Igniting Sacramento1008 Presentation Small - Presentation Transcript
Igniting and Inviting Student
Motivation and High Performance
Dr. Bobb Darnell
bobbdarnell@mac.com
Other titles
Trying to Get Students to Achieve Every
Standard on the Planet While Trying to
Stay Happy and Well
No Child Left in the Middle, On the
Side, or Behind
No Teacher Left Behind
Today you will . . .
1. Be familiar with changes to our learners and
educational context.
2. Be familiar with successful instructional practices
and teaching/learning strategies.
3. Know additional ways to intervene when student
demonstrate low performance and or require
accommodations for learning disabilities/
differences.
You might be an experienced
educator if . . .
You want to slap the next person who says,
“Must be nice to have all your holidays and
summers free.”
Out in public you feel the urge to talk to
strange children and correct their behavior.
You encourage obnoxious parents to check
into other schools or home schooling.
You might be an experienced
educator if . . .
You had a hard time choosing your
child’s name because there is NO name
you could give a child that wouldn’t
bring on high blood pressure the
moment you heard it.
Around Spring, your staff vote on
having a Prozac dispenser in the
lounge.
Goals, Activities, Homework
Learning Goals
1. Be familiar with changes to our learners and educational context.
2. Be familiar with successful instructional practices and teaching/learning
strategies.
3. Know additional ways to intervened when student demonstrate low
performance and or require accommodations for learning
disabilities/differences.
Activities
Exploring changes to our learners and educational context
A Motivational Model
Demonstration and application of powerful teaching/learning strategies
Homework
Apply at least one idea, strategy, or technique and contact the presenter to let
him/her know if it worked.
Tell one colleague or other educator about your success or seek help with
challenging problems.
We are going to use two
resources today.
The handout
Your new 12 page brochure
Factors Involved in Desire (Motivation)
and High Performance
Safety
Success (This is the most essential
element related to motivation/desire.)
Valued Purpose
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems,
Evergreen, CO (1997)
Factors Involved in Desire (Motivation)
and High Performance
Safety (2)
Success (This is the most essential (1)
element related to motivation/desire.)
Valued Purpose
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems,
Evergreen, CO (1997)
Why do students fail to
succeed the first time?
1. Lack of skills
2. Lack of confidence
3. Lack of motivation
4. Lack of perseverance/determination
5. Lack of respect for the culture of school/education
6. Lack of vision for the role school plays in career
preparation or lifestyle
7. Lack of connection to positive relationships with teachers
and/or peers
(Data collected by interviewing over 210 students with multiple Fs.)
Some students choose
defiance and resistance.
Defiance is often a response to too much
anxiety.
Defiance is one of two responses to an
overwhelmed limbic system--flight or fight.
Defiance is often a result of the student
feeling out of control.
Defiance is a often a result of the student
trying to cover up feelings of impotence
and/or incompetence.
Defiance is a predicted response to anxiety overload.
Some students choose
defiance and resistance.
Defiance is often a response to too much
anxiety.
Defiance is one of two responses to an
overwhelmed limbic system--flight or fight.
Defiance is often a result of the student
feeling out of control.
Defiance is a often a result of the student
trying to cover up feelings of impotence
and/or incompetence.
Power Thinking Cartoon
Marzano,
Tactics in
Thinking, 1989
It seems like everything has
changed.
1. The students have changed.
2. Expectations have changed.
3. The science of teaching and learning and
professional development have changed.
It seems like everything has
changed.
1. The students have changed.
2. Expectations have changed.
3. The science of teaching and learning and
professional development have changed.
The students have changed.
1. Immediate Gratification
Video games (They know how they are
doing right away.)
Cooking (Microwave on high for one
minute------voila, dinner)
Instant messaging
Text message and voice mail
The students have changed.
2. Shorter Attention Span and Visually Preferred
Here’s one impact.
The students have changed.
3. Hands-On Multi-Taskers
Cell phones MP3 players
Wide screen LCD and Simulation video games
plasma TVs Extraordinary electronic
Cable and satellite TV visual graphics
with hundreds of Voice mail
channels Email
Hand held video games Instant messaging
PDAs DVDs and CDs
Laptop and desktop Movies on demand
computers
Voice activated devices
Digital still and video
cameras and more . . .
The students have changed.
4. Focused On Objectives, Big Picture,
Strategies, Practice, and Do Overs
The “NEW Millennial”
Instructional Lesson Format
Focus
and
Warm-up
5-15%
Direct Teaching 1. Students
15-25%
want to know
the objectives
Student Performance and understand
35-45%
the big picture.
2. Students want
hands-on learning
Review
and want to change 15-25%
activities after 12 to 3. Students want
20 minutes. Closure
to know how
5-15%
they are doing
and they want
success.
Learning Goals
1. Be familiar with changes to our learners and educational
context.
2. Be familiar with successful instructional practices and
teaching/learning strategies.
3. Know additional ways to intervened when student demonstrate
low performance and or require accommodations for learning
disabilities/differences.
Activities
Exploring changes to our learners and educational context
A Motivational Model
Demonstration and application of powerful teaching/learning
strategies
Homework
Apply at least one idea, strategy, or technique and contact the
presenter to let him/her know if it worked.
Tell one colleague or other educator about your success or seek
help with challenging problems.
Which scenario would YOU choose if
you went to graduate school?
2
1
•Resource list
•Resource list •Schedule of classes
•Schedule of •List of course units
•Teaches
classes
And
•List of course •List of objectives for each unit
units •Provides essential topics and concepts for
each unit
•Teacher teaches
•Informs you about the types of assessments
and then tests and the emphasis on each topic
•Provides strategies for succeeding in the class
1. Objectives and Standards
Student achievement increases when the
learning expectations/goals are aligned with
state standard and identified for each unit and
lesson.
Student achievement increases when
teachers clearly identify the learning goals
and agenda in writing and orally before the
lesson begins and during the lesson’s
closure (Marzano, 2001).
Categories of Instructional Strategies That
Affect Student Achievement
Category Percentile
Gain
Identifying Similarities and Differences 45
Summarizing and note taking 34
Reinforcing effort and providing recognition 29
Homework and practice 28
Non-linguistic representations 27
Cooperative Learning 27
Setting objectives and feedback 23
Generating and testing hypotheses 23
Question, cues, and advanced organizers 22
Marzano, Pickering, Pollack. Classroom Instruction that Works. ASCD, 2001
General Biology Curriculum Map
Science Mendelian Circulation Respiration
Ecology and Molecular
Skills and Cells Genetics and Digestion and Systems 2 Kingdoms
Evolution Genetics
Basics Immunity Excretion
Concepts/
Topics
•Scientific
Method
Biology Sample Map
Concepts/
Topics
•Ecosystems
(12a, 12b)
•Energy
Concepts/
Topics
•Microscope
Concepts/
•DNA
Topics
Structure and
Concepts/
Topics
•Meiosis
(12a)
Concepts/
Topics
•Anatomy
•Physiology
Concepts/
Topics
•Anatomy
(12a)
Concepts/
Topics
•Anatomy
(12a)
Concepts/
Topics
•Anatomy and
Physiology of:
Concepts/
Topics
•Monera
•Protista
(11a) Relationships •Cell parts and Replication •Monohybrid •Cell Transport •Physiology •Physiology (12a) •Fungi
•Measurement (12b) function (12a) Crosses •Bacterial •Cell Transport •Cell Transport Skeletal •Plant
(11a) •Photo- (12a) • Mitosis (12a) Growth (11a) •Urinalysis Muscular •Animal
•Organic synthesis •Cell Transport (12a) •Pedigree •Viral Growth •Enzymes (11a) Nervous
Molecules (12b, 12c) (11a)(12c) •Protein Charts •Immune (12c) •Cellular Reproductive
•Population •Single-celled Synthesis (12a) response •Lock and Key Respiration •Cell Transport
•Classification (12b) Organisms (12a) •Incomplete (12b) •Structure (12c) •STDs
•Natural •Biotechnology Dominance •HIV/AIDS determines •Contraceptive
Selection (12a)(13b) (12a) •Structure function
(12a) •Structure •Sex Linkage determines
determines (12a) function
function •Karyotyping
Skills Skills Skills Skills Skills Skills Skills Skills Skills Skills
•Hypothesis •Making Study •Microscope •Constructing •Solve Problems •Use Diagrams •Plan Diet •Use Diagrams •Use diagrams •Use Examples
(11a) Tools skills Models •Organize •Organize •Compare and •Compare and
•Measurement •Reading •Using Diagrams (12a) Events •Compare and diagrams • Interpret Contrast Contrast
(11a) Diagrams •Creating •Prediction •Prediction Contrast • Use examples Data •Logging (12a)
•Organizing •Making Graphics (11a) (11a) •Sterile (11a) (11a) Information •Research
and Recording Diagrams •Prediction •Analyzing Data •Karyotypes Technique •Using •Using •Powerpoint Information
Data •Prediction (11a)(12a) (11a) •Analyze Data (11a) Indicators Indicators •Presentation •Identification
(11a) (11a) •Conpare and •Construct (11a) • Write (11a) (11a) skills Skills
•Using and •Analyzing Data Contrast Proteins •Draw Procedures •Organize Data •Analyze Data •Research Skills •Using a
Making a (11a)(13a) •Following Lab (12a) Conclusion (11a) (11a) (11a) Dichotomous Key
Dicotomous •Graphing instructions •Organizing (11a) •Draw •Analyze Data •Draw
Key (11a) (11a) Process •Compute Conclusions (11a) Conclusions
•Reading •Reading (12a) probabilities (11a)(13a) •Reading (11a)(13a)
•Reading Strategies Strategies •Basic Strategies •Reading
Strategies biotechnology Strategies
skills
•Writing Lab •Draw
Conclusions Conclusions
(11a)(13a) (11a)(13a)
How does your school/district
review and revise curriculum?
12.A.4a Explain how genetic
combinations produce visible
effects and variations among
physical features and cellular
functions of organisms.
12.A.4b Describe the structures
and organization of cells and
tissues that underlie basic life
functions including nutrition,
respiration, cellular transport,
biosynthesis and reproduction.
Putting the
puzzle
together is
easier when
you have the
picture on the
box before,
during, and
after learning
new content.
Maintaining Wellness
Sample
Psychological/
Habits/Things
Nutrition Exercise Physical
to Avoid
Conditions
aerobics hypertension
vitamins anaerobic high cholesterol excessive eating
minerals running diabetes stress
calories pulse obesity poor diet choices
fats smoking
cycling stress
proteins excessive drinking
games eustress
carbohydrates
Outcomes
Students will . . .
1. create a healthy diet.
2. create an exercise program which adapts to different physical and psychological needs.
3. evaluate a lifestyle to determine the degree to which the individual will remain healthy.
4. create a multimedia presentation which teaches about a significant component of
wellness.
The “NEW Millennial”
Instructional Lesson Format
Focus
and
Warm-up
5-15%
Direct Teaching 1. Students
15-25%
want to know
the objectives
Student Performance and understand
35-45%
the big picture.
Review
15-25%
Closure
5-15%
Learning Goals
1. Describe the environment of dinosaurs.
2. Describe what dinosaurs ate.
3. Compare two dinosaurs.
Activities
Brainstorm what you know about dinosaurs.
Look at pictures of where dinosaurs lived.
Compare T Rex and Brontosaurus dinosaurs.
Homework
Draw a picture of a dinosaur in his/her environment
Create a chart showing the similarities and differences between T Rex and
Brontosaurus dinosaurs.
Dinosaurs’ Environment T Rex Brontosaurus
•plants •size •size
•other animals •skeleton •skeleton
•trees •teeth •teeth
•mountains •movement •movement
•plains
How many of you . . .
State the learning goals (not activities) at the
beginning of the class session?
Write the learning goals on the board and refer to
them at the beginning of the class session?
Connect the learning goals to the learning
activities?
Refer to the learning goals at the end of the class
session, and help student determine their
progress and/or need for assistance?
Learning Goals
1. Describe the environment of dinosaurs.
2. Describe what dinosaurs ate.
3. Compare two dinosaurs.
Activities
Brainstorm what you know about dinosaurs.
Look at pictures of where dinosaurs lived.
Compare T Rex and Brontosaurus dinosaurs.
Homework
Draw a picture of a dinosaur in his/her environment
Create a chart showing the similarities and differences between T Rex and
Brontosaurus dinosaurs.
Dinosaurs’ Environment T Rex Brontosaurus
•plants •size •size
•other animals •skeleton •skeleton
•trees •teeth •teeth
•mountains •movement •movement
•plains
Factors Involved in Desire (Motivation)
and High Performance
Safety
Success (This is the most essential
element related to motivation/desire.)
Valued Purpose
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems,
Evergreen, CO (1997)
Unit
Objectives
(Know and
be able to
do)
Unit Performance Objectives
1. Define and use unit vocabulary.
2. Recognize the phases of meiosis and illustrate them in a graphic
organizer.
3. Compare & contrast meiosis (males and females) and mitosis.
4. Construct punnett squares for monohybrid and dihybrid crosses.
5. Predict the probability of passing a trait to the next generation.
6. Create and interpret pedigree charts.
7. Determine an individual’s gender from a karyotype
8. Diagnose a genetic disease.
9. Simulate the process of inheritance.
10. Take on the role of a genetic counselor and create document to
educate your clients about their genetic risk.
The Research about Setting
Objectives
Stating objectives verbally and in public
written form.
When students know what they are
learning, their performance, on average,
has been shown to be 27 percentile
points higher than students who do not
know what they are doing.
Why post and state
objectives?
1. Many students with 3. Addresses the learning
learning disabilities have needs of students who
limited auditory memory, are “visually preferred
provide stimulus to 4. Addresses the learning
maintain attention and needs of ELL students
self-monitoring. 5. Motivates students to
2. Addresses the learning learn by providing a
needs of students with focus
limited visual memory
Why post and state
objectives?
6. Motivates students by 9. Increases students
making them feel safe chances for success
7. Addresses the trust 10. Increases achievement
issues of some learners and is strongly supported
8 Increases student by research
involvement and 11. Improves assessment of
responsibility for student learning
learning. 12. Easy to create and use
Key to Successful Learning
The targets for learning need to be
stated in student-friendly
language/objectives with clear
indicators for success.
Factors Involved in Desire (Motivation)
and High Performance
Safety
Success (This is the most essential
element related to motivation/desire.)
Valued Purpose
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems,
Evergreen, CO (1997)
Categories of Instructional Strategies That
Affect Student Achievement
Category Percentile
Gain
Identifying Similarities and Differences 45
Summarizing and note taking 34
Reinforcing effort and providing recognition 29
Homework and practice 28
Non-linguistic representations 27
Cooperative Learning 27
Setting objectives and feedback 23
Generating and testing hypotheses 23
Question, cues, and advanced organizers 22
Marzano, Pickering, Pollack. Classroom Instruction that Works. ASCD, 2001
The “NEW Millennial”
Instructional Lesson Format
Focus
and
Warm-up
5-15%
Direct Teaching 1. Students
15-25%
want to know
the objectives
Student Performance and understand
35-45%
the big picture.
Review
15-25%
Closure
5-15%
Factors Involved in Desire (Motivation)
and High Performance
Safety
Success (This is the most essential
element related to motivation/desire.)
Valued Purpose
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems,
Evergreen, CO (1997)
Unit
vocabulary
Objectives
Apply what you have learned.
Page 1
•List the academic vocabulary that is
part of one of your first units of study.
•Try to group the vocabulary in
categories
Health-Related Skill-Related Personal Heart
Fitness Fitness Fitness
Evaluation
•Muscular •Agility •Total •Pulse/Heart
Strength •Balance Fitness Rate
•Flexibility •Coordination •Physical •Carotid
•Muscular •Power Fitness Artery
Endurance •Reaction •Goal •Radial
•Cardiovascular Time Setting Artery
Endurance •Speed •VO2 Max •Resting
•Body •Bioelectrical Heart Rate
Composition Impedance
•Composite
Unit
vocabulary
Objectives
Unit
vocabulary
Objectives
Unit
vocabulary
Objectives
Unit
vocabulary
Objectives
Apply what you have learned.
Page 2
•Create unit objectives for part of one of your units
of study.
•Start with a verb.
Objectives
1. Write a definition for magma and lava.
2. Compare and contrast intrusive and extrusive igneous
rocks.
3. Create a model showing how igneous rocks are formed.
4. Describe the similarities and differences between scoria
and obsidian.
5. Describe the similarities and differences between
concordant and discordant igneous rock bodies.
Unit
vocabulary
Objectives
Learning Goals
1. Describe the environment of dinosaurs.
2. Describe what dinosaurs ate.
3. Compare two dinosaurs.
Activities
Brainstorm what you know about dinosaurs.
Look at pictures of where dinosaurs lived.
Compare T Rex and Brontosaurus dinosaurs.
Homework
Draw a picture of a dinosaur in his/her environment
Create a chart showing the similarities and differences between T Rex and
Brontosaurus dinosaurs.
Dinosaurs’ Environment T Rex Brontosaurus
•plants •size •size
•other animals •skeleton •skeleton
•trees •teeth •teeth
•mountains •movement •movement
•plains
Factors Involved in Desire (Motivation)
and High Performance
Safety
Success (This is the most essential
element related to motivation/desire.)
Valued Purpose
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems,
Evergreen, CO (1997)
A hair raising century by Australian opener Graeme
Wood on Friday set England back on its heels in the third
test at the Melbourne Cricket Ground. Unfortunately,
living dangerously eventually cost the Australians the
match. Wood was caught out of his crease on the first
over after lunch. Within ten more overs, the Australians
were dismissed. Four were dismissed by dangerous
running between creases. Two were dismissed when the
English bowlers lifted the bails from the batsmen's
wickets. The three remaining batsmen were caught by
English fieldsmen. One was caught as he tried for a six.
When the innings were complete the Australians had
fallen short of the runs scored by the English.
What do you need to be able to
read/learn?
A hair raising century by Australian opener Graeme
Wood on Friday set England back on its heels in the third
test at the Melbourne Cricket Ground. Unfortunately,
living dangerously eventually cost the Australians the
match. Wood was caught out of his crease on the first
over after lunch. Within ten more overs, the Australians
were dismissed. Four were dismissed by dangerous
running between creases. Two were dismissed when the
English bowlers lifted the bails from the batsmen's
wickets. The three remaining batsmen were caught by
English fieldsmen. One was caught as he tried for a six.
When the innings were complete the Australians had
fallen short of the runs scored by the English.
5. Explicit Teaching of
Vocabulary
Student achievement increases when
students receive explicit vocabulary
instruction that is relevant to the content
material studied (Marzano, 2001).
Importance of Word Meaning
1. Concept vocabulary is the door to understanding,
memory storage, and information retrieval for your
students.
2. The inability to speak your discipline's language
hampers their content mastery and learning
success each day, semester, and academic year.
3. Vocabulary knowledge is essential for reading
comprehension. If students are not familiar with
the words they read, they will have difficulty
understanding text.
Unit
vocabulary
Think about pizza for the next 30
seconds.
What was your pizza like?
Tell your partner about your pizza
Diagram of a Concept.
You can improve your memory
if you use . . .
School is not a game, but . . .
How many of you
have ever played
Monopoly?
How many of you
have won?
How many of you
who haven’t won
(much or ever) still
want to play
Monopoly?
What if I was to
teach you a strategy
that helped you win?
Who wins in school?
What if I was to
teach you a strategy
that helped you win?
How would you feel
about . . .
me?
the game?
the next challenge?
yourself?
Reading/Thinking: You can’t play
school without these skills.
•Main Idea
•Significant Details
•Sequence of Events
•Comparison
•Cause and Effect
•Meaning of Words
•Generalizations/Conclusions
•Problem/Solution
•Author’s Voice/Purpose/Design
Vocabulary Development and
Concept Attainment
Lessons:
Students can increase their comprehension
and recall when they group information and
identify patterns.
Concept attainment and word meaning
depend on background information.
Pre-teaching vocabulary aids in the
development of concepts.
50% 83%
The Three-Column Format
Word Definition Memory Cue
Word Definition Memory Cue
crease The end point
before the goal
The Three-Column Format . . .
Helps students document words, definitions,
and memory cues in an organized way.
Provides an organized format for drill and
practice.
Gives credibility to saving foundation
knowledge.
Teaches and models effective notetaking.
Budding
Type of asexual reproduction in which
an outgrowth forms on the parent
organism and later separates, giving
rise to a new organism.
Budding
Type of asexual reproduction in which
an outgrowth forms on the parent
organism and later separates, giving
rise to a new organism.
The Three-Column Format
Re-coded
Word Definition Memory Cue
Word Definition Memory Cue
Concept of Definition
Strategy
Category Properties
What is it? What is it
like?
less than 25
climate cm. of
rainfall
no cloud
cover:
winds dry
rain land
forest desert
Comparisons heat radiates
into dry land
air at night
Mojave Gobi Sahara
Illustrations
What are some
examples?
Concept of Definition
Strategy
Category Properties
What is it? What is it
like?
Comparisons
Illustrations
What are some
examples?
See if you can remember
these items.
one -- bun six -- sticks
two -- shoe seven -- heaven
three -- tree eight -- gate
four -- door nine -- line
five -- hive ten -- hen
Can you remember?
one six
two seven
three eight
four nine
five ten
See if you can remember
these items.
one -- bun six -- sticks
two -- shoe seven -- heaven
three -- tree eight -- gate
four -- door nine -- line
five -- hive ten -- hen
Create a definition concept word in
your discipline.
Concept of Definition
Strategy
Category Properties
What is it? What is it
like?
less than 25
climate cm. of
rainfall
no cloud
cover:
winds dry
land
•
rain
forest desert
Comparisons heat radiates
into dry land
air at night
Mojave Gobi Sahara
Illustrations
What are some
examples?
Create a definition and a memory
cue for a word in your discipline.
The Three-Column Format
Word Definition Memory Cue
Word Definition Memory Cue
• Moving
• Colorful
• Bizarre
• Unusual
• Familiar
• Rhyming
• Auditory
•Emotional
•Physical
The Three-Column Format
Word Definition Memory Cue
Word Definition Memory Cue
crease The end point
before the goal
Here’s how to get students to
remember concept words and their
meanings.
1. Select and teach approximately 5-7 words
each day.
2. Students go home with their three column
format and study the words for
approximately 10-15 minutes.
3. Students pair up and test each other for 1-2
minutes each.
4. Ask the students to talk about their
progress and to share memory cues.
Rehearse/Practice in Six
Minutes or Less
Choral practice (entire class recites)
Paired testing
Jigsaw
Friendly competition
Games like . . .
Jeopardy Question Matrix with Pictures
Vocabulary Charades
$100,000 Pyramid
Draw Me Pictionary
Talk a Mile a Minute/The Old Password Game
Continue the process of teaching
effective memory strategies.
5. Students go home and review the
previous words and learn 5-7 new
words.
6. Students pair up and test each other
for 1-2 minutes each.
Give a vocabulary test to the
students to determine their mastery
of the unit’s concept words.
Provide the students with their scores
and ask them what worked and what
didn’t work.
Ask them to repeat the process for the
next two to three units.
Ask them to establish an improvement
goal and plan.
What will happen?
You can prove to students that strategy and
effort are better indicators for success than
intelligence. Everybody can be “smart” if they
use smart strategies.
You will accelerate concept mastery and
vocabulary development.
You will provide a feeling of self-efficacy (I
can do it attitude).
Factors Involved in Motivation
and High performance
Safety (Students feel safer when they know what to expect
and when they believe someone is honest with them and
wants them to be successful.)
Success (Students experience success when they apply
effective strategies and effort and it works.)
Valued Purpose (Students value getting better and being
successful.)
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems, Evergreen, CO (1997)
Neuropathways that help you
remember
1. Visual • Moving
• Colorful
2. Auditory • Bizarre
3. Kinesthetic • Unusual
• Familiar
4. Tactile/Sensory • Rhyming
5. Emotional • Loud or soft
• Funny or sad
Evidence of Student Failure
1. Lack of skills 1. Poor attendance in school
2. Lack of confidence 2. Lack of attention in classes
3. Lack of motivation 3. Failure to attempt and/or
complete in and out-of-class
4. Lack of perseverance/ Resulting assignments
determination in 4. Revengeful behavior and
5. Lack of respect for the chronic misconduct
culture of school/education 5. Failure to participate in
6. Lack of vision for the role available interventions
school plays in career 6. Resistance and Defiance
preparation or lifestyle 7. A cycle of failure
7. Lack of connection to
positive relationships with
teachers and/or peers
Power Thinking Cartoon
Marzano,
Tactics in
Thinking, 1989
Apply what you have learned.
Page 3
•Create a three-column form for two
vocabulary words in a unit/chapter of
study.
•Create a Concept of Definition
Diagram
Concept of Definition
Strategy
The Three-Column Format
Category Properties
Word Definition Memory Cue
What is it
Word Definition Memory Cue
What is it?
like?
less than 25
climate cm. of
rainfall
no cloud
cover:
winds dry
rain land
forest desert
Comparisons heat radiates
into dry land
air at night
Mojave Gobi Sahara
Illustrations
What are some
examples?
4. Background Information
Student achievement increases when ……
Teachers consistently activate prior knowledge and build
students’ background relevant to the new learning.
Research Results for Advanced Organizers, Cues, and
Questions
Up to a 29 percentile gain in achievement
An average 22 percentile gain in achievement
The brain remembers well when it connects/bridges
from old to new.
ASCD 2001 Classroom Instruction that Works (Marzano,
Pickering, and Pollack)
What do you need to be able to
read/learn?
A hair raising century by Australian opener Graeme
Wood on Friday set England back on its heels in the third
test at the Melbourne Cricket Ground. Unfortunately,
living dangerously eventually cost the Australians the
match. Wood was caught out of his crease on the first
over after lunch. Within ten more overs, the Australians
were dismissed. Four were dismissed by dangerous
running between creases. Two were dismissed when the
English bowlers lifted the bails from the batsmen's
wickets. The three remaining batsmen were caught by
English fieldsmen. One was caught as he tried for a six.
When the innings were complete the Australians had
fallen short of the runs scored by the English.
Schema Theory
Lesson:
You can increase comprehension if you
activate prior knowledge and build new
background knowledge.
Before Reading/New Learning
Activate and build background
information
Review and pre-teach vocabulary
Provide a motivational purpose for
reading
The “NEW Millennial”
Instructional Lesson Format
Focus
and
Warm-up
5-15% Building and
activating
Direct Teaching
15-25% background
information
Student Performance
before the
35-45% new lesson
begins
Review
15-25%
Closure
5-15%
Ways to Activate Prior Knowledge and Connect New
Brainstorm Use a defuzzing wheel and a question or word to
stimulate thinking.
Content Pre-Test Create true/false questions about new material.
Values Conflict Present a list of values about the new topic and ask
students to choose the values they agree with.
Vote Create an option for decision making and take a vote.
KWL Get students to brainstorm what they know about a topic
and what they would like to learn.
Herringbone Place the Herringbone graphic and ask students to create
Questioning questions (who, what, where, when, why, how)
View a Scene Ask students to view a still picture and describe what
they see.
Part of a story Read part of a story and ask students to describe the
setting, characters, or main goal/problem.
Defuzzing Wheel
Why is it difficult
for some people to
change?
Anticipation Guide:
Content Pre-test Example
True or False
1. There are 6 planets
2. The earth revolves around the sun.
3. Neptune is the planet with all of the
rings.
4. Earth is one of the biggest planets.
Values Conflict Example 1
Agree or Disagree
1. Ministers should be held to a higher
standard of morality than others.
2. In some cases, adultery is
acceptable.
3. People in a community should know
when someone has committed
adultery.
Values Conflict Example 2
Strongly Agree Agree Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. War is justified in certain circumstances.
2. A country should have a draft.
3. All citizens of a country should have to
serve the government for 2 years.
4. The citizens of a country have limited
power regarding starting and ending a
war.
Content Pre-test -- Math
Metrics (Likely--Unlikely)
1. The basketball player is 3 meters tall.
2. The bicycle was traveling 20 kilometers per hour.
3. He drank a liter of pop in one gulp.
4. The temperature dropped to 25 degrees Celcius
and it started to snow.
5. The pencil had a mass of 100 grams.
6. The area of a postage stamp is 20 square
centimeters
Herringbone
Ways to Activate Prior Knowledge and Connect New
Predict Use pictures, headings, and text to support predictions.
Skim Read captions, boldface headings, word charts, and
graphs to connect with the new materials.
Question Use pictures, chapter headings, graphs, to generate
meaningful questions.
Visualize Create mental pictures of words, concepts, and
predictions.
Role Play Imagine a scenario (e.g., problem, need for invention)
and play a role.
View a Movie View a portion of a movie and use it as an introduction
to new material.
Listen to a Song Listen to a song and use it as an introduction to new
material.
Journaling/Free Provide a journal prompt related to new material to
Writing access prior knowledge.
Drawing Provide a prompt and ask the students to draw from their
experience/knowledge
You are an astronaut, fireman,
salesperson, or nurse.
What do you think you have to
know and be able to do?
KWL
Know
Want to Know
Learned
Why is it important to have a
positive attitude?
How can disaster become positive?
Categories of Instructional Strategies That
Affect Student Achievement
Category Percentile
Gain
Identifying Similarities and Differences 45
Summarizing and note taking 34
Reinforcing effort and providing recognition 29
Homework and practice 28
Non-linguistic representations 27
Cooperative Learning 27
Setting objectives and feedback 23
Generating and testing hypotheses 23
Question, cues, and advanced organizers 22
Marzano, Pickering, Pollack. Classroom Instruction that Works. ASCD, 2001
Factors Involved in Motivation
and High performance
Safety (Students feel safer when they know what to expect and when
you relate new learning to things they already know.)
Success (Students experience success when they feel they know
something about the new learning.)
Valued Purpose (Students value learning they understand.)
Love and Belonging (Students are more engaged in learning when
they feel comfortable working with their peers.)
Fun and Enjoyment (Students are more engaged in learning when
they are having fun.)
Freedom and Independence (Students are more engaged in learning
when they have open-ended choices.)
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning
Systems, Evergreen, CO (1997)
Evidence of Student Failure
1. Lack of skills 1. Poor attendance in school
2. Lack of confidence 2. Lack of attention in classes
3. Lack of motivation 3. Failure to attempt and/or
complete in and out-of-class
4. Lack of perseverance/ Resulting assignments
determination in 4. Revengeful behavior and
5. Lack of respect for the chronic misconduct
culture of school/education 5. Failure to participate in
6. Lack of vision for the role available interventions
school plays in career 6. Resistance and Defiance
preparation or lifestyle 7. A cycle of failure
7. Lack of connection to
positive relationships with
teachers and/or peers
Power Thinking Cartoon
Marzano,
Tactics in
Thinking, 1989
Apply what you have learned.
Page 4
•Plan to activate/build background
information with one or more of the
following strategies:
--Anticipation Guide --Role play
--Values Conflict --Questions
--Movie/audio clip
--Pre-test
--Brainstorming (Defuzzing Wheel)
--Others listed
Ways to Activate Prior Knowledge and Connect New
Predict Use pictures, headings, and text to support predictions.
Skim Read captions, boldface headings, word charts, and
graphs to connect with the new materials.
Question Use pictures, chapter headings, graphs, to generate
meaningful questions.
Visualize Create mental pictures of words, concepts, and
predictions.
Role Play Imagine a scenario (e.g., problem, need for invention)
and play a role.
View a Movie View a portion of a movie and use it as an introduction
to new material.
Listen to a Song Listen to a song and use it as an introduction to new
material.
Journaling/Free Provide a journal prompt related to new material to
Writing access prior knowledge.
Drawing Provide a prompt and ask the students to draw from their
experience/knowledge
See if you can remember these
items. Pick your three favorite lottery
numbers from 1-10.
one -- bun six -- sticks
two -- shoe seven -- heaven
three -- tree eight -- gate
four -- door nine -- line
five -- hive ten -- hen
What do you remember?
Thinking About High Achievement and Learning Environments
What activities, lessons, or
strategies encourage your
students to think?
(Think--Write--Pair--Share)
Thinking About High Achievement and Learning Environments
What activities, lessons, or
strategies encourage your
students to think?
(Think--Write--Pair--Share)
Why is it important for
students to think well?
(Pair--Think--Write--Share)
Thinking About High Achievement and Learning Environments
What activities, lessons, or
strategies encourage your
students to think?
(Think--Write--Pair--Share)
Why is it important for Create a picture that
students to think well? represents one way that
you make decisions.
(Pair--Think--Write--Share) (Think--Draw--Pair--
Share-Share your
partner’s picture)
Thinking about Thinking
Create a picture that
represents one way that
you make decisions.
Thinking About High Achievement and Learning Environments
What activities, lessons, or Finish the sentence.
strategies encourage your My thinking is ignited
students to think? and invited when . . .
(Think--Write--Pair--Share) (Think--Write--Pair--
Share)
Why is it important for Create a picture that
students to think well? represents one way that
you make decisions.
(Pair--Think--Write--Share) (Think--Draw--Pair--
Share-Share your
partner’s picture)
What did I do to get
participation?
What did I do to get 100%
participation?
Think and write time Pairs/trios and cooperation
Acknowledge response by Time to check out your
summarizing or rephrasing answer
Open ended questions Pace
Questions relate to
Appealed to your favorite
background experience
thinking style
Expectation to participate
Different ways to share
Anticipation
Roles
We need to teach students that . .
.
Thinking and doing is mandatory and
not optional.
What if you went to a party where there were
different conversations in the corners of the
room. Where would you hang out?
People just People expressing
mentioning what is their ideas, feelings,
going on in the and decisions about
news the issues and
events
People discussing the People discussing
news items with an how they might
attempt to analyze and
solve the problem,
understand the events
and issues address the issues,
or create something
Thinking About High Achievement and Learning Environments
What activities, lessons, or Finish the sentence.
strategies encourage your My thinking is ignited
students to think? and invited when . . .
(Think--Write--Pair--
(Think--Write--Pair--Share) Share)
Remembering Relating
Why is it important for Create a picture that
students to think well? represents one way that
you make decisions.
(Think--Draw--Pair--Share-Share
(Pair--Think--Write--Share) your partner’s picture)
Reasoning Rorganizing
Remembering (Memory) Relating
Means . . Means . .
•observing •describing feelings
•memorizing •empathizing
•sequencing •preferring and valuing
•categorizing •deciding
Cues: Who? What? Where? When? Cues: How do you feel, believe, think
How? How would you decide?
Reasoning (Understanding) Reorganizing (Synthesis)
Means . . Means . .
•comparing/contrasting •generating
•classifying/analyzing •hypothesizing
•summarizing •imagining
•verifying •elaborating
Cues: Why? How do you know that? •using metaphors
What evidence do you have? Cues: What if? In how many ways?
What is similar? Different? Create . . .
Hansen, Silver, Strong, ASCD 1989
Circle of Knowledge
Discussion Strategy
Design focus questions.
Internalize the question.
Show their response in writing.
Communicate in small groups
Use a variety of recognition techniques.
Summarize and record the discussion.
Stimulate thinking through probing, acceptance, and
higher-level thinking questions.
Hansen, Silver, Strong, ASCD 1989
The Lessons:
Students have different thinking preferences and we
need to have them develop all four kinds of thinking
to achieve curriculum standards and become
responsible, confident learners.
Students need to learn how to think better by
teachers and students teaching, modeling, and
reinforcing thinking during content instruction.
Factors Involved in Desire (Motivation)
and High Performance
Safety
Success (This is the most essential
element related to motivation/desire.)
Valued Purpose
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems,
Evergreen, CO (1997)
Apply what you have learned.
Page 11
•Create a plan to have students discuss
concepts and topics in your next unit or chapter.
Remembering (Memory) Relating
Cues: Who? What? Where? Cues: How do you feel,
When? How? believe, think How would
you decide?
Reasoning (Understanding) Reorganizing (Synthesis)
Cues: What if? In how
•Cues: Why? How do you many ways? Create . . .
know that What evidence do
you have? What is similar?
Different?
If they would just think!
6. Explicit Teaching of Learning and
Literacy Skills: Comprehension/
Thinking
Student achievement increases when
learning, literacy, and content-specific skills
are explicitly taught
(Marzano, 2001, Beyer, 1987).
It takes between 15 and 25 practices to
incorporate a skill or strategy into a
person's learning repertoire.
Factors Involved in Motivation
and High performance
Safety (Students feel safer when they know what to expect
and when they believe someone is honest with them and
wants them to be successful.)
Success (Students experience success when they apply
effective strategies and effort--and, it works.)
Valued Purpose (Students value getting better and being
successful.)
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning
Systems, Evergreen, CO (1997)
What does a coach or director do to
encourage high performance?
They teach prerequisite skills and
strategies.
Here’s how important it is to explicitly
teach an important lesson or skill.
Today is brought to you by . . .
the letter A
and the number 6
Today is brought to you by . . .
the solar system
grouping and patterning information
Reading/Thinking: You can’t play
school without these skills.
•Main Idea
•Significant Details
•Sequence of Events
•Comparison
•Cause and Effect
•Meaning of Words
•Generalization/Conclusions
•Problem/Solution
•Author’s Voice/Purpose/Techniques
Goals, Activities, Homework
Learning Goals
1. Be familiar with changes to our learners and educational context.
2. Be familiar with successful instructional practices and teaching/learning
strategies.
3. Know additional ways to intervened when student demonstrate low
performance and or require accommodations for learning
disabilities/differences.
Activities
Exploring changes to our learners and educational context
A Motivational Model
Demonstration and application of powerful teaching/learning strategies
Homework
Apply at least one idea, strategy, or technique and contact the presenter to let
him/her know if it worked.
Tell one colleague or other educator about your success or seek help with
challenging problems.
Reading/Thinking: You can’t play
school without these skills.
•Main Idea
•Significant Details
•Sequence of Events
•Comparison
•Cause and Effect
•Meaning of Words
•Generalization/Conclusions
•Problem/Solution
•Author’s Voice/Purpose/Techniques
Remember as many words as you
can.
You have 20 seconds.
black brown
cinnamon gloves
canary parrot
sweater shirt
dove green
garlic pepper
How did you do?
black brown
cinnamon gloves
canary parrot
sweater shirt
dove green
garlic pepper
Remember as many words as you can.
You have 20 seconds.
vanilla horse
chocolate camel
strawberry elephant
yellow desk
red table
green chair
Three important Questions
Did it seem like the time I gave you to
study was longer for the second list?
Did you have more confidence in your
performance on the second list?
Did you think the second list was easier
when you first saw it?
How did you do now?
vanilla horse
chocolate camel
strawberry elephant
yellow desk
red table
green chair
Concept Development
Lesson:
Students can increase their comprehension
and recall when they group information and
identify patterns.
Research about Graphic
Organizers
Identification of 29 scientifically based
research studies.
Visual learning strategies improve student
performance.
Reading comprehension
Student achievement
Thinking and learning skills
Retention
Visual organizers can help
students . . .
Clarify thinking
Reinforce understanding
Integrate new knowledge
Identify misconceptions
The research about learning and
the brain has suggested that . . .
49% of our students are visually
preferred learners
34% of our students are
kinesthetic/tactile preferred learners
17% of our students are auditory
preferred learners
Sousa, David. How the Brain Learns, ASCD, 2000
The research also suggests that
comprehension and recall can be
improved . . .
by 200% if you encourage students to
group information and find patterns.
by 200% if you get the students to
explain and discuss the patterns.
by 50% if the visual display of the
patterns includes colors
Sousa, David. How the Brain Learns, ASCD, 2000
Research about Graphic
Organizers
Identification of 29 scientifically based
research studies.
Visual learning strategies improve student
performance.
Reading comprehension
Student achievement
Thinking and learning skills
Retention
Graphic Organizers Can Show Text Patterns
and Improve Comprehension
•Main Idea
•Significant Details
•Sequence of Events
•Comparison
•Cause and Effect
•Meaning of Words
•Generalization/Conclusions
•Problem/Solution
•Author’s Voice/Purpose/Techniques
The hammer is a tool used to
build the house.
A graphic organizer is a tool used to
construct meaning and provide
evidence of learning.
•Main Idea
•Significant Details
•Sequence of Events
•Comparison
•Cause and Effect
•Meaning of Words
•Generalization
•Author’s Voice
and
Content Area Learning
Europe US
Japan Effects Japan
Geograhy
US Europe
WW II
Significant
People
Causes
Politics
Significant
Territorial Events
Threats Economic
Pearl
Harbor D Day
Blood Flow
through the Heart
Right
valve?
valve ?
valve?
valve?
We often find that one cause has several effects,
EFFECTS/RESULTS
CAUSE
and that several causes lead to one effect.
CAUSE
EFFECT/RESULT
Event leads
to...
Event which Event which
leads to... leads to...
Event which
leads to...
Similarities
Differences Differences
Object, Event Object, Event
or Person or Person
First Second
Character Character
Characterization
STORY TITLE
Themes
Conflict
Setting
Herringbone
Factors Involved in Motivation
and High performance
Safety (Students feel safer when they know what to expect and
when they believe someone is honest with them and wants
them to be successful.)
Success (Students experience success when they apply
effective strategies and effort--and, it works.)
Valued Purpose (Students value getting better and being
successful.)
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems, Evergreen, CO (1997)
Evidence of Student Failure
1. Lack of skills 1. Poor attendance in school
2. Lack of confidence 2. Lack of attention in classes
3. Lack of motivation 3. Failure to attempt and/or
complete in and out-of-class
4. Lack of perseverance/ Resulting assignments
determination in 4. Revengeful behavior and
5. Lack of respect for the chronic misconduct
culture of school/education 5. Failure to participate in
6. Lack of vision for the role available interventions
school plays in career 6. Resistance and Defiance
preparation or lifestyle 7. A cycle of failure
7. Lack of connection to
positive relationships with
teachers and/or peers
Power Thinking Cartoon
Marzano,
Tactics in
Thinking, 1989
Apply what you have learned.
Page 5
•Choose a graphic organizer that you
will use to get the students to process
information from a unit/chapter of
study.
The “NEW Millennial”
Instructional Lesson Format
Focus
and
Warm-up
5-15%
Direct Teaching
Explicit 15-25%
teaching
during Student Performance
guided 35-45%
practice
makes a
difference. Review
15-25%
Closure
5-15%
Optimal Learning Time
10 minutes 3 minutes 7 minutes
Prime Apply Prime
Time 1 Time Time 2
Explicit Teaching Sequence
Step 1 - Introduce the Skill/Strategy
Step 2 - Explain the Skill/Strategy
Step 3 - Demonstrate (model) the
Skill/Strategy
Step 4 - Review What Was Done
Step 5 - Apply the Skill/Strategy in a
Variety of Contexts (guided practice)
Step 6 - Reflect on the Skill and Strategy
How do you involve students?
T otal (whole class)
A lone
P artners
S mall groups
Instructional Performance Sequence
Explicit Instruction and Guided Practice
for Successful Learning
Supporting Students During
Guided Practice
Praise
Describe exactly what the student has done right so far. Beware of
negative openers. Refer the student to the IPS.
Prompt
Describe exactly what you want the student to do. \"The next thing to do
is . . .\"
Leave
Turn and walk away before the student has time to carry out the prompt.
Frederick Jones (1985)
Instructional Performance Sequence
Supporting Students During
Guided Practice
Praise
Describe exactly what the student has done right so far. Beware
of negative openers. Refer the student to the IPS.
Prompt
Describe exactly what you want the student to do. \"The next
thing to do is . . .\"
Leave
Turn and walk away before the student has time to carry out the
prompt.
Frederick Jones (1985)
Research Conclusions: Math
1. Students getting consistent and immediate feedback about progress (especially
via computers) increase performance.
2. Students’ performance increases when teachers utilize very tightly sequenced
forms of explicit instruction.
3. Explicit instruction in the use of problem solving strategies enhances
performance, particularly among students performing below average.
4. Students’ performance increases when teachers explicitly teach concept
vocabulary.
5. Providing teachers with regular updates on student performance in terms of state
standards enhances performance.
US Department of Education, The Use of Scientifically Based Research in Education,
Working Group Conference, Wednesday, February 6, 2002.
Factors Involved in Motivation
and High performance
Safety (Students feel safer when they know what to expect and
when they believe someone is honest with them and wants
them to be successful.)
Success (Students experience success when they apply
effective strategies and effort--and, it works.)
Valued Purpose (Students value getting better and being
successful.)
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems, Evergreen, CO (1997)
Great Guided Practice
Evidence of Student Failure
1. Lack of skills 1. Poor attendance in school
2. Lack of confidence 2. Lack of attention in classes
3. Lack of motivation 3. Failure to attempt and/or
complete in and out-of-class
4. Lack of perseverance/ Resulting assignments
determination in 4. Revengeful behavior and
5. Lack of respect for the chronic misconduct
culture of school/education 5. Failure to participate in
6. Lack of vision for the role available interventions
school plays in career 6. Resistance and Defiance
preparation or lifestyle 7. A cycle of failure
7. Lack of connection to
positive relationships with
teachers and/or peers
Power Thinking Cartoon
Marzano,
Tactics in
Thinking, 1989
Apply what you have learned.
Page 6
•Choose a process/procedure that you
will teach students and create an
Instructional Performance Sequence
(storyboard)
Winning at school is important.
Categories of Instructional Strategies That
Affect Student Achievement
Category Percentile
Gain
Identifying Similarities and Differences 45
Summarizing and note taking 34
Reinforcing effort and providing recognition 29
Homework and practice 28
Non-linguistic representations 27
Cooperative Learning 27
Setting objectives and feedback 23
Generating and testing hypotheses 23
Question, cues, and advanced organizers 22
Marzano, Pickering, Pollack. Classroom Instruction that Works. ASCD, 2001
How do we change?
Storyboard
Summarizing Joshua
List Group Label
Summarizing Joshua
List Group Label
Storyboard
A Sequence Summary Frame
The passage or movie is about . . . .
(big idea)
First . . .
Second . . .
Third . . .
Near the End . . .
In the End . . .
7. Explicit Teaching of Learning and
Literacy Skills: Writing
Student achievement increases when
learning, literacy, and content-specific skills
are explicitly taught (Marzano, 2001, Beyer,
1987).
It takes between 15 and 25 practices to
incorporate a skill or strategy into a person's
learning repertoire.
Writing to Learn
Research Findings about Summarizing
Student-Generated Summaries
Teachers who involve students in
summarizing newly acquired information
promote learning because the active
process of summarizing helps to integrate
and reinforce the major points of
instruction.
Research Results for
Summarizing
Up to a 47 percentile gain in
achievement
An average 32 percentile gain in
achievement
www.mcrel.org (Meta-analysis by Bob
Marzano)
ASCD 2001 Classroom Instruction that
Works (Marzano, Pickering, and Pollack)
Summary Frames are
Powerful Teachers
A summary frame . . .
guides students’ processing of new
learning.
provides a template of your expectations.
Provides “road signs” to help the student
determine if they are performing to
expectations.
explicitly teaches various types of thinking.
Sequence Summary Frame
In order to _______________ you must
follow several steps.
First, _____________________
Then, ____________________
Next, _____________________
Finally, ___________________
Chronological Frame
____________has a specific order.
At the beginning _______________.
After that, _____________________
Then, ____________________
Next, _____________________
The, ____________ended when
____________________.
Compare-Contrast Frame
______________ and _____________ are
alike and are different in several ways.
First, they are alike because __________ but
they are different _________.
Secondly, ______ is ___________ while
___________ is __________.
Finally, _______ and ________ are alike
because _______________.
But, they are different because ___________.
Problem-Solution Frame
The problem began when __________.
The ___________ tried to __________.
After that, ________________.
Then, __________________
The problem was finally resolved when
_______________.
Cause/Effect Summary Frame
In order to understand the (effect/result)
_________________ you must identify the causes.
The first cause of (effect/result)_______ is
_________________.
Secondly, ____________________ was another cause of
(effect/result) ___________.
A third cause of (effect/result)_______ is __________.
It is clear that (effect/result)__________ has a number of
contributing causes.
Main Idea/Significant Detail
Summary Frame
The main idea of this passage is
________________________.
One fact or example that supports this main idea is
_____________________.
Another fact or example that supports this main point is
_________________.
In addition, ____________________.
Finally, ________________________ illustrates that
(main idea) _______________________.
Character Trait Analysis
Summary Frame
A significant personality characteristic of (character name) ___________ in the
(book/story/passage) _______________ is that he/she was (characteristic)
_________________.
The first incident where/way that the character demonstrates (characteristic)
__________ was ________________.
A second incident where/way that the character demonstrates this trait was
________________,
(Character) ________________also shows this trait when he/she _______________.
Finally, (character) __________ shows that he/she is (characteristic) _______ when
_____________.
It is clear that (characteristic) _________________ makes (character) _________ an
(choose one--interesting, fascinating, important, etc) character in (book/story)
____________________.
Conclusion/Generalization
Summary Frame
A person can conclude that _____________.
The first reason for/evidence that (conclusion/ generalization)
_____________ is __________________.
A second reason for/evidence that (conclusion/ generalization)
_____________ is __________________.
Yet another example that, (conclusion/generalization)
_______________ is ___________________.
There is no question then that
(conclusion/generalization______________________.
MEL-Con Paragraph Template
The main idea of this
passage is
_____________________
___.
One fact or example that
supports this main idea is
_____________________.
Another fact or example
that supports this main
point is
_________________.
In addition,
____________________.
Finally,
_____________________
___ illustrates that (main
idea)
_____________________
__.
The hammer is a tool used to
build the house.
A summary frame is a tool used to
construct meaning and provide
evidence of learning.
•Main Idea
In order to _______________ you must •Significant Details
follow several steps.
•Sequence of Events
First, _____________________
•Comparison
Then, ____________________
Next, _____________________
•Cause and Effect
Finally, ___________________
•Meaning of Words
•Generalization
•Author’s Voice
and
Content Area Learning
What does a coach or director do to
encourage high performance?
Factors Involved in Motivation
and High performance
Safety (Students feel safer when they know what to expect and
when they believe someone is honest with them and wants
them to be successful.)
Success (Students experience success when they apply
effective strategies and effort--and, it works.)
Valued Purpose (Students value getting better and being
successful.)
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems, Evergreen, CO (1997)
Use this cause/effect graphic
organizer
Detail
Effect:
a use a use
Excessive C C
Eating of
Candy
e
e
us
us
Ca
a C
Cause/Effect Summary Frame
In order to understand the (effect/result)
_________________ you must identify the causes.
The first cause of (effect/result)_______ is
_________________.
Secondly, ____________________ was another cause of
(effect/result) ___________.
A third cause of (effect/result)_______ is __________.
It is clear that (effect/result)__________ has a number of
contributing causes.
Evaluating Student Graphic Organizers and
Summaries: Cause-Effect
Main Causes/Effects
The student:
__5 included concisely stated, insightful, and relevant
causes and/or effects
__4 included accurate and relevant causes and/or
effects
__3 included some accurate causes and/or effects
that addressed only a portion or less significant
part of the topic
__2 omitted most causes and/or effects
__1 included no causes and/or effects
Evaluating Student Graphic Organizers and Summaries:
Cause-Effect
Relevant Details/Examples
The student:
__5 concisely stated significant, insightful, and relevant
details/examples
__4 concisely included significant relevant details/examples
__3 included some relevant details/examples
__2 omitted most relevant details/examples
__1 included no relevant details/examples
Evaluating Student Graphic Organizers and Summaries:
Cause-Effect
Organization of Ideas
The student:
__5 used a logical organizational scheme to connect all causes and/or
effects to supportive details
__4 used a logical organizational scheme to connect most causes
and/or effects to supportive details
__3 used a logical organizational scheme inconsistently, and some
causes and/or effects to supportive details
__2 attempted to use a logical organizational scheme, but many of the
supportive details are not connected to causes and/or effects
__1 did not use any logical organizational scheme and there is no
connection of causes and/or effects to supportive details
Power Thinking Cartoon
Marzano,
Tactics in
Thinking, 1989
Apply what you have learned.
Page 7
•Choose a type of thinking/
comprehension that you want student
to improve and select a summary
frame that you plan to use.
•Create a sample summary.
Sequence Summary Frame
____________has a specific order.
At the beginning _______________.
After that, _____________________
Then, ____________________
Next, _____________________
The, ____________ended when ____________________.
7. Encouraging Self-Assessment
and Adjustment
Student achievement increases when students are
encouraged to think about their thinking during learning
and task performance.
Marzano’s (1998) research of 4000 different
instructional interventions found that those that were
most effective in improving student learning were
those that focused on how students think about their
thinking processes and on how students feel about
themselves as learners.
If you keep on doing what you’ve
always done, you will continue to get
what you always got.
What do we want?
What are we doing to get what we want?
What do we need to change?
What’s our plan?
Think of a big project or task
you completed successfully.
What strategies, techniques, or
resources did you use successfully?
What would change if you did this
project again?
What are the first two steps you would
take to make one of the changes?
Monitoring Progress and Making
Adjustments: Self Assessment
1. Identify what the goals and standards of success
are.
2. Review your performance (e.g., tests, projects,
grades, progress).
3. Identify strategies/techniques/steps that were and
were not effective.
4. Decide what strategies/techniques you want/need
to change or abandon.
5. Try the new strategies or techniques and monitor
progress.
6. making adjustments to your strategies.
7. Celebrate progress.
Metacognition
Lesson:
Students can increase their performance
when they think about and adjust their
strategies the learning process.
If you keep on doing what you’ve
always done, you will continue to get
what you always got.
What do you want?
What have you been doing to get what
you want?
What do you have to change?
What’s your plan?
Teacher and student goal
setting requires a process.
When anyone is trying to learn,
feedback about the effort has three
elements:
recognition of the desired goal,
evidence about present position, and
some understanding of a way to close the
gap between the two (Inside the Black Box,
Black and Wiliam, 1998).
SMART Goals
S= Strategic and Specific
M= Measurable
A= Attainable
R= Results-based
T= Time-bound
Sample Student SMART Goal
Goal
I can create pieces of writing to tell others what I am thinking
or feeling
Indicators
I can write sentences with different beginnings.
I can tell that words mean different things and I know when
these words add to or take away from what I am trying to say
in my writing.
Measures
Begin Again Sentence Activity (Written response)
Mix and Match Activity (Selected Response)
20 Minute Summary (Product)
Targets
My writing will earn a rating of 3.
Methods
I will have almost all items correct.
Practice writing
sentences.
Self-assess
Goal Setting
Goal setting establishes direction,
purpose and expectations for learning.
Reflection about goals helps students
develop metacognitive abilities.
Learning goals should be specific
enough to guide learning.
How do you teach students about
goal setting, planning, and time
management?
Personal planning and responsibility
Content mastery
Metacognition
Lesson:
Students can increase their performance
when they think about and adjust their
strategies the learning process.
If you keep on doing what you’ve
always done, you will continue to get
what you always got.
What do you want?
What have you been doing to get what
you want?
What do you have to change?
What’s your plan?
Good learners debrief. Debriefing
plays an integral role in learning new
knowledge, skills, and attitudes.
The Self-Assessment Strategy
What did you accomplish?
What strategies, steps, or practices did
you successfully apply?
What do you need to abandon or
change?
What’s your plan?
Factors Involved in Motivation
and High performance
Safety (Students feel safer when they know what to expect and
when they believe someone is honest with them and wants
them to be successful.)
Success (Students experience success when they apply
effective strategies and effort--and, it works.)
Valued Purpose (Students value getting better and being
successful.)
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems, Evergreen, CO (1997)
Evidence of Student Failure
1. Lack of skills 1. Poor attendance in school
2. Lack of confidence 2. Lack of attention in classes
3. Lack of motivation 3. Failure to attempt and/or
complete in and out-of-class
4. Lack of perseverance/ Resulting assignments
determination in 4. Revengeful behavior and
5. Lack of respect for the chronic misconduct
culture of school/education 5. Failure to participate in
6. Lack of vision for the role available interventions
school plays in career 6. Resistance and Defiance
preparation or lifestyle 7. A cycle of failure
7. Lack of connection to
positive relationships with
teachers and/or peers
Power Thinking Cartoon
Marzano,
Tactics in
Thinking, 1989
Apply what you have learned.
Page 8
•Create a plan to engage students in
at least weekly self-assessment about
their approach to learning (e.g.,
strategies, practices) and their
progress (e.g., grades, improvement)
2. Assessment and Evaluation
Student achievement increases when students receive
feedback about their progress related to stated learning
standards/goals.
Teachers consistently use formative assessments
(during learning, to promote learning) and summative
assessments (at the end of learning, to evaluate
learning). Students regularly receive feedback about
their progress related to objectives/standards (Marzano,
2001).
Ways to collect
evidence of
learning
What types of assessments
should you use?
Selected response (e.g., multiple choice,
matching, true/false
Constructed response (e.g., fill-in-the-
blank, short answer, label, visual)
Products (e.g., essay, model, spreadsheet)
Performances (e.g., speeches, recital,
demonstrations,
Process (e.g., conferences, observations,
logs)
Choosing the Right Tool for the
Right Verb
1. Write a definition for Bloom’s Hierarchy of Thinking Types of
magma and lava. •Knowledge Assessments
2. Compare and contrast •Comprehension
intrusive and extrusive •Analysis • Selected response
igneous rocks. •Application
(e.g., multiple
3. Create a model showing •Synthesis
how igneous rocks are •Evaluation choice, matching,
formed. true/false
4. Describe the similarities • Constructed
Types of
and differences Thinking/Comprehension response (e.g., fill-in-
between scoria and the-blank, short
•Main Idea
obsidian. answer, label, visual)
5. Describe the similarities •Supporting Details
• Products (e.g.,
and differences •Sequential and Order Relationships
essay, model,
between concordant and •Comparative Relationships
spreadsheet)
discordant igneous rock •Causal Relationships
bodies. • Performances (e.g.,
•Problem-Solution Relationships speeches, recital,
6. What would happen if •Making Generalizations and Drawing
igneous rocks became demonstrations,
Conclusions
very difficult to find? • Process (e.g.,
•Word Analysis, Recognition, and
conferences,
Meanings of Word in Isolation and in
Context observations, logs)
•Author’s Approach, Purpose, and
Design
Formative
Assessment Plan
There’s a big difference.
Evaluation . . . Assessment . . .
Is the gathering of Is the gathering of
information in order to information in order to
document, label, grade, or change our behavior o
score performance. improve performance.
Evaluation is about grades Assessment is about
and scores. teaching and learning.
Evaluation is a Assessment is a
commitment to scores and commitment to quality.
judgments.
(Rogers 2008)
Use an energizing cycle or
assessment and feedback.
Common Cycle
Teach Teach Teach Teach Test
Use an energizing cycle or
assessment and feedback.
Shortened-Cycle Assessment
Teach/ Teach/ Teach/ Teach/ Evaluate
Assess Assess Assess Assess
Re-teach and re-assess
when necessary.
Use an energizing cycle or
assessment and feedback.
Common Cycle
Teach Teach Teach Teach Test
Shortened-Cycle Assessment
Teach/ Teach/ Teach/ Teach/ Evaluate
Assess Assess Assess Assess
Re-teach and re-assess when necessary.
Factors Involved in Motivation
(Energy--Passion--Positive Attitude)
Safety
Success (This is the most essential
element related to motivation/desire.)
Valued Purpose
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems,
Evergreen, CO (1997)
Actions are driven by
the need to be
successful.
(Spence Rogers, 2008)
Would students be more motivated
and perform better or worse on
performance assessments if . . .
Rubrics are distributed at the Better Worse
beginning of the assignment with
exemplars and discussion?
Teachers teach strategies and Better Worse
techniques to achieve the
expectations?
Students receive feedback from peers Better Worse
and the teacher?
Students are guided through self- Better Worse
assessment to note incremental
progress and the need for revision or
change in strategy or performance?
Why Use Rating Scales
Rating Scales (Rubrics) also . . .
1. provide students with expectations about what will be assessed as
well as standards that need to be met,
2. increase consistency in the rating of performances, products and
understandings when used by students during self/peer assessment,
and by teachers, and
3. provide student with “road signs” – information about where they are
in relation to where they need to be.
(MCREL, 1992)
Happy Camper--
Views life with optimism
4. Always sees the positive side--sees half- full glass
as plenty full enough
3. Frequently sees the positive--perceives the glass as
half full
2. Sometimes dwells on the negative--perceives the
glass as half empty
1. Picks up the half-empty glass and pours out water to
prove things will always get worse
Factors Involved in Motivation
and High performance
Safety (Students feel safer when they know what to expect and when
they believe the tests and assessments are just what you told them
and taught them.)
Success (Students experience success when they apply effective
strategies and effort.)
Valued Purpose (Students value getting better and being
successful.)
Love and Belonging
Fun and Enjoyment
Freedom and Independence
Rogers, Ludington, and Graham. Motivation and Learning, Peek Learning Systems, Evergreen, CO (1997)
Apply what you have learned.
Page 9
•Create a plan for assessing student
learning
--formatively (every day to 48 hours
after learning)
--summatively (big tests, projects,
assisgments)
Apply what you have learned.
Page 9
•Create a plan for assessing student
learning
--formatively (every day to 48 hours
after learning)
--summatively (big tests, projects,
assisgments during and at the end of
the unit)
3. Correctives, Enrichments,
and Reassessment
Student achievement increases when
students have additional opportunities to
learn content and skills and have additional
opportunities to demonstrate acquisition of
learning objectives (Guskey, Implementing
Mastery Learning 1987). Particular objectives
may require a mastery level (e.g., 70%) of
acquisition.
Adapting to Student Learning Needs
Correctives
1. Teach the same material in a different
way than the original method
2. Involve students in a different way
than the original involvement
3. Provide students with successful
experiences
Corrective Suggestions
re-teaching small group study
alternative textbooks sessions
alternative materials individual tutoring
workbooks learning centers and
academic games laboratories
(crossword puzzles, computer-assisted
simulations)
instruction
Adapted from Guskey, T. Implementing Mastery Learning.
Enrichment/Extensions . . .
1. Should be rewarding and exciting
learning opportunities
2. Should be challenging
3. Should appeal to the need for
achievement, affiliation, and/or control
Enrichment/Extension
Suggestions
Tutoring peers locating background
developing practice materials for future or
exercises current topics
developing related media
materials developing additional
completing special projects, formative assessments
experiments planning to teach a
developing games, mini-unit
problems, and contests creating bulletin boards
using advanced computer- and displays
assisted lessons
applying knowledge to a
new situation
What do staff need to learn to be able to
meet students diverse learning needs?
Change Content
What students will learn and the materials that
represent the content
Change Process
Activities through which students make sense of
key ideas using essential skills
Change Product/Assessment
How students demonstrate and extend what they
understand and can do as a result of a span of
learning
Change Environment
The classroom conditions that set the tone and
expectations of learning
Apply what you have learned.
Page 10
•Choose some corrective techniques/
practices you will use to respond
students’ lower performance.
•Chose two or more enrichment
techniques/practices you will use to
respond to students’ high
performance.
Responses to
Formative
Assessments
Corrective Suggestions
re-teaching small group study
alternative textbooks sessions
alternative materials individual tutoring
workbooks learning centers and
academic games laboratories
(crossword puzzles, computer-assisted
simulations)
instruction
Adapted from Guskey, T. Implementing Mastery Learning.
Enrichment/Extensions . . .
1. Should be rewarding and exciting
learning opportunities
2. Should be challenging
3. Should appeal to the need for
achievement, affiliation, and/or control
Apply what you have learned.
Page 10
•Choose some corrective techniques/
practices you will use to respond
students’ lower performance.
•Chose two or more enrichment
techniques/practices you will use to
respond to students’ high
performance.
Are you motivating students for high performance?
1. Stating and showing (in writing) objectives at the beginning and end of each
lesson (27 percentile increase)
2. Providing frequent feedback to students about their learning related to the
objectives (within 48 hours most of the time) (37 percentile increase)
3. Providing corrective activities that respond to student progress and providing
additional opportunities to retake/retest (26 percentile increase)
4. Helping student activate and build background information and advance
organization (22 percentile increase)
5. Explicitly teaching vocabulary as well as retention and retrieval (memory)
strategies (33 percentile increase)
6. Explicitly teaching learning skills and strategies using Graphic organizers (for
patterning, thinking, and writing) (27 percentile increase)
7. Explicitly teaching learning skills and strategies using Summaries (for patterning,
thinking, and writing) (34 percentile increase)
8. Encouraging student self-assessment and adjustment (24 percentile increase)
Goals, Activities, Homework
Learning Goals
1. Be familiar with changes to our learners and educational context.
2. Be familiar with successful instructional practices and teaching/learning strategies.
3. Know additional ways to intervened when student demonstrate low performance and
or require accommodations for learning disabilities/differences.
Activities
Exploring changes to our learners and educational context
A Motivational Model
Demonstration and application of powerful teaching/learning strategies
Homework
Apply at least one idea, strategy, or technique and contact the presenter to let him/her
know if it worked.
Tell one colleague or other educator about your success or seek help with challenging
problems.
Head An idea I had . . .
Heart A feeling I had . . .
Foot An action I may
take . . .
0 comments
Post a comment