• Like
  • Save
Open Access: extending access to the research literature
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×
 

Open Access: extending access to the research literature

on

  • 694 views

Presentation given at the UHMLG Spring Forum 2014 in London on 28th Feb 2014

Presentation given at the UHMLG Spring Forum 2014 in London on 28th Feb 2014

See http://www.swets.com/events/uhmlg-spring-forum-2014

Statistics

Views

Total Views
694
Views on SlideShare
620
Embed Views
74

Actions

Likes
1
Downloads
6
Comments
1

1 Embed 74

https://twitter.com 74

Accessibility

Categories

Upload Details

Uploaded via as Adobe PDF

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel

11 of 1

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Processing…
Post Comment
Edit your comment

    Open Access: extending access to the research literature Open Access: extending access to the research literature Presentation Transcript

    • om nc %u or d% oo %g on m es c om e :%c v s ec. rsp ac ic#Pe n% em pe cad O #A An ?% er ng da n% o m y### rr #Cu um# en or h tep ess#F r#S Acc 14 so es pen# b#20 of #O Fe Pr LG h# HM U t 28
    • Who#am#I? occamstypewriter.org/scurry/ “the#world’s#most#generousMminded# and#amiable#OA#advocate”# Richard#Poynder,#Dec#2013
    • Academic#Journals#were#a#great#idea…
    • …but#the#web#changes#everything !4
    • Anarchy#Policy#in#the#UK#M#2012 Rt%Hon%David%Wille@s%MP:% The#“funding#model#is#surely#going#to#have#to# change#even#beyond#the#welcome#transi.on#to# open#access#and#hybrid#journals#that’s#already# underway.#To%try%to%preserve%the%old%model%is%the% wrong%ba@le%to%fight.” Dame%Janet%Finch:% “The#principle#that#the#results#of#research#that#has# been#publicly%funded#should#be#freely#accessible#in# the#public#domain#is#a#compelling#one,#and# fundamentally%unanswerable.”
    • What#is#Open#Access? Budapest%DeclaraFon,%2002%% “free#availability#on#the#public#internet,#permiYng#any#users#to#read,#download,# copy,#distribute,#print,#search,#or#link#to#the#full#texts#of#these#ar.cles,#crawl#them# for#indexing,#pass#them#as#data#to#soware…” GraFs%OA:%% Free#online#access# ! ! Libre%OA:%# Free#online#access#with#some#addi.onal# usage#rights#(e.g.#reproduc.on,#text# mining#—#licenseMdependent)$ Gold%OA:%% Immediate#availability#via#the#journal#(OA#or#'hybrid')# May#require#an#ar.cle#processing#charge#(APC)# ! Green%OA:%# Available#via#a#repository#(ins.tu.on#or#subjectMbased)# Author's#peerMreviewed#version#(or#preMprint)# May#require#a#delay#(embargo#period) h]p://www.opensocietyfounda.ons.org/openaccess/
    • Open#Access#is:# ‣ ‣ a#natural#consequence#of#the#internet# good#for#research# faster#exchange#of#ideas# fosters#interMdisciplinarity# enables#text#mining# stronger#sense#of#community#ownership# ‣ good#for#the#taxpayer# be]er#cost#control#(eventually)# access#to#the#research#they#paid#for# changes#dynamic#of#public#engagement# ‣ affec.ng#&#affected#by#many#aspects#of#academic#life… Open#Access#is#not:# ‣ ‣ ‣ free#(or#the#same#as#‘fileMsharing’)# the#end#of#peer#review#or#synonymous#with#low#quality# easy
    • The#rela.onship#of#academics#with#Open#Access
    • Why#are#we#not#there#yet? Funder#&#Govt#Policies# ‣ Too#meek#(preM2012).#Policy#but#li]le#enforcement# ‣ Confusion?#GoldFinch#but#not#GreenFinch?# ‣ New$(revised)#RCUK#policy#(April#1st,#2013):# ‣ Prefers#gold#(and#CCMBY)#but#permits#green# ‣ Embargoes#extended#for#5Myear#transi.on#(6,#12,#24#mo)# Block#grant#funding## 5#yr#rollMout#to#include#review#&#flexibility:#a#‘journey'# ‣ ‣ ‣ HEFCE#&#REF#2020 h]p://blogs.rcuk.ac.uk/2012/09/28/rcukMopenMaccessMpolicyMwhenMtoMgoMgreenMandMwhenMtoMgoMgold/
    • House#of#Lords#Select#Commi]ee#Report#(Feb#2013) h]p://www.parliament.uk/business/commi]ees/commi]eesMaMz/lordsMselect/scienceMandMtechnologyMcommi]ee/news/openMaccessMreportMpublished/
    • House#of#Commons#Select#Commi]ee#Report#(Sept#2013) Ques.ons#about# hybrid#OA h]p://www.parliament.uk/business/commi]ees/commi]eesMaMz/commonsMselect/businessMinnova.onMandMskills/news/onMpublMopenMaccess/
    • Why#are#we#not#there#yet? Opposi.on#of#some#publishers# ‣ worried#about#‘sustainability’#(aka#profits*)# ‣ Elsevier:#36%#(£724m/£2,000m)# ‣ Springer:#34%#(£294m/£866m)# ‣ John#Wiley#&#Sons:#42%#($106m/$253m)# ‣ Informa#plc:#32%#(£47m/£145m)# ‣ NB:#Hindawi:#52%**#($3.3m/$6.3m)# ‣ Are#these#reasonable#given#the#input#from#researchers?# ‣ Hybrid#OA#is#expensive#&#problema.c:## ‣ publishers#need#to#show#clearly#there’s#no#doubleMdipping# ‣ avoid#unless#there#is#a#pathway#to#flipping#journal#to#OA *Figures#for#2010.#Source#—#h]p://poe.ceconomics.blogspot.co.uk/2012/01/enormousMprofitsMofMstmMscholarly.html# **h]p://scholarlyoa.com/2013/04/04/hindawisMprofitsMareMlargerMthanMelseviers/
    • Why#are#we#not#there#yet? We’re#s.ll#working#this#stuff#out# ‣ OA#journals#work:#e.g.$PLOS,#BMC# ‣ Innova.on:## ‣ eLife# ‣ PeerJ# ‣ Fron.ers# ‣ Need#a#shakeMup#to#allow#market#penetra.on#by# new#.tles#(see#later) 13
    • Why#are#we#not#there#yet? We’re#s.ll#working#this#stuff#out# ‣ The#Open#Access#Bu]on# h]ps://www.openaccessbu]on.org
    • Why#are#we#not#there#yet? Researchers#are#illMinformed#and#conserva.ve# ‣ too#few#aware#of:# ‣ subscrip.on#costs## ‣ how#OA#works# ‣ benefits#of#OA# ‣ (Librarians#can#help#here!) ‣ confusion#in#universi.es#about#their#public#du.es?# ‣ undermined#by#student#fee#increases?## ‣ obliga.ons#to#taxpayers# ‣ how#are#these#balanced#against#academic#freedom? 15
    • Why#are#we#not#there#yet? Concerns#of#learned#socie.es# ‣ loss#of#valuable#income? h]p://openMaccess.org.uk/informa.onMandMguidance/guideMtoMgoldoa/ Stuart#Shieber h]p://blogs.law.harvard.edu/pamphlet/2013/01/29/whyMopenMaccessMisMbe]erMforMscholarlyMsocie.es/ 16
    • Why#are#we#not#there#yet? Researchers#fear#damage#to#established#models# ‣ varia.on#between#humani.es#and#sciences## ‣ different#rela.onships#with#their#published#work# ‣ varia.on#between#the#sciences# ‣ Physics#arΧiv#vs#bioRΧiv# ‣ suspicious#of#the#web# ‣ addicted#to#impact#factors# Image:%h]p://associate.com/photos/BibleMPicturesMM1897MWMAMFoster/pageM0069M1.jpg 17
    • To#realise#the#vision#of#OA,#we#need#to#replace#the#apparatus#of#the#Impact#factor# occamstypewriter.org/scurry "affirms$the$principle$that$it$is$the$intrinsic$ merit$of$the$work,$and$not$the$:tle$of$the$ journal$in$which$an$author’s$work$is$ published,$that$should$be$considered$in$ making$funding$decisions." "when$assessing$proposals$for$research$ funding$RCUK$considers$that$it$is$the$ quality$of$the$research$proposed$and$not$ where$an$author$has$published…$that$is$of$ paramount$importance." April$8,$2013 18
    • To#realise#the#vision#of#OA,#we#need#to#replace#the#apparatus#of#the#Impact#factor# l$23,#3285–3289. Vale,#R.#D.#(2012)#Mol$Biol$Cel Lawrence,#P.#A.# (2007)#Curr.$Bio l.#17,# R583–5. Samuel#Reich,#E.#(2013)#Nature#502,#291M3.
    • The inexorable rise of Open Access UK: 35% Green OA UK: 5% Gold OA World: 17% Gold OA onl e n nli O (A y line o On C) P APC) o ly (n n OA online Print sub/
    • Remaining#Challenges ‣ GeVng%the%message%out%to#academics## ‣ Agreement#on#the#principles#of#OA# ‣ ‣ OA#mechanisms#that#work#for#all%fields# APC#payment#mechanisms#that#are#fair%and%visible%to%researchers% ‣ Remove#support#for#hybrid%OA?% ‣ Disavowal#of#Impact#Factors% ‣ Compliance%enforcement%from#funders#and#ins.tu.ons# ‣ Market%innovaFons%(from#new#&#est.#publishers)#—#level#playing#field# ‣ Established#publishers#need#to#earn%back%trust%—#transparency#&#generosity% ‣ Dura.on#&#cost#of#transi.on?#(When#will#subs%money#be#released?)# ‣ InternaFonal%cooperaFon%on#OA#policy
    • "It's#the#end#of#the#world#as#we#know#it#(And#I#feel#fine)”# Michael#S.pe,#REM ? s n o s. e u Q