Your SlideShare is downloading. ×
0
StevanHarnad
Canada Research Chair in Cognitive Sciences
Université du Québec à Montréal
&
Professor of Web Science
Univer...
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Doing the right thing with the right KIND of thing
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Words are names of categories
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Pevtzow, R. &Harnad, S.
(1997)
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Cangelosi&Harnad 2002
“TOADSTOOL” = “MUSHROOM” + “STRIPES”
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Some words are not used in any definition.
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
They can be removed
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
This process is recursive.
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Till no other word can be removed
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Resulting subgraph is
“Grounding Kernel” (GK) of dictionary
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Summary for compressed real dictionary
1500 words
+
Boole
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text
Text Text Text Text Text Text Te...
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text
Text Text Text Text Text Text Te...
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
The “hard problem” of consciousness:
Doing vs. Feeling
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Jorge ArmonyBernard BaarsMark BalaguerSimon Baron-Cohen
Roy Baumeister Bjorn Brembs John Campbell Erik Cook Fernando
Cerve...
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Borner, Katy graphic webs of science Dedeo, Simon collective dynamics on WikipediaDorogovtse...
QUESTIONS/COMMENTS?
Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Stevan Harnad for Knowledge Stream

1,628

Published on

Эволюционирует ли наш разум с распространением знаний и технологий? 19 сентября эксперт в области когнитивистики, профессор университетов Квебека и Саутгемптона Стивен Харнад ответил на этот вопрос в центре Digital October.

http://digitaloctober.ru/ru/events/knowledge_stream_kognitivnoe_neveroyatnoe

Published in: Education, Technology
0 Comments
1 Like
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
1,628
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
9
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
2
Comments
0
Likes
1
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide
  • Talk about Web Science and the Mind. Berners-Lee invented the Web. Socrates invented philosophy, and philosophy of mind
  • FromGlossogony to Google (Glossogony is the beginning of language) Evolution of Communication to the Cognitive Commons. We will talk more about what cognition is. For now, assume cognition means thinking. A “commons” is a grazing field that belongs to no individual but to everyone. Anyone’s sheep and cows can graze there.
  • Much of cognition is categorization, and acquiring new categories. To categorize is to do the right thing with the right KIND of thing, such as learning which mushrooms can be eaten and which cannot. We can categorize by eating vs not-eating, or by calling them edible ones mushrooms and the inedible ones toadstools.
  • Words are names of categories. Categories have members and non-members, and categories can themselves be members of categories, e.g., apples are fruits
  • We put things in the same category because they are more more similar, but it is not so simple: sometimes things more similar because we put them in the same category. Reds look more like reds, and yellows like yellows, but that’s because our brains make them look more alike. Really they are just continuous differences in the frequency of lightwaves.
  • In the lab, we have shown that if experimental subjects are trained, by trial and error, to categorize textures based on rules about their features that the subjects do not know, then if the category is hard to learn, the subjects that learn it show a “rainbow” effect of learning: Textures that are in the same category look more like one another than they did before the subject learned the category. This is called “categorical perception” and is related to the “Whorf Hypothesis” that the language influences our perceptions: The way we name and categorize things changes the way they look to us.
  • These changes in our perception when we acquire new categories are also reflected in changes in our brain activity. On the left we see the change emerging in the brain wave as the subjects learn the category the hard way by trial and error. On the right we see a similar effect when they are told the rule verbally. The difference is important, because trial and error is slow, uncertain and risky, whereas verbal description is fast, safe and reliable. We think that was the enormous adaptive advantage that led to the evolution of languagein our species.
  • In an artificial life computer simulation, little creatures had to learn about three different categories of mushrooms: The mushrooms that were edible had spots on their tops and those that were poisonous toadstools did not. The mushrooms that had to be marked were striped, those that did not had none. And the ones to which they had to return had both spots and stripes. All creatures vocalized what they were doing: EAT, MARK, RETURN. All the creatures had to learn the edible mushrooms and the markable mushrooms by trial and error, getting sick and going hungry if they made mistakes.. But the returnable mushrooms could be learned in two different ways, the same way as the rest, by trial and error, or by overhearing those creatures who had already learned that the returnable mushrooms were EAT and MARK. So they could learn it the hard, long, risky way, or they could learn it by “hearsay” from thpse who already knew that RETURN = EAT + MARK. Those who learned the easy way instead of the hard way survived and reproduced better, and in a few generations they were the only kind of creature left: Language is a revolutionary new way of learning new categories by fast reliable verbal instruction instead of long risky experience. Perhaps this is how and why language evolved.
  • If so, then the birth of language was also the birth of the “category commons” --- all the shared categories that we call knowledge, and that we pass on by word of mouth. For example, if I tell a child that toadstools are mushrooms with stripes. One sentence, and he has the new category, no time lost, no risk.
  • Language is reciprocal altruism. Leads to OA
  • But some words need to be grounded the old way: how many?
  • 4 revolutions: question of timing
  • Returns discourse to the speed of thought
  • No doubt this is collaborative and interactive cognition
  • `cognition is as cognition does: Explain the causal mechanism that generates our capacity to do what we can all do
  • Can cognition be wider than the head?
  • Transcript of "Stevan Harnad for Knowledge Stream"

    1. 1. StevanHarnad Canada Research Chair in Cognitive Sciences Université du Québec à Montréal & Professor of Web Science University of Southampton Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    2. 2. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    3. 3. Doing the right thing with the right KIND of thing Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    4. 4. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013 Words are names of categories
    5. 5. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    6. 6. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013 Pevtzow, R. &Harnad, S. (1997)
    7. 7. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    8. 8. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013 Cangelosi&Harnad 2002
    9. 9. “TOADSTOOL” = “MUSHROOM” + “STRIPES” Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    10. 10. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    11. 11. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    12. 12. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    13. 13. Some words are not used in any definition. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    14. 14. They can be removed Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    15. 15. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    16. 16. This process is recursive. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    17. 17. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    18. 18. Till no other word can be removed Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    19. 19. Resulting subgraph is “Grounding Kernel” (GK) of dictionary Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    20. 20. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    21. 21. Summary for compressed real dictionary 1500 words + Boole Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    22. 22. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    23. 23. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    24. 24. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    25. 25. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    26. 26. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    27. 27. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    28. 28. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    29. 29. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013 Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text
    30. 30. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    31. 31. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013 Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text > Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text Text
    32. 32. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    33. 33. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    34. 34. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    35. 35. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    36. 36. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    37. 37. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    38. 38. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    39. 39. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    40. 40. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    41. 41. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    42. 42. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    43. 43. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    44. 44. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    45. 45. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    46. 46. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    47. 47. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013 The “hard problem” of consciousness: Doing vs. Feeling
    48. 48. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    49. 49. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    50. 50. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    51. 51. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    52. 52. Jorge ArmonyBernard BaarsMark BalaguerSimon Baron-Cohen Roy Baumeister Bjorn Brembs John Campbell Erik Cook Fernando Cervero Paul CisekAxel CleermansGary Comstock Antonio DamasioDan DennettGregory Dudek Jeffrey Ebert David Edelman Shimon Edelman Barbara Finlay Dario Floreano Stan Franklin David Freedman Michael Graziano Patrick Haggard StevanHarnadInman Harvey Eva Jablonka Phillip Jackson David Jacobs Hakwan Lau Joseph Ledoux Malcolm MacIver Stefano Mancuso Julio Martinez Jennifer Mather Alfred Mele Bjorn Merker Thomas MetzingerEzequielMorsellaKarim Nader GualtieroPiccinini Christopher Pack Luiz Pessoa Gilles Plourde Alain Ptito Amir Raz David Rosenthal Anil Seth John Searle Michael Shadlen Amir ShmuelWolf Singer WayneKnowledge Stream 19 sept 2013 http://turingc.blog spot.ca
    53. 53. Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013 Borner, Katy graphic webs of science Dedeo, Simon collective dynamics on WikipediaDorogovtsev, Sergey network evolution Dror, Itiel cognitive technology and distributed cognition: the risks Gingras, Yves scientific interaction before and since the Web Gloor, Peter collaborative networks Golbeck, Jennfer social web Goldstone, Rob internet-enabled imitation and exploration in social networks Gordon, Deborah collective behaviour -- beginning of the conference Griffin, Stephen web-based interactive scholarship Hall, Wendy web science Halpin, Harry web semantics Han, Jiawey knowledge mining Hendler, Jim data webHey, Tony science web Heylighen, Francis global brain & distributed intelligence Kousha, KaivanwebmetricsLiu, Yang-Yu network control Menary, Richard extended mind Monnin, Alexandre web philosophyNeylon, Cameron open science data-mining Nishikawa, Takashi community structure (&Motter, A) Radicchi, Filippo network communities Rupert, Rob extended mind philo Simon, Judith socio-technical epistemology Steyvers, Mark crowdsourcing& wisdom of crowds Stibel, Jeff web & brain Tetlow, Phil web life Todd, Peter memory search, external foraging, and web search
    54. 54. QUESTIONS/COMMENTS? Knowledge Stream 19 sept 2013
    1. A particular slide catching your eye?

      Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

    ×