Lorain County Community College
      Strategic Energy Plan




          Elyria, Ohio 28th April 2009

           Garfort...
Strategic Energy Plan
             Team and Targets




                                         Reduce energy costs
    ...
Energy and Climate
             In the headlines around the world




Copyright: Garforth International llc
New Global Energy Realities
             Growing Impact on USA



              Volatile global energy prices
           ...
Global Cost of Energy


                                          What we pay for
                                        ...
Energy Productivity Differences
             How well do we spend our $1.5 Trillion?



                                  ...
Greenhouse gas levels
             160,000 yrs* of ice core data
                                          2050 Business a...
Warming the Planet




Copyright: Garforth International llc
Climate Change
             Range of Potential Impacts




Copyright: Garforth International llc     *Stern Review
Perfect Energy Storm
             When fears collide…


                                                         Availabil...
Creating a New Energy Reality
             …invest in energy and education…

    “To finally spark the creation of a clean...
Total US Energy Use



                              Coal

                                                               ...
Effectiveness by Sector
             How well do we use our energy?


                               Sector              E...
Dysfunctional Energy Supply Chain
             From fuel to service
                          Uses 70% of all energy


   ...
LCCC Campus overview


                                         Buildings from 1966 to 2008
                             ...
Lorain County Community College
             2007 vs 2004 Energy Overview

                                               ...
LCCC Energy Use 2007
             Benchmark - Austrian and Ohio Colleges


                                               ...
Evaluating energy needs
             Eight Buildings Modeled in Detail




Copyright: Garforth International llc
Establish Baseline
              Example – University Center



                                               Seasonal
  ...
Typical Efficiency Measures
             Examples from multiple buildings
                                                ...
Building Efficiency
             Many Opportunities Identified

              Building operation
                       ...
Base-to-Efficient Case Comparison
                                          Seasonal Demand by end use


                 ...
Energy Supply and Distribution
             Multiple Choices Evaluated

                                         Energy D...
Changing the Culture
             Green Campus Team



                                                  Students


      ...
Green Campus Team
             Many opportunities…

              Educate and inform…again and again!
              Redu...
Strategic Energy Plan
             Final Recommendations

              Investments
                          Building e...
Campus Strategic Energy Plan
             Results far exceed State Law



              Efficiency and Financial Indicati...
Thank you!
“Only Use what you Need, When you Need it,
        In the Amount Needed!” *



                              *C...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Green Campus Presentation April 28, 2009

1,689

Published on

Published in: Education, Technology, Business
0 Comments
1 Like
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
1,689
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
2
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0
Likes
1
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Transcript of "Green Campus Presentation April 28, 2009"

  1. 1. Lorain County Community College Strategic Energy Plan Elyria, Ohio 28th April 2009 Garforth International llc Energy Productivity Solutions
  2. 2. Strategic Energy Plan Team and Targets  Reduce energy costs  Increase energy efficiency  Reduce greenhouse gas Garforth International llc Energy Productivity Solutions Global Perspective – Local Expertise Copyright: Garforth International llc
  3. 3. Energy and Climate In the headlines around the world Copyright: Garforth International llc
  4. 4. New Global Energy Realities Growing Impact on USA  Volatile global energy prices  Dependence on imports  Climate change legislation  Underinvested energy infrastructure  China and India major new energy customers  Trigger events – blackouts, hurricanes, tornados …. Driving Local Ohio Policies Copyright: Garforth International llc
  5. 5. Global Cost of Energy What we pay for Gas, Electricity, Fuels.... $ 6.7 Trillion Energy we Energy we waste use USA ~ $1.5Trillion 12% of GDP Copyright: Garforth International llc
  6. 6. Energy Productivity Differences How well do we spend our $1.5 Trillion? Energy Energy Region Population GDP Energy /Capita /GDP USA 4.6% 25.9% 20.5% 100 100 EU 7.5% 31.1% 15.9% 47 60 Japan 1.9% 8.1% 4.6% 54 67 China 20.0% 6.1% 15.0% 17 312 India 17.1% 2.0% 4.7% 6 291 World 100% 100% 100% 22 81 Key to Competitiveness and Security *Various US/EU Sources – 2007 sources Copyright: Garforth International llc
  7. 7. Greenhouse gas levels 160,000 yrs* of ice core data 2050 Business as Usual Stabilization level? 2050 Today * John Houghton – UK Met Office et al Copyright: Garforth International llc
  8. 8. Warming the Planet Copyright: Garforth International llc
  9. 9. Climate Change Range of Potential Impacts Copyright: Garforth International llc *Stern Review
  10. 10. Perfect Energy Storm When fears collide… Availability Uncertain Prices Climate Change Growing awareness – Growing Opportunity Copyright: Garforth International llc
  11. 11. Creating a New Energy Reality …invest in energy and education… “To finally spark the creation of a clean energy economy, we will double the production of alternative energy in the next three years. We will modernize more than 75% of federal buildings and improve the energy efficiency of two million American homes, saving consumers and taxpayers billions on our energy bills. In the process, we will put Americans to work in new jobs that pay well and can’t be outsourced – jobs building solar panels and wind turbines; constructing fuel-efficient cars and buildings; and developing the new energy technologies that will lead to even more jobs, more savings, and a cleaner, safer planet in the bargain. …..That means updating the way we get our electricity by starting to build a new smart grid that will save us money, protect our power sources from blackout or attack, and deliver clean, alternative forms of energy to every corner of our nation.” President Obama – January 8th, 2009 Copyright: Garforth International llc
  12. 12. Total US Energy Use Coal Homes Buildings Gas 38.7% Commercial Domestic Oil Industry Uranium Industry 33.25% Renewable Transport Transportation 27.79% Import Oil Buildings largest energy consumer Copyright: Garforth International llc Source: US DoE EIA
  13. 13. Effectiveness by Sector How well do we use our energy? Sector Energy Energy Use Index Share USA/EU Industry 33% 1.2 Buildings* 39% USA 2.5 CALIF 1.8 Transportation* 28% 1.4  Most energy lost in range of inefficiencies  Only 5% to 15% used productively Major potential for efficiency gains! *Indicative ratio of US average to global best practice Copyright: Garforth International llc
  14. 14. Dysfunctional Energy Supply Chain From fuel to service Uses 70% of all energy 25% 5%  High greenhouse gas  High-cost low returns  High risk Pay for 100 get less than 10 Copyright: Garforth International llc
  15. 15. LCCC Campus overview  Buildings from 1966 to 2008  Networked heating and cooling for most buildings  New Library islanded building  No centralized automated building management system  Limited scheduling and occupancy management  No sub-metering for gas or electricity  Significant plug loads likely Copyright: Garforth International llc
  16. 16. Lorain County Community College 2007 vs 2004 Energy Overview 2007 2004 2004 2007 Utility $K kWhe $K kWhe Gas $ 507 $ 609 20,609,535 19,330,432 Electricity $ 947 $ 1,108 12,635,513 13,821,165 $ 1,454 33,245,048 $ 1,717 33,151,597 Total  Energy use 2% lower  Energy costs 18% higher  Carbon Footprint 19,600 Metric Tons  Carbon footprint from Commuting? State Law call for 20% reduction by 2014 Copyright: Garforth International llc
  17. 17. LCCC Energy Use 2007 Benchmark - Austrian and Ohio Colleges  LCCC Total Energy Index  375 kWhe/m2/year  79% higher than Austria average Lorain County CC Electricity Heat  Terra Community College  285 kWhe/m2/year  24% less than LCCC Average  Lakeland Community College  377 kWhe/m2/year  1% higher than LCCC  Owens Community College  438 kWhe/m2/year  17% higher than LCCC Energy Efficiency Potential Copyright: Garforth International llc
  18. 18. Evaluating energy needs Eight Buildings Modeled in Detail Copyright: Garforth International llc
  19. 19. Establish Baseline Example – University Center Seasonal Patterns End Uses Needs Energy Spot anomalies e.g. high plug loads Indexes Develop Energy End-Use Profiles Copyright: Garforth International llc
  20. 20. Typical Efficiency Measures Examples from multiple buildings  Upgrade roof insulation to at least R25  Eliminate thermal shorts in roof structure and window sills  Selectively replace windows  Install occupancy sensors  Implement daylighting control in atrium, corridors, classrooms, labs…  Realign and repair doors to reduce infiltration  Selectively add vestibules to high usage doors  Reduce plug load with staff/student awareness program  Manage heating, cooling and lighting according to scheduled needs Behavioral and Investment Based Copyright: Garforth International llc
  21. 21. Building Efficiency Many Opportunities Identified  Building operation  Heat and cool areas only when needed  Pre-condition areas according to weather  Night and low-occupancy set back of thermostats  Only light occupied areas  Utilize daylighting wherever feasible  Manage exterior lighting for real usage patterns  Reducing miscellaneous electrical loads  Building Structure  Roof insulation  Reduction of thermal bridges  Selective window replacements  Reduce unwanted air infiltration Improved control and metering is a Must Copyright: Garforth International llc
  22. 22. Base-to-Efficient Case Comparison Seasonal Demand by end use E n e rg y E ffic ie n t C a s e : C a m p u s C o n s u m p tio n S im u la te d B a s e L in e C a s e : C a m p u s C o n s u m p tio n S im u la te d 5000000 5000000 4500000 4500000 Ho t W a te r Hot W ater 4000000 4000000 S p a ce He a t Na t G a s S pace Heat Nat G as 3500000 3500000 A re a L ig hts A rea Lights k W h r e q u iv a le n t k W h r e q u iv a le n t Ta sk L ig hts 3000000 Task Lights 3000000 M isc. E q uip . M isc. E quip. 2500000 2500000 P um p s & A ux. P um ps & A ux. 2000000 2000000 V e nt. F a ns V ent. F ans S p a ce He a t E le ctric S pace Heat E le ctric 1500000 1500000 He a t Re je ct. Heat Reje ct. 1000000 1000000 S p a ce C o o l S pace C ool 500000 500000 0 0 Ja n Feb Mar A pr May Jun Jul A ug S ep O ct No v D ec Jan F eb M ar A pr M ay Jun Jul A ug S ep O ct Nov D ec M o n th s M o n th s Base Case Efficient Case Energy efficiency increased by 37% Copyright: Garforth International llc
  23. 23. Energy Supply and Distribution Multiple Choices Evaluated  Energy Distribution  Steam only  Islanded buildings  Upgrade heating network  Steam to hot water  Extend to new buildings and LC and SP  Upgraded cooling  On-Campus Generation  Combined heat and power  Engines  Turbine  Existing gas boilers  Biomass heating  Solar Photovoltaic  Wind energy Copyright: Garforth International llc
  24. 24. Changing the Culture Green Campus Team Students Staff Faculty Community Committed to Energy Excellence Copyright: Garforth International llc
  25. 25. Green Campus Team Many opportunities…  Educate and inform…again and again!  Reduce electricity use - personal space heaters, fans, refrigerators, vending machines, Office equipment  Turn off lights when leaving rooms  Use daylight whenever possible  Schedule classes with energy use in mind  Turn off equipment in computers labs when not in use  New investment ideas…  New syllabus ideas…. Reduce energy use by another 5% to 20%! Copyright: Garforth International llc
  26. 26. Strategic Energy Plan Final Recommendations  Investments  Building efficiency upgrades  Controls and meters  Hot water network  Combined heat and power generation  Consider biomass heating option  Active energy management  Scheduling and occupancy  Weather predictive management  Track and report greenhouse gas performance  Recognize educational opportunity  Design installations with teaching in mind  Update curriculum with energy and climate subjects Engaged Energy Team! Copyright: Garforth International llc
  27. 27. Campus Strategic Energy Plan Results far exceed State Law  Efficiency and Financial Indications  Energy efficiency gain ~ 37%  Greenhouse gas reductions ~ 39%  Internal Rate of Return (IRR) ~ 8% to 15%  Foundations of new academic programs  Base for wider community engagement Culture of Continuous Improvement Copyright: Garforth International llc
  28. 28. Thank you! “Only Use what you Need, When you Need it, In the Amount Needed!” * *Courtesy of Toyota Manufacturing

×