Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Admire Mare: Mediating climate change in selected southern african newspapers


Published on

  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Admire Mare: Mediating climate change in selected southern african newspapers

  1. 1. By Admire Mare Rhodes University
  2. 2. Definition of Terms <ul><li>Mediation is a multi-faceted and layered concept which refers to ‘a process that connects and translates disparate worlds, people’s imaginations, values, and ideas whether in its symbolic, social or technological form’ (Meintjes, 2003: 8). It emphasizes the discursive dimensions of mediation , which includes the use of songs, poetry texts, biographical interviews, testimonies, group discussions and electronic interactions. ( oramedia, traditional media and new media technologies </li></ul><ul><li>In terms of mass media in Africa, this entails bridging the public sphere and the policy sphere through the creation of a public sphere or public space. Thus the press can be conceptualised as ‘midwives’, ‘intermediaries or bridges’, public fora, dialogical space (Paulo Freire), translators (messengers), environmental scanners, information disseminators, message multipliers (modernisation discourse), mobilisers and spaces for intercultural learning </li></ul>
  3. 3. Climate change is about human behaviour? <ul><li>Climate change is essentially caused by human practices and lifestyles (at the individual, corporate and national level) in their quest to accumulate wealth , develop infrastructure and conquer nature so as to alleviate social ills. </li></ul><ul><li>Linked with the Industrial revolution , Colonialism ...and subsequent development models such as modernisation , neo-liberal economics and globalisation. ...development seen as catching up, technology transfer, industrialisation and urbanisation </li></ul><ul><li>Hence the solutions to climate change lie in behavioural change at the personal, local, national, regional and international level ...adaptation and mitigation </li></ul>
  4. 4. Media and climate change: Towards behavioural change? <ul><li>Changing attitudes towards climate change is not like selling a particular brand of soap – it’s like convincing someone to use soap in the first place . </li></ul><ul><li>The media is considered an indispensable cog in behavioural change interventions hence the importance of this study.... convincing someone to use soap in the place requires more than just a policy pronouncement. However questions arise: </li></ul><ul><li>What role do the media play in influencing personal, local and national action to address climate change? </li></ul><ul><li>How does the media cover climate change, and are there any discernible changes in climate news coverage? </li></ul><ul><li>How do climate change stories come to be reported, and who gets cited as legitimate sources in those stories? </li></ul><ul><li>What influence do the media play in forming public opinion? </li></ul>
  5. 5. Role of Media in climate change Discourse <ul><li>Not clear when climate change became a newsworthy issue but scholars traces it as far back as the 1930s </li></ul><ul><li>It was until the mid-1980s when the three media-science-policy spheres collided (Boykoff and Roberts, 2007). </li></ul><ul><li>Mass media coverage has proven to be a key contributor– that have shaped and affected science and policy discourse as well as public understanding and action. </li></ul><ul><li>Few things are as much a part of our lives as the news…it has become a sort of instant historical record of the pace, progress, problems, and hopes of society” (Bennet, 2002: 10) </li></ul><ul><li>Hence the normative role of the media in society has been framed within the Habermasian public sphere theory. The media (press) is seen a space for critical-rational debate , formation of public opinion based on consensus not dissensus —however this view has been critiqued for sidelining marginalised groups such as women, youth and the people with disabilities, there are multiple public spheres not one unitary sphere. </li></ul>
  6. 6. Continued... <ul><li>In the contexts of rural Africa, subaltern or alternative public spheres exist in the form of: ( markets, oramedia, churches, agricultural extension meetings, imbizos and of late social media, mobile phones amongst youth )—oral societies. </li></ul><ul><li>The press in Africa is not a free-for-all bonanza- - not everyone has access to speak or write their own narratives into being: (issues of accessibility , affordability, appropriateness , adaptability and acceptability are crucial) in this space journalists ( editors, sub-editors, proof readers ) have the privilege to speak, write and photograph events and newsworthy information on behalf of the public and their employers ( investors ). </li></ul><ul><li>Particular voices tend constantly appear as newsmakers , news sources and knowers of the environment—male centric voices, educated elite, middle class, powerful and rich </li></ul><ul><li>However, as a forum for the production, reproduction and transformation of the meaning of public issues, the media influence the understandings of risks , responsibilities, as well as the functioning of democratic politics (Carvalho, 2010). </li></ul>
  7. 7. Continued... <ul><li>However the media blackout on climate change is worrying given that despite Africa’s position as the least developed continent, estimates by climatologists point to the fact that it will be one of the hardest hit areas in the coming decades . </li></ul><ul><li>“… Environmental issues constitute a relatively marginal concern in most African newspapers , radio and television news, and current affairs programs. Much more attention is given to national politics , labour disputes, the arts, and business.” (Mutere, 1991 in Boafo, 1991) </li></ul><ul><li>Studies on how the press has covered a range of environmental issues have been negligible to say the least in Southern Africa </li></ul>
  8. 8. Climatic Changes in South Africa and Zimbabwe <ul><li>Zimbabwe has experienced a spate of climate-related natural disasters especially Cyclone Eline, Cyclone Japhet and flooding in Muzarabani and Lower Zambezi areas. Cyclone Eline which occurred in February 2000 caused severe flooding; the drought in 1991-1992 which is described as the worst in living memory, combined with Economic Structural Adjustment Programme (ESAP), Fast Track Land Reform and a tripod social, political and economic crisis which began in 2000 have increased the vulnerability of the poor especially in regions 4 and 5. </li></ul><ul><li>South Africa has not been spared --It has been grappling with perennial flooding especially in the Northern Cape , Western Cape , Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal since 2008. More than 4 000 dwellings and 18 000 people had been affected by flooding in the Western Cape, while the impacts in KwaZulu-Natal prompted the declaration of a state of disaster. Violent hailstorms, heavy snowfalls and gale-force winds are a regular occurrence in South Africa (South Africa, 2007:15). </li></ul>
  9. 9. Study Population: The Weekly Press in South Africa and Zimbabwe <ul><li>The weekly press offers a fruitful space to explore the coverage of climate change because of its in-depth coverage of issues, as there is greater space for investigative journalism, ‘ which is critical for comprehensive environmental news coverage , and more time during which the reporter can gather information for the story’. There is also a greater likelihood that journalists at a weekly can go out of their immediate surroundings to cover stories as they are not constrained by the 24-Hour cycle in operation at daily papers. </li></ul><ul><li>The Sunday Mail (39 per cent readership, ZAMPS, 2010) is a broadsheet owned by the Zimbabwe Newspapers Group in which the Government of Zimbabwe is a majority shareholder while The Mail and Guardian (circulation of between 30 000 and 40 000 per week) is a tabloid owned by Alpha Media, a private company run by Trevor Ncube. It targets middle class earners whereas the Sunday Mail flags itself as a family paper. </li></ul>
  10. 10. Methodology <ul><li>It comprises qualitative content analysis with critical textual analysis --combines the systematic analysis of large bodies of text as in quantitative content analysis, but with a more holistic approach to the text . It involves exploring the meanings that are embedded in the representations as opposed to looking at the frequency of particular themes as a reflection of particular phenomena. </li></ul><ul><li>In order to get articles for analysis, I decided to monitor the content on ‘climate change’ in South Africa and Zimbabwe by relying on and websites. I was interested in collecting only climate change news stories over the last 12 months (January to December 2010). </li></ul>
  11. 11. Findings: current trends <ul><li>Both Sunday Mail and M &G climate news stories are pitched within the global scientific hegemony which gives prominence to ‘ science experts ’ while sideling bearers of indigenous knowledge systems as ‘ non-experts’ . This constructs particular ‘subject positions’ for individuals and cultivate dispositions to action or inaction’ . </li></ul><ul><li>The coverage of climate change in Southern Africa is sporadic, event-based, official-centred and jargon-laden . This unintentionally creates “knowers” and tabula rasa (passive recipients) of development interventions. </li></ul><ul><li>There is tendency within the two papers to represent ‘climate change’ as a marauding juggernaut caused by invincible forces. For instance, ‘ You can't afford to be slow in an emergency. Act now for the planet,&quot; is the World Wildlife Fund's urgent call to reduce carbon emissions. The problem of flagging the alarmist card is that it has the unintended consequences of demobilising people through inculcating feelings of isolation, hopelessness, and powerlessness . </li></ul>
  12. 12. Continued... <ul><li>Media coverage of climate change (adaptation and mitigation) is not a simple collection of news articles and clips produced by journalists and producers; rather, representations signify key frames derived through complex and non-linear relationships between scientists, policy actors and the public, often mediated by news stories . </li></ul><ul><li>Mediation of the climate change story in Southern Africa is still lethargic and spasmic. Leonie Joubert is on record as describing environmental journalists in South Africa as ‘missing the story of the century’. </li></ul><ul><li>Environmental reporting constitutes one percent of the total reporting in South African media--only half of this percent is spent on climate change (Media Tenor South Africa Report, 2010). </li></ul><ul><li>Climate change stories are event-based, revolves around speeches by government officials, workshop notes, public lectures and international conferences. Most of stories analysed were written just before and after big international conferences such as COP 16. </li></ul>
  13. 13. Continued... <ul><li>The environment beat is still considered a ‘ lower order’ genre in African newsrooms. </li></ul><ul><li>Climate change stories rarely make it to the front page . This is because they don’t fall within the armpit of a journalistic dictum, ‘if it bleeds, it leads” headline format. In the case of The Sunday Mail , climate news becomes front page stories when they are accompanied by speeches from the Vice-President or President. </li></ul><ul><li>10 per cent of the stories focused on indigenous knowledge systems and their role in climate change adaptation. </li></ul><ul><li>The Mail and Guardian dealt with science, policy and climate change at an international level and gave little South African context. </li></ul><ul><li>On two occasions, the Mail and Guardian framed the climate change stories as a political issue pitting the developed countries against developing countries. There is somehow silence on ESKOM’s ambitious electricity generating coal project in Kolberg in Cape Town. </li></ul>
  14. 14. Continued.... <ul><li>Due to the urban bias of most newsrooms in South Africa, most stories of climate change in the Mail and Guardian were sourced from foreign news agencies such as Reuters and AFP with little or no effort to domesticate these stories to speak to their readers’ every-day lives. </li></ul><ul><li>There is clear absence of investigative journalism on climate change looking at the implications of energy, mining and industrial policies on climate change at the local level </li></ul><ul><li>In the case of the Sunday Mail, journalists visited communal areas three times, most of the articles were sourced from government officials </li></ul>
  15. 15. Legitimate sources: whose voice is it anyway? <ul><li>The press is a ‘space’ where certain voices are allowed to speak on behalf of others—through filters, gatekeepers and gatewatchers —’quality control’ is emphasized. </li></ul><ul><li>26 ( 87 per cent ) out 30 stories were sourced from climate scientists , while 4 (13 per cent) used ordinary people as sources-- ‘science journalists are overly-reliant on single scientific sources, going against the journalistic norm of testing the claims of news sources’ (Conrad, 1999). </li></ul><ul><li>Legitimate sources tend to be those in authority or experts invited to speak at these gatherings . The Sunday Mail relied on climate scientists or political figures such as President Robert Mugabe, Vice-President Joyce Mujuru, VP John Nkomo and Governor Angela Masuku. On the other hand, the Mail and Guardian made use of quotes from Dorah Lebelo (a gender and climate change expert), Joseph Stiglitz (an economist), Martyn Davies, and Louise Naude’ (climate change officer-WWW) etc. </li></ul>
  16. 16. Continued... <ul><li>Women only featured when the story had a gender slant to it, for instance in the following stories: Climate Change Reality Dawns on Rural Farmers’ and ‘ climate-change policy ignores women farmers’ . Paradoxically, research shows that women are likely to be affected by climate change as they rely on environment for survival compared to men. </li></ul><ul><li>Ethnic/Linguistic minorities, the poor and women continue to be excluded either at the level of news sources due to lack of the material and symbolic resources to participate fully in the climate change discourse </li></ul><ul><li>The framing of the news sometimes depicts the issue of climate change as a concern only for the elites and those in government </li></ul><ul><li>Faith in most stories was put in international treaties at the expense of localised adaptation strategies. </li></ul>
  17. 17. Speaking in Tongues? Jargon use <ul><li>Stories based on fieldwork had little jargon compared to stories sourced from ‘ climate scientists ’ in the two newspapers. </li></ul><ul><li>Jargon such as ‘carbon emissions’, ‘a low carbon economy’, green, green economics, green sectors, green technology, a just and sustainable policy, market-based climate change adaptation solutions, genetic modification, people-centred solutions, primitive hocus-pocus, human-caused climate change, carbon neutral, greenhouse gas reporting, green bank, emission reduction, emission control, underground coal gasification, hydrogen economy and spreading the green gospel’ were more prominent. </li></ul><ul><li>In the context of Africa, where climate change is expected to have ‘disastrous’, it is important to educate and inform rather than mystify and alienate . </li></ul>
  18. 18. Framing climate change as a crisis <ul><li>The framing of headlines is done in order to retain attention more than it is to inform, educate and mobilise--‘newspapers are commercial products and the stories they carry are intended to sell the paper’ </li></ul><ul><li>For instance, the following headlines: ‘ War against climate change rages in Zimbabwe’ . It is a typical attention-seeking and sensationalist headline which uses metaphors of war. It constructs Zimbabwe as a battleground where people are fighting tooth and nail against climate change. </li></ul><ul><li>Climate change is presented as ‘ devastating’, ‘adverse ’ and ‘ravaging ’, there is silence on opportunities immanent in climate change i.e. Rethinking our lifestyles, development models, energy use etc </li></ul>
  19. 19. So where does the problem lie? <ul><li>Dearth of science journalists in our newsrooms—environmental journalism curriculum doesn’t exist at universities and colleges. This creates over-dependence on ‘experts’ to frame the climate change discourse. </li></ul><ul><li>Hierarchy of importance ascribed to different issues by a news organization—factors which determines whether environmental issues make it onto the media agenda in the local press is a complex interplay between various factors. </li></ul><ul><li>Media content i.e. Climate change is affected by political and economic factors such proprietary demands, advertisers etc </li></ul><ul><li>News commodification and media concentration affect diversity and attempts to democratise the media space. </li></ul>
  20. 20. Continued... <ul><li>Urban biases of newsrooms in Southern Africa (Zimbabwe has no private community newspapers, only government mouthpieces which are under-funded and a state run news agency which is poorly resourced. On the other hand, South Africa have a three tier media system—community, commercial and public, however illiteracy and lack of media diversity (for instance, The Big Four Monopoly) </li></ul><ul><li>Tabloidization of news , H-Metro and B-Metro in Zimbabwe and Daily Sun and Sunday Sun —sensationalism, slander and soft news </li></ul><ul><li>Media pluralism is not the same as diversity (it is more broad and encompasses linguistic politics, ethnic balance etc) </li></ul><ul><li>Local languages remain sidelined by national papers thereby creating pockets of ‘information have-less’ </li></ul>
  21. 21. Where do we go from here? <ul><li>Reincarnation of oramedia is long over-due —for instance, “marketplaces in Africa in themselves are veritable communication forums... Market places are not just where people go to buy or sell but are diffusion forums for important social interaction . . . vogues are copied in marketplaces. They also constitute places of censure” (Ugboajah 1985: 169). </li></ul><ul><li>The fact that marketplaces are a forum for the convergence of women, from different classes is a compelling reason why such forum should be seriously considered for knowledge sharing, intercultural learning and translation of climate information . </li></ul><ul><li>The word of mouth (extension officers, traditional leaders), poetry, parables and riddles remain crucial in oral societies </li></ul>
  22. 22. Continued... <ul><li>Roping in citizen-centric media (social media, mobile phones) in the climate change agenda </li></ul><ul><li>Citizen centric media which is an important cog in the climate information cycle as information disseminators, mobilisers, translators, and environmental scanners, platforms for debate and fora for intercultural learning. </li></ul><ul><li>It has the potential to restore the ‘voice’ to those threatened by climatic changes especially youth and women, however, the issue of digital divide persists. </li></ul><ul><li>It allows media ‘consumers’ to become ‘produsers’, which challenges the authority of mainstream journalists as the exclusive centre of knowledge on the subject’, suggesting that ‘the audiences knows more collectively than the reporter alone’ (Glaser, 2006). Thus citizen journalism can become an antidote to the publisher-centric agenda setting of climate change debates. </li></ul>
  23. 23. Continued... <ul><li>Mainstreaming climate change is all journalistic beats , i.e. political, business, sports and entertainment. </li></ul><ul><li>Ensuring every journalist critically reflects on how climate change impacts on their field. For instance, economic journalists should be able to understand the carbon market while health journalists should be able to understand rising heat waves means for salmonella outbreaks in townships and rural areas and waterborne diseases associated with flooding, sports journalist must link use of flood lights to increased use of coal especially in the context of Zimbabwe and South Africa. It is important to make environmental stories relate to readers’ everyday lives. </li></ul>
  24. 24. Continued.... <ul><li>Bridging the gap between climate scientists and the journalistic fraternity —creation of an effective communication loop. </li></ul><ul><li>Writing of science journalism guide books with glossary of key terms, organising workshops for inter-disciplinary learning and packaging of user friendly information (local languages disseminated via trustworthy and relevant mediums i.e. Oramedia </li></ul>
  25. 25. Continued... <ul><li>Introduction of environmental journalism courses as part of the curricula in order to create a critical mass of well trained science journalists instrumental in mobilising and sensitizing their communities. </li></ul><ul><li>Time is ripe for journalism training schools in Africa to welcome a new baby in the family of journalism </li></ul><ul><li>Training of science journalists would allow for better understanding of the sustainable development challenges as well as enable journalists to better respond, from an informed position, to the challenges of development in such areas as environmental degradation, climate change mitigation, adaptation and disaster warming among others. </li></ul>
  26. 26. Conclusion... <ul><li>Climate change coverage is still an add-on issue to the journalistic menu </li></ul><ul><li>Framing and representation of climate news is not immune from the political, economic and ideological moorings at the newsroom level </li></ul><ul><li>Its time to broaden ‘beat’ centred journalism </li></ul><ul><li>Social media is a potential antidote to corporatised journalism </li></ul>
  27. 27. Thank you