The Trails of Two Cities
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×
 

Like this? Share it with your network

Share

The Trails of Two Cities

on

  • 728 views

Part of our Putting Community Knowledge in Place special session at the Knowledge Cities World Summit in Melbourne, November 2010.

Part of our Putting Community Knowledge in Place special session at the Knowledge Cities World Summit in Melbourne, November 2010.

Statistics

Views

Total Views
728
Views on SlideShare
727
Embed Views
1

Actions

Likes
0
Downloads
1
Comments
0

1 Embed 1

http://www.docseek.net 1

Accessibility

Categories

Upload Details

Uploaded via as Apple Keynote

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Processing…
Post Comment
Edit your comment
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n
  • \n\n

The Trails of Two Cities Presentation Transcript

  • 1. The Trails of Two Cities and what they suggest to re-inspire growth of Melbourne’s heavy rail network Tony Smith Complex Systems Analyst Meme Media ts@meme.com.au
  • 2. The Trails of Two Cities• Topographical differences and their impact• Historical divergence driven by trams• Changing expectations and lead times• Trying to complete this paper when new news seems to break every other day• Hope and the Transport Integration Act• What really might be possible by 2050?
  • 3. Topographical differences and their impact Northco n te kJ Showgrounds Somerton t ton on rke y oo ro Royal Flem br a tz St Royal Carl m ay ingto Fi re St Jn ew Sa Neeya Br nR th me h c N otch Rd l N M wmrds gt Nth Park or Sc Park Flem Fo in Br Ep es a ark ingto ill ow ng ns ot Fitzroy pi org Campbellfield Nth H sc Fo os g n Bri Ke ng Jn ns M de Po e ra on dge ot Ge t un r H w y Macaulay Rd sc dg ill ift r Sd (M ra St Jn Yd ne Cl y ai S St W n r Thomastown en lbou od Broadmeadows Li es o ingw ne t rd Hays Sdg A Me Coll Campbellfield ) Footscray (Suburban) th N Sydenham Glenroy Fawkner e urn East Brooklyn Yarraville o Melbourne Yard Melb Nth Coburg Preston (Reservoir) Rich Preston (Regent St) Pascoe Vale Bell Park Prin ers St Flin es Brid Flin m Preston (Murray Rd) ond ders Sp c Coburg d ott St Albans isw d Preston (Bell St) on St Y oo hm de Montague Ric Moreland Thornbury ge ing rk d St h Essendon ton a Port Melbourne Nth Croxton Al ld P Heidelberg ote Sth Melbourne Moonee Ponds Brunswick hc ie Middle ph Graham St S Brun irf rt Albion swick Northcote Rin Sth Yarra Sdg Ivanhoe No Ascot Vale Fa Fr ailway Map of Victoria, 1890 Albert Park gw ee Port Melbourne zi Newport oo ng k ar dB C g rP oy Sd Pra ric s ee hra Rin Station k Newport Jn D m ic k Pier Middle Park n Ba Glenfer ha Br Sd Workshops r K gw Cam H ker ew s n itc m ill Auburn r g itc tall ill bu M ha oo H aw s Su ry H s ck R ey berw u d Mn t Bu Pi hor d x Win rb Tu a Bo rr rie Bl Nth Williamstown dso te r rn cni n an ley c ell C St Kilda Kew Jn 1 0 1 2 3 Heyington River sdale Kooyong Scale of Miles Hawksburn Tooronga 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 Toorak Gardiner Hartwell Armadale La Altona Bay ve Swan Hill Scale of Kilometres Glen Iris William Ashburton rt Inner & Western Melbourne Rly on Malvern Balaclava Darling ach W ay n ton h Caulfie Be stown ill tow Al Beac Scale: 1 to 150,000 ld aB ia m Waverley Road ms Elsternwick st Lake Boga a ow ton a Rc illi n Deniliquin Ro Al Pi W G Oakleigh er Muownly le sst unt n Nth No H Mystic Park rru k Brighton rt oo Mc h Rd mb dr ay on Melbourne Area Lake Charm Koondrook Ki e Middle Ko amw Eas nnon en Brighton Tr a tB ma Rly Claytons Rd G Reedy Lake rig an Brighton Beach hto H n na Kerang Scale: 1 to 350,000 in Ye w ks ar 1 0 1 2 3 5 South Brighton ob 4 n - Moa on Hampton ra ur South Kerang s Mathoura n Scale of Miles Spring Vale Tragowel 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Sandringham Highett ui Deniliq Strathmerton Scale of Kilometres Macorna Moira Cheltenham C lia Ya ob ha rr ra ia Yarrawonga ow at Wahgunyah m Mincha Katunga aa of N ey W pro Mentone M che ah Rutherglen Dandenong Wy Echu oa view Pyramid Hill ca m Fair Whar Numurkah Katamatite a nloth Boort f Telford Albury Gle Echuca Lilliput Echuca Rc Wunghnu Katamatite Ba Tramway Mologa Youanmite Tungamah Mordialloc a rn od ng Teddywaddy Springs aw ga illa th ne a Ch W do Be Bo ong Mitiamo Yabba Nth Hydes Brick Sdg Rd an g Mysia Be o a Tallygaroopna i W lte th ech Warracknabeal ie a a wo r ug nn n St James rth s Yabba Sth W Me an ne oy la st gi Kellalac Borung at ang Prairie Congupna Rd Jn rig Ta ur on yc ule Ea ga La ba e an lla K nd ra ke Co ara ee p rlt n ny rr te Lo n ia ys ng ck rra To Sheep Hills Mo t uo ha Devenish Sd ta wi hi eo n D am ur Korong Vale Rochester oro Le eto Ba Donald a rra ton C H opn g m Dingee D iv br Nooramunga r Ta W a ic lli oo an C er ya Laens Sdg rv Be Li ll os Sh Ev ki Bu Pi K ry um K hi echSe Nullan Wedderburn ep Goorambat Lyndhurst gr e bu ata Wedderburn Jn ne Miram Piram ng Tandarra wo rig N pa o lis Ki ru Le Lo ve lle rto es rth er Sa Ge Minyip Cope Cope dg i n Cr M sv g Elmore ra ng Swanwater oss e tin d C in ld Dimboola Toolamba tu oo ra ing or er w ur ie Gl Ta Ge Kearneys Sdg w at om Sutherland ld kf K W Ju en le t w Raywood Sth Elmore Ba oo e n in by Wail g rs ge by ng row In Br to Fo on id ud Be l Arcadia n Carrum na rna Ju st Br s na ee St A Sebastian an le er an by Pimpinio ng lla oo G Murtoa Ba Do lm rd at m er ey Fl ap Bullabul G Bu dd fo w Pa We oornon Murchison D Sydn oe ar ag tle Bo llsfo Vi rk n C rd g ol es in yr B Hun agshot Ru ck ld Arnolds Bridge et ni M N efie Dargalong H u rdt e pa son To ill at ey g Em Hop tly Ba Ja ha Wahring sl Sd im w ny Sd a Lla Leic lm K gha le ib Horsham n w s uk g In eda up at al no m Lubeck ne tu Be lly g La Tarn x Eu V m on Nagambie A ec Cr ro Pa urie agul ar tis Horsham Tramway Sdg a al eig te M la Lo Ax ins rin Ea co Walwal Ballast Pits Ax gh ht H e Walwal wi Tabilk Bu n rou ot er gw th st on eC sbo ck ed r ut hc D ea Gold olly M nt oo Dun So eat Noradjuha k a on Ck d le Ravenswood Av h H Bet Bet ea Rc Glenorchy Mangalore e ne A un M aid ng l de g Ballast Pit ar e L Havelock B ourtk Sdg l c yb e Frankston H ra Simsons Maldon Harc rs C e Sdg om or ad oo e Bark aine Seymour se Lan dg Epsom Bo ou ob Mucklefo ne eb Deep Lead lhou l lem sto Schoo woo ek S gh To rd us A Grampians Stawell Maldon Cast hin vo h ra re ale Jn Elp Epsom Rc k ca Tallarook T C ale lls sd o rt k Fa erri bro rad aw d olo Daisy Hill Lowry Sdg eek ry Langwarrin oo Ta ek Ch pbe sbu K eh Ca ris ew ly Mo re e N es Cr gl ad lm ew lls y ul m Ca C Ma om dg sa a Talbot G ste ds E s S ld Great Western ton Ck Ca Gu Nth Geelong ys an H ia Broadford a ew ton fie c Ca olesw m Co tt Ye rn Fy le Joy M alha ne ild th s Sd ifo Armstrongs Ga thk o n Ky ra g B es ou for e al eld St ruh Lancefi es un n C in rth gr Da Ch Geelong rls fJ Mornington Jn d Sandhurst llo bi Fe Tyld ow Day ylesf ek M Ca Cl lif Kilmore Kilmore East M Do ev Ararat ure Golden Square r re Sh sc us lesf ord rn en oo go Mathiesons Sdg iot en ord eC Hi kC ng ro an Romse To Woodb Jn ue ll y od Wandong ap rt dl lo urn ds 2 3 Bu 1 0 1 a Sth Geelong k Q Nth n fo all ee id u l nd Byla Kangaroo oo Kilmore Jn c Monegeeta G au M de aw M oo Monegeeta Merri Merri Sdg Flat ie Scale of Miles Be Mornington Tr sl W Bu Tr Bolinda Ly o Le on Wallan 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 ced en Somerville lla on Ma Lancefield Jn Beveridge Breakwater tha rne Br M rt vil Ck Geelong Rc Scale of Kilometres ar ad sbo m le lls ods oo Gi sh Whittlessea de Wildwo ok Geelong Sandhurst na a Rid w wood ybro s n Ruperts bury Donn lla Yan Yean rr len C e a ill W k Ba ar M Bac Sun Craigieburn Sth Yan Yean Ta a G sv Pa arsh us ic aw kc Casterton le ar ch Scale: 1 to 500,00 Scale: 1 to 500,000 rr M acch Coleraine Diggers ea lif an sh us Ya C Rest Ye str lyd ark H fe Rc ol Li olb on rw B Rd rin ea ale d n rd ay to M C G g m fo ilg is D le oo ro ey nd n gl M nno owsl un H n ro yd In Wa chara ty ou Sa Th R ke n Me g en lto Bo ta om ld Sd k H o ju Coleraine Jn Hamilton Elaine n Br in ps p s ba Li Bu er on o iag Ba nd n M ck H ow t sh irn gh en olo ill Ro Meredith yP sd si au r ate Bo de ng le al St sw lly is ark da e Branxholme al Bay u ly da ss nd e le n dg e G ul W d W ra re bri ur re s R W err H so rf tre ee G Fern G Ti ld ar D th M er ib ha ey n Ma ba na Le nk aw mb ribeeee rn r N lam ora p Lethbridge Quarries Sdg W ol d fie C Fe nt Mo ngha m i d n r el Lit Mun ow Condah Gh h R bo ou L Fer G ong Goo rin Rc e O aco ick ba al ce sfi tle ro al Jin ar w H Duddens Lane m ffi n Riv sd ig Be erw Sd ha da ar U Stra er n r Le Myamyn irn Lara er Ty Na n ld g Stratftford r vi ke B Waubra Creswick Rc fie ck Kingston Ba a th Pa Bu ord Jn ar fr Graves Sdg ar ln Mon Addington on mon N af Mortlake Bu Bravington Toongabbie tgom Al M ln ery Br le Sailors Fall ld W Cranbourne oo nda Leo ar ear th n ale ll Aasia Coys Sdg r o ils n mf l nard lga go op iel e Pe Mo ow Bunyi ysd Lillico M on Be i Sale n Le th L e Longw Glengarry s H W Sto oe Clyd M Le tta ri Dr cus Hove Nth ca rra od d afa m rd ea s Newlyn ill ll in ne ng t Heywood M Cre Drou or ve ac we ew c pe r ch Sd r N Ya f swic Fu Ma an G sclif Tr Bo din ra lR e Rc ort am el g ar Toora p O Cre W rit k or Koonendah lh a Blo ragu Te se Irr nd ce een d swic re Ba Ro Sc gurr ee C Da fiel arry M am ar rnco in arat a Fl O u ld k ew it ead ar C e C irs W ard se Lo om l Q Coalvill yn Hi lowh on ro ta Terang Rc rnu d bo yL t da Tr a n lls ba K th y Tyabb Narraca Mt B D low it n Birre ss ll Co rra ne Ball Mo Layard ck ro ar Wa am g n le Il oro Ya N om sC le Ro rn Sd to m Miners Rest w ug La al yn la ol Gherang Hastings y nd n Sulky C en a ar le g K ar go e ale Ha k W neit c g rp h Thorpd W att nin bo Rose la re z Pisgah Ballarat Area Wormbete Waubra Jn bor n Bittern en bro Ga Yin elwo rt ok rvo Pom Po d t Portland Pier Pa c for Wensleydale Crib Point na od ney be t Ba (W rsd nm r um ee Rc et Cu Bunin t East Jn Cattle Sdg Sto ck lla en ale ure rr b dg Jn llo Bu rum int Sc e Scale: 1 to 750,000 ra d J Balla rthur St ee ermer D Port Fairy Al Ya Bo ur oo a t G ou n 5 ar Mi Wind yong 0 Po ier lan 5 10 15 20 r N Bu on ol la lim rb lP ar ree sfo th rr ar Dowling Forest ny oo de ) rd Pi Scale of Miles ce ra mb ra Sto ns la rna MA 10 5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 Cardigan al ar p W ei n W w nh Scale of Kilometres k to Trunk Lead re oo ns ar Bu Scale: 1 to 2,000,000 br un Eu Cana W t ill ra ng D M rek di lla s Not ar Yd Haddon Ba ee a VR Private Open ttle Jn Mt Clear s Navigators on Broad Gauge (53") Ca Nintingbool an d or rat G Standard Gauge (48.5") Yendon lla Ba Narrow Gauge (26") Smythesdale Buninyong Lal Lal Rc Other 5 0 5 10 15 Scarsdale Scale of Kilometres Lal Lal Lignite Sdg 5 0 5 10
  • 4. Topographical differences and their impact Northco Showgrounds te Somerton t ton on rke y ro Royal Flem a tz St Royal Carl m ingto Fi re St Jn ew Sa Neeya nR th me h c N otch Rd l N M wmrds gt Nth Park or Sc Park FlemFo in Br Ep es an ark ingto ill ow ns ot Fitzroy pi org Campbellfield Nth g H sc Fo n Bri Ke ng Jn ns M de e ra on dge ot Ge t un r H w y Macaulay Rd sc dg ill ift ro Sd (M ra St Jn Yd e Cl s g y ai S St urn W n d Broadmeadows Thomastown Li n o es de elb o gwo ne t r in Campbellfield Coll ) A M Footscray (Suburban) th N Sydenham Glenroy Fawkner e ourn East Yarraville Melbourne Yard Melb Nth Coburg Preston (Reservoir) Rich Preston (Regent St) Pascoe Vale Bell Park Prin ers St Flin es Brid Flin mon Preston (Murray Rd) ders Sp c Coburg d ott St Albans d isw d Preston (Bell St) on St Y oo hm de Montague Ric Moreland Thornbury ge ing rk d th Essendon ton a eS Port Melbourne Nth Croxton Al ld P Sth Melbourne Heidelberg cot Moonee Ponds Brunswick ie Middle ph Graham St rth S Brun irf Albion swick Northcote Rin Sth Yarra Sdg Ivanhoe No Ascot Vale Fa Victoria, 1890 Albert Park gw Port Melbourne Newport o od k arC g rP oy Br Sd Pra sJ ee ick h Rin Station m ick Newport ran n D Pier Middle Park Ba Glenfer ha Br Sd Workshops r K gw Cam H ker ew s n itc m ill Auburn ur g itc tall ill M ha oo H aw s Su ry kb H s R ey berw u d Mn t ac Bu Pi hor d x Win rb Tu Bo rr rie Bl Nth Williamstown d te sor rn cni n an ley c el C St Kilda K l ew Jn 1 0 1 2 3 Heyington River sdale Kooyong Scale of Miles Hawksburn Tooronga 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 Toorak Gardiner Hartwell Armadale La Altona Bay ve Scale of Kilometres Glen Iris William Ashburton r to Inner & Western Melbourne Rly Malvern n Balaclava Darling ach W ay wn ton h Caulfie Be stown ill Al Beac Scale: 1 to 150,000 ld aB ia sto m Elsternwick Waverley Road st am a ow ton Rc illi n Deniliquin Ro Al Pi W G Oakleigh er Muownly le sst unt n Nth No H rru Brighton rt Mc h Rd mb Melbourne Area Ki e Middle Eas nnon en Brighton a tB y rig Claytons Rd oama Rl Brighton Beach hto Scale: 1 to 350,000 n 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 Hampton South Brighton uin - M Mathoura Scale of Miles Spring Vale 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Sandringham Highett Deniliq Strathmerton Scale of Kilometres Moira Cheltenham C lia Ya ob ha rr ra ia Yarrawonga o at Wahgunyah m Katunga aa w N ey W Mentone M ah Echu Rutherglen Dandenong oa ca W m harf Numurkah Katamatite a Telford Albury Echuca Lilliput Echuca Rc Wunghnu Katamatite Ba Tramway Youanmite Tungamah Mordialloc a rn od ng Springs aw ga illa th one ga Ch W do Yabba Nth Hydes Brick Sdg B on Rd an g Be o ath Tallygaroopna ilt W ech er a a wo ug n St James rth s Yabba Sth Me W an ne oy a st Congupna Rd an rig al at Jn Ea La K Be Co gara ng nd ee Lo n ys ing To Mo t uo Devenish Sd ta am Rochester oro w rra n H opn g D br a Nooramunga Ta erto B oo ove C ya os Sh Ev ki Pi um eec K ep Goorambat Lyndhurst g e ne hw r rig pa Le ort Lo e rto es er ill h dg n Cr M sv Elmore ra oss e in ld Toolamba tu ing w ie Gl Ta Kearneys Sdg ld kf W en et Elmore Ba oo in rs row Br to Fo on Arcadia Be n Carrum st s na an er an Ba lla lm rd m G Bu dd fo w Pa We oornon Murchison ag tle Bo llsfo Vi rk rd g ol es in yr gsh et ni M ot Dargalong To H e ill ey g Wahring Ba sl Sd lm w Sd gh ale n w s at g d am tu xe Nagambie E m A
  • 5. Showgrounds Topographical differences and their impact Northc ote Somerton t lton on rke y ro Roya a itz St Roya min m Car gton F ere St Jn ew Sa Neeya th h R c m l Pa N otch Rd l N M wmrds lP gt Nth or Br in Flem Sc Ep es an ark rk Jn ark ingt ill ow ns Fitzroy pi org Campbellfield Nth g on B H Ke ng ns e ridg on Ge t H Macaulay Rd e ill ift St Jn Yd ne Cl S t r Thomastown od Broadmeadows en lbou gwo in rd lin e) A Me Col Campbellfield Footscray (Suburban) th N Sydenham Glenroy Fawkner rne bou Eas Melbourne Yard Mel Nth Coburg Preston (Reservoir) t Ri Preston (Regent St) Pascoe Vale chm Bell Park Prin ers St Flin es Brid Flin Preston (Murray Rd) ond der c Coburg d St Albans nd Preston (Bell St) s St ge mo ich Thornbury Yd Montague R Moreland ing rk St h Essendon ton a Port Melbourne Nth Croxton Al ld P Heidelberg ote Sth Melbourne Moonee Ponds Brunswick hc ie Middle ph Graham St S Brun irf rt Albion swick Northcote Rin Sth Yarra Sdg Ivanhoe No Ascot Vale Fa ictoria, 1890 Albert Park gw Port Melbourne oo k ar dB g rP Sd Pra ric h ee Rin Station m ick rt ran D k Pier Middle Park Ba Glenfe ha Br Sd hops r K gw Cam H ker ew n s itc m ill Auburn r g itc ll ill bu M ha oo M nsta H aw s Su ry H ck R ey berw u d t Bu Pi hor d x Win rrie rb Tu a Bo rr Bl h Williamstown d te sor rn cni n an ley c el l C St Kilda Kew Jn 1 0 1 2 3 Heyington Rive rsdal e Kooyong Scale of Miles Hawksburn Tooronga 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 Toorak Gardiner Hartwell Armadale La Altona Bay ve Scale of Kilometres Glen Iris William Ashburton rt Inner & Western Melbourne Rly on Malvern Balaclava Darling ach W ay wn ton h Caulfie Be stown ill Al Beac Scale: 1 to 150,000 ld aB ia sto m Elsternwick Waverley Road st am a ow ton Rc illi n Deniliquin Ro Al Pi W G Oakleigh er Mu n le sst unt n Nth No ow ly H rru Brighton rth mb Mc Rd Melbourne Area Ki ee n Middle Brighton Eas nnon a tB a Rly rig Claytons Rd Brighton Beach hto Scale: 1 to 350,000 n - Moam 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 Hampton South Brighton Mathoura Scale of Miles Spring Valeiliquin 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Sandringham Highett Strathmerton Scale of Kilometres Moira Cheltenham C lia Ya ob ha rr ra ia Yarrawonga ow at Wahgunyah m Katunga aa N ey W Mentone ah Rutherglen Dandenong Numurkah Katamatite Albury Telford Lilli