Milking the Rhino is an award-winning documentary that examines environmental conservationfrom the perspective of people who live in the midst of wildlife, and offers a complex, intimateportrait of two community-based conservation efforts in Kenya and Namibia.It explores the relationship between people and wildlife in Africa by following the Maasai people in Kenya and Himba people in Namibia.Milking the Rhino refers to leveraging local natural resources for self-determined development
The rationale for hosting this competition has five different perspectives.The MTR Innovative Solutions Showcase strived to engage students in 1. an experiential ethics education experience that engaged them emotionally, 2. helped develop entrepreneurial mindsets,3. provided a non-travel based global experience, 4. developed their appreciation for indigenous knowledge5. ultimately fostered user-centered design.>> I think it is important to talk about some of these aspects. Its hard to summarize the concepts/themes.I suggest that you read the rationale sections in the paper a couple of times and decide what you want to delve into. If I were you, I would spend 2 mins talking about the eng ethics aspects and then spend a few sentences on the other themes
1. The preliminary means of understanding the context and challenge was viewing and reflectingon the “Milking the Rhino” documentary. The other resources included Milking the Rhino studyguide, scholarly literature, and a discussion forum focused on the challenges illustrated in thefilm. 2. Students were provided a series of ten prompts which they were supposed to review before the screening. They were expected to discuss thedocumentary (with instructor) and the prompts (amongst themselves) and formulate their responses. 3. Students were challenged to understand and articulate the way the world looks from the Maasaior Himba people’s point of view. Their thoughts about the world or the people, places andproblems in the two case-studies in the documentary were secondary. 4. The ultimate goal was to empathize with the stakeholders, understand their context of use,unravel the sticky information and derive innovative product ideas from the lives of the usersthemselves, and to design innovative and sustainable solutions that empower the stakeholders.5. Students were challenged to make three-minute video clips of their solution to “milk the rhino”,i.e. leverage local natural resources to address a specific constraint to local livelihoods. Thevideo pitch could address any general or specific problem related to the indigenous peoples'livelihoods, including wildlife and natural resource management, access to income, famine,gender inequity, human rights, inter-generational conflict, child and maternal health, etc.6. Students had to identify the problem themselves and convince the referees that the problem was critical to the community.
Complementary and important points:An objective of the competition was to educate students on how to convey their ideas in a precise and concise manner. Articulatingcomplex ideas to a general audience is a crucial skill for entrepreneurs and social media likeYouTube provides an excellent medium to reach more people and garner more support. All video pitches were uploaded on YouTube - no other websites orvideo files were accepted. There were no project reports or presentations.
The student pitches were rated by a multi-disciplinary panel of five faculty members. These fivereferees represented the fields of engineering design, entrepreneurship, tourism anddevelopment, social structures in Africa, video production and human rights. The referees ratedevery team on a scale of 1-10 on ten rating criteria.
Sample solutions…there are videos on YouTube
Two student quotesTime management and collaboration created challenges for the teams. They wanted clearly defined objectives and expectations!>>> the point is that this is exactly what we want them to learn…most things in the real world do not have specific objectives and expectations defined…we want students to thrive in a chaotic environment and create value with minimal resources!!!
The 2011 Milking the Rhino Innovative Solutions Showcase will be a global competition open to students from across the United States and beyond. The current prize money is about $2,500. Stay updated on mtrsolutions.weebly.com>> get the people excited!The faculty team is also interested in exploring the notion of emotional engagement with suchchallenges as an effective pedagogy for deeper engineering ethics education.
Milking the RhinoInnovative Solutions Showcase Amanda Perez + Khanjan MehtaHumanitarian Engineering & Social Entrepreneurship (HESE) Program The Pennsylvania State University
HESE: Convergence for Impact Affordable Greenhouses Solar Food Dehydrator Mashavu Telemedicine Business Networking
Milking the Rhino: The Documentary • Jeannie Magill, Originator and Co-Producer • Kartemquin Films and Bullfrog Productions • How the Maasai and Himba Milked the Rhino: Leveraged natural resources (wildlife) to empower own community by tourism and conservation www.milking therhino.org/film.php
Indigenous Knowledge…is the accumulated experience, wisdom and know-howof a local environment that has been developed overmany generations through careful observation, listening,experimentation and adaptation
Educational GoalsIndigenous Knowledge Ethics & Self and User Centered Determination Design & HESE Innovation & Global Engagement Entrepreneurship
The Challenge • Empower indigenous communities to sustainably utilize their cultural and natural resources • Engage students to identify pressing issues and design sustainable and creative solutions
Competition Guidelines• Video pitch of indigenous problem and innovative solutions• 3 minute video uploaded to Youtube.com• 1-4 students per video, external advisor permitted if acknowledged in video• Videos are public and must abide by all copyright regulations http://mtrsolutions.weebly.com/solution-guidelines.html
Judging Criteria: 5 member interdisciplinary panel • Specific problem is articulated • Appropriate for context and population Problem • Addresses African problem • Innovative, practical, feasible • Economically sustainable Solution • Potential for Scale Up? • Pitch has logical Flow • Audio and visual are professional, entertain Video and intrigue
MTR-ISS Sponsors Farrell Center for Corporate Innovation and Entrepreneurship
Sample Solutions • Simple and inexpensive method of extracting Avocado seed oil for sale to cosmetic industry. • Making jewelry from indigenous resources
Assessment Results• Focus groups:• Global awareness, teamwork, communication and collaboration skills – constraints and challenges of the competition – impact of student learning relative to the competition• All students agreed that this competition helped them better understand the challenges and opportunities facing indigenous people
Assessment Results• “I learned that designing low cost engineering solutions can be successful for people with economic hardship”• “The idea of learning about your users is important [in order] to know your users”• Time management and collaboration created challenges for the teams. They wanted clearly defined objectives and expectations!
Critical Reflection• Global Education • Entrepreneurship• Q • Q
Critical Reflection• Indigenous Knowledge + Western Knowledge• Development Ethics & Self Determination• Innovation and Entrepreneurship• Global Engagement• Context-Driven + User-Centered Design• Systems Design
Is it worth it?• Student teams – “Random” Students – Integrated into classes – Real Ventures• University Competition?• Global Competition?