INTELLECTUAL CAPITAL FROM OGILVYONE WORLDWIDE CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? HOW BRANDS IN ASIA CAN BENEFIT FROM INTERACTING WITH CUSTOMERS THROUGH SOCIAL MEDIA. Asia Pacific Offices Australia, Bangladesh, China, Hong Kong, India, Indonesia, Japan, Korea, Malaysia, Myanmar, Nepal, New Zealand, Pakistan, Philippines, Singapore, Sri Lanka, Taiwan, Thailand, Vietnam Contacts For general information, please contact Lucy McCabe, Lead Consultant on (+65) 6213 7925 or email firstname.lastname@example.orgFor media queries, please contact Jane Fraser, Corporate Communications Director on (+65) 6213 7899 or email jane.fraser@ogilvy .com Join the conversation blog at www.the-open-room.com CONSULTANCY SERVICES FROMOgilvy is a wholly owned company within the WPP Group that provides a full range of marketing services to clients globally. OgilvyOne is the world’s leading one-to-one relationshipmarketing company, with a proven track record for some of the biggest and most admired brands. It has responded to clients’ changing needs by developing a deeper understanding of customer data and consumer behaviour by developing an integrated Consultancy Offering featuring Customer Management, Data Analysis, and Digital strategies.
Content ForewordForeword 2 The rise of social media across Asia is not a story about the importance of blogs. It is not about how people can collaborate on wikis or join in social networks. All of these are justIntroduction 3 pieces of the story. The bigger trend is that social media is allowing connections between people in a way that has never happened before. From international friendships to regionalWhat is Social Media? 5 conversations, the web is moving from a static collection of pages to a more social communications platform where word of mouth counts. What does this mean for brands?The Social Media evolution 7 That the world we are all marketing our products and services in is changing around us, because our customers are evolving along with the tools available to them. This is not justWhy should brands care? 9 happening in one part of the world, it is a global shift.Asia Market Analysis 11 Yet it is not happening in the same way in every country. The problem with much of the social media advice is that it is based on lessons learned in one part of the world withoutSocial Media dynamics 31 a more local connection. As a global agency, we face this cross cultural challenge often.Social Media planning 33 So much so, that it has led to the collaborative piece that you now hold in your hands. This is a study about the impact of social media across Asia and how it is helping to bring brandsMeasurement 36 to life. It was prepared by bringing together digital experts from more than 10 countries across the Ogilvy network. Top rated bloggers, digital strategists, public relations pros andTips for success 37 media planners all shared their expertise to develop a comprehensive look at Asia from market to market.Case studies 40 The result is a surprisingly fresh look at social media from the perspective of 12 differentHow to get started 48 countries across the Asia region. In this guide, you will see actionable insights, useful statistics, and relevant country-based information. When I first read it, I found it uniquelyReferences 49 useful. Since then, I have kept it beside me as I started to plan global social media strategyAcknowledgements 50 as an invaluable cultural resource to understand the state of social media in key markets. If you are trying to unlock the potential of social media, I suspect you will find this report similarly illuminating. Rohit Bhargava SVP, Digital Strategy & Founding Member of Ogilvys 360 Digital Influence Group Author, Personality Not Included (a guide for brands on using your personality for marketing)
IntroductionAll brands can have a social life. Big brands, small home grown brands, business brands,consumer brands and individuals who want to create their own ‘personal’ brand. Social mediais democratic by nature and the barriers to entry are relatively low.This study provides direction to brand marketers and digital consultants on how to design asocial media strategy in Asia as part of a brand’s overall digital strategy. It starts by definingsocial media, as well as giving insights into its similarities and differences across key Asianmarkets - China, Hong Kong, India, Indonesia, Japan, Korea, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore,Taiwan, Thailand and Vietnam. It then provides practical, hands on advice on what steps brandsshould take to plan their social media strategies along with frameworks and tips for success.As social media is changing, this is a dynamic study which invites you to share your questions,observations and experiences. By exchanging ideas, it will get more marketers to betterunderstand social media in Asia, and in turn deliver more effective solutions that not onlyenhance consumer’s lives but deliver deeper value to brands.This study does not have all the answers, but hopefully goes some way towards addressingthe key questions or at least stimulating the debate.Please join the conversation at www.the-open-room.com
05 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 06 What is Social Media? 1. Social Networking Platforms Sites that connect friends and their peer networks together spurred by user generated content of all forms. These networks are growing by the day to become habitual platforms for people Social Media is the combination of channels, platforms, communities, content1 and tools that to stay in touch. Often thought of as ‘interactive address books’, big players in Asia include power the phenomenon of peer to peer communication or ‘word of mouth’. Cyworld, Hi-5, Mixi, Friendster, Orkut, Facebook, Bebo and My Space. This breaks down into 6 areas [see Figure 1]: 2. Social Bookmarking Platforms 1. Social Networking Platforms This is an emerging area in the region riding on the back of the power of aggregation. These 2. Social Bookmarking Platforms sites aggregate and promote content on the web through indexing, user-collaboration and 3. Content, Applications & Media voting mechanisms to save time. Examples of this include del.icio.us, digg, Yahoo! Answers 4. Blogging Platforms and Wikipedia. 5. Social Gaming 6. Social Connectivity Tools 3. Content, Applications & Media There are a number of sites that are considered the forefathers of ‘Web2.0’, by making it easy Let’s describe these briefly in turn. to create, store and share content by putting that power in the user’s hands. These entities essentially host and store proprietary content of all forms, and because of their richness are becoming destinations in their own right. They also become the source of a lot of the content that users are publishing back into their social networks and include FlickR, You Tube and application developers such as slide.com. 4. Blogging Platforms Blogs and Bulletin Board Systems (BBS) continue to be a major source of social media providing platforms for communities to come together, opinions to be voiced (often anonymous) and discussion on a range of topics. These have evolved from the modern day form of a ‘public diary’ to a ‘broadcast platform’ for individuals to share their news and connect. The personal nature of blogs continues to remain popular particularly for entertainment and educational purposes as well as for citizen journalism. Today bloggers have credibility as public informers and as a result of RSS and micro-blogs, are highly inter-connected and collaborative. Key enablement platforms include blogger, blogspot, typepad, twitter and wordpress. 5. Social Gaming Asia would not be complete without the mention of social gaming and it will be interesting to see how this phenomena will spread. The internet has made it possible for users to connect and escape into gaming worlds where teams can compete and participate realtime against other gamers. These specialist sites include World of Warcraft and Ragnarok, and have a tribal following. 6. Social Connectivity Tools All of the above entities would not be able to operate if it wasn’t for the connectivity tools that power them – email, SMS, RSS feeds, instant messenger and live chat. Each of them fuel the dialogue and connectivity that make it the place to flirt, debate, game, share, exchange, vent. Platforms for deeper connections. Figure 1: Asia Social Media Landscape
07 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 08 The Social Media evolution Social media is an evolution in the development of social connectivity. In the offline world, people buy their newspapers to get their news. They take pictures, print them out, put them in an album and share with friends. They call their family for a chat. They send letters and birthday cards to loved ones. In the digital world, nothing has really changed, it’s just become so much easier. Technology has made things faster, more affordable and is able to deliver it on a larger scale making it accessible to everyone – from individuals to the smallest brand. SPEED – ability to connect faster SCALE – ability to reach far more people than ever before COST – ability to participate, create and generate content As a result, traditional media entities have taken note and seized the potential of the interconnected-ness of the consumer worldwide. BBC is among many to create its YouTube channel, AOL has invested USD850m in Bebo not to mention entrepreneurial players in the region such as Li Ka Shing’s USD120m punt in Facebook, the launch of a dedicated YouTube channel in India and the many VC funded social media entities that are popping up in China, Hong Kong, Korea, Japan and Malaysia. The list goes on. Social media has transformed the way people consume information, and that will continue to happen. News spreads faster, trends gather pace, people connect and information is available – to all - on an unprecedented level. And the implications are significant. If you’re not online for a few days let alone hours, you run the risk of being out of date. Social media launches stars. Take the Backdorm Boys in China, Duk-In Joo in Korea, Wan Wan in Taiwan, Kenny Sia in Malaysia and Mr Brown in Singapore. It also fails them. Take Edison Chan in Hong Kong and the high society exposés by Brian Gorrell in the Philippines. It’s also big for politics and news. Campaigns are being won and lost through social media in Asia, and the web is the platform for a new type of reporter - the citizen journalist. Take the election campaign in Malaysia and the amazing coverage of the China earthquake in Sichuan Province in early 2008. These examples are all evidence that social media is transforming the way consumers interact with each other online, and most importantly that people really do listen and trust what other people have to say. Humans are social beings, they like to share things, talk together and technology lets them do it on an unprecedented level. Ken Mandel Regional Managing Director, Yahoo! South East Asia
09 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 10 Why should brands Right now, the largest single group of users on the Internet today is in Asia. Half a billion in Asia care? Asian users. And that’s only 14% penetration. So when they get to 70% penetration which is where we are in the US and some parts of Europe, we’re talking about a couple of billion people. That’s a very, very big customer base. It’s a very diverse customer base but the There are 4 key reasons: internet can reach all of them once we get to that penetration level. So this is a really exciting place to be. 1. Social Media is big in Asia. Brands cannot underestimate the size of social media in Asia. Over 450 million consumers are Vinton Cerf engaging with social media, some of whom are as dependent on it as their Western counterparts, Vice President & Chief Internet Evangelist, Google Inc. if not more. When social media eventually goes mobile, the numbers reach over a billion, and this scale is something that brands cannot ignore. The consumer can now make a huge stink about something if they are not 2. Consumer opinion counts more than ever. happy about it. And so if a company isn’t going to be there online monitoring Consumers in Asia are talking about your brands whether you like it or not, and that opinion that and contributing to the discussion in a positive way, then they’re going has a huge impact on their views of a brand and consideration to purchase. 7 of the top 10 to pay the price. The most obvious examples are that simply a blogger is markets that rely most on ‘recommendations from consumers’ hail from the Asia region2. The unhappy with a product and will post something online and that then through internet is a platform that people listen to and learn about your brand. If you’re not participating Google, through search engines becomes a kind of mecca, a big kind of in the discussion or feeding into it, you are likely to lose. water fountain around which other disaffected users and consumers will gather. Now if the company doesn’t know that that website exists, or tries 3. Consumers are highly connected and harder to reach then before. to ignore it or worse knows that it exists and tries to crush it, then they are The diversity of Asia needs no reminder, and this further accentuates the need to understand going to experience serious problems. commonalities and differences in media repertoire as well as consumer motivations. Marketers are losing the ability to reach consumers in the way they used to as social media starts to Jeremy Wagstaff displace aspects of traditional brand advertising. Building a corporate website and driving Technology Commentator, BBC, WSJ, Loosewireblog.com traffic is simply not enough, and calls for brands to re-evaluate the way they reach their audiences. Brands that understand social media by creating a web of activity that can influence and surround the target audience are most likely to be effective. There’s not the same ability, the same physics of the old days where you buy a few things [media] and you reach your audience. Today, the audience is an aggregation of in some 4. The Y-Generation3 live their lives in social media and if you’re not talking to them, cases, thousands of individual points, individual blogs, destinations and sites that in totality someone else will. get the audience that a marketer is looking for. Social media creates a huge opportunity for brand marketers where they can connect with their target audience like never before. Though the importance of this media may be in its Kent Wertime infancy with some of the older demographic segments, there is no disputing that for the President, OgilvyOne Asia Y-Generation and future generations, social media is part and parcel of their daily lives. Brands that fail to appreciate this opportunity will risk losing an entire base of consumers in the future making social media not just a growth strategy but a defensive one too. You should try to embrace as many different forms of media as possible because different audiences are in different places. But you will see an increasing amount of, especially the younger generation that’s going to hang out online and be comfortable in communities and social media. And if you don’t market to them, or if you don’t have dialogues with them (not even market to them.) ... then you’re going to lose an entire customer base. Lee Kin Mun Founder & Blogger, Mrbrown.com
11 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 12 Asia Market Analysis: Asia Social Media Market Analysis The size of the pie Asia Social Media Statistics Population 2008 Forecast Internet Users 2008 Internet Penetration Forecast Estimated Social Media User (% Breakdown Forecast 2008 We estimate that just under a 3rd of the world’s online population or a staggering 456M users 2008) in Asia are actively consuming social media. There will always be differences in reported data but irrespective of whether it’s 450m or 470m or even 500m, the numbers are too big to be China 1,330,044,605 253,000,000 19.0% 202,400,000 ignored as social media becomes endemic in internet culture. What’s most important to Hong Kong 7,018,636 4,878,713 69.5% 3,902,970 understand is the vast differences in adoption and use of social media. India 1,147,995,898 60,000,000 5.2% 48,000,000 In Japan and Korea who arguably lead the world in terms of sophistication, it’s all about Indonesia 237,512,355 25,000,000 10.5% 20,000,000 ubiquitous access (mobile and PC internet) and rich functional engagement through intimate Japan 127,288,419 94,000,000 73.8% 75,200,000 social networking, open blogging and gaming. China, on the other hand has its social media roots in discussion, information gathering and sharing through public bulletin boards and Korea, South 49,232,844 34,820,000 70.7% 27,856,000 blogging with broadcast entertainment on the rise, and this pattern is being fast followed by Malaysia 25,274,133 14,904,000 59.0% 11,923,200 Taiwan from a much smaller base. Pakistan 167,762,040 17,500,000 10.4% 14,000,000 Other markets in the region vary significantly. In Hong Kong and Singapore which have high Philippines 92,681,453 14,000,000 15.1% 11,200,000 digital penetration and rich broadband, the role of social media is catching on but splits acutely between English and Chinese speaking dialects who are consuming the medium in different Singapore 4,608,167 4,026,400 87.4% 3,221,120 ways to augment their personal and professional networks. Taiwan 22,920,946 15,400,000 67.2% 12,320,000 Thailand 65,493,298 13,416,000 20.5% 10,732,800 India too has evolved its very own type of social media centering on personal and professional networking. Matrimonial sites are hot platforms for socially engaging, and LinkedIn finds its Vietnam 86,116,559 20,159,615 23.4% 16,127,692 highest demographics are Indians both at home and abroad. The opportunity for entertainment TOTAL ASIA 3,363,949,353 571,625,328 456,883,782 from the home of Bollywood needs no reminding as broadband penetration slowly increases. The Philippines, Vietnam and Malaysia have a thriving social media scene which cannot be TOTAL WORLD 6,676,120,288 1,463,632,361 31% ignored by brands. Social networking and blogging are the key platforms for expression extending from the leading portals. Entertainment is on the rise but still secondary. Even the Sources: i] www.internetworldstats.com [population and internet user forecast Jun 2008] - China, Hong Kong, India, Indonesia, likes of Indonesia and Thailand have embraced social media by providing a platform for Japan, South Korea, Malaysia, Pakistan, Philippines, Taiwan, Thailand, Vietnam, Total Asia Pacific and Total World. netizens to collaborate with each other and to reach out and learn from public blogs in ways ii] Singapore population www.internetworldstats.com and internet user forecast - IDA Jun 2008. iii] Social media estimates they couldn’t through traditional media. What is most important is that their high use of mobile based on calculation of 80% of forecast users reflecting endemic nature of social media amongst internet community. has already seen internet-enabled SMS services being offered in these markets to see mobile start to go social. Figure 2: Asia Social Media Statistics Figure 2 provides a macro view of what’s happening in social media to provide a sense of scale. To give a more balanced perspective, working with Ogilvy’s in-market digital specialists and a wide range of desk research, we have pulled together a view by market of the different ‘Who said that Asia was following?’ I mean, what statistics can you show me to prove that? motivations and trends - political, social, economic, cultural or otherwise – to help marketers ...It’s not the highest percentage of the population but the largest total aggregate block is in Asia. better understand what role social media is having in its consumer’s lives, the opportunities, If you look at blogs, a third of the bloggers in the world are in Japan. If you look at the developments and why it is gripping Asia overall. in mobile, a lot of that, the most cutting edge stuff is happening in places like Japan and Korea but increasingly China, India, Singapore, Hong Kong and Taiwan are very innovative new users of technology. Kent Wertime President, OgilvyOne Asia
15 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 16 Cluster 1: Leader Markets China, Korea, Japan CHINA SOUTH KOREA Prevalence of Social Media Prevalence of Social Media The sheer size and economic growth rate in China makes it a country to watch, for all brands in Broadband has determined the future for Korea’s technological advancement. Ubiquitous access to the region. As of July 2008, there were an official 253m4 online users with an estimated 200m broadband from the late 1990s has meant that early adoption of social media services and voice over consuming social media.The total represents a 56.2% year-on-year growth – up by 91 million from IP have become a way of life – when North American and European counterparts - were in their June of last year. Impressively, 84.7% of Chinese internet users are now accessing the Net via infancy. The result is the world’s most advanced digital usage across ages and demographics with broadband5 representing over 214m6 broadband users. The internet has also become a pivotal rich media content at the heart of the service. platform for entertainment along with eCommerce which has come of age, growing from RMB120b in turnover in 2001 to RMB1,020b18 in 2008. All this is set to grow even faster as broadband continues Dependence on Social Media to roll out. Social Networking Leaders Along with internet penetration, there were 500m mobile subscribers by the end of 20077. Out of Social networking is big business in Korea. Cyworld has had a significant effect on the market’s these mobile subscribers, 73.05m owners used their devices to go online8. Access via mobile phone internet culture by being the world’s first successful cyberworld (social network) on a mass scale is still mainly supplemental, and is rarely the main means, primarily leveraging the channel for (>18m accounts28), dominating and creating a consolidated platform where consumers can handle Instant Messenger (IM) and SMS. their social lives and more. Its mash-up of social networking, blogging, music and video-sharing has Dependence on Social Media drawn users whilst monetising itself through eCommerce – video and music – to become the world’s 2nd29 largest music/ video retailer behind iTunes. Speaking Out With approximately 48%30 of Korean’s population having a Cyworld account and 30%31 of its users Bulletin Board Systems (BBS) are at the heart of China’s social media with 10m9 posts published being in their 20s, it’s no surprise that its success has made little space for new entrants. Cyworld daily and 80%10 of Chinese sites running their own BBS. An active BBS is the most valuable has also created a language in Korea. Apart from the abbreviations commonly used in Korea amongst component of a brand’s digital campaign11 and an essential social element to all sites. Monitoring network users, the individuals home page or ‘hompy’ is commonly talked about. Personalised to conversations on BBS is an invaluable gauge to determine what brand perception is. include favourite ‘streaming music’, Koreans now only buy music digitally (CD is for the older Blogging, while not anonymous, has also taken off, with blogging listed among the top ten generation) and competently stream it as background music to their home page as well as to their applications for Chinese netizens. 107m people say they use blogs and personal spaces, approximately mobile devices. To date, over 200m songs have been downloaded on Cyworld generating over 42.3% of the Chinese Netizenry. US$100m32 in sales revenues. Entertainment-lovers Mobile Ubiquity An overwhelming majority of Chinese citizens use social media for digital music and video, utilizing Rich media and mobile come hand in hand. Mobile TV is passé in Korea. What people can do online, digital channels as their entertainment superhighway. Of the top ten applications, the three biggest they can do via their mobile, and the channel is used to store and view downloaded content from the entertainment apps are music, video, and online games. Internet music remains the biggest, with web while on the go. Cyworld, backed by Korea’s largest telco (SK) has ensured ubiquitous access use rates of 84.5%, or 214m people and internet video use at 71%, and online gaming at 58.3%12. and removed all barriers including pricing so that individuals can really experience the opportunities They are major drivers of internet use growth in China. This is reflected in the rise of YouTube- presented by web2.0. The strategy has worked with 43%33 of SK’s revenues coming from Cyworld like video broadcasting platforms such as youku.com and tudou.com, which deliver as much as itself. As a result, high quality mobile phones are used to create content with ease and post them 100m13 video views daily to 12m users directly and through national broadcast sites. These channels to Cyworld in seconds where they can be voted, commented on and vy for the home page status. address the demand for user and professionally generated content delivered at speeds that are Trusted Communities faster than in the United States. Word of mouth is a very powerful phenomenon in Korea. Koreans tend to find safety in numbers so Social Networking vertical blog forums are core sources for information gathering and sharing through the leading portals of Naver (31m visitors/ month34) and Daum (29m visitors/ month35). Being connected is a core part of a young person’s life in urban China with over half14 of netizens making new friends online and 90%15 of young people using IM to connect with their friends. It’s not uncommon for a Korean to post a question on one of the popular question and answer sites The instant connectivity with friends is what drives the growth of BBS, IM usage and in turn, such as ‘Knowledge In’ from Naver to request an answer within 24 hours, and to show thanks using social networks. ‘knowledge points’. This type of collaborative usage makes the internet a powerful and dependable resource. However, unlike Wikipedia which focuses on editorial accuracy and integrity of content, Tencent ‘rules the space’16 having evolved from an Instant Messenger company circa 199917 to a the posted answer will likely have no mechanism to check for accuracy. Instead, the Korean puts social media empire that includes one of China’s most popular social networks, Q Zone, as well trust in the integrity of the online respondent and the speed in getting an answer. as a leading portal and online game platform. In addition to community collaboration, these forums are becoming broadcast platforms and most Two well-funded companies with social networking offerings more like those popular in the west recently have been used for socio-political means to mobilize and generate support. For example, are also vying with Tencent for dominance. 51.com has been successful in penetrating lower-tier Agora, the online forum in Daum was recently used to organize passive, candle-lit protests offline cities and hinterland provinces with 120m18 users and plans to move into the gaming space with against the governments’ decision to resume the import of American beef. Digital media was used ‘Giant’ the online game developer. Xiaonei.com, the Facebook-like, campus-based social network to orchestrate, co-ordinate and amplify the activity, broadcasting the live demonstrations. which raised a whopping $430m and. enjoys a dominant market share in traditional social networking according to Shanghai-based iResearch, is now targeting the students and white collar workers. Intimate Blogging The early movers with large user bases (and war chests) may well continue to dominate the market, The primary motivation36 for blogging in Korea is to communicate with acquaintances by sharing but newcomers like Kaixin001, which has soared in popularity just in recent months, may still play their thoughts. Culturally, there are some cultural differences37 in the way personal blogs in Korea an important role. There is little doubt that social networking will continue to take hold in the way are constructed from those in the West. In general, Western blogs comprise originated content - it has in Japan and Korea, but without one company dominating the way Mixi and Cyworld do in discussions, photographs, pictures – designed to stimulate opinion and discussion. However, most those respective markets. of the content you find on a Korean blog is an alternative form of expression. Blogs tend to comprise a highly personal aggregation of ‘cut and pasted’ content from existing mainstream media sources creating a ‘digital scrapbook’ or virtual filing mechanism. The intimacy of blogging thus makes it a more private platform for marketers.
17 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 18 Gaming Addicts Gaming in Korea is a key pillar and somewhat of a national obsession. It’s not uncommon for teenagers or even young businessmen to head off after school/ work to one of the PC Bangs (or internet cafes) to finesse skills in Lineage II – Korean’s most popular online game double the size of World of Warcraft with 14m users38. Successful online gamers39 are paid professionals becoming sporting superstars in their own right with endorsements and celebrity status. Whilst gaming cuts across all demographics and ages, the alarming appeal to very young netizens with 65% of 5 years old40 using the internet to play online games has potential negative social ramifications. This raises challenges to brands who want to find an ethical and socially responsible means to tap into this passion. JAPAN Prevalence of Social Media Social media has become an important part of modern Japan by providing a virtual extension to its traditional emphasis on personal relationships. Combined with pervasive broadband & mobile (3+G) internet, it provides the basis for a strong social media culture satisfying an estimated 75m users . 19 Dependence on Social Media Blog Nation Japan is a nation of bloggers. ‘Japanese‘ is the most used language in the blogosphere and the highest blog readership in the world (74%)20. Blogging is used habitually to create a positive record of one’s thoughts using pictures, videos and text much the same way as a diary. Anonymous blogging and the creation of avatars indicate that the Japanese do not like to speak out overtly and be seen as confrontational. This reserved cultural reality is starting to change as younger Japanese, brought up with technology, are increasingly using it to share their views and opinions publicly and to speak out. They are also able to plug into what everyone’s blogging about using a Japanese based blog search engine called Kizasi.jp which aggregates the most popular key words from 7m authors and 171m entries. Key blog sites include Yahoo! blog, Ameba, Livedoor, Hatena diary, so-net and cocolog, but the most popular consumer blogs are tech blogs such as Gigazine, Gizmodo and Engadget21 as well as some celebrity or “Otaku” blogs – Akiba and Shokotan. In addition to typical blog sites, Tokyo consistently has the highest daily twitter activity out of all the global cities22 which fits in with its blogging profile. Not so-Social Networking Local Japanese social networking sites adhere to the traditional maintenance of close personal relationships by extending connections to one or two degrees of separation versus western grown sites promoting ‘six degrees of separation’. With 90% of Japanese not being able to read English, it’s no surprise that Japan’s social media users have opted for localized domestic sites and content, for use across PC and mobile platforms. Not surprisingly, social network sites have already consolidated versus other parts of the region due to its controlled ‘invitation-only policy’ and the power of word of mouth popularizing primary sites. Mixi is the ‘de facto’ social networking site for Japanese-speaking netizens with 80%23 market share, having 10m users (1/8 of the wired market) and a staggering 11b page views a month. Mixi provides a bird’s eye view of one’s relations on the net making it easy to connect and maintain contact through the diary, footprint, forum and message functions. It has become an entrenched daily communication tool for young netizens using it to listen, share music, chat and track back to friends. Gree with 4m users24 is its closest competitor and has taken a different slice of the market by targeting older professionals and providing customized content to cater for the more discerning consumer. Both platforms are accessed via the mobile phone with 30%25 of Mixi and 25% of Gree26 users, and this has spurned the rise of dedicated mobile social networking sites such as Mobage-town with 9.87m users27 indicating the trend of things to come.
19 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 20 Cluster 2: Developing Markets Hong Kong, Singapore, Taiwan, India HONG KONG Prevalence of Social Media Hong Kong has one of the highest internet penetrations and breadth of broadband (2m subscribers ) 41 in the developing world, with over 72% of the population online42. There are an estimated 3.9m netizens dipping into social media in Hong Kong. Though they are active, social media in itself is still quite a passive exercise for the majority of Hong Kongers making it ‘not as’ social as one might expect. Dependence on Social Media Social Networking Polarisation Just over half (53.2%)43 of active internet users have a social network profile in Hong Kong. This splits broadly between Facebook (1m users44) frequented by a slightly older, western-educated set and the locally targeted Xanga (1.8m users)45 dominated by slightly younger Hong Kong Chinese. Though these players hold marketshare, the way in which these networks are used varies considerably. Facebookers in Hong Kong tend to be highly collaborative and participative in their networks by ‘poking’ their friends or updating their pictures to keep in touch, and entertain. The motivation for Xanga, however, is far more reserved. For young Hong Kong secondary school students, it’s a way to express oneself and to passively share thoughts on things that matter to them amongst their inner circle – an evolution in some ways from personal blogging and instant messenging46. The novelty for social networking in a country where proximity provides little barrier to communication, and where mobile communication is prevalent (157% penetration47), does beg some questions opening up the opportunity for more mobile social networking similar to Korea and Japan. Knowledge-Thirsty As the ‘advertising capital of the world’ (US$7B48) with the highest per capita spending, it’s no coincidence that Hong Kongers value the open, honest and less commercialised opinions that they find in social forums and professional blogs. This strong faith in ‘word of mouth’ is evidenced with 93%49 of online users claiming that they rely most on ‘recommendations from consumers’ and 65.8%50 of active internet users claiming to have read a blog. This trend has resulted in the birth of homegrown forums such as the highly popular Cantonese site - discuss.com.hk (8%marketshare51) with 1m52 registered users - hosting 9,00053 discussion boards from topics as broad as the military to western art galleries. Other sites include Yahoo’s hk.knowledge.yahoo.com, and interest-led sites such as forum.hkgolden.com and miniforum.org. The accessibility and openness in sharing opinion and information on these exchanges is an important social media success story in Hong Kong particularly amongst Traditional Chinese users. These sites will continue to remain popular, as will sites on the mainland that are accessed through Baidu search. Surprisingly, political blogs or citizen journalism which are gathering pace in mainland China are practically non existent in Hong Kong. This is mainly attributed54 to a relatively open freedom of expression, as Hong Kongers don’t yet feel that they have to treasure or tap these new outlets to get heard. Image-Obsessed Youth The young Hong Kong Chinese are more worried about their appearance than their US counterparts with 39%55 citing ‘looking good’ and 53% citing ‘overweight’ as key fears. It therefore comes as no surprise that this ‘image-obsessed generation’loves to go online and check out Canto-gossip, film, fashion and music hits from entertainment and blog sites in Hong Kong and the mainland. Celebrity blogs such as the (now infamous) Edison Chen Koon-hei and Eason Chan Yick-shun sites are popular amongst fans as are rich media video destinations like YouTube and its Chinese equivalent to view the official and uncut versions before sharing them with their friends.
21 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 22 SINGAPORE TAIWAN Prevalence of Social Media Prevalence of Social Media With over 80%63 broadband penetration, it is hardly surprising that this connected nation has found Taiwan can claim to be the first country in the world to have installed broadband infrastructure space for social media. The Government is supportive of digital as a progressive platform for island-wide, providing connectivity to remote communities. Internet users exceed 60% of the economic growth and its investment in wireless broadband64, the ultra high speed digital highway population and an increasing number, 47% of internet connections are broadband76. The government infrastructure65 and commitment to nurturing digital talent is testament to this. Aided by English- has committed the country to being on a par with the US by 201077. The high penetration of literacy (the country’s official business language), it has meant that Singaporeans have been fast broadband enables Taiwanese to access large amounts of content and empowers a digitally savvy to adopt Western social media behaviours. country with an estimated 12m78 social media users. Dependence on Social Media Dependence on Social Media Blog Express Nation of Newscasters According to a survey, 51%66 of Singaporeans trust a blog as much as they do traditional media In a country where sensationalism in traditional media channels is commonplace, citizen journalism and the Google ‘Blogger’platform now ranks 5th67 on the top 100 most visited sites for Singapore. is growing in Taiwan due to widespread dissatisfaction with the range and quality of traditional Despite the growth of this medium, the reality of the internet being a completely ‘open channel’ news sources. The proliferation of social media channels to express opinions, comment on the for expression is some way off. An unofficial blog etiquette has evolved in Singapore with slanderous news, and share content, has brought about competition and altered the traditional business model bloggers facing extreme penalties. That said, the Government welcomes entrepreneurial thinking of mainstream media. UDN and Chinatimes are at the forefront of this trend with Apple Daily and and positive expression resulting in the evolution of an active and influential blogger community Liberty Times also allowing commentary on their sites. which brands are starting to tap in the City State. Star Bloggers Social Networking Wan Wan. Amaryliss. Amykaku. Taiwan is a nation filled with star bloggers exuding mass appeal. Social networking & forums are the dominant sub-category online, representing 10.2%68 of all Across its active internet base, blogging has become a popular channel for the propagation of Internet visits by Singapore users and evidenced with the meteoric rise of social networks. Friendster individual opinions with 86.6% having read a blog, and 70.9% having started a blog themselves. dominates the landscape with 13.31% marketshare69 and 940k70 unique visitors per month to its Blogging in Taiwan has led to a yearly blogger’s conference “TW Bloggers BoF” over 600 Taiwanese closest rival Facebook’s 495k71 unique visitors (the 3rd largest market penetration for Facebook in Bloggers. The event is self-organized, by local enthusiastic bloggers, and sponsored by the Taiwan Asia Pacific). Though the relative newcomer has continued to grow +7.5% a month since January Government Information Office as well as traditional media like TVBS, China TV, China Times ISP’s 2008, Friendster is not likely to give up its dominance so easily as it invests aggressively to retain and web 2.0 companies79. its young captive audience. Though other social networks do register72 such as Multiply, Windows Live Spaces and Xanga, the reality is that the battleground is firmly set between Facebook and Socially Charged Friendster. BBS in Taiwan is big, with over 1.84m unique visitors a month. What makes these networks so popular is their simplicity and accessibility. Singaporeans spend Social media is also coming of age with 63.1% of Taiwanese maintaining their own social networking a significant amount of time online a day, and being quite a reserved populus, social networks site and engaging with various forms of social media from uploading photos (69%), to watching provide a culturally acceptable way for connecting. Singaporean netizens are the most likely73 videos (89.25) and downloading podcasts (33%). Despite being highly engaged with the most popular people in Asia to visit and check out other people’s profiles on a social network demonstrating entertainment forms of social media, downloading music is not one of Taiwan’s top social media its power as a channel to reach out and connect with others non intrusively. activities.80 For similar reasons, the anonymity aspect of Forums has allowed them to become important social Mobile Ready exchanges for interest groups. One example is the hardwarezone community which is the 18th Taiwan has more than 24m mobile subscribers, with over 6.5m on 3G.81 Despite mobile penetration, most visited site74 in Singapore addressing the needs of technorati. Other specialist forums include mobile internet is still a minority activity with only 9.25% of Taiwanese going online using a mobile fashionation.wordpress.com, singaporecarsforum.com and expatsingapore. These are obvious device primarily because of the high cost82 Among mobile internet users, downloading ringtones platforms for brands to reach niche audiences, and with 24%75 of Singaporeans claiming that the (38.36%) and browsing (21.14%) are the most popular activities. online presence of brands ‘significantly’ increases their interest, becomes a compelling platform for branded placement.
23 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 24 INDIA Prevalence of Social Media India is one of the fastest growing online markets in the region with a total of 60m56 and projected to grow to 71m57 users and 10.5m broadband users by 2011. The internet’s appetite from the Indian populus, centers around its use for socializing (chatting/ networking and Instant Messenger) as well as entertainment, finding matrimonial matches, and professional advancement58. This reflects the demographic skew of the internet in India which favours educated and affluent, English speaking Indians rather than Hindi or other dialects. In terms of mobile numbers India is second only to China in the region, with 142 million59 mobile subscribers, double that of landline owners. The channel promises to be big for the future with licenses just issued for 3G60 circumventing the regulatory issues that, until now, have impeded growth for anything beyond basic SMS and photo uploading for social media. Dependence on Social Media A Happy Threesome. TV. Internet. Mobile. TV, internet, and mobile have found each other. India is one of the few markets that tie on and offline channels in an integrated multi-channel social media marketing mix. With their mobile devices, friends and online buddies send messages via short code to television programs which are displayed at the bottom of popular TV programs. And with the partnership of Zee Dish TV and Shaadi.com, traditional and online integration will be even stronger as brands bring interactive matrimonial services to subscribers – a notable social media trend where real world ‘word of mouth’ has been extended to digital channels. The new service will enable Zee Dish TV subscribers to select from Shaadi.com’s vast profile base and display the relevant matches on the TV screen with daily profile refreshes. With this partnership, the doors open for other joint TV/internet engagements for brands to capitalize on. Brand Evangelism While blogging has not taken off in a big way in India, it is not due to a lack of opinion. Strong sentiments towards brands, whether positive or negative are widely voiced in forums and self- formed groups within social networking sites. Self-appointed ‘brand protectors’ adamantly defend or defame favored or disfavored brands in the social networking space at platforms such as http://pulsar200club.blogspot.com and http://www.team-bhp.com/web/ Climbing the Corporate Ladder The internet is a popular channel for professional advancement. “Job searching’ is the 2nd61 most popular use of the internet with 73% of consumers using it for this purpose – even higher than news. As further proof, the highest demographics on LinkedIn are both resident and non-resident Indians (NRI) who are leveraging their connections on the net to find and develop their careers. Acknowledging this trend, homegrown professional networks such as Ryze have been born but are increasingly losing ground to more established players. Entertainment Channel Biggest Driver Broadband brings with it rich media delivery and the recent launch of Youtube.co.in (India’s YouTube) fuels the reality that social media will take a new life in the coming months. As yet, there is little local content developed, but there soon will be, starting with the entertainment field and the recent Rajshri/YouTube.co.in deal, where full Hindi movies will become available through YouTube. Increased access to dedicated Indian content will accelerate uptake in web usage and power demand. As an interesting twist, Indian entertainment consumption is not occurring solely in India with 30%62 of video consumption in a 24-hour window coming from Indians outside of India – USA, Japan and Philippines in particular- an important consideration for brands wanting to focus on Indian based consumers or opportunity for those wanting to reach Indian expatriates.
25 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 26 Cluster 3: Developing Markets Philippines, Malaysia, Vietnam PHILIPPINES Prevalence of Social Media Social media is thriving in the Philippines. Despite one of the lowest internet penetration figures in the world (15.6%) and only 14m Filipinos92 connected to the internet, social media consumption has still become a prevalent channel with an estimated 11m93 users. Its strong culture of self expression, entertainment, and networking leads to a natural synergy with social media as a platform to express oneself, interact with friends, family and broadcast to a wider community. With IDC estimating the growth of Internet users to grow to 21.5 million94 by the end of 2008, there will be little doubt that social media will be play a much bigger part in the Philippines for years to come. Dependence on Social Media Friendster and Multiply A mix of social networking sites may exist all over Asia, but in the Philippines, Friendster with 10.7m95 subscribers is King. The Philippines makes up over 38.8% of Friendster’s users worldwide. It’s such an important market, that Friendster, recognizing the low internet penetration in the country, decided to complement online advertising with a mobile phone text messaging service exclusively for Filipino users. Friendster also set up a Mobile Broadcast System, a chat application, between the web and mobile phones to extend the use of Friendster Mobile in the Philippines.96 A challenger to Friendster is social media aggregator Multiply. With approximately 2.2m97 registered users in the Philippines, Multiply saw its share of the Philippine market increase rapidly enough to warrant an advertising deal with local media giant ABS-CBN in December 2007, then the launch of Multiply Philippines98 in June 2008. Blog This The prevalence of blogging has become so popular in Philippines, there is a yearly award show – the Philippine Blog Awards – which recognizes top blogging talent globally in a number of categories - Filipino bloggers, mainstream media practitioners, as well as local corporations. Blogging has become a powerful and respected broadcast platform used by media and government. According to Noynoy Aquino99, “The blogosphere has become an extension of our democratic space where we express an opinion. Bloggers are a most compelling force indeed that could shape an informed vote.” Internet Stars With a nation of aspiring stars, it is not surprising to find that YouTube is the 3rd most popular site in the country. More Filipino artists are finding avenues such as YouTube to share their talent online and get discovered. For example, Alyssa Alano, an actress trying to break into stardom, gained fame when a video of her singing Sixpence None The Richer’s “Kiss Me” was uploaded to YouTube, complete with garbled and incomprehensible lyrics. Similarly, Christine Gambito, a Fil-American actress, was tapped by the Department of Tourism to promote the Philippines after her ‘Happyslip’ video blog gained a large following both at home and abroad. But it’s not always good PR. Brian Gorrell100, an Australian, exposed Filipino high society with his posts on their fraud and widespread drug use resulting in a public scandal. Whilst doing them some harm, he himself attained minor celebrity status and now hosts a radio show from Australia.
27 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 28 MALAYSIA VIETNAM Prevalence of Social Media Prevalence of Social Media Social media in Malaysia is still in its nascent stages. Malaysia currently has 13.5m internet users The internet in Vietnam is rapidly growing across demographics with 20% penetration rate101 and (50%)83 up 265% from 2000. Despite the growth, only 5% of the total population is on broadband around 18m102 users online. Broadband service is still nascent at 7%103 penetration. The internet thus limiting the wider rich media opportunity. This is set to change as the government has slated addresses the demand created from highly regulated and controlled offline media and gives a 30% broadband target by 2010 as well as allocating RM12.2b to develop the ‘knowledge economy’ consumers a channel to openly express themselves. Basic mobiles have experienced phenomenal and build digital savviness. Today, we estimate social media users at around 11m84 albeit in a update with a predicted 270% growth to reach 46m mobile users by 2010104. That said, mobile as basic form. a channel is largely untapped and limited to basic SMS services even since the opening of the telecom industry to private sector investment in 2006105. Dependence on Social Media The population of Vietnam has a youth skew with 60% (over 80m people) under the age of 30. The Speaking Out young population coupled with the opening of the internet in 1997106, has created demand for trial With tight Government controls over traditional media in Malaysia, it’s no surprise that the internet and exploration online. The teen oriented websites in Vietnam record monthly page views from a has become an outlet for Malaysian netizens to express themselves. Ironically, politics has been few hundred thousand to a few million.107 As a result, internet usage has been growing steadily at a huge impetus to popularise social media. The 2008 political elections saw a well orchestrated an average annual rate of 30%108. campaign85 from the Opposition reaching out to young Malaysians using blogs (blog.limkitsiang.com Dependence on Social Media and anwaribrahimblog.com), social networking, videos and political websites to communicate and gulvanise support. VotED (Facebook Groups) and Malaysiakini.com were the tipping point, as well Entertainment as building credibility in the channel as an open, acceptable and social platform. Entertainment reigns supreme in the Vietnamese social media landscape with locally originated Established bloggers include kennysia.com notorious for his open, honest observations on day to film and video at the heart. Video social media sites such as Clip.vn, along with YouTube, are among day life from his home in Kuching, Sarawak. To subsidise the trend in blogging, blog-advertising the highest visited sites with companies like Zing, Baamboo, and 7 sac also offering musical search agencies have emerged - Nuffnang and Advertlets - providing Malaysian bloggers like Kenny with functionality. However, with the regulation of online pirating of music by the Ministry of Information solutions to help monetize their efforts through online advertising. and Communications, the price tag for licensing is too steep for all but a few of the music service Socially Networked providers forcing consolidation amongst Vui.vn, Yeuamnhac, and Pops.com109. Social networking is gathering momentum in Malaysia. Friendster.com is the number 1 social Teen portals are becoming popular social destinations for young people providing entertainment networking site with 3.02m86 unique visitors a month - over three times the size of its nearest and youth oriented news – fashion, gossip and sexual health. These include Hoahcotro (online competitor. Facebook and MySpace register just 758k and 735k visitors respectively. version of Vietnam’s No. 1 teen weekly magazine), and Kenh14.vn within the channelVN.net. Friendster’s success has been attributed to its early market entry as well as being the first to offer Another rising trend is the growth of gaming. Though research varies greatly with as high as 57% a complete social networking experience887 in Malay (Bahasa). Its ability to capture networks of of the youth market in the urban cities actively playing games on such sites as vinagame.vn, friends early has made it hard for later entrants to get members to migrate. Young Malaysians are regardless of number variance, there is no questioning that gaming is one of the top uses and will extremely sensitive to commercialism and privacy, and Friendster has been highly sensitive to continue to grow. this. Creating an easy to use and customisable interface makes it a strong platform for individual Social Networking & Blogging expression and its popularity and credibility has been reinforced by getting big name brands and celebrities to set up their Friendster profiles in order to generate further engagement. For example, In contrast to offline media, social networks and blogs have enabled the Vietnamese to speak out, the 22 year old Malaysian star, Karen Kong has gained more than 92k88 fans on Friendster since comment, and express their viewpoints like never before. Whilst news sites such as 24H.com.vn, setting up her profile in early 2007, and there seems to be no end to her friend requests. Though dantri.com.vn, vnexpress.net and vietnamnet.vn have provided speedy sources for what’s going on there is an understanding that engagement levels in Facebook are higher than that of Friendster, domestically and internationally accounting for 6/10110 of the most visited destinations, the blog the reality is that Facebook’s restriction to English speaking users limits its audience. Segmented phenomenon has been revolutionary. marketing will be key to exploiting social networks by better understanding which tribes are using Blogging has become a core component of many social networking sites with topics ranging from which platform and why. ‘behind-the-scenes’celebrity exposés, political discussion from journalists to personal musings Entertainment Escapism from regular Vietnamese netizens. In terms of scale, social networking111 has become one of the top activities for internet users – with 72% of 18-30 year olds, and 43% of the older populus - using With the government plans for broadband in place, domestic media owners such as Media Prima it to connect with their friends and family. Currently, Yahoo! 360 is the leader with other competing have seized the opportunity to launch GUA.com with an aim to be the biggest entertainment and sites including Cyworld Vietnam and Yeah1. However, with Friendster aggressively entering the lifestyle portal in Malaysia. They seem to be having an impact. The latest count of Media Prima space, along with the influx of capital from other social networking platforms such as Yobanbe, websites show the delivery of more than 50m89 page views and 3.6m unique visitors per month. TimnhanhCafe and Facebook-clones (Tamtay, Guongmat, FaceViet, Zoomban and I-pro.vn), the They are not alone. YouTube was the second90 most popular search term in 2007, as recorded on landscape is set to change radically in the next 18 months. Niche social networking groups are the Google Malaysia Zeitgeist, and is also the fastest rising search term in 2007 reaching 51.7%91 also coming into the picture, such as PhunuNet - tailored towards women – presenting an opportunity heavy internet users. for a more segment-oriented approach for brands. Entertainment doesn’t stop there. The explosion of networked games from China has fueled the number of gamers in Malaysia by bypassing piracy issues as well as allowing gamers to socialize and escape into a virtual world without barriers. Linked to this demand for engagement and infotainment is the growth of virtual worlds in the private and corporate sector such as Second Life – an interesting market for brands to explore.
29 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 30 Cluster 4: Follower Markets Indonesia, Thailand INDONESIA THAILAND Prevalence of Social Media Prevalence of Social Media Internet usage is projected to grow significantly to reach 32m users by 2010 (a four fold increase) 112 Internet in Thailand sits at 20.5% penetration with 13.4m126 users largely made up of working adults much of it coming from the youth and female categories113. The key online motivation is for research and students in the key cities. In parallel, social media is gathering pace in Thailand particularly as well as email and instant chat but still 94%114 of consumers turn to TV for breaking news. Though around community and social networking functions. Broadband penetration is still a long way off the infrastructure has improved significantly in large cities like Jakarta and Surabaya, the delivering critical mass with around 1m subscribers127. Mobile on the other hand is well established Government’s continued caution over foreign investment limits115 in the internet broadband and with mobile penetration standing at 82%128 having grown in six years from 8m to 53m by 2007. telco area continue to hamper accelerated growth. Broadband penetration is virtually non-existent at just 0.4%116or 831k users though there are efforts to increase usage through more realistic Dependence on Social Media pricing structures as well as greater accessibility with ‘warnets’ or internet kiosks costing just Community Discussion US$0.3-0.5117 per hour. Research indicates that 55.3%129 of Thais in Bangkok use the internet to look for news related Dependence on Social Media content – breaking news, political discussion and current affairs. The mainstream portals are the key incubators for such discussion, in particular, Pantip.com/café’s 350k daily users130 and Social Networking Ratchadamnern and Manager.co.th’s buzzing news section. Friendster dominates the Indonesian social networking youth market with 9m118 registered users Closely linked is the success of citizen journalism addressing the demand for live news and the versus Facebook’s 95k119 catering to a more mature, English speaking audience. Around 40% of relative latency of traditional mainstream media. Big events such as the opposition coup in 2006131 Indonesia’s internet users are between 20-24 and they are among the first to start participating have seen socio-political blogs transform into powerful news-sharing sources. Blogs are an in social networks. Female usage is reportedly on the rise representing a valuable insight. Their increasingly important part of the social media landscape in Thailand with 84%132 of internet users desire to go online for news, window shopping, job search, parenting, blogging and to join mailing claiming to write or participate in a blog making it a key channel for word of mouth. Twitter and lists demonstrates the importance of social media to access and consume knowledge privately Twitter-like micro-blogging services are yet to take off in Thailand though attempts are being made and anonymously. to elevate the profile particularly in the large cities with rumours of Twitter-clones emerging such Despite broadband constraints, there appears to be a pent up demand for entertainment. Popular as noknok.in.th. local shows like Empat Mata, Indonesian Idol, Wisata Kuliner Trans TV and Extravaganza Trans Aside from news, the volume of noise in Pantip, Sanook, Kapook, Manager and Mthai tends to TV are shared by fans on YouTube.com. The reality of local video content is inevitably limited by come from the countless number of lifestyle blogs and bulletin boards addressing the passion dial-up services and penalties for misuse. platforms of travel, food, celebrity, IT, film, and sport among others. Though social networking is visible amongst the youth segment, public forums discussing important Social Networking topics120 such as technology, current affairs and religion are also present. Personal blog platforms such as blogger.com are starting to be used as a means for Indonesians to express themselves. Thai youth are very social (spending a reported 70% of mobile usage talking133) providing a hot However, their potential should be cautioned since recent government legislation (March 08) market for social networking platforms and tools. With 2.4m registered members134 of which 78% prescribes severe penalties for slander121. are 18-34, and a base growing +20% per month, Hi-5 has tapped into this demand by providing young Thais with a tailored, social networking platform in Thai. Essentially, young Thais want to Socially Mobile be accepted and recognized amongst their peer groups. Hi-5 makes it easy for them to express Despite 90m mobile subscribers (41%122 penetration), mobile usage is limited to basic SMS and their identity to friends and acquaintances by posting pictures for comment as well as allowing voice calls. Brands have been trying to tap into this vast audience with SMS broadcasting and them to modify the look and feel to make it truly personal. pull campaigns, with only those that have provided strong consumer benefits or broad passion Facebook has become the ‘de facto’ platform for English speaking and expatriate Thai residents platforms such as the English Premiership League123 football updates having any success. providing a great way of keeping in touch with friends abroad. That said, its membership base circa Unfortunately consumers cannot be targeted easily so most of these campaigns are seen as a 100k135 shows that it’s actually in decline (-18%) from January to May136 indicating that the novelty nuisance and spam. factor might be wearing thin. The scepticism of the opportunity for exploiting mobile maybe about to change. The recent launch 124 In an effort to take a slice of the social networking pie, Sanook.com with 460k137 daily visitors in July of Friendster’s mobile platform in Indonesia - m.friendster.com - as a free service enabling followed by kapook.com with 300k138 have evolved from basic email and news services to provide mobile internet users to sign up and retrieve updates on their friends activities, check messages, everything from search to a community channel with chat rooms, bulletin boards, photo storage, browse and upload photos and post bulletins could be the turning point for young Indonesians. and connectivity tools such as instant messenger. Their sticky content and established base makes However, with data still being charged to local telcos, the success of this platform will likely be them consistently popular destinations for brands wanting to get into social media but still fail to determined by affordability. However, with a reported 60%125 of mobile internet traffic going to offer the social networking capabilities provided by dedicated platforms. social media platforms, one of the first victors in this richer service is likely to be the mobile social networks. Watch this space. Unfulfilled Mobile Networking The basic mobile opportunity in Thailand continues to grow with mobile internet now available in key cities. A projected non voice communications market is set to expand by 40%139 this year in a market worth US$798m. A recent survey indicated that around 20% of respondents claimed they had ‘used’ online chat services such as MSN or Googletalk, whilst 39% of those that hadn’t indicated that they were ‘interested’ in doing so. Though the appetite is there, the reality of delivering a mobile social networking platform is some way off.
37 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 38 Tips for success: How can brands increase their chances of success in Social Media? There are a number of considerations that could increase your chance of brand success: Management Support – letting go of the brand is a reality of social media and it’s critical that the brand’s senior management fully understand the implications, and are willing to take the Social media is scary. It’s not a well scripted scenario. You’re out there in the middle of risk as well as commit resource. This means identifying an overall ‘gatekeeper’ for social a social network and comments good or bad will flow. You have to be prepared to accept media as well as one or more contributors who are empowered to speak out and contribute that but a lot of brands want control. to the discussion, liaise with influencers as well as listen in and monitor what’s being said and done. Social media isn’t something that brands can dip in and out of. They have to be committed Ken Mandel for the long term, and be prepared to take the good with the bad. Regional Managing Director, Yahoo! SEA Brand Integrity – social media success has to be embedded in honesty and trust by playing to the brand’s core values and ideals. No falsifications. Pretending to be one of the ‘punters’ in the discussion room, commenting on a blog without saying who you are, or misleading influencers is a ‘no-no’. You will be sniffed out. Brands that disclose conflicts of interest, are responsive to questions, and permit negative What they (marketers) can do though is to try and develop a strategy which as well as positive discussion are most likely to get accepted. In many ways, participation enables them to find an authentic voice, a credible voice and a commitment in social media is a personification of the brand, and any involvement should be ‘human’ to contributing to the discussion online and trying to address the problems and real. Brands like humans are infallible after all. The truer you are, the better you are of the users. likely to be. Jeremy Wagstaff Brand Contribution – brands need to be willing to contribute to be accepted in social media. Technology Commentator, BBC, WSJ, Loosewireblog.com Even to go as far as contributing unconditionally. Traditionally, marketers have been trained to barter e.g. ‘I’ll give you a free trial if you give me your email address’, or ‘forward this to a friend to win a chance to…’. Brands take and consumers give. This model is being challenged in the social media universe. A philanthropic undertone comes through in so much social media as people invest time in sharing information. Understanding this, and contributing as a good social media citizen is a hallmark of understanding the media. Brands need to play a careful role. They are a participant – like you or me- but if it’s Brands need to consider how they can do this. Offering new ideas, facilitating the discussion, forced, contrived or not relevant, they will fail. Consumers are open to accepting a brand giving free content or creating exclusive footage are all ways of driving goodwill amongst in the social media environment if they play by the social media rules. You need to be influencers and the target audience. An example of this is MTV Asia who uploaded their extensive prepared to give when you enter social media. research findings on youth in Asia to slideshare.com so other companies, even competitors could see it, or IBM’s World Community Grid which let’s PC users channel that wasted energy Ken Mandel from PC downtime e.g. during a lunch break – to power super computers to help address Regional Managing Director, Yahoo! SEA critical environmental and research issues. Taking the higher ground will inspire respect and adoration.
39 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 40 Case Studies: So who’s doing Social Media well in Asia? There are a lot of brands that think they are doing social media in the region but in fact are just creating content and assets within the social media space. In all the weeks of research spent investigating cases, we have identified just a handful of brands that have stood out as truly delivering a winning social media strategy. What are the brand success stories? Case Study 1 Brand : e27 Market : South East Asia Target : Start-ups, technologists, entrepreneurs and investors Links : www.e27.sg www.entrepreneur27singapore.wikispaces.com Background Modelled on e27 in Silicon Valley, with no marketing budget, two young ambitious guys – Justin Lee and Bjorn Lee – used social media to turn e27 in 12 months from a social enterprise idea to a leading community for digital entrepreneurs in South East Asia. The secret to the team’s success was its ability to successfully identify, engage and build trust with the ‘right influencers’ for its brand. Its formula was simple. Using face to face events, it identified potential key influencers and actively engaged with them one-to-one through email, Twitter and Instant Messenger sharing insights, observations and contacts about the entrepreneurial space. This worked to turn these acquaintances from passive participants to powerful brand evangelists resulting in positive discussion in the blogosphere. To maintain the dialogue with its influencers and the broader member base, e27 used its dedicated wikispace and website as the virtual place to connect with and share ideas. By giving total control to its members, it provided a refreshing change from other contolled communities. Every brand has a social network they could be a part of... I think too much focus is just on B2C. Ken Mandel Regional Managing Director, Yahoo! SEA
41 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 42 How well did it do? Case Study 2 1. Influencer Reach: e27 has managed to identify 3 pillar evangelist groups – Brand : Motorola bloggers, industry observers and tech-watchers. Market : China Links : http://motomp3.tom.com 2. Influencer Activity: www.youtube.com/watch?v=3mkrHv886G8 These influencers have been able to create credibility and Target : Chinese youth market (12 - 20 years old) visibility amongst their own audiences as well as elevating e27 amongst the start-up community. Each ‘by invitation’ Background event provides a new conversation for a spur of blog postings How do you reach out to Chinese youth with your latest using photography, video and discussion to hook people in. cell phones? For Motorola, using social influencers was the way in. Tapping on the popularity of the Back Dorm Boys 3. Brand Impact: (Win Win and Huang Yi Xin) and their lip sync videos, Motorola Acquisition: e27 has developed a permission-based database sought to engage the duo to help them promote their latest of a 1,000 highly valuable members and continues to generate line of entry level handsets designed for Chinese Youth. After interest by reaching out to application developers and rounds of discussions with their initially-apprehensive entrepreneurs using social network groups. manager (Wei Wei’s mum), they were finally persuaded to produce a video which featured the duo lip-syncing to the Engagement: With zero marketing budget, from a modest song “Radio in my Head” in typical over-the-top fashion with first event with 30 attendees they have grown to host events the Motorola C381 phone as a part of the performance. that average 400 attendees. These events are now endorsed by influential organizations and government agencies including Google, Microsoft, Information Development How well did it do? Association and Media Development Authority of Singapore. 1. Influencer Reach: Brand Equity: e27 is the first Singapore blog to get a mention All the influencers (all two of them) were successfully on the respected OpenWeb Asia Workgroup [www.openweb.asia] identified, reached and engaged behind this campaign with which is a network of premium blogs focusing on the Asia total success. web industry. 2. Influencer Activity: Overall Conclusion Initially seeded on Motorola’s campaign website, the video Young, nimble start ups are often the first and most spread at a viral pace through peer-to-peer channels with successful to leverage social media. Creative, daring thinking more than 60 million views recorded. combined with a well constructed viral model that singles out anchor influencers makes a great social media success 3. Brand Impact: story amongst their target audience. Their story evolves. By the end of the campaign, sales for Motorola’s four low-price tier phones had increased by over 270%, moving more than 200,000 units in a month. Overall Conclusion Large brands that move fast and are willing to take risks are far more likely to reap the rewards. Motorola’s deep understanding of social media in China combined with what was current at the time for their target audience, made this campaign such a great success. Ironically, if it was run again today, it would unlikely have the same level of impact in China. They caught the moment!
43 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 44 Case Study 3 3. Brand Impact: Apart from the obvious fan base, a short test of mentions of Brand : Marmite Marmite against its main competitor ‘Vegemite’ on the walls Market : Global (25 - 35 years old) of Facebook yielded far stronger results, and ‘Marmite’ Links : www.marmite.com searches on Google pulled up 3 of the top 7 sites as those en.wikipedia.org/wiki/marmite created and originated by fans. www.spurgeon.org/phil/marmite.htm www.ilovemarmite.com/ Overall Conclusion Marmite is a great example of how a low involvement Background category can leverage social media by adhering to the Marmite, for those who do not know, is a salty yeast based social media rules. Straight talking. The Marmite Group spread made in England. Unsurprisingly opinion is divided as sets out ‘to share the joy of Marmite - eating and make it to whether or not it actually tastes good. Basically you either available to all those with excellent taste; and using triggers “love it or you hate it”. Marmite has run many campaigns over - squeezy vs glass bottle discussion - to stimulate debate. the years drawing on this insight as have the avid fans in Amplified through unofficial website conversations, Marmite continuing the conversation online. has created a low risk and low cost relationship platform through Facebook Groups that can engage with a significant Its foray into social media draws from its latest contention group of passionates anywhere in the world. campaign for squeezy marmite (the product has moved from glass jar to tube). The official Marmite website and Facebook page provides fun content, is open to heated debate about the taste of the new squeezy version, and invites members to share stories from their childhood about the spread. Marmite’s main targets were not typical big celebrities or influential figures. Their online brand influencers were “Marmite babies” who grew up eating Marmite and simply loving it. The sheer presence of Marmite on Facebook brought reminiscence to Marmite lovers identifying with the ‘iconic black bottle’ logo as it appeared in their newsfeeds, and intriguing them into this passionate community putting this low involvement brand front of mind. In parallel, unofficial fan sites have emerged telling you anything and everything you need to know about this brand. Take Seamus Waldron’s ilovemarmite.com site, and the commentary by Phil Johnson in www.spurgeon.org/phil/marmite. How well did it do? 1. Influencer Reach: Marmite’s presence on Facebook started through seeding amongst the Marmite generation of 25-35 year olds, and through the mechanics of Facebook attracted 149k (and growing) fan sign ups. 2. Influencer Activity: With little encouragement, the fan base uploaded pictures and videos to remind users how much they love Marmite, and triggered discussion (both good and bad) about their new product. New updates to the Facebook community created a spur of conversations (3.9k wall posts and 193 discussion topics). Some expressed their food loves while others shared their good old days eating Marmite tapping happy childhood memories. And 149 fans even went to the extent of sharing their experiences with Marmite by posting obscure photos and engaging with their resident ‘sarniologist’, George.
45 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 46 Case Study 4 3. Brand Impact: In addition to the high volume of impressions, Lenovo stood out as an innovator of the Games Brand : Lenovo with its campaigns being featured in USA Today, New York Times and many local media channels Market : Olympic fans globally let alone online blog referrals including www.Mashable.com, www.theinfluentialmarketingblog.com Links : http://summergames.lenovo.com, and www.theiphoneblog.com http://www.tinyurl.com/beijingflickr; http://www.twitter.com/Ienovo2008; Visibility through brand placement of the IdeaPad needs no mention, and the halo effect of this http://lenovo.zumobi.com; publicity on Lenovo’s brand equity as a truly global brand (not Chinese) is a great bi-product. http://rohitbhargava.typepad.com But the story continues with a 100 happy athletes able to leave the Olympic Games not just with great memories but with a Lenovo IdeaPad Laptop – endorsing the brand. Background For any die-hard Olympic enthusiasts (particularly in Asia), Overall Conclusion getting a ‘real’ view of the Olympics other than the official Lenovo orchestrated (and pulled off) one of the most ambitious and challenging social media footage, medal tallies, TV analysis and melodrama stories is campaigns to date which many similar brands would find too daring. To mitigate their exposure, actually quite hard. With an ambition to reach out to fans they partnered with a professional agency with deep experience in social media and opted around the world in Web2.0 style, Lenovo decided to activate their sponsorship of the Beijing Olympics beyond the Olympic to keep the infrastructure relatively simple (using off the shelf social media tools and Torch Relay and Olympic Village by powering athletes to share applications) rather than create them from scratch. This enabled the teams to focus on the their real, unfiltered experiences up to and during the Games heart of the experience – inspired content – by channeling energies on reaching, inspiring to deliver a truly Olympic 2.0 experience. and supporting the athletes themselves. Branded ‘The Voices of the Olympic Games’, this platform offered fresh, diverse and personal stories directly from the athletes, with Lenovo providing the ‘glue’. How well did it do? 1. Influencer Reach: This ambitious program saw Lenovo use online forums, postings and PR to target and recruit over 100 Olympians playing to their personal motivations of recognition, support, sponsorship and satisfaction. With these influencers on board representing more than 25 countries, 30 sports and 8 languages, Lenovo donated a new IdeaPad laptop which with little persuasion inspired them to start blogging their personal stories. 2. Influencer Activity: Lenovo used a range of social media platforms to distribute the content from the host site - http://summergames.lenovo.com – including a Live Twitter feed, Flickr photogallery, del.ici.ous, a Facebook application and even an iPhone application. Through these activities, Lenovo was able to facilitate and aggregate the true voices of the games to inspire fans and other aspiring young athletes with a reported 10 million impressions across social media and traditional media. The tangibility of these stories were undisputable and captured the moment. Amazing stories included India’s first ever Olympic Solo Shooting winner, Abhinav Bindra who amidst his glory started conversation around the ‘problems’ plaguing Indian sport, and Cyclist Josiah Ng from Malaysia’s commentary on his collarbone operation inspiring responses from concerned fans. For other athletes the blog made it easy to connect and receive well wishes from friends, family and fans who weren’t present in Beijing.
47 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 48 How to get started If you’ve read this far, you’ve probably got a good idea what social media is about and an appetite to go on and do something. There are some basic things that you can start doing immediately: 1. Open the conversation: if you are managing a website, go and review it again to see whether it invites suggestions, comments and participation. Creating a dialogue is a starting point and your existing customers are the most important place to start. They need a channel to you, so make it easy for them. 2. Start listening: before you start entering into social media, start to get a feel of what conversations are already going on about your brand. Listen in, monitor and identify where the ‘buzz’ is. Use search engines as a starting point and look at listings on the second and third pages. You might get a nice surprise that there are some positive things already being said about your brand. 3. Sign up to a social networking and social bookmarking site: go online and try it out. The closer you are to understanding what your consumers are doing and how they’re doing it, the higher the chance that you will be able to provide a practical grounded strategy that is relevant and topical. 4. Develop and learn from young social media users: there are lots of people around you that understand social media better than you. Go and speak with a friend, the office intern or even sign up to a blog. Start to immerse yourself into understanding how social media is impacting lives. Use these informers as a human barometer on what’s hot and what’s not. 5. Talk to an expert that understands social media: speak to your agency or sign up to online communities around the medium as well as check out useful reading material, guides and blogs online. As a starter, try http://digitalwatch.ogilvy.com.cn/en/ or www.openweb.asia. 6. Try it: start testing. You can’t wait until social networking hits a tipping point and all your competitors are doing it. Give it a go, get some key learnings, see what works and what doesn’t work, and don’t stay out of it.
49 OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? OGILVY INSIGHT: CAN BRANDS HAVE A SOCIAL LIFE? 50 1 Text, Rich media (video, photo, music, games, voice) 75 Asia Pacific Digital Marketing Yearbook 2008 2 Nielsen Online Global Consumer Study April 2007 – 76 International Telecommunication Union Top 10 markets who claimed that they relied most on 77 http://www.internetworldstats.com/asia2.htm ‘recommendations from consumers’- Hong Kong (93%), 78 OgilvyOne Estimates based on Internetworldstats.com Jun08 Taiwan (91%), Indonesia (89%), India (87%), South Korea 79 http://www.edelmanapac.com/edelman/blog?month=4 Acknowledgements (87%), Philippines (86%), Ireland (84%), Mexico (84%), UAE &day=19&year=2007 (84%) and New Zealand (83%). 80 Universal McCann, March 2008 3 Y-Generation 1977-94 US Today 81 National Communications Commission This paper has involved a lot of people so thanks to you all for your time, effort and 4 China Internet Network Information Center July 2008 82 www.tnic.net 5 China Internet Network Information Center July 2008 83 Nielsen (2008) passion for this thriving medium – you know who you are. 3 China Internet Network Information Center July 2008 84 OgilvyOne Estimates based on Internetworldstats.com Jun08 7 TNS/CNNIS 85 www.monstorandcritics.com/news/asiapacific/features/ 8 China Internet Network Information Center July 2008 articles/1412199.php/malaysian_politicians_hop_onto_the_ An extra special thanks goes to our social media gurus who inspired us to think of social media as 9 readwriteweb.com.archives/bbs_china blogging_bandwagon 10 readwriteweb.com.archives/bbs_china 86 Design News May08 www.designtaxi.com a practical and very real discipline: 11 http://www.melcherruwart.com/2008/05/04/its-all-about- 87 Design News May08 www.designtaxi.com the-bbs/ 88 AsiaOne digital: story/ 12 China Internet Network Information Center July 2008 89 Adoimagazine.com 2008 13 www.reuters.com/article/pressRelease/ 9th January, 2008 90 Adoimagazine.com 2008 E27 : Justin Lee & Bjorn Lee, Joint Founders 14 China Internet Network Information Centre 25Apr08 91 Comscore segment metrix (mar 08) 15+ from home and Google : Vinton Cerf, VP and Chief Internet Evangelist 15 China Internet Network Information Centre 25Apr08 work PCs 16 Kaiser Kuo – blogger & Digital Consultant May08 92 Yahoo Loosewireblog.com : Jeremy Wagstaff, BBC, Asia WSJ and Technology Commentator 17 www.newsweek.com/id/78112 93 OgilvyOne Estimates based on Internetworldstats.com Jun08 18 www.marbridgeconsulting.com/marbridgedaily/ 94 Xinhuanet, Jan 2008 MTV Asia : Ian Stewart, Senior Vice President 2008-07-01/ 95 Manila Times Jan08 Mr Brown.com : Lee Kin Mun, Founder & Blogger 19 Internet World Stats derivations June 2008 96 Alexa Top 100 Sites 20 Technorati & Edelman 2007 97 http://www.techcrunch.com/2007/11/07multiplv-big-in-the- OgilvyOne Asia : Kent Wertime, President 21 Technorati Japan, accessed Jan 4th, 2008 philippines-lands-ad-deal/ 22 Source: http://www.twitterlocal.net/stats 98 http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/inquirerheadlines/nation/view/ OgilvyPR USA : Rohit Bhargava, Senior Vice President 360 Digital Influencer 23 Infinita Mar 2007 20080622-144061/Filipinos-are-prolific-and-Multiply 24 Analytica1st.com, Feb 29 2008 99 “Social media and PR in Asia” by Singapore Management Wego.com : Miguel Bernas, Marketing Director 25 Infinita Mar 2007 University Wiki (2008) Yahoo! SEA : Ken Mandel Vice President & Regional MD 26 Source: Gree press release, July 2007 100 http://delfindjmontano.blogspot.com – Brian Gorrell includes 27 Source: Infinita Inc (Mar 08) on his blog a list of links to mainstream media pickups. 28 GMID South Korea Country Pulse 2007 101 Internet World Stats (IWS) 30 Sep 2007 29 US News article Sep 06 102 Internet World Stats Dec 2007 30 Koreanclick/ Korean National Statistical Office Jun08 103 Internet World Stats Dec 2007 31 Koreanclick Jun08 104 Wireless Asia 2007 32 Digital Korea CNN.com 2007 105 http://english.vietnamnet.vn/tech/2008/08/801025/ 33 Inside Cyworld Plus 8 Star Limited 2007 106 http://www.internetworldstats.com/asia/vn.htm 34 Koreanclick Jun08 107 http://harryd844.wordpress.com 35 Koreanclick Jun08 108 Intellasia 2008 36 Edelman Korea (Kaist Research 2007) 109 http://harryd844.wordpress.com 37 OgilvyOne Korea (Jul08) 110 Tamtay.vn, yobanbe.vn 2007 38 Digital Korea Video Report CNN.com 2007 111 AC Nielsen Uses of the Internet in HCMC and Hanoi (2007) 39 Digital Korea Video Report CNN.com 2007 112 Hot Telecom (Mar 08) 40 GMID South Korea Country Pulse 2007 113 Transcript from Merlyna’s public lecture as part of the 41 Census and Statistics Department of Hong Kong, and Office association of Internet researchers Conference, Australia of the Telecommunications Authority 27-30 Sep 2007 42 Census and Statistics Department of Hong Kong, and Office 114 Synovate 2007 – ADMA report 2007 of the Telecommunications Authority 115 2007 Asia - Telecoms, Mobile and Broadband in Indonesia 43 McCann Ericsson report (Mar 08) and Timor Leste by Paul Budde (Sep 07) 44 Comscore data referenced in article ‘Facebook Platform, 6 116 April 2008 - Hot Telecom Market Statistics and Forecast waves Making Waves in Hong Kong’Jun08 117 OgilvyOne Jakarta (Jun08) 45 Xanga (Feb07) 118 Antara news – 2Jul08: Article: Friendster mobile site now 46 Key Insights on Youth in Shanghai, Hong Kong and the United available in Indonesian States Revealed in Harris Interactive 2007 U.S. / China 119 http://inlogicalbearer.blogspot.com/2008/01/facebook- YouthPulseComparison Study Business Wire, Dec 19, 2007 statistics-slow-down-in-north.html from ‘Harris Interactive Report: ‘91% 15-21 year olds in 120 Budi Patra – journalist and blogger (2007) Hong Kong say they spent time instant messaging yesterday’ 121 http://indonesiafirst.com/2008/04/indonesia-bans-youtube- 47 OFTA, Apr08 myspace/ 48 AC Nielsen - 2006 122 2008 Asia - Telecoms, Mobile and Broadband in Indonesia 49 Marketing charts.com/ The Nielsen Company and Timor Leste by Paul Budde & Hot Telecm Market 50 McCann Ericsson report (Mar 08) Statistics a&Forecast Report (Apr08) 51 HitWise Hong Kong report – Social Network and Forums 123 I-Pop EVP, Colin Miles (Mar08) (Apr 08) 124 Antara news – 2Jul08: Article: Friendster mobile site now 52 Alexa Top 100 sites available in Indonesian 53 Alexa Top 100 Sites 125 Antara news – 2Jul08: Article: Friendster mobile site now 54 South China Morning Post: New kids on the blog. By Carrie available in Indonesian Chan 22Aug05 (http://zonaeuropa.com/20050822_3.htm) 126 http://internet.nectec.or.th/webstats/home.iir?Sec=home 55 Key Insights on Youth in Shanghai, Hong Kong and the United 127 Thailand’s Mobile Market Reached 53 Million Subscribers States Revealed in Harris Interactive 2007 U.S. / China by End-2007: Business Wire, May 23, 2008/ YouthPulseComparison Study Business Wire, Dec 19, 2007 http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0EIN/is_2008_May from ‘Harris Interactive Report: ‘91% 15-21 year olds in _23/ai_n25452529?tag=rel.res5 Hong Kong say they spent time instant messaging yesterday’ 128 Thailand’s Mobile Market Reached 53 Million Subscribers 56 OgilvyOne Estimates based on Internetworldstats.com Jun08 by End-2007: Business Wire, May 23, 2008/ 57 eMarketer Report Jun 07 http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0EIN/is_2008_May 58 Indiatimes.com Aug07 _23/ai_n25452529?tag=rel.res5 59 International Telco Union 2007 129 ADMA 2007 Report: Extract from Synovate Media Atlas: 60 http://www.eetimes.com/news/latest/showArticle.jhtml? Bangkok Residents (2007) articleID=209901456 130 Nectec government research as referenced by ADMA ASPAC 61 JuxtConsult 2007 Yearbook Report - 2008 62 Nautanki.tv (Jul08 131 Bangkok Post, Mar06: Citizen journalism in action: 63 Information Development Authority Singapore 2008 Interestingly named, The Media Slut is a new medium 64 IDA Singapore News & Events Jan07 covering Thailand’s political unrest 65 IDA Singapore News & Events Jan07 132 Microsoft survey on blogging (Aug-Sep 2006) 66 Blogging Asia: A windows live report (2006) 133 Universal McCann Report (Mar08) 67 Alexa’s Top 100 most visited sites for Singapore 134 Hi-5 Presentation – Top Space Feb08 68 Hitwise Press Release (Mar08) 135 Facebook Advertising Centre: Facebook subscribers from 69 Hitwise Singapore - Top 20 Websites - July, 2008 Jan to Jun 08 70 ComScore Singapore, Jan, Feb & Apr 2008, Aged 15+ 136 Facebook Advertising Centre: Facebook subscribers from All the content featured in this study is the opinion of OgilvyOne gleaned from a wide range of independent sources. Whilst every 71 ComScore Singapore, Jan, Feb & Apr 2008, Aged 15+ Jan to Jun 08 precaution has been taken in the preparation of this document, OgilvyOne assumes no responsibility for errors, omissions, or 72 Hitwise Top 5 Social media sites (Mar08) 137 Truehits.net-Jun 2008 for damages resulting from the use of the information herein. Products or corporate names may be trademarks of other 73 Synovate Young Asians Survey 2008 138 Truehits.net-Jun 2008 companies and are used only for the explanation and to the owner’s benefit, without intent to infringe. All content herein may 74 Hitwise (Jun08) 139 Bangkok Post – ADMA Report 2007 be reproduced and used provided that credit is given to OgilvyOne Asia Pacific and www.ogilvy.com