SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 20
Trends and Drivers in HVACR Energy Efficiency Incentive Programs Presented by: Talbot H. Gee, HARDI Prepared Exclusively for: HARDI Western Regional Conference Las Vegas, NV March 21, 2011
Objectives: Maximizing $6+bil Market and EE overview SCE Program Highlights Discussion with Dale Gustavson, Better Buildings NV Power: Program Specifics with Tom Downey Q&A Curbing the high-efficiency equipment slide Update on the U.S. energy efficiency market Why the Western Region is especially important How to capitalize on EE incentives
A New Normal? Ten year avg: 6.35 million units Source: AHRI, JP Morgan
U.S. Factory Shipments of Central A/C and Air-Source HeatPumps to HARDI Member Sales12/12 Rates-of-Change
U.S. Factory Shipments of Central A/C and Air-Source HeatPumps to U.S. Housing Starts12/12 Rates-of-Change ITR predicts a 1.5% decline in 2011 housing starts from 2010, forecasting  579,000 units.  This does not bode well for 2011 unitary shipments given this historical correlation.
2011’s Efficiency Mix Since 2006: Nearly 5x increase in >15 SEER unit shipments Over 2.5x increase in >13 SEER unit shipments 2010 record $5.4 bil in US electric efficiency funds …but 27% drop in total unitary volume (7 mil to just over 5 mil) HARDI est. 78% 13 SEER in 2011 Source: JP Morgan 2011 HVAC Outlook, CEE 2010 Annual Report
System Replacement Rates Plummet Source: JP Morgan
The Appliance Standards Effect “It is important to keep in mind, that the economics of energy efficiency, even with the help of the government, are generally not attractive enough, in our view, to drive discretionary replacements without a “green” incentive, as most consumers tend to focus on the upfront costs of replacing a new system.  This is best exemplified by the significant pre-buy seen when the industry transitioned to 13 SEER in 2006- distributors clearly saw that the value delivered by higher efficiency was not commensurate with the higher price.” JP Morgan 2010 HVAC Market Review & Outlook
All of This Despite… $5.4b is electric 39% C&I 31% Resi & low income 75% in West for EE Source: CEE 2010 Annual Report
Source: CEE 2010 Annual Report
While Leading, CA is Not Alone CA, NY, FL, MA accounted for 50% ($2.7b) of 2010 budgets Source: CEE 2010 Annual Report
Utility Efficiency Program Needs Simpler to design, implement, and justify + Cheaper to design, implement, and justify + More effective (i.e. better uptake) = Better prescriptive OR performance based
Southern Cal Edison Distributor Incentives 2010 Program Highlights Added incentives for water-cooled chillers and variable refrigerant flow equipment (VRF) 10 GWH energy savings and 4 MW demand reduction Incented over 42,000 Tons with 31% annual growth rate Source: CEE 2010 Annual Report
Snapshot of Others in CA
Other Notable Western Region Programs Source: 2010 CEE Annual Report
And a few more… Source: 2010 CEE Annual Report
Maximizing EE $$ HARDI Foundation to form: Center for Energy Efficiency Optimization Will study how wholesale distribution can best drive and influence energy efficiency Support Your HARDI Foundation!
Q&A w/ Dale Gustavson Better Buildings Inc.  www.betterbuildings.com Staff for Western HVAC Performance Alliance SCE and PG&E program support
Nevada Energy Program Tom Downey, Field Manager, Proctor Engineering Anne Marie Blankenship, Program Manager, Resource Solutions Group
Questions

More Related Content

What's hot

Gap analysis of renewable energy generation in the lower mekong basin
Gap analysis of renewable energy generation in the lower mekong basinGap analysis of renewable energy generation in the lower mekong basin
Gap analysis of renewable energy generation in the lower mekong basinCPWF Mekong
 
Examples of my work
Examples of my workExamples of my work
Examples of my workaaroncrowell
 
Algeria EE Indicators
Algeria EE IndicatorsAlgeria EE Indicators
Algeria EE IndicatorsRCREEE
 
A National Review of Combined Heat and Power Programs in utility Energy Effic...
A National Review of Combined Heat and Power Programs in utility Energy Effic...A National Review of Combined Heat and Power Programs in utility Energy Effic...
A National Review of Combined Heat and Power Programs in utility Energy Effic...ICF
 
WWF CleantechGroup Global Cleantech Innovation Index 2017 - Slide Deck
WWF CleantechGroup Global Cleantech Innovation Index 2017 - Slide DeckWWF CleantechGroup Global Cleantech Innovation Index 2017 - Slide Deck
WWF CleantechGroup Global Cleantech Innovation Index 2017 - Slide DeckStefan Henningsson
 
Julie Fitch - Investing in Energy Efficiency: Experience from California
Julie Fitch - Investing in Energy Efficiency: Experience from CaliforniaJulie Fitch - Investing in Energy Efficiency: Experience from California
Julie Fitch - Investing in Energy Efficiency: Experience from Californianoe21
 

What's hot (9)

Gap analysis of renewable energy generation in the lower mekong basin
Gap analysis of renewable energy generation in the lower mekong basinGap analysis of renewable energy generation in the lower mekong basin
Gap analysis of renewable energy generation in the lower mekong basin
 
Examples of my work
Examples of my workExamples of my work
Examples of my work
 
SEAI Energy Modelling Group Summary - Matthew CLancy, SEAI -EPA
SEAI Energy Modelling Group Summary - Matthew CLancy, SEAI -EPASEAI Energy Modelling Group Summary - Matthew CLancy, SEAI -EPA
SEAI Energy Modelling Group Summary - Matthew CLancy, SEAI -EPA
 
Final Project -Hansa Keswani
Final Project -Hansa KeswaniFinal Project -Hansa Keswani
Final Project -Hansa Keswani
 
Algeria EE Indicators
Algeria EE IndicatorsAlgeria EE Indicators
Algeria EE Indicators
 
A National Review of Combined Heat and Power Programs in utility Energy Effic...
A National Review of Combined Heat and Power Programs in utility Energy Effic...A National Review of Combined Heat and Power Programs in utility Energy Effic...
A National Review of Combined Heat and Power Programs in utility Energy Effic...
 
GreenGov 2015 - Kate Brandt, CEQ
GreenGov 2015 - Kate Brandt, CEQGreenGov 2015 - Kate Brandt, CEQ
GreenGov 2015 - Kate Brandt, CEQ
 
WWF CleantechGroup Global Cleantech Innovation Index 2017 - Slide Deck
WWF CleantechGroup Global Cleantech Innovation Index 2017 - Slide DeckWWF CleantechGroup Global Cleantech Innovation Index 2017 - Slide Deck
WWF CleantechGroup Global Cleantech Innovation Index 2017 - Slide Deck
 
Julie Fitch - Investing in Energy Efficiency: Experience from California
Julie Fitch - Investing in Energy Efficiency: Experience from CaliforniaJulie Fitch - Investing in Energy Efficiency: Experience from California
Julie Fitch - Investing in Energy Efficiency: Experience from California
 

Viewers also liked

Tim edwards (2) the hvacr supply chain 3
Tim edwards (2) the hvacr supply chain 3Tim edwards (2) the hvacr supply chain 3
Tim edwards (2) the hvacr supply chain 3ARAaus
 
BSRIA World Market Intelligence Industry Briefing - AHR Expo 2016
BSRIA World Market Intelligence Industry Briefing - AHR Expo 2016BSRIA World Market Intelligence Industry Briefing - AHR Expo 2016
BSRIA World Market Intelligence Industry Briefing - AHR Expo 2016BSRIA
 
BSRIA Industry Presentation at Chillventa 2016
BSRIA Industry Presentation at Chillventa 2016BSRIA Industry Presentation at Chillventa 2016
BSRIA Industry Presentation at Chillventa 2016BSRIA
 
Ian tuena (1) nrc presentation hpe2016
Ian tuena (1) nrc presentation hpe2016Ian tuena (1) nrc presentation hpe2016
Ian tuena (1) nrc presentation hpe2016ARAaus
 
What Would Steve Do? 10 Lessons from the World's Most Captivating Presenters
What Would Steve Do? 10 Lessons from the World's Most Captivating PresentersWhat Would Steve Do? 10 Lessons from the World's Most Captivating Presenters
What Would Steve Do? 10 Lessons from the World's Most Captivating PresentersHubSpot
 

Viewers also liked (7)

Project on HVACR
Project on HVACRProject on HVACR
Project on HVACR
 
Tim edwards (2) the hvacr supply chain 3
Tim edwards (2) the hvacr supply chain 3Tim edwards (2) the hvacr supply chain 3
Tim edwards (2) the hvacr supply chain 3
 
BSRIA World Market Intelligence Industry Briefing - AHR Expo 2016
BSRIA World Market Intelligence Industry Briefing - AHR Expo 2016BSRIA World Market Intelligence Industry Briefing - AHR Expo 2016
BSRIA World Market Intelligence Industry Briefing - AHR Expo 2016
 
BSRIA Industry Presentation at Chillventa 2016
BSRIA Industry Presentation at Chillventa 2016BSRIA Industry Presentation at Chillventa 2016
BSRIA Industry Presentation at Chillventa 2016
 
Ian tuena (1) nrc presentation hpe2016
Ian tuena (1) nrc presentation hpe2016Ian tuena (1) nrc presentation hpe2016
Ian tuena (1) nrc presentation hpe2016
 
HVDC vs HVAC ppt
HVDC vs HVAC pptHVDC vs HVAC ppt
HVDC vs HVAC ppt
 
What Would Steve Do? 10 Lessons from the World's Most Captivating Presenters
What Would Steve Do? 10 Lessons from the World's Most Captivating PresentersWhat Would Steve Do? 10 Lessons from the World's Most Captivating Presenters
What Would Steve Do? 10 Lessons from the World's Most Captivating Presenters
 

Similar to Trends and drivers in HVACR energy efficiency programs

Looking Ahead: 2010 and Beyond – The Decade of Energy Efficiency
Looking Ahead: 2010 and Beyond – The Decade of Energy EfficiencyLooking Ahead: 2010 and Beyond – The Decade of Energy Efficiency
Looking Ahead: 2010 and Beyond – The Decade of Energy EfficiencyAlliance To Save Energy
 
Funding Energy Efficiency With Rebates & Incentives Kim
Funding Energy Efficiency With Rebates & Incentives KimFunding Energy Efficiency With Rebates & Incentives Kim
Funding Energy Efficiency With Rebates & Incentives Kimkimcollins01
 
LBNL 11th Fyp Presentation
LBNL 11th Fyp PresentationLBNL 11th Fyp Presentation
LBNL 11th Fyp PresentationJulian Wong
 
LBNL China 11th 5YP Energy Connservation Progress
LBNL China 11th 5YP Energy Connservation ProgressLBNL China 11th 5YP Energy Connservation Progress
LBNL China 11th 5YP Energy Connservation ProgressJulian Wong
 
Alliance's Brian Castelli at EXPO INCYTAM 2008 in Mexico City
Alliance's Brian Castelli at EXPO INCYTAM 2008 in Mexico CityAlliance's Brian Castelli at EXPO INCYTAM 2008 in Mexico City
Alliance's Brian Castelli at EXPO INCYTAM 2008 in Mexico CityAlliance To Save Energy
 
Energy Efficiency – Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...
Energy Efficiency – Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...Energy Efficiency – Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...
Energy Efficiency – Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...Alliance To Save Energy
 
Energy Efficiency - Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...
Energy Efficiency - Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...Energy Efficiency - Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...
Energy Efficiency - Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...Alliance To Save Energy
 
EU Workshop: A Shared Vision for Energy & Climate
EU Workshop: A Shared Vision for Energy & ClimateEU Workshop: A Shared Vision for Energy & Climate
EU Workshop: A Shared Vision for Energy & ClimateAlliance To Save Energy
 
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...guest3e1229f
 
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...Alliance To Save Energy
 
Building America’s Green Economy: A Foundation of Energy Efficiency, A Future...
Building America’s Green Economy: A Foundation of Energy Efficiency, A Future...Building America’s Green Economy: A Foundation of Energy Efficiency, A Future...
Building America’s Green Economy: A Foundation of Energy Efficiency, A Future...Alliance To Save Energy
 
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.Final
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.FinalEpa.Globalcon.Mjd.Final
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.Finalmikedunn2
 
9th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency
9th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency9th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency
9th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy EfficiencyAlliance To Save Energy
 
Howard Marks, U.S. DOE
Howard Marks, U.S. DOEHoward Marks, U.S. DOE
Howard Marks, U.S. DOEguest9fb1af
 
Overview of Energy Efficiency in the U.S.
Overview of Energy Efficiency in the U.S.Overview of Energy Efficiency in the U.S.
Overview of Energy Efficiency in the U.S.Alliance To Save Energy
 
Pew clean energy program
Pew clean energy programPew clean energy program
Pew clean energy programTNenergy
 
progress energy q3 2008
progress energy q3 2008progress energy q3 2008
progress energy q3 2008finance25
 
Energy_Focus_IR_Presentation_12_14
Energy_Focus_IR_Presentation_12_14Energy_Focus_IR_Presentation_12_14
Energy_Focus_IR_Presentation_12_14Jim Gatto
 

Similar to Trends and drivers in HVACR energy efficiency programs (20)

Looking Ahead: 2010 and Beyond – The Decade of Energy Efficiency
Looking Ahead: 2010 and Beyond – The Decade of Energy EfficiencyLooking Ahead: 2010 and Beyond – The Decade of Energy Efficiency
Looking Ahead: 2010 and Beyond – The Decade of Energy Efficiency
 
Funding Energy Efficiency With Rebates & Incentives Kim
Funding Energy Efficiency With Rebates & Incentives KimFunding Energy Efficiency With Rebates & Incentives Kim
Funding Energy Efficiency With Rebates & Incentives Kim
 
LBNL 11th Fyp Presentation
LBNL 11th Fyp PresentationLBNL 11th Fyp Presentation
LBNL 11th Fyp Presentation
 
LBNL China 11th 5YP Energy Connservation Progress
LBNL China 11th 5YP Energy Connservation ProgressLBNL China 11th 5YP Energy Connservation Progress
LBNL China 11th 5YP Energy Connservation Progress
 
Alliance's Brian Castelli at EXPO INCYTAM 2008 in Mexico City
Alliance's Brian Castelli at EXPO INCYTAM 2008 in Mexico CityAlliance's Brian Castelli at EXPO INCYTAM 2008 in Mexico City
Alliance's Brian Castelli at EXPO INCYTAM 2008 in Mexico City
 
Energy Efficiency – Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...
Energy Efficiency – Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...Energy Efficiency – Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...
Energy Efficiency – Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...
 
Energy Efficiency - Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...
Energy Efficiency - Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...Energy Efficiency - Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...
Energy Efficiency - Good for the World’s Economy; Good for the Nation’s Econo...
 
EU Workshop: A Shared Vision for Energy & Climate
EU Workshop: A Shared Vision for Energy & ClimateEU Workshop: A Shared Vision for Energy & Climate
EU Workshop: A Shared Vision for Energy & Climate
 
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...
 
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...
Paul Hamilton, Schneider Electric: Lean and Clean: Equipping Modern Manufactu...
 
Building America’s Green Economy: A Foundation of Energy Efficiency, A Future...
Building America’s Green Economy: A Foundation of Energy Efficiency, A Future...Building America’s Green Economy: A Foundation of Energy Efficiency, A Future...
Building America’s Green Economy: A Foundation of Energy Efficiency, A Future...
 
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.Final
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.FinalEpa.Globalcon.Mjd.Final
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.Final
 
9th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency
9th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency9th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency
9th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency
 
Howard Marks- U.S DOE
Howard Marks- U.S DOEHoward Marks- U.S DOE
Howard Marks- U.S DOE
 
Howard Marks, U.S. DOE
Howard Marks, U.S. DOEHoward Marks, U.S. DOE
Howard Marks, U.S. DOE
 
Overview of Energy Efficiency in the U.S.
Overview of Energy Efficiency in the U.S.Overview of Energy Efficiency in the U.S.
Overview of Energy Efficiency in the U.S.
 
GEM 6100 Project 2 GROUP 4
GEM 6100 Project 2 GROUP 4GEM 6100 Project 2 GROUP 4
GEM 6100 Project 2 GROUP 4
 
Pew clean energy program
Pew clean energy programPew clean energy program
Pew clean energy program
 
progress energy q3 2008
progress energy q3 2008progress energy q3 2008
progress energy q3 2008
 
Energy_Focus_IR_Presentation_12_14
Energy_Focus_IR_Presentation_12_14Energy_Focus_IR_Presentation_12_14
Energy_Focus_IR_Presentation_12_14
 

Trends and drivers in HVACR energy efficiency programs

  • 1. Trends and Drivers in HVACR Energy Efficiency Incentive Programs Presented by: Talbot H. Gee, HARDI Prepared Exclusively for: HARDI Western Regional Conference Las Vegas, NV March 21, 2011
  • 2. Objectives: Maximizing $6+bil Market and EE overview SCE Program Highlights Discussion with Dale Gustavson, Better Buildings NV Power: Program Specifics with Tom Downey Q&A Curbing the high-efficiency equipment slide Update on the U.S. energy efficiency market Why the Western Region is especially important How to capitalize on EE incentives
  • 3. A New Normal? Ten year avg: 6.35 million units Source: AHRI, JP Morgan
  • 4. U.S. Factory Shipments of Central A/C and Air-Source HeatPumps to HARDI Member Sales12/12 Rates-of-Change
  • 5. U.S. Factory Shipments of Central A/C and Air-Source HeatPumps to U.S. Housing Starts12/12 Rates-of-Change ITR predicts a 1.5% decline in 2011 housing starts from 2010, forecasting 579,000 units. This does not bode well for 2011 unitary shipments given this historical correlation.
  • 6. 2011’s Efficiency Mix Since 2006: Nearly 5x increase in >15 SEER unit shipments Over 2.5x increase in >13 SEER unit shipments 2010 record $5.4 bil in US electric efficiency funds …but 27% drop in total unitary volume (7 mil to just over 5 mil) HARDI est. 78% 13 SEER in 2011 Source: JP Morgan 2011 HVAC Outlook, CEE 2010 Annual Report
  • 7. System Replacement Rates Plummet Source: JP Morgan
  • 8. The Appliance Standards Effect “It is important to keep in mind, that the economics of energy efficiency, even with the help of the government, are generally not attractive enough, in our view, to drive discretionary replacements without a “green” incentive, as most consumers tend to focus on the upfront costs of replacing a new system. This is best exemplified by the significant pre-buy seen when the industry transitioned to 13 SEER in 2006- distributors clearly saw that the value delivered by higher efficiency was not commensurate with the higher price.” JP Morgan 2010 HVAC Market Review & Outlook
  • 9. All of This Despite… $5.4b is electric 39% C&I 31% Resi & low income 75% in West for EE Source: CEE 2010 Annual Report
  • 10. Source: CEE 2010 Annual Report
  • 11. While Leading, CA is Not Alone CA, NY, FL, MA accounted for 50% ($2.7b) of 2010 budgets Source: CEE 2010 Annual Report
  • 12. Utility Efficiency Program Needs Simpler to design, implement, and justify + Cheaper to design, implement, and justify + More effective (i.e. better uptake) = Better prescriptive OR performance based
  • 13. Southern Cal Edison Distributor Incentives 2010 Program Highlights Added incentives for water-cooled chillers and variable refrigerant flow equipment (VRF) 10 GWH energy savings and 4 MW demand reduction Incented over 42,000 Tons with 31% annual growth rate Source: CEE 2010 Annual Report
  • 15. Other Notable Western Region Programs Source: 2010 CEE Annual Report
  • 16. And a few more… Source: 2010 CEE Annual Report
  • 17. Maximizing EE $$ HARDI Foundation to form: Center for Energy Efficiency Optimization Will study how wholesale distribution can best drive and influence energy efficiency Support Your HARDI Foundation!
  • 18. Q&A w/ Dale Gustavson Better Buildings Inc. www.betterbuildings.com Staff for Western HVAC Performance Alliance SCE and PG&E program support
  • 19. Nevada Energy Program Tom Downey, Field Manager, Proctor Engineering Anne Marie Blankenship, Program Manager, Resource Solutions Group