Data Portability? Communal Data and Identity

Data Ownership? Yours Theirs Ours Cristina Wodtke’s model based on Matt Webb, Stewart Butterfield’s and Gene Smith’s writings

Yours

Theirs

Ours

Yours Control: Access to instances of YOU Management: Identities Influence: Presence & Reputation Identity

Ours Theirs YOURS Control: Access to A SHARED instance YOU Management: Identity/user attributes Influence: Presence & Reputation Identity Friends Shared Content Conversations Shared Membership Access to Them Service Providers Content Availability Identity Availability Metadata of a Single Instance

Trust Based Transactions Yours Access, Content Access, Content Instanced Based Communal Data Identity Thiers Identity Thiers Identity Thiers Identity Thiers Identity

Transactional Realities Expectations Reasonable security efforts Privacy proportional to transaction type Access User controlled access User executed transactions Availability User driven Service provider constrained

Expectations

Reasonable security efforts

Privacy proportional to transaction type

Access

User controlled access

User executed transactions

Availability

User driven

Service provider constrained

Intent and Access Identities YOUR collective control point Shared content is instanced based A transaction is unique to an instance of an identity Shared content is inherently transactional User driven access

Identities

YOUR collective control point

Shared content is instanced based

A transaction is unique to an instance of an identity

Shared content is inherently transactional

User driven access

Yours: A Virtual Registry? Where to participate When to participate How to contribute How to enable access Who to enable Identity Registry *ccarfi * Identity

Where to participate

When to participate

How to contribute

How to enable access

Who to enable

Questions Is a unique identity a shared asset? Service provider, you and your shared communal content Is transactional data inherently communal? Access driven events What is the value of the transactional data at an identity instance? Facebook v. Twitter Will portability drive shared value?

Is a unique identity a shared asset?

Service provider, you and your shared communal content

Is transactional data inherently communal?

Access driven events

What is the value of the transactional data at an identity instance?

Facebook v. Twitter

Will portability drive shared value?

Data Portability? Communal Data and Identity