SCHOOL SAFETY ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY: VISUS
Prof. Stefano Grimaz
SPRINT-Lab University of Udine (I)
OUTLINE
VISUS METHODOLOGY
2
FINAL CONSIDERATIONS
© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Che...
VISUS IN THE SCHOOL SAFETY PILLARS
3© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physic...

4© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of ...

5© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of ...

6© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of ...

7© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of ...

8© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of ...

9© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of ...

10© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of...

11© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of...

12© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of...

13© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of...

14© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of...

15© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of...
RESUMING
16© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - Unive...

17© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of...
18© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of U...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

3. Stefano Grimaz - Visus Methodology - Safe School Facilities

650 views

Published on

5th International Disaster and Risk Conference IDRC 2014 Integrative Risk Management - The role of science, technology & practice 24-28 August 2014 in Davos, Switzerland

0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
650
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
3
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

3. Stefano Grimaz - Visus Methodology - Safe School Facilities

  1. 1. SCHOOL SAFETY ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY: VISUS Prof. Stefano Grimaz SPRINT-Lab University of Udine (I)
  2. 2. OUTLINE VISUS METHODOLOGY 2 FINAL CONSIDERATIONS © prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) VISUS APPLICATIONS SCHOOL SAFETY
  3. 3. VISUS IN THE SCHOOL SAFETY PILLARS 3© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) ©SPRINT-LabUniversityofUdine(I) Decision Making Support Safety Upgrading Strategies ASSESSMENT & PLANNING ROLE/CONTRIBUTES SCHOOL SAFETY THE THREE PILLARS OF THE COMPREHENSIVE SCHOOL SAFETY
  4. 4.  4© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) SCHOOL SAFETY CONCERNS WHICH SCHOOL NEEDS TO BE ADEQUATE FIRST? WHY? WHAT INTERVENTIONS ARE NECESSARY? HOW MUCH DOES THE RETROFITTING COST? HOW MANY INTERVENTIONS ARE FEASIBLE WITH THE AVAILABLE RESOURCES? HOW SHOULD WE COMMUNICATE THE RISK LEVEL TO PEOPLE? CONCERNS OF ADMINISTRATORS “HOW MUCH IS ENOUGH” TO KNOW FOR DEFINING WHAT IS OPPORTUNE TO DO? ASSESSMENT FOR PLANNING
  5. 5.  5© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) THE IDEA CODIFY THE EXPERT APPROACH CHARACTERIZATION GLOBAL JUDGEMENT EVALUTATION REPORTING MAIN ISSUES
  6. 6.  6© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) VISUS THE EXPERT WORK PRECODIFIED EVALUTATION AUTOMATIC STANDARDIZED REPORTING PRE-CODIFIED CHARACTERIZATION PRE-CODIFED SUBSTANTIAL ELEMENTARY SCENARIOS SAFETY GLOBAL JUDGEMENT MAIN ISSUES STRUCTURAL PERFORMACE CLASS VISUS safety indicators ROSE OF INTERVENTION NEEDS (WARNINGS NEEDLES) WARNING LEVEL VISUS SURVEYOR ©SPRINT-LabUniversityofUdine(I)
  7. 7.  7© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) VISUS FIRST APPLICATION (seismic safety) ASSESS PROJECT (NE ITALY) Friuli Venezia Giulia N-E of Italy WHERE 1022 SCHOOLS Various structural typologies Different geological scenarios Seismic Unitary Scenario WHAT PROJECT FOUNDED BY THE CIVIL PROTECTION OF FRIULI VENEZIA GIULIA REGION (I) HOW
  8. 8.  8© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) GIS - SCHOOLS ASSESS PROJECT (NE ITALY) KKK KKK
  9. 9.  9© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) DECISION MAKING SUPPORT KEY ELEMENTS K WHICH SCHOOL NEEDS TO BE ADEQUATE FIRST? WHY? WHAT KIND OF INTERVENTIONS ARE NECESSARY? HOW MUCH DOES THE RETROFITTING COST? HOW MANY INTERVENTIONS ARE FEASIBLE WITH THE AVAILABLE RESOURCES? HOW SHOULD WE COMMUNICATE THE RISK LEVEL TO PEOPLE? CONCERNS OF ADMINISTRATORS KEY ELEMENTS FOR ANSWERS CHARACTERIZATION LIST OF THE SEISMIC SAFETY OF SCHOOLS VISUS
  10. 10.  10© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) VISUS SURVEYORS TRAINING EL SALVADOR PILOT PROJECT VISUS APP FOR DATA COLLECTION VISUS SURVEYORVISUS SURVEYOR
  11. 11.  11© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) VISUS SURVEYS SELF-MANAGED IMPLEMENTATION ON FIELD SURVEY DESK WORK1 2 data collection 3 preparation ELABORATION AND REPORTING inspection El Salvador Pilot Project SCHOOL COMPLEX EVALUATION SUMMARY BUILDINGS WARNINGS WEAKNESSES INTERVENTION NEEDS VISUS TRAINING (3 days)0
  12. 12.  12© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) VISUS APPLICATION TRANSFER OF KNOWLEDGE VISUS: A CAPACITY BUILDING TOOL
  13. 13.  13© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) VISUS FOR TECHNICAL TRIAGE INVESTIGATE “HOW MUCH IS ENOUGH” FOR DEFINING WHAT IS OPPORTUNE TO DO DECISION MAKING SUPPORT FOR PLANNING EFFECTIVE RISK REDUCTION ATIONS A TRIAGE ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY (EXPERT-BASED APPROACH) Visual Inspection for defining Safety Upgrading Strategies the meaning of the acronim
  14. 14.  14© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) THE LEVEL OF ANALYSIS VISUS POSITION 0 1 3 Available documentation Desk analysis VISUS INPUT data-approach OUTPUT decision making information Preliminary classification (deficit of capacity – seismic codes) Class or index of risk Priority ranking for deepening/intervention Multi-aspect weakness characterization Intervention needs Cost estimation Decision support tool for multicriteria definition of intervention strategies Detailed engineering, geophysical and geotechnical data acquisition and quantitative analyses (building) Seismic site characterization Quantitative assessment of structural safety Seismic design Detailed cost quantification Macro-typological data Rapid survey (national/large scale) Visual inspection and quality material characterization by trained technicians (regional/urban scale) Level of Assessment Detailed investigation and analysis 2 INTERVENTION STRATEGYOF INTERVENTION QUICKASSESSMENT TRIAGE
  15. 15.  15© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) VISUS EVOLUTION MULTI-HAZARD TRIAGE © SPRINT-Lab University of Udine (I)
  16. 16. RESUMING 16© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) METHODOLOGY LOCAL COMMITEE TRAINING FOR TRAINERS TRAINING FOR SURVEYORS MEETINGS WITH LOCAL EXPERTS AND STAKEHOLDERS ADAPTATION CONTEXTUALSATION INDIVIDUAL REPORTS VISUS TRIAGE INDICATORS DECISION MAKING SUPPORT TO GOVERNMENTS FOR REACHING THEIR SCHOOL SAFETY COMMITMENTS (PROVIDE INFORMATION AND KEY ELEMENTS FOR DEFINING AN EFFECTIVE SAFETY UPGRADING STRATEGY) CHARACTERIZATION OF THE PROBLEM AND THE INTERVENTION NEEDS VISUS APP OPEN STREET MAP PRODUCTS CAPACITY BUILDING VISUS: AS SUPPORT PRE-CODIFIED EVALUATION CRITERIA KNOWLEDGE TRANSFER VISUS SURVEYORS VISUS PACKAGE
  17. 17.  17© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) FINAL CONSIDERATIONS LESSON LEARTN MULTIDIMENSIONAL SAFETY CHARACTERIZATION OF THE SCENARIO AS DECISION MAKING SUPPORT TOOL FOR ADMINISTRATORS AND SAFETY MANAGERS HOLISTIC APPROACH (GLOBAL SAFETY) USE OF “COMMUNICATIVE” SAFE-INDICATORS FOR TRANSFERRING SCIENTIFIC RESULTS OF ASSESSMENT AND FOR INCREASING AWARENESS ON THE SAFETY PROBLEM LESSON LEARNT FROM EXPERIENCE IMPORTANCE OF IMPORTANCE OF A MULTI-DIMENSIONAL APPROACH FOR AN EFFECTIVE RISK REDUCTION, MAINLY AT REGIONAL SCALE TRIAGE: ALLOWS GOVERNMENTS TO CHARACTERIZE THE SITUATION IN A FAST BUT PRAGMATIC WAY (NO HIGH ECONOMIC AND HUMAN CAPACITIES ARE REQUIRED) THE PRECODIFICATION OF THE REASONING OF THE EXPERT ON CHARACTERIZATION AND EVALUATION FACILITATES THE CAPACITY BUILDING AND ENSURES THE UNIFORMITY OF JUDGEMENT
  18. 18. 18© prof. ing. Stefano Grimaz – Director of SPRINT-Lab – Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (I) MANY THANKS FOR YOUR ATTENTION! Prof. Stefano Grimaz stefano.grimaz@uniud.it Director of SPRINT – Safety and Protection Intersectorial Laboratory Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment University of Udine (Italy) http://sprint.uniud.it Contact references: VISUS Method developed by SPRINT-Lab - Department of Chemistry Physics and Environment - University of Udine (Italy) and adopted for UNESCO’s project entitled “Providing decision-making information and tools for enhancing school safety in El Salvador through school facilities assessment and OpenStreetMap sourcing”

×