Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Hedge Fund Operational Due Diligence - The Madoff Identity - Corgentum


Published on

An overview of the effects of the Madoff crisis on hedge fund operational due diligence from both the hedge fund's and investor's perspective. For more information visit

Published in: Economy & Finance, Business
  • All of these additional burdens will require a demands for increased transparency hedge fund to dip into their already regarding operational issues strained resources and will likely lead to slimmer overall profit margins. There are some quintessential dealmakers guide series to learn more about best practices in due diligence:
    Are you sure you want to  Yes  No
    Your message goes here
  • Be the first to like this

Hedge Fund Operational Due Diligence - The Madoff Identity - Corgentum

  1. 1. The Madoff Identity: A New Operational Due Diligence Paradigm in a Post-Madoff World March 2009 Corgentum Consulting LLC 20 Fleet St. Jersey City, NJ 07306 USA Email: Tel. 201-360-2430 Web:
  2. 2. more than ever, the ability to adapt in this The initial details concerning the largest post-Madoff environment is the benchmark alleged financial fraud in history are just against which hedge funds will be beginning to come into focus, yet one thing measured. Unfortunately in most investor’s is already clear, the repercussions of the minds, particularly those whose homes are Madoff scandal have elevated both now for sale as a result of losing virtually regulators and investors concerns related to everything with Madoff9), duplicity and hedge funds operational (i.e. non- mistrust are the new market mantras. investment related) risks to heighted levels of justified paranoia. Initially it seemed as if Preliminary reports surrounding the the Madoff scandal was the final supernova allegedly huge Ponzi scheme that was in a galaxy of unbelievable institutional Madoff Investment Securities LLC, are failures and fraudulent activities throughout bringing to light a blurry portrait of the 2008. firm’s seemingly bi-polar founder and namesake Bernard (aka: “Bernie”) Madoff. Unfortunately, with details of other new Madoff, a former NASDAQ chairman was alleged fraudsters continuing to emerge at ostensibly best known for being a hallmark an alarmingly steady rate such as the of integrity, who clearly understood the vanishing Arthur Nadel1), the brash Nicholas deep import of the seemingly blind trust Cosmo2), the Texan cricket hero R. Allen bestowed upon him by celebrities, wealthy Stanford3), the bold Paul Greenwood and country club golfers and unfortunately Stephen Walsh4), the audacious Ray M. charities. Yet many still find it hard to White5), the brazen Tom Petters6) and the believe that this once stalwart bastion of bizarre Rod Cameron Stringer7), it seems as ethics has been relegated to the status of a if Madoff was only the brightest star in an common thief. As when similar frauds, such expanding constellation of hedge fund as Sam Israel’s Bayou Hedge Fund Group, fraud. 2008 even saw hedge fund managers first hit the news a number of articles have themselves allegedly duped by purported been written seeking to point the finger at scams such as the one allegedly the obvious usual suspects including Mr. perpetrated by lawyer Marc Dreier who is Madoff himself, the SEC, fund of hedge charged with, among other things, selling fund managers, Swiss private banks, capital fraudulent securities to hedge funds and introducers, etc. When a fraud of this impersonating other attorneys8). magnitude takes place there is obviously no shortage of culpability to go around. After the wave of alleged frauds and failures that was 2008, it is clear that once Did Madoff start his firm off as a total scam established investment norms, former from the very beginning? While we may confidence in sterling reputations and long never know the true answer, it is standing institutional legacies are all reasonable to assume that he did not. Most susceptible to failure and change. Now investment frauds of this magnitude rarely 2
  3. 3. start off with the intent to defraud new, not even to the modern hedge fund investors. Indeed, hailing back to the days industry. The uniqueness of the Madoff Charles Ponzi’s universal postage stamp10), scandal lies not only in the magnitude of it is an essential element of a large scale the losses, estimated at $50 billion, and its fraud to have some shred of genuine scope, but more importantly in the fact that credibility. In Madoff’s case, people were such a well respected individual fooled so receiving handsome returns on their many. investments. Just as Ponzi did, if investors wanted to pull their cash out, Madoff paid Was this Jekyll and Hyde act a secret to them. The problem it seems was with the which Madoff himself was only privy? recent extended market turmoil followed Details are now emerging that the by too many requests for redemptions in a Securities and Exchange Commission is short period of time, there was no longer looking into the potential involvement of enough cash to continue to feed the other parties. The list of potential suspects machine and the house of cards collapsed. being questioned includes Madoff’s Yet a number of burning questions remain relatives who were employed at his firm outstanding, including one of the most and longtime Madoff employee Frank intriguing - who was the real Bernie DiPascali who was described as being Madoff? “evasive” during questioning by Securities and Exchange investigators.13) The Madoff Identity: Genius or Mad-Man? Also coming under scrutiny is Madoff Assuming that Mr. Madoff did indeed Investment Securities LLC three-person perpetrate this fraud, it seems that he had “auditor” Friehling & Horowitz who been living a life of dual identities for a very curiously for the past 15 years has been long time. On one hand, there was the informing the American Institute of elusive ethical market genius who was Certified Public Accountants that they do active with charitable organizations11) and not actually perform audits14). had found a way to produce an unbelievable continued steady stream of Of course, hindsight is 20/20 and now there profits over an extended period of years in are a host of individuals claiming that they both up and down markets. Adding to his passed on Madoff because they didn’t aura, Madoff was in such high demand that believe his incredulous returns15). Others he refused to take investments from people claim they saw enough red flags to suspect on numerous occasions12).On the other Madoff’s operations were a sham. hand, there was the alleged fraudster who Unbelievably, Harry Markopoulos even manufactured false investor statements in reported his suspicions about Madoff to the order to steal money from investors. Such SEC on numerous occasions to no avail16). split personalities between a fraudster’s public face and private actions are nothing 3
  4. 4. Regardless of who knew what, when, and The Investor’s Perspective how, one thing is certain – change in the Hedge fund investors will likely place an hedge fund industry is inevitable. It is likely increased responsibility on themselves and that this change will take place across many their advisors, to collect and monitor more fronts, and in particular via increased information about the operational risks of regulation17). However, even with increased hedge funds. Anything short of collecting regulation, it is impossible for investors to and digesting even a minimum base-level predict with any certainty the next major amount of operational information would fraudulent scheme. Beyond that, there is a border on the blindly naïve assumption that justified heightened importance which all the Madoff’s of the world have already investors must place on evaluating the been caught. Furthermore, hedge fund quality and nature of a hedge fund’s investors are beginning to come to grips operational infrastructure. As such, with the cold fact that a hedge fund investors will still bear the onus of organization can fail not just because of performing effective operational due poor investment performance of outright diligence, or hiring capable investment fraud, but for a host of other non- advisors to perform this due diligence on investment related reasons including poor their behalf. operational risk management, business continuity and disaster recovery, The Duality of Diligence: reputational risks, valuation risks, improper A Transparency Tug of War accounting risks, legal and compliance risks, Madoff’s dual identity is emblematic of the regulatory risks, etc. transparency tug of war that is operational due diligence. In the post-Madoff world Even beyond issues of outright failure, a hedge fund operational due diligence will poor operational infrastructure, reduces the represent a constant struggle between overall efficiency of the hedge fund investors and hedge funds that will focus organization which can have a series of on: negative repercussions for an organization • access to information including reduced performance. A concept which is known as Operational DragSM. • the rate (i.e. – timeliness) at which In summary, in the post-Madoff world the this information is released hedge fund operational due diligence process from the investor perspective is How exactly will this delicate informational likely to be altered in the following major balance be struck in a post-Madoff world? It ways: is worth considering this question from the • Institutions which invest in hedge perspective of both parties to the hedge funds and in particular money fund operational due diligence process – managers like fund of hedge funds investors and hedge funds. will dedicate more resources to due 4
  5. 5. diligence with a particular focus on The Hedge Fund’s Perspective operational due diligence Those hedge funds that have survived 2008, have now found themselves in the midst of • Hedge fund investors will take an operational due diligence quandary. On greater ownership and involvement the one hand, they want to ensure that in the operational due diligence those investors that have stayed with them process and no longer completely have all the information they need to outsource operational due diligence remain comfortable that their hedge fund to professional hedge fund organization has taken steps to properly allocators such as fund of hedge mitigate operational risk. Additionally, funds and consultants these same hedge funds want to attract new capital from investors who are looking • There will be a marked increase in for operationally strong organizations. Yet both investment committee voting on the other hand, these same hedge funds authority and veto power extended do not want to provide full transparency, to operational due diligence analysts particularly when it may expose any at more hedge fund allocation operational weaknesses which may be organizations present. Successful operational risk management in the post-Madoff world will • Investors will increase both the require hedge funds to walk a tightrope of scope and depth of operational continually boosting investor confidence in issues covered during a due a fund’s operational risk management diligence review, with a particular capabilities, while not destroying and focus being placed on operational competitive advantages or informational risk edges through the dissemination of this information. • Investors will place a premium on those hedge funds that allow them Hedge funds may not be prepared for the both: increased breadth and depth of investor i) access to operational reviews in this post-Madoff environment. information; and No longer will it be sufficient for investors ii) pro-actively provide to rely on generic due diligence this information on a questionnaires or to be granted a meeting frequent basis with a hedge fund’s senior operational professionals for a few hours once a year • Hedge fund investors will increase for an annual review. Investors will likely the frequency with which they request much greater detail on a host of perform operational due diligence different operational issues ranging from reviews legal and compliance issues, information technology, cash management and 5
  6. 6. valuation. Hedge fund investors will also and retain capital hedge funds will now, likely increase the frequency with which more than ever, be able to maximize the they want this operational information. In return on investment of resources allocated effect, it is likely that hedge funds will likely to effectively preparing to effectively need to deal with a normalization of the navigate the investor operational due broad temporal disconnect between the diligence process. Mirroring the changes in almost real-time monitoring of a hedge operational due diligence from the funds investments by investment analysts investor’s perspective, in the post-Madoff and the extremely infrequent monitoring of world the operational due diligence process operational risks. from the hedge fund’s perspective is likely be altered in the following major ways: These increased due diligence requirements • Hedge funds will be faced with vast will require hedge funds to be prepared to increases in both the frequency and devote more resources to each individual thoroughness of operational due investor’s operational due diligence reviews diligence reviews across a number of different areas including on-site meeting, document preparation and • Hedge funds will face increased due diligence questionnaire completion. As resource requirements and intimated earlier in this discussion, expenses in preparing for and compounding this problem is the increased executing investor operational due frequency with which these operational due diligence reviews diligence reviews will likely take place. • Hedge funds will face greater All of these additional burdens will require a demands for increased transparency hedge fund to dip into their already regarding operational issues strained resources and will likely lead to slimmer overall profit margins. • Hedge funds will be required to Consequently, hedge funds will be provide operational information to incentivized to ensure that they have investors with increased frequency detailed, cost-effective plans for dealing and timeliness with the on-going requirements of operational due diligence. So what does all this gloom and doom mean for investors and hedge funds that are still left standing on albeit shaky ground? Corgentum’s analysis of the situation is that vigilance and transparency are the new currency of hedge fund operational risk management. As such, in order to attract 6
  7. 7. CONCLUSION A change in the modern approach to hedge fund investing and operational due diligence is underway. The repercussions of the Madoff crisis compounded with the recession like economic climate will have a significant impact on the nature of hedge fund due diligence, particular with respect to operational risk. Both investors and hedge funds will be forced to rethink previously rigid due diligence paradigms. In order to survive, both groups (and hedge funds in particular) must be prepared for the costs associated with the increased resources that will be allocated to effectively carry out operational due diligence in the post-Madoff world. Investors must be able to demonstrate that they can properly manage and mitigate operational risk via execution of efficient due diligence. Those hedge funds that are prepared for these increasingly rigorous due diligence reviews and which make the processes as seamless as possible for investors will be the most effective at not only attracting but retaining capital from increasingly sensitive investors. 7
  8. 8. REFERENCES 1) Nadel disappeared on January 14, 2009 after reportedly transferring at least $1.25 million from two funds to a secret bank account: 2) Cosmo allegedly paid ex-convicts to recruit investors. He was court ordered to under extensive gambling therapy while previously imprisoned. Cosmo told Entrepreneur Magazine that he began his business with one employee in August 1999 – he was actually imprisoned at that time: 3) Stanford was charged by the SEC with perpetrating an $8-billion investment fraud via false promises of high-interest returns on his bank’s certificates. Stanford is well known throughout the Caribbean for promoting the sport of cricket:,0,3859843.story 4) Authorities claim Greenwood and Walsh’s WG Trading Company and Westridge Capital misappropriated approximately $667 million via a fraudulent enhanced indexing strategy: 5) The Commodity Futures Trading Commission charged Ray M. White and his company, CRW Management LP, with allegedly stealing millions of dollars to fund a lavish lifestyle which included Dallas Stars season tickets and sponsorship of his son’s drag racing team: 250-investors.html 6)Petters was indicted by a federal grand jury for allegedly orchestrating a $3.5 billion Ponzi scheme: 7) Stringer, via his RCS Hedge Fund, allegedly misappropriated millions from investors since 2001. In addition to running his hedge fund Stringer, who is an ex-car salesman, worked as a bail bondsman, tow-truck driver and a crop duster: 8) Dreier was accused of impersonating a lawyer from the Ontario Teachers Pension Plan named Michael Padfield: 9) “My house is up for sale.” Allan Goldstein, Madoff Investor: 8
  9. 9. 10) Ponzi’s original scam was a supposed arbitrage scheme involving international reply coupons for postage stamps. 11) Such as Gift of Life Bone Marrow Foundation: 12) Barbara Fox, president of a Manhattan estate agency business, said she "literally begged" Madoff to take her money but he refused: details/Revealed:+Magic+Madoffs+family+piggy+bank+in+the+heart+of+Mayfair/ 13) 14) 15)Such as Ben Stein: 16),8599,1874218-2,00.html 17) 9
  10. 10. ABOUT CORGENTUM Corgentum Consulting, LLC (, is a full service hedge fund operational risk consultancy practice. The firm utilizes proprietary methodologies and original operational risk research to partner with both hedge funds and investors to diagnose and mitigate operational risk exposures, and improve upon the overall efficiency and effectiveness of the operational due diligence process. Corgentum’s primary practice areas include outsourced operational due diligence, development of operational due diligence functions, hedge fund operational due diligence meeting preparation, operational efficiency analysis and implementation management. Corgentum was founded by Jason Scharfman one leading experts in the field of hedge fund operational due diligence and the author of Hedge Fund Operational Due Diligence: Understanding the Risks (John Wiley & Sons 2008). © 2009 Corgentum Consulting LLC 10