SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
APPENDIX II - Deceptive Action taken by the WOFE regarding
Filing of its SAIC Documents
In evaluating HOGS’ SAIC filings, GeoInvesting took the most comprehensive approach
possible, evaluating the financials of both the individual subsidiaries as well as of the parent
company (“WOFE”).

Specifically, we obtained SAIC data for 11 of 14 of Zhongpin’s 2009 subsidiaries and 11 of 13
of the company’s 2008 subsidiaries. Several, including the biggest subsidiary, were audited.
Please see Appendix IV for why we are completely confident that the subsidiaries we don’t have
information for are immaterial to our discussion.

The ownership structure of HOGS is similar to that of many US listed Chinese companies.
There is a parent company (“WOFE”) which has no substantial business operations. Instead, the
WOFE is the legal entity that aids in capital raising activities and may be entitled to receive cash
flows such as dividends from its subsidiaries.

The 2010 Form 10-K explains this in detail. (WOFE explained)
       “As a result of such agreements, HZFC (WOFE), which is a wholly owned indirect
       subsidiary of our company, is entitled to 100% of any cash dividends declared and
       paid by Henan Zhongpin and to vote all outstanding shares of capital stock of Henan
       Zhongpin in any action by the shareholders of Henan Zhongpin.
       On May 20, 2005, Henan Zhongpin Food Co., Ltd. (“HZFC”) was established in China
       for the sole purpose of holding the capital stock of [the operating company] Henan
       Zhongpin and its subsidiaries. The owners of Henan Zhongpin formed HZFC with an
       initial investment of 16,000,000 Renminbi (“RMB”) ($1,932,367).”

In China, the annual inspections are performed by various PRC government agencies (SAIC,
SAT, SAFE, Customs and others). Those agencies require the financial statements of the WOFE
to complete their inspections. The WOFE is therefore required to file its own audited
financial statements with the SAIC. In the case of HOGS, its WOFE submitted only
consolidated financial statements and not its own, making it impossible for the agencies to
complete their inspections. Furthermore, as we stated, HOGS’ SEC documents clearly state that
the WOFE only exists to receive cash flows, such as potential dividends, from its subsidiaries so
it has no meaningful operations. Thus, the WOFE’s true financial statements (which should not
be consolidated) should not reflect meaningful revenues or net income.

However, we cannot find the WOFE’s financial statement, but only a consolidated financial
statement. Furthermore, the WOFE claimed the financial data of the consolidated financial
statement (total assets, total liability, revenue and net income) as its own data in the SAIC report.
Apparently, this is wrong and unacceptable.

We understand that it would be much more convenient to amend/compromise one filing (the
parent/WOFE) than to coordinate the amendment of many (13 or 14 in HOGS’ case)
subsidiaries. What is particularly noteworthy with HOGS’ SAIC filings is that while the
consolidated net incomes of the company’s operating subsidiaries do not come close to
matching the SEC filings, the financial statements of the WOFE do in fact match what was
filed with the SEC. So, it seems the consolidated net income reported by the WOFE is
dramatically greater than the sum of its operating subsidiaries. That is simply not possible and
makes little accounting sense since consolidation would result in less cumulative net income, not
more. That’s because related party balances are eliminated in consolidation which reduces
consolidated net income. Furthermore, the WOFE, as clearly stated in SEC filings, has no
meaningful operations. It basically exists to receives cash flows, such as potential dividends,
from its subsidiaries. Where then, are the true financial statements of your WOFE?

Given this odd set of circumstances we can only conclude that HOGS’ management amended
(i.e., falsified) the filings of its WOFE apparently for no other purpose but to ensure the
financial statements reported to the SAIC were consistent with what was filed with the
SEC.

More Related Content

More from GeoInvesting LLC

Shedding Light on Tech Pro Technology (03823.HK)
Shedding Light on Tech Pro Technology (03823.HK)Shedding Light on Tech Pro Technology (03823.HK)
Shedding Light on Tech Pro Technology (03823.HK)GeoInvesting LLC
 
Growth + Value Opportunities
Growth + Value OpportunitiesGrowth + Value Opportunities
Growth + Value OpportunitiesGeoInvesting LLC
 
2016 Microcap Conference Toronto
2016 Microcap Conference Toronto2016 Microcap Conference Toronto
2016 Microcap Conference TorontoGeoInvesting LLC
 
April 11, 2016 - Heng Ren White Paper on Chinese Buyouts
April 11, 2016 -  Heng Ren White Paper on Chinese BuyoutsApril 11, 2016 -  Heng Ren White Paper on Chinese Buyouts
April 11, 2016 - Heng Ren White Paper on Chinese BuyoutsGeoInvesting LLC
 
Moseda Technologies Company Presentation, November 2015
Moseda Technologies Company Presentation, November 2015Moseda Technologies Company Presentation, November 2015
Moseda Technologies Company Presentation, November 2015GeoInvesting LLC
 
Moseda Technologies Mobile Health Solutions
Moseda Technologies Mobile Health SolutionsMoseda Technologies Mobile Health Solutions
Moseda Technologies Mobile Health SolutionsGeoInvesting LLC
 
Geo investing Newsletter April 2015
Geo investing Newsletter April 2015Geo investing Newsletter April 2015
Geo investing Newsletter April 2015GeoInvesting LLC
 
L & L Energy's (LLEN) Dickson Lee Sentencing Memorandum - 2015
L & L Energy's (LLEN) Dickson Lee Sentencing Memorandum - 2015L & L Energy's (LLEN) Dickson Lee Sentencing Memorandum - 2015
L & L Energy's (LLEN) Dickson Lee Sentencing Memorandum - 2015GeoInvesting LLC
 
Vocus cloud marketing software analyst day presentation june 6 2012
Vocus cloud marketing software analyst day presentation june 6 2012Vocus cloud marketing software analyst day presentation june 6 2012
Vocus cloud marketing software analyst day presentation june 6 2012GeoInvesting LLC
 
Anonymous Analytics calls QIHU out for Fraud
Anonymous Analytics calls QIHU out for FraudAnonymous Analytics calls QIHU out for Fraud
Anonymous Analytics calls QIHU out for FraudGeoInvesting LLC
 
Equity Insights - Sionex (SINX) Research Report May 2012
Equity Insights - Sionex (SINX) Research Report May 2012Equity Insights - Sionex (SINX) Research Report May 2012
Equity Insights - Sionex (SINX) Research Report May 2012GeoInvesting LLC
 
Neenah Paper Feb 2012 Investor Presentation
Neenah Paper Feb 2012 Investor PresentationNeenah Paper Feb 2012 Investor Presentation
Neenah Paper Feb 2012 Investor PresentationGeoInvesting LLC
 
Conclusive Proof that L&L International (LLEN) Does Not Own the Ping Yi Mine
Conclusive Proof that L&L International (LLEN) Does Not Own the Ping Yi MineConclusive Proof that L&L International (LLEN) Does Not Own the Ping Yi Mine
Conclusive Proof that L&L International (LLEN) Does Not Own the Ping Yi MineGeoInvesting LLC
 
Cleantech Innovations (CTEK) files Injunctive Relief Against NASDAQ
Cleantech Innovations (CTEK) files Injunctive Relief Against NASDAQCleantech Innovations (CTEK) files Injunctive Relief Against NASDAQ
Cleantech Innovations (CTEK) files Injunctive Relief Against NASDAQGeoInvesting LLC
 
Appendix IV - Zhongpin Sub Breakdown
Appendix IV - Zhongpin Sub BreakdownAppendix IV - Zhongpin Sub Breakdown
Appendix IV - Zhongpin Sub BreakdownGeoInvesting LLC
 
Share Transfer from Ming Zhao to Citic Trust (July, 2010)
Share Transfer from Ming Zhao to Citic Trust (July, 2010)Share Transfer from Ming Zhao to Citic Trust (July, 2010)
Share Transfer from Ming Zhao to Citic Trust (July, 2010)GeoInvesting LLC
 
Share Pledge from Putai Mining to Citic Trust (Jan, 2011)
Share Pledge from Putai Mining to Citic Trust (Jan, 2011)Share Pledge from Putai Mining to Citic Trust (Jan, 2011)
Share Pledge from Putai Mining to Citic Trust (Jan, 2011)GeoInvesting LLC
 
Share Transfer from Putai to Ming Zhao (September 2009)
Share Transfer from Putai to Ming Zhao (September 2009)Share Transfer from Putai to Ming Zhao (September 2009)
Share Transfer from Putai to Ming Zhao (September 2009)GeoInvesting LLC
 
3 25-2011 GeoInvesting Rebuttal to CGPI Letter to Shareholders
3 25-2011 GeoInvesting Rebuttal to CGPI Letter to Shareholders3 25-2011 GeoInvesting Rebuttal to CGPI Letter to Shareholders
3 25-2011 GeoInvesting Rebuttal to CGPI Letter to ShareholdersGeoInvesting LLC
 

More from GeoInvesting LLC (20)

Shedding Light on Tech Pro Technology (03823.HK)
Shedding Light on Tech Pro Technology (03823.HK)Shedding Light on Tech Pro Technology (03823.HK)
Shedding Light on Tech Pro Technology (03823.HK)
 
Growth + Value Opportunities
Growth + Value OpportunitiesGrowth + Value Opportunities
Growth + Value Opportunities
 
2016 Microcap Conference Toronto
2016 Microcap Conference Toronto2016 Microcap Conference Toronto
2016 Microcap Conference Toronto
 
April 11, 2016 - Heng Ren White Paper on Chinese Buyouts
April 11, 2016 -  Heng Ren White Paper on Chinese BuyoutsApril 11, 2016 -  Heng Ren White Paper on Chinese Buyouts
April 11, 2016 - Heng Ren White Paper on Chinese Buyouts
 
Moseda Technologies Company Presentation, November 2015
Moseda Technologies Company Presentation, November 2015Moseda Technologies Company Presentation, November 2015
Moseda Technologies Company Presentation, November 2015
 
Moseda Technologies Mobile Health Solutions
Moseda Technologies Mobile Health SolutionsMoseda Technologies Mobile Health Solutions
Moseda Technologies Mobile Health Solutions
 
AVXL Promo Content
AVXL Promo ContentAVXL Promo Content
AVXL Promo Content
 
Geo investing Newsletter April 2015
Geo investing Newsletter April 2015Geo investing Newsletter April 2015
Geo investing Newsletter April 2015
 
L & L Energy's (LLEN) Dickson Lee Sentencing Memorandum - 2015
L & L Energy's (LLEN) Dickson Lee Sentencing Memorandum - 2015L & L Energy's (LLEN) Dickson Lee Sentencing Memorandum - 2015
L & L Energy's (LLEN) Dickson Lee Sentencing Memorandum - 2015
 
Vocus cloud marketing software analyst day presentation june 6 2012
Vocus cloud marketing software analyst day presentation june 6 2012Vocus cloud marketing software analyst day presentation june 6 2012
Vocus cloud marketing software analyst day presentation june 6 2012
 
Anonymous Analytics calls QIHU out for Fraud
Anonymous Analytics calls QIHU out for FraudAnonymous Analytics calls QIHU out for Fraud
Anonymous Analytics calls QIHU out for Fraud
 
Equity Insights - Sionex (SINX) Research Report May 2012
Equity Insights - Sionex (SINX) Research Report May 2012Equity Insights - Sionex (SINX) Research Report May 2012
Equity Insights - Sionex (SINX) Research Report May 2012
 
Neenah Paper Feb 2012 Investor Presentation
Neenah Paper Feb 2012 Investor PresentationNeenah Paper Feb 2012 Investor Presentation
Neenah Paper Feb 2012 Investor Presentation
 
Conclusive Proof that L&L International (LLEN) Does Not Own the Ping Yi Mine
Conclusive Proof that L&L International (LLEN) Does Not Own the Ping Yi MineConclusive Proof that L&L International (LLEN) Does Not Own the Ping Yi Mine
Conclusive Proof that L&L International (LLEN) Does Not Own the Ping Yi Mine
 
Cleantech Innovations (CTEK) files Injunctive Relief Against NASDAQ
Cleantech Innovations (CTEK) files Injunctive Relief Against NASDAQCleantech Innovations (CTEK) files Injunctive Relief Against NASDAQ
Cleantech Innovations (CTEK) files Injunctive Relief Against NASDAQ
 
Appendix IV - Zhongpin Sub Breakdown
Appendix IV - Zhongpin Sub BreakdownAppendix IV - Zhongpin Sub Breakdown
Appendix IV - Zhongpin Sub Breakdown
 
Share Transfer from Ming Zhao to Citic Trust (July, 2010)
Share Transfer from Ming Zhao to Citic Trust (July, 2010)Share Transfer from Ming Zhao to Citic Trust (July, 2010)
Share Transfer from Ming Zhao to Citic Trust (July, 2010)
 
Share Pledge from Putai Mining to Citic Trust (Jan, 2011)
Share Pledge from Putai Mining to Citic Trust (Jan, 2011)Share Pledge from Putai Mining to Citic Trust (Jan, 2011)
Share Pledge from Putai Mining to Citic Trust (Jan, 2011)
 
Share Transfer from Putai to Ming Zhao (September 2009)
Share Transfer from Putai to Ming Zhao (September 2009)Share Transfer from Putai to Ming Zhao (September 2009)
Share Transfer from Putai to Ming Zhao (September 2009)
 
3 25-2011 GeoInvesting Rebuttal to CGPI Letter to Shareholders
3 25-2011 GeoInvesting Rebuttal to CGPI Letter to Shareholders3 25-2011 GeoInvesting Rebuttal to CGPI Letter to Shareholders
3 25-2011 GeoInvesting Rebuttal to CGPI Letter to Shareholders
 

Recently uploaded

The resilient U.S. late-cycle expansion contributed to a stalling pattern in ...
The resilient U.S. late-cycle expansion contributed to a stalling pattern in ...The resilient U.S. late-cycle expansion contributed to a stalling pattern in ...
The resilient U.S. late-cycle expansion contributed to a stalling pattern in ...Kumaran637735
 
slideshare_2404_presentation materials_en.pdf
slideshare_2404_presentation materials_en.pdfslideshare_2404_presentation materials_en.pdf
slideshare_2404_presentation materials_en.pdfsansanir
 
Basic Accountants in|TaxlinkConcept.pdf
Basic  Accountants in|TaxlinkConcept.pdfBasic  Accountants in|TaxlinkConcept.pdf
Basic Accountants in|TaxlinkConcept.pdftaxlinkcpa
 
Methanex Investor Presentation (April 2024)
Methanex Investor Presentation (April 2024)Methanex Investor Presentation (April 2024)
Methanex Investor Presentation (April 2024)Methanex Corporation
 
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024CollectiveMining1
 
如何办理伦敦大学毕业证(文凭)London学位证书
如何办理伦敦大学毕业证(文凭)London学位证书如何办理伦敦大学毕业证(文凭)London学位证书
如何办理伦敦大学毕业证(文凭)London学位证书Fis s
 
Osisko Gold Royalties Ltd - Corporate Presentation, April 23, 2024
Osisko Gold Royalties Ltd - Corporate Presentation, April 23, 2024Osisko Gold Royalties Ltd - Corporate Presentation, April 23, 2024
Osisko Gold Royalties Ltd - Corporate Presentation, April 23, 2024Osisko Gold Royalties Ltd
 
No 1 AMil Baba In Islamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Lahore No 1 Amil Baba In Faisl...
No 1 AMil Baba In Islamabad  No 1 Amil Baba In Lahore No 1 Amil Baba In Faisl...No 1 AMil Baba In Islamabad  No 1 Amil Baba In Lahore No 1 Amil Baba In Faisl...
No 1 AMil Baba In Islamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Lahore No 1 Amil Baba In Faisl...First NO1 World Amil baba in Faisalabad
 
定制(UWIC毕业证书)英国卡迪夫城市大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
定制(UWIC毕业证书)英国卡迪夫城市大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一定制(UWIC毕业证书)英国卡迪夫城市大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
定制(UWIC毕业证书)英国卡迪夫城市大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一Fir La
 
如何办理(UTS毕业证书)悉尼科技大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(UTS毕业证书)悉尼科技大学毕业证学位证书如何办理(UTS毕业证书)悉尼科技大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(UTS毕业证书)悉尼科技大学毕业证学位证书Fis s
 
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024CollectiveMining1
 
如何办理北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证(文凭)UNC学位证书
如何办理北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证(文凭)UNC学位证书如何办理北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证(文凭)UNC学位证书
如何办理北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证(文凭)UNC学位证书Fir La
 

Recently uploaded (20)

The resilient U.S. late-cycle expansion contributed to a stalling pattern in ...
The resilient U.S. late-cycle expansion contributed to a stalling pattern in ...The resilient U.S. late-cycle expansion contributed to a stalling pattern in ...
The resilient U.S. late-cycle expansion contributed to a stalling pattern in ...
 
slideshare_2404_presentation materials_en.pdf
slideshare_2404_presentation materials_en.pdfslideshare_2404_presentation materials_en.pdf
slideshare_2404_presentation materials_en.pdf
 
Model Call Girl in Uttam Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Uttam Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Uttam Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Uttam Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
young call girls in Govindpuri 🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Service
young call girls in Govindpuri 🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Serviceyoung call girls in Govindpuri 🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Service
young call girls in Govindpuri 🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Service
 
Escort Service Call Girls In Shalimar Bagh, 99530°56974 Delhi NCR
Escort Service Call Girls In Shalimar Bagh, 99530°56974 Delhi NCREscort Service Call Girls In Shalimar Bagh, 99530°56974 Delhi NCR
Escort Service Call Girls In Shalimar Bagh, 99530°56974 Delhi NCR
 
Basic Accountants in|TaxlinkConcept.pdf
Basic  Accountants in|TaxlinkConcept.pdfBasic  Accountants in|TaxlinkConcept.pdf
Basic Accountants in|TaxlinkConcept.pdf
 
Methanex Investor Presentation (April 2024)
Methanex Investor Presentation (April 2024)Methanex Investor Presentation (April 2024)
Methanex Investor Presentation (April 2024)
 
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024
 
young call girls in Yamuna Vihar 🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Service
young  call girls in   Yamuna Vihar 🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Serviceyoung  call girls in   Yamuna Vihar 🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Service
young call girls in Yamuna Vihar 🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Service
 
Model Call Girl in Udyog Vihar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Udyog Vihar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Udyog Vihar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Udyog Vihar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
young call girls in Hauz Khas,🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
young call girls in Hauz Khas,🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Serviceyoung call girls in Hauz Khas,🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
young call girls in Hauz Khas,🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
 
如何办理伦敦大学毕业证(文凭)London学位证书
如何办理伦敦大学毕业证(文凭)London学位证书如何办理伦敦大学毕业证(文凭)London学位证书
如何办理伦敦大学毕业证(文凭)London学位证书
 
Osisko Gold Royalties Ltd - Corporate Presentation, April 23, 2024
Osisko Gold Royalties Ltd - Corporate Presentation, April 23, 2024Osisko Gold Royalties Ltd - Corporate Presentation, April 23, 2024
Osisko Gold Royalties Ltd - Corporate Presentation, April 23, 2024
 
No 1 AMil Baba In Islamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Lahore No 1 Amil Baba In Faisl...
No 1 AMil Baba In Islamabad  No 1 Amil Baba In Lahore No 1 Amil Baba In Faisl...No 1 AMil Baba In Islamabad  No 1 Amil Baba In Lahore No 1 Amil Baba In Faisl...
No 1 AMil Baba In Islamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Lahore No 1 Amil Baba In Faisl...
 
定制(UWIC毕业证书)英国卡迪夫城市大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
定制(UWIC毕业证书)英国卡迪夫城市大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一定制(UWIC毕业证书)英国卡迪夫城市大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
定制(UWIC毕业证书)英国卡迪夫城市大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
 
如何办理(UTS毕业证书)悉尼科技大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(UTS毕业证书)悉尼科技大学毕业证学位证书如何办理(UTS毕业证书)悉尼科技大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(UTS毕业证书)悉尼科技大学毕业证学位证书
 
Call Girls in South Ex⎝⎝9953056974⎝⎝ Escort Delhi NCR
Call Girls in South Ex⎝⎝9953056974⎝⎝ Escort Delhi NCRCall Girls in South Ex⎝⎝9953056974⎝⎝ Escort Delhi NCR
Call Girls in South Ex⎝⎝9953056974⎝⎝ Escort Delhi NCR
 
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - April 2024
 
young Call girls in Dwarka sector 1🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Service
young Call girls in Dwarka sector 1🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Serviceyoung Call girls in Dwarka sector 1🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Service
young Call girls in Dwarka sector 1🔝 9953056974 🔝 Delhi escort Service
 
如何办理北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证(文凭)UNC学位证书
如何办理北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证(文凭)UNC学位证书如何办理北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证(文凭)UNC学位证书
如何办理北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证(文凭)UNC学位证书
 

Appendix II - Zhongpin. Deceptive Actions by WOFE

  • 1. APPENDIX II - Deceptive Action taken by the WOFE regarding Filing of its SAIC Documents In evaluating HOGS’ SAIC filings, GeoInvesting took the most comprehensive approach possible, evaluating the financials of both the individual subsidiaries as well as of the parent company (“WOFE”). Specifically, we obtained SAIC data for 11 of 14 of Zhongpin’s 2009 subsidiaries and 11 of 13 of the company’s 2008 subsidiaries. Several, including the biggest subsidiary, were audited. Please see Appendix IV for why we are completely confident that the subsidiaries we don’t have information for are immaterial to our discussion. The ownership structure of HOGS is similar to that of many US listed Chinese companies. There is a parent company (“WOFE”) which has no substantial business operations. Instead, the WOFE is the legal entity that aids in capital raising activities and may be entitled to receive cash flows such as dividends from its subsidiaries. The 2010 Form 10-K explains this in detail. (WOFE explained) “As a result of such agreements, HZFC (WOFE), which is a wholly owned indirect subsidiary of our company, is entitled to 100% of any cash dividends declared and paid by Henan Zhongpin and to vote all outstanding shares of capital stock of Henan Zhongpin in any action by the shareholders of Henan Zhongpin. On May 20, 2005, Henan Zhongpin Food Co., Ltd. (“HZFC”) was established in China for the sole purpose of holding the capital stock of [the operating company] Henan Zhongpin and its subsidiaries. The owners of Henan Zhongpin formed HZFC with an initial investment of 16,000,000 Renminbi (“RMB”) ($1,932,367).” In China, the annual inspections are performed by various PRC government agencies (SAIC, SAT, SAFE, Customs and others). Those agencies require the financial statements of the WOFE to complete their inspections. The WOFE is therefore required to file its own audited financial statements with the SAIC. In the case of HOGS, its WOFE submitted only consolidated financial statements and not its own, making it impossible for the agencies to complete their inspections. Furthermore, as we stated, HOGS’ SEC documents clearly state that the WOFE only exists to receive cash flows, such as potential dividends, from its subsidiaries so it has no meaningful operations. Thus, the WOFE’s true financial statements (which should not be consolidated) should not reflect meaningful revenues or net income. However, we cannot find the WOFE’s financial statement, but only a consolidated financial statement. Furthermore, the WOFE claimed the financial data of the consolidated financial statement (total assets, total liability, revenue and net income) as its own data in the SAIC report. Apparently, this is wrong and unacceptable. We understand that it would be much more convenient to amend/compromise one filing (the parent/WOFE) than to coordinate the amendment of many (13 or 14 in HOGS’ case)
  • 2. subsidiaries. What is particularly noteworthy with HOGS’ SAIC filings is that while the consolidated net incomes of the company’s operating subsidiaries do not come close to matching the SEC filings, the financial statements of the WOFE do in fact match what was filed with the SEC. So, it seems the consolidated net income reported by the WOFE is dramatically greater than the sum of its operating subsidiaries. That is simply not possible and makes little accounting sense since consolidation would result in less cumulative net income, not more. That’s because related party balances are eliminated in consolidation which reduces consolidated net income. Furthermore, the WOFE, as clearly stated in SEC filings, has no meaningful operations. It basically exists to receives cash flows, such as potential dividends, from its subsidiaries. Where then, are the true financial statements of your WOFE? Given this odd set of circumstances we can only conclude that HOGS’ management amended (i.e., falsified) the filings of its WOFE apparently for no other purpose but to ensure the financial statements reported to the SAIC were consistent with what was filed with the SEC.