VET – Hayward – any learning leading to an understanding of work, to include BTECs, applied alevels, OCR nationals, diplomas, apprenticeships
Not suggesting that all routes are available to everyone, due to....
Students from lower socio economic groups are more likely to leave education. Finance, education, class, gender, location, culture, religion, ethnicity, family background/occupation, parents (intervention, encourage, know the system) (Also, impacted by ability, behaviour). Impact on: pre-entry guidance, lack of transferability of quals, prejudice admission Students attitude barriers & financial concerns, used informal trusted peer network.
Students often lack info. To make choices. Effectiveness of IAG questioned e.g. Pring, Wolf, Osfted. Mislead or given incorrect information – content, teaching style, assessment. Can lead to wrong course, not understand, doesn’t match expectations. Reliance advice needs to be available to all. Suitable progression routes need to be identified. IAG not only progression influence e.g. Hayward, 2006.
Transition is also influenced by youth decision making see Hodkinson. As influenced by macro factors e.g. life history, socio-economic and cultural context & IAG. Can be linked to Bourdieu – habitus – the individuals view of the world is derived from the macro factors their social group, aspirations and power influences on their location and context. Hodkinson and Sparkes suggests that young people try to make pragmatic rational decisions based on partial information and the macro factors. They call this arena the ‘horizon for action’ where decisions are influenced by the ‘dialectic of constraint’ life changes and action are influenced by macro factors. Bloomer highlights how these decisions are not linear and entirely predictable, thus need to be seen from students own perspective. Thus need an interpretative, mainly qualitative approach to understand social construction of reality. Bourdieu and Giddens structuration are useful here.
Teachers blame students for lack of motivation, but researcher like Foreman-Peck indicated it was the school IAG at fault. Winch suggests that IAG staff need – detailed labour market knowledge, employment trends, students knowledge/skills/abilities/interests [link to policy change – can schools provide this if Foreman-Peck notes hubris?] Reasons – financial incentives (Bourdieu power link) – Ofsted suggests schools without sixth forms give best advice.
Like Jenkins, argue should not be structurally deterministic.
25% L3 students gained at least one vocational qualification Political importance – 50% HE target, NEET figures 1 in 4 in some areas Schools ability to provide VET (resources, staff, employer access, timetable, written assessments – Ofsted, Wolf) & where do they aim for? HE?
Business students from the North West will be tracked from Year 11 to Year 12. Semi-structured interviews. Business for class practicality & as is offered in variety of institutions, has HE progression route. L1- field: The ﬁeld of interest for my study is post 16, level 3 qualiﬁcation oﬀering institutions with course focus on academic progression to higher education Field is the social space where interactions between people take place (Thompson;2008). Here the agents positions are compared to the ﬁeld of power, such as political power over IAG reform, VET aims and VET course recognition – depends on view point e.g. from SFC, school. Maton (2005) suggests establishing the social space’s historical, local, national, international context in league tables, policy & uni view of business and VET. Semi-structured interviews will be held once a year to collect in-depth data. Staff and parents will be interviewed to collect contextual data. Bourdieu's three level approach will be used to analyse the interactions within the field, the relationships between social agents and the habitus of social actors. Daoud suggests need to see from angle of all the main players, Bourdieusain framework is useful to do this, can give meaning to complex interactions outlined by Bloomer. Level 2: Structure of relationships between agents The next level looks at the relationships between agents to include the capitals, for example cultural access to information and economic capital and access to resources, economic, social and cultural credentials of the agents and education institutions to reﬂect competition for resources and pedagogic products. Economic (money and assets), cultural (knowledge, tastes,aesthetic, cultural, language, narrative, voice), social (aﬃliations, networks, family, religious, cultural, heritage) (Thompson; 2008). Level 3: Habitus of agents (students and institutions) Bourdieu deﬁnes habitus as being owned by an individual or institution that is formed subjectively through past structure, for example, education and life histories, which helps to shape the present and future (Bourdieu; 1994). Habitus is “how the ’outer’ social and ’inner’, self help to shape each other... We carry history with us to our present being and we make choices to act in certain ways an not others. It is an ongoing and active process continually making history, but not just from our own doing.” (Maton; 2008, p. 50-51). This can compare existing data of students from diﬀerent institutions for research question one and ﬁve through interpreting their accounts and individual context.
Exploring the impact of school type on post compulsory vocational courses and transition guidance
Exploring the impact of school type on post compulsory vocational courses and transition guidance Graham Garforth firstname.lastname@example.org Supervisors: Prof. R. Murphy & Prof. S. McGrathWednesday, July 18, 2012 School of Education Postgraduate Research 1 Conference, University of Nottingham
Today • Definitions • Student transition & guidance literature • Importance • Aim • MethodsWednesday, July 18, 2012 School of Education Postgraduate Research 2 Conference, University of Nottingham
Definitions • Vocational Education (VE) • Post Compulsory Education (16+) • Information and Guidance (IAG) • School/Institution Type • Progression/TransitionWednesday, July 18, 2012 School of Education Postgraduate Research 3 Conference, University of Nottingham
Macro factorsInformation and GuidanceStudent Decision Making
Macro factorsInformation and GuidanceStudent Decision Making Institution Type?
Macro factorsInformation and GuidanceStudent Decision Making Institution Type?
“Students wants do not emerge in a completely voluntary fashion, but as a consequence of structural dispositions, … their concerns and ambitions… So students want formation is neither reducible to individual emotion-cognitive processes, nor previous socialization or structural processes, instead it emerges in relation to, and between these processes and contexts.” Daoud & Puaca (2011), p. 615.Wednesday, July 18, 2012 School of Education Postgraduate Research 10 Conference, University of Nottingham
Aim To explore the effect that post-16 institutional type attended has on information and guidance received and the transitionary effect of this on students.Wednesday, July 18, 2012 School of Education Postgraduate Research 11 Conference, University of Nottingham
Why? Student transition is not entirely determined by macro influences, if we understand more about how students can improve their power, it may result in positive social change for individual students.Wednesday, July 18, 2012 School of Education Postgraduate Research 12 Conference, University of Nottingham
Importance • Course design & the aim of VE – employability/HE • Student expectations & motivation • IAG policy change • Increasing no. vocational students • 2013 rise of the compulsory leaving age • Paucity of IAG researchWednesday, July 18, 2012 School of Education Postgraduate Research 13 Conference, University of Nottingham
RQ. TransitionInfluences?RQ. TransitionExpectations?RQ. IAG used?RQ. Differencedue to institutiontype?RQ. Expectations Met?Wednesday, July 18, 2012 School of Education Postgraduate Research 14 Conference, University of Nottingham
Thank youAny questions?Comments?Graham Garforth email@example.comWednesday, July 18, 2012 School of Education Postgraduate Research 15 Conference, University of Nottingham
References Daoud, A. & Puaca, G. (2011) ‘An organic view of students’ want formation: pragmatic rationality, habitus and reflexivity.’ British Journal of Sociology of Education. Vol. 32(4), pp. 603-622.Wednesday, July 18, 2012 School of Education Postgraduate Research 17 Conference, University of Nottingham