How Did All These People Get Here? Looking
Beyond Level 1 Outcomes in Live Events
Michael Baffuto, CCMEP
Director, CME Pro...
Disclosure/Disclaimer
• Disclosure:
– Employee of Integrity Continuing Education
• Disclaimer:
– Information presented, un...
Objectives
At the conclusion of this session, participants should be
better able to:
•Describe key considerations for deve...
What Is Audience Generation?
• For clarity, audience generation in this
presentation refers to promotion of a free,
live C...
Social Media
• Application of social media to CME is becoming increasingly
worthwhile1
• Creates large opportunity for inn...
Expected Rates of Returns
According to Google
Delivery Method Expected Rate of Return
Mail1
1%-4.4%
Email2
1.73%
Fax3
0.5%...
Strengths and Weaknesses: Direct Mail
Strengths
• Consistent response rates
• High degree of
personalization possible
• Pr...
Strengths and Weaknesses: Email
Strengths
• Inexpensive
• Fast
• Popular form of
communication
• HTML affords high degree
...
Strengths and Weaknesses: Fax
Strengths
• Highly customizable
• Fast
• Inexpensive
• Requires less development
• Quality o...
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Database Marketing
Strengths
• Prior relationship
with recipient
• Fast
• Free
• Possible to tem...
Data Matters
• Purge duplicates
• Ensure correct names, titles, and addresses
• The more cleaning you can do before sendin...
Registration Collection
• Make registration simple
– Web forms (3 click rule!)
– Toll-free phone number
– Perforated mail/...
Follow-up
• It is imperative that you follow-up with a prospective
participant after they have registered
– Use preferred ...
Comparison of Registration Attrition
Rates with Follow-up vs No Follow-up
Percent of Registrants who Participated in Live ...
Assessing the Effectiveness of Mail, Fax, and Email
Invitations for Live CME Event Audience Generation
• Retrospective ana...
Data Inclusions
• Compared data inclusion criteria:
– 1.0-2.0 hour live regional workshop activity
– Primary care physicia...
Number of Invitations Sent
Date on file. Integrity Continuing Education.
Method of Registration and Discovery
Method of Discovery Method of Registration
%ofTotalRegistrations
%ofTotalRegistration...
Audience Generation Mechanism
Return Rates
Date on file. Integrity Continuing Education.
Rate of Attendance Based on Method
of Discovery and Registration
Discovery Method Registration Method
%ofRegistrantsAttend...
Cost Per Registration and Attendee By
Audience Generation Mechanism
Reflective of per invite costs of $0.75 for mail, $0.2...
Assessing the Effectiveness of Mail, Fax, and Email Invitations for
Live CME Event Audience Generation Conclusions
• Datab...
Best Practices for Live Meeting
Audience Generation
• Know your audience
• Have good data, but don’t get lost in it
• Give...
Thank you!
Questions?
Twitter: @mbaffuto
Email: mbaffuto@integrityce.com
25
How Did All These People Get Here? Looking Beyond Level 1 Outcomes in Live Events (Baffuto)
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

How Did All These People Get Here? Looking Beyond Level 1 Outcomes in Live Events (Baffuto)

184

Published on

Published in: Education
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
184
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
2
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

How Did All These People Get Here? Looking Beyond Level 1 Outcomes in Live Events (Baffuto)

  1. 1. How Did All These People Get Here? Looking Beyond Level 1 Outcomes in Live Events Michael Baffuto, CCMEP Director, CME Programming Integrity Continuing Education, Inc.
  2. 2. Disclosure/Disclaimer • Disclosure: – Employee of Integrity Continuing Education • Disclaimer: – Information presented, unless otherwise noted, is derived from my own professional experience.
  3. 3. Objectives At the conclusion of this session, participants should be better able to: •Describe key considerations for developing an audience generation plan •List expected return rates for common audience generation methods •Develop audience generation plans in accordance with activity expectations and allotted budget
  4. 4. What Is Audience Generation? • For clarity, audience generation in this presentation refers to promotion of a free, live CME activity to a targeted group of physicians • Audience generation forms for discussion: – Direct mail – Email – Fax – Database marketing
  5. 5. Social Media • Application of social media to CME is becoming increasingly worthwhile1 • Creates large opportunity for innovation2 • Data related to social media use by healthcare providers is inconsistent3 • Merit of social media as audience generation tool requires further investigation • Very important to overall digital strategy, but adjunctive to traditional audience generation 1. Wang AT, et al. Mayo Clinic Proceedings. 2012;87(12):1162-1170. 2. Cheston CC, et al. Academic Medicine. 2013;88(6):893-901. 3. McGowan BS. Available at: http://www.slideshare.net/cmeadvocate/utilization-of-social-media-outlets-to- enhance-medical-education-impact-0102bsm. Accessed February 27, 2014.
  6. 6. Expected Rates of Returns According to Google Delivery Method Expected Rate of Return Mail1 1%-4.4% Email2 1.73% Fax3 0.5%-8% Database Marketing ?? 1. Direct Marketing Association of America. 2. DMDatabases. 3. Quirk’s Marketing Research Review.
  7. 7. Strengths and Weaknesses: Direct Mail Strengths • Consistent response rates • High degree of personalization possible • Printing and database advancements have increased ease of use • Data is readily available Weaknesses • Expensive • Relatively slow • Time consuming to manage • Requires heavy production involvement
  8. 8. Strengths and Weaknesses: Email Strengths • Inexpensive • Fast • Popular form of communication • HTML affords high degree of customization • Green Weaknesses • Open and click rates are imperfect measurement • Advanced production requires design knowledge • Requires regulatory knowledge • Have to keep opt out records • Spam/image filters
  9. 9. Strengths and Weaknesses: Fax Strengths • Highly customizable • Fast • Inexpensive • Requires less development • Quality of data well known Weaknesses • Personalization may increase costs • May require equipment upgrades or outsourcing for high volume • Have to keep opt out records • Involves Telephone Consumer Privacy Act
  10. 10. Strengths and Weaknesses: Database Marketing Strengths • Prior relationship with recipient • Fast • Free • Possible to template • Regularly scheduled • Strong data Weaknesses • Repeated communication often unwanted • Not always relevant • May require dedicated staff • Requires opt-in and management of opt-out records
  11. 11. Data Matters • Purge duplicates • Ensure correct names, titles, and addresses • The more cleaning you can do before sending out recruitment materials the better • Removing inactive contacts from mailing lists goes a long way to improving deliverability • There are services available to assure clean data, such as the National Change of Address Service • For data purchased, expect 95% deliverability or better – Less than 95% - change your vendor • Highly specific data criteria will lead to exponentially fewer records Derived from: www.frugalmarketing.com and Direct Marketing Association of America.
  12. 12. Registration Collection • Make registration simple – Web forms (3 click rule!) – Toll-free phone number – Perforated mail/fax back forms • Collect all required information at the point of registration • Use the registration period as an opportunity to collect communication preferences • Ask them about the method of discovery • Provide opportunity to opt in to future communication
  13. 13. Follow-up • It is imperative that you follow-up with a prospective participant after they have registered – Use preferred method of contact • Provider confirmation with all meeting details and contacts/URLs for additional information
  14. 14. Comparison of Registration Attrition Rates with Follow-up vs No Follow-up Percent of Registrants who Participated in Live Meeting – Asthma Series Date on file. Integrity Continuing Education.
  15. 15. Assessing the Effectiveness of Mail, Fax, and Email Invitations for Live CME Event Audience Generation • Retrospective analysis of registration and participation data for 153 US regional CME workshops • Methods used for audience generation: – Integrity CE internal database email marketing – Direct mail invitations – Email blast marketing – Fax invitations • Objectives: – Which audience generation method was most successful? – Did the method of program discovery effect the likelihood of participant attendance?
  16. 16. Data Inclusions • Compared data inclusion criteria: – 1.0-2.0 hour live regional workshop activity – Primary care physician target audience – Physician registrations only • Total programs included in analysis: 153 • Total registrations included in analysis: 8,407 (4,707 participants)
  17. 17. Number of Invitations Sent Date on file. Integrity Continuing Education.
  18. 18. Method of Registration and Discovery Method of Discovery Method of Registration %ofTotalRegistrations %ofTotalRegistrations Date on file. Integrity Continuing Education.
  19. 19. Audience Generation Mechanism Return Rates Date on file. Integrity Continuing Education.
  20. 20. Rate of Attendance Based on Method of Discovery and Registration Discovery Method Registration Method %ofRegistrantsAttending %ofRegistrantsAttending Date on file. Integrity Continuing Education.
  21. 21. Cost Per Registration and Attendee By Audience Generation Mechanism Reflective of per invite costs of $0.75 for mail, $0.275 for email, and $0.31 for fax. Date on file. Integrity Continuing Education.
  22. 22. Assessing the Effectiveness of Mail, Fax, and Email Invitations for Live CME Event Audience Generation Conclusions • Database marketing was the most effective method of audience generation and had the highest rate of attendance • For first-time registrants: – Mail offered the highest rate of response – Email was the most frequent method of discovery – Fax invitations had the lowest cost per registrant and attendee • Attendees who: – Discovered the activity by fax had the highest rate of attendance, followed by mail, and email – Registered via online registration portals were least likely to attend the session
  23. 23. Best Practices for Live Meeting Audience Generation • Know your audience • Have good data, but don’t get lost in it • Give yourself enough time • Allocate adequate budget to achieve your attendance goals • Make your marketing materials the best that they can be • Set realistic expectations for rates of return • Be concerned with the correct outcome: registrations and participants • The registration process does not end when the participant signs up
  24. 24. Thank you! Questions? Twitter: @mbaffuto Email: mbaffuto@integrityce.com 25
  1. A particular slide catching your eye?

    Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

×