Takeaways unwrapped event 070411 jemma grime presentation - changing market mechanisms barriers faced by the small business sector
Changing Market Mechanisms Barriers faced by the small business sector y Jemma Grime HBA Project Manager Wigan Council
IntroductionThe Healthy Business Award is delivered by Wigan Council, funded by NHSAshton, Leigh and Wigan and works in partnership with the School of Food g gScience and Nutrition at the University of Leeds.The HBA has a dedicated delivery team skilled in public health, food science,nutrition,nutrition business management, development & engagement and media & managementcommunications.The HBA has several different interventions which are designed by businesssector. tThe Healthy Business team works with cafes, restaurants, fish and chip shops,workplace canteens, nurseries, care homes, hospitals, stadia, vending and p , , , p , , gmanufacturers.
Small Independent Food SectorUnderstanding a business’s trading environment is key to improving thenutritional content of the food small businesses serve.Factors influencing the delivery of an effective intervention:• Motivation – are they interested in healthy eating?• Education – can they cook?• Financial – natural ingredients often more expensive, less shelf life expensive• Time – Short-staffed due to poor economic climate•P Perception – Wh i h l h f d? Will customers want it? i What is healthy food? i?• Management issues – Change in ownership, compliance with FoodSafety and Trading Standards legislation. legislation
Tackling the Businesses gMaintenance of the business’s trading environment, key considerations:Saturating the Healthier Choice market could prove too much competition for afixed market, contributing to further economic decline.The ‘Hard to Reach’ businesses do not like trying new ingredients and cookingpractices – consultative phased approach approach.Many consumers do not wish to eat healthily - by carrying out stealth changesthis issue is negated.Two key approaches:• Increasing labelling of healthier options – making it easier for people to eathealthily when they want toto.• Nutritionally improving businesses by reformulation, improved cookingpractices, procurement and portion size.
Case Study y Fish and Chip Shops• Business and consumer perception• Research - raw ingredients, p p g prepared ingredients, gingredient preparation, cooking and serving practices.• Health vs Taste – links between quality and health.• Engaging the businesses
Barriers faced on delivery of yintervention• K Knowledge and experience of f l d d i f fryer • Frying Practice • Ingredients e g potato variety & quality (seasonal variations) oil type e.g. variations), type. • Frequency of oil change – indicators of oil degradation • Speed of Service and ‘Hot Hold’ time Hot Hold• Equipment and facilities available.
Barriers faced on delivery ofinterventioni t ti• Equipment and facilities available . • Frying ranges are often 20 years old – simple tasks such as emptying and cleaning of range pans becomes difficult. • Temperature management issues issues.• Lack of awareness to oil : product.• Potato storage and prep area too cold cold.• Added sodium through batter mixes, gravy/curry mixes, bicarb for peas.• Additives including colourings and flavour enhancers enhancers.• Meal deals incentivising large portions.• Issues surrounding food safety safety.
Intervention Results• Fried products contain approx 27% less fat and saturated fat post intervention.• The fat that is absorbed in the product contains less undesirable compoundssuch as trans fats and acrylamide.• Cost of additional oil changes largely off-set by introducing more efficient andeconomical practices practices.• Shops report that they are busier due to increased product quality andmarketing of the HBA Fish and Chip shop work.• Type of fat used e.g. Palm Oil is generally used due to healthier oils being lessstable, taste preference, cost of the fat and the issue with equipment.• Portion sizes of chips are often reduced due to offering meal deals whichinclude peas at the expense of a few chips. Packaging methods which reduce theportion size are also trialled with the business.• Less sodium introduced into the product through pre-mixes.• Scraps no longer served.
Outcomes1. The HBA has improved the health of the borough’s residents through reducing fat, saturated fat, salt and added sugar and increasing the consumption of fruit, vegetables and fibre. The fish and chip p g p intervention is just one of several strands of the HBA programme. An estimated 70,000 premature deaths in the UK could be avoided each year if diets matched nutritional guidelines in terms of consumption of vegetables and reduced consumption of salt, saturated fat and added sugar. p , g This is more than 10% of current annual mortality. The health benefits of meeting the national nutritional guidelines have been estimated to be as high as £20 billion each year year. Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALY) Department of Health estimate.
Outcomes2. Food consumed from HBA premises contributes less to increasing b d f t i i body fatness th non-HBA premises. than HBA i Increasing body fatness is associated with serious medical complications for example diabetes hypertension CAD stroke and cancer diabetes, hypertension, CAD, cancer. Kopelman, P/ 2007. Helath Risks Associated with Overweight and Obesity. Short Science Review. Foresight Tackling Obesities; Future Choices. Obesity Reviews, 8 (s1); 13-17.Cost to the NHS: If the ratio of total costs of overweight and obesity to health service cost of obesity remains similar to 2001 (i.e. 7 to 1), by 2050, an overall total cost of overweight and obesity per annum of £49.9 £49 9 billion at today’s prices can be anticipated today s anticipated. McPherson, K., Marsh, T. and Brown, M. 2007. Modelling future Trends in Obesity and the Impact on Health; Foresight Tackling Obesities; Future Choices.
Outcomes3. The HBA is working towards reducing inequality in the g g q y borough with approximately 45% of HBA premises serving SOAs.4. The HBA has raised personal awareness around healthier lifestyles as shown by project evaluation and informal y y j feedback.5. HBA is helping to address salt perception through reformulation and added salt reduction, complementing the FSA’s salt reduction targets.