Unit 2: Education
2) Ethnic differences in achievement
Interpretation
• Gender and class differences exist within and
between ethnic groups.
• Remember that everyone has a class...
Application
• When answering an essay question on
ethnicity and achievement, refer to the
achievement patterns of a range ...
External factors and ethnic
differences
• Cultural deprivation
• Material deprivation
• Class
C.D. Intellectual and language skills
• C.D theorist claim: low-income black families
lack intellectual stimulation  fail...
Bereiter and Engelmann
• The language of poorer
black American families
is ungrammatical and
disjointed
•  their children...
C.D Attitudes, values + fam. structure
• C.D.T: the sub-culture into
which some black
children are socialised is
fatalisti...
C.D Attitudes, values + fam. structure
C.D.T:
• The lack of a male role-
model for Aff./Car. boys
encourage an ANTI-
EDUCA...
• Moynihan (1965): The Culture of poverty:
• Moynihan argues that the absence of a male
role model of achievement in black...
• Pryce (1979): The Impact o Slavery
• Pryce (1979) argues that Black Caribbean
culture is less resistant to racism becaus...
• Khan (1979): Asian Families
• Khan (1979) argues that the Asian family is an
obstacle to achievement
• Especially for gi...
Working working-class pupils
Most research has focused in ethnic minority families, but white working–class
pupils also un...
Lupton (2004): W.C White pupils
• Lupton (2004) studied four mainly working-class
schools with different ethnic compositio...
Evans (2006): W.C. White Pupils
• Evans (2006) argue that street culture in
white W.C. areas can be brutal
• And can be br...
Interpretation
• When answering a question on ethnicity and
achievement, don’t just refer to non-white
pupils
• Referring ...
Compensatory education
• Compensatory education  is an education
policy that aims to encounter the effects of
cultural de...
Analysis
• Explain how compensatory education is based
on the assumption that under-achievement is
caused by cultural depr...
Criticisms of cultural deprivation
Cultural deprivation theory has been widely criticised as an explanation of ethnic
diff...
Keddie: Victim-blaming
• Argues that cultural deprivation is a victim
blaming explanation
• Minority ethnic groups are cul...
Ball: Cultural exclusion
• Argues that minority ethnic group parents are
at a disadvantage because they are less aware
of ...
Cultural domination
• Compensatory education imposes the
dominant white middle-class culture on
minority ethnic group pupi...
Material deprivation and class
Material deprivation (or poverty) is a lack of physical or economic resources
essential for...
Interpretation
• Don’t let your answer on ethnicity and
achievement drift into one that’s really just
about class
• Make i...
Evidence: M.E.G are likely to face M.D
• Pakistani’s and Bangladeshi’s are more likely
to be poor
• For many minorities, u...
Evaluation
• While class plays an important part, it doesn’t
fully over-ride the influence of ethnicity:
• Pupils of the s...
Racism in wider society
• While material deprivation among minority
ethnic groups clearly affects pupils’
achievement, it ...
Internal factors and ethnic differences
Some sociologists focus on the impact of factors within school and the education
s...
Analysis
• Show you know all three and deal with them
separately, but also explain how they can be
linked together as part...
1. Labelling
Interactionalists focus on a small-scale, face-to-face interactions, such as those
between pupils and teacher...
Application
• When describing a factor (such as
labelling), make sure you spell out exactly
HOW it ultimately leads to edu...
Gillborn and Youdell (2000): Black pupils
• G & Y (2000) found teachers had ‘racialised
expections’ (labels) about black p...
cont. Gillborn and Youdell (2000): Black
pupils
• G & Y (2000) conclude that conflict between
white teachers and black pup...
Wright (1992): Asian pupils
• Research on Asian pupils shows evidence of teacher
stereotyping:
• Wright (1992) found that ...
Connolly (1998): Asian pupils
 Similarly, Connolly found that primary school
teachers saw Asian pupils as passive and
con...
Analysis
• Explain why these teacher actions might
reduce pupils’ self-esteem and create under-
achievement
2. Pupils subcultures
Pupils may react in a variety of different ways to racist labelling in school, including
forming or ...
Sewell (1998): Conformists
• Conformists were the
1st largest group
• They were keen to
succeed
• Accepted the school’s
go...
Sewell (1998): Innovators
• Innovators were the 2nd
largest
• They were pro-
education but anti-
school
• They valued
succ...
Sewell (1998): Retreatists
• Retreatists were a tiny
minority of isolated
individuals
disconnected from
both the school an...
Sewell (1998): Rebels
• Rebels were a small but
highly visible minority of
black pupils
• They rejected the school’s
goal ...
However...(REBELS)
 However, despite only a small minority of
black boys actually fitting the stereotype of
the ‘black ma...
Evaluation
• This tells us the range and characteristics of
possible pupil responses, but not why
different boys chose dif...
Interpretation
• You can use Sewell’s study to show you are
aware that pupils’ responses to racism in
schools vary conside...
O’Donnell and Sharpe (2000): Asian boys
• O’D & S (2000) found a macho ‘warrior’
response similar to the ‘rebels’ among so...
Rejecting negative labels
• Studies show that not all minority ethnic
pupils who are negatively labelled accept and
confor...
1. Fuller (1984): R.N.L
• Fuller (1984) studied a group of high-achieving
black girls in year 11 of a London comprehensive...
2. Mac an Ghaill (1992)
• M.G.’s study of black and Asian ‘A’ level students at a
sixth form college found that they did n...
Evaluation
• Use Fuller and Mac an Ghaill’s findings to
criticise labelling as deterministic – it doesn’t
inevitably resul...
3. Institutional Racism
Many sociologists argue that although the racist labelling practised by some teachers is
important...
The ethnocentric curriculum
• This is an important example of institutional
racism
• ‘Ethnocentric’ refers to an attitude ...
1. Troyna and Williams: E.C.C
• T & W note that the E.C.C gives priority to
white culture and the English
language, litera...
2. David: E.C.C
• David argues that the National Curriculum is a
‘specifically British’ curriculum that teaches
the cultur...
3. Ball: E.C.C
• Ball sees the history curriculum in British
schools as recreating a ‘mythical age of
empire of age and pa...
 The Result of evidence: 1. 2. and 3.
• The result may be that minority ethnic group
pupils feel that they and their cult...
Evaluation
• Although the school curriculum largely
ignores Asian culture, Indian and Chinese
pupils’ achievement is still...
Other examples of institutional
racism include:
1. Setting and streaming
2. Governing bodies
CRE (1992) study: Setting and streaming
• The CRE (1992) study of ‘Jayleigh’ school
found that Asian pupils were consisten...
Hatcher (1996): Governing bodies
• Hatcher (1996) found that schools’ governing
bodies:
1. Gave a low priority to ‘race’ i...
Analysis
• Show you know the difference between:
• individual racism (e.g. by teachers)
• and institutional racism ( resu...
Selection and segregation
• The selection procedures followed by schools
can also be a form of institutional racism
when t...
S & S: Commission for Racial Equality
(1993)
• C.for.R.E found racism in secondary schools’
admissions procedures, e.g. pr...
S & S: Marketisation
• Marketisation may make this (selection and
segregation) worse by increasing the amount of
selection...
S & S: (Gerwitz) Self-segregation
• Gerwitz found that Asian parents made active
choices to avoid ‘rough’ schools with a
r...
Evaluation
• Use examples of policies that promote
marketisation (see Topic 6), such as exam
league tables, to show how th...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

GCE Sociology Revision (AQA)- Unit 2 Education- Ethhnic differences in achievement (2)

33,658 views

Published on

For AQA GCE Sociology Unit 2: Education, Revision. Print out as a handout, it is a good way to revise. Application, Interpretation and Analysis tips are also included. All derived from the AS Sociology Revision Guide. Good luck!!!

Published in: Education, Spiritual
  • Digitalessay.net is a good website if you’re looking to get your essay written for you. You can also request things like research papers or dissertations. It’s really convenient and helpful. If you’ve got something very last-minute then it can be a little risky but either way it’s probably better than anything you can throw together :).
       Reply 
    Are you sure you want to  Yes  No
    Your message goes here
  • Fantastic notes
       Reply 
    Are you sure you want to  Yes  No
    Your message goes here

GCE Sociology Revision (AQA)- Unit 2 Education- Ethhnic differences in achievement (2)

  1. 1. Unit 2: Education 2) Ethnic differences in achievement
  2. 2. Interpretation • Gender and class differences exist within and between ethnic groups. • Remember that everyone has a class, an ethnicity and a gender • Thus, their achievement is affected by the interplay of all three
  3. 3. Application • When answering an essay question on ethnicity and achievement, refer to the achievement patterns of a range of different ethnic groups
  4. 4. External factors and ethnic differences • Cultural deprivation • Material deprivation • Class
  5. 5. C.D. Intellectual and language skills • C.D theorist claim: low-income black families lack intellectual stimulation  fail to develop reasoning and problem-solving skills • Some C.D.T claim: children who do not speak English at home may be held back educationally  However, language is not a major factor in under-achievement (Swann Report 1985) Indian pupils do well despite often not speaking English at home Any negative effect is likely to be temporary
  6. 6. Bereiter and Engelmann • The language of poorer black American families is ungrammatical and disjointed •  their children are unable to express abstract ideas • Thus, a major barrier to educational success
  7. 7. C.D Attitudes, values + fam. structure • C.D.T: the sub-culture into which some black children are socialised is fatalistic • They focused on the immediate gratification as-well  lack of motivation to succeed
  8. 8. C.D Attitudes, values + fam. structure C.D.T: • The lack of a male role- model for Aff./Car. boys encourage an ANTI- EDUCATIONAL MACHO GANG CULTURE  Sewell (1998): only a minority of Aff./Car. Booys were anti-school SIMILARLY: N.R.T – Murray (1984): • High rates of lone- parenthood + lack of positive R.M  under- achievement among some M.E groups  Connor (2004): Minority- ethnic groups often placed higher value on education that white parents
  9. 9. • Moynihan (1965): The Culture of poverty: • Moynihan argues that the absence of a male role model of achievement in black matrifocal lone parent families produces inadequately socialised children • They then fail at school •  then, become inadequate parents themselves •  Perpetuate a culture of poverty C.D Attitudes, values + fam. structure
  10. 10. • Pryce (1979): The Impact o Slavery • Pryce (1979) argues that Black Caribbean culture is less resistant to racism because of the experience of slavery • As a result, many black people have low self- esteem and under-achieve C.D Attitudes, values + fam. structure
  11. 11. • Khan (1979): Asian Families • Khan (1979) argues that the Asian family is an obstacle to achievement • Especially for girls, because it takes a controlling attitude towards them • As a result, they do less better than boys  Some argue that Asian families have more positive attitudes towards their education and that adult authority in them is similar to that in school  So that Asian parents are more likely than white likely than white parents to support the school’s behaviour policies C.D Attitudes, values + fam. structure
  12. 12. Working working-class pupils Most research has focused in ethnic minority families, but white working–class pupils also under-achieve . This may because they have lower aspirations than many other ethnic groups  and this may be the result of white working class culture, including the lack of parental support. There is recent evidence to support this
  13. 13. Lupton (2004): W.C White pupils • Lupton (2004) studied four mainly working-class schools with different ethnic compositions • Teachers reported poorer levels of behaviour and discipline in the white working-class schools • They linked this to lower levels of parental support • Also, negative attitudes of white W.C. parents towards education
  14. 14. Evans (2006): W.C. White Pupils • Evans (2006) argue that street culture in white W.C. areas can be brutal • And can be brought into school • The result is a strong pressure to reject education
  15. 15. Interpretation • When answering a question on ethnicity and achievement, don’t just refer to non-white pupils • Referring to white W.C. under-achievement provides balance in your answer
  16. 16. Compensatory education • Compensatory education  is an education policy that aims to encounter the effects of cultural deprivation • E.g:- • Operational Head Start in the USA: was established to compensate for the cultural deficit they are said to suffer because of their deprived background • Sure Start: in the UK aims to support the development of pre-school children in deprived areas
  17. 17. Analysis • Explain how compensatory education is based on the assumption that under-achievement is caused by cultural deprivation rather than any other factors
  18. 18. Criticisms of cultural deprivation Cultural deprivation theory has been widely criticised as an explanation of ethnic differences in achievement: -Victim-blaming - Cultural exclusion -Cultural domination
  19. 19. Keddie: Victim-blaming • Argues that cultural deprivation is a victim blaming explanation • Minority ethnic groups are culturally different, not culturally deprived •  and they under-achieve because schools are ethnocentric – biased in favour of white culture
  20. 20. Ball: Cultural exclusion • Argues that minority ethnic group parents are at a disadvantage because they are less aware of how to negotiate the British education system • This results in ‘cultural exclusion’ rather than cultural deprivation  Similarly, according to Gerwitz, complex school application forms are an example of cultural exclusion practices in some schools
  21. 21. Cultural domination • Compensatory education imposes the dominant white middle-class culture on minority ethnic group pupils’ own culture
  22. 22. Material deprivation and class Material deprivation (or poverty) is a lack of physical or economic resources essential for normal life in society. Material deprivation explanations of ethnic differences in achievement argue that educational failure is the result of material factors such as substandard housing and low income. Ethnic minorities are more likely to face these problems.
  23. 23. Interpretation • Don’t let your answer on ethnicity and achievement drift into one that’s really just about class • Make it clear that not all members of minority ethnic groups are working-class
  24. 24. Evidence: M.E.G are likely to face M.D • Pakistani’s and Bangladeshi’s are more likely to be poor • For many minorities, unemployment is higher, pay is lower, and overcrowding in the home is more likely • According to the Swanne Report (1985):social class accounts for at least half of the difference in educational achievement between ethnic groups
  25. 25. Evaluation • While class plays an important part, it doesn’t fully over-ride the influence of ethnicity: • Pupils of the same class - but different ethnicity,  achieve differently • E.g. Middle-class black pupils do less well at GCSE than White or Asian middle-class pupils
  26. 26. Racism in wider society • While material deprivation among minority ethnic groups clearly affects pupils’ achievement, it may itself be the product of racism in wider society • Members of minority ethnic groups face direct and indirect discrimination at work and in the housing market • As a result  they are more likely to have low pay or be unemployment, and this affects their children’s educational opportunities
  27. 27. Internal factors and ethnic differences Some sociologists focus on the impact of factors within school and the education system as causing ethnic differences in achievement. These internal factors include: 1. Labelling 2. Pupil subcultures 3. Ethnocentricity and institutional racism
  28. 28. Analysis • Show you know all three and deal with them separately, but also explain how they can be linked together as parts of a whole package of inter-related factors
  29. 29. 1. Labelling Interactionalists focus on a small-scale, face-to-face interactions, such as those between pupils and teachers. They are interested in the impact of the labels that teachers give to children from different ethnic backgrounds e.g. Black pupils are often seen as disruptive and Asian pupils as passive As a result of these of these negative racist labels, teachers may treat ethnic minority differently, disadvantaging them and bringing about a self-fulfilling prophecy that leads to the under-achievement. Sociologists have studied labelling in relation to both black and Asian pupils
  30. 30. Application • When describing a factor (such as labelling), make sure you spell out exactly HOW it ultimately leads to educational under-achievement
  31. 31. Gillborn and Youdell (2000): Black pupils • G & Y (2000) found teachers had ‘racialised expections’ (labels) about black pupils and expected more discipline problems and saw their behaviour as threatening • Black pupils were more likely than others to be punished for the same behaviour • The pupils felt that their teachers under- estimated their ability and picked on them
  32. 32. cont. Gillborn and Youdell (2000): Black pupils • G & Y (2000) conclude that conflict between white teachers and black pupils stems from the racists stereotypes that teachers have, rather than from the pupils’ actual behaviour • This can cause  under-achievement because it leads to: 1. Higher levels of exclusions of black boys 2. Black pupils being placed in lower sets or streams
  33. 33. Wright (1992): Asian pupils • Research on Asian pupils shows evidence of teacher stereotyping: • Wright (1992) found that Asian primary school pupils were stereotyped by their teachers and treated differently:  Teachers assumed the children would have a poor grasp of English and so they used simplistic language when speaking to them  They mispronounced children’s names  They saw them as a problem that they could ignore • As a result  Asian pupils, especially the girls , were marginalised and prevented from participating fully, affecting their self - esteem
  34. 34. Connolly (1998): Asian pupils  Similarly, Connolly found that primary school teachers saw Asian pupils as passive and conformist • Both teachers and pupils saw Asian boys as more ‘feminine’, vulnerable and less able to protect themselves
  35. 35. Analysis • Explain why these teacher actions might reduce pupils’ self-esteem and create under- achievement
  36. 36. 2. Pupils subcultures Pupils may react in a variety of different ways to racist labelling in school, including forming or joining pupil subcultures Sewell (1998) found that black boys adopted a range of responses to teachers’ racist labelling of them as rebellious and anti-school:
  37. 37. Sewell (1998): Conformists • Conformists were the 1st largest group • They were keen to succeed • Accepted the school’s goals and had friends from different ethnic groups
  38. 38. Sewell (1998): Innovators • Innovators were the 2nd largest • They were pro- education but anti- school • They valued success, but not teachers’ approval
  39. 39. Sewell (1998): Retreatists • Retreatists were a tiny minority of isolated individuals disconnected from both the school and black subcultures outside it
  40. 40. Sewell (1998): Rebels • Rebels were a small but highly visible minority of black pupils • They rejected the school’s goal and rules and conformed instead to the stereotype of the ‘black macho lad’ • They despised both white boys and conformist black boys • Their aim was to achieve the status of ‘street hood’
  41. 41. However...(REBELS)  However, despite only a small minority of black boys actually fitting the stereotype of the ‘black macho lad’, teachers tended to see them all in this way   This resulted in the under-achievement of many boys, not just the rebels, as a result of discrimination by teachers
  42. 42. Evaluation • This tells us the range and characteristics of possible pupil responses, but not why different boys chose different responses
  43. 43. Interpretation • You can use Sewell’s study to show you are aware that pupils’ responses to racism in schools vary considerably •  not all live up to their teachers’ negative expectations
  44. 44. O’Donnell and Sharpe (2000): Asian boys • O’D & S (2000) found a macho ‘warrior’ response similar to the ‘rebels’ among some Asian boys who despised more conformists Asian youths as ‘weaklings’
  45. 45. Rejecting negative labels • Studies show that not all minority ethnic pupils who are negatively labelled accept and conform to the label • Some may remain committed to succeeding despite racist labelling: • Examples are as follows (evidence):
  46. 46. 1. Fuller (1984): R.N.L • Fuller (1984) studied a group of high-achieving black girls in year 11 of a London comprehensive • The girls maintained a positive self-image by rejecting teachers’ stereotype of them • They recognised the value of education and were determined to achieve, but only conformed in terms of doing schoolwork, working hard without giving the appearance of doing so • They didn’t seek the teachers’ approval, and they maintained friendship with black girls in lower streams • In some ways  they are similar to the innovators in Sewell’s study
  47. 47. 2. Mac an Ghaill (1992) • M.G.’s study of black and Asian ‘A’ level students at a sixth form college found that they did not necessarily accept teachers’ labels • E.g. Some girls felt that the all-girls school they had previously attended gave them greater academic commitment  However, Mirza (1992) found that black girls’ strategies for dealing with teachers’ racism  e.g. Not asking certain staff for help, sometimes restricted their opportunities  As a result  even though they did not (fulfill the prophecy) to accept the labels, they were still disadvantaged
  48. 48. Evaluation • Use Fuller and Mac an Ghaill’s findings to criticise labelling as deterministic – it doesn’t inevitably result in a self-fulfilling prophecy of failure
  49. 49. 3. Institutional Racism Many sociologists argue that although the racist labelling practised by some teachers is important, it is not an adequate explanation for the widespread ethnic differences found in achievement. Instead, they argue, we must focus on institutional racism – discrimination against ethnic minorities that is built into the way institutions such as schools and colleges operate on a routine or even unconscious basis, rather than conscious intentions of individual teachers
  50. 50. The ethnocentric curriculum • This is an important example of institutional racism • ‘Ethnocentric’ refers to an attitude or policy that prioritises the culture of one particular ethnic group while disregarding or downgrading others • Many sociologists have argued that the curriculum of British schools is ethnocentric
  51. 51. 1. Troyna and Williams: E.C.C • T & W note that the E.C.C gives priority to white culture and the English language, literature and music
  52. 52. 2. David: E.C.C • David argues that the National Curriculum is a ‘specifically British’ curriculum that teaches the culture of the ‘host community’
  53. 53. 3. Ball: E.C.C • Ball sees the history curriculum in British schools as recreating a ‘mythical age of empire of age and past glories’ •  while at the same time ignoring the history of black and Asian people
  54. 54.  The Result of evidence: 1. 2. and 3. • The result may be that minority ethnic group pupils feel that they and their culture and identity are not valued in education •  and this diminishes their sense of self- esteem which has a negative effect on their educational achievement
  55. 55. Evaluation • Although the school curriculum largely ignores Asian culture, Indian and Chinese pupils’ achievement is still above average • Also, Stone argues: that there is no evidence that black pupils actually suffer from low self- esteem
  56. 56. Other examples of institutional racism include: 1. Setting and streaming 2. Governing bodies
  57. 57. CRE (1992) study: Setting and streaming • The CRE (1992) study of ‘Jayleigh’ school found that Asian pupils were consistently placed in lower sets than their ability warranted and were less likely to be entered for GCSE exams • Similarly, the workings of the ‘A*- C economy’ meant that black pupils were placed in lower sets  and had less chance of gaining qualifications
  58. 58. Hatcher (1996): Governing bodies • Hatcher (1996) found that schools’ governing bodies: 1. Gave a low priority to ‘race’ issues 2. Failed to deal with racist behaviour 3. And often lacked formal channels of communication with ethnic minority parents  A possible explanation: Ranson (2005) found that governing bodies are disproportionately white
  59. 59. Analysis • Show you know the difference between: • individual racism (e.g. by teachers) • and institutional racism ( resulting from the structure of the school/college)
  60. 60. Selection and segregation • The selection procedures followed by schools can also be a form of institutional racism when they are used in a discriminatory way against minority ethnic group pupils
  61. 61. S & S: Commission for Racial Equality (1993) • C.for.R.E found racism in secondary schools’ admissions procedures, e.g. primary school reports stereotyped minority pupils •  there was a lack of information or application forms in minority languages • And there was bias in entrance interviews
  62. 62. S & S: Marketisation • Marketisation may make this (selection and segregation) worse by increasing the amount of selection in the education system and creating more opportunities for negative stereotype to affect school admissions •  This makes it more difficult for some minority pupils to get into high-achieving schools • As a result  the educated system becomes racially segregated, with M.E.G to be more likely to be concentrated in unpopular, unsuccessful schools
  63. 63. S & S: (Gerwitz) Self-segregation • Gerwitz found that Asian parents made active choices to avoid ‘rough’ schools with a reputation for racism.. • Opting instead for ones they perceived as ‘safe’ and with firm discipline
  64. 64. Evaluation • Use examples of policies that promote marketisation (see Topic 6), such as exam league tables, to show how they could lead to increased ethnic segregation as schools filter out minority groups they regard as under- achievers or ‘liability’ pupils

×