SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 5
Download to read offline
y'tpw.v.*:'z *&
IN TllE U NITED STATESD ISTRICT COURT FOR THE W ESTERN
DISTRICT OF VIRGIN IA DAN W LLE DIW SION
A LV IN L.SUTHERLW ,.TR.,
#laintiff, ' j
CivilA ction No.4:15CV 00037
V.
LIEUTENANT J.W .SM ITR,
and
SERGEAN T H .S.M CH ARD SON ,
M d
OFFICER N .M .SLOW R,atld
UFFICER M .C.PACE,and
OFFICER R .C.LANDRUM ,and
f
OFFICER D.C.LANUASTER,and
OFFICER W .C.SHIW LY,and
OFFICER W .R.V ERRILL,and
OFFICER J.D .D IX ON .and
okvRq':OFR::ue 01:%eeoe
ATnANM(ki,VA
FILED
APR 222216,,:.. ' ..''
JULIAc. U L , LE
BY; .
DEP ct-R
OFFICER L.D .LAN D ,
befendants.
PLAINTIFF'SM OTIONTO COW XLW ITH SANCTIONS
.
'
/o8.ê
Case 4:15-cv-00037-JLK-RSB Document 80 Filed 04/22/16 Page 1 of 5 Pageid#: 1249
NOW COVESPlaintiff,AlvinL.Sutherlin,Jr.(Pr0Se)requeststhatthis
Honorablecourtcom pelsthedefendantstofulfllthecourt'sOrderfled on
04/01/2016(DktNo.68)andsubpoenafiledon12/22/2015(Dk1No.39).The
plaintiffrespecévely asksforsancéonsage stthedefendantstm derRule370fthe
FederalRulesofCivilProcedureand enforcethesanctionsagainstthedefendants.
Thesubpoena(DktNo.39)readsasfollows:
''YOU ARE COM M AN DED to produceatthetim e,date,andplacesetforth
below thefollowingdocuments,eleckonicallystoredinformation?orobjects,and
toperm itinspecéon,copying;testing,orsam pling ofthem aterial.Any and all
bodywarm tamera(BW P)documentationFxledwithintheDanvillePolice
D epartm ent'srecordsand/orEvidence.com .Includl g,butnotlim ited toany
ofscersfailuretoactivatehksorhersBW C,failureofanyBW C atthe
beginningordurihgtheirshifqanywritten authorization toedit,alter,erase,
duplicate,copy and/orshareany BW C .videoand/oraudio fkom the
follow ingoffcersXIaXnGI:-ISERGEANTH.S.M CHARDSON,OFFICERN.M .
SLOVER,OFFICER M .C.PA CE,OFFICER RC.LAN DRUM ,OFFICER D .C .
LANCASTER,OFFICER W .C.SHIW LY,OFFICER W .R M ERRILL,OFFICER
J.D .D IXON ,LIEU TEN ANT J.W .SM ITH,OFFICER L.D .LAND ,and/or
CAPTM N D.HAI,EYIinrelae gtoanyandallincidentsatthelocaéon505
Jefferson SkeetDanville,Virginia24541onandafterSeptember25th ?2013
involvingAlvinL.SutherlinJr.,M ichelleOwensmatldBritm eyC.Logano''
Thedefendantshavechosentothedefythecourtsorderin fully disclosz gbody
wom cameraWdeos(BWC)'s(See:Elderv.Cityof,
Danville,Vaeta1,No.4:2013cv00047X .D.Va.2014)andnotprovideallofthe
tm editedvideosâom a11ofthedefendants,presentat505Jeferson street,
D anvilleVirginiaforthe Septem ber25th 2013 asOrderflled on 04/01/2016
(DktNo.68).TheOrderreadsasfollows:
Case 4:15-cv-00037-JLK-RSB Document 80 Filed 04/22/16 Page 2 of 5 Pageid#: 1250
''PlaintiffssubpoenatotheDanvillePoliceDepartmentseeltsGlalnyandall
bodywarm Isiclcamera(BW C)documentationflledwithintheDanville
PoliceDepartm ent'srecordsand/orEvidence-com .lncluding,butnotIim ited
toanyoflkersIsiclfailuretoactivateMsorhersIsiclBW C,failureofany
BW C ...any written authorization to edit,alter,erase,duplicatw copy and/or
shareany BW C videoand/oraudio-''Dkt.No.30.Thesubpoenarequests
inform ation aboutfootageobtal ed from an om cerw hoisnotnam ed in
Plaintiffscom plaintaswellasinform atioh aboutfoofagefkom Septem ber25,
2013 and thereafter.TheFederalRulesofCivilProcedurerequirethat
inform ation requa ted in discovery berelevantto aclàim ordefenseand
proportionaltotheneedsofthecase.Fed.R.Civ.P.26(b)(1).PlaltiFs
requestforinform ation aboutthefootageobtained by any oœ cernotG volved
in thesearch ofPlaintiffsresidenceorforany petiod oftim ebeyond the
execution oftheselrch warranton Septem ber25.2013 isneitherrelevantnor
proportionaltohisclaim s.A ccordingly,thesubpoena shallbelim ited in scope
tothefootagefrom cam erasw orn byoflk erswhowerepresentduringthe
execution ofthew arrantdescribed in Plaintiffscom plaint.Thescopeofthe
subpoena shallalso beIim itedto thedateand tim eperiod oftheevents
da cribed in thecom plal tand to theoflk erswho arenam ed asdefendantsin
thiscase.D efendants'm otion to quash isthereforeGR ANTED in part.
D efendantsaredirected to providePlal tiffw ith theinform ation requested in
thesubpoena(asIimitedbythisorder)withintwentpone(21)daysofthedate
ofthksorden ''
Thedefendantshavenotproduced any ofthesupportingdocum entaéon gnd
recordsasstated within thesubpoenaincluding 9om Evidence.com andthe
plaintiffhasonlyreceivedsomeeditedbodyworncamera(BWC)thathaveclearly
beenedited.Thesevideoshavealréadybeensubmittedinasexhibitsbfevidence
tothecourt.Theplaintiffalsostillhasnoibeengivenanybodyworncamera
(BW C)videos9om OFFICER D.C.LM CASTER,OFFICER L.D.LA'o and/or
LIEUTENAN T J.W .SM ITH to date.
A1lofthedefendantsinthiscasewerepresentat505Jefferson streetDanville
V irginia245410n Septem ber26th.2013and a11w ereissuedworkingbodyw orn
$GWXCase 4:15-cv-00037-JLK-RSB Document 80 Filed 04/22/16 Page 3 of 5 Pageid#: 1251
cameras(BWC)onthatdayatthebeginningoftheirslo followingtheDanville
PoliceDepartment's(BWC)'spolicy.Noswornnmdavitsoroflcialdoctlments
havebeenprovidedtoshow thisisnotfacm alinform ation.
-'
N
:
3.-
h$
AlvinL.Suthe ',Jr.(ProSe)
1StFloor505Jefferson Stre , ,
DanvillevVirginla24 41-2037
434-728-2673(Ce11pho e)
Sutherlinjr@m ail.com .
o
'
lhereby certlfythatthefore o'gnoticro awsuitwassentbyregttlarm ail,
postalpaidorhanddeliveredathis nd ayofAprilm2016toClerkofCourtof
ThèUi ted StatesDisz ctCourtFo estern DistrictbfVirginiaDanville
D ivision and .1alsohereby ce ' thatl vem ailedorh> d deliveredacopyof
theforegoingto theofficeo anielaM edle KirbypP.C,110N orth Union
SkeetP.0.Box720,D lle,VA 24543-072
/'- Nw
F..r-s-Case 4:15-cv-00037-JLK-RSB Document 80 Filed 04/22/16 Page 4 of 5 Pageid#: 1252
cameras(BWC)onthatdayatthebeginningoftheirshiâfollowingtheDanville
PoliceDepartment's(BWC)'spolicy.NoswornaG davitsoroffcialdocllments
havebeen providedto show thisisnotfactualinform ation.
c'' untycf .57
-, mmonwaay/sy
mt antj . j,,s me*: d v
0 . myandandoaax)..
'
AlvinL SutherlinJr( se) .-? ' e-ablk* > * j
f
ufap xp;;
505JeffersonStreet,1StFloor tprintyourexpiravondqa- )
Danville,V irginia24541-2037
434-728-2673(Ce11phone)
Sutherlinjr@m ail.com
-,
,
'
tk'., ReneeLawso'n Berger,
.;: .1x
jj' . $,# NotaryPublic
'u
6'
/').CommonweaIthofVirginia.x. ;..;! ,v .4v,ti.is-%7-q;, Reg.8/7255233
w'ên.,,,.--. ut'oommipxx sxps,gunoao,20:z
Ihereby certifythattheforegoingnoéceoflaw suitw assentby regularm ail,
postalpaidorhaqddelivered,this22nd,dayofApri,12016toClerkofCourtof
TheUnitedStatesDistrictCourtForW estem DisG ctofVirginiyDanville
Division and .1alsohereby certifythatlhavem ailed orhanddellvered acopyof
theforegoingtotheofficeMfDanielmM edley& Kirby .Q 110NorthUnion
SkeetP.0 .Box 720,Dœm lle,VA 24543-0720
ForE
Case 4:15-cv-00037-JLK-RSB Document 80 Filed 04/22/16 Page 5 of 5 Pageid#: 1253

More Related Content

Recently uploaded

Town of Haverhill's Motion for Summary Judgment on DTC Counterclaims
Town of Haverhill's Motion for Summary Judgment on DTC CounterclaimsTown of Haverhill's Motion for Summary Judgment on DTC Counterclaims
Town of Haverhill's Motion for Summary Judgment on DTC CounterclaimsRich Bergeron
 
Town of Haverhill's Summary Judgment Motion for Declaratory Judgment Case
Town of Haverhill's Summary Judgment Motion for Declaratory Judgment CaseTown of Haverhill's Summary Judgment Motion for Declaratory Judgment Case
Town of Haverhill's Summary Judgment Motion for Declaratory Judgment CaseRich Bergeron
 
Smarp snapshot 200 -- Google Cloud Next '24
Smarp snapshot 200 -- Google Cloud Next '24Smarp snapshot 200 -- Google Cloud Next '24
Smarp snapshot 200 -- Google Cloud Next '24Jong Hyuk Choi
 
Ashutosh Yadav v. State of UP 22nd March, 2024 All HC.pdf
Ashutosh Yadav v. State of UP 22nd March, 2024 All HC.pdfAshutosh Yadav v. State of UP 22nd March, 2024 All HC.pdf
Ashutosh Yadav v. State of UP 22nd March, 2024 All HC.pdfVidit Agrawal
 
OMassmann - Investment into the grid and transmission system in Vietnam (2024...
OMassmann - Investment into the grid and transmission system in Vietnam (2024...OMassmann - Investment into the grid and transmission system in Vietnam (2024...
OMassmann - Investment into the grid and transmission system in Vietnam (2024...Dr. Oliver Massmann
 
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Material Facts For Declaratory Judgment Moti...
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Material Facts For Declaratory Judgment Moti...Town of Haverhill's Statement of Material Facts For Declaratory Judgment Moti...
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Material Facts For Declaratory Judgment Moti...Rich Bergeron
 
Anti-Online Sexual Abuse or Exploitation of Children (OSAEC) and Anti-Child S...
Anti-Online Sexual Abuse or Exploitation of Children (OSAEC) and Anti-Child S...Anti-Online Sexual Abuse or Exploitation of Children (OSAEC) and Anti-Child S...
Anti-Online Sexual Abuse or Exploitation of Children (OSAEC) and Anti-Child S...Diamond959916
 
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Facts for Summary Judgment on Counterclaims ...
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Facts for Summary Judgment on Counterclaims ...Town of Haverhill's Statement of Facts for Summary Judgment on Counterclaims ...
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Facts for Summary Judgment on Counterclaims ...Rich Bergeron
 
Power Point Obligations and contracts Article 1313-1327
Power Point Obligations and contracts Article 1313-1327Power Point Obligations and contracts Article 1313-1327
Power Point Obligations and contracts Article 1313-1327bariajenne
 
ENG7-Q4-MOD3. determine the worth of ideas mentioned in the text listened to
ENG7-Q4-MOD3. determine the worth of ideas mentioned in the text listened toENG7-Q4-MOD3. determine the worth of ideas mentioned in the text listened to
ENG7-Q4-MOD3. determine the worth of ideas mentioned in the text listened toirenelavilla52178
 
IOS PPT.pptx doctrine of stare decisiss
IOS PPT.pptx  doctrine of stare decisissIOS PPT.pptx  doctrine of stare decisiss
IOS PPT.pptx doctrine of stare decisissPothysVaran1
 

Recently uploaded (11)

Town of Haverhill's Motion for Summary Judgment on DTC Counterclaims
Town of Haverhill's Motion for Summary Judgment on DTC CounterclaimsTown of Haverhill's Motion for Summary Judgment on DTC Counterclaims
Town of Haverhill's Motion for Summary Judgment on DTC Counterclaims
 
Town of Haverhill's Summary Judgment Motion for Declaratory Judgment Case
Town of Haverhill's Summary Judgment Motion for Declaratory Judgment CaseTown of Haverhill's Summary Judgment Motion for Declaratory Judgment Case
Town of Haverhill's Summary Judgment Motion for Declaratory Judgment Case
 
Smarp snapshot 200 -- Google Cloud Next '24
Smarp snapshot 200 -- Google Cloud Next '24Smarp snapshot 200 -- Google Cloud Next '24
Smarp snapshot 200 -- Google Cloud Next '24
 
Ashutosh Yadav v. State of UP 22nd March, 2024 All HC.pdf
Ashutosh Yadav v. State of UP 22nd March, 2024 All HC.pdfAshutosh Yadav v. State of UP 22nd March, 2024 All HC.pdf
Ashutosh Yadav v. State of UP 22nd March, 2024 All HC.pdf
 
OMassmann - Investment into the grid and transmission system in Vietnam (2024...
OMassmann - Investment into the grid and transmission system in Vietnam (2024...OMassmann - Investment into the grid and transmission system in Vietnam (2024...
OMassmann - Investment into the grid and transmission system in Vietnam (2024...
 
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Material Facts For Declaratory Judgment Moti...
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Material Facts For Declaratory Judgment Moti...Town of Haverhill's Statement of Material Facts For Declaratory Judgment Moti...
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Material Facts For Declaratory Judgment Moti...
 
Anti-Online Sexual Abuse or Exploitation of Children (OSAEC) and Anti-Child S...
Anti-Online Sexual Abuse or Exploitation of Children (OSAEC) and Anti-Child S...Anti-Online Sexual Abuse or Exploitation of Children (OSAEC) and Anti-Child S...
Anti-Online Sexual Abuse or Exploitation of Children (OSAEC) and Anti-Child S...
 
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Facts for Summary Judgment on Counterclaims ...
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Facts for Summary Judgment on Counterclaims ...Town of Haverhill's Statement of Facts for Summary Judgment on Counterclaims ...
Town of Haverhill's Statement of Facts for Summary Judgment on Counterclaims ...
 
Power Point Obligations and contracts Article 1313-1327
Power Point Obligations and contracts Article 1313-1327Power Point Obligations and contracts Article 1313-1327
Power Point Obligations and contracts Article 1313-1327
 
ENG7-Q4-MOD3. determine the worth of ideas mentioned in the text listened to
ENG7-Q4-MOD3. determine the worth of ideas mentioned in the text listened toENG7-Q4-MOD3. determine the worth of ideas mentioned in the text listened to
ENG7-Q4-MOD3. determine the worth of ideas mentioned in the text listened to
 
IOS PPT.pptx doctrine of stare decisiss
IOS PPT.pptx  doctrine of stare decisissIOS PPT.pptx  doctrine of stare decisiss
IOS PPT.pptx doctrine of stare decisiss
 

MOTION TO COMPEL Doc.80 04-29-2016

  • 1. y'tpw.v.*:'z *& IN TllE U NITED STATESD ISTRICT COURT FOR THE W ESTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGIN IA DAN W LLE DIW SION A LV IN L.SUTHERLW ,.TR., #laintiff, ' j CivilA ction No.4:15CV 00037 V. LIEUTENANT J.W .SM ITR, and SERGEAN T H .S.M CH ARD SON , M d OFFICER N .M .SLOW R,atld UFFICER M .C.PACE,and OFFICER R .C.LANDRUM ,and f OFFICER D.C.LANUASTER,and OFFICER W .C.SHIW LY,and OFFICER W .R.V ERRILL,and OFFICER J.D .D IX ON .and okvRq':OFR::ue 01:%eeoe ATnANM(ki,VA FILED APR 222216,,:.. ' ..'' JULIAc. U L , LE BY; . DEP ct-R OFFICER L.D .LAN D , befendants. PLAINTIFF'SM OTIONTO COW XLW ITH SANCTIONS . ' /o8.ê Case 4:15-cv-00037-JLK-RSB Document 80 Filed 04/22/16 Page 1 of 5 Pageid#: 1249
  • 2. NOW COVESPlaintiff,AlvinL.Sutherlin,Jr.(Pr0Se)requeststhatthis Honorablecourtcom pelsthedefendantstofulfllthecourt'sOrderfled on 04/01/2016(DktNo.68)andsubpoenafiledon12/22/2015(Dk1No.39).The plaintiffrespecévely asksforsancéonsage stthedefendantstm derRule370fthe FederalRulesofCivilProcedureand enforcethesanctionsagainstthedefendants. Thesubpoena(DktNo.39)readsasfollows: ''YOU ARE COM M AN DED to produceatthetim e,date,andplacesetforth below thefollowingdocuments,eleckonicallystoredinformation?orobjects,and toperm itinspecéon,copying;testing,orsam pling ofthem aterial.Any and all bodywarm tamera(BW P)documentationFxledwithintheDanvillePolice D epartm ent'srecordsand/orEvidence.com .Includl g,butnotlim ited toany ofscersfailuretoactivatehksorhersBW C,failureofanyBW C atthe beginningordurihgtheirshifqanywritten authorization toedit,alter,erase, duplicate,copy and/orshareany BW C .videoand/oraudio fkom the follow ingoffcersXIaXnGI:-ISERGEANTH.S.M CHARDSON,OFFICERN.M . SLOVER,OFFICER M .C.PA CE,OFFICER RC.LAN DRUM ,OFFICER D .C . LANCASTER,OFFICER W .C.SHIW LY,OFFICER W .R M ERRILL,OFFICER J.D .D IXON ,LIEU TEN ANT J.W .SM ITH,OFFICER L.D .LAND ,and/or CAPTM N D.HAI,EYIinrelae gtoanyandallincidentsatthelocaéon505 Jefferson SkeetDanville,Virginia24541onandafterSeptember25th ?2013 involvingAlvinL.SutherlinJr.,M ichelleOwensmatldBritm eyC.Logano'' Thedefendantshavechosentothedefythecourtsorderin fully disclosz gbody wom cameraWdeos(BWC)'s(See:Elderv.Cityof, Danville,Vaeta1,No.4:2013cv00047X .D.Va.2014)andnotprovideallofthe tm editedvideosâom a11ofthedefendants,presentat505Jeferson street, D anvilleVirginiaforthe Septem ber25th 2013 asOrderflled on 04/01/2016 (DktNo.68).TheOrderreadsasfollows: Case 4:15-cv-00037-JLK-RSB Document 80 Filed 04/22/16 Page 2 of 5 Pageid#: 1250
  • 3. ''PlaintiffssubpoenatotheDanvillePoliceDepartmentseeltsGlalnyandall bodywarm Isiclcamera(BW C)documentationflledwithintheDanville PoliceDepartm ent'srecordsand/orEvidence-com .lncluding,butnotIim ited toanyoflkersIsiclfailuretoactivateMsorhersIsiclBW C,failureofany BW C ...any written authorization to edit,alter,erase,duplicatw copy and/or shareany BW C videoand/oraudio-''Dkt.No.30.Thesubpoenarequests inform ation aboutfootageobtal ed from an om cerw hoisnotnam ed in Plaintiffscom plaintaswellasinform atioh aboutfoofagefkom Septem ber25, 2013 and thereafter.TheFederalRulesofCivilProcedurerequirethat inform ation requa ted in discovery berelevantto aclàim ordefenseand proportionaltotheneedsofthecase.Fed.R.Civ.P.26(b)(1).PlaltiFs requestforinform ation aboutthefootageobtained by any oœ cernotG volved in thesearch ofPlaintiffsresidenceorforany petiod oftim ebeyond the execution oftheselrch warranton Septem ber25.2013 isneitherrelevantnor proportionaltohisclaim s.A ccordingly,thesubpoena shallbelim ited in scope tothefootagefrom cam erasw orn byoflk erswhowerepresentduringthe execution ofthew arrantdescribed in Plaintiffscom plaint.Thescopeofthe subpoena shallalso beIim itedto thedateand tim eperiod oftheevents da cribed in thecom plal tand to theoflk erswho arenam ed asdefendantsin thiscase.D efendants'm otion to quash isthereforeGR ANTED in part. D efendantsaredirected to providePlal tiffw ith theinform ation requested in thesubpoena(asIimitedbythisorder)withintwentpone(21)daysofthedate ofthksorden '' Thedefendantshavenotproduced any ofthesupportingdocum entaéon gnd recordsasstated within thesubpoenaincluding 9om Evidence.com andthe plaintiffhasonlyreceivedsomeeditedbodyworncamera(BWC)thathaveclearly beenedited.Thesevideoshavealréadybeensubmittedinasexhibitsbfevidence tothecourt.Theplaintiffalsostillhasnoibeengivenanybodyworncamera (BW C)videos9om OFFICER D.C.LM CASTER,OFFICER L.D.LA'o and/or LIEUTENAN T J.W .SM ITH to date. A1lofthedefendantsinthiscasewerepresentat505Jefferson streetDanville V irginia245410n Septem ber26th.2013and a11w ereissuedworkingbodyw orn $GWXCase 4:15-cv-00037-JLK-RSB Document 80 Filed 04/22/16 Page 3 of 5 Pageid#: 1251
  • 4. cameras(BWC)onthatdayatthebeginningoftheirslo followingtheDanville PoliceDepartment's(BWC)'spolicy.Noswornnmdavitsoroflcialdoctlments havebeenprovidedtoshow thisisnotfacm alinform ation. -' N : 3.- h$ AlvinL.Suthe ',Jr.(ProSe) 1StFloor505Jefferson Stre , , DanvillevVirginla24 41-2037 434-728-2673(Ce11pho e) Sutherlinjr@m ail.com . o ' lhereby certlfythatthefore o'gnoticro awsuitwassentbyregttlarm ail, postalpaidorhanddeliveredathis nd ayofAprilm2016toClerkofCourtof ThèUi ted StatesDisz ctCourtFo estern DistrictbfVirginiaDanville D ivision and .1alsohereby ce ' thatl vem ailedorh> d deliveredacopyof theforegoingto theofficeo anielaM edle KirbypP.C,110N orth Union SkeetP.0.Box720,D lle,VA 24543-072 /'- Nw F..r-s-Case 4:15-cv-00037-JLK-RSB Document 80 Filed 04/22/16 Page 4 of 5 Pageid#: 1252
  • 5. cameras(BWC)onthatdayatthebeginningoftheirshiâfollowingtheDanville PoliceDepartment's(BWC)'spolicy.NoswornaG davitsoroffcialdocllments havebeen providedto show thisisnotfactualinform ation. c'' untycf .57 -, mmonwaay/sy mt antj . j,,s me*: d v 0 . myandandoaax).. ' AlvinL SutherlinJr( se) .-? ' e-ablk* > * j f ufap xp;; 505JeffersonStreet,1StFloor tprintyourexpiravondqa- ) Danville,V irginia24541-2037 434-728-2673(Ce11phone) Sutherlinjr@m ail.com -, , ' tk'., ReneeLawso'n Berger, .;: .1x jj' . $,# NotaryPublic 'u 6' /').CommonweaIthofVirginia.x. ;..;! ,v .4v,ti.is-%7-q;, Reg.8/7255233 w'ên.,,,.--. ut'oommipxx sxps,gunoao,20:z Ihereby certifythattheforegoingnoéceoflaw suitw assentby regularm ail, postalpaidorhaqddelivered,this22nd,dayofApri,12016toClerkofCourtof TheUnitedStatesDistrictCourtForW estem DisG ctofVirginiyDanville Division and .1alsohereby certifythatlhavem ailed orhanddellvered acopyof theforegoingtotheofficeMfDanielmM edley& Kirby .Q 110NorthUnion SkeetP.0 .Box 720,Dœm lle,VA 24543-0720 ForE Case 4:15-cv-00037-JLK-RSB Document 80 Filed 04/22/16 Page 5 of 5 Pageid#: 1253