Falling in Love with Forms [BlendConf 2014]

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Aaron Gustafson
@AaronGustafson
slideshare.net/AaronGustafson

Forms suck.

They are incredibly
tedious to create.

They are undeniably
annoying to fill in.

They can be
frustrating to test.

They require logic.

can
Forms suck.

don’t have to
Forms suck.

can
a lot less
Forms suck.

Forms can be…
easy to build
predictable
effortless to use
and accessible

It’s all in how you
look at them.

HELPFUL HINT
Break large,
complex forms into
smaller, simpler,
reusable patterns

How about a
common example?
Let’s look
at a contact form.

webstandardssherpa.com/contact

webstandardssherpa.com/contact

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 1: Label & Field
Your Name
<input type=“text” name=“full_name”>

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 1: Label & Field
Your Name
<input name=“full_name”>

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 1: Label & Field
Your Name
<input name=“full_name”/>

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 1: Label & Field
Your Name
<input name=“full_name”>

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 1: Label & Field
<label>Your Name</label>
<input name=“full_name”>

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 1: Label & Field
<label for=“full_name”>Your Name</label>
<input id=“full_name” name...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 1: Label & Field
<label for=“full_name”>Your Name</label>
<input id=“full_name” name...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 2: Label, Field & Note
<label for=“email”>Your Email</label>
<input id=“email” name=...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 2: Label, Field & Note
<label for=“email”>Your Email</label>
<input id=“email” name=...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 2: Label, Field & Note
<label for=“email”>Your Email</label>
<input id=“email” name=...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 2: Label, Field & Note
<label for=“email”>Your Email</label>
<input type=“email” id=...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 2: Label, Field & Note
<label for=“email”>Your Email</label>
<input type=“email” id=...

Browsers ignore
what they don’t
understand

Progressive
Enhancement

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 2: Label, Field & Note
<label for=“email”>Your Email</label>
<input type=“email” id=...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 2: Label, Field & Note
<label for=“email”>Your Email</label>
<input type=“email” id=...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 2: Label, Field & Note
<label for=“email”>Your Email</label>
<input type=“email” id=...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 2: Label, Field & Note
<label for=“email”>Your Email</label>
<input type=“email” id=...

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Rinse & Repeat
<label for=“subject”>Purpose of Your Message</label>
<select id="subject" nam...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Rinse & Repeat
<label for=“message”>Your Message</label>
<textarea id="message" name="messag...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Buttons
<input type=“submit” value=“Send My Message”>

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Buttons
<button type=“submit”>Send My Message</button>

HELPFUL HINT
A button element
can contain pretty
much anything
! (within reason)

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Buttons
<button type="submit" value=“basic">
<h3>Basic Plan</h3>
<p>You get 20 <abbr title=...

That new email field
looks cool, can we
see more of that
fancy HTML5 stuff?

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting URLs
<label for=“url”>URL</label>
<input type=“url” id=“url” name=“url” required ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting URLs
<label for=“url”>URL</label>
<input type=“url” id=“url” name=“url” required ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting URLs
<label for=“url”>URL</label>
<input type=“url” id=“url” name=“url” required ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Providing hints
<label for=“url”>URL</label>
<input type=“url” id=“url” name=“url” required ...

HELPFUL HINT
Placeholders are just
that: placeholders
for actual content.
They are not labels!

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Providing hints
<label for=“url”>URL</label>
<input type=“url” id=“url” name=“url” required ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting phone numbers
<label for="preferred_phone">Preferred Phone</label>
<input type="t...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting phone numbers
<label for="preferred_phone">Preferred Phone</label>
<input type="t...

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting numbers
<label for="test">What is 1 + 1?</label>
<input id="test" type=“number" n...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting numbers
<label for="test">What is 1 + 1?</label>
<input id="test" type=“number" n...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting numbers
<label for="test">What is 1 + 1?</label>
<input id="test" type=“number" n...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting numbers
<label for=“volume">How Loud is Spinal Tap?</label>
<input id="volume" ty...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting numbers
<label for="test">What is 1 + 1?</label>
<input id="test" type=“number" n...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting dates & times
<label for="preferred_dates">Preferred Date to Visit</label>
<input...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting dates & times
<label for="preferred_dates">Preferred Date to Visit</label>
<input...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting dates & times
<label for="preferred_dates">Preferred Date to Visit</label>
<input...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting dates & times
<label for="preferred_dates">Preferred Date to Visit</label>
<input...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting dates & times
<label for="preferred_dates">Preferred Date to Visit</label>
<input...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting dates & times
<label for="requested_tour_time">Tour Time Requested</label>
<input...

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requesting dates & times
<label for="requested_tour_time">Tour Time Requested</label>
<input...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Mentalism
<label for="state">State</label>
<input id="state" name="state" list="states">
<d...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Mentalism
<label for="state">State</label>
<input id="state" name="state" list="states">
<d...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Mentalism
<label for="state">State</label>
<input id="state" name="state" list="states">
<d...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Mentalism
<label for="state">State</label>
<input id="state" name="state" list="states">
<d...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Mentalism: smart fallbacks
<label for=“state" id=“state_label”>State</label>
<datalist id=“s...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Mentalism: smart fallbacks
<label for=“state" id=“state_label”>State</label>
<datalist id=“s...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Mentalism: smart fallbacks
<label for=“state" id=“state_label”>State</label>
<datalist id=“s...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Mentalism: smart fallbacks
<label for=“state" id=“state_label”>State</label>
<datalist id=“s...

Ok, I get it: forms in
HTML5 are awesome.
But how should we
organize our forms?

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Do we divide it up?
<div>
<label for=“full_name”>Your Name</label>
<input id=“full_name” na...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Do paragraphs make sense?
<p>
<label for=“full_name”>Your Name</label>
<input id=“full_name...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Is it a list of questions?
<ol>
<li>
<label for=“full_name”>Your Name</label>
<input id=“f...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Is it a list of questions?
form ol,
form ul {
list-style: none;
margin: 0;
padding: 0;
}

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Control Group Classification
<li class=“text”>
<label for=“full_name”>Your Name</label>
<in...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Control Group Classification
<li class=“form-control form-control--text”>
<label for=“full_n...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Control Group Classification
<li class=“text”>
<label for=“full_name”>Your Name</label>
<in...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Control Group Classification
<li class=“email”>
<label for=“email”>Your Email</label>
<inpu...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Control Group Classification
<li class=“select”>
<label for=“subject”>Purpose of Your Messag...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Control Group Classification
<li class=“textarea”>
<label for=“message”>Your Message</label>...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Control Group Classification
<li class=“buttons”>
<button type=“submit”>Send My Message</but...

Makes sense.
What about more
complex form
constructs?

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 3: Confirmations
<input type=“checkbox” name=“newsletter” value=“yes”>
Sign me up fo...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 3: Confirmations
<input type=“checkbox” name=“newsletter” value=“yes”
id=“newsletter...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 3: Confirmations
<label>
<input type=“checkbox” name=“newsletter” value=“yes”>
Sign...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 3: Confirmations
input {
/* Styles for most normal input types */
}
!
label input...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 3: Confirmations
<label for=“newsletter”>
<input type=“checkbox” name=“newsletter” v...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 3: Confirmations
<li class=“confirm”>
<label for=“newsletter”>
<input type=“checkbo...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 4: Multiple Choice
Tablets (8 available)
!
<label for="asus-nexus-7">
<input type=...

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 4: Multiple Choice
Tablets (8 available)
!
<ul>
<li></li>
<!...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 4: Multiple Choice
<fieldset>
<legend>Tablets (8 available)</legend>
<ul>
<li><!--...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 4: Multiple Choice
<fieldset>
<legend>Tablets <em>(8 available)</em></legend>
<ul> ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 4: Multiple Choice
<fieldset>
<legend>Tablets <em>(8 available)</em></legend>
<ul> ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 4: Multiple Choice
<li class=“grouped checkboxes”>
<fieldset>
<legend>Tablets <em>(...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 5: Related Entry
Requested Day and Time
!
<label for="requested_date">Requested Day...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 5: Related Entry
<fieldset>
<legend>Requested Day and Time</legend>
!
<label for="...

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 5: Related Entry
<li class=“grouped date-time-selects”>
<fieldset>
<legend>Requeste...

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 5: Related Entry
/* Hide the labels in an accessible way */
form .date-time-selects ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 6: Multiple Labels
<li class=“grouped year-month-day-selects”>
<fieldset>
<legend>S...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 6: Multiple Labels
<li class=“grouped year-month-day-selects”>
<fieldset>
<legend>S...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 6: Multiple Labels
<li class=“grouped year-month-day-selects”>
<fieldset>
<legend>S...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 6: Multiple Labels
<li class=“grouped year-month-day-selects”>
<fieldset>
<legend i...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 6: Multiple Labels
<li class=“grouped year-month-day-selects”>
<fieldset>
<legend i...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 7: The dreaded table

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 7: The dreaded table
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<td></td>
<th>Poor</th>
<!-- Headings ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 7: The dreaded table
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<td></td>
<th>Poor</th>
<!-- Headings ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 7: The dreaded table
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<td></td>
<th>Poor</th>
<!-- Headings ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 7: The dreaded table
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<td></td>
<th id=“value-1”>Poor</th>
<...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 7: The dreaded table
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<td></td>
<th id=“value-1”>Poor</th>
<...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 7: The dreaded table
<table>
<thead>
<tr>

<th id=“value-...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Pattern 7: The dreaded table
<table>
<thead>
<tr>

<th id=“value-...

HELPFUL HINT
Focus on
making the form
read naturally
and easily.

HELPFUL HINT
You can’t always
make an interface
perfect, but you can
make it usable.

Ok, I think I’m
getting it, but
small screens still
scare me a little.

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Tap-friendly hit targets
.confirm label,
.radios label,
.checkboxes label {
margin: -1em 0...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Tap-friendly hit targets
.confirm label,
.radios label,
.checkboxes label {
margin: -1em 0...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
No layout before its time
.form-control {
clear: both;
}
.form-control label,
.form-contr...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
No layout before its time
.form-control label,
.form-control input {
display: block;
margi...

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
No layout before its time
.form-control label,
.form-control input {
display: block;
margi...

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
No layout before its time
.form-control label,
.form-control input {
display: block;
margi...

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
No layout before its time
@media only screen and (min-width:30em) {
!
form .grouped ul li {...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
No layout before its time
@media only screen and (min-width:30em) {
!
form .grouped ul li {...

Makes sense.
Could we talk a bit
about validation?

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requiring a field
<p>Fields marked with a * are required.</p>
<p>
<label for=“first_name"> ...

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requiring a field
<p>Fields marked with a * are required.</p>
<p>
<label for=“first_name"> ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requiring a field
<p>Fields marked with a * are required.</p>
<p>
<label for=“first_name"> ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requiring a field
<p>Fields marked with a * are
<strong id="required">required</strong>.</p>...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requiring a field
<p>Fields marked with a * are
<strong id="required">required</strong>.</p>...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requiring a field
<p tabindex="0">Fields marked with a * are required.</p>
<p>
<label for=“...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Requiring a field
<p tabindex="0">Fields marked with a * are required.</p>
<p>
<label for=“...

HELPFUL HINT
Focus on
making the form
read naturally
and easily.

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Native validation
<label for=“email”>Your Email</label>
<input type=“email” id=“email” name=...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Non-native format validation
<label for="test">What is 1 + 1?</label>
<input id="test" type=...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Non-native format validation
<label for=“test">Enter three numbers
followed by two letters</...

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Non-native format validation
<label for=“test">Enter three numbers
followed by two letters</...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Custom error messages

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Custom error messages
var field = document.getElementById(‘test’);
field.setCustomValidity( ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Custom error messages
var field = document.getElementById(‘test’);
field.setCustomValidity( ...

github.com/easy-designs/jquery.easy-validation.js

YouTube videos are no longer supported on Slideshare

View original on YouTube

A dead simple
polyfill for HTML5
forms & custom
validation messages.

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Custom error messages
<label for=“test">Enter three numbers
followed by two letters</label> ...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Custom error messages
<form …
data-validation-error-empty=“You forgot to enter text here”
d...

HELPFUL HINT
Don’t forget about
server-side
validation either.

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Provide a list of errors
retreats4geeks.com/contact

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Provide a list of errors
<div role=“alert”>
<p>There were errors with your form submission:<...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Provide a list of errors
<div role=“alert”>
<p>There were errors with your form submission:<...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Provide easy access to them
<div role=“alert”>
<p>There were errors with your form submissio...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Provide easy access to them
<label for=“message”>
Message <abbr title=“required">*</abbr>
<...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Provide field-level help
<li class="text validation-error">
<label for=“email">Email <abbr t...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Provide field-level help
li.validation-error {
color: #922026;
}
!
li.validation-error in...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Provide field-level help
.validation-error label::before {
content: "x ";
font-family: Verd...

FALLING IN LOVE WITH FORMS
Provide field-level help
.validation-error label::before {
content: "x ";
font-family: Verd...

Forms suck.

can
a lot less
Forms suck.

Forms can be…
easy to build
predictable
effortless to use
and accessible

Thank you!
!
@AaronGustafson
aaron-gustafson.com
slideshare.net/AaronGustafson