Successfully reported this slideshow.
Your SlideShare is downloading. ×

Athens 2022 - Aguilli Isidro.pptx

Ad
Ad
Ad
Ad
Ad
Ad
Ad
Ad
Ad
Ad
Ad

Check these out next

1 of 25 Ad
Advertisement

More Related Content

More from EADTU (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

Advertisement

Athens 2022 - Aguilli Isidro.pptx

  1. 1. Rankings of Universities Europe on Focus Isidro F. Aguillo Editor Rankings Web isidro.aguillo@csic.es Adobe Stock 265167168
  2. 2. Global Rankings
  3. 3. • Prestige-based (English PR) indicators • Nobel Prizes: Immigrant (stolen) talent USA & Commonwealth • Excluded Research Councils (CNRS, MaxPlanck; CNR, CSIC, …) and C&E European Academies Other GlobalNorth countries • Small o medium sized HEIs not ranked • (Very) Incomplete coverage of the sources (WoS/Scopus) GlobalSouth countries Strongly biased scenario
  4. 4. Survey-based (British) rankings 3 in Top 12 4 in Top 10
  5. 5. (External) Talent aggregated …………………...............................… ONLY 13 (of 1000) universities with total score larger than >50% (2022)
  6. 6. Ranking Web(ometrics)
  7. 7. A different model PULL DATA COLLECTION LOCAL+SOURCES INDICATORS DESIGN AND WEIGHTS RANKING PUSH OPEN SCIENCE PRIORITIES INDICATORS DESIGN AND WEIGHTS RANKING OPEN SCIENCE INITIATIVES
  8. 8. Web is THE scholarly communication channel Web is GLOBAL and LOCAL Web is OPEN (Open Science + Open Access) Web is the most feasible PR tool Web is built both TOP-DOWN and BOTTOM-UP Web-based
  9. 9. IMPACT 50% ACTIVITY 50% EXCELLENCE Papers OPENNESS Profiles VISIBILITY Linking Networks
  10. 10. Global South included! July 2021 Country Top 1000 1297 14 145 2 5288 13 1173 7 2595 2 293 1 133 0 59 0 148 0 123 0 65 0 358 1 102 0 121 8 279 0 73 3 68 4 704 12 194 5 290 0 56 0 32 0 21 0 6 0 180 1 34 0 70 0 131 3 66 0 66 0 170 0
  11. 11. Excellence in Research 6 647 HEIs >0
  12. 12. But a surprising digital divide!
  13. 13. Web and Distance Learning
  14. 14. Glocal=Global+Local • WEB: Local Expertise for Global Audiences International Cooperation • WEB: Knowledge Transfer without Brain Drain Distance Learning=Open • WEB: Community Building and Development Web & Distance Learning Universities
  15. 15. Easy and cheap publication of contents • WEB: Personal pages Transborder impact • WEB: Truly global audience Social networks • WEB: Social tools Web & Distance Learning scholars & students
  16. 16. Not to Rank: Understanding & Solving
  17. 17. EU Bottom-up approach 10 webpages
  18. 18. US Bottom-up approach https://gking.harvard.edu/ 3 570 webpages
  19. 19. Top-down (lack of) strategy 2118 profiles
  20. 20. Opening contents OPEN KNOWLEDGE OPEN SCIENCE OPEN RESEARCH OPEN ACCESS OPEN PEER-REVIEW OPEN DATA OPEN SOURCE PRE-PRINTS CITIZEN SCIENCE OPEN INFRAESTRUCTURES OPEN METHODS PUBLIC WEB WIKIPEDIA EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES RESPONSIBLE R&I POPULAR SCIENCE EVALUATION POLICIES LIBRARIES MUSEUMS SOCIAL NETWORKS MASS MEDIA HOSPITALS
  21. 21. Open access?
  22. 22. Open data? https://dataverse.org/
  23. 23. Open Social: Altmetrics data
  24. 24. Ranking Not only World- class research intensive universities. True Global coverage Leadership Open Science commitment. Cooperation with governments, organizations, and communities Distance Learning Fair evaluation and Ranking. Web quality contents as the key tool Webometrics promotes …
  25. 25. Thanks for your attention! Questions?

×