept of Labor 401k Brochure
TAC Dept of Labor 401k BrochureTAC Dept of Labor 401k Brochure
TAC Dept of Labor 401k BrochureRichard Holtheuer
 
Understanding the Impact of Health Care Reform on Your Business in 2013
Understanding the Impact of Health Care Reform on Your Business in 2013Understanding the Impact of Health Care Reform on Your Business in 2013
Understanding the Impact of Health Care Reform on Your Business in 2013Insperity
 
Ruffner Fallacy of Best Practice
Ruffner Fallacy of Best PracticeRuffner Fallacy of Best Practice
Ruffner Fallacy of Best Practiceicgfmconference
 
Nonprofit @ bec doms
Nonprofit @   bec domsNonprofit @   bec doms
Nonprofit @ bec domsBabasab Patil
 

What's hot (20)

Lessons from the Front Lines of GASB 75 Reporting
Lessons from the Front Lines of GASB 75 ReportingLessons from the Front Lines of GASB 75 Reporting
Lessons from the Front Lines of GASB 75 Reporting
 
2013 Regulatory Update
2013 Regulatory Update2013 Regulatory Update
2013 Regulatory Update
 
B2B Webinar January 2011
B2B Webinar January 2011B2B Webinar January 2011
B2B Webinar January 2011
 
Harcourt Brown & Carey NGA State Clean Energy Financing Presentation
Harcourt Brown & Carey NGA State Clean Energy Financing PresentationHarcourt Brown & Carey NGA State Clean Energy Financing Presentation
Harcourt Brown & Carey NGA State Clean Energy Financing Presentation
 
ASC 606, Revenue From Contracts with Customers Health Care: What to Expect
ASC 606, Revenue From Contracts with Customers Health Care:  What to ExpectASC 606, Revenue From Contracts with Customers Health Care:  What to Expect
ASC 606, Revenue From Contracts with Customers Health Care: What to Expect
 
GASB 75 Implementation Issues
GASB 75 Implementation IssuesGASB 75 Implementation Issues
GASB 75 Implementation Issues
 
Top Common Code Section 403(b) Problems and Solutions
Top Common Code Section 403(b) Problems and SolutionsTop Common Code Section 403(b) Problems and Solutions
Top Common Code Section 403(b) Problems and Solutions
 
DC Plans in a Post-PPA Environment
DC Plans in a Post-PPA EnvironmentDC Plans in a Post-PPA Environment
DC Plans in a Post-PPA Environment
 
Florida retirement system project
Florida retirement system projectFlorida retirement system project
Florida retirement system project
 
Advanced Markets Insight: Life Insurance Basics—Life Insurance Pricing and Po...
Advanced Markets Insight: Life Insurance Basics—Life Insurance Pricing and Po...Advanced Markets Insight: Life Insurance Basics—Life Insurance Pricing and Po...
Advanced Markets Insight: Life Insurance Basics—Life Insurance Pricing and Po...
 
Pensions Core Course 2013: Prefunding pensions - options and arguments
Pensions Core Course 2013: Prefunding pensions - options and argumentsPensions Core Course 2013: Prefunding pensions - options and arguments
Pensions Core Course 2013: Prefunding pensions - options and arguments
 
08 State Export finance funds brown
08 State Export finance funds   brown08 State Export finance funds   brown
08 State Export finance funds brown
 
TAC Dept of Labor 401k Brochure
TAC Dept of Labor 401k BrochureTAC Dept of Labor 401k Brochure
TAC Dept of Labor 401k Brochure
 
Correcting Plan Errors
Correcting Plan Errors Correcting Plan Errors
Correcting Plan Errors
 
Understanding Modified Endowment Contracts (MEC)
Understanding Modified Endowment Contracts (MEC)Understanding Modified Endowment Contracts (MEC)
Understanding Modified Endowment Contracts (MEC)
 
Understanding the Impact of Health Care Reform on Your Business in 2013
Understanding the Impact of Health Care Reform on Your Business in 2013Understanding the Impact of Health Care Reform on Your Business in 2013
Understanding the Impact of Health Care Reform on Your Business in 2013
 
Ruffner Fallacy of Best Practice
Ruffner Fallacy of Best PracticeRuffner Fallacy of Best Practice
Ruffner Fallacy of Best Practice
 
Opeb now what
Opeb   now whatOpeb   now what
Opeb now what
 
Nonprofit @ bec doms
Nonprofit @   bec domsNonprofit @   bec doms
Nonprofit @ bec doms
 
BUS02DEC10MAI1FUL040
BUS02DEC10MAI1FUL040BUS02DEC10MAI1FUL040
BUS02DEC10MAI1FUL040
 

Similar to GASB Statements 67 68

GASB's New Rules on Uniformity and Disclosure
GASB's New Rules on Uniformity and Disclosure GASB's New Rules on Uniformity and Disclosure
GASB's New Rules on Uniformity and Disclosure CBIZ, Inc.
 
Grant Thornton - Higher Education News 2012 UK
Grant Thornton - Higher Education News 2012 UKGrant Thornton - Higher Education News 2012 UK
Grant Thornton - Higher Education News 2012 UKGrant Thornton
 
1.This situation can exist because companies vary as to whether th.pdf
1.This situation can exist because companies vary as to whether th.pdf1.This situation can exist because companies vary as to whether th.pdf
1.This situation can exist because companies vary as to whether th.pdfapleathers
 
The Importance of an Educational Policy Statement for 401k Plans
The Importance of an Educational Policy Statement for 401k PlansThe Importance of an Educational Policy Statement for 401k Plans
The Importance of an Educational Policy Statement for 401k PlansThe 401k Study Group ®
 
Governmental Audit Update
Governmental Audit UpdateGovernmental Audit Update
Governmental Audit UpdateDiane Bradley
 
PPI - the role of CDC in decumulation
PPI - the role of CDC in decumulationPPI - the role of CDC in decumulation
PPI - the role of CDC in decumulationHenry Tapper
 
Client Alert: February 2009
Client Alert: February 2009Client Alert: February 2009
Client Alert: February 2009SES Advisors
 
University of illinois institute of government and public affairs six simpl...
University of illinois institute of government and public affairs   six simpl...University of illinois institute of government and public affairs   six simpl...
University of illinois institute of government and public affairs six simpl...Cook County Commissioner Bridget Gainer
 
L2 flash cards financial reporting - SS 6
L2 flash cards financial reporting - SS 6L2 flash cards financial reporting - SS 6
L2 flash cards financial reporting - SS 6analystbuddy
 
PPACA: Staying Compliant & Strategic
PPACA: Staying Compliant & StrategicPPACA: Staying Compliant & Strategic
PPACA: Staying Compliant & StrategicCBIZ, Inc.
 
Wage in Retirement
Wage in RetirementWage in Retirement
Wage in RetirementHenry Tapper
 
First, the retained earnings increased by 85.35 compared from
First, the retained earnings increased by 85.35 compared fromFirst, the retained earnings increased by 85.35 compared from
First, the retained earnings increased by 85.35 compared fromShainaBoling829
 
How to Avoid a Head-on Collision with The Cadillac Tax
How to Avoid a Head-on Collision with The Cadillac TaxHow to Avoid a Head-on Collision with The Cadillac Tax
How to Avoid a Head-on Collision with The Cadillac TaxBill Conlan
 
Plan Design 101
Plan Design 101Plan Design 101
Plan Design 101dlinehan2
 
Plan Design 101
Plan Design 101Plan Design 101
Plan Design 101dlinehan2
 
QMV Commonwealth Budget Update - 2018-19
QMV Commonwealth Budget Update - 2018-19QMV Commonwealth Budget Update - 2018-19
QMV Commonwealth Budget Update - 2018-19Jonathan Steffanoni
 
Improvements Proposed to Accounting for Defined Benefit Plans
Improvements Proposed to Accounting for Defined Benefit PlansImprovements Proposed to Accounting for Defined Benefit Plans
Improvements Proposed to Accounting for Defined Benefit PlansMHM (Mayer Hoffman McCann P.C.)
 
Tpub investor deck_2q15_final
Tpub investor deck_2q15_finalTpub investor deck_2q15_final
Tpub investor deck_2q15_finaltribuneIR
 

Similar to GASB Statements 67 68 (20)

GASB's New Rules on Uniformity and Disclosure
GASB's New Rules on Uniformity and Disclosure GASB's New Rules on Uniformity and Disclosure
GASB's New Rules on Uniformity and Disclosure
 
Grant Thornton - Higher Education News 2012 UK
Grant Thornton - Higher Education News 2012 UKGrant Thornton - Higher Education News 2012 UK
Grant Thornton - Higher Education News 2012 UK
 
Puzzlebox comp 2010
Puzzlebox comp 2010Puzzlebox comp 2010
Puzzlebox comp 2010
 
1.This situation can exist because companies vary as to whether th.pdf
1.This situation can exist because companies vary as to whether th.pdf1.This situation can exist because companies vary as to whether th.pdf
1.This situation can exist because companies vary as to whether th.pdf
 
The Importance of an Educational Policy Statement for 401k Plans
The Importance of an Educational Policy Statement for 401k PlansThe Importance of an Educational Policy Statement for 401k Plans
The Importance of an Educational Policy Statement for 401k Plans
 
Governmental Audit Update
Governmental Audit UpdateGovernmental Audit Update
Governmental Audit Update
 
PPI - the role of CDC in decumulation
PPI - the role of CDC in decumulationPPI - the role of CDC in decumulation
PPI - the role of CDC in decumulation
 
Client Alert: February 2009
Client Alert: February 2009Client Alert: February 2009
Client Alert: February 2009
 
University of illinois institute of government and public affairs six simpl...
University of illinois institute of government and public affairs   six simpl...University of illinois institute of government and public affairs   six simpl...
University of illinois institute of government and public affairs six simpl...
 
L2 flash cards financial reporting - SS 6
L2 flash cards financial reporting - SS 6L2 flash cards financial reporting - SS 6
L2 flash cards financial reporting - SS 6
 
PPACA: Staying Compliant & Strategic
PPACA: Staying Compliant & StrategicPPACA: Staying Compliant & Strategic
PPACA: Staying Compliant & Strategic
 
Wage in Retirement
Wage in RetirementWage in Retirement
Wage in Retirement
 
First, the retained earnings increased by 85.35 compared from
First, the retained earnings increased by 85.35 compared fromFirst, the retained earnings increased by 85.35 compared from
First, the retained earnings increased by 85.35 compared from
 
How to Avoid a Head-on Collision with The Cadillac Tax
How to Avoid a Head-on Collision with The Cadillac TaxHow to Avoid a Head-on Collision with The Cadillac Tax
How to Avoid a Head-on Collision with The Cadillac Tax
 
Plan Design 101
Plan Design 101Plan Design 101
Plan Design 101
 
Plan Design 101
Plan Design 101Plan Design 101
Plan Design 101
 
QMV Commonwealth Budget Update - 2018-19
QMV Commonwealth Budget Update - 2018-19QMV Commonwealth Budget Update - 2018-19
QMV Commonwealth Budget Update - 2018-19
 
CompendiumOne
CompendiumOneCompendiumOne
CompendiumOne
 
Improvements Proposed to Accounting for Defined Benefit Plans
Improvements Proposed to Accounting for Defined Benefit PlansImprovements Proposed to Accounting for Defined Benefit Plans
Improvements Proposed to Accounting for Defined Benefit Plans
 
Tpub investor deck_2q15_final
Tpub investor deck_2q15_finalTpub investor deck_2q15_final
Tpub investor deck_2q15_final
 

More from Heinrich Edimo

Oil Tariffs on Non Arms Length Pipeline
Oil Tariffs on Non Arms Length PipelineOil Tariffs on Non Arms Length Pipeline
Oil Tariffs on Non Arms Length PipelineHeinrich Edimo
 
1-205 Federal Royalty Auditing - Training2
1-205 Federal Royalty Auditing - Training21-205 Federal Royalty Auditing - Training2
1-205 Federal Royalty Auditing - Training2Heinrich Edimo
 
GASB Scope of Authority & FAF Oversight
GASB Scope of Authority & FAF OversightGASB Scope of Authority & FAF Oversight
GASB Scope of Authority & FAF OversightHeinrich Edimo
 
Lean-Six Sigma for Employees
Lean-Six Sigma for EmployeesLean-Six Sigma for Employees
Lean-Six Sigma for EmployeesHeinrich Edimo
 
Edimo Henrich Week 6-7 Group Leader Discussion
Edimo Henrich Week 6-7 Group Leader DiscussionEdimo Henrich Week 6-7 Group Leader Discussion
Edimo Henrich Week 6-7 Group Leader DiscussionHeinrich Edimo
 

More from Heinrich Edimo (6)

Oil Tariffs on Non Arms Length Pipeline
Oil Tariffs on Non Arms Length PipelineOil Tariffs on Non Arms Length Pipeline
Oil Tariffs on Non Arms Length Pipeline
 
1-205 Federal Royalty Auditing - Training2
1-205 Federal Royalty Auditing - Training21-205 Federal Royalty Auditing - Training2
1-205 Federal Royalty Auditing - Training2
 
GASB Scope of Authority & FAF Oversight
GASB Scope of Authority & FAF OversightGASB Scope of Authority & FAF Oversight
GASB Scope of Authority & FAF Oversight
 
Lean-Six Sigma for Employees
Lean-Six Sigma for EmployeesLean-Six Sigma for Employees
Lean-Six Sigma for Employees
 
Week 5 Presentation
Week 5 PresentationWeek 5 Presentation
Week 5 Presentation
 
Edimo Henrich Week 6-7 Group Leader Discussion
Edimo Henrich Week 6-7 Group Leader DiscussionEdimo Henrich Week 6-7 Group Leader Discussion
Edimo Henrich Week 6-7 Group Leader Discussion
 

GASB Statements 67 68

  • 1. New GASB Updates and Rating Agency Comments Presented By Henrich Y. Edimo
  • 2. History  On June 25,2012, GASB took Steps to improve the reporting of pension liabilities by states and local governments and pension plans by using statements No. 67 (Financial Reporting for Pension Plan) and No. 68 (Accounting and Financial Reporting for Pensions).  These improvements among others, include the requirement for net pension liability to be reported on the Balance Sheet  Prior to the implementation of GASB’s Statement No. 68, some estimates put government net pension liability at approximately $1 trillion. Estimates of this unfunded liability after Statement No. 68 exceed $3 trillion.
  • 3. Types of Retirement Systems  Single Employer: Employer has its own separate account with specific details regarding its pension assets and liabilities in the annual financials.  Agent Multi-employer: Same as single employer system (e.g. Virginia Employees Retirement System).  Cost Sharing: Employers don’t have their own separate account and they have no specific details regarding their pension assets and liabilities in the annual financials. Only system –wide assets and liability are shown.
  • 4. Disclosures  GASB Statement No. 67  It mandates a statement of fiduciary net position (amount held in trust for paying retirement benefits) and a statement of changes in fiduciary net position.  It enhances note disclosure s and the RSI (Required Supplementary Information) for both defined benefit and defined contribution plans.  It requires the presentation of new information about annual money- weighted ROR in the footnotes and in 10-years RSI Schedule.  Defines contribution plan remain unchanged.
  • 5. Disclosures Continued  GASB Statement No. 68  It requires governments providing defined benefit plans to report the net pension liability in their statement of net assets (Difference between the present value of pension liability and the fair value of pension assets, set aside in a trust).  It mandates pension expenses to be recognized currently. These expenses/cost structure include: annual service cost and interest on pension liability, effect on the net pension liability on changes in benefit terms, effect on difference actuarial assumptions and actual experience.  For governments participating in cost-sharing plans, Statement No. 68 requires reporting liabilities and expenses equal to their proportionate share of their collective net pension liabilities and expenses for the plan.
  • 6. Potential Challenges and Issues/ Balance Sheet Effect  Considerable additional work for actuaries - drives cost.  May be delays completing work due to understanding and/or implementing new rules.  Staff and auditors for cost sharing plans may have a more difficult learning curve than those with single employer systems.  Investment return between now and implementation could have a big effect on the balance sheet.  Often large surprises for cost sharing employers who usually did not show employer-specific unfunded liabilities.  Broad range of effects when measured as a percent of assets or net assets.  Late CAFR will be more common than usual during implementation.  Rating agencies will have a lot of detail to track, much to learn.
  • 7. Moody’s Thoughts  Moody’s comments on four areas:  Multiple-employer cost-sharing plan liabilities would be allocated to specific government employers based on proportionate share of total plan contribution.  Actuarial accrued liabilities would be adjusted based on a high –grade corporate bond index discount rate .  Asset smoothing would be replaced with the market value as of the actuarial reporting date.  Annual pension contributions would be adjusted to reflect the foregoing changes as well a common amortization period.
  • 8. General Effect of Moody’s Proposed Discount Rate  This implies:  Another discount rate , in addition to what is used for GASB reporting  Another alternative estimates of liabilities and unfunded liabilities.  Another set of #s to explain to investors. City council, tax payers and media.  If implemented as proposed, Moody’s would use the same discount rate for all retirement systems regardless of  Asset Allocation  Cost of Investment or administration  Funded ratio  Whether open to new hires or not
  • 9. Conclusion  Despite varying reports on the exact amount of unfunded liability, the fact remains that public pension plans undoubtedly have assets substantially below the present value of the future promises. Full disclosure of the funding status is critical. While mere recognition of these net pension liability does not solve the problem, full disclosure is necessary to allow informed decisions by users and for policy makers to fully vet solution.
  • 10. QUESTIONS  Why Change GASB 25 & 27 Standards ?  What level of education and training is being provided by GASB and rating agencies to help stakeholders understand these statements?  Are rating agencies regulated today? If Yes, by whom and how independent are those ratings?  What criteria should we use to determine the discount rate?  What impact will the entry age methodology have on the fund?  The implementation of these standards will require considerable additional work for actuaries, attorneys, auditors and accountants. Who will foot the bill?  What is motivating the rating agencies to act swiftly with respect to the changes implemented by GASB?  What will be the learning curve towards understanding and implementing the new standards?