The Societal Implications of Nanotechnology The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun with invaluable assistance, support, and comments from Pamela Brochhausen, Wai Fong Chiang, Takao Inoue, Leslie Jarmon, Elizabeth Keating, Brian Lewis, Melissa Moon, Honoria Starbuck, and Chiho Sunakawa.

Table of Contents Defining ‘Nanotechnology’ What’s Out There? Nano Products Timeline of Nano Events Popular Culture Classroom Community Family The Economy Global Politics Cultural Meanings and Social Values Cultural Practice

Defining ‘Nanotechnology’

What’s Out There? Nano Products

Timeline of Nano Events

Popular Culture

Classroom

Community

Family

The Economy

Global Politics

Cultural Meanings and Social Values

Cultural Practice

Defining ‘Nanotechnology’ Return to Table of Contents The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

Nanotechnology The term itself is a combination of two meaningful parts (what linguists call 'morphemes') + NANO TECHNOLOGY

The term itself is a combination of two meaningful parts (what linguists call 'morphemes')

+

What Does ‘Nano' Mean? The 'nano' in 'nanotechnology' is often thought of as a shortened form of 'nanometer‘, which is one billionth (10 -9 ) of a meter. The diameter of one human hair is about 10,000 to 80,000 nanometers. A picture of nanofibrils shown with a human hair for reference (Espin Technologies, Inc.) IMAGE SOURCE: http://www.sigmaaldrich.com/Area_of_Interest/Chemistry/Materials_Science/Nanomaterials/Tutorial/Nanotechnology.html

The 'nano' in 'nanotechnology' is often thought of as a shortened form of 'nanometer‘, which is one billionth (10 -9 ) of a meter. The diameter of one human hair is about 10,000 to 80,000 nanometers.

Any Unit of Measure However, theoretically, it can be used to refer to one billionth of any measure of interest--for example, a nanosecond refers to one billionth of a second. nanometer nanosecond nanogram nanomole

However, theoretically, it can be used to refer to one billionth of any measure of interest--for example, a nanosecond refers to one billionth of a second.

nanometer

nanosecond

nanogram

nanomole

What Does ‘Technology' Mean? TECHNOLOGY : (from the American Heritage Dictionary, 4th Edition , 2000) 1 a. The application of science, especially to industrial or commercial objectives. b. The scientific method and material used to achieve a commercial or industrial objective. 2. Electronic or digital products and systems considered as a group: a store specializing in office technology. 3. Anthropology . The body of knowledge available to a society that is of use in fashioning implements, practicing manual arts and skills, and extracting or collecting materials. How does it differ from 'science'? While the notion of 'science' has often been contrasted with that of 'technology'--the first referring to the building of theory and the second referring to the application of this theory--such a distinction may be blurred in the case of nanoscience and nanotechnology.

TECHNOLOGY : (from the American Heritage Dictionary, 4th Edition , 2000)

1 a. The application of science, especially to industrial or commercial objectives.

b. The scientific method and material used to achieve a commercial or industrial objective.

2. Electronic or digital products and systems considered as a group: a store specializing in office technology.

3. Anthropology . The body of knowledge available to a society that is of use in fashioning implements, practicing manual arts and skills, and extracting or collecting materials.

How does it differ from 'science'?

While the notion of 'science' has often been contrasted with that of 'technology'--the first referring to the building of theory and the second referring to the application of this theory--such a distinction may be blurred in the case of nanoscience and nanotechnology.

A Broad Definition: A Popular Perspective Many people understand nanotechnology to be any kind of technology that deals with particles measured in nanometers. This broad definition would include, among other things, thin films, fine particles, chemical synthesis, and advanced microlithography. Scientists, however, tend to find this definition too broad and prefer to call this technology 'nano-scale technology' in contradistinction to '(molecular) nanotechnology'. On the other hand, those in the marketing sector may refer to technology fitting under this broad definition as 'nanotechnology' given its marketing appeal. things measured in nanometers technology ‘ nanotechnology’ (nanoscale technology) all things nano

Many people understand nanotechnology to be any kind of technology that deals with particles measured in nanometers. This broad definition would include, among other things, thin films, fine particles, chemical synthesis, and advanced microlithography. Scientists, however, tend to find this definition too broad and prefer to call this technology 'nano-scale technology' in contradistinction to '(molecular) nanotechnology'. On the other hand, those in the marketing sector may refer to technology fitting under this broad definition as 'nanotechnology' given its marketing appeal.

A Narrow Definition: A Scientific Perspective Scientists and engineers who are centrally involved in developing this technology sometimes prefer a narrow definition, which they also refer to as ‘molecular nanotechnology’ (MNT). This technology specifically involves manipulating individual atoms and molecules to build structures with complex atomic specifications . Nanotechnology of this sort is still at its infant stages, but products that have been developed include materials that ‘self-heal’ or are relatively lightweight and strong, nano-devices that deliver drugs to the human body, and nano-materials that fuse with human tissue or bone. things measured in nanometers technology ‘ (molecular) nanotechnology’ all things nano

Scientists and engineers who are centrally involved in developing this technology sometimes prefer a narrow definition, which they also refer to as ‘molecular nanotechnology’ (MNT). This technology specifically involves manipulating individual atoms and molecules to build structures with complex atomic specifications . Nanotechnology of this sort is still at its infant stages, but products that have been developed include materials that ‘self-heal’ or are relatively lightweight and strong, nano-devices that deliver drugs to the human body, and nano-materials that fuse with human tissue or bone.

Meaning as Connotation: A Cultural Perspective Beyond its formal definition—its denotation—it is important to also consider the social meanings of the term—its connotations. Connotations, of course, are culture-specific, and here we discuss only a limited set of social meanings. Perhaps one of the most salient connotations relates to the concept of ‘time.’ As a relatively new technology, most people understand that, until recently, nanotechnology did not exist. technology Things measured in nano units “ONCE UPON A TIME”

Beyond its formal definition—its denotation—it is important to also consider the social meanings of the term—its connotations. Connotations, of course, are culture-specific, and here we discuss only a limited set of social meanings. Perhaps one of the most salient connotations relates to the concept of ‘time.’ As a relatively new technology, most people understand that, until recently, nanotechnology did not exist.

But in the present time, nanotechnological research is a quickly growing area. technology Things measured in nano units “NOW” Meaning as Connotation: A Cultural Perspective

But in the present time, nanotechnological research is a quickly growing area.

Many believe that the technology will continue to develop, yet both the specific prospects and dangers of nanotechnology remain a mystery. While some have great hopes for what this technology can achieve for our society and the world, others remain either skeptical or fearful of what it can do. technology Things measured in nano units “FUTURE” ??? Safety Clean water, air World peace Longer and healthier lives End of disease, poverty Modernity ??? Fear Immorality Corporate control Loss of spirituality Loss of privacy Dystopia Meaning as Connotation: A Cultural Perspective

Many believe that the technology will continue to develop, yet both the specific prospects and dangers of nanotechnology remain a mystery. While some have great hopes for what this technology can achieve for our society and the world, others remain either skeptical or fearful of what it can do.

What’s Out There? Nano Products Return to Table of Contents The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

Computing and Data Storage Processors with declining energy use and cost thus increasing efficiency of computers by one million. Small mass storage devices Integrated nanosensors: Collecting, processing and communicating massive amounts of data with minimal size, weight, and power consumption Higher transmission frequencies and more efficient utilization of optical spectrum to provide at least 10 times the bandwidth Quantum computing Display technologies: Flat-panel displays for TV and video screens that may one day be thinner than a sheet of paper ADAPTED FROM: “Nanotechnology,” M. Meyyappan, Director, Center for Nanotechnology, NASA Ames Research Center

Processors with declining energy use and cost thus increasing efficiency of computers by one million.

Small mass storage devices

Integrated nanosensors: Collecting, processing and communicating massive amounts of data with minimal size, weight, and power consumption

Higher transmission frequencies and more efficient utilization of optical spectrum to provide at least 10 times the bandwidth

Quantum computing

Display technologies: Flat-panel displays for TV and video screens that may one day be thinner than a sheet of paper

Electronics Products Samsung 8 GB compact flash card “ This flash memory unit boasts a fat 8 gigabytes of memory, room for loads of songs, photos and PowerPoint presentations.” Business Week OLED digital camera “ Organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) are much brighter than the liquid crystals (LCDs) used in many of today's flat-screen TVs and computer monitors. They boast a wider viewing angle than LCDs, which must be viewed head-on. OLEDs don't require backlighting as LCDs do, reducing power consumption.” Forbes 2003

Samsung 8 GB compact flash card

“ This flash memory unit boasts a fat 8 gigabytes of memory, room for loads of songs, photos and PowerPoint presentations.” Business Week

OLED digital camera

“ Organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) are much brighter than the liquid crystals (LCDs) used in many of today's flat-screen TVs and computer monitors. They boast a wider viewing angle than LCDs, which must be viewed head-on. OLEDs don't require backlighting as LCDs do, reducing power consumption.” Forbes 2003

Electronics Products “ There are also a tremendous amount of . . . electronic applications out there that are effecting our every day lives. Just take a trip to your local electronics mega-store and you will see a multitude of these including: faster and more powerful computers, palm pilots (blackberries), flash drives, digital cameras and displays, cell phones, LCDs, LEDs, MP3’s, electronic ink displays, thin film batteries, and flexible electronics to name a few. All of these applications are possible and affordable due to the ability to work effectively and efficiently at the nano-scale.” National Nanotechnology Infrastructure Network

“ There are also a tremendous amount of . . . electronic applications out there that are effecting our every day lives. Just take a trip to your local electronics mega-store and you will see a multitude of these including: faster and more powerful computers, palm pilots (blackberries), flash drives, digital cameras and displays, cell phones, LCDs, LEDs, MP3’s, electronic ink displays, thin film batteries, and flexible electronics to name a few. All of these applications are possible and affordable due to the ability to work effectively and efficiently at the nano-scale.” National Nanotechnology Infrastructure Network

Materials and Manufacturing Manufacturing metals, ceramics, polymers at exact shapes without machining Lighter, stronger and programmable materials Lower failure rates and reduced life-cycle costs Bio-inspired materials Multifunctional, adaptive materials Self-healing materials Self-cleaning surfaces (e.g., windows) (‘smart surface’ of nanometer-high ‘mushrooms’ that absorb or repel water at the flick of a switch) FUTURE: “Smart” materials that can change color or shape and, perhaps, even assemble themselves ADAPTED FROM: “Nanotechnology,” M. Meyyappan, Director, Center for Nanotechnology, NASA Ames Research Center

Manufacturing metals, ceramics, polymers at exact shapes without machining

Lighter, stronger and programmable materials

Lower failure rates and reduced life-cycle costs

Bio-inspired materials

Multifunctional, adaptive materials

Self-healing materials

Self-cleaning surfaces (e.g., windows) (‘smart surface’ of nanometer-high ‘mushrooms’ that absorb or repel water at the flick of a switch)

FUTURE: “Smart” materials that can change color or shape and, perhaps, even assemble themselves

Materials Manufacturing Products Hummer H2 sport utility truck “ Made with about seven pounds of nanocomposite material, the cargo bed Hummer's H2 SUT is lighter and more scratch proof than older plastics. Besides the weight advantage, GM says the nanocomposite parts don't change shape when exposed to temperature changes.” Business Week Self-cleaning concrete “ An exterior view shows U.S. architect Richard Meier's Jubilee Church, located in the Tor Tre Teste area of Rome, in this 2003 file photo. It is made of self-cleaning concrete that helps keep the surface shiny white.” The Associated Press, July 2005

Hummer H2 sport utility truck

“ Made with about seven pounds of nanocomposite material, the cargo bed Hummer's H2 SUT is lighter and more scratch proof than older plastics. Besides the weight advantage, GM says the nanocomposite parts don't change shape when exposed to temperature changes.” Business Week

Self-cleaning concrete

“ An exterior view shows U.S. architect Richard Meier's Jubilee Church, located in the Tor Tre Teste area of Rome, in this 2003 file photo. It is made of self-cleaning concrete that helps keep the surface shiny white.” The Associated Press, July 2005

Sports Products Tennis rackets “ The Nanotube Power and VS Nanotube Drive lightweight, oversized-head models are made out of high modulus graphite with carbon nanotubes. . . One hundred times stronger than steel, yet one-sixth the weight, carbon nanotubes increase the rigidity of the stabilizers on each side of the racket's sweet spot. . . VS Nanotube rackets are five times more rigid than current carbon rackets and pack significantly more power.” Business Week Tennis balls “ Wilson Double Core tennis balls, with. . . InMat's Air D-Fense nanocomposite product inside, remain playable for four weeks. . . . InMat makes it harder for the air to escape by coating the ball's inner core with 20 microns thick of layered sheets of clay polymer nanocomposites--each 1 nanometer thin.” Business Week NanoDynamics golf ball “ This ball is engineered with nanoparticles to spin less, which should mean less slices and hooks. The bad news? Lower spin could mean shorter drives.” Business Week Stronger golf clubs More accurate bowling balls

Tennis rackets

“ The Nanotube Power and VS Nanotube Drive lightweight, oversized-head models are made out of high modulus graphite with carbon nanotubes. . . One hundred times stronger than steel, yet one-sixth the weight, carbon nanotubes increase the rigidity of the stabilizers on each side of the racket's sweet spot. . . VS Nanotube rackets are five times more rigid than current carbon rackets and pack significantly more power.” Business Week

Tennis balls

“ Wilson Double Core tennis balls, with. . . InMat's Air D-Fense nanocomposite product inside, remain playable for four weeks. . . . InMat makes it harder for the air to escape by coating the ball's inner core with 20 microns thick of layered sheets of clay polymer nanocomposites--each 1 nanometer thin.” Business Week

NanoDynamics golf ball

“ This ball is engineered with nanoparticles to spin less, which should mean less slices and hooks. The bad news? Lower spin could mean shorter drives.” Business Week

Stronger golf clubs

More accurate bowling balls

Clothing Products “ In the clothing world, we have pants that repel water and won’t stain shirts and shoe inserts that keep you cool in the summer and warm in the winter, and nano socks that don’t “stink” due to the inclusion of nanotech materials (nanosized sliver particles).” National Nanotechnology Infrastructure Network Breathable waterproof ski jacket “ Nanotechnology makes the two-layer laminate windproof, waterproof, breathable and grime resistant--great for those bums who don't get around to washing their jackets until after the season. The result: a jacket with a long, functional life superior to coated jackets and competitive with Gore-Tex products.” Forbes 2003 Wrinkle-resistant, stain-repellent threads “ Nano-Tex researchers attached molecular structures to cotton fibers, forming a barrier that causes liquids and stains to bead up on the surface and prevent absorption. Treated fabrics are not only wrinkle-proof but repel stains from perennial offenders like soda, coffee, wine, mayonnaise and syrup.” Forbes 2003 Color-changing fabrics Thread developed for military but may soon be used by clothing companies.

“ In the clothing world, we have pants that repel water and won’t stain shirts and shoe inserts that keep you cool in the summer and warm in the winter, and nano socks that don’t “stink” due to the inclusion of nanotech materials (nanosized sliver particles).” National Nanotechnology Infrastructure Network

Breathable waterproof ski jacket

“ Nanotechnology makes the two-layer laminate windproof, waterproof, breathable and grime resistant--great for those bums who don't get around to washing their jackets until after the season. The result: a jacket with a long, functional life superior to coated jackets and competitive with Gore-Tex products.” Forbes 2003

Wrinkle-resistant, stain-repellent threads

“ Nano-Tex researchers attached molecular structures to cotton fibers, forming a barrier that causes liquids and stains to bead up on the surface and prevent absorption. Treated fabrics are not only wrinkle-proof but repel stains from perennial offenders like soda, coffee, wine, mayonnaise and syrup.” Forbes 2003

Color-changing fabrics

Thread developed for military but may soon be used by clothing companies.

Cosmetics Products Skin care “ L’Oreal's Plenitude line of cosmetics contains nanocapsules, which help active ingredients get to the skin's deeper layers. The nanocapsules are also in L'Oreal's higher-end brands such as Lancome.” Small Times, March 2004 “ Novasome” capsules can deeply penetrate skin and don't degrade while on the shelf Nanocrystalline Sunscreen “ Its main ingredient is Z-COTE, a substance made with nanotechnology . . . Nano-dispersed zinc oxide. . . . Zinc oxide provides broad-spectrum protection against UVA and UVB rays, but its characteristic white pasty goop often leaves sunbathers and lifeguards feeling like they're wearing clown makeup. The nanotechnology in Z-Cote produces a high-purity nanocrystalline zinc oxide, which allows the sunscreen to go on clear.” Forbes 2003

Skin care

“ L’Oreal's Plenitude line of cosmetics contains nanocapsules, which help active ingredients get to the skin's deeper layers. The nanocapsules are also in L'Oreal's higher-end brands such as Lancome.” Small Times, March 2004

“ Novasome” capsules can deeply penetrate skin and don't degrade while on the shelf

Nanocrystalline Sunscreen

“ Its main ingredient is Z-COTE, a substance made with nanotechnology . . . Nano-dispersed zinc oxide. . . . Zinc oxide provides broad-spectrum protection against UVA and UVB rays, but its characteristic white pasty goop often leaves sunbathers and lifeguards feeling like they're wearing clown makeup. The nanotechnology in Z-Cote produces a high-purity nanocrystalline zinc oxide, which allows the sunscreen to go on clear.” Forbes 2003

Products with Protective Coatings Glare-reducing and fog-resistant coatings for eyeglasses and windshields Sunglasses “ To give the glasses antireflection and scratch-resistance functionality, Nanofilm deposits coating layers of 150 nanometers and 20 microns thick, respectively. Then it uses chemical self-assembly to form a polymer coating, three to ten nanometers thin, on the outer layer of the antireflective lenses. This not only seals and repels grime and skin oils but also makes the lenses more responsive.“ Forbes 2003 High-Performance Ski Wax “ Nanowax produces a hard, fast-gliding surface. The ultrathin coating lasts much longer than conventional waxing systems, while leaving the base free of buildup. And here's the "intelligent" part: Cerax Nanowax hardens as temperatures drop, adapting to the ski bases and snow crystals, so you can reach top speed from the first few feet on.” Forbes 2003 No-wax car finish --for example, by Mercedes.

Glare-reducing and fog-resistant coatings for eyeglasses and windshields

Sunglasses

“ To give the glasses antireflection and scratch-resistance functionality, Nanofilm deposits coating layers of 150 nanometers and 20 microns thick, respectively. Then it uses chemical self-assembly to form a polymer coating, three to ten nanometers thin, on the outer layer of the antireflective lenses. This not only seals and repels grime and skin oils but also makes the lenses more responsive.“ Forbes 2003

High-Performance Ski Wax

“ Nanowax produces a hard, fast-gliding surface. The ultrathin coating lasts much longer than conventional waxing systems, while leaving the base free of buildup. And here's the "intelligent" part: Cerax Nanowax hardens as temperatures drop, adapting to the ski bases and snow crystals, so you can reach top speed from the first few feet on.” Forbes 2003

No-wax car finish --for example, by Mercedes.

Health and Medicine Expanding ability to characterize genetic makeup will revolutionize the specificity of diagnostics and therapeutics Nanodevices can make gene/DNA sequencing more efficient ‘ Gene gun’ that uses nanoparticles to deliver genetic material to target cells DNA microchip arrays using advances for IC industry Semiconductor nanocrystals as fluorescent biological labels Effective and less expensive health care using remote and in-vivo devices New formulations and routes for drug delivery, optimal drug usage “ Liposomes. . . were developed to deliver anticancer therapeutics directly at tumors. Specifically, liposomal doxorubicin is being used to treat certain forms of cancer, while liposomal amphotericin B treats fungal infections often associated with aggressive anticancer treatments.” Cancer treatment “ Recently, a nanoparticulate formulation of the well-known anticancer compound taxol was submitted to the FDA as a new treatment for advanced-stage breast cancer.” ADAPTED FROM: “Nanotechnology,” M. Meyyappan, Director, Center for Nanotechnology, NASA Ames Research Center

Expanding ability to characterize genetic makeup will revolutionize the specificity of diagnostics and therapeutics

Nanodevices can make gene/DNA sequencing more efficient

‘ Gene gun’ that uses nanoparticles to deliver genetic material to target cells

DNA microchip arrays using advances for IC industry

Semiconductor nanocrystals as fluorescent biological labels

Effective and less expensive health care using remote and in-vivo devices

New formulations and routes for drug delivery, optimal drug usage

“ Liposomes. . . were developed to deliver anticancer therapeutics directly at tumors. Specifically, liposomal doxorubicin is being used to treat certain forms of cancer, while liposomal amphotericin B treats fungal infections often associated with aggressive anticancer treatments.”

Cancer treatment

“ Recently, a nanoparticulate formulation of the well-known anticancer compound taxol was submitted to the FDA as a new treatment for advanced-stage breast cancer.”

Health and Medicine More durable, rejection-resistant artificial tissues, muscles, bone E.g. bionic eye, ear...: “synthetic orthopedic implants, like screws and plates, fabricated from nano-size particles of calcium and phosphate -- the materials that make up human bone. The material bonds with the natural bone and gradually becomes a part of it.” Sensors for early detection and prevention (“quantum dots”: “bits of semiconductor material a few thousand atoms wide, that will detect a variety of cancers and, perhaps, someday serve as “smart bombs” to destroy tumor cells”) STD prevention: “VivaGel is a topical microbicide gel product that has been developed for women as a preventative against the sexual transmission of HIV. It is also active in animal studies for the prevention of other sexually transmitted diseases including genital herpes and chlamydia.” (PR Newswire US, January 25, 2005) IN THE WORKS : thin films to measure blood-sugar levels FUTURE : diabetic insulin biocapsules pharmaceuticals utilizing “bucky ball” technology to selectively deliver drugs cancer therapies using targeted radioactive biocapsules. National Nanotechnology Infrastructure Network (“smart bombs” that destroy tumor cells), infections, clogged arteries, old age. ADAPTED FROM: “Nanotechnology,” M. Meyyappan, Director, Center for Nanotechnology, NASA Ames Research Center

More durable, rejection-resistant artificial tissues, muscles, bone

E.g. bionic eye, ear...: “synthetic orthopedic implants, like screws and plates, fabricated from nano-size particles of calcium and phosphate -- the materials that make up human bone. The material bonds with the natural bone and gradually becomes a part of it.”

Sensors for early detection and prevention (“quantum dots”: “bits of semiconductor material a few thousand atoms wide, that will detect a variety of cancers and, perhaps, someday serve as “smart bombs” to destroy tumor cells”)

STD prevention: “VivaGel is a topical microbicide gel product that has been developed for women as a preventative against the sexual transmission of HIV. It is also active in animal studies for the prevention of other sexually transmitted diseases including genital herpes and chlamydia.” (PR Newswire US, January 25, 2005)

IN THE WORKS : thin films to measure blood-sugar levels

FUTURE :

diabetic insulin biocapsules

pharmaceuticals utilizing “bucky ball” technology to selectively deliver drugs

cancer therapies using targeted radioactive biocapsules. National Nanotechnology Infrastructure Network

(“smart bombs” that destroy tumor cells), infections, clogged arteries, old age.

Health and Medicine Products LabNow Blood Analyser “ Tiny channels in a card filter white from red blood cells. When the card is popped into the analysing machine, it can come up with a white-cell count in 10 to 15 minutes. This could be important for HIV/Aids treatment.” Business Week Bandages embedded with silver nanoparticles Drug delivery via a patch Thin films on implantations into the human body (for example screws, joints, and stents) allowing devices to last longer Respiration monitors that are many times more sensitive Man-made skin for skin graft applications. National Nanotechnology Infrastructure Network

LabNow Blood Analyser

“ Tiny channels in a card filter white from red blood cells. When the card is popped into the analysing machine, it can come up with a white-cell count in 10 to 15 minutes. This could be important for HIV/Aids treatment.” Business Week

Bandages embedded with silver nanoparticles

Drug delivery via a patch

Thin films on implantations into the human body (for example screws, joints, and stents) allowing devices to last longer

Respiration monitors that are many times more sensitive

Man-made skin for skin graft applications. National Nanotechnology Infrastructure Network

Energy and Environment Energy Production Clean, less expensive sources enabled by novel nanomaterials and processes Solar energy: Photovoltaic cells Energy Utilization High efficiency and durable home and industrial lighting Solid state lighting can reduce total electricity consumption Materials of construction sensing changing conditions and in response, altering their inner structure Environmental cleanup Filters built out of carbon nanotubes, hollow cylinders only a few nanometers across, made of carbon atoms. Such fine sieves can filter bacteria and poliovirus particles out of drinking water. IN THE WORKS : Tiny cages of atoms to trap pollutants and chemical weapons in water and soil ADAPTED FROM: “Nanotechnology,” M. Meyyappan, Director, Center for Nanotechnology, NASA Ames Research Center

Energy Production

Clean, less expensive sources enabled by novel nanomaterials and processes

Solar energy: Photovoltaic cells

Energy Utilization

High efficiency and durable home and industrial lighting

Solid state lighting can reduce total electricity consumption

Materials of construction sensing changing conditions and in response, altering their inner structure

Environmental cleanup

Filters built out of carbon nanotubes, hollow cylinders only a few nanometers across, made of carbon atoms. Such fine sieves can filter bacteria and poliovirus particles out of drinking water.

IN THE WORKS : Tiny cages of atoms to trap pollutants and chemical weapons in water and soil

Energy and Environment Products “ NanoBreeze Air Purifier destroys all types of airborne contaminants. It attacks them on a molecular level using patented nanotechnology. ” GE Power Turbine “ Turbines are the workhorses of the digital age, providing both the juice to run our PCs, as well as the push to propel our jet planes. GE is exploring how nanotechnology can help to ruggedize the turbine blades used to spin these power plants. Using ceramics enriched with nanoscale particles, GE hopes to build more powerful turbines that operate at higher temperatures.” Business Week

“ NanoBreeze Air Purifier destroys all types of airborne contaminants. It attacks them on a molecular level using patented nanotechnology. ”

GE Power Turbine

“ Turbines are the workhorses of the digital age, providing both the juice to run our PCs, as well as the push to propel our jet planes. GE is exploring how nanotechnology can help to ruggedize the turbine blades used to spin these power plants. Using ceramics enriched with nanoscale particles, GE hopes to build more powerful turbines that operate at higher temperatures.” Business Week

Transportation Thermal barrier and wear resistant coatings High strength, light weight composites for increasing fuel efficiency High temperature sensors for under the hood Improved displays Battery technology Wear-resistant tires Automated highways ADAPTED FROM: “Nanotechnology,” M. Meyyappan, Director, Center for Nanotechnology, NASA Ames Research Center

Thermal barrier and wear resistant coatings

High strength, light weight composites for increasing fuel efficiency

High temperature sensors for under the hood

Improved displays

Battery technology

Wear-resistant tires

Automated highways

National Security Very high sensitivity, low power sensors for detecting chem/bio/nuclear threats Lightweight military platforms, without sacrificing functionality, safety and soldier security Reduce fuel needs and logistical requirements Reduce carry-on weight of soldier gear Increased functionality per unit weight ADAPTED FROM: “Nanotechnology,” M. Meyyappan, Director, Center for Nanotechnology, NASA Ames Research Center

Very high sensitivity, low power sensors for detecting chem/bio/nuclear threats

Lightweight military platforms, without sacrificing functionality, safety and soldier security

Reduce fuel needs and logistical requirements

Reduce carry-on weight of soldier gear

Increased functionality per unit weight

Space Exploration Advanced miniaturization, a key thrust area to enable new science and exploration missions Ultrasmall sensors, power sources, communication, navigation, and propulsion systems with very low mass, volume and power consumption are needed Revolutions in electronics and computing will allow reconfigurable, autonomous, “thinking” spacecraft Nanotechnology presents a whole new spectrum of opportunities to build device components and systems for entirely new space architectures Networks of ultrasmall probes on planetary surfaces Micro-rovers that drive, hop, fly, and burrow Collection of microspacecraft making a variety of measurements ADAPTED FROM: “Nanotechnology,” M. Meyyappan, Director, Center for Nanotechnology, NASA Ames Research Center

Advanced miniaturization, a key thrust area to enable new science and exploration missions

Ultrasmall sensors, power sources, communication, navigation, and propulsion systems with very low mass, volume and power consumption are needed

Revolutions in electronics and computing will allow reconfigurable, autonomous, “thinking” spacecraft

Nanotechnology presents a whole new spectrum of opportunities to build device components and systems for entirely new space architectures

Networks of ultrasmall probes on planetary surfaces

Micro-rovers that drive, hop, fly, and burrow

Collection of microspacecraft making a variety of measurements

Molecular Manufacturing ( products not yet developed ) Self-replicating molecular assemblers: Devices that could, on their own, arrange atoms and molecules in precise ways for a specific purpose,” thus allowing us to “build almost anything that the laws of nature allow to exist.” “ Mechanical surgeons” that could travel to trouble spots inside the body “ Fresh food – ‘genuine meat, grain, vegetables, and so forth’ -- could be produced in the home.” “ Suits made with nanotechnology could be used for virtual reality, simulating ‘most of the sights and sensations of an entire environment.’” “ And nanotechnology could make some form of telepathy as possible as telephony.” “ Nanomachines could precisely adjust your hair and skin color to your liking” “ Wrinkles could be smoothed and excess fat removed”

( products not yet developed )

Self-replicating molecular assemblers: Devices that could, on their own, arrange atoms and molecules in precise ways for a specific purpose,” thus allowing us to “build almost anything that the laws of nature allow to exist.”

“ Mechanical surgeons” that could travel to trouble spots inside the body

“ Fresh food – ‘genuine meat, grain, vegetables, and so forth’ -- could be produced in the home.”

“ Suits made with nanotechnology could be used for virtual reality, simulating ‘most of the sights and sensations of an entire environment.’”

“ And nanotechnology could make some form of telepathy as possible as telephony.”

“ Nanomachines could precisely adjust your hair and skin color to your liking”

“ Wrinkles could be smoothed and excess fat removed”

Molecular Manufacturing ( products not yet developed ) “ Mold the face and body to whatever shape might be desired” “ Respirocyte,” an artificial red blood cell capable of delivering oxygen hundreds of times more efficiently than real red blood cells, would be invaluable in the treatment of various respiratory and cardiovascular disorders, or as a substitute for real blood during transfusions. But they would also have “a variety of sports, veterinary, battlefield and other applications”; they could be used to boost a mountain climber's endurance, to help a diver hold his breath for hours, or to enable a soldier to fight harder. Nanomachines that repair cells and fix damaged DNA; to remove toxins, clean out cholesterol, and eliminate scar tissue; to destroy cancer cells and fight countless diseases “ A person might intentionally put himself into stasis, perhaps to “time travel” dreamlessly into the future, or to wait out a centuries-long interstellar voyage.” “ Mind-control systems, invisible and mobile eavesdropping devices, or unimaginably horrific tools of torture”

( products not yet developed )

“ Mold the face and body to whatever shape might be desired”

“ Respirocyte,” an artificial red blood cell capable of delivering oxygen hundreds of times more efficiently than real red blood cells, would be invaluable in the treatment of various respiratory and cardiovascular disorders, or as a substitute for real blood during transfusions. But they would also have “a variety of sports, veterinary, battlefield and other applications”; they could be used to boost a mountain climber's endurance, to help a diver hold his breath for hours, or to enable a soldier to fight harder.

Nanomachines that repair cells and fix damaged DNA; to remove toxins, clean out cholesterol, and eliminate scar tissue; to destroy cancer cells and fight countless diseases

“ A person might intentionally put himself into stasis, perhaps to “time travel” dreamlessly into the future, or to wait out a centuries-long interstellar voyage.”

“ Mind-control systems, invisible and mobile eavesdropping devices, or unimaginably horrific tools of torture”

The Perfect Fridge? Some products combine different kinds of nanotechnology, such as the Samsung Nano SilverSeal refrigerator “ Samsung has rolled out a line of fridges and washing machines that use nanocoatings to prevent nasty bugs from growing. Specks of silver, as small as one nanometer across, are used to coat surfaces. These nanoparticles are so electrically active that they inhibit the growth of harmful bacteria and fungs. In its fridge, Samsung used the nanosilver in the deodorizer unit and water dispenser to sanitize the air and water that passes over them.” Business Week

Timeline of Nano Events Return to Table of Contents The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

A Few Notable Events 1959 : Richard Feynman gives his famous paper on nanotechnology “There’s Plenty of Room at the Bottom” on December 29th at the annual meeting of the American Physical Society at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech). 1981 : Eric Drexler publishes the first journal article on molecular nanotechnology: "Molecular engineering: An approach to the development of general capabilities for molecular manipulation.“ 1986 : Eric Drexler writes Engines of Creation , which describes his his goal of molecular manufacturing, the manufacture of nanoscale devices and artefacts capable of sophisticated operations. 1996 : Robert F. Curl Jr. and Richard E. Smalley, both of Rice University in Houston, Texas and Harold W. Kroto of the University of Sussex in England, win the 1996 Nobel Prize for Chemistry for their discovery of buckminsterfullerene , the scientific name for buckyballs . 2002 : The US Army awards a five-year contract to MIT to develop the US Army Institute of Soldier Nanotechnologies, a research unit devoted to developing military applications for nanotechnology.

1959 : Richard Feynman gives his famous paper on nanotechnology “There’s Plenty of Room at the Bottom” on December 29th at the annual meeting of the American Physical Society at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech).

1981 : Eric Drexler publishes the first journal article on molecular nanotechnology: "Molecular engineering: An approach to the development of general capabilities for molecular manipulation.“

1986 : Eric Drexler writes Engines of Creation , which describes his his goal of molecular manufacturing, the manufacture of nanoscale devices and artefacts capable of sophisticated operations.

1996 : Robert F. Curl Jr. and Richard E. Smalley, both of Rice University in Houston, Texas and Harold W. Kroto of the University of Sussex in England, win the 1996 Nobel Prize for Chemistry for their discovery of buckminsterfullerene , the scientific name for buckyballs .

2002 : The US Army awards a five-year contract to MIT to develop the US Army Institute of Soldier Nanotechnologies, a research unit devoted to developing military applications for nanotechnology.

What to Expect in the Near Future Short term (within 5 years) Nanoparticles Automotive industry (body moldings,timing belts, engine covers) Packaging industry Cosmetics Flat panel displays Coatings CNT-based probes in semiconductor metrology Tools Catalysts (extension of existing market) Medium term (5-10 years) Memory devices Fuel cells, batteries Biosensors (CNT, molecular, qD based) Biomedical devices Advances in gene sequencing Advances in lighting

Short term (within 5 years)

Nanoparticles

Automotive industry (body moldings,timing belts, engine covers)

Packaging industry

Cosmetics

Flat panel displays

Coatings

CNT-based probes in semiconductor metrology

Tools

Catalysts (extension of existing market)

Medium term (5-10 years)

Memory devices

Fuel cells, batteries

Biosensors (CNT, molecular, qD based)

Biomedical devices

Advances in gene sequencing

Advances in lighting

What to Expect in the Long Term Long term (> 15 years) Nanoelectronics (CNT) Molecular electronics Routine use of new composites in Aerospace, automotive (risk-averse industries) Many other things we haven’t even thought of yet SOURCE: “Nanotechnology: Opportunities and Challenges”, M. Meyyappan, Director, Center for Nanotechnology, NASA Ames Research Center

Long term (> 15 years)

Nanoelectronics (CNT)

Molecular electronics

Routine use of new composites in Aerospace, automotive (risk-averse industries)

Many other things we haven’t even thought of yet

SOURCE: “Nanotechnology: Opportunities and Challenges”, M. Meyyappan, Director, Center for Nanotechnology, NASA Ames Research Center

Popular Culture Return to Table of Contents The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

Talking about Nano While many of the specific consequences of nanotechnology are still unknown, talk about nanotechnology is quickly circulating, not only among scientists and engineers but also within cultural realms, such as the media and popular arts.

Science Fiction Recent works of popular culture have made reference to nanotechnology, including films ( The Hulk, The Tuxedo, Spider Man ), books ( Prey by Michael Crichton and Diamond Age by Neal Stephenson), television shows ( Star Trek) and video games ( Metal Gear Solid ). While some of these works have been critiqued for inaccurately portraying the risks and potential of nanotechnology, they can be credited for piquing popular interest in the topic.

Recent works of popular culture have made reference to nanotechnology, including films ( The Hulk, The Tuxedo, Spider Man ), books ( Prey by Michael Crichton and Diamond Age by Neal Stephenson), television shows ( Star Trek) and video games ( Metal Gear Solid ).

While some of these works have been critiqued for inaccurately portraying the risks and potential of nanotechnology, they can be credited for piquing popular interest in the topic.

The Possibility of Molecular Manufacturing? Some current books have examined nanotechnology’s potential to transform everyday life from a science-based perspective. Among others: Engines of Creation by K. Eric Drexler Nanotechnology: Molecular Speculations on Global Abundance edited by BC Crandall Our Molecular Future: How Nanotechnology, Robotics, Genetics, and Artificial Intelligence Will Transform Our World by Douglas Mulhall For more works: http:// www.foresight.org/nano/Bookstore.html Some of the ideas in these works have been critiqued as physically impossible, namely the notion of molecular manufacturing , which involves self-assembling molecular structures. According to Professor Richard Smalley of Rice University, self-replicating structures are ‘simply not possible in our world’ and speculation about them does more to hurt rather than help the public’s acceptance of nanotechnology.

Some current books have examined nanotechnology’s potential to transform everyday life from a science-based perspective. Among others:

Engines of Creation by K. Eric Drexler

Nanotechnology: Molecular Speculations on Global Abundance edited by BC Crandall

Our Molecular Future: How Nanotechnology, Robotics, Genetics, and Artificial Intelligence Will Transform Our World by Douglas Mulhall

For more works: http:// www.foresight.org/nano/Bookstore.html

Some of the ideas in these works have been critiqued as physically impossible, namely the notion of molecular manufacturing , which involves self-assembling molecular structures. According to Professor Richard Smalley of Rice University, self-replicating structures are ‘simply not possible in our world’ and speculation about them does more to hurt rather than help the public’s acceptance of nanotechnology.

Arts and Film It has been argued that DVDs have changed the way in which viewers appreciate film as art by allowing viewers to understand the film production process. For instance, we now have access to director’s commentaries on her stylistic choices as well as mini-documentaries that demystify the “making of” a film. With the potential to store even more information on digital media, how else might our understanding of film, and other art forms, change? For example, consider DVDs that store footage of auditions and documentaries about actors’ role preparation as well as their scene-by-scene commentary. What will happen when artists’ interpretations compete with those of ‘experts’ who interpret art for a living? How will this change our ideas of what art is?

It has been argued that DVDs have changed the way in which viewers appreciate film as art by allowing viewers to understand the film production process. For instance, we now have access to director’s commentaries on her stylistic choices as well as mini-documentaries that demystify the “making of” a film.

With the potential to store even more information on digital media, how else might our understanding of film, and other art forms, change? For example, consider DVDs that store footage of auditions and documentaries about actors’ role preparation as well as their scene-by-scene commentary.

What will happen when artists’ interpretations compete with those of ‘experts’ who interpret art for a living?

How will this change our ideas of what art is?

Fashion Nanotechnology has been used to develop new threads that reflect all light that hits it, allowing fabric to change colors. While initially developed at Massachusetts Institute Technology for soldiers’ uniforms, these threads may soon be used in the fashion world. SOURCE: ( “Clothes That Change Color” ) How will the fashion industry be impacted with such ‘smart fabrics’ that both change colors and self-clean? Consider how old fads gain ‘vintage’ prestige. What fashion status will given to fabrics that can become dirty or cannot change colors? Which other accessories will become ‘retro’ and which will simply disappear? GLASSES : Will they be replaced by corrective surgery performed by nano-robots or will they become vintage adornments on the face?

Nanotechnology has been used to develop new threads that reflect all light that hits it, allowing fabric to change colors. While initially developed at Massachusetts Institute Technology for soldiers’ uniforms, these threads may soon be used in the fashion world.

SOURCE: ( “Clothes That Change Color” )

How will the fashion industry be impacted with such ‘smart fabrics’ that both change colors and self-clean?

Consider how old fads gain ‘vintage’ prestige. What fashion status will given to fabrics that can become dirty or cannot change colors?

Which other accessories will become ‘retro’ and which will simply disappear?

GLASSES : Will they be replaced by corrective surgery performed by nano-robots or will they become vintage adornments on the face?

Public Figures The development of internet and computer technology has increased the potential to bring the ‘private’ lives of public figures into the public eye. Nanotechnology may facilitate this process as undetectable recording devices and efficient computers contribute to the immediate dissemination of images and sounds. To what degree should the private lives of public figures be respected? What are some ways to regulate the use of nanotechnology to ‘smear’ reputations? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

The development of internet and computer technology has increased the potential to bring the ‘private’ lives of public figures into the public eye. Nanotechnology may facilitate this process as undetectable recording devices and efficient computers contribute to the immediate dissemination of images and sounds.

To what degree should the private lives of public figures be respected?

What are some ways to regulate the use of nanotechnology to ‘smear’ reputations?

Classroom Return to Table of Contents The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

Classroom Structure With the increasing use of computers that efficiently and inexpensively store large amounts of information, the classic model of the public school classroom may change.

Classroom Structure: The Role of the Teacher What will the role of the teacher be as students depend increasingly on information technology for knowledge transmission?

What will the role of the teacher be as students depend increasingly on information technology for knowledge transmission?

Classroom Structure: Alternative Education Paradigms Will home-schooling and alternative education paradigms be more acceptable given the inexpensive resources accessible via computers? What innovations might be possible to tailor learning to each individual? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Will home-schooling and alternative education paradigms be more acceptable given the inexpensive resources accessible via computers?

What innovations might be possible to tailor learning to each individual?

Classroom Structure: New Experiences Students may be able to attend virtual classrooms with students from all over the world, using programs that not only simulate other environments but allow students to be virtually present in classrooms. How will the classroom experience change through such advancements? How will discipline be maintained without the direct presence of teachers to enforce rules? What types of new language and learning practices will result from such opportunities for cross-cultural exposure? What types of obstacles will result from the lack of shared languages and learning practices?

How will the classroom experience change through such advancements?

How will discipline be maintained without the direct presence of teachers to enforce rules?

What types of new language and learning practices will result from such opportunities for cross-cultural exposure?

What types of obstacles will result from the lack of shared languages and learning practices?

Curriculum: How will traditional subjects be affected? Algebra Anthropology Biology Calculus Chemistry Chinese Computer Science Dance Economics English French Geometry Japanese Journalism Latin Literature Music National History Physical Education Physics Psychology Sociology Spanish Swahili Theater Visual Arts World History

Curriculum: Sciences and Liberal Arts The nanotechnological “revolution” will lead to many changes in the demands of the workforce. Social scientists believe it will provide an increasing number of career opportunities in the sciences as well as a decrease in the need for manual labor complemented by the need for intellectual labor. In preparation for these changes, should schools place greater emphasis on the sciences? What might be some consequences for our culture? Should science and liberal arts programs be rejoined?

The nanotechnological “revolution” will lead to many changes in the demands of the workforce.

Social scientists believe it will provide an increasing number of career opportunities in the sciences as well as a decrease in the need for manual labor complemented by the need for intellectual labor.

In preparation for these changes, should schools place greater emphasis on the sciences? What might be some consequences for our culture?

Should science and liberal arts programs be rejoined?

Curriculum: Science How can we discover new ways to teach across boundaries? Nanotechnology combines the principles of chemistry, physics, biology, and engineering. physics engineering chemistry biology

How can we discover new ways to teach across boundaries?

Curriculum: Learning across Cultural Boundaries Computers that store large amounts of information and allow communication with people across the world will allow teachers and students access to information from many types of cultures. What are the best ways to emphasize cross-cultural course content? How will the sharing of music, popular culture, politics and shared challenges change students’ understanding of their place in the world? How can educators and students create local, state, national, and international identities? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Computers that store large amounts of information and allow communication with people across the world will allow teachers and students access to information from many types of cultures.

What are the best ways to emphasize cross-cultural course content?

How will the sharing of music, popular culture, politics and shared challenges change students’ understanding of their place in the world?

How can educators and students create local, state, national, and international identities?

Curriculum: Language Teachers and students will be given a variety of opportunities to teach and learn with others in various parts of the world, for example, through virtual classrooms. How will language abilities and knowledge be shared and measured? How will monolingual speakers, such as many English-speaking Americans, manage in such classrooms? What should be the language medium of education in multilingual classrooms? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Teachers and students will be given a variety of opportunities to teach and learn with others in various parts of the world, for example, through virtual classrooms.

How will language abilities and knowledge be shared and measured?

How will monolingual speakers, such as many English-speaking Americans, manage in such classrooms?

What should be the language medium of education in multilingual classrooms?

Curriculum: New Theories Some scientific theories that are currently important in our society may diminish in relevance. For instance: IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart Natural selection: Given that ‘imperfect’ genes may be ‘corrected’ with new technological developments, will the notion of genetic variation and mutation become irrelevant?

Some scientific theories that are currently important in our society may diminish in relevance. For instance:

Natural selection: Given that ‘imperfect’ genes may be ‘corrected’ with new technological developments, will the notion of genetic variation and mutation become irrelevant?

Lessons in Nanotechnology How can children learn about nanotechnology in the present? Take a nano quiz Check out a science web magazine called Nanooze Tour the Science Museum in London Visit the The Wonderful World of Carbon Nanotubes Presentation at the Museam of Science, Boston Adapted from the National Nanotechnology Initiative, Education Center . Other teacher resources can be found here .

How can children learn about nanotechnology in the present?

Take a nano quiz

Check out a science web magazine called Nanooze

Tour the Science Museum in London

Visit the The Wonderful World of Carbon Nanotubes Presentation at the Museam of Science, Boston

Adapted from the National Nanotechnology Initiative, Education Center .

Other teacher resources can be found here .

Classroom values To what degree should such devices be used and limited? Michael Stravato for The New York Times Sandra Martinez, 10, uses her ID card to indicate that she is getting off her school bus in Spring, Tex. Sensors that track movements and closely monitor students’ activities will be available.

To what degree should such devices be used and limited?

Classroom Values: Monitoring Students Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) Systems are not nanotechnological devices, but the current controversy over using electronic tracking systems provides an indication of how local communities may respond to nano-devices that similarly, though invisibly, track human bodies. “In Texas, 28,000 Students Test an Electronic Eye” By Matt Richtel [click title for full text] November 17, 2004, The New York Times SPRING, Tex. - In front of her gated apartment complex, Courtney Payne, a 9-year-old fourth grader with dark hair pulled tightly into a ponytail, exits a yellow school bus. Moments later, her movement is observed by Alan Bragg, the local police chief, standing in a windowless control room more than a mile away. Chief Bragg is not using video surveillance. Rather, he watches an icon on a computer screen. The icon marks the spot on a map where Courtney got off the bus, and, on a larger level, it represents the latest in the convergence of technology and student security. Hoping to prevent the loss of a child through kidnapping or more innocent circumstances, a few schools have begun monitoring student arrivals and departures using technology similar to that used to track livestock and pallets of retail shipments. . . . But there are critics, including some older students and privacy groups like the American Civil Liberties Union, who argue that the system is security paranoia. . . “Elementary school nixes electronic IDs” By Alorie Gilbertm Staff Writer [click title for full text ] February 17, 2005, CNET News.com An elementary school in the rural town of Sutter, Calif., has pulled the plug on a new student surveillance system after the technology came under fire by parents and privacy groups. Brittan Elementary School, located about 40 miles north of state capital Sacramento, is shutting off the high-tech student-tracking system because the company supplying it backed out of the deal, the school said Tuesday. The company, called InCom, put a kibosh on the project after some parents and a representative of the American Civil Liberties Union aired complaints at a school board meeting last week. Their protests became the subject of numerous media reports. Parents and privacy advocates were concerned that student badges containing tiny radio devices would infringe on kids' privacy--and that the radio waves could pose a health risk. . . More information on Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) Systems

Classroom Identities What might be some obstacles to providing equal education? What are some of the ways we can safeguard the concept of equal education for all? At present, there is a traditional gendered division between the arts and the sciences. How might this division be embedded in cultural ideas? Will these cultural ideas change over time? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart Students in various environments will have greater access to educational opportunities given that tools, such as computers, are more widely affordable. Communication across various kinds of social lines, such as social class and ethnicity, will also be possible.

What might be some obstacles to providing equal education?

What are some of the ways we can safeguard the concept of equal education for all?

At present, there is a traditional gendered division between the arts and the sciences. How might this division be embedded in cultural ideas? Will these cultural ideas change over time?

Community Return to Table of Contents The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

Community: Class Structure Will it be the case that certain public spaces will benefit more from nanotechnology because residents can afford it, resulting in a snowball effect leading to a larger class gap? Or will the benefits of nanotechnology “trickle down” to all classes? What are some ways to increase the positive benefits of this technology to all—for example, in terms of health, security, and the military? Upper Middle Working ? ? Some predicted that there would be a gap between the rich and poor—a “digital divide”—with the development of the Internet. Working Middle Upper Working Upper

Will it be the case that certain public spaces will benefit more from nanotechnology because residents can afford it, resulting in a snowball effect leading to a larger class gap? Or will the benefits of nanotechnology “trickle down” to all classes?

What are some ways to increase the positive benefits of this technology to all—for example, in terms of health, security, and the military?

Crime: Policing and Monitoring Which public spaces should be monitored by nano-devices that are undetectable to the human eye? How can we best ensure that we keep our civil rights? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart Nanodevices that can police public spaces in cost effective ways may change the nature of criminal activity.

Which public spaces should be monitored by nano-devices that are undetectable to the human eye?

How can we best ensure that we keep our civil rights?

Crime: Drugs If we develop nano-medical devices that alter the mind much like narcotics, how will the “war on drugs” change? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart Who will be the new suppliers? How will laws be enforced by the police? Who will be the buyers?

If we develop nano-medical devices that alter the mind much like narcotics, how will the “war on drugs” change?

Who will be the new suppliers?

How will laws be enforced by the police?

Who will be the buyers?

Crime: Weapons Who should have the right to own these weapons? How can the government regulate such ownership? To what degree will citizens feel protected—or vulnerable? How will the possession of weapons by private citizens help resolve or increase conflict? individual vs. society Sophisticated nano weapons, such as self-replicating toxins, may become both easily accessible and affordable. freedom vs. regulation conflict vs. peace

Who should have the right to own these weapons?

How can the government regulate such ownership?

To what degree will citizens feel protected—or vulnerable?

How will the possession of weapons by private citizens help resolve or increase conflict?

Crime: Civil Rights CIVIL RIGHTS / PRIVACY With new scientific discoveries it is not always possible to foresee problems. What are some problems you see in this picture? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Crime: Civil Rights CIVIL RIGHTS / PRIVACY With new scientific discoveries it is not always possible to foresee problems. What are some problems you see in this picture? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

With new scientific discoveries it is not always possible to foresee problems.

What are some problems you see in this picture?

Crime: Civil Rights CIVIL RIGHTS / PRIVACY With new scientific discoveries it is not always possible to foresee problems. What are some problems you see in this picture? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

With new scientific discoveries it is not always possible to foresee problems.

What are some problems you see in this picture?

Crime: Civil Rights CIVIL RIGHTS / PRIVACY With new scientific discoveries it is not always possible to foresee problems. What are some problems you see in this picture? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

With new scientific discoveries it is not always possible to foresee problems.

What are some problems you see in this picture?

Crime: Civil Rights IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart CIVIL RIGHTS / PRIVACY With new scientific discoveries it is not always possible to foresee problems. What are some problems you see in this picture? Some of these products m ay be manufactured in individual homes. How should the government police the development of potentially dangerous or potent products without sacrificing civil rights?

With new scientific discoveries it is not always possible to foresee problems.

What are some problems you see in this picture?

Some of these products m ay be manufactured in individual homes. How should the government police the development of potentially dangerous or potent products without sacrificing civil rights?

Immigration What effects can you imagine for the US economy? Who will perform the kind of manual labor presently performed by immigrants? How will this affect both small businesses and large corporations? Consider how the Berlin Wall, which once divided East and West Germany, may have prevented the growth of the East German economy. Would closed borders bring similar dangers to the US economy? Would a tightly maintained border allow the US to control and make maximum use of its natural and labor resources? Many people have advocated closing off US national borders. A border patrol of nanorobots able to detect tiny movements may allow the US to create a tightly maintained fence.

What effects can you imagine for the US economy?

Who will perform the kind of manual labor presently performed by immigrants?

How will this affect both small businesses and large corporations?

Consider how the Berlin Wall, which once divided East and West Germany, may have prevented the growth of the East German economy. Would closed borders bring similar dangers to the US economy?

Would a tightly maintained border allow the US to control and make maximum use of its natural and labor resources?

Environment: Cleanup “ [R]esearchers from Banaras Hindu University, in Varanasi, India, and Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute described a process for building large filters out of carbon nanotubes, hollow cylinders only a few nanometers across, made of carbon atoms. The team demonstrated how such fine sieves could filter bacteria and poliovirus particles out of drinking water.” (Richard Monastersky, September 10, 2004, Friday, The Dark Side of Small, The Chronicle of Higher Education ) IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

“ [R]esearchers from Banaras Hindu University, in Varanasi, India, and Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute described a process for building large filters out of carbon nanotubes, hollow cylinders only a few nanometers across, made of carbon atoms. The team demonstrated how such fine sieves could filter bacteria and poliovirus particles out of drinking water.” (Richard Monastersky, September 10, 2004, Friday, The Dark Side of Small, The Chronicle of Higher Education )

Environment: Dangers “ Activists caution that nanoparticles are small enough to enter the lungs or be absorbed through the skin. As a result, they could accumulate in the food chain and kill ecologically important organisms and adversely affect human health, too” (Jennifer Bails. January 21, 2005 Friday. Nanotechnology is next big thing in electronics and manufacturing. Pittsburgh Tribune Review .) “ In a study run by Anna A. Shvedova, an adjunct associate professor at West Virginia and a senior staff scientist at the institute, the researchers put carbon nanotubes into the lungs of mice and found scar tissue forming within a week, faster than the scarring from any other material they have tested.” (Richard Monastersky. September 10, 2004, Friday, The Dark Side of Small, The Chronicle of Higher Education ) DANGER nanotechnology

“ Activists caution that nanoparticles are small enough to enter the lungs or be absorbed through the skin. As a result, they could accumulate in the food chain and kill ecologically important organisms and adversely affect human health, too” (Jennifer Bails. January 21, 2005 Friday. Nanotechnology is next big thing in electronics and manufacturing. Pittsburgh Tribune Review .)

“ In a study run by Anna A. Shvedova, an adjunct associate professor at West Virginia and a senior staff scientist at the institute, the researchers put carbon nanotubes into the lungs of mice and found scar tissue forming within a week, faster than the scarring from any other material they have tested.” (Richard Monastersky. September 10, 2004, Friday, The Dark Side of Small, The Chronicle of Higher Education )

Environment: Dangers BUT remember that many technological developments we depend on every day may have harmful side-effects. antibiotics Teflon plastics x-rays asbestos pesticides fire retardants What are some ways we can manage the risk of nano-related products? For example: testing individuals for allergies keeping records of products’ effects instituting rigorous testing standards before products enter the market

BUT remember that many technological developments we depend on every day may have harmful side-effects.

What are some ways we can manage the risk of nano-related products?

For example:

testing individuals for allergies

keeping records of products’ effects

instituting rigorous testing standards before products enter the market

Environment: Worth the Risk? GRAY GOO Researcher and author Eric Drexler predicts that nanotechnology will allow us to clean the environment with nano-sized, self-replicating cleaning machines that rid the air of carbon dioxide and poisons. On the other hand, he also notes that “auto-assemblers” that would assemble molecules into desired products could have the potential of turning the earth into a mass of “gray goo” in less than 10 hours. Although this position is discounted by many scientists who believe that self-replicating molecular structures are “not of this world,” what should your role be in setting policy decisions about the development and use of nanotechnology to clean the environment? Should we seek to use nanotechnology to clean the environment even if it puts it at great risk? For more information see Environmental Regulation of Nanotechnology:Some Preliminary Observations

Although this position is discounted by many scientists who believe that self-replicating molecular structures are “not of this world,” what should your role be in setting policy decisions about the development and use of nanotechnology to clean the environment?

Should we seek to use nanotechnology to clean the environment even if it puts it at great risk?

For more information see Environmental Regulation of Nanotechnology:Some Preliminary Observations

Environment: Alternative Sources of Energy “ Konarka's solar panels are manufactured with a coating made from microscopically small nanoparticles of titanium dioxide to which a light-absorbing dye is applied. By using the tiny, ice-cube-shaped particles, Konarka is able to increase the effectiveness of the panels by giving them more surface area upon which to apply the dye. . . Mr. Tripathy invented a technique for “painting” nanoparticles at temperatures below 500 degrees Celsius, making it feasible to apply the dye to rolls and strips of flexible plastic instead of heavier sheets of glass. The technique, which also reduces manufacturing costs, could be used on clothing fibers as well. A soldier outfitted in such clothing could in effect be wearing his own lightweight source of electricity.” Goldie Blumenstyk. September 10, 2004, Big Bucks for Tiny Technology, The Chronicle of Higher Education . How will our lives change if we can wear electricity in the future in the form of solar clothing?

“ Konarka's solar panels are manufactured with a coating made from microscopically small nanoparticles of titanium dioxide to which a light-absorbing dye is applied. By using the tiny, ice-cube-shaped particles, Konarka is able to increase the effectiveness of the panels by giving them more surface area upon which to apply the dye. . . Mr. Tripathy invented a technique for “painting” nanoparticles at temperatures below 500 degrees Celsius, making it feasible to apply the dye to rolls and strips of flexible plastic instead of heavier sheets of glass. The technique, which also reduces manufacturing costs, could be used on clothing fibers as well. A soldier outfitted in such clothing could in effect be wearing his own lightweight source of electricity.”

Goldie Blumenstyk. September 10, 2004, Big Bucks for Tiny Technology, The Chronicle of Higher Education .

How will our lives change if we can wear electricity in the future in the form of solar clothing?

Local Communities in Transition What are the societal benefits of maintaining small communities such as these? What kind of compensation can be provided, if any, given the hardship that this technological turn will bring to their immediate lives? What are some of the ways that we as a nation have handled similar situations in the past? What has worked and what hasn’t? Specific communities that have traditionally survived by supplying raw materials (e.g., timber or coal) may encounter difficulties finding new sources of income. For instance, timber may become less valuable given the development of building materials that are lighter, stronger, and less expensive, and new efficient and inexpensive forms of energy will be developed. The result may be the death of these communities as new generations migrate to urban areas.

What are the societal benefits of maintaining small communities such as these?

What kind of compensation can be provided, if any, given the hardship that this technological turn will bring to their immediate lives?

What are some of the ways that we as a nation have handled similar situations in the past? What has worked and what hasn’t?

Local Communities in Transition Autonomous communities may develop because of innovations in nanotechnology. Some communities may come to have the potential for self-sufficiency through the use of nanotechnology. On the other hand, other communities may reject the pace of technological change. What can we learn from this about happiness and fulfillment? Why are such communities often seen as a threat? community community community community community

Autonomous communities may develop because of innovations in nanotechnology. Some communities may come to have the potential for self-sufficiency through the use of nanotechnology. On the other hand, other communities may reject the pace of technological change.

What can we learn from this about happiness and fulfillment?

Why are such communities often seen as a threat?

What are the different ways of leveraging benefits and minimizing risks associated with nanotechnological products? global treaties laws enforced by the police surveillance of homes tracking of human bodies government-controlled distribution of technology industry-controlled distribution circulation of message through the media, education, and by word-of-mouth Regulation of Nanotechnology IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

What are the different ways of leveraging benefits and minimizing risks associated with nanotechnological products?

global treaties

laws enforced by the police

surveillance of homes

tracking of human bodies

government-controlled distribution of technology

industry-controlled distribution

circulation of message through the media, education, and by word-of-mouth

Regulation of Nanotechnology: Property Rights How can we prepare ourselves for the changes in what it means to own property? How will our understanding of property ownership change as ‘intellectual property’ gains relative importance? What kind of patent system should be developed to prevent the proliferation of inexpensively manufactured ‘copies’? Should there be regulation of these copies or should intellectual property be regarded as public property? The notion of having private property, while assumed to be a basic right in many societies, is a culturally specific idea; it has held varying importance in different cultures and across time. With the growth of nanotechnology, we may eventually have the potential to “create” all sorts of objects molecule-by-molecule. There may also be an increased emphasis on the ‘ownership’ of intellectual rather than physical property.

How can we prepare ourselves for the changes in what it means to own property?

How will our understanding of property ownership change as ‘intellectual property’ gains relative importance?

What kind of patent system should be developed to prevent the proliferation of inexpensively manufactured ‘copies’?

Should there be regulation of these copies or should intellectual property be regarded as public property?

Family Return to Table of Contents The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

Household Labor Household labor will be significantly affected by the introduction of products that, on the one hand, save time yet, on the other hand, increase expectations of “immaculate” living quarters. IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Household labor will be significantly affected by the introduction of products that, on the one hand, save time yet, on the other hand, increase expectations of “immaculate” living quarters.

Products that Provide Convenience Self-cleaning windows: Windows will be made of materials that repel water and dirt at the flick of a switch. Stain - and wrinkle-free clothing: Ironing will be a chore of the past. “ Smart” paints: Paint will paint itself onto walls. IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart IMAGE SOURCE: http://www.thehumorwriter.com/Life_With_A_Man/Housework_for_Husbands/man-ironing.jpg

Self-cleaning windows:

Windows will be made of materials that repel water and dirt at the flick of a switch.

A Decrease in Household Labor? Devices that are made to reduce household labor may not reduce as much labor as we might anticipate. Consider the cases of In the past, the introduction of these household appliances did not necessarily decrease labor given increased cultural expectations, specifically in middle class families, for clothes and dishes to be cleaner and ideal bread to be home-baked, pasta to be homemade, and coffee beans to be home-ground. How might our cultural expectations for the kinds of labor performed in the home change as ‘time-saving’ technological tools are introduced? How will wrinkle-free clothing affect our perception of wrinkled clothing? How will smart paints change our expectations for decorating and re-decorating the home? How will ‘dirt’ and ‘stains’ be viewed as products are created to more efficiently prevent them from being visible? washing machines dishwashers bread machines pasta makers coffee grinders IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Devices that are made to reduce household labor may not reduce as much labor as we might anticipate. Consider the cases of

In the past, the introduction of these household appliances did not necessarily decrease labor given increased cultural expectations, specifically in middle class families, for clothes and dishes to be cleaner and ideal bread to be home-baked, pasta to be homemade, and coffee beans to be home-ground.

How might our cultural expectations for the kinds of labor performed in the home change as ‘time-saving’ technological tools are introduced?

How will wrinkle-free clothing affect our perception of wrinkled clothing?

How will smart paints change our expectations for decorating and re-decorating the home?

How will ‘dirt’ and ‘stains’ be viewed as products are created to more efficiently prevent them from being visible?

Family Values and Structure: Childcare Surveillance devices that track the movement of children may reduce the time and stress of child labor. Parents may be able to perform childcare without having to be in the direct presence of their children. They will be able to view their activities and communicate easily with them from remote locations. IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Surveillance devices that track the movement of children may reduce the time and stress of child labor.

Parents may be able to perform childcare without having to be in the direct presence of their children. They will be able to view their activities and communicate easily with them from remote locations.

Family Values and Structure: Childcare What might be some of the dangers of depending on such devices? How will they affect parent-child relations in terms of the following? communication and understanding emotional support discipline How can we use these devices yet maintain respect for children’s privacy? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

What might be some of the dangers of depending on such devices?

How will they affect parent-child relations in terms of the following?

communication and understanding

emotional support

discipline

How can we use these devices yet maintain respect for children’s privacy?

Nanotechnology promises many advances in medicine, including disease prevention through devices that detect medical problems in their early stages and provide comprehensive information about individuals’ genetic predispositions. Nano-robots may also help rebuild non-working organs and alter the genetic makeup of offspring. These medical advances may significantly alter families’ values and structures. As society’s physical health improves and life-spans increase, to what degree will societal expectations for women to conceive early change? Would you genetically engineer your own children? What kinds of genetically engineering for their children should parents be allowed to undertake? Why or why not? Family Values and Structure

Nanotechnology promises many advances in medicine, including disease prevention through devices that detect medical problems in their early stages and provide comprehensive information about individuals’ genetic predispositions.

Nano-robots may also help rebuild non-working organs and alter the genetic makeup of offspring. These medical advances may significantly alter families’ values and structures.

As society’s physical health improves and life-spans increase, to what degree will societal expectations for women to conceive early change?

Would you genetically engineer your own children?

What kinds of genetically engineering for their children should parents be allowed to undertake? Why or why not?

Family Values and Structure: Childcare and Care for the Elderly Many other kinds of advances in medicine can be anticipated: drug delivery devices more efficient drugs bloodstream monitors Older individuals will not need to be cared for by families and elderly care professionals. Multiple generations will have the option of living together, and older generations may contribute to childcare. In addition to childcare, what kinds of new family practices can be anticipated in these multi-generational families? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Many other kinds of advances in medicine can be anticipated:

drug delivery devices

more efficient drugs

bloodstream monitors

Older individuals will not need to be cared for by families and elderly care professionals.

Multiple generations will have the option of living together, and older generations may contribute to childcare.

In addition to childcare, what kinds of new family practices can be anticipated in these multi-generational families?

Family Values and Structure: Childcare How will multi-generational households affect our culture? How will such a change in the family structure change relationships between the generations? What will be the benefits of having children learn the languages, stories, and practices of their grandparents’ generation? What kinds of cross-cultural difficulties can grandparents expect to encounter during childcare given quickly shifting cultural values? How will grandparents enforce discipline? What kinds of changes will our society see in family structure and the notion of the ‘primary caregiver’? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

How will multi-generational households affect our culture?

How will such a change in the family structure change relationships between the generations?

What will be the benefits of having children learn the languages, stories, and practices of their grandparents’ generation?

What kinds of cross-cultural difficulties can grandparents expect to encounter during childcare given quickly shifting cultural values? How will grandparents enforce discipline?

What kinds of changes will our society see in family structure and the notion of the ‘primary caregiver’?

Family Values and Structure: Gender roles As labor becomes more intellectual rather than physical, there may be a decreased demand for employees to work outside the home. Many job-related tasks will be performed through home computers. In some ways, the return of labor to the home setting can be seen as similar to pre-industrial economies when agricultural tasks did not require women and men to separate their work in terms of the ‘private’ and ‘public’ domains, respectively. Both women and men worked performed similar kinds of labor. At present, many families have already begun to engage in less traditional forms of labor division because of opportunities for both women and men to work from home. What kinds of gendering of labor can be seen in these households? What kinds of problems and benefits are evident in such family settings? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

As labor becomes more intellectual rather than physical, there may be a decreased demand for employees to work outside the home. Many job-related tasks will be performed through home computers.

In some ways, the return of labor to the home setting can be seen as similar to pre-industrial economies when agricultural tasks did not require women and men to separate their work in terms of the ‘private’ and ‘public’ domains, respectively. Both women and men worked performed similar kinds of labor.

At present, many families have already begun to engage in less traditional forms of labor division because of opportunities for both women and men to work from home.

What kinds of gendering of labor can be seen in these households?

What kinds of problems and benefits are evident in such family settings?

Family Values and Structure: Gender roles As both women and men have increasing opportunities to work from home, many societal values are likely to change. How will our notions of women’s and men’s work change? How will this affect how each gender is valued both in the home and in public settings more generally? Consider these possibilities: In heterosexual households, women in general will have less of an economic dependence on men. Women and men will be equally expected to become a part of the money-earning labor force. Work traditionally deemed for women, such as cooking, cleaning, home-decorating, and childcare, will become part of the expected duties of men. IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

As both women and men have increasing opportunities to work from home, many societal values are likely to change.

How will our notions of women’s and men’s work change?

How will this affect how each gender is valued both in the home and in public settings more generally?

Consider these possibilities:

In heterosexual households, women in general will have less of an economic dependence on men.

Women and men will be equally expected to become a part of the money-earning labor force.

Work traditionally deemed for women, such as cooking, cleaning, home-decorating, and childcare, will become part of the expected duties of men.

Homes: Where We Live? The structure of our future homes will change the way we live our lives both inside and outside our homes.

Homes: Where We Live? New materials developed with nanotechnology will make our walls, windows, and pipes stronger, lighter, and able to withstand the forces of the natural world; they will also reduce the need for maintenance. The ‘handyman’ will be replaced by the ‘tech person’. Walls themselves may be digital displays that allow us to enjoy natural landscapes—according to our mood—without leaving the home. As lightweight structures, they will be sliding units that allow families to easily transform the spaces of the home from small, private spaces to a large, shared studio. Computer work stations will sit in every room, allowing families to work and study together or separately. ‘Going to work’ or ‘going to school’ will involve walking across the room to the nearest work station. For exercise, we will use energy-efficient appliances such as stationary bicycles and treadmills that ‘power up’ dishwashers, washing machines, and compost machines that fertilize our lawns. And in a more distant future, when ‘nano-ovens’ can ‘grow’ our fruits and vegetables and bake the perfect loaf of ciabatta, grocery shopping will be an old-fashioned ritual. A FEW IDEAS ADAPTED FROM “ What Will Our Houses Look Like ?” by architects Wes Jones and Bernard Tschumi, Time.

New materials developed with nanotechnology will make our walls, windows, and pipes stronger, lighter, and able to withstand the forces of the natural world; they will also reduce the need for maintenance. The ‘handyman’ will be replaced by the ‘tech person’.

Walls themselves may be digital displays that allow us to enjoy natural landscapes—according to our mood—without leaving the home. As lightweight structures, they will be sliding units that allow families to easily transform the spaces of the home from small, private spaces to a large, shared studio.

Computer work stations will sit in every room, allowing families to work and study together or separately. ‘Going to work’ or ‘going to school’ will involve walking across the room to the nearest work station.

For exercise, we will use energy-efficient appliances such as stationary bicycles and treadmills that ‘power up’ dishwashers, washing machines, and compost machines that fertilize our lawns.

And in a more distant future, when ‘nano-ovens’ can ‘grow’ our fruits and vegetables and bake the perfect loaf of ciabatta, grocery shopping will be an old-fashioned ritual.

A FEW IDEAS ADAPTED FROM “ What Will Our Houses Look Like ?” by architects Wes Jones and Bernard Tschumi, Time.

Homes: Sense of Community Given that many of these new conveniences will reduce the need to leave the home, how will this affect relations between family members? How will our self-sufficiency change our relationships with our neighbors and others outside the home? In what ways can computer technology help us maintain good relations with our neighbors? How might computers threaten these relations? What are some ways that neighborhoods can maintain a sense of ‘community’? How will our attitudes towards the natural world, such as rain and trees, change as our homes ‘protect’ us from it? Will we become increasingly fearful of its unpredictability? Or will we crave outdoor activities like never before as well as become obsessed with bringing nature, such as plants, indoors? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Given that many of these new conveniences will reduce the need to leave the home, how will this affect relations between family members?

How will our self-sufficiency change our relationships with our neighbors and others outside the home? In what ways can computer technology help us maintain good relations with our neighbors? How might computers threaten these relations?

What are some ways that neighborhoods can maintain a sense of ‘community’?

How will our attitudes towards the natural world, such as rain and trees, change as our homes ‘protect’ us from it? Will we become increasingly fearful of its unpredictability? Or will we crave outdoor activities like never before as well as become obsessed with bringing nature, such as plants, indoors?

Homes: Living in Privacy Nanotechnology will likely increase the number of undetectable surveillance devices as well as centralized and detailed records of our everyday lives—our emails, phone calls, schedules, purchases, and rolodexes. Our sense of privacy may come under threat, as both the government and individuals gain the potential to peer into our intimate spaces. What kinds of limitations should be placed on such surveillance devices? What are the dangers and benefits of having a centralized database that records our everyday lives? How will our notions of ‘public’ and ‘private’ spaces change? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Nanotechnology will likely increase the number of undetectable surveillance devices as well as centralized and detailed records of our everyday lives—our emails, phone calls, schedules, purchases, and rolodexes.

Our sense of privacy may come under threat, as both the government and individuals gain the potential to peer into our intimate spaces.

What kinds of limitations should be placed on such surveillance devices?

What are the dangers and benefits of having a centralized database that records our everyday lives?

How will our notions of ‘public’ and ‘private’ spaces change?

The Economy Return to Table of Contents The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

Industries Nanotechnology may have profound effects on the industrial sector. According to one source, in ten years, 11% of total manufacturing jobs will involve building products that incorporate emerging nanotechnology .( PR Newswire , October 25, 2004) What could be some of the effects for private businesses? For instance: Simplification of supply chains as companies both manufacture materials and assemble products. Increased manufacturing efficiency and reduced costs. = Efficiency Reduced costs Manufacture of materials + Assembly of product Assembly of product Manufacture of materials

Nanotechnology may have profound effects on the industrial sector.

According to one source, in ten years, 11% of total manufacturing jobs will involve building products that incorporate emerging nanotechnology .( PR Newswire , October 25, 2004)

What could be some of the effects for private businesses?

For instance:

Simplification of supply chains as companies both manufacture materials and assemble products.

Increased manufacturing efficiency and reduced costs.

= Efficiency

Reduced costs

Industries As alternative, functional, durable, and inexpensive materials are created, there may be a diminishing need for certain types of materials. Which industries will grow, which will disappear? Some have warned that without regulation, single corporations will be able to monopolize a market sector because of the potential of nanotechnology. How should such a threat be regulated? Wood Coal Cotton ? Materials manufacturing Computers ?

As alternative, functional, durable, and inexpensive materials are created, there may be a diminishing need for certain types of materials.

Which industries will grow, which will disappear?

Some have warned that without regulation, single corporations will be able to monopolize a market sector because of the potential of nanotechnology.

How should such a threat be regulated?

Economic System The economic system of the United States, as well as other industrialized nations, is often described as being capitalist . In other words, trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the government, as in a socialist system. Most nations, however, have in fact a combination of the two kinds of systems. One of the main critiques of capitalism is the exploitation of laborers by the wealthy and the perpetuation of social class inequalities. With the growth of an industry that depends increasingly on intellectual rather than manual labor, how will the nature of the labor class change? What kinds of new power relations between social groups and nations will result? In what ways does nanotechnology solve some of the problems associated with capitalism? mitigating environmental harm through cleaner methods of production leveling the playing field among nations through affordable access to education and basic resources bringing peace because of decreased competition for once scarce resources

The economic system of the United States, as well as other industrialized nations, is often described as being capitalist . In other words, trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the government, as in a socialist system. Most nations, however, have in fact a combination of the two kinds of systems.

One of the main critiques of capitalism is the exploitation of laborers by the wealthy and the perpetuation of social class inequalities.

With the growth of an industry that depends increasingly on intellectual rather than manual labor, how will the nature of the labor class change?

What kinds of new power relations between social groups and nations will result?

In what ways does nanotechnology solve some of the problems associated with capitalism?

mitigating environmental harm through cleaner methods of production

leveling the playing field among nations through affordable access to education and basic resources

bringing peace because of decreased competition for once scarce resources

Will socialism make a comeback? In an essay for Time called “Will Socialism Make a Comeback?” , Francis Fukuyama suggests that socialism in its purest form will never return because of the inherent inefficiency of a central government attempting to regulate a complex market, as well as globalization and information technology allowing citizens to compare their standard of living with those in other countries. Yet “the impulse toward social equality has not disappeared,” he writes. Though governments themselves may not become socialist, societies may depend on nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) to constrain corporations and protect the poor and the environment. Contrary to Fukayama’s argument, to what degree might the increased efficiency of information processing in fact allow central governments to efficiently regulate their market? Given the potential for nations to depend less on other nations because of more widely available resources, how might globalization be affected?

In an essay for Time called “Will Socialism Make a Comeback?” , Francis Fukuyama suggests that socialism in its purest form will never return because of the inherent inefficiency of a central government attempting to regulate a complex market, as well as globalization and information technology allowing citizens to compare their standard of living with those in other countries.

Yet “the impulse toward social equality has not disappeared,” he writes. Though governments themselves may not become socialist, societies may depend on nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) to constrain corporations and protect the poor and the environment.

Contrary to Fukayama’s argument, to what degree might the increased efficiency of information processing in fact allow central governments to efficiently regulate their market?

Given the potential for nations to depend less on other nations because of more widely available resources, how might globalization be affected?

How will international trade be affected as nations become more self-sufficient? Currently, the United States exports the following types of products: agricultural products (soybeans, fruit, corn) 9.2% industrial supplies (organic chemicals) 26.8% capital goods (transistors, aircraft, motor vehicle parts, computers, telecom equipment) 49.0% consumer goods (automobiles, medicines) 15.0% (Source: the CIA World Factbook ) What new goods will wealthier nations, such as the US, export? Which do they have an obligation to export? Consider the following: scientific knowledge sophisticated nano-devices for cleaning the environment medical nano-devices for curing cancer What may be exported by poorer nations? Consider the following: the educated elite may become part of the intellectual labor force of wealthier nations experimental technology banned in the US because of perceived dangers virtual tours of ‘exotic’ locations International Trade

How will international trade be affected as nations become more self-sufficient?

Currently, the United States exports the following types of products:

agricultural products (soybeans, fruit, corn) 9.2%

industrial supplies (organic chemicals) 26.8%

capital goods (transistors, aircraft, motor vehicle parts, computers, telecom equipment) 49.0%

consumer goods (automobiles, medicines) 15.0%

(Source: the CIA World Factbook )

What new goods will wealthier nations, such as the US, export? Which do they have an obligation to export? Consider the following:

scientific knowledge

sophisticated nano-devices for cleaning the environment

medical nano-devices for curing cancer

What may be exported by poorer nations? Consider the following:

the educated elite may become part of the intellectual labor force of wealthier nations

experimental technology banned in the US because of perceived dangers

virtual tours of ‘exotic’ locations

Costs for Consumers What kinds products and services will become less expensive? medical treatment computers energy resources what else? What kinds of products and services will become more expensive? In other words, what will be high in demand yet scarce in availability? Should the cost of products and services be determined by the market or a central system of regulation? € $ ₣ ₤ ₩

What kinds products and services will become less expensive?

medical treatment

computers

energy resources

what else?

What kinds of products and services will become more expensive? In other words, what will be high in demand yet scarce in availability?

Should the cost of products and services be determined by the market or a central system of regulation?

Unemployment Nanorobots and nanotechnological devices may eventually and efficiently perform much of the labor currently performed by humans. health checkups by nano-nurses, surgery by nano-doctors house-painting by smart-paints home ‘agriculture’ by nano-ovens teaching by powerful human-like robots or computers Which segments of society will become suddenly unemployed? What kind of system can prevent undue hardship to these groups? What has worked in the past as our society has shifted its labor needs?

Nanorobots and nanotechnological devices may eventually and efficiently perform much of the labor currently performed by humans.

health checkups by nano-nurses, surgery by nano-doctors

house-painting by smart-paints

home ‘agriculture’ by nano-ovens

teaching by powerful human-like robots or computers

Which segments of society will become suddenly unemployed?

What kind of system can prevent undue hardship to these groups?

What has worked in the past as our society has shifted its labor needs?

Gender Women are underrepresented in the technology-oriented sector of the labor force. 1 out of 10 employed engineers is a woman 2 out of 10 employed engineering technologists and technicians are women 3 out of 10 computer systems analysts, engineers, and scientists are women 1 out of 4 computer programmers is a woman Technology-oriented occupations are projected to increase significantly in the future, but it is unclear whether this is good or bad news for women who wish to earn an income. Why is it important for women to have a visible presence in the technology sector? In what ways does today’s technology reflect the interests of male consumers? In what ways does the pursuit of a career in ‘high technology’, including nanotechnology, clash with the lifestyle expectations of women? What can we do to prevent greater gender imbalance? (Facts from the Department of Labor’s website)

Women are underrepresented in the technology-oriented sector of the labor force.

1 out of 10

employed engineers is a woman

2 out of 10

employed engineering technologists and technicians are women

3 out of 10

computer systems analysts, engineers, and scientists are women

1 out of 4

computer programmers is a woman

Technology-oriented occupations are projected to increase significantly in the future, but it is unclear whether this is good or bad news for women who wish to earn an income.

Why is it important for women to have a visible presence in the technology sector?

In what ways does today’s technology reflect the interests of male consumers?

In what ways does the pursuit of a career in ‘high technology’, including nanotechnology, clash with the lifestyle expectations of women?

What can we do to prevent greater gender imbalance?

(Facts from the Department of Labor’s website)

Global Politics Return to Table of Contents The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

Violence and Social Unrest Social unrest often results from disenfranchisement which often leads to a sense of desperation. For instance, events in the US such as the Watts riots of 1965 and the LA riots of 1992 as well as nationwide civil rights riots in 1968 were the result of race-based political and economic inequity primarily between whites and African Americans. (The copyright holder allows anyone to use this image for any purpose.) Rioters in Barcelona, Spain

Social unrest often results from disenfranchisement which often leads to a sense of desperation.

For instance, events in the US such as the Watts riots of 1965 and the LA riots of 1992 as well as nationwide civil rights riots in 1968 were the result of race-based political and economic inequity primarily between whites and African Americans.

Violent conflict, while often rationalized and understood as based on racial, ethnic, religious, ethical, or philosophical differences, often has an economic dimension. For instance, violence often erupts between groups competing for scarce resources, as some theorists regard as part of the cause of the Hutu and Tutsi genocide of 1994 in the Central African nation of Rwanda. Even wealthy nations are involved in violent conflict related to economic struggle. For instance, the current war in Iraq is understood by some as related to the maintenance of US dominance in the international oil market. War and Economics

Violent conflict, while often rationalized and understood as based on racial, ethnic, religious, ethical, or philosophical differences, often has an economic dimension.

For instance, violence often erupts between groups competing for scarce resources, as some theorists regard as part of the cause of the Hutu and Tutsi genocide of 1994 in the Central African nation of Rwanda.

Even wealthy nations are involved in violent conflict related to economic struggle. For instance, the current war in Iraq is understood by some as related to the maintenance of US dominance in the international oil market.

Abundant Resources With the reduction of poverty and the abundance of resources, local and global unrest is less likely. As a result of nanotechnology, impoverished nations may come to have greater access to resources that wealthier nations may take for granted, such as clean water, abundant food, electricity, and medicine as well as internet access and climate-controlled shelters. Nanotechnology, which will help provide devices and vehicles and homes that efficiently run on alternative sources of energy, such as solar energy, will reduce the need for oil in industrialized nations. How will US relations with nations in the Middle East be affected? What will happen to the political power of nations such as the US which will lead the nanotechnology revolution? What will be some other political consequences?

With the reduction of poverty and the abundance of resources, local and global unrest is less likely.

As a result of nanotechnology, impoverished nations may come to have greater access to resources that wealthier nations may take for granted, such as clean water, abundant food, electricity, and medicine as well as internet access and climate-controlled shelters.

Nanotechnology, which will help provide devices and vehicles and homes that efficiently run on alternative sources of energy, such as solar energy, will reduce the need for oil in industrialized nations.

How will US relations with nations in the Middle East be affected?

What will happen to the political power of nations such as the US which will lead the nanotechnology revolution?

What will be some other political consequences?

Military Nanotechnology has implications as well for military units that become directly involved in international conflict situations. Through the National Nanotechnology Initiative, the US Department of Defense invested $50 million for a new Institute for Soldier Nanotechnologies at M.I.T. in May 2003. This institute will develop lighter and strong clothing and equipment for the Army, such as armor that softens and hardens on command and clothing the stores and recycles energy. SOURCE: Kieper, Adam. 2003. The Nanotechnology Revolution. The New Atlantis , 2: 17-34. How will the nature of war change with better-equipped foot-soldiers? How have conflicts become better or worse given current technological tools used by soldiers?

Nanotechnology has implications as well for military units that become directly involved in international conflict situations.

Through the National Nanotechnology Initiative, the US Department of Defense invested $50 million for a new Institute for Soldier Nanotechnologies at M.I.T. in May 2003. This institute will develop lighter and strong clothing and equipment for the Army, such as armor that softens and hardens on command and clothing the stores and recycles energy.

SOURCE: Kieper, Adam. 2003. The Nanotechnology Revolution. The New Atlantis , 2: 17-34.

How will the nature of war change with better-equipped foot-soldiers?

How have conflicts become better or worse given current technological tools used by soldiers?

“ Weapons of mass destruction” might also be develop, given the possibilty for molecular structures to self-replicate using nanotechnology, according to some scientists. In addition, nanotechnology could be used to both aid the manufacture of conventional dangerously lethal bioweapons. SOURCE: Kieper, Adam. 2003. The Nanotechnology Revolution. The New Atlantis , 2: 17-34. In some ways, nanotechnology might be likened to nuclear technology, which has immense potential as an affordable source of energy while also presenting the threat of large-scale destruction whether via accident or intention. Some have cited the potential for global domination by countries that have access to nanotechnological weapons. Weapons development may also become an attractive industry to some poorer countries seeking both economic capital and political leverage. Weapons

“ Weapons of mass destruction” might also be develop, given the possibilty for molecular structures to self-replicate using nanotechnology, according to some scientists. In addition, nanotechnology could be used to both aid the manufacture of conventional dangerously lethal bioweapons.

SOURCE: Kieper, Adam. 2003. The Nanotechnology Revolution. The New Atlantis , 2: 17-34.

In some ways, nanotechnology might be likened to nuclear technology, which has immense potential as an affordable source of energy while also presenting the threat of large-scale destruction whether via accident or intention.

Some have cited the potential for global domination by countries that have access to nanotechnological weapons.

Weapons development may also become an attractive industry to some poorer countries seeking both economic capital and political leverage.

What have been some successful ways of regulating the development of weapons? How can we realistically police and regulate the development of nanotechnology on a global scale without infringing on human rights? To what extent will the world become a safer place because of nanotechnology and to what extent will it become more dangerous? Regulation

What have been some successful ways of regulating the development of weapons?

How can we realistically police and regulate the development of nanotechnology on a global scale without infringing on human rights?

To what extent will the world become a safer place because of nanotechnology and to what extent will it become more dangerous?

Unequal Distribution Though resources may become both more accessible in general, equally distributing them among nations and communities will be a challenge. Consider how access to both computers and the Internet is not equal across communities and nations, a phenomenon sometimes referred to as the “digital divide.” Given that technology such as digital tools can further advance the economic status of a community and given that such tools are most accessible to wealthier communities, the wealthiest will have the greatest access to means of further wealth production.

Though resources may become both more accessible in general, equally distributing them among nations and communities will be a challenge.

Consider how access to both computers and the Internet is not equal across communities and nations, a phenomenon sometimes referred to as the “digital divide.”

Given that technology such as digital tools can further advance the economic status of a community and given that such tools are most accessible to wealthier communities, the wealthiest will have the greatest access to means of further wealth production.

Unequal Distribution What are some of the ways in which we can prevent a further widening of economic differences between communities as a result of nanotechnological developments? To what extent can we expect wealth to “trickle down” from wealthier to poorer communities and nations?

What are some of the ways in which we can prevent a further widening of economic differences between communities as a result of nanotechnological developments?

To what extent can we expect wealth to “trickle down” from wealthier to poorer communities and nations?

In addition to international treaties and economic cooperation, one of the ways to sustain peaceful relations may be to promote greater cross-cultural understanding. Nanotechnological tools, such as efficient and inexpensive computers and transportation may provide greater opportunities for communication across national borders. And such communication will continue the trend towards a globalized economy. In the past, however, cultural contact has not always led to greater understanding. For instance, economic relations framed as ‘cooperation’, such as the use of labor in non-industrialized nations by corporations in industrialized nations, has sometimes been perceived as exploitation. And the flow of cultural products and ideas, while often influencing youth and class style, has not always been welcomed by all segments of a nation’s population. Cross-Cultural Understanding

In addition to international treaties and economic cooperation, one of the ways to sustain peaceful relations may be to promote greater cross-cultural understanding.

Nanotechnological tools, such as efficient and inexpensive computers and transportation may provide greater opportunities for communication across national borders. And such communication will continue the trend towards a globalized economy.

In the past, however, cultural contact has not always led to greater understanding.

For instance, economic relations framed as ‘cooperation’, such as the use of labor in non-industrialized nations by corporations in industrialized nations, has sometimes been perceived as exploitation. And the flow of cultural products and ideas, while often influencing youth and class style, has not always been welcomed by all segments of a nation’s population.

Cross-Cultural Understanding What will be the global effects of cross-cultural communication and worldwide access to education and information? What kinds of cultural understandings and misunderstandings may result? To what degree can we expect our cultural ideals to be adopted by other cultures? And to what degree are we willing to accept other kinds of cultural ideals? What kinds of resentment may result among members of poorer nations for whom economic disparities become starkly apparent through increased communication? How can nanotechnology be used to increase understanding among wealthier nations of the difficulties of relatively poor ones?

What will be the global effects of cross-cultural communication and worldwide access to education and information?

What kinds of cultural understandings and misunderstandings may result?

To what degree can we expect our cultural ideals to be adopted by other cultures? And to what degree are we willing to accept other kinds of cultural ideals?

What kinds of resentment may result among members of poorer nations for whom economic disparities become starkly apparent through increased communication?

How can nanotechnology be used to increase understanding among wealthier nations of the difficulties of relatively poor ones?

Cross-Cultural Issues The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

Boundaries Which boundaries will disappear and which will newly arise? To what degree do you think groups will seek to reinforce boundaries? culture x culture y New technologies will facilitate greater communication with groups from other geographical locations. We may witness an increasing movement of cultural ideas across boundaries as we are seeing currently with rap music, clothing styles, and technology. What could “local” and “global” mean in terms of cultural practices? How might this exchange of ideas, practices, and forms result in new ways of thinking about cultural ownership, appropriations, or borrowing?

Which boundaries will disappear and which will newly arise?

To what degree do you think groups will seek to reinforce boundaries?

What could “local” and “global” mean in terms of cultural practices?

How might this exchange of ideas, practices, and forms result in new ways of thinking about cultural ownership, appropriations, or borrowing?

There will be potential improvements in quality of life for many countries. clean water for drinking and agriculture disease prevention medicine and advanced medical equipment food grown in greenhouses inexpensive computers solar-generated power efficient energy storage devices Cultural Appropriateness How can we be sensitive to the cultural impacts these technologies will have and how local institutions might be altered? What can we do to minimize disruptive effects to people and families?

There will be potential improvements in quality of life for many countries.

clean water for drinking and agriculture

disease prevention

medicine and advanced medical equipment

food grown in greenhouses

inexpensive computers

solar-generated power

efficient energy storage devices

How can we be sensitive to the cultural impacts these technologies will have and how local institutions might be altered?

What can we do to minimize disruptive effects to people and families?

Cultural Relativity How can a global system of regulation be instituted or at least recommended? The world’s cultures and institutions will interpret uses of nanotechnology differently and may install varying kinds of technology for restricting or maintaining personal freedoms.

How can a global system of regulation be instituted or at least recommended?

Developments in medicine will likely result in increased lifespans and thus an increase in population. Population How can we prepare for population growth as each of the following areas is affected? resources education jobs culture

Developments in medicine will likely result in increased lifespans and thus an increase in population.

How can we prepare for population growth as each of the following areas is affected?

resources

education

jobs

culture

Global environment Some argue that nanotechnology promises a far cleaner global environment, as many “clean” energy and manufacturing alternatives (e.g. solar energy) are developed, and harmful materials may even be transformed into environmentally-safe ones. Imagine the effects on the global ecology of filters that kill bacteria and insects and devices that release nanoparticles into the environment. Clean rivers and streams safe for drinking, fishing, and swimming Clean air even in large urban areas What will happen to an ecosystem that kills ‘good’ bacteria, such as acidophilus? How will our immune systems cope with the lack of bacteria and viruses that our bodies have built up a resistance to? Given our temptation to exterminate ‘annoying’ insects, how can we differentiate between those that are central and peripheral to the ecosystem?

Some argue that nanotechnology promises a far cleaner global environment, as many “clean” energy and manufacturing alternatives (e.g. solar energy) are developed, and harmful materials may even be transformed into environmentally-safe ones.

Imagine the effects on the global ecology of filters that kill bacteria and insects and devices that release nanoparticles into the environment.

Clean rivers and streams safe for drinking, fishing, and swimming

Clean air even in large urban areas

What will happen to an ecosystem that kills ‘good’ bacteria, such as acidophilus?

How will our immune systems cope with the lack of bacteria and viruses that our bodies have built up a resistance to?

Given our temptation to exterminate ‘annoying’ insects, how can we differentiate between those that are central and peripheral to the ecosystem?

Cultural Meanings and Social Values Return to Table of Contents The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

The Body IMAGE SOURCE: http://www.time.com/time/reports/v21/health/body.html It may become possible for individuals to completely alter their physical appearances either through cosmetic surgery performed by nanorobots or changes in genetic sequences on chromosomes. However, altering one’s physical appearance is not new to our society. For example, body-building, tanning, dieting, tooth-whitening, wearing braces, and wearing color contact lenses can be seen as examples of altering one’s physical appearance. In addition, recently popularized television shows featuring “extreme makeovers” suggest a growing acceptance of cosmetic surgical procedures.

The Body How will notions of boundaries between social identities, such as races and genders, change as genetic and physical modifications become easier? Will our present conception of “identity” depend less on physical characteristics, such as skin color and facial hair, and more on other kinds of characteristics, such as language and clothing? Where should the line be drawn between ‘necessary’ and ‘unnecessary’ procedures? Would you transform your body? IMAGE SOURCE: http://www.time.com/time/reports/v21/health/body.html

How will notions of boundaries between social identities, such as races and genders, change as genetic and physical modifications become easier?

Will our present conception of “identity” depend less on physical characteristics, such as skin color and facial hair, and more on other kinds of characteristics, such as language and clothing?

Where should the line be drawn between ‘necessary’ and ‘unnecessary’ procedures?

Would you transform your body?

Beauty How will this affect attention to physical beauty by both women and men? If everyone has the potential to be ‘flawless’, what will this mean? Will society stop tolerating physical changes that are part of the natural aging process? Or will ‘natural flaws’ come to be something that is aesthetically valued, much as ‘torn’ and ‘faded’ jeans are currently valued? “ Nano Hydrene Complex” for men (U.S.) http://www.studio5ive.com/HTML/mens-eye-serum.htm “ Neosino” for women (Italy) Silicon (silica) Dioxide in the shape of Nanoparticles http:// www.neosino.com/eng/neosino.html A “Nano Imagery” advertisement (Japan) explains how nanoparticles penetrate the skin http://www.rakuten.co.jp/adept/460553/507119/569782/ Many new products may increase expectations of ‘flawless’ skin.

How will this affect attention to physical beauty by both women and men?

If everyone has the potential to be ‘flawless’, what will this mean? Will society stop tolerating physical changes that are part of the natural aging process? Or will ‘natural flaws’ come to be something that is aesthetically valued, much as ‘torn’ and ‘faded’ jeans are currently valued?

Redefining the Normal Nano-devices that allow individuals to 'fix' physical characteristics deemed fixable by society will affect particular communities that may be seen as non-normative. The use of technology to 'fix' characteristics is now new, however, often resulting from and contributing to the valuing of certain types of physical and cultural characteristics over others. In the Deaf community, for instance, the use of cochlear implants that allow Deaf individuals to hear has resulted in a societal view of Deafness as a 'problem' that can be 'fixed.‘ IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Redefining the Normal Nano-devices that allow individuals to 'fix' physical characteristics deemed fixable by society will affect particular communities that may be seen as non-normative. The use of technology to 'fix' characteristics is now new, however, often resulting from and contributing to the valuing of certain types of physical and cultural characteristics over others. It is also not uncommon for East Asian women to surgically create a ‘double eyelid’, which some view as associated with beauty standards defined by those of European descent. IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Redefining the Normal Nano-devices that allow individuals to 'fix' physical characteristics deemed fixable by society will affect particular communities that may be seen as non-normative. The use of technology to 'fix' characteristics is now new, however, often resulting from and contributing to the valuing of certain types of physical and cultural characteristics over others. Women in the US also sometimes receive breast implants to achieve what may be regarded as a more ‘feminine’ figure. IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

Redefining the Normal How will the meaning of these concepts evolve and should we encourage them to evolve? RACE and GENDER: What will ‘race’ and ‘gender’ mean if racial and gender boundaries can be easily crossed through surgical procedures assisted by nanorobots and the altering of genetic structures? DISABILITY: How will 'disability' be redefined with devices that can enable sight and other 'normal' functions? DISEASE: What will 'disease' mean as many psychological and physiological diseases are ‘cured’? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

How will the meaning of these concepts evolve and should we encourage them to evolve?

RACE and GENDER: What will ‘race’ and ‘gender’ mean if racial and gender boundaries can be easily crossed through surgical procedures assisted by nanorobots and the altering of genetic structures?

DISABILITY: How will 'disability' be redefined with devices that can enable sight and other 'normal' functions?

DISEASE: What will 'disease' mean as many psychological and physiological diseases are ‘cured’?

Redefining the Normal What kinds of aesthetic norms and desires will evolve? Will we develop a culture of extreme sensitivity to 'defects' and 'sanitary' living? Or will such concepts become irrelevant as humans become increasingly ‘flawless’ and live in a ‘perfect’ environment? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

What kinds of aesthetic norms and desires will evolve?

Will we develop a culture of extreme sensitivity to 'defects' and 'sanitary' living? Or will such concepts become irrelevant as humans become increasingly ‘flawless’ and live in a ‘perfect’ environment?

Redefining the Normal What are the processes that create social hierarchies? On the one hand, the valuing of particular kinds of skin colors, eye shapes, and physiques can be thought to be arbitrary and culturally specific; no skin color is inherently better than any other. On the other hand, beliefs about beauty are not so arbitrary , given the they are linked to specific hierarchies of power between social groups. IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

What are the processes that create social hierarchies?

On the one hand, the valuing of particular kinds of skin colors, eye shapes, and physiques can be thought to be arbitrary and culturally specific; no skin color is inherently better than any other.

On the other hand, beliefs about beauty are not so arbitrary , given the they are linked to specific hierarchies of power between social groups.

Redefining the Normal What kinds of new hierarchies might develop? Will those with ‘natural’ features be more highly valued just as ‘natural blonds’ are in some segments of today’s society? Will aesthetic beauty become an irrelevant social value given that anyone can achieve it? How could we as a society better value equality? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

What kinds of new hierarchies might develop?

Will those with ‘natural’ features be more highly valued just as ‘natural blonds’ are in some segments of today’s society?

Will aesthetic beauty become an irrelevant social value given that anyone can achieve it?

How could we as a society better value equality?

Age How will our conception of aging change? What will our attitudes be towards the older generation? Will ageism disappear given that the elderly will be able to maintain good health? Will society increasingly discriminate against the elderly who cannot maintain good health? What will be the meaning of being a ‘youth’ as a greater number of life-stages results? What new ways will there be to identify generational differences? For example: Younger generations may be distinguished by physical characteristics, such as greater height or straighter teeth. As physiological condition and appearance may not be correlate with age, we may come to depend on other kinds of markers, such as language style, clothing, and cultural tastes. How will the federal system of Social Security need to be altered to accommodate longer lives? When should workers be able to retire and receive Social Security benefits? Who will decide who gets to live longer—that is, whose life is worth extending? IMAGE SOURCE: Art Parts Aging Nanotechnological developments may enable longer life-spans because of the improved physical health of the older generation.

How will our conception of aging change?

What will our attitudes be towards the older generation?

Will ageism disappear given that the elderly will be able to maintain good health?

Will society increasingly discriminate against the elderly who cannot maintain good health?

What will be the meaning of being a ‘youth’ as a greater number of life-stages results?

What new ways will there be to identify generational differences?

For example:

Younger generations may be distinguished by physical characteristics, such as greater height or straighter teeth.

As physiological condition and appearance may not be correlate with age, we may come to depend on other kinds of markers, such as language style, clothing, and cultural tastes.

How will the federal system of Social Security need to be altered to accommodate longer lives? When should workers be able to retire and receive Social Security benefits?

Who will decide who gets to live longer—that is, whose life is worth extending?

Value of Labor How will this change, for example, the ways in which children are educated and prepared for the adult world? How would you prepare your children? What will be the value of physical strength? Will physical strength be seen as a primitive goal of the past? Will it become highly valued because of its rarity? Will we be spending more time in the gym because of the increasing value of maintaining good health? Will physical strength become highly desired despite its direct ‘functional’ value? Note that some of today’s affluent communities emphasize physical health despite its lack of necessity for performing daily labor. The nantechnological revolution is predicted to place greater value on intellectual rather than physical labor, since nanobots will be able perform the latter. IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

How will this change, for example, the ways in which children are educated and prepared for the adult world?

How would you prepare your children?

What will be the value of physical strength?

Will physical strength be seen as a primitive goal of the past?

Will it become highly valued because of its rarity?

Will we be spending more time in the gym because of the increasing value of maintaining good health?

Will physical strength become highly desired despite its direct ‘functional’ value?

Note that some of today’s affluent communities emphasize physical health despite its lack of necessity for performing daily labor.

Risky Behavior How will society’s norms of behavior change? What will our society’s new risky behaviors be? With significant advances in medicine, individuals may no longer have fears of behaviors previously thought to be ‘risky’. For example, venereal diseases may be more easily cured and physical damage made more manageable. On the other hand, society’s new emphasis on physical ‘perfection’ may result in a culture of paranoia. IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

How will society’s norms of behavior change?

What will our society’s new risky behaviors be?

Illness What will become our society’s greatest health problems? All cultures across time and space have illnesses, both physical or psychological. With nanotechnology’s contribution to medicine, today’s illnesses, such as cancer, AIDS, and depression, may be easily cured. IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

What will become our society’s greatest health problems?

Value of Material Goods What will a diamond ring mean once it can easily be created by reassembling atoms? How will the virtue of ‘being frugal’ change as resources, such as electricity, water, and air cooling chips, become abundant and easily affordable? What new kinds of material desires will emerge as today’s relatively ‘expensive’ products, such as air conditioners, refrigerators, computers, and cars become commonplace, and individuals are left with extra money to spend? How will the economic market’s relative valuing of the functionality of a product change? To what degree will ‘less functional’ characteristics, such as aesthetics become increasingly valued? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart

What will a diamond ring mean once it can easily be created by reassembling atoms?

How will the virtue of ‘being frugal’ change as resources, such as electricity, water, and air cooling chips, become abundant and easily affordable?

What new kinds of material desires will emerge as today’s relatively ‘expensive’ products, such as air conditioners, refrigerators, computers, and cars become commonplace, and individuals are left with extra money to spend?

How will the economic market’s relative valuing of the functionality of a product change? To what degree will ‘less functional’ characteristics, such as aesthetics become increasingly valued?

Morality What kind of moral debates will arise with new nano-devices that. . . stimulate the brain like a psychoactive drug provide sexual pleasure alter the body with ease change the genetic coding of our future children Who should be allowed to use them? Who should determine the regulation of these devices? the public academics judges individuals congress

What kind of moral debates will arise with new nano-devices that. . .

stimulate the brain like a psychoactive drug

provide sexual pleasure

alter the body with ease

change the genetic coding of our future children

Who should be allowed to use them?

Who should determine the regulation of these devices?

the public

The efficiency of computers as well as the application of nanotechnology to genetic engineering and testing will allow us to receive and store comprehensive medical information. Which illnesses would you want to know that you are predisposed to having? What kinds of information about health and genetic predisposition should be accessible? To individuals? To families? To potential partners? To the public? How can we guarantee that such information is protected? Too Much Information?

The efficiency of computers as well as the application of nanotechnology to genetic engineering and testing will allow us to receive and store comprehensive medical information.

Which illnesses would you want to know that you are predisposed to having?

What kinds of information about health and genetic predisposition should be accessible? To individuals? To families? To potential partners? To the public?

How can we guarantee that such information is protected?

Creationism Genetic researchers already have the technology to clone DNA, animals, and human embryos. Nanotechnology may allow geneticists to more precisely manipulate encode genetic information, allowing them to create specific kinds of plants and animals, including humans. What are some of the dangers of such research? Which segments of society will accept or reject it? In addition, some people liken the creation of self-replicating molecular structures to the creation of life. How are such structures like and unlike living creatures? How will these discoveries have an impact on religious beliefs, such as the 'meaning of life' and who 'God' is? What will 'consciousness' mean if our thoughts become 'downloadable' onto a computer?

Genetic researchers already have the technology to clone DNA, animals, and human embryos. Nanotechnology may allow geneticists to more precisely manipulate encode genetic information, allowing them to create specific kinds of plants and animals, including humans.

What are some of the dangers of such research?

Which segments of society will accept or reject it?

In addition, some people liken the creation of self-replicating molecular structures to the creation of life.

How are such structures like and unlike living creatures?

How will these discoveries have an impact on religious beliefs, such as the 'meaning of life' and who 'God' is?

What will 'consciousness' mean if our thoughts become 'downloadable' onto a computer?

Evolution With the possibility of changing genetic material, and creating ‘desirable’ genetic mutations, altered species (including humans) may ‘evolve’ relatively quickly. What are the dangers and benefits of allowing societal values determine which particular genes survive? What kinds of implications does this have for our understanding of gender, ethnicity, and sexuality? Which genes will be seen as desirable? What will ‘blood lineage’ come to mean? What will our gender and ethnic landscape look like? How should such research be regulated?

With the possibility of changing genetic material, and creating ‘desirable’ genetic mutations, altered species (including humans) may ‘evolve’ relatively quickly.

What are the dangers and benefits of allowing societal values determine which particular genes survive?

What kinds of implications does this have for our understanding of gender, ethnicity, and sexuality?

Which genes will be seen as desirable?

What will ‘blood lineage’ come to mean?

What will our gender and ethnic landscape look like?

How should such research be regulated?

Intention and Emotion We may develop means of detecting precise human movements (eye movement, pulse, blood pressure) and chemical changes in the brain using nano-devices embedded in the body. Nanotechnology may be used to ‘read’ the psychological state of the body. How will our understanding of intention change? Should individuals be punished for crimes they intended but never carried out? Consider how we often hide our emotions to maintain harmony and save face. How will human relationships change as both positive and negative emotions become perceptible to others? How might the potential for ‘readings’ by others change our brains and the way we control our emotions? How can we guarantee that we preserve some sense of emotional privacy?

We may develop means of detecting precise human movements (eye movement, pulse, blood pressure) and chemical changes in the brain using nano-devices embedded in the body. Nanotechnology may be used to ‘read’ the psychological state of the body.

How will our understanding of intention change? Should individuals be punished for crimes they intended but never carried out?

Consider how we often hide our emotions to maintain harmony and save face. How will human relationships change as both positive and negative emotions become perceptible to others?

How might the potential for ‘readings’ by others change our brains and the way we control our emotions?

How can we guarantee that we preserve some sense of emotional privacy?

Some, such as technology critic Jacques Ellul, argue that the rise of technology leads to the decline of traditional spirituality, as we begin to view technology itself as sacred. In a recent article on the nanotechnology revolution, Adam Kieper compares the “assembler breakthrough” to a “Second Coming or a Judgment Day” and likens cryonics, in which humans are preserved, to an afterlife. SOURCE: Kieper, Adam. 2003. The Nanotechnology Revolution. The New Atlantis , 2: 17-34 . Consider, however, that technology can aid the growth of religious belief such as use of the internet to spread religious messages (e.g., podcasts of sermons) In addition, technology can help us connect with other human beings, through emails and webcam meetings, and help give individuals a sense of belonging and purpose. Finally, while some forms of technology have destroyed much of the natural world, nanotechnology may have the potential to help restore it. Technology and Spirituality

Some, such as technology critic Jacques Ellul, argue that the rise of technology leads to the decline of traditional spirituality, as we begin to view technology itself as sacred. In a recent article on the nanotechnology revolution, Adam Kieper compares the “assembler breakthrough” to a “Second Coming or a Judgment Day” and likens cryonics, in which humans are preserved, to an afterlife.

SOURCE: Kieper, Adam. 2003. The Nanotechnology Revolution. The New Atlantis , 2: 17-34 .

Consider, however, that technology can aid the growth of religious belief such as use of the internet to spread religious messages (e.g., podcasts of sermons)

In addition, technology can help us connect with other human beings, through emails and webcam meetings, and help give individuals a sense of belonging and purpose.

Finally, while some forms of technology have destroyed much of the natural world, nanotechnology may have the potential to help restore it.

Philosophy Humans will depend increasingly on machines, such as computers, prosthetic body parts, climate-sensitive clothing, for their daily survival. Some ‘natural’ products, such as ‘fresh’ vegetables and water will be manufactured by human-made devices. To what degree will certain distinctions we may assume become blurred? the human-machine distinction the nature-artifact distinction To what degree have these distinctions already become blurred?

To what degree will certain distinctions we may assume become blurred?

the human-machine distinction

the nature-artifact distinction

To what degree have these distinctions already become blurred?

History and Epistemology How will the way we pass down ‘history’ change? What will it mean to ‘know’ things? IMAGE SOURCE: Microsoft clipart Given increased life-spans, we will encounter many people who were direct witnesses to historical events. We may also be able to learn from virtual experiences via computers or even through the alteration of our neural structures.

How will the way we pass down ‘history’ change?

What will it mean to ‘know’ things?

Cultural Practice Return to Table of Contents The research for this project is funded by a grant to Elizabeth Keating from Information Technology Services (ITS) at the University of Texas at Austin. Modules created by Elaine Chun.

Old and New Rapid societal change often results in a revaluing of cultural practices, as older cultural practices become ‘out-dated’ yet viewed as ‘authentic’. Writing letters on real paper Family reunions that require traveling Growing vegetables in a garden Preparing dishes from a recipe Desktop computers Clothing that needed washing and ironing Glasses that were worn on the face Cars that used gasoline What kinds of cultural artifacts will fill our museums? Which of these artifacts will become ‘retro’ fashion fads? Which particular kinds of practices will be valued because of how they represent ‘old society’ before the nanotechnological revolution?

Rapid societal change often results in a revaluing of cultural practices, as older cultural practices become ‘out-dated’ yet viewed as ‘authentic’.

Writing letters on real paper

Family reunions that require traveling

Growing vegetables in a garden

Preparing dishes from a recipe

Desktop computers

Clothing that needed washing and ironing

Glasses that were worn on the face

Cars that used gasoline

What kinds of cultural artifacts will fill our museums?

Which of these artifacts will become ‘retro’ fashion fads?

Which particular kinds of practices will be valued because of how they represent ‘old society’ before the nanotechnological revolution?

Class Distinctions Nanotechnological developments will eventually affect most segments of society as well as make various kinds of cultural practices accessible to all. For example, opportunities for travel will increase as aircrafts become faster and cheaper. food language clothing music table manners hobbies cars What kinds of new cultural practices will arise in the following areas? Which will be used to create distinctions between social classes?

Nanotechnological developments will eventually affect most segments of society as well as make various kinds of cultural practices accessible to all. For example, opportunities for travel will increase as aircrafts become faster and cheaper.

What kinds of new cultural practices will arise in the following areas? Which will be used to create distinctions between social classes?

Some of the value of today’s foods is placed on the inaccessibility of particular food types and flavors—e.g., wines from a specific province, vegetables grown in specific climates, fish caught in certain types of water. Nanotechnology may allow us to not only preserve the freshness of food items but also ‘manufacture’ food that has the ‘perfect’ flavor through the manipulation of its molecular structure. Food IMAGE SOURCE: http://www.pics4learning.com/details.php?img=adobe071.jpg How will the value of foods change? As ‘perfect’ food items become available, will ‘imperfect’ food grown in soil become rare and desirable items? Or will we not tolerate any blemishes? Could consumers yearn for a nostalgic past when food was once imperfect? Would food assembled by nanotechnological means be purposefully given ‘imperfections’ to simulate ‘old-fashioned’ techniques of agriculture?

Some of the value of today’s foods is placed on the inaccessibility of particular food types and flavors—e.g., wines from a specific province, vegetables grown in specific climates, fish caught in certain types of water.

Nanotechnology may allow us to not only preserve the freshness of food items but also ‘manufacture’ food that has the ‘perfect’ flavor through the manipulation of its molecular structure.

How will the value of foods change?

As ‘perfect’ food items become available, will ‘imperfect’ food grown in soil become rare and desirable items? Or will we not tolerate any blemishes?

Could consumers yearn for a nostalgic past when food was once imperfect? Would food assembled by nanotechnological means be purposefully given ‘imperfections’ to simulate ‘old-fashioned’ techniques of agriculture?

Food and Class Some possibilities: An international culinary board of expert food critics. Vote by internet The government As all kinds of foods become quickly available, what kinds of foods will be sold in fast food restaurants? Which segments of society will control which flavors are 'authentic,' 'pure,' or 'delicious'? McSushi and fries? Could Saturday Night Live ’s parody in the mid 1980s of a McDonald’s advertisement become reality? IMAGE SOURCE: http:// www.replica.co.uk/images/catpages/sushi.htm

Some possibilities:

An international culinary board of expert food critics.

Vote by internet

The government

As all kinds of foods become quickly available, what kinds of foods will be sold in fast food restaurants?

Which segments of society will control which flavors are 'authentic,' 'pure,' or 'delicious'?

Language Change You say tomayto, I say tomahto. What will we say tomorrow? Linguists have shown that language change is natural. The figure below illustrates the ways in which vowel sounds changed during the transition from Middle to Modern English. What will be the consequence of increased cross-cultural contact made possible by efficient and inexpensive computers and modes of transportation? How will our language change? As the average lifespan increases, what will be the linguistic consequence of the coexistence of different generations of speakers? What kinds of community factors will prevent language from changing? Technological means of rigorously enforcing linguistic norms The formation of official language academies, such as the presently existing L’Académie française, that attempt to enforce ‘correct’ ways of speaking.

What will be the consequence of increased cross-cultural contact made possible by efficient and inexpensive computers and modes of transportation? How will our language change?

As the average lifespan increases, what will be the linguistic consequence of the coexistence of different generations of speakers?

What kinds of community factors will prevent language from changing?

Technological means of rigorously enforcing linguistic norms

The formation of official language academies, such as the presently existing L’Académie française, that attempt to enforce ‘correct’ ways of speaking.

Language Change Dialectologists have shown that dialects often develop when barriers between communities exist, whether such barriers are geographical (mountains or rivers) or social (ethnicity-based communities). As communities are allowed to become self-sufficient through technological advances, new dialects may emerge. On the other hand, many kinds of social boundaries may be ‘erased’ via technologies that allow communication across borders. As history has shown, cross-cultural exchanges have resulted in various kinds of new language practices. For example. . .

Dialect Leveling Dialects can merge with one another, a process known as ‘dialect leveling’. Such a process occurred as American English speakers moved westward after the American Revolution, resulting in fewer dialectal differences in the midwestern and western areas as compared to the eastern parts of the US.

Hybrid Languages Languages can be mixed and alternated by individuals as a form of ‘code-switching.’ An example of English-Korean code-switching: I brought my umbrella biga olgguh gatesuh Gloss: ‘I brought my umbrella because it seemed it would rain .’ A community can develop local norms of mixing languages, such as in the case of what is sometimes called ‘Spanglish ’ , which may be viewed as ‘code-switching’ between Spanish and English while also a ‘code’ with its own rules. Sometimes a completely new language may emerge through the combination of the words of one language and the grammatical structure of the other. When such ‘pidgins’ are learned by children, they become ‘creoles’, which have the systematicity and complexity of any language.

Languages can be mixed and alternated by individuals as a form of ‘code-switching.’

An example of English-Korean code-switching:

I brought my umbrella biga olgguh gatesuh

Gloss: ‘I brought my umbrella because it seemed it would rain .’

A community can develop local norms of mixing languages, such as in the case of what is sometimes called ‘Spanglish ’ , which may be viewed as ‘code-switching’ between Spanish and English while also a ‘code’ with its own rules.

Sometimes a completely new language may emerge through the combination of the words of one language and the grammatical structure of the other. When such ‘pidgins’ are learned by children, they become ‘creoles’, which have the systematicity and complexity of any language.

Lingua Franca In other to communicate, speakers may depend on a common language, or a ‘lingua franca’, chosen by speakers or an officially governing body. Its choice may depend on any number of factors, although the political and economic prestige of the language often plays a major role. What will be the new lingua franca as worldwide communication becomes possible with technological advances? Some lingua francas of the past and present a worldwide lingua franca arising originally from British colonial influence and continuing as a result of US economic power English a written lingua franca used for centuries among speakers of mutually unintelligible Chinese dialects Written Chinese the language of the European educated elite during the 17 th to 19 th centuries French the language of colonial administration and trade in 14 th to 16 th century Asia and Africa Portuguese

In other to communicate, speakers may depend on a common language, or a ‘lingua franca’, chosen by speakers or an officially governing body. Its choice may depend on any number of factors, although the political and economic prestige of the language often plays a major role.

What will be the new lingua franca as worldwide communication becomes possible with technological advances?

Language Loss As global communication and economic exchange becomes enabled by technological advances, communities may place greater emphasis on the learning of lingua francas that have relative economic value, such as English and Spanish. Linguists have noted that one of the results of such ‘language shift’ is the potential endangerment of less economically valuable languages, eventually leading to their extinction. “ Of the 6,809 languages currently listed in the database of the Ethnologue: Languages of the World, 330 languages each have one million speakers or more. This large size population contrasts sharply with the approximately 450 languages that are so small that they are in the last stages of becoming extinct, with only a few elderly speakers left in each one.” --Barbara F. Grimes, Ethnologue Editor 1971-2000 SOURCE: http://www.sil.org/sociolx/ndg-lg-grimes.html A sampling of endangered languages: Zapotec (Mexico) Menominee (USA) Ainu (Japan) Ratagnon (Philippines) Abaga (Papua New Guinea) Bete (Nigeria) Squamish (Canada) Berbice Creole Dutch (Guyana) Hawai'i Pidgin Sign Language (USA)

How can we use technology? Despite the profitability for some societies to learn languages that have economic value, such as English, why is it important to preserve endangered languages? Language is not only a medium for transmitting culture; it is a tightly bound to culture—for instance, in poems, jokes, stories, and ways of expressing culturally-specific ideas. The loss of a language will necessarily result in a significant loss of a people’s culture. How can technology be used to help in the preservation process? Databases for storing and transmitting language samples and verbal art forms Distribution of images and sounds that increase worldwide awareness and valuing of the diverse languages of the world Can you think of other ways? How can we maintain the world’s linguistic diversity while allowing linguistic minorities participate in the global economy? What would be some of the advantages and disadvantages to using translation machines, instead of forcing communities to speak a common language?

Despite the profitability for some societies to learn languages that have economic value, such as English, why is it important to preserve endangered languages?

Language is not only a medium for transmitting culture; it is a tightly bound to culture—for instance, in poems, jokes, stories, and ways of expressing culturally-specific ideas. The loss of a language will necessarily result in a significant loss of a people’s culture.

How can technology be used to help in the preservation process?

Databases for storing and transmitting language samples and verbal art forms

Distribution of images and sounds that increase worldwide awareness and valuing of the diverse languages of the world

Can you think of other ways?

How can we maintain the world’s linguistic diversity while allowing linguistic minorities participate in the global economy?

What would be some of the advantages and disadvantages to using translation machines, instead of forcing communities to speak a common language?