Click on for noteworthy pandemic insights on your consumers from Epsilon’s Abacus Cooperative database. Our research synthesizes transaction-based data across 525 retailers, both in-store and through online, call center and catalog channels.
The lockdowns in 2020 lead to a captive audience as consumers were at home in need of products and services for necessity and for 'entertainment'. With many brick-and-mortar shopping experiences closed and "shopping as a pastime" nearly eliminated, consumers turned to online options fill those needs
We all saw Retail take a huge hit as stores closed, which drove demand online. Overall retail declined by 66% during this time.
Direct saw a 43% increase ON AVERAGE, some brands saw over 100% increase which was directly related to the category of product you provide.
Repeat buyers in the Direct channel also saw a 17% increase for an overall 20% increase.
Brands saw a 43% increase in new buyers across direct channels in 2020 compared to the previous year.
That said, it didn’t necessarily make up for the delta from the lack of new buyers in in-store channels
Repeat buyers were also up on direct channels – seeing a 17% increase YOY in repeat buyers
So what did these NTF and Repeat buyers look like? Were they different?
Yes, they were different. Not by huge swings but remember this is the average across millions of buyers.
Commentary on how both in-store and direct channels were attracting a new type of buyer that was not previously with the brand across in-store and direct channels.
What’s the context?
Could be read as stealing marketshare from others?
Younger demographics, new families, etc. looking for what was available where they could get it vs. shopping their typical stores?
Lots of “brand swapping” with this group – differs from what is considered their typical, “loyal” customer base?
Wasn’t all panic buying – didn’t need to go to work, etc. – just browsing the web – opted in for emails, etc. and recreational shopping over the web vs. walking to a new store.
People tried new hobbies – forced to cook at home more, restaurants were closed, people were trying gardening and collecting things to entertain kids around the house.
Are these people going to stick around with new hobbies from this time last year or not?
So what did these NTF and Repeat buyers look like? Were they different?
Yes, they were different. Not by huge swings but remember this is the average across millions of buyers.
Commentary on how both in-store and direct channels were attracting a new type of buyer that was not previously with the brand across in-store and direct channels.
What’s the context?
Could be read as stealing marketshare from others?
Younger demographics, new families, etc. looking for what was available where they could get it vs. shopping their typical stores?
Lots of “brand swapping” with this group – differs from what is considered their typical, “loyal” customer base?
Wasn’t all panic buying – didn’t need to go to work, etc. – just browsing the web – opted in for emails, etc. and recreational shopping over the web vs. walking to a new store.
People tried new hobbies – forced to cook at home more, restaurants were closed, people were trying gardening and collecting things to entertain kids around the house.
Are these people going to stick around with new hobbies from this time last year or not?
Not a dramatic difference - still down a bit YOY but not a dramatic increase in transactions.
Have to pay for shipping if you buy direct, not going to make as many transactions - this is the number of transactions during that period, not just in a day
Gained a lot of new households and customers, but the activity of those people was the same as other new buyers
Speaks a lot to what those brands were offering at that time, don't have the same turn of inventory as retailers.
DIRECT: Purchase frequency was highest for Repeat Buyers at 2.7 transactions per household compared to 1.6 for New Buyers.
IN-STORE: Repeat buyers had 2.6 visits on average, whereas new buyers only had 1.8 visits on average – both were in line (with some changes) from 2019.
During the same timeframe, the people that could go in-store did spend a lot, but those dollars didn't necessarily translate into the direct channel.
"Panic buying" extended beyond just grocery here
Spend:
DIRECT: New Buyers spent $142 per order, whereas Repeat Buyers spent $134.
IN-STORE: New Buyers spent $277 per purchase, whereas Repeat Buyers spent $110.
For reference:
RETAIL: 34% of the 2020 New March to May Buyers were retained, a decrease of 11% YOY
For reference: In-store was flat overall as well
Bigger dump of new customers to online or direct - want to know if these people are continuing
First phase - so many people shifted into online, now looking at if they are/are not continuing online
AOV was relatively flat from early to later pandemic - $135 average across the year, but for both March-May and June-Dec (across new and repeat buyers), AOV was up significantly from $128/order to $135/order
Reactivation was a big component here
Apparel & Accessories – Direct – March-May highlights:
While Apparel-related purchases went down at physical stores, the Direct channel saw a surge in New Buyers.
Unfortunately, revenue was down 7% overall, but at least folks were finding their favorite and new brands through other channels.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households.
Revenue from New Buyers was up in March to May for all categories, except in Mature Female Apparel.
Apparel & Accessories – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December.
AOV and purchase frequency was down.
The increase in active New and Repeat buyers drove the growth.
New Buyer retention rates were fairly flat, whereas Repeat Buyers retention was down in most cases.
Similar to earlier in the year, the Mature Female Apparel brands struggled to convert these New and Repeat Buyers, but other apparel offers saw growth with them.
Home Furnishings – Direct – March-May highlights:
The Home & Garden market also experienced a surge of New and Repeat Buyers, which drove revenue up over 2019 levels.
AOV declined, but purchase frequency was up.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households for all the categories except for Home Fixtures & Furniture.
All the buyer segments also spent more at a category level in March to May 2020. Bath & Kitchen saw the largest increases, with Patio & Garden brands coming in second place.
Home Furnishings – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments for the remainder of the year, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was also up from June to December 2020.
Dramatic increases in active buyers drove this growth.
Increases in purchase frequency and AOV further contributed to the growth in revenue.
Repeat Direct Buyers’ retention rates were up in 2020.
Revenue increases seen earlier in the year, were also happening in June to December for New and Repeat Buyers across all the Home & Garden categories.
Home Furnishings – Direct – March-May highlights:
The Home & Garden market also experienced a surge of New and Repeat Buyers, which drove revenue up over 2019 levels.
AOV declined, but purchase frequency was up.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households for all the categories except for Home Fixtures & Furniture.
All the buyer segments also spent more at a category level in March to May 2020. Bath & Kitchen saw the largest increases, with Patio & Garden brands coming in second place.
Home Furnishings – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments for the remainder of the year, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was also up from June to December 2020.
Dramatic increases in active buyers drove this growth.
Increases in purchase frequency and AOV further contributed to the growth in revenue.
Repeat Direct Buyers’ retention rates were up in 2020.
Revenue increases seen earlier in the year, were also happening in June to December for New and Repeat Buyers across all the Home & Garden categories.
Home Furnishings – Direct – March-May highlights:
The Home & Garden market also experienced a surge of New and Repeat Buyers, which drove revenue up over 2019 levels.
AOV declined, but purchase frequency was up.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households for all the categories except for Home Fixtures & Furniture.
All the buyer segments also spent more at a category level in March to May 2020. Bath & Kitchen saw the largest increases, with Patio & Garden brands coming in second place.
Home Furnishings – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments for the remainder of the year, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was also up from June to December 2020.
Dramatic increases in active buyers drove this growth.
Increases in purchase frequency and AOV further contributed to the growth in revenue.
Repeat Direct Buyers’ retention rates were up in 2020.
Revenue increases seen earlier in the year, were also happening in June to December for New and Repeat Buyers across all the Home & Garden categories.
Home Furnishings – Direct – March-May highlights:
The Home & Garden market also experienced a surge of New and Repeat Buyers, which drove revenue up over 2019 levels.
AOV declined, but purchase frequency was up.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households for all the categories except for Home Fixtures & Furniture.
All the buyer segments also spent more at a category level in March to May 2020. Bath & Kitchen saw the largest increases, with Patio & Garden brands coming in second place.
Home Furnishings – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments for the remainder of the year, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was also up from June to December 2020.
Dramatic increases in active buyers drove this growth.
Increases in purchase frequency and AOV further contributed to the growth in revenue.
Repeat Direct Buyers’ retention rates were up in 2020.
Revenue increases seen earlier in the year, were also happening in June to December for New and Repeat Buyers across all the Home & Garden categories.
Fashion & beauty extras – Direct – March-May highlights:
In March to May, Fashion & Beauty Extras brands had more New and Repeat Buyers compared to the same time in 2019.
Revenue from New Buyers was up 13% but down 3% for Repeat Buyers.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households for all the Fashion & Beauty Extras categories, except for Health & Beauty.
March to May revenue was up for Health & Beauty and Jewelry brands, but down for Fashion Accessories and Shoe brands
Fashion & beauty extras – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December 2020.
Purchase frequency was down 7% on average.
Increases in active New and Repeat Buyers drove the growth.
From 2019 to 2020, New Buyer retention rates were flat, whereas Repeat Buyers retention rates were down in most cases.
These New and Repeat Buyers increased their spend in June to December with all the Fashion & Beauty Extra categories except Repeat Buyers with Shoes and New Buyers with Health & Beauty.
Fashion & beauty extras – Direct – March-May highlights:
In March to May, Fashion & Beauty Extras brands had more New and Repeat Buyers compared to the same time in 2019.
Revenue from New Buyers was up 13% but down 3% for Repeat Buyers.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households for all the Fashion & Beauty Extras categories, except for Health & Beauty.
March to May revenue was up for Health & Beauty and Jewelry brands, but down for Fashion Accessories and Shoe brands
Fashion & beauty extras – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December 2020.
Purchase frequency was down 7% on average.
Increases in active New and Repeat Buyers drove the growth.
From 2019 to 2020, New Buyer retention rates were flat, whereas Repeat Buyers retention rates were down in most cases.
These New and Repeat Buyers increased their spend in June to December with all the Fashion & Beauty Extra categories except Repeat Buyers with Shoes and New Buyers with Health & Beauty.
Fashion & beauty extras – Direct – March-May highlights:
In March to May, Fashion & Beauty Extras brands had more New and Repeat Buyers compared to the same time in 2019.
Revenue from New Buyers was up 13% but down 3% for Repeat Buyers.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households for all the Fashion & Beauty Extras categories, except for Health & Beauty.
March to May revenue was up for Health & Beauty and Jewelry brands, but down for Fashion Accessories and Shoe brands
Fashion & beauty extras – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December 2020.
Purchase frequency was down 7% on average.
Increases in active New and Repeat Buyers drove the growth.
From 2019 to 2020, New Buyer retention rates were flat, whereas Repeat Buyers retention rates were down in most cases.
These New and Repeat Buyers increased their spend in June to December with all the Fashion & Beauty Extra categories except Repeat Buyers with Shoes and New Buyers with Health & Beauty.
Fashion & beauty extras – Direct – March-May highlights:
In March to May, Fashion & Beauty Extras brands had more New and Repeat Buyers compared to the same time in 2019.
Revenue from New Buyers was up 13% but down 3% for Repeat Buyers.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households for all the Fashion & Beauty Extras categories, except for Health & Beauty.
March to May revenue was up for Health & Beauty and Jewelry brands, but down for Fashion Accessories and Shoe brands
Fashion & beauty extras – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December 2020.
Purchase frequency was down 7% on average.
Increases in active New and Repeat Buyers drove the growth.
From 2019 to 2020, New Buyer retention rates were flat, whereas Repeat Buyers retention rates were down in most cases.
These New and Repeat Buyers increased their spend in June to December with all the Fashion & Beauty Extra categories except Repeat Buyers with Shoes and New Buyers with Health & Beauty.
Food & gifts – Direct – March-May highlights:
Food & Gift brands had a large increase in New and Repeat buyers, which drove revenue up substantially over the same time in 2019.
AOV was also up by double-digits.
Purchase frequency was up for New Buyers and down for Repeat Buyers.
As with many other Direct markets, New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households.
Gourmet Food brands saw triple-digit increases in gross revenue, while Gift brands were up by double-digits.
Food & gifts – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments for the remainder of the year, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December 2020.
Dramatic increases in active buyers drove this growth.
Purchase frequency and AOV were up and further contributed to the growth in revenue.
New and Repeat Direct Buyers’ retention rates were up in 2020.
The trend from March to May continued into June to December with tremendous growth for both New and Repeat Buyers with Gifts and Gourmet Food brands.
Food & gifts – Direct – March-May highlights:
Food & Gift brands had a large increase in New and Repeat buyers, which drove revenue up substantially over the same time in 2019.
AOV was also up by double-digits.
Purchase frequency was up for New Buyers and down for Repeat Buyers.
As with many other Direct markets, New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households.
Gourmet Food brands saw triple-digit increases in gross revenue, while Gift brands were up by double-digits.
Food & gifts – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments for the remainder of the year, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December 2020.
Dramatic increases in active buyers drove this growth.
Purchase frequency and AOV were up and further contributed to the growth in revenue.
New and Repeat Direct Buyers’ retention rates were up in 2020.
The trend from March to May continued into June to December with tremendous growth for both New and Repeat Buyers with Gifts and Gourmet Food brands.
Food & gifts – Direct – March-May highlights:
Food & Gift brands had a large increase in New and Repeat buyers, which drove revenue up substantially over the same time in 2019.
AOV was also up by double-digits.
Purchase frequency was up for New Buyers and down for Repeat Buyers.
As with many other Direct markets, New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households.
Gourmet Food brands saw triple-digit increases in gross revenue, while Gift brands were up by double-digits.
Food & gifts – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments for the remainder of the year, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December 2020.
Dramatic increases in active buyers drove this growth.
Purchase frequency and AOV were up and further contributed to the growth in revenue.
New and Repeat Direct Buyers’ retention rates were up in 2020.
The trend from March to May continued into June to December with tremendous growth for both New and Repeat Buyers with Gifts and Gourmet Food brands.
Food & gifts – Direct – March-May highlights:
Food & Gift brands had a large increase in New and Repeat buyers, which drove revenue up substantially over the same time in 2019.
AOV was also up by double-digits.
Purchase frequency was up for New Buyers and down for Repeat Buyers.
As with many other Direct markets, New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households.
Gourmet Food brands saw triple-digit increases in gross revenue, while Gift brands were up by double-digits.
Food & gifts – Direct – June-Dec highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments for the remainder of the year, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December 2020.
Dramatic increases in active buyers drove this growth.
Purchase frequency and AOV were up and further contributed to the growth in revenue.
New and Repeat Direct Buyers’ retention rates were up in 2020.
The trend from March to May continued into June to December with tremendous growth for both New and Repeat Buyers with Gifts and Gourmet Food brands.
Hobbies & interests – Direct – March-May highlights:
Hobbies & Interests brands had more New and Repeat buyers in 2020, which drove revenue up over the same time in 2019.
AOV was down for New Buyers and up for Repeat Buyers.
Purchase frequency rose 2% for New Buyers and was flat for Repeat Buyers.
Like other Direct markets, New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households.
Aside from New Buyers spend with Crafts & Collectibles, all the other categories saw growth from both New and Repeat Buyers in March through May 2020.
Hobbies & interests – Direct – June-December highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December.
Increases in AOV and purchase frequency also contributed to the growth.
Double-digit increases in active New and Repeat buyers was the driver of the growth though.
Retention rates were higher for more of the Repeat Buyer segments; whereas there was little change for New Buyers.
Gross revenue was up for all segments and categories in the Hobbies & Interests market.
Hobbies & interests – Direct – March-May highlights:
Hobbies & Interests brands had more New and Repeat buyers in 2020, which drove revenue up over the same time in 2019.
AOV was down for New Buyers and up for Repeat Buyers.
Purchase frequency rose 2% for New Buyers and was flat for Repeat Buyers.
Like other Direct markets, New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households.
Aside from New Buyers spend with Crafts & Collectibles, all the other categories saw growth from both New and Repeat Buyers in March through May 2020.
Hobbies & interests – Direct – June-December highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December.
Increases in AOV and purchase frequency also contributed to the growth.
Double-digit increases in active New and Repeat buyers was the driver of the growth though.
Retention rates were higher for more of the Repeat Buyer segments; whereas there was little change for New Buyers.
Gross revenue was up for all segments and categories in the Hobbies & Interests market.
Hobbies & interests – Direct – March-May highlights:
Hobbies & Interests brands had more New and Repeat buyers in 2020, which drove revenue up over the same time in 2019.
AOV was down for New Buyers and up for Repeat Buyers.
Purchase frequency rose 2% for New Buyers and was flat for Repeat Buyers.
Like other Direct markets, New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households.
Aside from New Buyers spend with Crafts & Collectibles, all the other categories saw growth from both New and Repeat Buyers in March through May 2020.
Hobbies & interests – Direct – June-December highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December.
Increases in AOV and purchase frequency also contributed to the growth.
Double-digit increases in active New and Repeat buyers was the driver of the growth though.
Retention rates were higher for more of the Repeat Buyer segments; whereas there was little change for New Buyers.
Gross revenue was up for all segments and categories in the Hobbies & Interests market.
Hobbies & interests – Direct – March-May highlights:
Hobbies & Interests brands had more New and Repeat buyers in 2020, which drove revenue up over the same time in 2019.
AOV was down for New Buyers and up for Repeat Buyers.
Purchase frequency rose 2% for New Buyers and was flat for Repeat Buyers.
Like other Direct markets, New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households.
Aside from New Buyers spend with Crafts & Collectibles, all the other categories saw growth from both New and Repeat Buyers in March through May 2020.
Hobbies & interests – Direct – June-December highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was up from June to December.
Increases in AOV and purchase frequency also contributed to the growth.
Double-digit increases in active New and Repeat buyers was the driver of the growth though.
Retention rates were higher for more of the Repeat Buyer segments; whereas there was little change for New Buyers.
Gross revenue was up for all segments and categories in the Hobbies & Interests market.
Kids – Direct – March-May highlights:
Buyers, which drove revenue up over 2019 levels.
AOV declined for New Buyers but grew for Repeat Buyers.
Purchase frequency was up across the board.
Spend per household was up as a result of these changes.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households in the Kids market – with 14% growth in 2020.
Kids – Direct – June-December highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was also up in June to December.
An increase in AOV also contributed to the growth.
The double-digit increases in active New and Repeat buyers was the primary contributor of the growth though.
Retention rates were higher Repeat Buyers; whereas there was little change year-over-year for New Buyers.
Kids – Direct – March-May highlights:
Buyers, which drove revenue up over 2019 levels.
AOV declined for New Buyers but grew for Repeat Buyers.
Purchase frequency was up across the board.
Spend per household was up as a result of these changes.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households in the Kids market – with 14% growth in 2020.
Kids – Direct – June-December highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was also up in June to December.
An increase in AOV also contributed to the growth.
The double-digit increases in active New and Repeat buyers was the primary contributor of the growth though.
Retention rates were higher Repeat Buyers; whereas there was little change year-over-year for New Buyers.
Kids – Direct – March-May highlights:
Buyers, which drove revenue up over 2019 levels.
AOV declined for New Buyers but grew for Repeat Buyers.
Purchase frequency was up across the board.
Spend per household was up as a result of these changes.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households in the Kids market – with 14% growth in 2020.
Kids – Direct – June-December highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was also up in June to December.
An increase in AOV also contributed to the growth.
The double-digit increases in active New and Repeat buyers was the primary contributor of the growth though.
Retention rates were higher Repeat Buyers; whereas there was little change year-over-year for New Buyers.
Kids – Direct – March-May highlights:
Buyers, which drove revenue up over 2019 levels.
AOV declined for New Buyers but grew for Repeat Buyers.
Purchase frequency was up across the board.
Spend per household was up as a result of these changes.
New Buyers made up a higher proportion of the active 3-month households in the Kids market – with 14% growth in 2020.
Kids – Direct – June-December highlights:
When following the March to May buyer segments, both the New and the Repeat Buyers spend was also up in June to December.
An increase in AOV also contributed to the growth.
The double-digit increases in active New and Repeat buyers was the primary contributor of the growth though.
Retention rates were higher Repeat Buyers; whereas there was little change year-over-year for New Buyers.