1. Problem Formulation and Identification
Jenifer Sellars
Ariana Bolton
Susana Hicks
Aurora Ruby Castro
MGT 350 / Yvonne Richardson
University of Phoenix
2. Agenda
Introduction: Jenifer Sellars
Problem, solution and +/- of each
Greek Restaurant: Ariana Bolton
Medical Device company: Ruby Castro
Network /High Tech: Jenifer Sellars
Real Estate: Susana Hicks
Conclusion: Jenifer Sellars
Q & E Session: All
3. Ariana: Greek Restaurant
Firefighting Method
Temporary solution
Stakeholders:
The restaurant owners
The investors
The employees
The customers
4. Ariana: Greek Restaurant
Problem Solving
Not a decision -
making process
Quick fix
No long term solution
More problems in
long run
5. Ariana: Greek Restaurant
Strengths and Weaknesses
+Strengths - Weaknesses
Provides temporary
satisfaction No long term solutions
Problems snowball
Potentially creates much
bigger problems
6. Ruby: NeoVista Incorporated
Autocratic Decision-Making
The Problem:
Our R&D department
takes more than 48
hours to receive AP
invoices that reference
our purchase orders.
7. Ruby: NeoVista Incorporated
Problem Solving
Goals: Impact of Alternatives:
Have invoices have Company spending money
invoices back within 24 Decision:
hours I get trained on hoe to
Evaluate: receive in the system
Implement Decision:
AP receives a lot of phone
calls and/or emails Meeting with R&D Vice
President and VP of Finance
Cause of Problem:
Measure Impact:
Materials personnel
Start off monitoring on
overwhelmed with work monthly basis, then weekly
Alternatives:
Hire new or train existing
employees to help
8. Ruby: NeoVista Incorporated
Strengths and Weaknesses
Weaknesses
Strengths
Vendors calling and emailing
No more angry phone calls/emails for payment daily
Build good credit Credit terms not allowed,
Invoices entered before month end Prepay all future orders
Materials person gets help Invoices being accrued
Save money if internal person Increased stress/ work for
trained materials person
AP routing for approval gets saved New hire will be expensive
Have to continue keeping a log
9. Jenifer: Cisco Staffing
Reactive decision-making
The Problem:
Issues are handled on a REACTIVE basis.
Takes multiple people experiencing the
same issue for attention to be given.
Stressful and frustrating to obtain timely resolutions.
10. Jenifer: Cisco Staffing
Problem Solving
Symptoms include: Root causes:
Late background checks Too many layers of
Delay start dates management
System access issues Not one person
Slow to obtain resolution
possessed autonomy to
or attention make corrections.
Lack of service to
Stakeholders
“Deal with it as we
go along attitude”
http://my.journaltimes.com/post/Solomon/blog/root_causes_of_school_system_failure.html Retrieved May 4, 2011
11. Jenifer: Cisco Staffing
Strengths ands Weaknesses
Strengths Weaknesses
Can make adjustments Problems escalated, drop
everything and fix!
„on the fly‟
Undue urgency created
No long term planning
required Not effective at decision-
making
Limited strengths Lacks planning and
insight
12. Susana: Real Estate
Autocratic decision-making
PROBLEM
One broker for many
employees.
Broker maintains all
liability.
Employees follow his style
of work, laws, and
guidelines.
13. Susana: Real Estate
Problem Solving
Real Estate in California is time sensitive
Unique clients, situations, and circumstance
One Broker with exclusive liability
Laws and specific demands must be adhered to
Broker decides final guidelines and policies.
14. Susana: Real Estate
Strengths and Weaknesses
+Strengths -Weaknesses
narrow room for outside
A very personal circumstances
relationship between
you and broker constant repetition of the
person in power
You do not have to
answer to a hierarchy of No room for advancement
supervisors or personnel
One person to report to
15. Conclusion: decision-making methods
“Firefighting” and
Reactive methods are
ineffective. No planning!
The autocratic method
can help adhere to
regulations, yet relies too
heavily on one person.
Q & A?
http://blog.perksconsulting.com/tag/strength/ Retrieves May 4, 2011
Editor's Notes
Discuss heater issue – how stakeholders are affected
Talk about tape on heater – “Band-Aid effect”
Be specific about the heater issue the + and -
Ruby: Also talk a little about the autocratic style – who is theone person making decisions??
Ruby: DON’T READ FROM SLIDES! Be prepared here…. Talk about this as YOUR plan, what you are recommending….
VE System goes down despite several complaints – no pro-activeness, plans in place or monitoring
Stakeholders: Recruiters, Hiring Managers, Candidates and New Hires. ROOT CAUSE: need to ask “Why, because” repeatedly until root cause is identified
Being pro-active much better! –checks and balances, performance measurements lacking
Firefighting/reactive: Unprepared, no plan un place. “Fail to plan, plan to fail” Autocratic: “hit by a bus – then what??’”