Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Open Innovation in Action - Modes of Open InnovationDr. Sabine BrunswickerFraunhofer-Institute for Industrial Engineering ...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThe innovation game haschanged¹Source: 1) Chesbrough (2003)
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThe orginial concept of open innovation describes a cognitive framework...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationSince 2003, the phenomenon is widely discussed and firms experiment wit...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationIn our new executive survey we found that open innovation is on the ris...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThere is not „one“ single open innovation strategy; it involves a „bunc...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationLarge firms like GE experiment with start-up competitions and idea cont...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationOpen innovation intermediaries are on the rise; various types of firms ...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationWe can differentiate between inflows and outflows of knowledge; they do...
Source. siehe auch Chesbrough (2003, 2006); Dahlander (2010)Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThere are v...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationCo-creation and informal networking are the top inbound practices; new ...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationJoint venturing is the top outbound mode of open innovation; spin-offs ...
Trusted NetworkNewpartnersPearlfinderSupplierGovernmentResearcherDevelopmentpartnerOpen Innovation in Action: Modes of Ope...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationLarge firms do not yet recognize the value of connected communities; ho...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThere is an internal component of openness; managing the journey from c...
Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThere are different maturity stages of open innovation; it is a journey...
Open Innovation A „new“ paradigm for managing innovation?It is not easy to implement open innovation; it requires a system...
 Back up
Open Innovation A „new“ paradigm for managing innovation?We are observing a shift towards the network level of open innova...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Dr Sabine Brunswicker

3,851 views

Published on

open innovation 2.0

Published in: Business, Technology
  • Really interesting​!

    Given your interest, I think you'll be very much interested in this list of emerging OI research:
    http://www.openinnovation.eu/07-05-2013/768/
       Reply 
    Are you sure you want to  Yes  No
    Your message goes here

Dr Sabine Brunswicker

  1. 1. Open Innovation in Action - Modes of Open InnovationDr. Sabine BrunswickerFraunhofer-Institute for Industrial Engineering & ESADE Business SchoolOpen Innovation 2.0 Conference, Dublin May 21, 2013
  2. 2. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThe innovation game haschanged¹Source: 1) Chesbrough (2003)
  3. 3. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThe orginial concept of open innovation describes a cognitive framework for a firm’sstrategy to profit from innovationOpen Modelexistingmarketnew marketother firm’smarketidea sourcingrunning/successful innovation projectsdiscarded innovation projectsClosed Modelmarket+++newproduct/serviceinternalinnovationresourcesinternalinnovationresourcesexternalinnovationresourcestechnologysourcingco-developmentpartnershipsspin-outSource: see also Chesbrough (2003, 2006)
  4. 4. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationSince 2003, the phenomenon is widely discussed and firms experiment with a range ofdifferent practices; do we know which ones matter?Google Search Open InnovationNov 2011 > 8 million hitsMay 2013 > 700 million hitsWidely discussed phenomena Multiple case studies Lack of insights?Adoption andpervasiveness ofof differentmodes of openinnovation
  5. 5. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationIn our new executive survey we found that open innovation is on the rise; it receivesincreasing management support at the top executive levelExecutive studyUC Berkeley andFraunhofer Sampling among the largest firms in Europe andUS Firm criteria: >1000 employees and >250million USD in sales Key informants: CEO, COO, or CTO atheadquarter Data collectionOctober– December 2012 125 datasets(5 % response rate)Adoption ofopen innovationAbandonmentOpen innovationexperienceManagementsupportIntensity78% practice openinnovation todayNo firm has abandonedopen innovationMedian of 5 years71 % have increasedmanagement support82 % have increasedopen innovation activitySource: Open Innovation Executive Survey Fraunhofer & UC Berkeley; n = 125
  6. 6. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThere is not „one“ single open innovation strategy; it involves a „bunch“ of practices
  7. 7. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationLarge firms like GE experiment with start-up competitions and idea contests toimplement inbound open innovation and create new innovation ecosystemsChallenge Powering theGrid Powering yourHomeB2B EntrantsOpportunity todevelop commercialrelationship with GEGE investment Nearly 4000 ideas 75,013entrepreneurs 23 partnerships ($200 USD investment)Source: www.ge.com, Chesbrough (2012) California Management ReviewCo- investment &venture partnersEmerald CapitalFoundation Capital….
  8. 8. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationOpen innovation intermediaries are on the rise; various types of firms have beenexperimenting with their services and learn their lessonsIntermediarySearcherMedium-sized firm (incollaboration withassocation)Solver CommunityReseachers, scientist, etc.“Request forproposal”Ideas andSolutionsMarket for Ideas and TechnologiesProblem: Strong durablegear materials that do notrequire lubricationSolutions:26 Solutions submitted16 new Solutions8 Solutions with potential fordevelopment
  9. 9. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationWe can differentiate between inflows and outflows of knowledge; they do notnecessarily imply a direct financial compensationDirectionInboundOutboundPecuniary Non-pecuniaryFinancial flowsSource: Chesbrough & Brunswicker (2013); Dahalander (2010)Inbound &pecuniaryInbound& non-pecuniaryOutbound&pecuniaryOutbound& non-pecuniary
  10. 10. Source. siehe auch Chesbrough (2003, 2006); Dahlander (2010)Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThere are various inbound practices to implement open innovationIP In-licensingInformal networkingPublically fundedR&D projectsContracting externalR&D servicesOpen InnovationIntermediariesInboundUniversity grantsSupplierinnovation awardsOwn crowdsourcinginitativeCustomer andconsumer co-creationIdea and start-upcompetition
  11. 11. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationCo-creation and informal networking are the top inbound practices; new practices score rather low2.342.642.663.373.713.733.874.194.384.431 2 3 4 5 6 73.804.093.764.014.474.044.114.284.124.681 2 3 4 5 6 7Customer and consumer co-creationInformal networkingUniversity research grantsPublically funded R&D consortiaContracting of external R&D serviceIdea and start-up competitionsIP in-licensingSupplier innovation awardsCrowdsourcing (unknown problem solvers)Specialized services OI intermediariesNot important HighlyimportantSignificantdecreaseSignificantincreaseNo changeSource: Open Innovation Executive Survey Fraunhofer & UC Berkeley; n = 91Importance in 2011(mean values)Change of importance 2008-2011(mean values)Inbound practices
  12. 12. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationJoint venturing is the top outbound mode of open innovation; spin-offs and donations scorevery low in terms of priority2.262.432.843.453.753.854.211 2 3 4 5 6 73.913.744.204.633.974.394.621 2 3 4 5 6 7Joint venture activitiesSelling of market-ready productsParticipation in public standardizationCorporate business incubation & venturingIP out-licensing & patent sellingDonations to commons or nonprofitsSpin-offsNot important HighlyimportantSignificantdecreaseSignificantincreaseNo changeImportance in 2011(mean values)Change of importance 2008-2011(mean values)Outbound practicesSource: Open Innovation Executive Survey Fraunhofer & UC Berkeley; n = 91
  13. 13. Trusted NetworkNewpartnersPearlfinderSupplierGovernmentResearcherDevelopmentpartnerOpen Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationIndeed, we found that new partnerships and innovation networks are the driving force of openness;IT offers firms new affordances for new kinds of innovation networks and empowers individualsPearlfinder• Company owned digital community• Challenge-driven innovation• Multi-staged process and individualTerms + Conditions• Link with other open innovationpracticesPartner and partner selection• Suppliers, universities,developmant partners,• No start-ups• Selection based on„manageral fit“and stabiltiy, IPR-Policy,„Academic Excellence“ andconcrete idea• Selection process based on newmethods such as incubation labChallengeUni
  14. 14. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationLarge firms do not yet recognize the value of connected communities; however, the gravity isshifting….The gravity is shifting….People-centric and digital networksBottom-up innovationConnected citizen
  15. 15. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThere is an internal component of openness; managing the journey from closed toopen innovation is the biggest challenge3.694.554.534.534.895.263.614.284.494.64.975.61 2 3 4 5 6 7Avoidance of external or already existing knowledgeEffectiveness of intellectual property protectionIdentifying new innovation sourcesProtecting internal critical know-howManagement of external relationship with innovation sourcesManaging the organizational change internallyChallenges of engaging in open innovation(mean values, 1=not important to 7= highly important)when firms startedtodayNot important Highly importantSource: Open Innovation Executive Survey Fraunhofer & UC Berkeley; n = 91
  16. 16. Open Innovation in Action: Modes of Open InnovationThere are different maturity stages of open innovation; it is a journey of experimentation andlearningClosed system First experimentCreating ofinnovationecosystemSystematicprocesses tomanage internaland externalinnovationsPerformanceMaturity levelsPhase 1 Phase 2 Phase 3 Phase 4 Phase 5Self-sustainingsystem(Platform player)FokalesUnternehmenKonkurrentenKundenKunden derKundenLieferanten2nd tierLieferantenUnis/ Forschungs-einrichtungenKomplementorenIntermediäreCommunitiesInterneTechnologie-BasisAktuellerMarktAktuellerMarktGescheiterte Ideen/abgebrochene ProjekteErfolgreiche Ideen/ erfolgreicheProjekteInterneTechnologie-BasisAktuellerMarktAktuellerMarktGescheiterte Ideen/abgebrochene ProjekteErfolgreiche Ideen/ erfolgreicheProjekteGescheiterte Ideen/abgebrochene ProjekteErfolgreiche Ideen/ erfolgreicheProjekteSource: Brunswicker and Ehrenmann (2012)New capabilities and processes: Design-led experimentation IP by design Network orchestration…
  17. 17. Open Innovation A „new“ paradigm for managing innovation?It is not easy to implement open innovation; it requires a systemic shift and re‐thinking of manyaspects of one’s business to utilize it effectively„If you’re not failing everynow and again, it’s a sign you’re notdoing anything very innovative.“Woody AllenManaging OpenInnovation in LargeFirmsSurvey report - Executive StudyOpen Innovation 2013Henry ChesbroughSabine BrunswickerContact:Sabine.brunswicker@iao.fraunhofer.de;sabine.brunswicker@esade.edu
  18. 18.  Back up
  19. 19. Open Innovation A „new“ paradigm for managing innovation?We are observing a shift towards the network level of open innovation activities; innovationcommunities and partnerships become more and more importantSource: Pisano and Verganti (2008)Elite Circle ConsortiumInnovation Mall Innovation CommunityGovernanceParticipationFlatHierarchyClosedOpen

×