Attaining Thought Leadership


Published on

Highlights of The Bloom Group’s Survey
on How Professional Services Firms
are Developing, Capturing and Marketing
Their Intellectual Capital

Published in: Business, Education
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Attaining Thought Leadership

  1. 1. Attaining Thought Leadership Highlights of The Bloom Group’s Survey  on How Professional Services Firms  are Developing, Capturing and Marketing  Their Intellectual Capital September 2006 Boston, MA © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  2. 2. Defining Our Terms = “Intellectual  “Thought  Capital” Leadership” The expertise of a professional services  Intellectual capital that has been codified  firms’ experts (present and past) that  and marketed ‐‐ and (most important) that  embodies the knowledge and methods they  the market views as superior use to solve client problems • For most professional firms, an  aspiration, not a reality – Not a tag to be slapped on any white  • “IC” for short paper or book you write • Often not codified; many times it’s “in  • Signs of thought leadership: their heads” – … A bestselling book • Key role of marketing: – … Dozens of speaking requests – Codifying IC when it’s not  – … A Harvard Business Review article  – Creating awareness of it in the most  that generates many reprint sales (that  effective and efficient ways possible are not from your firm!) © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  3. 3. Focus of The Bloom Group Study • How important is it for professional services firms to attain thought  leadership? • What leads to thought leadership? • What is marketing’s role in helping firm experts become recognized  as thought leaders? • What marketing activities or programs are better than others at  establishing thought leadership? © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  4. 4. Research Process • Created structured online survey  questionnaire May-June – 28 questions for marketing and non‐ marketing managers July-Sept. • Solicited respondents through email – From Bloom Group and PM Forum databases Sept. • Analyzed data – Overall, across all respondents – Marketing vs. non‐marketing respondents – Size of firm – Type of firm (consulting, IT services, etc.) – “Leaders” and “laggards”  – Respondents who said their IC was “far superior” vs.  those who said their IC was “inferior” or “far  inferior” © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  5. 5. Who Responded: A Look at the 179 Survey Participants  Types of Firm: Sizes of Firm: Roles in Firm: Most consultancies, some IT  About half over and half under  About half CMOs and other marketing  services, law, accounting and  $100 million in annual revenues managers;  training firms one‐third CEOs, MDs or heads of  practices/service lines • 61% consulting • 35% less than $25m • 26% for CMO/marketing head  • 10% IT services • 13% for $25m‐$50m • 21% for other marketing managers • 8% law • 5% for $51m‐$100m • 13% for CEO/managing director • 5% accounting • 17% for $101m‐$500m • 20% for head of practice or  • 5% training and development service line • 5% for $501m‐$1b • 2% research • 21% other • 25% for over $1b • 1% engineering • 10% other © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  6. 6. Finding No. 1:  In Professional Services, the Key Factor in Marketing Effectiveness is  Strong IC 1 to 5 Rating: Strong IC  4.40 Referenceable client work  4.29 Strong sales/business development capabilities  4.15 Sound marketing strategy  4.02 Strong brand and image  3.99 Firm focus  3.94 Sufficient financial resources  3.83 Marketing staff with PS backgrounds  3.75 Recognized experts already on staff  3.75 Average ratings on a scale of 1=not at all important to 5 =of highest importance © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  7. 7. Who Values Thought Leadership the Most? Training &  Law Accounting IT Services Consulting Development 5 4 Average rating of  the importance of  4.71 4.43 4.47 4.44 strong IC for  3 effective marketing 3.75 2 1 0 No. 1 No. 7 No. 2 No. 2 No. 1 Ranking on list of 9  (tied for last) (tied with strong  key factors in  brand & image) marketing  effectiveness © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  8. 8. Finding No. 2:  Firms With Strong IC are Far More Likely to Generate Substantial Market  Awareness and Business Leads Than Firms with Weak IC Response Percent: Very effective 31% IC Leaders 5% IC Laggards Effective 50% IC Leaders  5% IC Laggards Average 13% IC Leaders  24% IC Laggards Ineffective 6% IC Leaders  48% IC Laggards Very ineffective 0% IC Leaders  19% IC Laggards  © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  9. 9. What Thought Leadership Can Do Thinker Concept Market Impact Business reengineering Creates blockbuster book (2 million copies) Michael Hammer/ Turns ex‐computer science professor into business guru CSC Index Boosts Index’s revenue in 7 years from $40m to $250m Customer loyalty  Rescues Bain & Co. from bankruptcy Frederick  management Reichheld Fuels a market for CRM software Companies that are  Two mega‐bestselling books (“Good to Great,” “Built to  Jim Collins “built to last”  and go  Last”); mega‐conference speaking fees from “good to great” Profitable growth,  Bestselling author and advisor/confessor to the CEO (Jack  Ram Charan executing strategy Welch, Jacques Nasser, Lawrence Bossidy et al) Competitive strategy Helped launch consultancy Monitor Co. Michael Porter Reigning strategy guru and Harvard Business School star Knowledge worker and  31 books and numerous Harvard Business Review articles Peter Drucker dozens of other ideas 9 © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  10. 10. Hallmarks of Thought Leadership  What is it? What we do Having a single fundamental  Clearly define issue/problem to research; create a  Focus message theme statement/structure for the POV Coming up with a unique  Conduct literature searches to review other POVs on  Novelty diagnosis of the problem or  topic and position for “white space” solution Meeting a critical and specific  Gather evidence on prevalence and importance of  Relevance market need (making case for  problem through survey, case interviews and literature  action) surveys Proving that the solution you  From client work and analysis of best practice case  Validity offer is effective studies, collect examples of companies that have  followed the solution you prescribe Demonstrating you have a  Develop tool, frameworks and methodologies that  Practicality solution that can be  companies can use to solve the problem implemented Having tight, consistent logic Produce an early white paper that sets down the  Rigor message, arguments and evidence; test core  frameworks and methods with internal group Making a clear argument, with  Identify and eliminate jargon, unclear concepts, and  Clarity words and concepts that are easy  other confusing material from the POV to understand © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  11. 11. Finding No. 3:  The Average Professional Firms’ IC is not Thought Leadership 5 Respondents’ Rating  of Importance of  Characteristics of  Strong IC 4.35 4.26 4.23 4.21 3.92 3.87 3.68 (Scale of 1 to 5,  1=not at all a factor,  3=factor, 5=major  factor) 4 Respondents’  Rating of Quality of  Their IC on These  Characteristics (Scale of 1 to 5,  3.89 3.47 3.51 3.78 3.44 3.56 3.35 1=very poor,  3 3=average, 5=very  strong) Relevance Proof Clarity Practicality Depth Novelty Rigor © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  12. 12. Finding No. 4:  Developing Thought Leadership Requires Resources and Research IC Leaders IC Laggards 57% of resources devoted  41% of resources devoted to  to developing IC  developing IC  43% of resources devoted  59% of resources devoted to  to marketing IC marketing IC Favorite IC Development  Favorite IC Development  Techniques Techniques 1. Professionals develop their own  1. Professionals develop their own  ideas (75%) ideas (67%) 2. Research consortium (44%) 2. Marketing helps professionals  3. Marketing helps professionals  develop/capture ideas (38%) develop/capture ideas (38%) 3. Internal research group (14%) 4. Internal research group (25%) 4. Research consortium (0%) © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  13. 13. Resource Requirements for IC Development: Key Skills   Compelling Rigorous Substantive Communication Analysis Research Tasks Tasks Tasks • Organize and structure research  • Synthesize & analyze research  • Design research plan, case  data and findings for focus,  findings (analytic) interview guides and survey  novelty and rigor • Identify patterns/trends (creative) questionnaire • Write findings in clear,  • Develop descriptive & prescriptive  • Interview executives at client &  compelling prose frameworks and methods for  other best practice firms • Identify logic gaps, unsupported  making decisions • Write case study reports arguments and other POV  weaknesses • Conduct thorough lit. search • Interview/debrief consultants Skills Skills • High analytic and creative ability • Top‐notch business writing skills • General topic knowledge Skills • General topic knowledge   • Group facilitation • Strong mgt. interview skills • High analytic skills • Strong research, case, & survey  Sources of Talent design Sources of Talent • Consulting firms • Strong business writing skills • Business journalism • Business schools • Business research/lit. search • Academic/management  • Research firms publications • Freelance writing • Business journalism Sources of Talent • Academia, business journalism,  research firms © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  14. 14. Intellectual Capital R&D Process Can Be Lengthy • Business reengineering Three years • Jim Collins’ ideas Five years • Most ideas that become “thought leadership” At least 6-9 months © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  15. 15. Finding No. 5:  Thought Leadership Can Level the Playing Field for the Smaller  Professional Firm Group A Group B Group C Group D $0‐25M $25‐100M $101M‐$1B >$1B Our IC is far inferior 0% 0% 3% 3% Our IC is inferior  12% 19% 19% 13% Our IC is about the same 17% 35% 25% 33% Our IC is superior 56% 39% 41% 44% Our IC is far superior 15% 8% 13% 8% 71% 47% 54% 52% © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC
  16. 16. The Bloom Group The Bloom Group powers up marketing for professional services  firms. We specialize in helping professional services firms determine  their marketing strategy, attain thought leadership and grow their  business through effective thought leadership marketing and  campaign execution. Contact us at:  Tel: 978.335.4313 email: © 2006 The Bloom Group LLC