Printer-Friendly Version                                                                                                  ...
Printer-Friendly Version                                                                                                  ...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Rich Tullo Editorial on Mark To Market and FASB 157

549 views
495 views

Published on

Sample OP-ED

Published in: Economy & Finance, Business
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
549
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
17
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Rich Tullo Editorial on Mark To Market and FASB 157

  1. 1. Printer-Friendly Version Page 1 of 2 Reform Mark-to-Market Rule Sunday, Oct 05, 2008 - 12:05 AM By RICHARD TULLO TIMES-DISPATCH COLUMNIST Iwrite not as a Democrat or Republican and not from Wall Street or from Main Street but as an American with the health and well-being of this country as my only project. My take on the financial situation: The bank crisis is a perfect storm owing to the complex math, government regulations, and exotic securities that have caused it. The basic problem is caused by bad laws that allowed a few bad apples on Main Street to take loans they could not pay back and a few bad apples on Wall Street to make loans that they knew were bad in order to make a bonus check. At the end of the day the banks got stuck holding the bag because Wall Street borrowed money from the banks. The government has to fix the problem because both Democrats and Republicans created it, and it will cost as much as $700 billion. While Congress calls the Treasury's plan a bailout, it is not a bailout but an investment in America. If the plan works, the government will own mortgages on some Main Street houses as it pays 20 cents for the mortgages and sells most of them to investors for 40 cents. It's a practical plan in theory since losses to taxpayers for the few mortgages that will go bad will be offset by the profits government makes on the rest. By most estimates the mortgages are worth more than 40 cents on the dollar. While the Treasury package fixes one issue, the failures that got us to this crisis still exist. FASB is a rule-making board created by Congress to issue the accounting rules that are called generally accepted accounting principles, or GAAP. Lack of congressional oversight on FASB and other ineffective regulations contributed to the current crisis. For example, mark-to-market accounting is the result of FASB rule 157, which basically states that a security should be valued at the last sale -- no matter what the intrinsic value (or realistic value) of that security is in the real world. FASB 157 was introduced in part because hedge funds and corporations were using marks to inflate balance sheets and carried interest. So suspending mark-to-market completely can create other problems. However, when applied to banking institutions, FASB 157 results in losses -- and banks cannot make loans to corporations, governments, small business operators, and consumers. FASB should be in business to protect investors and prevent bankruptcies -- not in the business of making rules that kill business and investors, as it did with Rule 157 and Lehman Brothers. One solution to the crisis would be to improve mark-to-market accounting. While an improvement to FASB 157 would not reverse the current problem, reform of FASB 157 would quarantine the crisis to the mortgage market and buttress the foundation of the banking system. If securities are marked to the call price (the price where a bank would sell them), then the downward spiral could reverse for mortgage securities. Marking securities to the call as the basis of balance sheet valuation is a better alternative to the current rule, which uses last sale or bid to determine price -- because bids can go to zero and the financial failures will cause some bonds to sell for nearly zero in a foreclosure-like (or distressed) sale. Marking to an ask or call price will (1) result in prices closer to the intrinsic value of these securities; (2) support the market created by the Treasury for these securities; (3) create transparency in pricing; (4) encourage banks to sell securities; and (5) give investors an opportunity to bid for securities with the government. As Americans, we need reform because the Treasury plan can only take a sick American economy off life-support. A complete overhaul of securities regulations is needed, as there are many rules such FASB 157 that create bigger problems than the ones they address. As we look forward I am optimistic because I believe new regulation will be designed to offer investors stable markets that disperse risk across a vibrant community of small but healthy private investment banks. This is the system that created the Reagan economic boom, and the Dow Jones Industrials went from 1,000 to 3,000 during his presidency. More important, the engines of our economy -- Microsoft, Home Depot, Intel, Dell, and Amgen, just to name a few -- were born of this http://www.inrich.com/cva/ric/search.PrintView.-content-articles-RTD-2008-10-05-0071.h... 10/6/2008
  2. 2. Printer-Friendly Version Page 2 of 2 simple yet elegant system. The old system of partner-based investment banks managed risk better because the people getting the bonuses were also the people on the hook if things did not work out. Some economists estimate that investors paid $5 billion to $10 billion more for financial services under the old system. Even if that were true, it's a bargain when compared with the $1 trillion (or $1,000 billion) capital infusion it will take to heal the banking system. Richard Tullo is a securities analyst and trader with more than 20 years of experience. During the late 1990s he brought more than 40 technology companies public as a NASDAQ market maker for Hambrecht & Quist and for Cowen and Co. From 2001-2004, Tullo was an investment analyst for an activist hedge fund in New York. He is now a private investor. Contact him at rtullo@aol.com. Go Back News | Sports | Entertainment | Living | Shopping/Classifieds | Weather | Opinion | Obituaries | Services/Contact Us ©2008 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General company. Terms & Conditions | Site Map -- Part of the GatewayVa Network -- webmaster@inrich.com http://www.inrich.com/cva/ric/search.PrintView.-content-articles-RTD-2008-10-05-0071.h... 10/6/2008

×