Presentation by Robert Nasi, Director of the CGIAR Research Program on Forests, Trees and Agroforestry, on the CGIAR - held at CIFOR's partners' meeting in Nairobi in February 2015.
9. Why forests are important
Forests provide $250 billion in various forms of income and are essential to
the livelihoods of 1.6 billion people – a quarter of the world’s population
They contain 80% of the Earth’s terrestrial biodiversity
Forests absorb up to a third of all carbon emissions
11. Consultative development process
27 May 2010: 20 page concept note sent to 328 partners
5 July: 73 respondents agree to provide comment on full draft proposal
14 July: Full draft proposal sent to 171 partners
27 August: 34 partners provide comments
6 September: Full draft submitted to Consortium Board
24 December: Consortium Board + 4 independent reviewers
provide comment on full draft
19 January 2011: Revised draft sent to 100+ partners
25 January: 18 partners provide comments
7 February: Full draft proposal re-
submitted to Consortium Board
6 April 2011: CRP6 Approved by
Fund Council
17. Partnerships
Levels/Types Research Partners Policy and Practice
Partners
Knowledge-sharing
Partners
International CIRAD, IRD, IUFRO,
Columbia University,
Wageningen, VITRI, other
universities and ARI
CPF, FAO, UNEP, World
Bank, UN-REDD, IPCC, FSC,
IUCN
BBC World Service Trust,
Panos, UN-REDD, CPF,
IUCN
Regional CATIE, ANAFE, FARA,
SEANAFE; ASARECA, CORAF,
SAARD, STCP,
SA/AP/LAFORGEN
AFF, COMIFAC, ASEAN,
ECOWAS
RECOFTC, STCP, CATIE
Country or local NARS, UNIKIS, other
universities, FORDA, KEFRI,
other research organizations
NARS, government, CBOs,
NGOs, private sector
companies
Local NGOs and
networks, government
18. Research outputs: more than 1300 publications (550 ISI),
several databases, numerous guidelines & toolkits
Outcomes: significant set of outcomes with good
representation in the CGIAR portfolio report
MEIA: on top of the game in the CGIAR; IDOs, Theory of
change, outcome mapping, joint implementation of M&E with
other CRPs
Gender: in the top 4, strategy, 3 hired, 3 to come, trained
>60 scientists, guidelines, tools – used by partners, commit
10% of funding
Capacity building: (>200 workshops, 5000 pax, 48%
women; 80 PhD, 500 interns, 47% women; 3 course in house,
120 pax, 67% women)
Funding: W2 increased to 8M; 45M W1/2 secured; 82M
raised in W3/others in 2 years. The 4th largest CRP
Achievements
19. Phase 1, 2011-14
Development
Phase 1.2, 2015-16
Refinement
Phases 3 + 4, 2017-25
Stock take & adaptation
Teams and processes
Common Operational Plan
Mapping projects
MEIA & Gender strategies
Building partnerships
External Evaluation 2013
Impact assessments
Theme evaluations
IDOs + targets
↗ collaboration between
CRPs (esp. 1.x)
↗ harmonization
↗ integration of partners
into governance and
implementation
Mid-term impact “overview”
Evaluation of implementation
of gender and MEIA strategy
Milestones to IDOs
Overall approach revisited
and modified based on
results of CRP impact
assessment, successes &
failures, etc.
Revisiting original themes,
focusing, addressing gaps
and emerging issues
New themes, continuation
of relevant ones
Overall impacts (target
achievements - 2023)
External evaluations 2018,
2023
Phased work plan
Defining research themes
Data management and
platforms
23. CIFOR’s vision
Forests are high on the
political agenda
People recognize the value
of forests for maintaining
livelihoods and ecosystems
Decisions that influence
forests and the people that
depend on them are based
on solid science and
principles of good
governance, and reflect
the perspectives of
developing countries and
forest-dependent people
24. CIFOR’s purpose
We advance human
wellbeing,
environmental
conservation and
equity by conducting
research to inform
policies and practices
that affect forests in
less-developed
countries.
25. CIFOR’s history
Established in 1993 as part of the
CGIAR
Board’s early guidance led to
emphasis on policy-oriented, multi-
disciplinary research
Major lines of research have included:
• Criteria and indicators
• Underlying causes of deforestation
• Decentralisation
• Improved logging practices
• Forests and livelihoods
• Forest finance and governance
Board approved a new strategy in
2008
27. Where we work: Tropical forests
Humid forests
1.1 billion hectares
Diverse, 50% terrestrial species
Low population density
Rural poor/marginalized groups
Dry forests
0.7 billion hectares
Less diverse, high endemism
Low /high population density
Disproportionate number of poor
28. Where we work
Cameroon Indonesia
Headquarters: Bogor, Indonesia
3 hubs & several project offices
Research sites in more than 30 countries
Peru Kenya
29. Global comparative
research
Synthesizing
existing knowledge
Developing new
methods
Partnership
Capacity-building
Outreach
How we
work:
Approaches
32. Smallholder production
systems and markets
Management and
conservation of forest and
tree resources
Environmental services and
landscape management
Climate change adaptation
and mitigation
Impacts of trade and
investment on forests and
people
Research
components
33. Research
component
Enhancing management and production systems for
smallholders (food security and nutrition)
Increasing income generation and market integration
for smallholders
Improving policy and institutions to enhance social
assets to secure rights in forest- and tree-dependent
communities
Smallholder production systems and markets
34. Example of research:
Poverty and Environment
Network (PEN)
Study of forest-based
contributions to incomes in
more than 8,000 households in
24 countries
Finding: Income from forests
contributes on average more
than one-fifth of total
household earnings for people
living in or
near forests
PEN publications to be
released
in April 2014
35. Example of impact: Money for honey
CIFOR analysis in Cameroon on the roles played by men, women and youth in
beekeeping chains aided the formation of the small enterprise Guiding Hope.
Today, it collaborates with over 1,000 producers and their households.
Body Shop began using Guiding Hope honey and wax in its products in 2010
36. Understanding threats to important tree species and
formulating genetic conservation strategies
Conserving and characterizing high-quality germplasm
of important tree crops and their wild relatives
Developing improved silvicultural, monitoring and
management practices for multiple use
Developing tools and methods to resolve conflicts over
distribution of benefits and resource rights
Management and conservation of forest and tree
resources
Research
component
37. Example of research: Bushmeat
In rural areas of the Congo Basin, many
communities depend on wild meat hunted in
forests for up to 80 percent of the fats and
proteins in their diets.
Scientific field work in Congo Basin resulted in
several articles and a 2008 synthesis monograph
on the bushmeat crisis and creation of the
Liaison Group on Bushmeat
38. Example of impact:
Certification for
smallholders
CIFOR assistance to the
Forestry Stewardship
Council’s efforts to
refine FSC standards
for small-scale
operations with
prospective application
in Brazil, Cameroon,
and Mexico
39. Understanding drivers of forest transition
Understanding the consequences of forest
transition for environmental services and
livelihoods
Learning landscapes: dynamics of multi-
functionality
Environmental services and landscape managementResearch
component
40. Example of research: Tenure
constraints on REDD
Competitiveness of REDD supply Bottleneck: Land tenure chaos
Unknown tenure 53%
Indigenous lands 9%
Agricultural settlements 10%
PA for sustainable use 9%
Community lands <1%
Registered properties 1%
Legend
Cities
Roads
State limits
Water
Sources: IBAMA, INCRA 2007, Soares-Filho et al. 2006
CIFOR analysis of tenure constraints to PES-based approaches to
forest conservation in Brazil
41. Example of impact:
Community forestry in Guinea
Research from a USAID-supported project in Guinea identified policy options to strengthen
community forests as legal entities and practical options for agricultural intensification
Up to threefold increase in local incomes, and major expansion in natural vegetation cover
42. Harnessing forests, trees and agroforestry
for climate change mitigation
Enhancing climate change adaptation
Understanding synergies between climate
change mitigation and adaptation
Climate change adaptation and mitigationResearch
component
43. Example of research:
Carbon in mangroves
New finding: Surprisingly large
amounts of carbon stored in
mangrove forests, especially
below ground
Mangrove photo
44. Example of impact:
Ecosystem-based adaptation
Joint CIFOR-CATIE research on
tropical forests and climate
change adaptation in Honduras
influenced the design of one of
the first projects ever approved
by the UNFCCC’s Adaptation
Fund Board
45. Understanding the processes and impacts
of forest-related trade and investment
Enhancing responses and policy options to
mitigate the negative impacts and enhance
the positive impacts of trade and
investment
Impacts of trade and investment on forests and peopleResearch
component
46. Example of research:
Implications of biodiesel-induced land-use
changes
Direct and/or indirect land-use changes from cultivation of feedstocks
cause can emissions due to carbon losses in soils and biomass
In the different case studies explored for this analysis, the largest carbon
debt is created by oil palm followed by jatropha and soybean
Carbon debt due to direct (dLUC) and indirect land-use change (iLUC)
expressed in terms of both carbon and CO2-eq
Note: (1)
represent the
low iLUC
scenario , and
(2) constitutes
the most
conservative
estimate
47. Example of impact: Forest industry
Research on Indonesia’s pulp and paper industry helped avert the
loss of 135,000 hectares of natural tropical rainforest, valued at
$133 million in avoided carbon emissions
50. Engagement with practitioners
CIFOR hosted and contributed to more than 20 conferences and workshops in 2013 that
involved civil society and business representatives
Sustainable Forest Management in Central Africa (above, May 2013)
Fires, Haze and Landscape Workshop (January 2014)
Forests Asia Summit (May 2014)
51. Capacity development:
Example from the DRC
Survey in 2005 found less than 10 active
researchers in DRC - a country that
represent 60% of the Congo Basin’s forests
Project at the University of Kisangani: 35
MSc students trained; 25 PhDs ongoing
Separate project in Congo Basin on climate
change adaptation trained 40 MSc students;
additional 15 PhD
52. Web-based
Combines with
traditional outreach
Demand driven
Tailored to
stakeholders
Shared platforms and
content with partners
Constant monitoring,
review, adaptation
Communications
CIFOR
Output
Knowledge
sharing
Knowledge
sharing
Knowledge
sharing
Impact
Impact
Impact
CIFOR
Research
CIFOR’s communications model
Forests are now receiving a level of attention that we haven’t seen for many years, if ever. Foremost among a number of reasons for this is the fact that forests are now centre stage in the global debate on climate change. Over the last couple of years the world has come to the realisation that curbing forest loss is a critical and cost-effective way to mitigate global warming. And yet, on the other hand, new forces continue to drive deforestation and degradation. For example, the promotion of biofuels as a solution to global warming is driving land conversion to crops such as soy bean or oil palm, while food shortages are placing even greater pressure on forests for conversion to rice, grain and other food crops. Then there’s China and its rapid economic growth literally changing the face of timber supply and demand, while the continuing globalisation of trade and decentralization of forest management are also changing the way forests are being used.
Forests cover 31% of the world’s land mass (Source: http://www.unep.org/geo/pdfs/Keeping_Track.pdf UNEP report “Keeping track of our changing environment” 2011)
Forests provide $250 billion in various forms of income (Source:
Essential to the livelihoods of 1.6 billion people – a quarter of the world’s population http://www.fao.org/forestry/livelihoods/en/
Forests contain 80% of the Earth’s terrestrial biodiversity(Source: Chape, S. et al. 2005. Measuring the extent and effectiveness of protected areas as an indicator of meeting
global biodiversity targets. Philosophical Transactions Royal Society (B) 360: 443–455.)
Forests absorb up to a third of all carbon emissions - in Science in August 2011: “A Large and Persistent Carbon Sink in the World's Forests”
http://www.sciencemag.org/content/333/6045/988
Some of our most important partnerships are with the host governments of the countries where we work. So most important of all is the Government of Indonesia, which has been our host ever since CIFOR was founded in 1993.
Host Country Agreement with Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Technical cooperation with Ministry of Forestry (MOU with FORDA)
“No surprises” policy
Indonesia forestry roundtables
Seconded researchers
Global comparative research
Global comparative study on REDD+: project funded by NORAD
Synthesizing existing knowledge
Example
Developing new methods
Example
Capacity building
Research on capacity-building needs – e.g., analysis of Indonesia’s Reforestation Fund
Capacity-building for research – integration into research agendas of forestry research institutes
67 graduate students currently associated with CIFOR
Photo shows CIFOR PhD student in GCS C3 Jodie Hartill measuring greenhouse gasses in peatland in Berbak National Park in Jambi
Impact assesment
Governments
In Indonesia…
CIFOR scientists advising Indonesia and Norway on Letter of Intent implementation
Current efforts to promote “REDD literacy” across stakeholder groups, including media
Global
Forest Day
National
Regional
Multilateral
Civil society
At Forests Indonesia Conferemce: 935 leaders, including 80 journalists, 250 private sector leaders
37 speakers and panelists, including Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, Indonesian Minister of Forestry Zulkifli Hasan, Erik Solheim, Norway’s Minister for the Environment, Jim Paice, UK Minister of State at the Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs, Andrew Steeer, World Bank Special Envoy for Climate Change, Louise Hand, Australia’s Ambassador for Climate Change.
Media training workshops in Indonesia: April 2011 in Bali on wetlands and climate change trained 17 journalists; 19 reporters trained on REDD+ in Palangkaraya in July 2011. REDD+ workshops scheduled for Vietnam in March 2012
October 2011: Norad Civil Society Workshop: Indonesian civil society organisations as agents of change in the Indonesian forest governance reform agenda
January 2012: Linking Great Ape Conservation and Poverty Alleviation: Sharing Experience from Africa and Asia
The man on the left of the photo is the first PhD from the University of Kisangani project
Greater goal and objective is to increase publication readership and publication downloads.
Know your stakeholders (think five, not 100,000)
Thinks of your audiences as individuals through each level
Visualize a stakeholder in each ring of the process/diagram
Share your platforms and content with partners
Don’t limit yourselves to just your own organizations content. Take and disseminate news feeds, other readings/publications etc. (on our FCC site we run “weekly readings” of other organizations chosen by our scientists.
It is all about the web.
Pictures
CIFOR main website homepage
We monitor 11 indicators, to see where readers come from, what they read, how long they spend, what they download. The number of page views of any website is a critical indicator of how interesting readers find your site, the more pages they read the more they like, the longer they stay, and the more often they return.
Forests News blog: 2,200 page views in January 2011. One year later, in Jan 2012, we had 17,000 page views that month.
Two years after that, in January 2014: almost 45,000 page views that month. Augmented by social media: Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, others
REDD-I newsletter sent monthly to 3,500 subscribers in Indonesian + MoF listserves.
REDD-I touch-screen computer in MoF lobby
We have done training workshops with MoF comms staff.
REDD-I readership = about 6,500/month
Publication downloads from REDD-I = 10,000 from May 2011 to January 2012
Media
International, regional and local journalist networks
Journalist trainings
Media interviews/briefings
100 media hits per month
Publications
Over 80 000 given out each year