Mythology and Geography


Published on

Material for participants. IST Comenius-Grundtvig Course. Europe between Mythology, Modernity and Multiculturalism. Powered by Laboratorio del Cittadino Onlus.

Published in: Education
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Mythology and Geography

  1. 1. Mythology, Geography and cartographyDESCRIPTION: This slide shows a 19th century reconstruction of the world view of the Greekphilosopher Strabo who wrote his famous geography at the beginning of the Christian era andcompiled his map from travelers reports and the "writings" of ancients. The now lost map by Straborepresented the sum total of cartographic knowledge before the Christian Era.The contribution of Strabo as a scholar of great stature as philosopher, historian, and geographer,epitomizes the continuing importance of the Greek intellectual heritage - and contemporary practice- to the development of cartography in the early Roman world. As the reviser of Eratosthenes, healso illustrates the continuous way later generations had built on the cartographic concepts firstclearly set out in the Hellenistic Age.We are fortunate in possessing all seventeen books of the Geographia by Strabo, written in goodGreek although he himself was mixed Asiatic and Greek stock; it is through his writings that mostof our knowledge of Eratosthenes mapping has come down. He was born at Amasia [Amasya] inPontus in 64 or 63 B.C. Strabo was educated at Nysa near Tralles in Caria and in 44 B.C. went toRome, where he studied under the Phoenician freedman Tyrannio and the Stoic philosopherAthenodorus. He showed himself a keen supporter of Augustus and visited Rome several times.From about 25 to 20 B.C. he was in Egypt, based at Alexandria. His Geographia was writtenbetween 9 and 5 B.C. and parts revised in AD 18-19. Surprisingly, though, it seems not to havebeen read in Rome in the first century, judging from the fact that it is not even mentioned by theelder Pliny.Strabo claimed to have traveled widely to bring together an enormous amount of geographicalknowledge. It is generally accepted, however, that he must have compiled much of this informationin the great library at Alexandria, where he had access to many earlier texts now lost. All hiswritings were firmly set in, if not direct extensions of, the work of his predecessors. Thus hisHistorical Memoirs in forty-seven books, now lost, was a continuation of Polybius. TheGeographia is of key importance to our whole knowledge of the history of Greek cartography as
  2. 2. well as to the history of science in general. Cortesão states that as a source it was "second to none inthe history of geography and cartography" of this period. Many of the earlier treastises that touchupon maps are known to us only through Strabo, while the interest of his commentary on thesewriters is in its critical handling of their theories, albeit he sometimes fails to advance truth by thisprocess.In many ways the most interesting passages relating to cartography in Strabos Geographia arethose that, although they contain no maps, give an account, for the first time in a surviving text, ofhow a description of the known world should be compiled. His motives for writing such ageography (so he tells us) were that he felt impelled to describe the inhabited world because of theconsiderable strides in geographical knowledge that had been made through the numerouscampaigns of the Romans and Parthians. The world map had to be adjusted to take account of thesefacts, and thus Strabo almost certainly proceeded by taking Eratosthenes map - and the criticism ofit by Polybius, Crates, Hipparchus, and Posidonius - as the basis for his own work.In this task of compilation Strabo seems to have worked systematically. The first stage was to locatethe portion of the terrestrial globe that was known to be inhabited. Strabo reasoned that it lay in anorthern quadrant of a globe, in a quadrilateral bounded by the frigid zone, the equator, and twomeridians on the sides. Strabo locates the frigid zone, or arctic circle, at 54° distance from theequator. The so-called quadrilateral, bounded by half of this arctic circle, half of the equator, andsegments of two meridians, is a spherical quadrilateral, a portion of a sphere. In this design Strabohad been influenced not only by Eratosthenes measurement of the earth but also by the concept ofthe four inhabited worlds, known and unknown, expounded by Crates, to whom he refers explicitly.Thus far Strabo had relied on theoretical argument derived from his authorities. But he also adducedgood empirical grounds for this cartographic reasoning. He continued:But if anyone disbelieves the evidence of reason, it would make no difference, from the point ofview of the geographer, whether we make the inhabited world an island, or merely admit whatexperience has taught us, namely, that it is possible to sail round the inhabited world on both sides,from the east as well as from the west, with the exception of a few intermediate stretches. And, as tothese stretches, it makes no difference whether they are bounded by sea or by uninhabited land; forthe geographer undertakes to describe the known parts of the inhabited world, but he leaves out ofconsideration the unknown parts of it - just as he does what is outside of it. And it will suffice to fillout and complete the outline of what we term "the island" by pining with a straight line the extremepoints reached on the coasting-voyages made on both sides of the inhabited world.Despite the extension of the geographical horizons of the inhabited world since the time ofEratosthenes, Strabos oikumene [inhabited world] was smaller. Although Pythæs, Eratosthenes, andperhaps Posidonius had fixed its northern limit on the parallel through Thule [Iceland ? 66° N],Strabo, like Polybius, refused to believe that human life was possible so far north, and he blamedPytheas for having misled so many people by his claim that the "summer tropic" becomes the"arctic circle" at the island of Thule. Again following Polybius, Strabo thus chose as the northernlimit of the map and of the inhabited world the parallel through Ierne [Irelandl, "which island notonly lies beyond Britain but is such a wretched place to live in on account of the cold that theregions on beyond are regarded as uninhabitable." This parallel (54° N) is the projection of thecelestial arctic circle constructed for the latitude of Rhodes (36° N); it coincides with the onementioned by Geminus as the northern limit of the temperate zone. The southern limit of habitableland, for Strabo as for Eratosthenes, is the parallel through the "Cinnamon-producing country"[Ethiopia/Somaliland] at about 12° N. He estimated the latitudinal extent of the inhabited world asless than 30,000 stades (compared with Eratosthenes 38,000 stades) and reduced its length to70,000 stades instead of Eratosthenes 78,000.In order to avoid the deformational problems of flat maps, Strabo stated that he preferred toconstruct his map on a globe large enough to show all the required detail. He recommended that it
  3. 3. be at least ten feet (approximately three meters) in diameter and mentions Crates in this regard. Onthe other hand, if a globe of this size could not be constructed, Strabo was familiar fromEratosthenes with the transformation necessary to draw it on a plane surface. For a graticule, Straboadopted the straight forward rectangular network of parallels and meridians. He defended hisprojection on the ground that it would make only a slight difference if the circles on the earth wererepresented by straight lines, "for our imagination can easily transfer to the globular and sphericalsurface the figure or magnitude seen by the eye on a plane surface." The dimensions of this flat mapwere also to be generous. Strabo envisaged that it would be at least seven feet long and presumablythree feet wide, which would suit the length of the inhabited world (70,000 by 30,000 stades), onefoot being equivalent to 10,000 stades. Taking eight stades to a Roman mile, the scales is1:6,250,000.As with all Greek world maps, the great impediment to study for the historian of cartography is thatwe have only these verbal descriptions, not the images themselves. Nevertheless, apart from thereduced size of the inhabited world, the map Strabo envisaged was similar in its overall shape tothat drawn by Eratosthenes. In describing its detailed geography, however, Strabo did not employ,at least overtly, Eratosthenes division of the world into irregular quadrilaterals or sphragides, buthe often used geometric figures or comparisons to everyday objects to describe the general outlineof a country. For instance, he says that the province of Gallia Narbonensis presents the shape of aparallelogram; that the rivers Garumma [Garonne] and Liger [Loire] are parallel to the Pyrenæus[Pyrenees], forming with the ocean and the Cemmenus Mountains [Cevenne] two parallelograms;that Britain is triangular; that Italy has been shaped sometimes like a triangle, sometimes like aquadrilateral; that Sicily is indeed triangular, though one side is convex and the two others slightlyconcave. Similarly, Strabo compares the shape of Iberia to an ox-hide, the Peloponnese to a plane-leaf; and the northern part of Asia, east of the Caspian, to a kitchen knife with the straight sidealong the Taurus range and the curved side along the northern coastline. India, with two adjacentsides (south and east) much longer than the two others, he described as Rhomboidal; Mesopotamia,between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers, he saw as being like a boat drawn in profile, with the deckon the Tigris side and the keel near the Euphrates. Strabo repeats that the river Nile was describedby Eratosthenes as a reversed N, and that its mouth was named after the Greek capital letter delta.It is not clear how we should interpret these familiar graphic similes Strabo employed to describe tohis readers the land areas and other features on the world map. But they do suggest that he waswriting with a map in front of him. In some cases, where alternative descriptions are provided, hemay have been attempting to collate the outlines of more than one map. It is also probable thatstudents were expected to consult the text of the Geographia with the help of maps, so that theshapes thus enumerated may have served as a simple mnemonic. Yet if such suggestions mustremain speculative, there can be little doubt that by the early Roman period world maps and globesdrawn by Greek scholars were encouraging a distinctively geographical way of thinking about theworld. And it is likely, among the educated group at least, that an increasingly standard image of theinhabited world had come to be more widely accepted through the use of these maps.Strabo was a lengthy and discursive writer, but demonstrated good critical power in assessingearlier geographical writers and has given us a verbal picture of the known world of the time. Hetreats Homer as the first writer on geography, and defends the Homeric picture of the known worldas substantially true. But within the Homeric chapters he has a section in which he attempts toanalyze navigation of the oceans over the ages. Thus he says: "It is not reasonable to suppose thatthe Atlantic consists of two seas, confined by narrow isthmuses so as to prevent circumnavigation;rather it must be confluent and continuous." His argument is that explorers tried to sail aroundAfrica but turned back when not obstructed by any landmass. The problems of the armchairgeographer are revealed in the journalistic trick of quotes from quotes on an important exploration:Posidonius says Herodotus thinks that certain men sent by Neco completed the circumnavigation.This is all he reports, so that we have to beware of using all his work as scientifically worthymaterial. Perhaps because he is drawing on an account at second hand, he is afraid to support what
  4. 4. may have seemed like science fiction. He does not deal extensively with Hanno the Carthaginian,instead spending much effort on questioning the explorations of Eudoxus of Cyzicus, who musthave added to the accumulation of knowledge about the remote parts of Africa.Strabo likes to represent myths and poetic phraseology geographically. Thus he says that the legendof the Golden Fleece brought back from Colchis by the Argonauts reflects the search for gold byearly Greeks in areas of the Black Sea. When Homer made Hera say: "For I shall see the bounds offertile earth and Oceanus, father of the gods", what he means, says Strabo, is that the Ocean touchesall the extremities of the land. Or again, when Homer describes Odysseus as seeing land as he wason the crest of a great wave, he must have been referring to the curvature of the earth, aphenomenon familiar to sailors. Some of this was polemic against Eratosthenes, who would nothave if that early epic poetry could contribute anything to scientific theory.The most detailed examination of a term arising from Homeric geography is in respect ofEthiopians. What did Homer mean by saying they were divided in two, some where Hyperion risesand some where he sets? The historian Ephorus (c.405-330 B.C.) mentioned an early tradition thatEthiopians had overrun Libya, i.e. north Africa, as far as Dyris [the Atlas Mountains], and that somehad stayed there. Crates view was based upon an unorthodox view that the division was north-southrather than the obvious interpretation of east-west. Aristarchus of Samothrace (ca. 155 B.C.)criticized Crates interpretation, but claimed that Homer was simply wrong and there was only onearea in which Ethiopians lived. Strabos own view is that there were two groups of Ethiopians, oneliving in Asia and one in Africa; and that Homer thought likewise, though not to the extent ofplacing the eastern group in India, of which he had no knowledge. However, this idea of easternEthiopians living in some area of India and resembling Indians in appearance and customs persistedthroughout antiquity.The function of geography, according to Strabo, is to be an interpreter, not of the whole world, butof the inhabited world. Thus, accepting Eratosthenes measurement of 252,000 stades for thecircumference of the earth, the geographer ought not to include the equatorial zone, since that inStrabos view is uninhabitable. Instead he should start his analysis with the Cinnamon Country [nearthe mouth of the Red Sea, Somaliland], about 8,800 stades north of the equator, in the south, andwith Ireland in the north. He categorizes regions from south to north according to greatest length ofday in equinoctial hours. This list, starting at Meroe with thirteen hours and ending at an area northof the Sea of Azov with seventeen hours, is similar to that given by the elder Pliny. As mentionedearlier, in the extreme north, Strabo denied the existence of a Thule Island [Iceland ?]. To him themost northerly inhabited area was Ierne [Ireland], itself only wretchedly inhabitable because of thecold, to such an extent that regions beyond it are regarded as uninhabitable. Likewise, if one wereto go not more than 4,000 stades [500 Roman miles] north from the center of Britain, one wouldfind an area near Ireland, which like the latter would be barely inhabitable.Strabos idea of the shape of the inhabited world is defined as follows:Let it be taken as hypothesis that the earth together with the sea is spherical. Though not ascomplete a sphere as if turned on a lathe . . . Let the sphere be thought of as having five zones. Letthe equator be conceived as a circle on n, and let a second circle be conceived parallel to it,delimiting the frigid zone in the northern hemisphere, and through the poles a circle cutting these atright angles. Then, since the northern hemisphere contains two-fourths of the earth . . ., in each ofthese fourths a quadrilateral is delimited . . . In one of these two quadrilaterals . . . we say that aninhabited world is settled, surrounded by sea and like an island.He goes on to suggest that the quadrilateral in which the Atlantic lies resembles in shape half thesurface of a spinning-wheel, and that the oikumene [inhabited world] resembles a chlamys, a Greekmantle. This suggests that the eastern and western extremities of the oikumene were thought of astapering and convex. Again, he estimated the length of the oikumene as 70,000 stades and its widthas less than 30,000.
  5. 5. As the ideal method of mapping the world, Strabo writes in far more cartographic terms than before,We have now inscribed on a spherical surface the area in which we say the inhabited world issettled; and anyone most closely modelling reality by means of man-made representations shouldmake a sphere of the earth, as Crates did, mark off the quadrilateral on it, and inside this shouldplace his map of the geographia, of the inhabited world. But one needs a large globe, so that thesection mentioned, being only a fraction of it, may clearly show the appropriate parts of theoikumene, which win present a recognizable shape to users. If one can construct such a globe, itshould be not less than 10 feet in diameter. If one cannot make it as big or not much smaller, oneshould construct a map of the oikumene on a plane surface at least seven feet long. For it will makelittle difference if instead of the circles, vis. parallels and meridians, we draw straight lines betweenwhich to place the klimata with the winds and the other differences, and the positions of parts of theearth relative to each other and to celestial phenomena.He goes on to say there is little point in making the meridians converge slightly in such a map, sowas it rectangular, a forerunner of something like Mercators projection?Like Herodotus, Strabo had travelled himself from Armenia and western Italy, from the Black Seato Egypt and up the Nile to Philæ. But his seventeen volumes-vastly important to hiscontemporaries- read like a romance to us today, and a glance at the map laid down according to hisdescriptions is like a vague and distorted caricature of the real thing. And yet, according to the menof his times, he "surpasses all the geographical writings of antiquity, both in grandeur of plan and inabundance and variety of its materials."Strabo has summed up for us the knowledge of the ancient world as it was in the days of theEmperor Cæsar Augustus of the great Roman Empire, as it was when in far-off Syria the Christ wasborn and the greater part of the known earth was under the sway of Rome. A wall-map had alreadybeen designed by order of Augustus to hang in a public place in Rome - the heart of the Empire - sothat the young Romans might realize the size of their inheritance, while a list of the chief places onthe roads, which, radiating from Rome, formed a network over the Empire, was inscribed on theGolden Milestone in the Forum.Strabo begins his book with a detailed account of southern Spain where he tells of her two hundredtowns.Those best known are situated on the rivers, estuaries, and seas; but the two, which have acquiredthe greatest name and importance, are Cordova and Cadiz. After these Seville is the most noted . . .A vast number of people dwell along the Guadalquivir, and you may sail up it almost a hundred andtwenty miles from the sea to Cordova and the places a little higher. The banks and little inlets of thisriver are cultivated with the greatest diligence. The eye is also delighted with groves and gardens,which for this district are met with in the highest perfection. For fifty miles the river is navigable forships of considerable size, but for the cities higher up smaller vessels are employed, and thence toCordova river-boats. These are not constructed of planks pined together, but they were formerlymade out of a single trunk. A chain of mountains, rich in metal, runs parallel to the Guadalquivir,approaching the river, sometimes more, sometimes less, toward the north.He grows enthusiastic over the richness of this part of southern Spain, famous from ancient daysunder the name of Tartessus for its wealth.Large quantities of corn and wine are exported, besides much oil, which is of the first quality, alsowax, honey, and pitch . . . the country furnishes the timber for their shipbuilding. They havelikewise mineral salt and not a few salt streams. A considerable quantity of salted fish is exported,
  6. 6. not only from hence, but also from the remainder of the coast beyond the Pillars. Formerly theyexported large quantities of garments, but they now send the unmanufactured wool remarkable forits beauty. The stuffs manufactured are of incomparable texture. There is a superabundance of cattleand a great variety of game, while on the other hand there are certain little hares which burrow inthe ground (rabbits). These creatures destroy both seeds and trees by gnawing their roots. They aremet with throughout almost the whole of Spain. It is said that formerly the inhabitants of Majorcaand Minorca sent a deputation to the Romans requesting that a new land might be given them, asthey were quite driven out of their country by these animals, being no longer able to stand againsttheir vast multitudes." The seacoast on the Atlantic side abounds in fish, says Strabo. "The congersare quite monstrous, far surpassing in size those of Our Sea. Shoals of rich fat tuna fish are drivenhither from the seacoast beyond. They feed on the fruit, of stunted oak, which grows at the bottomof the sea and produces very large acorns. So great is the quantity of fruit, that at the season whenthey are ripe the whole coast on either side of the Pillars is covered with acorns thrown up by thetides. The tuna fish become gradually thinner, owing to the failure of their food as they approachthe Pillars from the outer sea.He describes, too, the metals of this wondrous land - gold, silver, copper, and iron. It is astonishingto think that in the days of Strabo the silver mines employed forty thousand workmen, and producedthe modern-day equivalence of approximately $1,800 a day!But we cannot follow Strabo over the world in all his detail. He tells us of a people living north ofthe Tagus, who slept on the ground, fed on acorn-bread, and wore black cloaks by day and night. Hedoes not think Britain is worth conquering - Ireland lies to the north, not west, of Britain; it is abarren land full of cannibals and wrapped in eternal snows - the Pyrenees nun parallel to the Rhine -the Danube rises near the Alps - even Italy herself runs east and west instead of north and south. Hisremarks on India are interesting."The reader," he says, "must receive the accounts of this country with indulgence. Few persons ofour nation have seen it; the greater part of what they relate is from report. Very few of themerchants who now sail from Egypt by the Nile and the Arabian Gulf to India have proceeded asfar as the Ganges."He is determined not to be led astray by the fables of the great size of India. Some had told him itwas a third of the whole habitable world, some that it took four months to walk through the plainonly. "Ceylon is said to be an island lying out at sea seven days sail from the most southerly partsof India. Its length is about eight hundred miles. It produces elephants."Strabo died about the year A.D. 21, and a century passed before Pliny wrote An Account ofCountries, Nations, Seas, Towns, Havens, Mountains, Rivers, Distances, and Peoples who nowExist or Formerly Existed.Strange to say, he never refers in the most distant way to his famous predecessor Strabo. He has butlittle to add to the earth-knowledge of Strabo. But he gives us a fuller account of Great Britain,based on the fresh discovers of Roman generals.LOCATION: this map only exists as reconstruction.