A U G U S T 2 , 2 010 / F I N A L P R E S E N TAT I O N

A Mobile Execution Tool for the
Exploration of Planetary Surfaces...
MEET THE TEAM

Katy Linn
Project
Coordinator

::

Christine Wu
Technical Lead

Jesse Venticinque Jennifer Lu
Design Lead
U...
MEET THE CLIENT

HCI Group

NASA Ames Research Center

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’...
BACKGROUND
DESIGN
DEMO
PROCESS
CONCLUSION

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone P...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

CLIENT’S CHARGE

To design an efficient plan interface for
real-time executi...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Astronaut’s day is planned down to the minute

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Co...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Astronaut’s day is planned down to the minute
Accomplish the maximum amount...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Astronaut’s day is planned down to the minute
Accomplish the maximum amount...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

SCHEDULE
JANUARY

FEBRUARY

MARCH

APRIL

M AY

Spring  Break

RESEARCH

KI...
BACKGROUND

DEMO

FEBRUARY

JANUARY

DESIGN

PROCESS

MARCH

CONCLUSION

APRIL

M AY

RESEARCH PLAN
LITERATURE REVIEW
COMP...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

JANUARY

DEMO

PROCESS

FEBRUARY

CONCLUSION

MARCH

Spring  Break

RESEARCH

KICK-OFF / SCOPE
RESEARC...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

JANUARY

PROCESS

FEBRUARY

CONCLUSION

MARCH

Spring  Break

RESEARCH

KICK-OFF / SCOPE
RESEARC...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

JANUARY

DEMO

PROCESS

FEBRUARY

CONCLUSION

MARCH

Spring  Break

RESEARCH

KICK-OFF / SCOPE
RESEARC...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

JANUARY

DEMO

PROCESS

FEBRUARY

CONCLUSION

MARCH

Spring  Break

RESEARCH

KICK-OFF / SCOPE
RESEARC...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

JANUARY

DEMO

PROCESS

FEBRUARY

CONCLUSION

MARCH

Spring  Break

RESEARCH

KICK-OFF / SCOPE
RESEARC...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

JANUARY

DEMO

PROCESS

FEBRUARY

CONCLUSION

MARCH

Spring  Break

RESEARCH

KICK-OFF / SCOPE
RESEARC...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

PLANNER

::

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

ASTRONAUT

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institut...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

PLANNER

::

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

ASTRONAUT

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institut...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

PLANNER

Mission Planning is complex: resource,
physical and sequential con...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

PLANNER

Mission Planning is complex: resource,
physical and sequential con...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

PLANNER

Mission Planning is complex: resource,
physical and sequential con...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

PLANNER

::

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

ASTRONAUT

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institut...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

ASTRONAUT

Astronauts cannot follow the plan exactly

::

Carnegie Mellon H...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

ASTRONAUT

Astronauts cannot follow the plan exactly
They need a subset of ...
BACKGROUND

::

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project

...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

ASTRONAUT

“The plan is just a suggestion...”
Former astronaut (3/1/2010)
:...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

THE PLANNERS PLAN

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

THE ASTRONAUTS PLAN

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institu...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

20 Literature Reviews
6 Competitive Analyses
6 Contextual Inquiries
3 Interviews
::

DEMO

}

PROCESS
...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

!

Inflexible Plans fail to capture
the variable nature of execution

!

Any...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

!

Inflexible Plans fail to capture
the variable nature of execution

!

Any...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

! Inflexible Plans

Astronauts execute the plan out of order

::

Carnegie M...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

! Inflexible Plans

Astronauts execute the plan out of order
Discrepancies a...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

!

Inflexible Plans fail to capture
the variable nature of execution

!

Any...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

! Single Representation of the Plan

Planners and Astronauts need different...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

!

Inflexible Plans fail to capture
the variable nature of execution

!

Any...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

!

Inflexible Plans fail to capture
the variable nature of execution

!

Any...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized for execution
! Single Representation of the Plan

::

C...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized for execution
! Single Representation of the Plan

Delta...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized for execution
! Single Representation of the Plan

Delta...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized for execution
! Single Representation of the Plan

Delta...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized for execution
! Single Representation of the Plan

Delta...
BACKGROUND
DESIGN
DEMO
PROCESS
CONCLUSION

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone P...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

ECOSYSTEM

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

MISSION CONTROL

INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION

PERSONNEL

PLANETA...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

ECOSYSTEM

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

MISSION CONTROL

INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION

PERSONNEL

PLANETA...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

MEET TIM

BACKGROUND:
EXPERIENCE:
RESPONSIBILITY:
GOALS:

::

38-year-old A...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

MISSION DAY OVERVIEW

DAILY PLANNING
CONFERENCE

4

2 CRATER

1

BOULDER

X...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Traverse to
different
stations

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interact...
BACKGROUND

Traverse to
different stations

::

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Egress at
each site to
perform EVA

Car...
BACKGROUND

Traverse to
different stations

::

Egress at
each site to
perform EVA

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Com...
BACKGROUND

Traverse to
different stations

::

Egress at
each site to
perform EVA

DESIGN

Complete
scheduled
activities
...
BACKGROUND

Traverse to
different stations

::

Egress at
each site to
perform EVA

DESIGN

Complete
scheduled
activities
...
BACKGROUND

Traverse to
different stations

::

Egress at
each site to
perform EVA

DESIGN

Complete
scheduled
activities
...
BACKGROUND

Traverse to
different stations

::

Egress at
each site to
perform EVA

DESIGN

Complete
scheduled
activities
...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

THE PLAN

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Maste...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

APOLLO MISSION PLAN

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institu...
BACKGROUND

::

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project

...
BACKGROUND

::

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project

...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

INFORMATION HIERARCHY
Header
t
Activity Lis
iewer

V
Procedure

::

Carnegi...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized for execution
! Single Representation of the Plan

Delta...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized for execution

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Intera...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized for execution
Segmentation of day’s plan

::

Carnegie M...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized for execution
Segmentation of day’s plan

Integrated
wor...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Delta between plan and execution

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Intera...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Delta between plan and execution
Marcus Bains Notch

::

Carnegie Mellon Hu...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Delta between plan and execution
Marcus Bains Notch

Time Left:
Mission & S...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Autonomy when appropriate

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction I...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Autonomy when appropriate

Not time
constrained

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Autonomy when appropriate

Not time
constrained
Prioritization
Backup Activ...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Glanceable and unobtrusive

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction ...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Glanceable and unobtrusive

Large Text,
High Contrast

::

Carnegie Mellon ...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Glanceable and unobtrusive

Large Text,
High Contrast
No unnecessary
intera...
BACKGROUND
DESIGN
DEMO
PROCESS
CONCLUSION

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone P...
BACKGROUND

::

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project

...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

MISSION DAY 5
DAILY PLANNING
CONFERENCE

4

2 CRATER

1

BOULDER

X

WATER ...
BACKGROUND
DESIGN
DEMO
PROCESS
CONCLUSION

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone P...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

ITERATIVE DESIGN CYCLES

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Ins...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

ITERATIVE DESIGN CYCLES

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Ins...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

RE

FI

NE

E

X

P

LO

R

E

EXPLORE, THEN REFINE

::

Carnegie Mellon Hu...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

RE

FI

NE

E

X

P

LO

R

E

EXPLORE, THEN REFINE

RESEARCH
::

Carnegie ...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

RE

FI

NE

E

X

P

LO

R

E

EXPLORE, THEN REFINE

RESEARCH
::

DESIGN & ...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

RE

FI

NE

E

X

P

LO

R

E

EXPLORE, THEN REFINE

RESEARCH
::

DESIGN & ...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

RE

FI

NE

E

X

P

LO

R

E

EXPLORE, THEN REFINE

RESEARCH
::

DESIGN & ...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

EXPLORE, THEN REFINE

RESEARCH
::

DESIGN & PROTOTYPING

EVALUATION

Carneg...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

EXPLORE, THEN REFINE (RINSE & REPEAT)
FIRST ITERATION

SECOND ITERATION

TH...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

EXPLORATION METHODS
Domain Research
Metaphors
Brainstorm
Bodystorm
Lo-Fi Sk...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

DOMAIN RESEARCH

CONCLUSION

RESEARCH

Desert RATS, Paper & Electronic Cuff Checklist
:...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

METAPHORS

CONCLUSION

DESIGN & PROTOTYPING

Explore planning and execution parallels:
...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

BRAINSTORM

CONCLUSION

DESIGN & PROTOTYPING

Interface, Input/Output, Physical Form
::...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

BODYSTORM

CONCLUSION

DESIGN & PROTOTYPING

Experienced physical constraints:
Motorcyc...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

LO-FI SKETCHES

CONCLUSION

DESIGN & PROTOTYPING

Non-Interactive, Used for Speed Datin...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

REFINEMENT METHODS
Speed Dating EVALUATION
Mid-Fi Wireframes
Think Alouds E...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

SPEED DATING

CONCLUSION

EVALUATION

Needs validation:
4-5 minutes on each concept, we...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

MID-FI WIREFRAMES

CONCLUSION

DESIGN & PROTOTYPING

Interactive, Used for shared under...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

THINK ALOUDS

CONCLUSION

EVALUATION

Interaction exploration:
Asked participants to ex...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

HI-FI PROTOTYPES

HTML + Javascript

CONCLUSION

DEVELOPMENT

Android Application

Inte...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

HI-FI PROTOTYPES

CONCLUSION

DEVELOPMENT

Push buttons
Arduino microcontroller, BlueSm...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

HI-FI PROTOTYPES

CONCLUSION

DEVELOPMENT

Foam enclosure, cuff-mounted
::

Carnegie Me...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

ORT: Operational Readiness Test

CONCLUSION

EVALUATION

30 minute mock planetary explo...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

ORT: Operational Readiness Test

CONCLUSION

EVALUATION

Mission briefing & device train...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

ORT: Operational Readiness Test

CONCLUSION

EVALUATION

Traverse from station to stati...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

ORT: Operational Readiness Test

CONCLUSION

EVALUATION

Perform activities
Observation...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

ORT: Operational Readiness Test

CONCLUSION

EVALUATION

Mission debrief & user feedbac...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

SUMMARY OF METHODS
Exploration
• Domain Research
• Metaphors
• Brainstorm
•...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

EVOLUTION OF KEY FEATURES
FIRST ITERATION

::

SECOND ITERATION

THIRD ITER...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

EVOLUTION OF KEY FEATURES
FIRST ITERATION

::

SECOND ITERATION

THIRD ITER...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

VISUAL DESIGN

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Glanceable

It sure is bright out here

::

Carnegie Mellon ...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

VISUAL DESIGN

CONCLUSION

Glanceable

It sure is bright out here
FIRST ITERATION

::

...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

VISUAL DESIGN

CONCLUSION

Glanceable

It sure is bright out here
FIRST ITERATION

SECO...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

VISUAL DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Glanceable

FIRST ITERATION

“ The colors are
really pale an...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

VISUAL DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Glanceable

SECOND ITERATION

“ The orange is
hard to see. T...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

VISUAL DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Glanceable

THIRD ITERATION

“ I like how the
text is big an...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

VISUAL DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Glanceable

FINAL ITERATION

“ I can walk and
read this at t...
BACKGROUND

TIME

DESIGN

Glanceable

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Delta

Time, served three ways

::

Carnegie Mellon Human...
BACKGROUND

TIME

DESIGN

Glanceable

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Delta

Time, served three ways
FIRST ITERATION

SECOND IT...
BACKGROUND

TIME

DESIGN

Glanceable

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Delta

Time, served three ways
GMT
Station time left

FIR...
BACKGROUND

TIME

DESIGN

Glanceable

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Delta

FIRST ITERATION

“ 45 minutes out
of what?”
- Peer...
BACKGROUND

TIME

DESIGN

Glanceable

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Delta

SECOND ITERATION

“ Is 0:05 minutes or
seconds?”
-...
BACKGROUND

TIME

DESIGN

DEMO

Glanceable

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Delta

THIRD ITERATION

“ I thought it was weird to see
s...
BACKGROUND

TIME

DESIGN

Glanceable

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

Delta

FINAL ITERATION

“ When I was ahead, I used the Mi...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

ACTIVITY LIST

DEMO

PROCESS

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

Autonomy

The story of Goldi...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

ACTIVITY LIST

DEMO

PROCESS

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

Autonomy

The story of Goldi...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

ACTIVITY LIST

DEMO

PROCESS

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

Autonomy

The story of Goldi...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

ACTIVITY LIST

DEMO

PROCESS

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

Autonomy

FIRST ITERATION

“...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

ACTIVITY LIST

DEMO

PROCESS

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

Autonomy

SECOND ITERATION

...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

ACTIVITY LIST

DEMO

PROCESS

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

Autonomy

THIRD ITERATION

“...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

ACTIVITY LIST

DEMO

PROCESS

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

Autonomy

FINAL ITERATION

“...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

PROCEDURE VIEW

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

Help is but one button away...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

PROCEDURE VIEW

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

Help is but one button away...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

PROCEDURE VIEW

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

Help is but one button away...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

PROCEDURE VIEW

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

SECOND ITERATION

“ I don’t...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

PROCEDURE VIEW

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

THIRD ITERATION

“ Sometime...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

PROCEDURE VIEW

Glanceable

CONCLUSION

Timeline optimized

FINAL ITERATION

“ I really...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

COMPLETION STATUS?

Status is already in the astronaut’s head
Unnecessary e...
BACKGROUND
DESIGN
DEMO
PROCESS
CONCLUSION

::

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone P...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

FINAL ORT RESULTS

All participants returned minutes ahead of schedule
Perf...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

FINAL ORT RESULTS

No wasted time over forgotten equipment
Reviewed activit...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

FINAL ORT RESULTS

“ I can see this being useful in a long
mission where yo...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

FINAL ORT RESULTS

“ At this point, it’s just my personal
taste, not the ov...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

DESERT RATS FEEDBACK

“ WOW! What you guys have here
represents exactly how...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

DESERT RATS FEEDBACK

“ LuMo is a great proof of concept for a
digital cuff...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

DESERT RATS FEEDBACK

“ This looks interesting and novel. Would be
interest...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

FUTURE WORK

MISSION CONTROL

INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION

PLANETARY SURFAC...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

FUTURE WORK

MISSION CONTROL

INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION

LuMo

PLANETARY ...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

LUMO

Robustness under extreme conditions
Collaboration between team member...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

FUTURE WORK

MISSION CONTROL

Onboard Plan Viewer

INTERNATIONAL SPACE STAT...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

ONBOARD PLAN VIEWER

LuMo+: Map View, Plan History, Partner’s Schedule
::

...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

FUTURE WORK

MISSION CONTROL

ISS Extravehicular Activities
INTERNATIONAL S...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

ISS EVA ACTIVITIES

Optimize for ISS extravehicular activities:
activities,...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

FUTURE WORK

MISSION CONTROL

Plan Making Tools
INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION...
BACKGROUND

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

CONCLUSION

PLAN MAKING TOOLS

Create procedures and execution notes using a form
Push ...
BACKGROUND

::

DESIGN

DEMO

PROCESS

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project

...
THANK YOU!
Questions?

teamlumina2010.com

::

info@teamlumina.com

Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

A Mobile Execution Tool for Planetary Surface Missions

193

Published on

Central to any human effort in space is the fluent and reliable execution of technical, operational,
and scientific plans by astronauts. From current Shuttle and International Space Station missions to future planetary surface exploration efforts, unique planning challenges call for better tools that enable astronauts to execute complex tasks, often under shifting and unpredictable conditions.
To this end, our interdisciplinary team of five Carn- egie Mellon Master of Human-Computer Interac- tion students, working with the Human-Computer Interaction Group at NASA Ames Research Center, has been tasked to design, develop, and evaluate a prototype assisting real-time execution of human space missions.

Published in: Design, Technology, Education
0 Comments
9 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
193
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
1
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0
Likes
9
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Transcript of "A Mobile Execution Tool for Planetary Surface Missions"

  1. 1. A U G U S T 2 , 2 010 / F I N A L P R E S E N TAT I O N A Mobile Execution Tool for the Exploration of Planetary Surfaces { Katy Linn Christine Wu Jesse Venticinque Jennifer Lu Noah Levin
  2. 2. MEET THE TEAM Katy Linn Project Coordinator :: Christine Wu Technical Lead Jesse Venticinque Jennifer Lu Design Lead User Research Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Noah Levin Web / Documentation Final Presentation 2
  3. 3. MEET THE CLIENT HCI Group NASA Ames Research Center :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 3
  4. 4. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 4
  5. 5. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION CLIENT’S CHARGE To design an efficient plan interface for real-time execution of human space missions :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 5
  6. 6. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Astronaut’s day is planned down to the minute :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 6
  7. 7. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Astronaut’s day is planned down to the minute Accomplish the maximum amount of work during these hours :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 7
  8. 8. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Astronaut’s day is planned down to the minute Accomplish the maximum amount of work during these hours The plan undergoes a lengthy creation and review process, bearing scrutiny from many roles :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 8
  9. 9. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION SCHEDULE JANUARY FEBRUARY MARCH APRIL M AY Spring  Break RESEARCH KICK-OFF / SCOPE RESEARCH PLAN LITERATURE REVIEW COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS CONTEXTUAL INQUIRIES RESEARCH SYNTHESIS REPORT WRITING INTERVIEWS M AY RECOMMENDATIONS JUNE J U LY AUG RESEARCH ITERATION 2 ITERATION 3 ITERATION 4 PROTOTYPING DEVELOPMENT Final  Presentation Move  to  Moffett Present  Research DESIGN ITERATION 1 USER AND EXPERT EVALUATION METHODS DESIGN DEVELOPMENT EVALUATION OPERATIONAL READINESS TEST (ORT) TODAY! :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 9
  10. 10. BACKGROUND DEMO FEBRUARY JANUARY DESIGN PROCESS MARCH CONCLUSION APRIL M AY RESEARCH PLAN LITERATURE REVIEW COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS CONTEXTUAL INQUIRIES Spring  Break RESEARCH KICK-OFF / SCOPE RESEARCH SYNTHESIS REPORT WRITING INTERVIEWS :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project RECOMMENDATIONS August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 10
  11. 11. BACKGROUND DESIGN JANUARY DEMO PROCESS FEBRUARY CONCLUSION MARCH Spring  Break RESEARCH KICK-OFF / SCOPE RESEARCH PLAN LITERATURE REVIEW COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS CONTEXTUAL INQUIRIES RESE INTERVIEWS :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 10
  12. 12. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO JANUARY PROCESS FEBRUARY CONCLUSION MARCH Spring  Break RESEARCH KICK-OFF / SCOPE RESEARCH PLAN LITERATURE REVIEW LITERATURE REVIEW COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS CONTEXTUAL INQUIRIES RESE INTERVIEWS 20 Papers Background knowledge to prepare for ethnographic research :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 11
  13. 13. BACKGROUND DESIGN JANUARY DEMO PROCESS FEBRUARY CONCLUSION MARCH Spring  Break RESEARCH KICK-OFF / SCOPE RESEARCH PLAN LITERATURE REVIEW COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS CONTEXTUAL INQUIRIES RESE INTERVIEWS 6 Planning and Execution Tools Understand current practices :: 12 Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation
  14. 14. BACKGROUND DESIGN JANUARY DEMO PROCESS FEBRUARY CONCLUSION MARCH Spring  Break RESEARCH KICK-OFF / SCOPE RESEARCH PLAN LITERATURE REVIEW COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS CONTEXTUAL INQUIRIES RESE INTERVIEWS 6 Contextual Inquiries (25 People) Discover what is actually happening at work :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 13
  15. 15. BACKGROUND DESIGN JANUARY DEMO PROCESS FEBRUARY CONCLUSION MARCH Spring  Break RESEARCH KICK-OFF / SCOPE RESEARCH PLAN LITERATURE REVIEW COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS CONTEXTUAL INQUIRIES RESE INTERVIEWS 3 Interviews Reveal retrospective accounts of the workflow :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 14
  16. 16. BACKGROUND DESIGN JANUARY DEMO PROCESS FEBRUARY CONCLUSION MARCH Spring  Break RESEARCH KICK-OFF / SCOPE RESEARCH PLAN LITERATURE REVIEW COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS CONTEXTUAL INQUIRIES RESE INTERVIEWS Talked to 28 People Total :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 15
  17. 17. BACKGROUND DESIGN PLANNER :: DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ASTRONAUT Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 16
  18. 18. BACKGROUND DESIGN PLANNER :: DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ASTRONAUT Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 17
  19. 19. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION PLANNER Mission Planning is complex: resource, physical and sequential constraints :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 18
  20. 20. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION PLANNER Mission Planning is complex: resource, physical and sequential constraints Changing the plan is stressful & difficult, and requires multiple roles :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 19
  21. 21. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION PLANNER Mission Planning is complex: resource, physical and sequential constraints Changing the plan is stressful & difficult, and requires multiple roles Want the plan to be followed accurately :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 20
  22. 22. BACKGROUND DESIGN PLANNER :: DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ASTRONAUT Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation
  23. 23. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ASTRONAUT Astronauts cannot follow the plan exactly :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 22
  24. 24. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ASTRONAUT Astronauts cannot follow the plan exactly They need a subset of information from the plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 23
  25. 25. BACKGROUND :: DESIGN DEMO PROCESS Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 CONCLUSION Final Presentation 24
  26. 26. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ASTRONAUT “The plan is just a suggestion...” Former astronaut (3/1/2010) :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 25
  27. 27. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION THE PLANNERS PLAN :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 26
  28. 28. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION THE ASTRONAUTS PLAN :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 27
  29. 29. BACKGROUND DESIGN 20 Literature Reviews 6 Competitive Analyses 6 Contextual Inquiries 3 Interviews :: DEMO } PROCESS CONCLUSION ~300 Findings Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 28
  30. 30. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ! Inflexible Plans fail to capture the variable nature of execution ! Any single representation of the plan fails to accommodate the varying needs and responsibilities across roles utilizing the plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 29
  31. 31. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ! Inflexible Plans fail to capture the variable nature of execution ! Any single representation of the plan fails to accommodate the varying needs and responsibilities across roles utilizing the plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 30
  32. 32. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ! Inflexible Plans Astronauts execute the plan out of order :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 31
  33. 33. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ! Inflexible Plans Astronauts execute the plan out of order Discrepancies arise between the plan and actual execution :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 32
  34. 34. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ! Inflexible Plans fail to capture the variable nature of execution ! Any single representation of the plan fails to accommodate the varying needs and responsibilities across roles utilizing the plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 33
  35. 35. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ! Single Representation of the Plan Planners and Astronauts need different kinds of information from the same plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 34
  36. 36. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ! Inflexible Plans fail to capture the variable nature of execution ! Any single representation of the plan fails to accommodate the varying needs and responsibilities across roles utilizing the plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 35
  37. 37. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ! Inflexible Plans fail to capture the variable nature of execution ! Any single representation of the plan fails to accommodate the varying needs and responsibilities across roles utilizing the plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 36
  38. 38. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Timeline optimized for execution ! Single Representation of the Plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 37
  39. 39. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Timeline optimized for execution ! Single Representation of the Plan Delta between plan and execution ! Inflexible Plans :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 38
  40. 40. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Timeline optimized for execution ! Single Representation of the Plan Delta between plan and execution ! Inflexible Plans Autonomy when appropriate ! Inflexible Plans :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 39
  41. 41. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Timeline optimized for execution ! Single Representation of the Plan Delta between plan and execution ! Inflexible Plans Autonomy when appropriate ! Inflexible Plans Glanceable and unobtrusive ! Single Representation of the Plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 40
  42. 42. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Timeline optimized for execution ! Single Representation of the Plan Delta between plan and execution ! Inflexible Plans Autonomy when appropriate ! Inflexible Plans Glanceable and unobtrusive ! Single Representation of the Plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 41
  43. 43. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 42
  44. 44. BACKGROUND DESIGN ECOSYSTEM DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION MISSION CONTROL INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION PERSONNEL PLANETARY SURFACE TOOLS :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 43
  45. 45. BACKGROUND DESIGN ECOSYSTEM DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION MISSION CONTROL INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION PERSONNEL PLANETARY SURFACE TOOLS :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 44
  46. 46. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION MEET TIM BACKGROUND: EXPERIENCE: RESPONSIBILITY: GOALS: :: 38-year-old Astronaut (Geologist) Has extensive training and experience Explore planetary surfaces from vehicle Help make new science discoveries Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 45
  47. 47. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION MISSION DAY OVERVIEW DAILY PLANNING CONFERENCE 4 2 CRATER 1 BOULDER X WATER SITE BASECAMP 3 RILLE :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 46
  48. 48. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Traverse to different stations :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 47
  49. 49. BACKGROUND Traverse to different stations :: DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Egress at each site to perform EVA Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 48
  50. 50. BACKGROUND Traverse to different stations :: Egress at each site to perform EVA DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Complete scheduled activities Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 49
  51. 51. BACKGROUND Traverse to different stations :: Egress at each site to perform EVA DESIGN Complete scheduled activities DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Ingress after EVA Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 50
  52. 52. BACKGROUND Traverse to different stations :: Egress at each site to perform EVA DESIGN Complete scheduled activities DEMO Ingress after EVA PROCESS CONCLUSION Traverse to next station Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 51
  53. 53. BACKGROUND Traverse to different stations :: Egress at each site to perform EVA DESIGN Complete scheduled activities DEMO Ingress after EVA PROCESS Traverse to next station Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project CONCLUSION Collaborate to replan as needed August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 52
  54. 54. BACKGROUND Traverse to different stations :: Egress at each site to perform EVA DESIGN Complete scheduled activities DEMO Ingress after EVA PROCESS Traverse to next station Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project Collaborate to replan as needed August 2nd, 2010 CONCLUSION Return to basecamp on time Final Presentation 53
  55. 55. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION THE PLAN :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 54
  56. 56. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION APOLLO MISSION PLAN :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 55
  57. 57. BACKGROUND :: DESIGN DEMO PROCESS Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 CONCLUSION Final Presentation 56
  58. 58. BACKGROUND :: DESIGN DEMO PROCESS Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 CONCLUSION Final Presentation 57
  59. 59. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION INFORMATION HIERARCHY Header t Activity Lis iewer V Procedure :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 58
  60. 60. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Timeline optimized for execution ! Single Representation of the Plan Delta between plan and execution ! Inflexible Plans Autonomy when appropriate ! Inflexible Plans Glanceable and unobtrusive ! Single Representation of the Plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 59
  61. 61. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Timeline optimized for execution :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 60
  62. 62. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Timeline optimized for execution Segmentation of day’s plan :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 61
  63. 63. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Timeline optimized for execution Segmentation of day’s plan Integrated workflow :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 62
  64. 64. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Delta between plan and execution :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 63
  65. 65. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Delta between plan and execution Marcus Bains Notch :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 64
  66. 66. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Delta between plan and execution Marcus Bains Notch Time Left: Mission & Station :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 65
  67. 67. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Autonomy when appropriate :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 66
  68. 68. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Autonomy when appropriate Not time constrained :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 67
  69. 69. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Autonomy when appropriate Not time constrained Prioritization Backup Activities :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 68
  70. 70. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Glanceable and unobtrusive :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 69
  71. 71. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Glanceable and unobtrusive Large Text, High Contrast :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 70
  72. 72. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Glanceable and unobtrusive Large Text, High Contrast No unnecessary interactions :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 71
  73. 73. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 72
  74. 74. BACKGROUND :: DESIGN DEMO PROCESS Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 CONCLUSION Final Presentation 73
  75. 75. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION MISSION DAY 5 DAILY PLANNING CONFERENCE 4 2 CRATER 1 BOULDER X WATER SITE BASECAMP 3 RILLE Tim: Geologist Astronaut Goal: Investigate water site :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 74
  76. 76. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 75
  77. 77. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ITERATIVE DESIGN CYCLES :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 76
  78. 78. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ITERATIVE DESIGN CYCLES :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 76
  79. 79. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION RE FI NE E X P LO R E EXPLORE, THEN REFINE :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 77
  80. 80. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION RE FI NE E X P LO R E EXPLORE, THEN REFINE RESEARCH :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 77
  81. 81. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION RE FI NE E X P LO R E EXPLORE, THEN REFINE RESEARCH :: DESIGN & PROTOTYPING Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 77
  82. 82. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION RE FI NE E X P LO R E EXPLORE, THEN REFINE RESEARCH :: DESIGN & PROTOTYPING EVALUATION Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 77
  83. 83. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION RE FI NE E X P LO R E EXPLORE, THEN REFINE RESEARCH :: DESIGN & PROTOTYPING EVALUATION Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project DEVELOPMENT August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 77
  84. 84. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION EXPLORE, THEN REFINE RESEARCH :: DESIGN & PROTOTYPING EVALUATION Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project DEVELOPMENT August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 77
  85. 85. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION EXPLORE, THEN REFINE (RINSE & REPEAT) FIRST ITERATION SECOND ITERATION THIRD ITERATION FINAL ITERATION EARLY SUMMER LATE SUMMER Research, Design & Prototyping Development & Evaluation RESEARCH :: DESIGN & PROTOTYPING EVALUATION Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project DEVELOPMENT August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 78
  86. 86. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION EXPLORATION METHODS Domain Research Metaphors Brainstorm Bodystorm Lo-Fi Sketches RESEARCH DESIGN & PROTOTYPING DESIGN & PROTOTYPING E PL X RE O DESIGN & PROTOTYPING DESIGN & PROTOTYPING :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 79
  87. 87. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS DOMAIN RESEARCH CONCLUSION RESEARCH Desert RATS, Paper & Electronic Cuff Checklist :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 80
  88. 88. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS METAPHORS CONCLUSION DESIGN & PROTOTYPING Explore planning and execution parallels: Robbing a bank, Football play, Third date :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 81
  89. 89. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS BRAINSTORM CONCLUSION DESIGN & PROTOTYPING Interface, Input/Output, Physical Form :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 82
  90. 90. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS BODYSTORM CONCLUSION DESIGN & PROTOTYPING Experienced physical constraints: Motorcycle safety gear :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 83
  91. 91. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS LO-FI SKETCHES CONCLUSION DESIGN & PROTOTYPING Non-Interactive, Used for Speed Dating: Split View, Station Centric, Bar Chart, Paper Towel :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 84
  92. 92. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION REFINEMENT METHODS Speed Dating EVALUATION Mid-Fi Wireframes Think Alouds EVALUATION Hi-Fi Prototypes DEVELOPMENT ORT EVALUATION DESIGN & PROTOTYPING REFIN E Operational Readiness Test :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 85
  93. 93. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS SPEED DATING CONCLUSION EVALUATION Needs validation: 4-5 minutes on each concept, wearable prototype :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 86
  94. 94. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS MID-FI WIREFRAMES CONCLUSION DESIGN & PROTOTYPING Interactive, Used for shared understanding Helped for quick and simple Think Alouds :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 87
  95. 95. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS THINK ALOUDS CONCLUSION EVALUATION Interaction exploration: Asked participants to externalize thoughts while completing a task :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 88
  96. 96. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS HI-FI PROTOTYPES HTML + Javascript CONCLUSION DEVELOPMENT Android Application Interactive, Used for Operational Readiness Tests :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 89
  97. 97. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS HI-FI PROTOTYPES CONCLUSION DEVELOPMENT Push buttons Arduino microcontroller, BlueSmirf bluetooth module :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 90
  98. 98. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS HI-FI PROTOTYPES CONCLUSION DEVELOPMENT Foam enclosure, cuff-mounted :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 91
  99. 99. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS ORT: Operational Readiness Test CONCLUSION EVALUATION 30 minute mock planetary exploration mission :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 92
  100. 100. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS ORT: Operational Readiness Test CONCLUSION EVALUATION Mission briefing & device training :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 93
  101. 101. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS ORT: Operational Readiness Test CONCLUSION EVALUATION Traverse from station to station :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 94
  102. 102. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS ORT: Operational Readiness Test CONCLUSION EVALUATION Perform activities Observations, sample collection, maintenance :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 95
  103. 103. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS ORT: Operational Readiness Test CONCLUSION EVALUATION Mission debrief & user feedback :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 96
  104. 104. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION SUMMARY OF METHODS Exploration • Domain Research • Metaphors • Brainstorm • Bodystorm • Lo-Fi Sketches EX :: PL OR E Refinement • Speed Dating • Mid-Fi Wireframes • Think Alouds • Hi-Fi Prototypes • ORT REFIN E Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 97
  105. 105. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION EVOLUTION OF KEY FEATURES FIRST ITERATION :: SECOND ITERATION THIRD ITERATION Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project FINAL ITERATION August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 98
  106. 106. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION EVOLUTION OF KEY FEATURES FIRST ITERATION :: SECOND ITERATION THIRD ITERATION Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project FINAL ITERATION August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 99
  107. 107. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO VISUAL DESIGN PROCESS CONCLUSION Glanceable It sure is bright out here :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 100
  108. 108. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS VISUAL DESIGN CONCLUSION Glanceable It sure is bright out here FIRST ITERATION :: SECOND ITERATION THIRD ITERATION Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 FINAL ITERATION Final Presentation 101
  109. 109. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS VISUAL DESIGN CONCLUSION Glanceable It sure is bright out here FIRST ITERATION SECOND ITERATION THIRD ITERATION soft subtle colors :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project FINAL ITERATION bold high contrast August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 102
  110. 110. BACKGROUND DESIGN VISUAL DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Glanceable FIRST ITERATION “ The colors are really pale and non-contrast.” - Peer feedback :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 103
  111. 111. BACKGROUND DESIGN VISUAL DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Glanceable SECOND ITERATION “ The orange is hard to see. The text could be bigger, too.” - ORT Participant :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 104
  112. 112. BACKGROUND DESIGN VISUAL DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Glanceable THIRD ITERATION “ I like how the text is big and easy to see.” - ORT Participant :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 105
  113. 113. BACKGROUND DESIGN VISUAL DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Glanceable FINAL ITERATION “ I can walk and read this at the same time.” - ORT Participant :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 106
  114. 114. BACKGROUND TIME DESIGN Glanceable DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Delta Time, served three ways :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 107
  115. 115. BACKGROUND TIME DESIGN Glanceable DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Delta Time, served three ways FIRST ITERATION SECOND ITERATION THIRD ITERATION FINAL ITERATION :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 108
  116. 116. BACKGROUND TIME DESIGN Glanceable DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Delta Time, served three ways GMT Station time left FIRST ITERATION SECOND ITERATION THIRD ITERATION FINAL ITERATION :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project Mission time left Station time left Marcus Bains Notch August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 109
  117. 117. BACKGROUND TIME DESIGN Glanceable DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Delta FIRST ITERATION “ 45 minutes out of what?” - Peer feedback :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 110
  118. 118. BACKGROUND TIME DESIGN Glanceable DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Delta SECOND ITERATION “ Is 0:05 minutes or seconds?” - ORT Participant “ I never used the current time for GMT” - ORT Participant :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 111
  119. 119. BACKGROUND TIME DESIGN DEMO Glanceable PROCESS CONCLUSION Delta THIRD ITERATION “ I thought it was weird to see something counting up and another counting down. And I never used Time Elapsed.” “ Is 0:04 seconds or minutes.” - ORT Participant - ORT Participant :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 112
  120. 120. BACKGROUND TIME DESIGN Glanceable DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION Delta FINAL ITERATION “ When I was ahead, I used the Mission Time Left. When I was behind, I used Station Time Left.” - ORT Participant “ If the text is red, I know, ‘oh, I’m Late!’” - ORT Participant :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 113
  121. 121. BACKGROUND DESIGN ACTIVITY LIST DEMO PROCESS Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized Autonomy The story of Goldilocks :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 114
  122. 122. BACKGROUND DESIGN ACTIVITY LIST DEMO PROCESS Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized Autonomy The story of Goldilocks FIRST ITERATION SECOND ITERATION THIRD ITERATION FINAL ITERATION :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 115
  123. 123. BACKGROUND DESIGN ACTIVITY LIST DEMO PROCESS Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized Autonomy The story of Goldilocks FIRST ITERATION Beveled rendering Ambiguous & extraneous information SECOND ITERATION THIRD ITERATION FINAL ITERATION :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project Flat rendering Obvious & relevant information August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 116
  124. 124. BACKGROUND DESIGN ACTIVITY LIST DEMO PROCESS Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized Autonomy FIRST ITERATION “ How important is it that I do things in order?” - Peer Feedback :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 117
  125. 125. BACKGROUND DESIGN ACTIVITY LIST DEMO PROCESS Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized Autonomy SECOND ITERATION “ It’s not very obvious what the star means.” - ORT Participant :: “ I pretty much just did things in order.” - ORT Participant Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 118
  126. 126. BACKGROUND DESIGN ACTIVITY LIST DEMO PROCESS Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized Autonomy THIRD ITERATION “ It wastes a lot of time when I have to go back for the tools.” “ I can’t help but want to touch the blue bar!” - ORT Participant - ORT Participant :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 119
  127. 127. BACKGROUND DESIGN ACTIVITY LIST DEMO PROCESS Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized Autonomy FINAL ITERATION “ I never once touched the screen.” - ORT Participant “ I did backup activities first because I can do them while walking towards the formation. - Repeat ORT Participant :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 120
  128. 128. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS PROCEDURE VIEW Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized Help is but one button away :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 121
  129. 129. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS PROCEDURE VIEW Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized Help is but one button away FIRST ITERATION Not applicable SECOND ITERATION THIRD ITERATION FINAL ITERATION :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 122
  130. 130. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS PROCEDURE VIEW Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized Help is but one button away FIRST ITERATION Document view Blue highlight Not applicable SECOND ITERATION THIRD ITERATION Inline view Purple highlight FINAL ITERATION :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 123
  131. 131. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS PROCEDURE VIEW Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized SECOND ITERATION “ I don’t know which procedure steps have notes” - ORT Participant :: “ I can’t see the procedure steps when I’m looking at notes.” - ORT Participant Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 124
  132. 132. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS PROCEDURE VIEW Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized THIRD ITERATION “ Sometimes I get confused about whether I’m looking at the Activity List or Procedure View.” - ORT Participant :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 125
  133. 133. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS PROCEDURE VIEW Glanceable CONCLUSION Timeline optimized FINAL ITERATION “ I really like what you guys did with the Activity View” - Repeat ORT Participant :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 126
  134. 134. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION COMPLETION STATUS? Status is already in the astronaut’s head Unnecessary externalization means mental load :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 127
  135. 135. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 128
  136. 136. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION FINAL ORT RESULTS All participants returned minutes ahead of schedule Performed scheduled and backup activities :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 129
  137. 137. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION FINAL ORT RESULTS No wasted time over forgotten equipment Reviewed activities during egress and ingress :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 130
  138. 138. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION FINAL ORT RESULTS “ I can see this being useful in a long mission where you might forget things or when things might change.” NASA Scientist (6/22/2010) :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 131
  139. 139. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION FINAL ORT RESULTS “ At this point, it’s just my personal taste, not the overall usability. I think it’s pretty great already.” Repeat ORT Participant (6/22/2010) :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 132
  140. 140. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION DESERT RATS FEEDBACK “ WOW! What you guys have here represents exactly how I think.” Desert RATS Geologist (6/22/2010) :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 133
  141. 141. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION DESERT RATS FEEDBACK “ LuMo is a great proof of concept for a digital cuff-mounted checklist.” Desert RATS Geologist (6/22/2010) :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 134
  142. 142. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION DESERT RATS FEEDBACK “ This looks interesting and novel. Would be interesting to see it developed further.” Desert RATS Engineer (6/18/2010) :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 135
  143. 143. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION FUTURE WORK MISSION CONTROL INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION PLANETARY SURFACE PERSONNEL TOOLS :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 136
  144. 144. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION FUTURE WORK MISSION CONTROL INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION LuMo PLANETARY SURFACE PERSONNEL TOOLS :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 137
  145. 145. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION LUMO Robustness under extreme conditions Collaboration between team members or teams :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 138
  146. 146. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION FUTURE WORK MISSION CONTROL Onboard Plan Viewer INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION PLANETARY SURFACE PERSONNEL TOOLS :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 139
  147. 147. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ONBOARD PLAN VIEWER LuMo+: Map View, Plan History, Partner’s Schedule :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 140
  148. 148. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION FUTURE WORK MISSION CONTROL ISS Extravehicular Activities INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION PLANETARY SURFACE PERSONNEL TOOLS :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 141
  149. 149. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION ISS EVA ACTIVITIES Optimize for ISS extravehicular activities: activities, procedures, and tools :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 142
  150. 150. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION FUTURE WORK MISSION CONTROL Plan Making Tools INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION PLANETARY SURFACE PERSONNEL TOOLS :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 143
  151. 151. BACKGROUND DESIGN DEMO PROCESS CONCLUSION PLAN MAKING TOOLS Create procedures and execution notes using a form Push plan updates in real-time :: Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 144
  152. 152. BACKGROUND :: DESIGN DEMO PROCESS Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 CONCLUSION Final Presentation 145
  153. 153. THANK YOU! Questions? teamlumina2010.com :: info@teamlumina.com Carnegie Mellon Human-Computer Interaction Institute :: Master’s Capstone Project August 2nd, 2010 Final Presentation 146

×